Efficiency, responsibility and disability: Philosophical lessons from the savings argument for pre-natal diagnosis

Politics, Philosophy and Economics

Volumn 14, Issue 1, 2015, Pages 3-22

  John, Stephen ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF CAMBRIDGE   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

contractualism; Disability; efficiency; pre natal diagnosis; reproductive ethics; responsibility

Indexed keywords

EID: 84922212513     PISSN: 1470594X     EISSN: 17413060     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1177/1470594X13505412     Document Type: Article

References (52)

1. Amundson RQuality of Life and Human Difference. Wasserman DBickenbach JWachbroit R, ed. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press; 2005:
2. Anderson EValue in Ethics and Economics. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press; 1993:
3. Asch A,Wasserman DQuality of Life and Human Difference. Wasserman DBickenbach JWachbroit R, ed. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press; 2005:
4. Bigelow J, et al.Parental autonomy.Journal of Applied Philosophy. 1998;5 (2): 183-196
5. Brock DQuality of Life and Human Difference. Wasserman DBickenbach JWachbroit R, ed. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press; 2005a:67-100.
6. Brock D.Shaping future children: parental rights and societal interests.Journal of Political Philosophy. 2005b;13 (4): 377-398
7. Brock DThe Bioethics Reader. Chadwick R, ed. London: WileyBlackwell; 2007:
8. Cost-effectiveness and disability discrimination.Economics and Philosophy. 2009;25 (1): 27-47
9. Brownlee K,Cureton ADisability and Disadvantage. Oxford: Oxford University Press; 2009:
10. Casal P,Williams A.Rights, equality, and procreation.Analyse & Kritik. 1995;17 (1): 93-116
11. Chamberlain J.Human benefits and costs of a national screening programme for neural tube defects.Lancet. 1978;16 (8103): 1293-1296
12. Chamberlain J.Which prescriptive screening programmes are worthwhile?.Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health. 1984;38 (4): 270-277
13. Coventry P,Pickstone J.From what and why did genetics emerge as a medical specialism in the 1970 s in the UK?.Social Science and Medicine. 1999;49 (9): 1227-1238
14. Ferguson-Smith A.Prospects for reducing the frequency of genetic disorders.Proceedings of the Royal Society of Medicine. 1974;67 (12): 1256-1257
15. Galston WLiberal Purposes: Goods, Virtues, and Diversity in the Liberal State. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press; 1991:
16. Ganiats T.Justifying prenatal screening and genetic amniocentesis programmes by cost-effectiveness analysis: A re-evaluation.Medical Decision Making. 1996;16 (1): 45-50
17. George R.Who should bear the cost of children?.Public Affairs Quarterly. 1987;1 (1): 1-42
18. Hagard S,Carter F.Preventing the birth of infants with Down’s syndrome: A cost-benefit analysis.British Medical Journal. 1976;1 (6012): 753-756
19. Hagard S,Carter F,Milne RG.Screening for spina bifida cystica.British Journal for Preventative and Social Medicine. 1976;30 (1): 40-53
20. Hall A,Bostanci A,John S.Ethical, Legal and Social Issues arising from Cell-free Fetal DNA Technologies. Cambridge: PHG Foundation; 2009:
21. Hansson S-O.Philosophical problems in Cost Benefit Analysis.Economics and Philosophy. 2007;23 (2): 163-183
22. Henderson J.Measuring the benefits of screening for open neural tube defects.Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health. 1982; (36 3): 214-219
23. Herrisone-Kelley P.Parental love and the ethics of sex selection.Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics. 2007;16 (3): 446-455
24. Report of the House of Commons Social Services Committee 1980. London: Her Majesty’s Stationery Office; 1980:
25. Holland SPublic Health Ethics. Cambridge: Polity Press; 2008:
26. Hubin D.The moral justification of benefit/cost analysis.Economics and Philosophy. 1994;10 (2): 169-194
27. Making Babies. 2006:
28. Kevles DIn the Name of Eugenics. London: Harvard University Press; 1995:
29. Kitcher PThe Lives to Come. London: Penguin; 1997:
30. LawsonD (2008) Shame on the doctors prejudiced against Down syndrome. The Independent25 November. Available at: http://www.independent.co.uk/voices/commentators/dominic-lawson/dominic-lawson-shame-on-the-doctors-prejudiced-against-down-syndrome-1033813.html
31. Lenman J.Preferences in their place.Environmental Values. 2000;9 (4): 431-451
32. Lippert-Rasmussen K.Racial profiling versus community.Journal of Applied Philosophy. 2006;23 (2): 191-205
33. MacLeod CThe Moral and Political Status of Children. MacLeod CArchard D, ed. Oxford: Oxford University Press; 2002:
34. McMahan JQuality of Life and Human Difference. Wasserman DBickenbach JWachbroit R, ed. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press; 2005:142-171.
35. Morris JKThe National Down Syndrome Cytogenetic Register 2007/8 Annual Report. London: Barts and The London School of Medicine and Dentistry; 1999:
36. Mulgan TFuture People. Oxford: Oxford University Press; 2006:
37. Newson A.Ethical aspects arising from non-invasive fetal diagnosis.Seminars in Fetal and Neonatal Medicine. 2007;13 (2): 103-108
38. Parfit DReasons and Persons. Oxford: Oxford University Press; 1984:
39. Rakowski EEqual Justice. Oxford: Clarendon Press; 1991:
40. Savulescu JThe Bioethics Reader. Chadwick R, ed. London: WileyBlackwell; 2007:
41. Scanlon TWhat We Owe To Each Other. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press; 1998:
42. Scanlon TMoral Dimensions: Permissibility, Meaning, Blame. London: Harvard University Press; 2008:
43. Schmidt H.Bonuses as incentives and rewards for health responsibility: A good thing?.Journal of Medicine and Philosophy. 2008;33 (3): 198-220
44. Schmidtz D.A place for cost-benefit analysis.Philosophical Issues. 2001;35 (1): 148-171
45. Seror V.Down syndrome serum marker screening: Decision criteria and implicit values.Health Policy. 1998;43 (1): 83-96
46. Stein Z,Susser M,Gutterman A.Screening programme for prevention of Down’s syndrome.The Lancet. 1973;301 (7798): 305-310
47. Sunstein CRisk and Reason. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press; 2002:
48. Wald N,Kennard A,Hackshaw A, et al.Antenatal screening for Down’s syndrome.Health Technology Assessment. 1998;2 (1): 75
49. Wikler DPublic Health, Ethics and Equity. Sen AAnand PPeter F, ed. Oxford: Oxford University Press; 2004:
50. Wilkinson S.‘Eugenics talk’ and the language of bioethics.Journal of Medical Ethics. 2008;34 (6): 467-471
51. Wolff JPolitical Philosophy. O'Hear A, ed. London: Royal Institute of Philosophy Supplements; 2007:
52. Wolff J.Disability, status enhancement, personal enhancement and resource allocation.Economics and Philosophy. 2009;25 (1): 49-68