Judicial Review and the Rights of Private Parties in EU Law

Judicial Review and the Rights of Private Parties in EU Law

Volumn , Issue , 2012, Pages 1-520

  Ward, Angela ^a  

^a Barrister of the Middle Temple ^*  (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

Damages Liability; Eu Law; Eu Litigation; Eu Treaty; Individual Rights; Judicial Review; Liability; National Law; Nullity Review; Validity Review

Indexed keywords

EID: 84922770063     PISSN: None     EISSN: None     Source Type: Book    
DOI: 10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199206865.001.0001     Document Type: Book

References (265)

1. J Temple-Lang, 'Actions for Declarations that Community Regulations are Invalid; the Duties of National Courts Under Article 10 EC' (2003) 28 ELRev 102, at 111.
2. P Eeckhout, The External Relations Law of the EU (2004).
3. T Tridimas The General Principles of EU Law (2006).
4. A Ward, 'National Sanctions in EC Law: A Moving Boundary in the Division of Competence' (1995) 2 ELJ 222.
5. P Dubinsky 'The Essential Function of Federal Courts: The European Union and the United States Compared' (1994) 42 American Journal of Comparative Law 295, 319.
6. M Dougan, 'Cutting Your Losses in the Enforcement Deficit: A Community Right to the Recovery of Unlawfully- Levied Charges' in A Dashwood and A Ward (eds), Cambridge Yearbook of European Legal Studies 1 (1998) 233.
7. R Bebr, 'Direct and Indirect Judicial Control of community Acts in Practice: the Relation Between Arts 173 and 177 of the EEC Treaty' in Michigan Law Review (ed) 82 (1984).
8. R Isaacs, 'La modulation par la Cour de Justice des Communautes Europeennes des effets dans le temps de se arrêts d'invalidité (1987) 25 CDE 444.
9. J-C Masclet, 'La jurisprudence Roquette I'épreuve des jurisidictions françaises (Conseil d'Etat et Cour de Cassation) (1986) 22 RTDE 161.
10. C Waelbroeck, 'May the Court of Justice Limit the Retrospective Operation of its Judgments?' (1981) 1 YEL115;
11. W Alexander, 'The Temporal effects of Preliminary Rulings' (1988) 8 YBEL 11.
12. J Coppel and A O'Neill, 'The European Court of Justice: Taking Rights Seriously?' (1992) 29 CMLRev 669.
13. E Sharpston, 'Legitimate Expectations and Economic Reality' (1990) 15 ELRev 103.
14. G Slynn, 'But in England there is no...' in Festschrift fuer Wolfgang Zeidler (1987) vol. 1 397;
15. J Jowell and A Lester, 'Proportionality: neither novel or dangerous' in J Jowel and D Oliver (eds), New Directions in Judicial Review (1988).
16. G de Búrca, 'The Principle of Proportionality and its Application in EC Law' (1993) 13 YBEL 105.
17. T Tridimas, The General Principles of EU Law (2006) 176-192.
18. T Tridimas, 'The Application of the Principle of Equality to Community Measures' in A Dashwood and S O'Leary (eds), The Principle of Equal Treatment (1997);
19. P Eekhout, The External Relations Law of the European Union (2005);
20. T Tridimas, 'Black, White and Shades of Grey; Horizontality of Directives Revisited' (2002) Yearbook of European Law 327.
21. C Harlow, 'Codification of European Administrative Procedures? Fitting the Foot to the Shoe or the Shoe to the Foot?' (1996) 2 ELJ 3 at 17.
22. J Temple-Lang, 'Actions for Declarations that Community Regulations are Invalid: the Duties of National Courts Under Article 10 EC' (2003) 28 ELRev 102.
23. P Pescatore, 'The Doctrine of "Direct Effect": An Infant Disease of Community Law' (1983) 155 ELRev at 177.
24. A Stone Sweet, The Judicial Construction of Europe (2004) 243.
25. T Tridimas, The General Principles of EU Law (2006).
26. N Green, 'The Treaty of Rome, National Courts, and the English Common Law: Enforcement of European Competition Laws After Milk Marketing Board' (1984) 48 Rables Zeitschrift 509;
27. R Bebr, Case commentary on Francovich (1992) 29 CMLRev 557;
28. Y Dubois, 'La responsabilité d'Etat pour les dommages causés aux particuliers par la violation du droit communautaire' (1992) RFDA No 8(1) 1;
29. H Smith, 'The Francovich Case: State Liability and the Individual's Right to Damages' (1992) 3 European Competition Law Review 129;
30. P Duffy, 'Damages Against the State: a new remedy for failure to implement Community obligations' (1992) 17 ELRev 133;
31. J Temple-Lang, 'New Legal Effects Resulting From the Failure of States to Fulfil obligations Under European Community Law: the Francovich Judgment' (1992-1993) 16 Fordham International Law Journal 1;
32. M Ross, 'Beyond Francovich' (1993) 56 MLR 55;
33. J Steiner, 'From Direct Effects to Francovich: shifting means of enforcement of Community law' (1993) 18 ELRev (1993) 3;
34. W van Gerven, 'Noncontractual Liability of Member States, Community Institutions and Individuals for breaches of Community Law with a View to a Common Law for Europe' (1994) 1 Maastricht Journal of European and Comparative Law 6;
35. W van Gerven, 'Bridging the Unbridgeable: Community and National Tort Laws After Francovich and Brasserie' (1996) 45 ICLQ 507;
36. C Harlow, 'Francovich and the Problem of the Disobedient State' (1996) 2 ELJ 199;
37. E Deards, "Curiouser and Curiouser"? The Development of Member State Liability in the Court of Justice' (1997) 3 European Public Law 117;
38. P Craig, 'Once More Unto the Breach: the Community, the State, and Damages Liability' (1997) 113 LQR 67;
39. J Steiner, 'The Limits of State Liability for Breach of European Community Law' (1998) 4 European Public Law 69;
40. D Oliver, 'State Liability in Damages Following Factortame III: A Remedy Seen in Context' in J Beatson and T Tridimas (eds), New Directions in European Public Law (1998) 49;
41. P Eeckhout, 'Liability of Member States in Damages and the Community System of Remedies' in J Beatson and T Tridimas (eds), New Directions in European Public Law (1998) 63;
42. N Green and A Barav, 'Damages in the National Courts for Breach of Community Law' 6 YBEL (1986) 55;
43. C Lewis and S Moore, 'Duties, Directives and Damages in European Community Law' (1993) Public Law 151;
44. G Anagnostaras, 'The Principle of State Liability for Judicial Breaches: The Impact of European Community Law' (2001) 7 European Public Law 281;
45. T Tridimas, 'Liability for Breach of Community Law: Growing Up and Mellowing Down?' (2001) 38 Common Market Law Review 301;
46. G Anagnostaras, 'State Liability and Altermnstive Courses of Action: How Independent can an Autonomous Remedy Be?' (2002) 21 YEL 355;
47. M Dougan, National Remedies Before the Court of Justice: Issues of Harmonisation and Differentiation (2004);
48. T Tridimas, The General Principles of EU Law (2006) 498-547.
49. B de White, 'Direct Effect, Supremacy and the Nature of the Legal Order' in P Craig and G de Burca(eds), The Evolution of EU Law (1999) 177.
50. Lord Slynn, 'Access to Sanctions in Community Law: An Overview' in M Verwilghen (ed), Equality Between Men and Women in the European Community (1993) p121.
51. Lord Slynn, 'Sanctions in Community Law: An Overview' in M Verwilghen (ed), Access to Equality Between Men and Women in the European Community (1993) p121.
52. Papadias, 'Interim Protection Under Community Law Before the National Courts. The Right to a Judge with Jurisdiction to Grant Interim Relief' (1994) 2 LIEI 153 at 185.
53. J Mackenzie Stuart, 'The Non-contractual Liability of the European Economic Community' (1975) CMLRev 507;
54. F Fines, Étude de la Responsabilité Extracontractuelle de la Communauté Economique Européenne (1990);
55. EW Fuss, 'La responsabilité des Communautés Européennes pour le comportement illegal de leurs organes' (1981) 17 RTDE 1;
56. G Roberts, 'Judicial Review of Legislative Measures: the European Court of Justice Breathes Life into the Second Paragraph of Article 215' (1988) 26 Columbia Journal of Transnational Law 245;
57. F Schockweiler, G Wivenes and J Godart, 'Le régime de la responsabilité extra-contractuelle du fait d'actes juridiques dans la Communaté européenne (1990) RTDE 27;
58. T Heukels and A McDonnell (eds), The Action for Damages in Community Law (1997);
59. T Tridimas, 'Liability for Breach of Community Law: Growing Up and Mellowing Down?' (2001) 38 CMLRev 301.
60. D Fairgrieve, M Andenas and J Bell (eds), Tort Liability of Public Authorities in Comparative Perspective (2002);
61. T Tridimas, The General Principles of EU Law (2006) pp477-497;
62. T Tridimas, 'Liability for Breach of Community Law: Growing Up and Mellowing Down?' (2001) 38 CMLRev 301.
63. P Oliver, 'Joint Liability of the Community and the Member States' in HG Schermers et al (eds), Non-Contractual liability of the European Communities (1988) 125;
64. M de Visser, 'The Concept of Concurrent Liability and its Relationship with the Principle of Effectiveness: A One-way Ticket into Oblivion?' (2004) 11 MJ 4.
65. M de Visser, 'The Concept of Concurrent Liability and its Relationship with the Principle of Effectiveness: a One Way Ticket into Oblivion?' (2004) 11 MJ 4.
66. M Dougan, 'Cutting Your losses in the Enforcement Deficit: A Community Right to the Recovery of Unlawfully Levied Charges' in A Dashwood and A Ward (eds), Cambridge Yearbook of European Legal Studies 1 (1998) 233.
67. R Barents 'The Quality of Community Legislation. Some observations on EC legislation in the Agricultural sector' (1994) Maastricht Journal of European and Comparative Law 101.
68. GF Mancini and DT Keeling, 'Democracy and the European Court of Justice' (1994) 57 MLR 175, 189.
69. G Vandersanden and A Barav, Contentieux communautaire (1977) 336;
70. A Dashwood, 'Community Decision Making after Amsterdam' in A Dashwood and A Ward (eds), Cambridge Yearbook of European Legal Studies 1 (1998) 25.
71. G Winter (ed), Sources and Categories of European Union Law: A comparative and Reform Perspective (1996).
72. W van Gerven, 'Bridging the Unbridgeable: Community and National Tort Laws after Francovich and Brasserie' (1996) 45 ICLQ 507, 528-529.
73. E Deards, 'Curiouser and Curiouser? The Development of Member State Liability in the Court of Justice' (1997) 3 European Public Law 117.
74. K Lenaerts and T Corthaut, 'Judicial Review as a Contribution to the Development of European Constitutionalism', 2003, 22 YEL 1.
75. E Stein, 'Lawyers, Judges, and the Making of a Transnational Constitution' (1981) 75 AJIL 1;
76. GF Mancini, 'The Making of a Constitution for Europe' (1989) 26 CMLRev 595.
77. A Stone Sweet, The Judicial Construction of Europe (2004).
78. JHH Weiler, 'The European Court of Justice: "Beyond Doctrine" or the Legitimacy Crisis of European Constitutionalism' in A Slaughter, A Stone Sweet and JHH Weiler (eds), The European Courts and National Courts -Doctrine and Jurisprudence: Legal Change in its Social Context (1998) 365.
79. A Arnull, 'Private Applicants and the Action for Annulment under Article 173 of the EC Treaty' (1995) 32 CMLRev 7, 46-47;
80. M Hedemann-Robinson, 'Article 173 EC, General Community Measures and Locus Standi for Private Persons: Still a Cause for Individual Concern?' (1996) 2 European Public Law 127;
81. S Peers and A Ward (eds), The EU Charter of Fundamental Rights: Law, Politics, and Policy (2004).
82. K Lenaerts, D Arts and I Maselis, Procedural Law of the European Union (2006) 329-334.
83. P Oliver, 'Le droit communautaire et les voies de recours nationales' (1992) 28 CDE 348.
84. N Green and A Barav, 'Damages in the National Courts for Breach of Community Law' (1986) 6 YBEL 55;
85. J Steiner 'How to Make the Action Suit the Case: Domestic Remedies for Breach of EEC Law' (1987) 12 ELRev 102;
86. A Barav, 'Damages in the Domestic Courts for Breach of Community Law by National Public Authorities' in HG Schermers et al (eds), Non-Contractual Liability of the European Communities (1988) 149;
87. D Curtin, 'Directives: the Effectiveness of Judicial Protection of Individual Rights' (1990) 27 CMLRev 709;
88. A Ward, 'Government Liability in the UK for Breach of Individual Rights in European Community Law' (1990) 19 Anglo-American Law Review 1;
89. S Weatherill, 'National Remedies and Equal Access to Public Procurement' (1990) 10 YBEL 243;
90. S Prechal, 'Remedies After Marshall' (1990) 27 CMLRev 451;
91. AG Tesauro, 'La Sanction des Infractions au Droit Communautaire' (1992) 32 Rivista di Diritto Europeo 477;
92. G de Búrca, 'Giving Effect to European Community Directives' (1992) 55 MLR 215;
93. E Szyszczak, 'European Community Law: New Remedies, New Directions?' (1992) 55 MLR 690;
94. F Snyder, 'The Effectiveness of European Community Law: Institutions, Processes, Tools and Techniques' (1993) 56 MLR 19;
95. B Fitzpatrick and E Szyszczak, 'Remedies and Effective Judicial Protection in Community Law' (1994) 57 MLR 434;
96. W Van Gerven, 'Bridging the Gap Between Community and National Laws: Towards a Principle of Homogeneity in the Field of Legal Remedies?' (1995) 32 CMLRev 679;
97. R Caranta, 'Judicial Protection Against Member States: a New jus commune Takes Shape' (1995) 32 CMLRev 703;
98. A Ward, 'National Sanctions in EC Law: A moving Boundary in the Division of Competence?' (1995) No 2 European Law Journal 205;
99. J Steiner, Enforcing EC Law (1995), in particular p 42 ff;
100. E Szyszczak, 'Making Europe More Relevant to its Citizens: Effective Judicial Process' (1996) 21 ELRev 351;
101. C Himsworth, 'Things Fall Apart: the Harmonisation of Community Judicial Procedural Protection Revisited' (1997) 22 ELRev 291;
102. C Kakouris, 'Do the Member States Possess Judicial Procedural Autonomy?' (1997) 34 CMLRev 1389;
103. M Ruffert, 'Rights and Remedies in European Community Law: a Comparative View' (1997) 34 CMLRev 307;
104. M Dougan, 'Cutting Your Losses in the Enforcement Deficit: A Community Right to the Recovery of Unlawfully-Levied Charges' in A Dashwood and A Ward (eds), Cambridge Yearbook of European Legal Studies 1 (1998) 233;
105. A Arnull, The European Union and its Court of Justice (2006) 267-334;
106. T Eilmansberger, 'The Relationship Between Rights and Remedies in EC Law: In Search of the Missing Link' (2004) 41 CMLRev 1199;
107. M Dougan, National Remedies Before the Court of Justice (2004);
108. M Accetto and S Zleptnig, 'The Principle of Effectiveness: Rethinking Its Role in Community Law' (2005) 11 European Public Law 375;
109. T Tridimas, The General Principles of EU Law (2006) 418-476.
110. JHH Weiler, 'The European Court of Justice: "Beyond Doctrine" or the Legitimacy Crisis of European Constitutionalism' in A Slaughter, A Stone Sweet and JHH Weiler (eds), The European Court and National Courts - Doctrine and Jurisprudence: Legal Change in its Social Context (1998) 365.
111. M Ruffert, 'Rights and Remedies in European Community Law: A Comparative View' (1997) 34 CMLRev 307 at 307.
112. P Manin, 'L'invocabilité des directives; Quelques interrogations' (1990) RTDE 669;
113. F Emmert and M Pereira de Azevedo, 'L'effet horizontal des directives de la jurisprudence de la CJCE: un bateau ivre' (1993) 29 RTDE 593;
114. F Emmert and M Pereira de Azevedo, 'Les jeux sont fait: rien ne va plus ou une nouvelle occasion perdue par la CJCE' (1995) 31 RTDE 11;
115. M Dougan, 'The "Disguised" Vertical Direct Effect of Directives?' (2000) 59(3) Cambridge Law Journal 586;
116. S Prechal, 'Does Direct Effect Still Matter?' (2000) 37 CMLRev 1047;
117. S Weatherill, 'Breach of Directives and Breach of Contract' (2001) 26 ELRev 177;
118. S Prechal, 'Direct Effect Reconsidered, Redefined and Rejected' in JM Prinssen and A Schrauwen (eds), Direct Effect: Rethinking a Classic of EC Legal Doctrine (2002), 15;
119. T Tridimas, 'Black, White and Shades of Grey: Horizontality of Directive Revisited' (2002) Yearbook of European Law 327;
120. D Colgan, 'Triangular Situations: the Coup de Grâce for the Denial of Horizontal Direct Effect of Community Directives' (2002) 8 European Public Law 545;
121. H Somsen, 'Discretion in European Community Environmental Law: An Analysis of ECJ Case Law' (2003) 40 Common Market Law Review 1413;
122. C Hilson, 'Legality Review of Member State Discretion under Directives' in T Tridimas and P Nebbia (eds), European Union Law for the 21st Century (2004) 1047;
123. S Drake, 'Twenty Years After Von Colson: the impact of 'indirect effect' on the protection of the individual's Community rights' (2005) 30 ELRev 329;
124. S Prechal, Directives in EC Law (2005).
125. D Curtin and M Mortelmans, 'Application and Enforcement of Community Law by the Member States: Actors in Search of a Third Generation Script' in D Curtin and T Heukels (eds), Institutional Dynamics of European Integration: Liber Amicorum Henry G. Schermers (1994) 434.
126. A Burley and W Mattly, 'Europe before the Court: a political theory of legal integration' (1993) 47 International Organization 41, 64.
127. K Lenaerts, 'Some Thoughts about the Interaction between Judges and Politicians' (1992) University of Chicago Legal Forum 93, 100-101.
128. TA Vandamme, The Invalid Directive (2005) pp7-10;
129. A Ward, 'Locus Standi Under Article 230(4) of the EC Treaty: Crafting a Coherent Test for a Wobbly Polity' (2003) 22 YEL 45.
130. J Temple-Lang, 'Actions for Declarations that Community Regulations are Invalid; the Duties of National Courts Under Article 10 EC' (2003) 28 ELRev 102, at 111.
131. A Dashwood, 'Community Decision Making after Amsterdam' in A Dashwood and A Ward (eds), Cambridge Yearbook of European Legal Studies 1 (1998) 25.
132. A Burley, 'Democracy and Judicial Review in European Community' (1992) The University of Chicago Legal Forum 81.
133. N Walker, 'Legal Theory and the European Union: A 25th Anniversary Essay' (vol. 25, 2005) No 4 OJLS 581, 582.
134. D Anderson and M Demetriou, References to the European Court (2002) pp 10-15 and 98-100.
135. A Dashwood and A Johnston, 'The Institutions of the Enlarged EU and the Regime of the Constitutional Treaty' (2004) 41 CMLRev 1481.
136. T Tridimas, 'Black, White and Shades of Grey: Horizontality of Directives Revisited' in Yearbook of European Law (2002) 327;
137. H Somsen, 'Discretion in European Community Environmental Law: An Analysis of ECJ Case Law' (2003) 40 Common Market Law Review 1413.
138. S Prechal, Directives in EC Law (2005) 231.
139. D Colgan, 'Triangular Situations: The Coup de Grâce for the Denial of Horizontal Direct Effect of Community Directives' (2002) 8 European Public Law 545, p565.
140. T Hartley 'The European Court, judicial objectivity and the Constitution of the European Union' (1996) 112 LQR 95 pp 104, 105.
141. K Lenaerts and T Corthout, 'Of Birds and Hedges: the Role of Primacy in Invoking Norms of EU Law' (2006) 31 ELRev 287.
142. A Ward, 'The Limits of Uniform Application of Community Law and Effective Judicial Review: A Look Post-Amsterdam' in C Kilpatrick et al (eds), The Future of Remedies in Europe (2000) 213.
143. C Hilson and T Downes, 'Making Sense of Rights: Community Rights in EC Law' (1999) 24 ELRev 121;
144. J Coppel, 'Rights, Duties and the end of Marshall' (1994) 57 MLR 859.
145. JHH Weiler, 'The Transformation of Europe' 100 Yale Law Journal (1991) 2403;
146. E Stein, 'Lawyers, Judges and the Making of a Transnational Constitution' (1981) 75 AJIL 1;
147. P Craig, 'Once Upon a Time in the West: Direct Effect and the Federalization of EEC Law' (1992) 12 Oxford Journal of Legal Studies 453.
148. G Betlam, 'The "Effet Utile" of Indirect Effect' (1995) 2 Maastricht Journal of European and Comparative Law 73.
149. G Winter, 'Direct Applicability and Direct Effect Two Distinct and Different Concepts in Community Law' (1972) CMLRev 425, 436.
150. M Dougan, 'The "Disguised" Vertical Direct Effect of Directives?' (2000) 59(3) Cambridge Law Journal 586, 610;
151. S Weatherill, 'Breach of Directives and Breach of Contract' (2001) 26 ELRev 177.
152. C Hilson and T Downes, 'Making Sense of Rights: Community Rights in EC Law' (1999) 24 ELRev 121.
153. C Hilson, 'Legality Review of Member State Discretion Under Directives' in T Tridimas and P Nebbia (eds), European Union Law for the 21st Century (2004) 209.
154. S Prechal, 'Does Direct Effect Still Matter?' (2000) 37 CMLRev 1047.
155. Y Galmot and J Bonichot, 'La Court de justice des Communauté européennes et la transposition des directives en droit national' (1988) 4 RFDA 1;
156. D Curtin, 'The Province of Government: Delimiting the Direct Effect of Directives in the Common Law Context' (1990) 15 ELRev 195 at 195-198;
157. F Emmert and M Periera de Azevedo, 'L'effet horizontal des directives de la jurisprudence de la CJCE: un bateau livre?' (1993) 29 RTDE 503.
158. D Curtin, 'The Province of Government: Delimiting the Direct Effect of Directives in the Common Law Context' (1990) 15 ELRev 195 at 200.
159. P Oliver, 'Le droit communautaire et les voies de recours nationales' (1998) 28 CDE 348 at 353-354.
160. J Steiner, 'Coming to Terms with EC Directives' (1990) 106 LQR 144;
161. P Meade, 'The obligation to apply European law: is Duke Dead' (1991) 16 ELRev 490;
162. J Stuyck and P Wytnick (1991) case commentary on Marleasing in CMLRev 205;
163. A Arnull, 'When is pregnancy like an arthritic hip' (1992) 17 ELRev 265;
164. N Maltby, 'Marleasing: What is all the Fuss About' (1993) 109 LQR 301;
165. N Gravells, 'European Community law in the English Courts' (1993) Public Law 44;
166. G de Búrca, 'Giving Effect to European Community Directives' (1992) 55 MLR 215;
167. B De Witte, 'Community Law and National Constitutional Values' (1991/2) LIEI 1.
168. D Curtin, 'The Province of Government: Determining the Direct Effect of Directives in the Common Law Context' (1990) 15 ELRev 195, 223.
169. T Tridimas, The General Principles of EU Law (2006).
170. K Lackhoff and H Nyssens, 'Direct Effect of Directives in Triangular Situations' (1998) 28 ELRev 397;
171. M Dougan, 'The "Disguised" Vertical Direct Effect of Directives?' (2000) 59(3) Cambridge Law Journal 586;
172. D Colgan, 'Triangular Situations: the Coup de Grâce for the Denial of Horizontal Direct Effect of Community Directives' (2000) vol. 8, issue 4 European Public Law 545;
173. S Weatherill, 'Breach of Directives and Breach of Contract' (2001) 26 ELRev 177.
174. C Hilson, 'Legality Review of Member State Discretion Under Directives' in T Tridimas and P Nebbia (eds), European Union Law for the Twenty-First Century (2004) 224, at 237-238.
175. JHH Weiler, 'Problems of Legitimacy in Post 1992 Europe' (1991) 46 Aussenwirtschaf 179 at 181-182;
176. G Majone, 'The Rise of the Regulatory State in Europe' (1994) 17 West European Politics 77;
177. G Hogan, 'The implementation of European Union law in Ireland: The Meagher case and the democratic deficit' (1994) 2 Irish Journal of European Law 190.
178. A Dashwood, 'Community Decision Making after Amsterdam' in A Dashwood and A Ward (eds), Cambridge Yearbook of European Legal Studies 1 (1998) 25.
179. A Ward, 'Locus Standi under Article 230(4): Crafting a Coherent Test for a Wobbly Polity' (2003) Yearbook of European Law 45.
180. C Harlow, 'A Community of Interests? Making the Most of European Law' (1992) 55 MLR 331;
181. L Brittan, 'Institutional Development of the European Community' (1992) Public Law 567.
182. S Williams, 'Sovereignty and Accountability in the EC' (1990) 61 Political Quarterly 90.
183. F. Snyder, New Directions in European Community Law (1990) 90.
184. W Ungerer, 'Institutional Consequences of Broadening and Deepening the Community: the Consequences for the Decision-Making Process' (1993) 30 CMLRev 71 at 76.
185. GF Mancini and DT Keeling, 'Democracy and the European Court of Justice' (1994) 57 MLR 175.
186. F Snyder, 'The Effectiveness of European Community Law: Institutions, Processes, Tools and Techniques' (1993) 56 MLR 19, 53.
187. M Ross, 'Beyond Francovich' (1993) 56 MLR 55, 71.
188. D Curtin and K Mortelmans, 'Application and Enforcement of Community Law by the Member States: Actors in Search of a Third Generation Script' in D Curtin and T Heukels (eds), Institutional Dynamics of European Integration (1994) 423.
189. S Prechal, Directives in EC Law (2nd edn, 2005) at 262-266 on multi-angular situations;
190. K Lackhoff and H Nyssens, 'Direct Effect of Directives in Triangular Situations' (1998) 23 ELRev 397;
191. M Dougan, 'The "Disguised" Vertical Direct Effect of Directives' (2000) 59(3) Cambridge Law Journal 586;
192. D Coglan, 'Triangular Situations: the Coup de Grâce for the Denial of Horizontal Direct Effect of Community Directives' (2002) 8 European Public Law 545.
193. A Arnull, 'Private applicants and the action for annulment under Article 173 of the EC Treaty' (1995) 32 CMLRev 7, 35.
194. M Hedemann-Robinson, 'Article 173 EC, General Community Measures and Locus Standi for Private Persons: Still a Cause for Individual Concern?' (1996) 2 European Public Law 127, 128.
195. GF Mancini and DT Keeling, 'Democracy and the European Court of Justice' (1994) 57 MLR 175, 186.
196. A Burely and W Mattli, 'Europe before the Court: apolitical theory of legal integration' (1993) 47 International Organisation 41, 60.
197. T Vandamme, The Invalid Directive (2005) pp 152-154.
198. H Rasmussen, 'Why is Art. 173 interpreted against private applicants' (1980) 5 ELRev 122;
199. C Harlow, 'Towards a Theory of Access to the European Court of Justice' (1992) 12 YEL 213;
200. P Nihoul, 'La recevabilité des recours en annulation introduits par un particulier a l'encontre d'un acte communautaire de portée générale' (1994) 30 RTDE 171;
201. A Arnull, 'Private Applicants and the Action for Annulment under Art. 173 of the EC Treaty' (1995) 32 CMLRev 7;
202. A Neuwahl, 'Article 174 Paragraph 4 EC: Past, Present and Possible Future' (1996) 21 ELRev 17;
203. A Arnull, 'Private Applicants and the Action for Annulment since Codorniu' (2001) 38 CMLRev 7;
204. S Enchelmaier, 'No-One Slips Through the Net? Latest Developments and Non-Developments, in the European Court of Justice's Jurisprudence on Article 230(4) EC' (2005) 24 Yearbook of European Law 173.
205. M Vogt, 'Indirect Judicial Protection in EC Law-the case of the plea of illegality' (2006) vol. 31. No 3 June ELRev, 364;
206. D Sinaniotis, 'The Plea of Illegality in EC Law' (2001) European Public Law 103.
207. G De Búrca, EU Law Text Cases and Materials (1998) 454, 457.
208. A Barav, 'Direct and Individual Concern: An Almost Insurmountable Barrier to the Admissibility of Individual Appeal to the EEC Court' (1974) 11 CMLRev 191.
209. R Greaves, 'Locus Standi under Article 173 EEC when Seeking Annulment of a Regulation' (1986) 11 ELRev 119 at 121-122.
210. A Ward, 'Locus Standi under Article 230(4) of the EC Treaty: Crafting a Coherent Test for a "Wobbly Polity"' (2003) 22 Yearbook of European Law 45.
211. A Dashwood, 'European Community legislative Procedures After Amsterdam' in A Dashwood and A Ward (eds), Cambridge Yearbook of European Legal Studies 1 (1998) 25.
212. A Ward, 'Judicial Architecture at the Cross-Roads: Private Parties and Challenge to EC Measures Post-Jégo Quéré' 4 (2001) Cambridge Yearbook of European Legal Studies 413.
213. D Sinaniotis, 'The Plea of Illegality in EC Law' (2001) European Public Law 103;
214. D Wyatt, 'The Relationship between Actions for annulment and References on Validity After TWD DEGGENDORF' in J Lonbay and A Biondi (eds), Remedies for Breach of EC Law (1996) 55;
215. J Temple-Lang, 'Actions for Declarations that Community Regulations are Invalid; the Duties of National Courts Under Article 10 EC' (2003) 28 ELRev 102.
216. C Harding, 'The Legal Acccountablity of Community Institutions: A Study of Illegality and Non-contractual Liability Under European Community Law' in R White and B Smythe (eds), Current Issues in European and International Law (1990) 52, 53.
217. M Hedemann-Robinson, 'Article 173 EC, General Community Measures and Locus Standi for Private Persons: Still a Cause for Individual Concern?' (1996) 2 European Public Law 127 at 154;
218. R Crauford Smith, 'Remedies for Breach of EC Law in National Courts: Legal Variation and Selection' in P Craig and G de Burca (eds), The Evolution of EULaw (1999).
219. M Accetto and S Zleptnig, 'The Principle of Effectiveness: Rethinking Its Role in Community Law' (2005) 11 European Public Law 375.
220. J Temple-Lang, 'New Legal Effects Resulting from the Failure of States to Fulfil Obligation Under European Community Law: the Francovich Judgment' (1991-1993) 16 Fordham International Law Journal 1, 44;
221. D Curtin, 'State Liability under Community Law: a New Remedy for Private Parties' (1992) 21 ILJ 74 at 80.
222. M Dougan, 'Cutting Your Losses and the Enforcement Deficit: A Community Right to the Recovery of Unlawfully Levied Charges' in A Dashwood and A Ward (eds), Cambridge Yearbook of European Legal Studies 1 (1998) 233;
223. K Magliveras, 'Unjust Enrichment and Restitution in Community Law' (1997) 6 Irish Journal of European Law;
224. A Biondi and L Johnson, 'The Right to Recovery of Charges Levied in Breach of Community Law: No Small Matter' (1998) 4 European Public Law 313.
225. H-J Priess, 'Recovery of Illegal State Aid: An Overview of Recent Developments in the Case Law' (1996) 33 CMLRev 69.
226. B de Witte, 'Direct Effect, Supremacy and the Nature of the Legal Order' in P Craig and G de Búrca (eds), The Evolution of EU Law (1999) 177.
227. JHH Weiler, 'Journey to an Unknown Destination: A Retrospective and Prospective of the European Court of Justice in the Arena of Political Integration' (1993) 31 JCMS 417 at 443.
228. F Snyder, 'The Effectiveness of European Community Law: Institutions, Processes, Tools and Techniques' (1993) 56 MLR 19;
229. J Weiler, 'The Community System: The Dual Character of Supranationalism' (1981) 1 YBEL 227 at 443.
230. A Ward, 'The Limits of Effective Judicial Review and Uniform Application of Community Law: a look post-Amsterdam' in C Kilpatrick, T Novitz and P Skidmore (eds), The Future of Remedies in Europe (2000).
231. N Green and A Barav, 'Damages in National Courts for Breach of Community Law' (1986) 6 YBEL 118-119.
232. A Barav, 'Damages in the Domestic Courts for Breach of Community Law by National Public Authorities' in HG Schermers and P Mead (eds), Non-Contractual Liability of the European Communities (1988) 165.
233. Parker LJ. N Green and A Barav, 'Damages in the National Courts for Breach of Community Law' (1986) 6 YBEL (1986) 55 at 117.
234. J Bengoetxea, The Legal Reasoning of the European Court of Justice (1993) 181.
235. D Curtin and T Heukels (eds), Institutional Dynamics of European Integration Liber Amicorum Henry G Schermers (1994).
236. T Eilmansbeger, 'The Relationship Between Rights and Remedies in EC Law; in search of the missing link' (2004) 41 CMLRev (2004) 1199, 1241.
237. M Dougan, National Remedies Before the Court of Justice (2004) p24.
238. P Oliver, 'Le droit communautaire et les voies de recours nationales' (1992) 28 CDE 348.
239. N Green and A Barav, 'Damages in the National Courts for Breach of Community Law' (1986) 6 YBEL 55;
240. J Steiner, 'How to Make the Action Suit the Case: Domestic Remedies for Breach of EEC Law' (1987) 12 ELRev 102;
241. A Barav, 'Damages in the Domestic Courts for Breach of Community Law by National Public Authorities' in HG Schermers et al (eds), Non-Contractual Liability of the European Communities (1988) 149;
242. D Curtin, 'Directives: the Effectiveness of Judicial Protection of Individual Rights' (1990) 27 CMLRev 709;
243. A Ward, 'Government Liability in the United Kingdom for Breach of Individual Rights in European Community Law' (1990) 19 Anglo-American Law Review 1;
244. S Weatherill, 'National Remedies and Equal Access to Public Procurement' (1990) 10 YBEL 243;
245. S Prechal, 'Remedies After Marshall' (1990) 27 CMLRev 451;
246. G Tesauro, 'La Sanction des Infractions au Droit Communautaire' (1992) 32 Rivista di Diritto Europeo 477;
247. G de Búrca, 'Giving Effect to European Community Directives' (1992) 55 MLR 215;
248. E Szyszczak, 'European Community Law: New Remedies, New Directions?' (1992) 55 MLR 690;
249. F Snyder, 'The Effectiveness of European Community Law: Institutions, Processes, Tools and Techniques' (1993) 56 MLR 19;
250. B Fitzpatrick and E Szyszczak, 'Remedies and Effective Judicial Protection in Community Law' (1994) 57 MLR 434;
251. W Van Gerven, 'Bridging the Gap Between Community and National Laws: Towards a Principle of Homogeneity in the Field of Legal Remedies?' (1995) 32 CMLRev 679;
252. R Caranta, 'Judicial Protection Against Member States: a New jus commune Takes Shape' (1995) 32 CMLRev 703;
253. A Ward, 'National Sanctions in EC Law: A Moving Boundary in the Division of Competence' (1995) No 2 ELJ;
254. J Steiner, Enforcing EC Law (1995), in particular at 42 et seq;
255. E Szyszczak, 'Making Europe More Relevant to its Citizens: Effective Judicial Process' (1996) 21 ELRev 351;
256. M Hoskins, 'Tilting the Balance: Supremacy and National Procedural Rules' (1996) 21 ELRev 365;
257. C Himsworth, 'Things Fall Apart: the Harmonistion of Community Judicial Procedural Protection Revisited' (1997) 22 ELRev 291;
258. C Kakouris, 'Do the Member States Possess Judicial Procedural Autonomy' (1997) 34 CMLRev 1389;
259. M Ruffert, 'Rights and Remedies in European Community Law: a Comparative View' (1997) 34 CMLRev 307;
260. J Lonboy and A Biondi (eds), Remedies for Breach of EC Law (1997);
261. R Craufurd Smith, 'Remedies for Breaches of EC Law in National Courts: Legal Variation and Selection' in P Craig and G de Búrca (eds), The Evolution of EU Law (1999) 287;
262. M Dougan, 'Cutting Your Losses in the Enforcement Deficit: A Community Right to the Recovery of Unlawfully Levied Charges' in A Dashwood and A Ward (eds), Cambridge Yearbook of European Legal Studies 1 (1998) 233;
263. M Dougan, National Remedies Before the Court of Justice (2004);
264. T Tridimas, The General Principles of EU Law (2006) 418-476.
265. A Ward, 'The Limits of the Uniform Application of Community Law and Effective Judicial Review: a Look Post-Amsterdam' in C Kilpatrick et al (eds), The Future of Remedies in Europe (2000) 213.