Tobacco industry use of personal responsibility rhetoric in public relations and litigation: Disguising freedom to blame as freedom of choice

American Journal of Public Health

Volumn 105, Issue 2, 2015, Pages 250-260

  Friedman, Lissy C ^a   Cheyne, Andrew ^b   Givelber, Daniel ^a   Gottlieb, Mark A ^a   Daynard, Richard A ^a  

^a NORTHEASTERN UNIVERSITY   (United States)

^b PUBLIC HEALTH INSTITUTE   (United States)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

FREEDOM; HUMAN; PERSONAL AUTONOMY; PROCEDURES; PSYCHOLOGY; PUBLIC RELATIONS; SMOKING; TOBACCO INDUSTRY;

FREEDOM; HUMANS; PERSONAL AUTONOMY; PUBLIC RELATIONS; SMOKING; TOBACCO INDUSTRY;

EID: 84921890292     PISSN: 00900036     EISSN: 15410048     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.2105/AJPH.2014.302226     Document Type: Article

References (114)

1. Brandt AM. The Cigarette Century: The Rise, Fall and Deadly Persistence of the Product That Defined America. New York, NY: Basic Book; 2007.
2. Fritschler AL, Hoefler JM. Smoking &Politics: Policy Making and the Federal Bureaucracy. 5th ed. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall; 1996.
3. Rabin RL. A sociological history of the tobacco tort litigation. Stanford L Rev. 1992; 44(4): 853-878.
4. Harvard Law Review. Note: plaintiff's conduct as a defense to claims against cigarette manufacturers. Harvard L Rev. 1986; 99: 809-827.
5. Daynard RA, Gottlieb M. Casting blame on the tobacco victim: impact on assumption of the risk and related defenses in the United States tobacco litigation. Norwegian Ministry of Health and Care Services; 2000. Available at: http: //www. regjeringen. no/nb/dep/hod/ dok/nouer/2000/nou-2000-16/22. html?id=359483. Accessed March 14, 2014.
6. Proctor RN. Everyone knew but no one had proof: tobacco industry use of medical history expertise in the US courts. Tob Control. 2006; 15(suppl 4): iv117-iv125.
7. Miura M, Daynard RA. The role of litigation in tobacco control. Salud Publica Mex. 2006; 48(suppl 1): S121-S136.
8. Kyriakoudes LM. Historians' testimony on "common knowledge" of the risks of tobacco use: a review and analysis of cigarette manufacturers in civil litigation. Tob Control. 2006; 15(suppl 4): iv107-iv116.
9. Malone R. Tactics corporations use to influence health and health policy and what we can do to counter them. In Wiist WH, ed. The Bottom Line or Public Health. New York, NY: Oxford University Press; 2010: 169-172.
10. McDaniel PA, Malone RE. Understanding Philip Morris's pursuit of US government regulation of tobacco. Tob Control. 2005; 14(3): 193-200.
11. Benson P. Tobacco talk: reflections on corporate power and the legal framing of consumption. Med Anthropol Q. 2010; 24(4): 500-521.
12. Nathanson CA. Collective actors and corporate targets in tobacco control: a cross-national comparison. Health Educ Behav. 2005; 32(3): 337-354.
13. Fallin A, Grana R, Glantz SA. "To quarterback behind the scenes, third-party efforts": The tobacco industry and the Tea Party. Tob Control. 2014; 23 (4): 322-331.
14. Offen N, Arvey SR, Smith EA, Malone RE. Forcing the Navy to sell cigarettes on ships: how the tobacco industry and politicians torpedoed Navy tobacco control. Am J Public Health. 2001; 101(3): 404-411.
15. Cheyne A, Dorfman L, Daynard RA, Mejia P, Gottlieb M. The debate on regulating menthol cigarettes: closing a dangerous loophole vs freedom of choice. Am J Public Health. 2014; 104(7): e54-e61.
16. Brownell KD, Warner KE. The perils of ignoring history: Big Tobacco played dirty and millions died. How similar is Big Food. Milbank Q. 2009; 87(1): 259-294.
17. Entman RM. Framing: towards clarification of a fractured paradigm. J Commun. 1993; 4(4): 51-58.
18. Gamson WA, Croteau D, Hoynes W, Sasson T. Media images and the social construction of reality. Annu Rev Sociol. 1992; 18: 373-393.
19. Iyengar S. Is Anyone to Blame. How Television Frames Political Issues. Chicago, IL: The University of Chicago Press; 1991.
20. Dearing JW, Rogers EM. Agenda-Setting. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage; 1996.
21. Scheufele D, Tewksbury D. Framing, agenda setting, and priming: the evolution of three media effects models. J Commun. 2007; 57(1): 9-20.
22. Smoking and Health. Report of the Advisory Committee to the Surgeon General of the Public Health Service. Washington, DC: US Department of Health, Education, and Welfare; 1964.
23. Federal Cigarette Labeling and Advertising Act, 15 USC §1331, Pub L No. 89-92, 79 Stat 282 (1965).
24. Dorfman L, Cheyne A, Gottlieb MA, et al. Cigarettes become a dangerous product: tobacco in the rearview mirror, 1952-1965. Am J Public Health. 2014; 104(1): 37-46.
25. Comprehensive Smoking Education Act, 15 USC §4403, Pub L No. 99-252, 100 Stat 30 (1986).
26. Minkler M. Personal responsibility for health: contexts and controversies. In: Calahan D, ed. Promoting Healthy Behavior: How Much Freedom. Whose Responsibility. Washington, DC: Georgetown University Press; 2000.
27. Mejia P, Dorfman L, Cheyne A, et al. Who is responsible. The origins of personal responsibility rhetoric in news coverage of the tobacco industry. Am J Public Health. 2014; 104(6): 1048-1051.
28. Kessler D. A Question of Intent. New York, NY: PublicAffairs; 2001.
29. Orey M. Assuming the Risk: The Mavericks, the Lawyers, and the Whistle-Blowers Who Beat Big Tobacco. Boston, MA: Little, Brown and Company; 1999.
30. Hilts PH. Smokescreen: The Truth Behind the Tobacco Industry Cover-up. Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley Publishing Company; 1996.
31. Douglas CE, Davis RM, Beasley JK. Epidemiology of the third wave of tobacco litigation in the United States, 1994-2005. Tob Control. 2006; 15(suppl 4): iv9-iv16.
32. Engle v Liggett Group Inc, 945 So2d 1246 (Fla 2006).
33. Kennedy A, Sullivan S, Henlin Y, Barnes RL, Glantz SA, Center for Tobacco Control Research. Tobacco Control in Florida 1999-2011: The Good, The Bad, and The Ugly. 2011. Available at: http: //escholarship. org/uc/ item/9rq720x1. Accessed June 18, 2014.
34. Friedman L. Tobacco industry use of personal responsibility rhetoric in Florida litigation. Poster presentation at: National Conference on Tobacco or Health; August 15-17, 2012; Kansas City, MO [on file with author]. Abstract available at: https: //nctoh. confex. com/ nctoh/2012/webprogram/Paper1887. html. Accessed June 24, 2014.
35. Nohlgren S. Florida is epicenter of fight against big tobacco. Tampa Bay Times. June 21, 2014. Available at: http: //www. tampabay. com/news/courts/civil/theflorida-gamblers-who-took-on-big-tobacco/2185422. Accessed June 23, 2014.
36. Simon M. Appetite for Profit: How the Food Industry Undermines Our Health and How to Fight Back. New York, NY: Nation Books; 2006.
37. Yoon S, Lam TH. The illusion of righteousness: corporate social responsibility practices of the alcohol industry. BMC Public Health. 2013; 13: 630.
38. Dow Schüll N. Addiction by Design. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press; 2012.
39. Hemenway D. Private Guns, Public Health. Ann Arbor, MI: University of Michigan Press; 2006.
40. Friedman LC. Tobacco industry use of corporate social responsibility tactics as a sword and a shield on secondhand smoke issues. J LawMed Ethics. 2009; 37(4): 819-827.
41. Mahood G. Tobacco industry denormalization: telling the truth about the tobacco industry's role in the tobacco epidemic. Montreal, Quebec: Non-Smokers' Rights Association, Smoking and Health Action Foundation; 2004. Available at: http: //www. nsra-adnf. ca/cms/file/ files/pdf/TID-Booklet. pdf. Accessed March 14, 2014.
42. Friedman LC. Shifting the burden from corporations to the public: the tobacco industry plays a shell game with corporate social responsibility and personal responsibility. Paper presented at: the 138th American Public Health Association Annual Meeting, November 9, 2010; Denver, CO [on file with author].
43. Legacy Tobacco Documents Library. Available at: http: //legacy. library. ucsf. edu. Accessed March 14, 2014.
44. Malone RE, Balbach E. Tobacco industry documents: treasure trove or quagmire. Tob Control. 2000; 9(3): 334-338.
45. Legacy Tobacco Documents Library. About the collections: Tobacco DATTA: Depositions and Trial Testimony Archive. Available at: http: //legacy. library. ucsf. edu/about/about-collections. jsp#datta. Accessed March 17, 2014.
46. Anderson SJ, McCandless PM, Klausner K, Taketa R, Yerger VB. Tobacco documents research methodology. Tob Control. 2011; 20(suppl 2): ii8-ii11.
47. Creswell JW. Qualitative Inquiry and Research Design: Choosing Among Five Traditions. London, England: Sage; 1998.
48. Kluger R. Ashes to Ashes: America's Hundred-Year Cigarette War, the Public Health, and the Unabashed Triumph of Philip Morris. New York, NY: Vintage Books; 1997.
49. Glantz S, Slade J, Bero L, Hanauer P, Barnes D. The Cigarette Papers. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press; 1996.
50. US v Philip Morris USA Inc et al., 449 FSupp2d 1 (DDC 2006).
51. Outline of proposed long term plan of communications for the tobacco industry. Proposal. May 1977. R. J. Reynolds. Bates no. 502124251-502124252. Available at: http: //legacy. library. ucsf. edu/tid/ikb29d00. Accessed March 17, 2014.
52. Philip Morris. Industry relations. 1978. R. J. Reynolds. Bates no. 2501019506. Available at: http: //legacy. library. ucsf. edu/tid/ghy59d00. Accessed March 17, 2014.
53. Delbanco A. The Real American Dream: AMeditation on Hope. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press; 1999.
54. Glendon MA. Rights Talk: The Impoverishment of Political Discourse. New York, NY: The Free Press; 1991.
55. de Tocqueville A. Democracy in America. de Tocqueville A, Mansfield HC, Winthrop D, trans. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press; 2000.
56. Batten, Barton, Durstine &Osborn. Issues and answers. March 6, 1976. R. J. Reynolds. Bates no. 501361366. Available at: http: //legacy. library. ucsf. edu/tid/amj49d00. Accessed March 17, 2014.
57. The Tobacco Institute. Re: The Cigarette Controversy. 1977. Ness Motley. Bates No. 500819192. Available at: http: //legacy. library. ucsf. edu/tid/ axj56b00. Accessed March 17, 2014.
58. Kornegay HR. Statement of H. R. Kornegay, President, The Tobacco Institute at the 19th Annual Meeting Tobacco Growers Information Committee. October 14, 1977. Lorillard. Bates no. 00499802. Available at: http: //legacy. library. ucsf. edu/tid/oae61e00. Accessed March 17, 2014.
59. No author. Draft # 3-media briefing script. 1970. Brown &Williamson. Bates no. 690016144. Available at: http: //legacy. library. ucsf. edu/tid/urw93f00. Accessed July 21, 2014.
60. Kloepfer W. Re: Transcript of a tape made by Philip Morris. July 18, 1973. Ness Motley. Bates no. TIFL0505352-TIFL0505353. Available at: http: //legacy. library. ucsf. edu/tid/btc56b00. Accessed July 21, 2014.
61. Browder A. How to stop smoking-American Cancer Society tobacco industry spokesperson, CHUM-Radio, Toronto. February 2, 1978. Tobacco Institute. Bates no. TIFL0510415. Available at http: //legacy. library. ucsf. edu/tid/ryu02f00. Accessed July 21, 2014.
62. No author. Untitled Philip Morris internal strategy report. 1978. Philip Morris. Bates no. 2501241597. Available at: http: //legacy. library. ucsf. edu/tid/ lbr22e00. Accessed July 21, 2014.
63. Conroy G. Tobacco: a freedom of choice. Pentagraph. July 14, 1979. Tobacco Institute. Bates no. TI31101323. Available at: http: //legacy. library. ucsf. edu/tid/uyq35b00. Accessed July 21, 2014.
64. Drath C. Channel 9 mid-morning LA, KHJ Channel 9, Los Angeles. February 1, 1980. Tobacco Institute. Bates no. TI09090443. Available at: http: //legacy. library. ucsf. edu/tid/tqi79b00. Accessed July 21, 2014.
65. Fyock J. Report concerning a public relations matter prepared by RJR legal consultant in connection with ongoing litigation transmitted to RJR in-house legal counsel, RJR outside legal counsel and RJR employee for the purpose of rendering legal advice. October 3, 1985. Bates no. 515776851. Available at: http: //legacy. library. ucsf. edu/tid/vil76b00. Accessed July 21, 2014.
66. Ball M. Rights of smokers being championed by a nonsmoker. The Times Picayune. November 15, 1978. Tobacco Institute. Bates no. TI21361263. Available at: http: //legacy. library. ucsf. edu/tid/rkg84b00. Accessed July 21, 2014.
67. Tobacco Institute. The Comprehensive Smoking Prevention Education Act of 1983 is unnecessary, unproved in operation and potentially counterproductive. 1983. Tobacco Institute. Bates no. TI22590581. Available at: http: //legacy. library. ucsf. edu/tid/rcs85b00. Accessed July 21, 2014.
68. Pyatt RA Jr, Horwitz S. Tobacco firms step up to diversify. Washington Post. October 6, 1985. Tobacco Institute. Bates no. TI49670931. Available at: http: //legacy. library. ucsf. edu/tid/juc28b00. Accessed July 21, 2014.
69. Philip Morris. Tobacco issues claims vs. facts. c. 1986-1988. Philip Morris. Bates no. 2501443313. Available at: http: //legacy. library. ucsf. edu/tid/ gzh22e00. Accessed July 21, 2014.
70. Merryman W. The Peter Mead Show. 1979. Tobacco Institute. Bates no. TI01550631. Available at: http: //legacy. library. ucsf. edu/tid/ckj19a00. Accessed March 17, 2014.
71. Tobacco Action Network. If you are tired of the federal government telling you how to run your life, now's the time to speak. April 14, 1983. Tobacco Institute. Bates no. TI03310696. Available at: http: //legacy. library. ucsf. edu/tid/tyo24b00. Accessed March 17, 2014.
72. Givelber D. Cigarette law. Indiana Law J. 1998; 73: 867-901.
73. Garner B. Black's Law Dictionary 9th Edition. Eagan, MN: West Publishing; 2009.
74. American Law Institute. Restatement (Third) of Torts: Product Liability. Philadelphia, PA: American Law Institute Publishers; 1997.
75. Cody NC, O'Reilly JT. The Products Liability Resource Manual: An Attorney's Guide to Analyzing Issues, Developing Strategies, and Winning Cases. Chicago, IL: American Bar Association; 1993: 149, 159-160.
76. Campaign for Tobacco-Free Kids. Tobacco Use Among Youth. March 4, 2013. Available at: http: //www. tobaccofreekids. org/research/factsheets/pdf/0002. pdf. Accessed March 17, 2014.
77. Steinberg L, Scott ES. Less guilty by reason of adolescence, developmental immaturity, diminished responsibility, and the juvenile death penalty. Am Psychol. 2003; 58(12): 1009-1018.
78. Ciresi MV, Walburn RB, Sutton TD. Decades of deceit: document discovery in the Minnesota tobacco litigation. Wm Mitchell L Rev; 1999; 25: 477-564.
79. US Department of Health and Human Services. Reducing Tobacco Use: A Report of the Surgeon General. Atlanta, GA: National Center for Chronic Disease Prevention and Health Promotion, Office on Smoking and Health; 2000.
80. Shook, Hardy &Bacon (B&W Outside Counsel). Training materials for counsel in smoking &health litigation; volume VI new cases: 820000 defendants' jury work defendants' strategy. 1982. Brown &Williamson. Bates no. 282012884-282013316. Available at: http: //legacy. library. ucsf. edu/tid/cnz95a00. Accessed March 17, 2014.
81. Browder A. The Tobacco Institute Inc. response to WTOP-TV American Smoke Out. November 16, 1977. Tobacco Institute. Bates no. TIFL0510816. Available at: http: //legacy. library. ucsf. edu/tid/iav02f00. Accessed July 21, 2014.
82. Associated Press. FTC wants stronger cigarette warning. Associated Press. July 21, 1977. Tobacco Institute. Bates no. TIMN0118415. Available at: http: //legacy. library. ucsf. edu/tid/agh92f00. Accessed July 21, 2014.
83. Kornegay H. Statement of Horace R. Kornegay President, The Tobacco Institute, Inc. before the Subcommittee on Health and the Environment of the House Committee on Interstate and Foreign Commerce. February 15, 1978. R. J. Reynolds. Bates no. 503801594-503801595. Available at: http: //legacy. library. ucsf. edu/tid/cpb85d00. Accessed July 21, 2014.
84. Roach B. Interview of Bob Roach by Dan Lewis of Channel January 11, 1978. Bates no. 680204682. Available at: http: //legacy. library. ucsf. edu/tid/ pwi66b00. Accessed July 21, 2014.
85. Dwyer WF. Statement by William F. Dwyer, vice president, The Tobacco Institute. January 10, 1978. Council for Tobacco Research. Bates no. 10421182. Available at: http: //legacy. library. ucsf. edu/tid/ hsu4aa00. Accessed July 21, 2014.
86. Tobacco Institute. Our believability is measured not merely by what we say, but what we do. November 29, 1978. R. J. Reynolds. Bates no. 503646982. Available at: http: // legacy. library. ucsf. edu/tid/atr85d00. Accessed July 21, 2014.
87. Prugh J. HEW huffs, tobaccoland plows ahead. Los Angeles Times. January 23, 1978. Tobacco Institute. Bates no. TI03580513. Available at: http: //legacy. library. ucsf. edu/tid/pbo79b00. Accessed July 21, 2014.
88. Randolph E. Califano has tobacco belt burned up. Chicago Tribune. March 16, 1978. Brown &Williamson. Bates no. 680204455. Available at: http: //legacy. library. ucsf. edu/tid/fvi13f00. Accessed July 21, 2014.
89. Philip Morris. Issues A-Z. 1978. Philip Morris. Bates no. 2501241574. Available at http: //legacy. library. ucsf. edu/tid/lbr22e00. Accessed July 21, 2014.
90. Trial testimony of DavidMichael Burns, MD, Roysdon v. R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co. December 11, 1985. DATTA. Bates no. CTRMN037436. Available at http: //legacy. library. ucsf. edu/tid/nkk79a00. Accessed March 17, 2014.
91. Trial testimony of Samuel D. Chilcote, Kueper v. R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co. November 19, 1992. DATTA. At p. 1610. Bates no. CHILCOTES111992. Available at: http: //legacy. library. ucsf. edu/tid/vga85a00. Accessed March 17, 2014.
92. Deposition of James Chandler Bowling. Cipollone v. Liggett Group Inc. December 18, 1984. DATTA. At p.
93. Bates no. BOWLINGJ121884. Available at: http: //legacy. library. ucsf. edu/tid/sma85a00. Accessed March 17, 2014.
94. Cipollone v. Liggett Group Inc, 505 US 504 (1992).
95. Defendant opening statement. Cipollone v. Liggett Group Inc. February 1, 1988. DATTA. Bates no. 85850121. Available at: http: //legacy. library. ucsf. edu/ tid/upo11b00. Accessed March 17, 2014.
96. Defendant closing statement. Cipollone v. Liggett Group Inc. June 2, 1988 [a. m. ]. DATTA. Bates no. 85862039. Available at: http: //legacy. library. ucsf. edu/ tid/noo11b00. Accessed March 17, 2014.
97. Browder A. State activities field meeting Lake Geneve Wisconsin a presentation. August 4, 1981. Tobacco Institute. Bates no. TI09280191. Available at: http: //legacy. library. ucsf. edu/tid/cvr92b00. Accessed March 17, 2014.
98. Whist A. Tobacco issue briefs. April 1985. Philip Morris. Bates no. 2501444257. Available at: http: // www. legacy. library. ucsf. edu/tid/gor22e00. Accessed March 17, 2014.
99. Dorfman L, Wallack L, Woodruff K. More than a message: framing public health advocacy to change corporate practices. Health Educ Behav. 2005; 32(3): 320-336.
100. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Designing and Implementing an Effective Tobacco Counter-Marketing Campaign. Atlanta, GA: National Center for Chronic Disease Prevention and Health Promotion, Office on Smoking and Health; 2003.
101. Malone RE. Word wars and tobacco control: saying what needs saying that we don't yet know how to say, or saying it better. Tob Control. 2010; 19(4): 261-262.
102. Wallack L, Dorfman L. Media advocacy: a strategy for advancing policy and promoting health. Health Educ Q. 1996; 23(3): 293-317.
103. Freudenberg N. Public health advocacy to change corporate practices: implications for health education practice and research. Health Educ Behav. 2005; 32(3): 298-319.
104. Dorfman L, Cheyne A, Friedman LC, Wadud A, Gottlieb M. Soda and tobacco industry corporate social responsibility campaigns: how do they compare. PLoS Med. 2012; 9(6): e1001241.
105. Moodie R, Stuckler D, Monteiro C, et al. Profits and pandemics: prevention of harmful effects of tobacco, alcohol, and ultra-processed food and drink industries. Lancet. 2013; 381(9867): 670-679.
106. Jahiel RI, Babor T. Lead editorial: Industrial epidemics, public health advocacy and the alcohol industry: lessons from other fields. Addiction. 2007; 102(9): 1335-1339.
107. Union of Concerned Scientists. Smoke, mirrors and hot air: how ExxonMobil uses Big Tobacco's tactics to manufacture uncertainty on climate science. January 2007. Available at: http: //www. ucsusa. org/assets/documents/ global-warming/exxon-report. pdf. Accessed March 17, 2014.
108. American Nonsmokers' Rights Foundation. The gaming industry stacks the deck against smokefree workplaces in Indiana. 2009. Available at: http: //www. no-smoke. org/pdf/gaminglegindiana-report. pdf. Accessed March 17, 2014.
109. Freudenberg N. Lethal But Legal: Corporations, Consumption and Protecting Public Health. New York, NY: Oxford University Press; 2014.
110. Atkin JL, McCardle M, Newell SJ. The role of advertiser motives in consumer evaluations of "responsibility" messages from the alcohol industry. J Mark Commun. 2008; 14(4): 315-335.
111. US Department of Health and Human Services. The Surgeon General's Call to Action to Prevent and Decrease Overweight and Obesity. Rockville, MD: Public Health Service, Office of the Surgeon General; 2001.
112. Coca-Cola Company. The Coca-Cola Company reinforces its commitment to help America in the fight against obesity. January 14, 2013. Available at: http: //www. coca-colacompany. com/press-center/ press-releases/the-coca-cola-company-reinforces-itscommitment-to-help-america-in-The-fight-against-obesity. Accessed March 17, 2014.
113. Center for Consumer Freedom. California soda scolds push unnecessary warnings. 2014. Available at: http: //www. consumerfreedom. com/2014/04/ california-soda-scolds-push-unnecessary-warnings. Accessed June 27, 2014.
114. Wilking W. Issue brief: Reining in pester power food and beverage marketing. 2011. Available at: http: // www. phaionline. org/wp-content/uploads/2011/09/ Pester-power. pdf. Accessed June 27, 2014