The burning question: Does forest bioenergy reduce carbon emissions? A review of common misconceptions about forest carbon accounting

Journal of Forestry

Volumn 113, Issue 1, 2015, Pages 57-68

  Ter Mikaelian, Michael T ^a   Colombo, Stephen J ^b   Chen, Jiaxin ^b  

^a ONTARIO FOREST RESEARCH INSTITUTE   (Canada)

^b Ontario Forest Research Institute   (United States)

Author keywords

Bioenergy; Carbon debt repayment; Carbon sequestration parity; Dividend then debt; No harvest baseline; Plantations; Reference point baseline; Stand versus landscape

Indexed keywords

BIOMASS; CARBON; GAS EMISSIONS; GREENHOUSE GASES; HARVESTING;

BIO-ENERGY; CARBON SEQUESTRATION; DEBT REPAYMENT; DIVIDEND-THEN-DEBT; PLANTATIONS; REFERENCE POINTS;

FORESTRY;

BIOENERGY; BIOMASS BURNING; CARBON DIOXIDE; CARBON EMISSION; CARBON SEQUESTRATION; GREENHOUSE GAS; PLANTATION;

EID: 84921802847     PISSN: 00221201     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.5849/jof.14-016     Document Type: Review

References (80)

1. ABT, K.L., R.C. ABT, AND C. GALIK. 2012. Effect of bioenergy demands and supply response on markets, carbon, and land use. For. Sci, 58: 523-539.
2. ABT, R.C., C.S. GALIK, AND J.D. HENDERSON. 2010. The nearterm market and greenhouse gas implications of forest biomass utilization in the Southeastern United States, Climate Change Policy Partnership, Duke University, Durham, NC. Available online at nicholasinstitute. duke.edu/sites/default/files/publications/ near-term-market-and-ghg-implications-offorest-biomass-in-southeast-paper.pdf; last accessed Oct. 1, 2014.
3. AEBIOM. 2013. Forest sustainability and carbon balance of EU importation of North American forest biomass for bioenergy production (AEBIOM). Report by AEBIOM European Biomass Association, BC Bioenergy Network, US Industrial Pellet Association, and Wood Pellet Association of Canada. Available online at www.aebiom.org/wp-content/uploads/2013/ 09/Final-Carbon-Study-Report-AEBIOM. pdf; last accessed Oct. 1, 2014.
4. AGOSTINI, A., J. GIUNTOLI, AND A. BOULAMANTI. 2013. Carbon accounting of forest bioenergy: Conclusions and recommendations from a critical literature review, European Commission Joint Research Centre, Institute for Energy, and Transport, Tech. Rep. EUR 25354 EN. Available online at iet.jrc.ec.europa.eu/bf-ca/ sites/bfca/files/files/documents/eur25354en_ online-final.pdf; last accessed Oct. 1, 2014.
5. BONIN, C., AND R. LAL. 2012. Bioethanol potentials and life-cycle assessments of biofuel feedstocks. Crit. Rev. Plant Sci, 31:271-289.
6. BRANDER, M., R. TIPPER, C. HUTCHISON, AND G. DAVIS. 2008. Consequential and attributional approaches to LCA: A guide to policy makers with specific reference to greenhouse gas LCA of biofuels. Ecometrica Press. 14 p. Available online at www.globalbioenergy.org/uploads/media/ 0804_Ecometrica_-_Consequential_and_ attributional_approaches_to_LCA.pdf; last accessed Oct. 1, 2014.
7. BERNDES, G., N. BIRD, AND A. COWIE. 2010. Bioenergy, land use change and climate change mitigation, IEA Bioenergy:ExCo:2010:03. 20 p. Available online at task39.org/files/2013/05/ Bioenergy-Land-Use-Change-and-Climate-Change-Mitigation.pdf; last accessed Oct. 1, 2014.
8. BIRD, N., A.COWIE, F. CHERUBINI, AND G. JUNGMEIER. 2011. Using a life cycle assessment approach to estimate the net greenhouse gas emissions of bioenergy. IEA Bioenergy:ExCo:2011: 03. 20 p. Available online at www.ieabioenergy. com/publications/using-a-lca-approach-toestimate-the-net-ghg-emissions-of-bioenergy/; last accessed Oct. 1, 2014.
9. CAMPBELL, J.E., J.F. FOX, AND P.M. ACTON. 2012. Terrestrial carbon losses from mountaintop coal mining offset regional forest carbon sequestration in the 21st century. Environ. Res. Lett, 7:045701, 6 p. doi:10.1088/1748-9326/7/4/045701.
10. CHEN, J., S. COLOMBO, AND M. TER-MIKAELIAN. 2008. Future carbon storage in harvested wood products from Ontario's Crown forests. Can. J. For. Res, 38:1947-1958.
11. CHEN, J., S. COLOMBO, AND M. TER-MIKAELIAN. 2013. Carbon stocks and flows from harvest to disposal in harvested wood products from Ontario and Canada. Ontario Ministry of Natural Resources, Climate Change Res. Rep. CCRR-33, Applied Research and Development Branch, Ontario, Canada. 41 p.
12. CHERUBINI, F., N.D. BIRD, A. COWIE, G. JUNGMEIER, B. SCHLAMADINGER, AND S. WOESSGALLASCHA. 2009. Energy-and greenhouse gas-based LCA of biofuel and bioenergy systems: Key issues, ranges and recommendations. Resour. Conserv. Recycling 53:434-447.
13. CHERUBINI, F., G.P. PETERS, T. BERNTSEN, A.H. STRØMMAN, AND E. HERTWICH. 2011. CO2 emissions from biomass combustion for bioenergy: Atmospheric decay and contribution to global warming. Global Change Biol. Bioenergy 3:413-426.
14. COLOMBO, S.J., J. CHEN, M.T. TER-MIKAELIAN, J. MCKECHNIE, P.C. ELKIE, H.L. MACLEAN, AND L.S. HEATH. 2012. Forest protection and forest harvest as strategies for ecological sustainability and climate change mitigation. For. Ecol. Manage, 281:140-151.
15. COOPER, C.F. 1983. Carbon storage in managed forests. Can. J. For. Res, 13:155-166.
16. DAIGNEAULT, A., B. SOHNGEN, AND R. SEDJO. 2012. Economic approach to assess the forest carbon implications of biomass energy. Environ. Sci. Technol, 46:5664-5671.
17. DEHUE, B. 2013. Implications of a 'carbon debt' on bioenergy's potential to mitigate climate change. Biofuels Bioprod. Biorefining 7:228-234.
18. DOMKE, G.M., D.R. BECKER, A.W. D'AMATO, A.R. EK, AND C.W. WOODALL. 2012. Carbon emissions associated with the procurement and utilization of forest harvest residues for energy, northern Minnesota, USA. Biomass Bioenergy 36:141-150.
19. DROHAN, P.J., M. BRITTINGHAM, J. BISHOP, AND K. YODER. 2012. Early trends in landcover change and forest fragmentation due to shalegas development in Pennsylvania: A potential outcome for the Northcentral Appalachians. Environ. Manage, 49:1061-1075.
20. FORBES, M.S., R.J. RAISON, AND J.O. SKJEMSTAD. 2006. Formation, transformation and transport of black carbon (charcoal) in terrestrial and aquatic ecosystems. Sci. Total Environ, 370:190-206.
21. FROESE, R.E., D.R. SHONNARD, C.A. MILLER, K.P. KOERS, AND D.M. JOHNSON. 2010. An evaluation of greenhouse gas mitigation options for coal-fired power plants in the US Great Lakes States. Biomass Bioenergy 34:251-262.
22. FUGLESTVEDT, J.S., K.P. SHINE, T. BERNTSEN, J. COOK, D.S. LEE, A. STENKE, R.B. SKEIE, G.J.M. VELDERS, AND I.A. WAITZ. 2010. Transport impacts on atmosphere and climate: Metrics. Atmos. Environ. Vol, 44: 4648-4677.
23. GALIK, C.S., AND R.C. ABT. 2012. The effect of assessment scale and metric selection on the greenhouse gas benefits of woody biomass. Biomass Bioenergy 44:1-7.
24. GRONOWSKA, M., S. JOSHI, AND H.L. MACLEAN. 2009. A review of US and Canadian biomass supply studies. BioResources 4:341-369.
25. GUSTAVSSON, L., L. ERIKSSON, AND R. SATHRE. 2011. Costs and CO2 benefits of recovering, refining and transporting logging residues for fossil fuel replacement. Appl. Energy 88:192-197.
26. GUSTAVSSON, L., K. PINGOUD, AND R. SATHRE. 2006. Carbon dioxide balance of wood substitution: Comparing concrete-and woodframed buildings. Mitig. Adapt. Strategies Global Change 11:667-691.
27. HABERL, H., D. SPRINZ, M. BONAZOUNTAS, P. COCCO, Y. DESAUBIES,M. HENZE, O. HERTEL, ET AL. 2012. Correcting a fundamental error in greenhouse gas accounting related to bioenergy. Energy Policy 45:18-23.
28. HARDY, C.C. 1996 Guidelines for estimating volume, biomass, and smoke production for piled slash. USDA For. Serv., Gen. Tech. Rep. PNW-GTR-364, Pacific Northwest Research Station, Portland, OR. 17 p.
29. HAVLIK, P., U.W. SCHNEIDER, E. SCHMID, H. BÖTTCHER, S. FRITZ, R. SKALSKY, K. AOKI, ET AL. 2011. Global land-use implications of first and second generation biofuel targets. Energy Policy 39: 5690-5702.
30. HEDEGAARD, K., K. THYØ, AND H. WENZEL. 2008. Life cycle assessment of an advanced bioethanol technology in the perspective of constrained biomass availability. Environ. Sci. Technol, 42: 7992-7999.
31. HELIN, T., L. SOKKA, S. SOIMAKALLIO, K. PINGOUD, AND T. PAJULA. 2013. Approaches for inclusion of forest carbon cycle in life cycle assessment-A review. Global Change Biol. Bioenergy 5:475-486.
32. HOLTSMARK, B. 2012. Harvesting in boreal forests and the biofuel carbon debt. Climatic Change 112:415-428.
33. HUDIBURG, T.W., B.E. LAW, C. WIRTH, AND S. LUYSSAERT. 2011. Regional carbon dioxide implications of forest bioenergy production. Nat. Climate Change 1:419-423.
34. HUJALA, M., H. ARMINEN, R.C. HILL, AND K. PUUMALAINEN. 2013. Explaining the shifts of international trade in pulp and paper industry. For. Sci, 59:211-222.
35. INCE, P., A. KRAMP, K. SKOG, D. YOO, AND V. SAMPLE. 2011. Modeling future US forest sector market and trade impacts of expansion in wood energy consumption. J. For. Econ, 17: 142-156.
36. INTERGOVERNMENTAL PANEL ON CLIMATE CHANGE (IPCC). 2006. IPCC guidelines for national greenhouse gas inventories, Vol. 2: Energy, Eggleston, H.S., L. Buenida, K. Miwa, T. Ngara, and K. Tanabe (eds.). Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, Japan, 2006. Available online at www.ipcc-nggip.iges.or.jp/public/2006gl/; last accessed Oct. 1, 2014.
37. INTERGOVERNMENTAL PANEL ON CLIMATE CHANGE (IPCC). 2007. Climate change 2007: The physical science basis; contribution of Working Group I to the Fourth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, Solomon, S., D. Qin, M. Manning, Z. Chen, M. Marquis, K.B. Averyt, M. Tignor, and H.L. Miller (eds.). Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK. Available online at www. ipcc.ch/publications_and_data/ar4/wg1/en/ contents.html; last accessed Oct. 1, 2014.
38. JOHNSON, E., AND D. TSCHUDI. 2012. Baseline effects on carbon footprints of biofuels: The case of wood. Environ. Impact Assess. Rev, 37: 12-17.
39. JONKER, J.G.G., H.M. JUNGINGER, AND A. FAAIJ. 2014. Carbon payback period and carbon offset parity point of wood pellet production in the Southeastern USA. Global Change Biol. Bioenergy 6:371-389.
40. KURZ, W.A., C.C. DYMOND, T.M. WHITE, G. STINSON, C.H. SHAW, G.J. RAMPLEY, C. SMYTH, ET AL. 2009. CBM-CFS3: A model of carbon-dynamics in forestry and land-use change implementing IPCC standards. Ecol. Model, 220:480-504.
41. LAMERS, P., AND M. JUNGINGER. 2013. The 'debt' is in the detail: A synthesis of recent temporal forest carbon analyses on woody biomass for energy. Biofuels Bioprod. Biorefining 7:373-385.
42. LAMERS, P., M. JUNGINGER, C.C. DYMOND, AND A. FAAIJ. 2014. Damaged forests provide an opportunity to mitigate climate change. Global Change Biol. Bioenergy 6:44-60.
43. LATTA, G.S., J.S. BAKER, R.H. BEACH, S.K. ROSE, AND B.A.MCKARL. 2013. A multi-sector intertemporal optimization approach to assess the GHG implications of US forest and agricultural biomass electricity expansion. J. For. Econ, 19:361-383.
44. LIPPKE, B., E. ONEIL, R. HARRISON, K. SKOG, L. GUSTAVSSON, AND R. SATHRE. 2011. Life cycle impacts of forest management and wood utilization on carbon mitigation: Knowns and unknowns. Carbon Manage, 2:303-333.
45. LUYSSAERT, S., E.-D. SCHULZE, A. BÖRNER, A. KNOHL, D. HESSENMÖLLER, B.E. LAW, P. CIAIS, AND J. GRACE. 2008. Old-growth forests as global carbon sinks. Nature 456:213-215.
46. MARLAND, G. 2010. Accounting for carbon dioxide emissions from bioenergy systems. J. Ind. Ecol, 14:866-869.
47. MATTHEWS, R., N. MORTIMER, E. MACKIE, C. HATTO, A. EVANS, O. MWABONJE, T. RANDLE, W. ROLLS, M. SAYCE, AND I. TUBBY. 2012. Carbon impacts of using biomass in bioenergy and other sectors: Forests, Research Agency of the Forestry Commission, Rep. URN 12D/ 085, UK. Available online at www.gov.uk/ government/uploads/system/uploads/ attachment_data/file/48346/5133-carbonimpacts-of-using-biomanss-and-other-sectors. pdf; last accessed Oct. 1, 2014.
48. MCKECHNIE, J., S. COLOMBO, J. CHEN, W. MABEE, AND H.L. MACLEAN. 2011. Forest bioenergy or forest carbon? Assessing trade-offs in greenhouse gas mitigation with wood-based fuels. Environ. Sci. Technol, 45:789-795.
49. MICALES, J.A., AND K.E. SKOG. 1997. The decomposition of forest products in landfills. Int. Biodeterior. Biodegrad, 39:145-158.
50. MINER, R.A., R.C. ABT, J.L. BOWYER, M.A. BUFORD, R.W.MALMSHEIMER, J.O'LAUGHLIN, E.E. ONEIL, R.A. SEDJO, AND K.E. SKOG. 2014. Forest carbon accounting considerations in US bioenergy policy. J. For, 112:32-40.
51. MITCHELL, S.R., M.E. HARMON, AND K.E. O'CONNELL. 2012. Carbon debt and carbon sequestration parity in forest bioenergy production. Global Change Biol. Bioenergy 4:818-827.
52. NAIK, S.N., V.V. GOUD, P.K. ROUT, AND A.K. DALAI. 2010. Production of first and second generation biofuels: A comprehensive review. Renewable Sustain. Energy Rev, 14: 578-597.
53. NATIONAL COUNCIL FOR AIR AND STREAM IMPROVEMENT, INC. 2013. A review of biomass carbon accounting methods and implications. National Council for Air and Stream Improvement, Inc., Tech. Bull. No. 1015, Research Triangle Park, NC. Available online at www. ncasi.org/Downloads/Download.ashx?id_ 8832; last accessed Oct. 1, 2014.
54. NEPAL, P., P. INCE, K. SKOG, AND S. CHANG. 2012. Projection of US forest sector carbon sequestration under US and global timber market and wood energy consumption scenarios, 2010-2060. Biomass Bioenergy 45:251-264.
55. PAN, Y., R.A. BIRDSEY, J. FANG, R. HOUGHTON, P.E. KAUPPI, W.A. KURZ, O.L. PHILLIPS, ET AL. 2011. A large and persistent carbon sink in the world's forests. Science 333:988-993.
56. PRAG, A., C. HOOD, AND P.M. BARATA. 2013. Made to measure: Options for emissions accounting under the UNFCCC. Climate Change Expert Group Pap. No. 2013(1). Available online at www.oecd.org/officialdocuments/ publicdisplaydocumentpdf/?cote_COM/ ENV/EPOC/IEA/SLT%282013%291 &docLanguage_En; last accessed Oct. 1, 2014.
57. RABL, A., A. BENOIST, D. DRON, B. PEUPORTIER, J.V. SPADARO, AND A. ZOUGHAIB. 2007. How to account for CO2 emissions from biomass in an LCA. Int. J. Life Cycle Assess, 12:281.
58. RAY, C. 2012. One way or another. Can. Biomass 2012 (Nov-Dec). Available online at www. canadianbiomassmagazine.ca/index. php?option_com_content&task_view&id_ 3827&Itemid_132; last accessed Oct. 1, 2014.
59. REPO, A., R. KA¨NKA¨NEN, J.-P. TUOVINEN, R. ANTIKAINEN, M. TUOMI, P. VANHALA, AND J. LISKI. 2012. Forest bioenergy climate impact can be improved by allocating forest residue removal. Global Change Biol. Bioenergy 4:202-212.
60. RICHTER, K. 1998. Life cycle assessment of wood products. P. 219-248 in Carbon dioxide mitigation in forestry and wood industry, Kohlmaier, G.H., M. Weber, and R.A. Houghton (eds.). Springer-Verlag, Berlin, Germany.
61. SATHRE, R., AND L. GUSTAVSSON. 2011. Timedependent climate benefits of using forest residues to substitute fossil fuels. Biomass Bioenergy 357:2506-2516.
62. SEARCHINGER, T.D., S.P. HAMBURG, J. MELILLO, W. CHAMEIDES, P. HAVLIK, D.M. KAMMEN, G.E. LIKENS, ET AL. 2009. Fixing a critical climate accounting error. Science 326:527-528.
63. SEDJO, R.A. 2011. Carbon neutrality and bioenergy: A zero-sum game? Resources for the Future, Discussion Pap. RFF DP 11-15, Washington, DC. Available online at www.rff.org/ documents/RFF-DP-11-15.pdf; last accessed Oct. 1, 2014.
64. SEDJO, R.A., AND X. TIAN. 2012. Does wood bioenergy increase carbon stocks in forests? J. For, 110:304-311.
65. SHINE, K.P. 2009. The global warming potential-The need for an interdisciplinary retrial. Climatic Change 96:467-472.
66. SKOG, K.E., AND G.A. NICHOLSON. 2000. Carbon sequestration in wood and paper products. P. 79-88 in The impact of climate change on America's forests: A technical document supporting the 2000 USDA Forest Service RPA assessment, Joyce, L.A., and R. Birdsey (eds.). USDA For. Serv., Gen. Tech. Rep. RMRSGTR-59, Rocky Mountain Research Station, Fort Collins, CO. 133 p.
67. SLEETER, B.M., T.S. WILSON, AND W. ACEVEDO (EDS.). 2012. Status and trends of land change in the Western United States-1973 to 2000, US Geological Survey, Professional Pap. 1794-A. 324 p. Available online at pubs.usgs.gov/pp/ 1794/a/; last accessed Oct. 1, 2014.
68. STRAUSS, W. 2011. How Manomet got it backwards: Challenging the "debt-then-dividend" axiom. Available online at futuremetrics.info/ wp-content/uploads/2013/07/Manomet-Got-it-Backwards.pdf; last accessed Oct. 1, 2014.
69. STRAUSS,W. 2013. Why CO2 from wood fuels is carbon neutral in combustion. Environ. Manage. Mag. 2013(May):13-15. Available online at www.awma.org; last accessed Oct. 1, 2014.
70. STRAUSS, W., AND L. SCHMIDT. 2012. Bioenergy battle-Wood versus coal. Can. Biomass 2012 (Mar-Apr). Available online at www. canadianbiomassmagazine.ca/index. php?option_com_content&task_view&id_ 3247&Itemid_132; last accessed Oct. 1, 2014.
71. TER-MIKAELIAN, M., S.J. COLOMBO, AND J. CHEN. 2014a. Effect of age and disturbance on decadal changes in carbon stocks in managed forest landscapes in central Canada. Mitigation Adaptation Strategies Global Change 19:1063-1075.
72. TER-MIKAELIAN, M.T., S.J. COLOMBO, D. LOVEKIN, J. MCKECHNIE, R. REYNOLDS, B. TITUS, E. LAURIN, A.-M. CHAPMAN, J. CHEN, AND H.L. MCLEAN. 2014b. Carbon debt repayment or carbon sequestration parity? Lessons from a forest bioenergy case study in Ontario, Canada. Global Change Biol. Bioenergy, doi: 10.1111/gcbb. 12198.
73. TER-MIKAELIAN, M.T., J. MCKECHNIE, S.J. COLOMBO, J. CHEN, AND H.L. MACLEAN. 2011. The carbon neutrality assumption for forest bioenergy: A case study for northwestern Ontario. For. Chron, 87:644-652.
74. NATURAL RESOURCES CANADA. 2013. The state of Canada's forests: Annual report 2013. Ottawa, ON, Canada. 56 p. Available online at cfs-.nrcan.gc.ca/publications?id_35191; last accessed Oct 1, 2014.
75. US DEPARTMENT OF ENERGY. 2013. Replacing the whole barrel: To reduce US dependence on oil. Available online at www1.eere.energy.gov/ bioenergy/pdfs/replacing_barrel_overview. pdf; last accessed Oct. 1, 2014.
76. US ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY. 2011. Accounting framework for biogenic CO2 emissions from stationary sources, US Environmental Protection Agency Office of Atmospheric Programs Climate Change Division. Available online at www.epa.gov/climatechange/Downloads/ ghgemissions/Biogenic-CO2-Accounting-Framework-Report-Sept-2011.pdf; last accessed Oct. 1, 2014.
77. WERNER, F., R. TAVERNA, P. HOFER, E. THÜRIG, AND E. KAUFMANN. 2010. National and global greenhouse gas dynamics of different forest management and wood use scenarios: A model-based assessment. Environ. Sci. Policy 13: 72-85.
78. YOSHIOKA, T., K. ARUGA, T. NITAMI, H. KOBAYASHI, AND H. SAKAI. 2005. Energy and carbon dioxide (CO2) balance of logging residues as alternative energy resources: System analysis based on the method of a life cycle inventory (LCI) analysis. J. For. Res, 10:125-134.
79. ZHANG, Y., J. MCKECHNIE, D. CORMIER, R. LYNG, W. MABEE, A. OGINO, AND H.L. MACLEAN. 2010. Life cycle emissions and cost of producing electricity from coal, natural gas, and wood pellets in Ontario, Canada. Environ. Sci. Technol, 44:538-544.
80. ZISKA, L.H. 2008. Rising atmospheric carbon dioxide and plant biology: The overlooked paradigm. DNA Cell Biol, 27:165-172.