Unholy questions about five central tenets of psychoanalysis that need to be empirically verified

Psychoanalytic Inquiry

Volumn 35, Issue , 2015, Pages 5-23

  Luyten, Patrick ^a,b  

^a UNIVERSITY OF LEUVEN   (Belgium)

^b UNIVERSITY COLLEGE LONDON   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

EID: 84920774106     PISSN: 07351690     EISSN: 19409133     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1080/07351690.2015.987590     Document Type: Article

References (96)

1. Aitchison, K., A. Basu, P. McGuffin, & I. Craig. (2005), Psychiatry and the "New Genetics": Hunting for genes for behaviour and drug response. Brit. J. Psych., 186(2): 91-92. doi:10.1192/bjp.186.2.91
2. Bakermans-Kranenburg, M. J., M. H. Van Ijzendoorn, J. Mesman, L. R. A. Alink, & F. Juffer. (2008), Effects of an attachment-based intervention on daily cortisol moderated by dopamine receptor D4: A randomized control trial on 1- to 3-year-olds screened for externalizing behavior. Develop. and Psychopath., 20: 805-820.
3. Bateman, A. W., & P. Fonagy. (2006), Mentalization Based Treatment for Borderline Personality Disorder: A Practical Guide. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
4. Belsky, D. W., A. Caspi, L. Arseneault, W. Bleidorn, P. Fonagy, M. Goodman, . . . T. E. Moffitt. (2012), Etiological features of borderline personality related characteristics in a birth cohort of 12-year-old children. Develop. and Psychopath., 24(1): 251-265. doi:10.1017/S0954579411000812
5. Belsky, J., & M. Pluess. (2013), Genetic moderation of early child-care effects on social functioning across childhood: A developmental analysis. Child Develop., 84(4): 1209-1225. doi:10.1111/cdev.12058
6. Blass, R. B. (2010), Affirming 'That's not psycho-analysis!' On the value of the politically incorrect act of attempting to define the limits of our field. Internat. J. Psychoanal., 91(1): 81-89. doi:10.1111/j.1745-8315.2009.00211.x
7. Blatt, S. J., D. C. Zuroff, L. L. Hawley, & J. S. Auerbach. (2010), Predictors of sustained therapeutic change. Psychother. Res., 20: 37-54.
8. Champagne, F. A., & J. P. Curley. (2009), Epigenetic mechanisms mediating the long-term effects of maternal care on development. Neuroscience & Biobehavioral Rev., 33(4): 593-600.
9. Clarkin, J. F., P. A. Foelsch, K. N. Levy, J. W. Hull, J. C. Delaney, & O. F. Kernberg. (2001), The development of a psychodynamic treatment for patients with borderline personality disorder: A preliminary study of behavioral change. J. Personal. Dis., 15(6): 487-495.
10. Connolly Gibbons, M. B., P. Crits-Christoph, J. P. Barber, S. W. Stirman, R. Gallop, L. A. Goldstein, . . . S. Ring-Kurtz. (2009), Unique and common mechanisms of change across cognitive and dynamic psychotherapies. J. Consulting & Clinical Psych., 77(5): 801-813.
11. Crits-Christoph, P., & M. B. Connolly Gibbons. (2002), Relational interpretations. In: Psychotherapy Relationships That Work, ed. J. C. Norcross. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press, pp. 285-300.
12. Csibra, G., & G. Gergely. (2009), Natural pedagogy. Trends in Cog. Sci., 13(4): 148-153. doi:10.1016/j.tics.2009.01.005
13. Diener, M. J., M. Hilsenroth, & J. Weinberger. (2007), Therapist affect focus and patient outcomes in psychodynamic psychotherapy: A meta-analysis. Amer. J. Psych., 164: 936-941.
14. Eagle, M. N. (2013), Attachment and Psychoanalysis: Theory, Research, and Clinical Implications. New York: Guilford Press.
15. Ellis, B. J., W. T. Boyce, J. Belsky, M. J. Bakermans-Kranenburg, & M. H. van Ijzendoorn. (2011), Differential susceptibility to the environment: An evolutionary-neurodevelopmental theory. Develop. and Psychopath., 23(1): 7-28. doi:10.1017/S0954579410000611
16. Erikson, E. H. (1959), Identity and the Life Cycle. New York: International Universities Press.
17. -. (1968), Identity: Youth and crisis. New York: Norton.
18. Fearon, P., Y. Shmueli-Goetz, E. Viding, P. Fonagy, & R. Plomin. (2014), Genetic and environmental influences on adolescent attachment. J. Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 55(9): 1033-1041. doi:10.1111/jcpp.12171
19. Fonagy, P. (2003a), Genetics, developmental psychopathology and psychoanalytic theory: The case for ending our (not so) splendid isolation. Psychoanal. Inq., 23(2): 218-247.
20. -. (2003b), Some complexities in the relationship of psychoanalytic theory to technique. Psychoanal. Quart., 72(1): 13-47.
21. -. (2008), A genuinely developmental theory of sexual enjoyment and its implications for psychoanalytic technique. J. Amer. Psychoanal. Assn., 56(1): 11-36.
22. -. (2010), The changing shape of clinical practice: Driven by science or by pragmatics? Psychoanal. Psychother., 24(1): 22-43.
23. -,& A. Bateman. (2006), Progress in the treatment of borderline personality disorder. Brit. J. Psychiatry, 188: 1-3. doi: 188/1/1[pii]10.1192/bjp.bp.105.012088
24. -, R. Edgcumbe, G. S. Moran, H. Kennedy, & M. Target. (1993), The roles of mental representations and mental processes in therapeutic action. Psychoanal. Study of the Child, 48: 9-48.
25. -, & P. Luyten. (2009), A developmental, mentalization-based approach to the understanding and treatment of borderline personality disorder. Develop. and Psychopath., 21(4): 1355-1381. doi:10.1017/s0954579409990198
26. -, & P. Luyten. (in press), A multilevel perspective on the development of borderline personality disorder. In: Development and Psychopathology, ed. D. Cicchetti. New York: Wiley.
27. -, P. Luyten, & E. Allison. (2014), Epistemic Petrification and the Restoration of Epistemic Trust: A New Conceptualization of Borderline Personality Disorder and its Psychosocial Treatment. Manuscript submitted for publication.
28. -, & M. Target. (2008), Attachment, trauma, and psychoanalysis. Where psychoanalysis meets neuroscience. In: Mind to Mind. Infant Research, Neuroscience, and Psychoanalysis, ed. E. J. Jurist, A. Slade, & S. Bergner. New York: Other Press, pp. 15-49.
29. -, M. Target, & G. Gergely. (2006), Psychoanalytic perspectives on developmental psychopathology. In: Developmental Psychopathology, 2nd edition, Volume 1, ed. D. Cicchetti & D. J. Cohen. Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley & Sons, pp. 701-749.
30. Fraley, R. C., & B. W. Roberts. (2005), Patterns of continuity: A dynamic model for conceptualizing the stability of individual differences in psychological constructs across the life course. Psychological Review, 112: 60-74.
31. Freud, A. (1981), The concept of developmental lines: Their diagnostic significance. Psychoanal. Study of the Child, 36: 129-136.
32. Freud, S. (1893), On the psychical mechanism of hysterical phenomena: Preliminary communication. Standard Edition, 2: 1-17. London: Hogarth Press, 1955.
33. -. (1894), The neuro-psychoses of defence. Standard Edition, 3: 43-61. London: Hogarth Press, 1962.
34. -. (1905), Three essays on the theory of sexuality. Standard Edition, 7: 123-230. London: Hogarth Press, 1953.
35. -. (1913), On beginning the treatment. Standard Edition, 12: 121-144. London: Hogarth Press, 1958.
36. -. (1914), Remembering, repeating, and working through. Standard Edition, 12: 145-156. London: Hogarth Press, 1958.
37. -. (1916), Introductory lectures on psycho-analysis. Standard Edition, 15 & 16: 13-477. London: Hogarth Press, 1963.
38. -. (1919), Lines of advance in psycho-analytic therapy. Standard Edition, 17: 157-168. London: Hogarth Press, 1955.
39. -. (1925), An autobiographical study. Standard Edition, 20: 7-74. London: Hogarth Press, 1959.
40. Gill, M. M. (1976), Metapsychology is not psychology. In: Psychology Versus Metapsychology: Essays in Memory of George S. Klein, ed. M. M. Gill & P. S. Holzman. New York: International Universities Press, pp. 71-105.
41. Goldfried, M. R., P. J. Raue, & L. G. Castonguay. (1998), The therapeutic focus in significant sessions of master therapists: A comparison of cognitive-behavioral and psychodynamic-interpersonal interventions. J. Consult. and Clin. Psych., 66: 803-810.
42. Grant, J., & R. Sandell. (2004), Close family or mere neighbors? Some empirical data on the differences between psychoanalysis and psychotherapy. In: Research on Psychoanalytic Psychotherapy With Adults, ed. P. Richardson, H. Kächele, & C. Renlund. London: Karnac, pp. 81-108.
43. Greenberg, J. R., & S. A. Mitchell. (1983), Object Relations in Psychoanalytic Theory. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
44. Gunderson, J. G., & K. Lyons-Ruth. (2008), BPD's interpersonal hypersensitivity phenotype: A gene-environment-developmental model. J. Personal. Disord., 22(1): 22-41. doi:10.1521/pedi.2008.22.1.22
45. Haltigan, J. D., G. I. Roisman, & R. C. Fraley. (2013), The predictive significance of early caregiving experiences for symptoms of psychopathology through midadolescence: Enduring or transient effects? Develop. and Psychopath., 25(1): 209-221. doi:10.1017/s0954579412000260
46. Heim, C., D. J. Newport, T. Mletzko, A. H. Miller, & C. B. Nemeroff. (2008), The link between childhood trauma and depression: Insights from HPA Axis studies in humans. Psychoneuroendocrinology, 33(6): 693-710.
47. Henry, W. P., H. H. Strupp, T. E. Schach, & L. Gaston. (1994), Psychodynamic approaches. In: Handbook of Psychotherapy and Behavior Change, 4th edition, ed. A. E. Bergin & S. L. Garfield. New York: John Wiley & Sons., pp. 467-508.
48. Hoglend, P. (2004), Analysis of transference in psychodynamic psychotherapy. Canadian J. Psychoanal., 12: 279-300.
49. -, S. Amlo, A. Marble, K. P. Bogwald, O. Sorbye, M. C. Sjaastad, & O. Heyerdahl. (2006), Analysis of the patient-therapist relationship in dynamic psychotherapy: An experimental study of transference interpretations. Amer. J. Psych., 163(10): 1739-1746.
50. -, K. P. Bogwald, S. Amlo, A. Marble, R. Ulberg, M. C. Sjaastad, . . . P. Johansson (2008), Transference interpretations in dynamic psychotherapy: Do they really yield sustained effects? Amer. J. Psych., 165(6): 763-771. doi:10.1176/appi.ajp.2008.07061028
51. Johansson, P., P. Hoglend, R. Ulberg, K. P. Bogwald, S. Amlo, A. Marble, . . . O. Heyerdahl. (2010), The mediating role of insight for long-term improvements in psychodynamic therapy. J. Consult. & Clinic. Psych., 78(3): 438-448.
52. Kächele, H. (2010), Distinguishing psychoanalysis from psychotherapy. Internat. J. Psychoanal., 91(1): 35-43.
53. Kendler, K. S. (1997), Social support: A genetic-epidemiologic analysis. Amer. J. Psych., 154(10): 1398-1404.
54. -. (2013), What psychiatric genetics has taught us about the nature of psychiatric illness and what is left to learn. Molecular Psych., 18(10): 1058-1066. doi:10.1038/mp.2013.50
55. Kernberg, O. F., & E. Caligor. (2005), A psychoanalytic theory of personality disorders. In: Major Theories of Personality Disorder, 2nd edition, ed. M. F. Lenzenweger & J. F. Clarkin. New York: Guilford Press, pp. 114-156.
56. Klahr, A. M., & S. A. Burt. (2014), Elucidating the etiology of individual differences in parenting: A meta-analysis of behavioral genetic research. Psycholog. Bull., 140(2): 544-586. doi:10.1037/a0034205
57. Klein, M. (1946), Envy and Gratitude and Other Works, 1946-1962. New York: Delta, 1975.
58. Koelen, J., P. Luyten, E. H. Eurelings-Bontekoe, L. Diguer, R. Vermote, B. Lowyck, & M. Bühring. (2012), The impact of level of personality organization on treatment response: A systematic review. Psychiatry: Interpersonal and Biological Proc., 75(4): 355-374.
59. Lacan, J. (1949), Le Stade du miroir comme formateur de la fonction du Je: telle qu'elle nous est révélée dans l'expérience psychanalytique [The mirror stage as formative of the function of the I as revealed in psychoanalytic experience]. Revue Francaise de Psychanalyse, 13(4): 449-455.
60. -. (1981), Le séminaire, livre III, Les psychoses [The Seminar, Book III: The Psychoses]. Paris: Seuil. [The Seminar, Book III: The Psychoses]. Paris: Seuil.
61. Lakatos, I. (1976), Proofs and Refutations: The Logic of Mathematical Discovery. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
62. Lambert, M. J., & D. E. Barley. (2002), Research summary on the therapeutic relationship and psychotherapy outcome. In: Psychotherapy Relationships That Work, ed. J. C. Norcross. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press, pp. 17-32.
63. Luborsky, L. (1984), Principles of Psychoanalytic Psychotherapy: A Manual for Supportive-Expressive (SE) Treatment. New York: Basic Books.
64. Luijk, M. P. C. M., G. I. Roisman, J. D. Haltigan, H. Tiemeier, C. Booth-LaForce, M. H. van Ijzendoorn, . . . M. J. Bakermans-Kranenburg. (2011), Dopaminergic, serotonergic, and oxytonergic candidate genes associated with infant attachment security and disorganization? In search of main and interaction effects. J. Child Psychol. and Psych., 52(12): 1295-1307. doi:10.1111/j.1469-7610.2011.02440.x
65. Luyten, P., & S. J. Blatt. (2013), Relatedness and self-definition in normal and disrupted personality development: Retrospect and prospect. Amer. Psych., 68(3): 172-183.
66. -, S. J. Blatt, & P. Fonagy. (2013), Impairments in self structures in depression and suicide in psychodynamic and cognitive behavioral approaches: Implications for clinical practice and research. Internat. J. Cog. Ther ., 6(3): 265-279. doi:10.1521/ijct.2013.6.3.265
67. -, S. J. Blatt, & L. C. Mayes. (2012), Process and outcome in psychoanalytic psychotherapy research: The need for a (relatively) new paradigm. In: Handbook of Evidence-Based Psychodynamic Psychotherapy. Bridging the Gap Between Science and Practice, 2nd edition, ed. R. A. Levy, J. S. Ablon, & H. Kächele. New York: Humana Press/Springer, pp. 345-359.
68. -, P. Fonagy, B. Lowyck, & R. Vermote. (2012), The assessment of mentalization. In: Handbook of Mentalizing in Mental Health Practice, ed. A. Bateman & P. Fonagy. Washington, DC: American Psychiatric Association, pp. 43-65.
69. -, L. C. Mayes, M. Target, & P. Fonagy. (2012), Developmental research. In: Textbook of Psychoanalysis, 2nd edition, ed. G. O. Gabbard, B. Litowitz, & P. Williams. Washington, DC: American Psychiatric Press, pp. 423-442.
70. -, B. Van Houdenhove, A. Lemma, M. Target, & P. Fonagy. (2013), Vulnerability for functional somatic disorders: A contemporary psychodynamic approach. J. Psychother. Integration, 23(1): 14-27.
71. -, N. Vliegen, B. Van Houdenhove, & S. J. Blatt. (2008), Equifinality, multifinality, and the rediscovery of the importance of early experiences: Pathways from early adversity to psychiatric and (functional) somatic disorders. Psychoanal. Study of the Child, 63: 27-60.
72. Main, M. (2000), The organized categories of infant, child and adult attachment: Flexible vs. inflexible attention under attachment-related stress. J. Amer. Psychoanal. Assn., 48(4): 1055-1096.
73. Malan, D. H. (1963), A Study of Brief Psychotherapy. New York: Plenum Press.
74. Marceau, K., B. N. Horwitz, J. Narusyte, J. M. Ganiban, E. L. Spotts, D. Reiss, & J. M. Neiderhiser. (2013), Gene-environment correlation underlying the association between parental negativity and adolescent externalizing problems. Child Develop., 84(6): 2031-2046. doi:10.1111/cdev.12094
75. McCullough, L., A. Winston, B. A. Farber, F. Porter, J. Pollack, M. Laikin, . . . M. Trujillo. (1991), The relationship of patient-therapist interaction to outcome in brief psychotherapy. Psychother., 28: 525-533.
76. McGowan, P. O. (2013), Epigenomic mechanisms of early adversity and HPA dysfunction: Considerations for PTSD research. Frontiers in Psychiatry, 4. doi:10.3389/fpsyt.2013.00110
77. Mikulincer, M., & P. R. Shaver. (2007), Attachment in Adulthood: Structure, Dynamics and Change. New York: Guilford Press.
78. Miller, S., B. Wampold, & K. Varhely. (2008), Direct comparisons of treatment modalities for youth disorders: A metaanalysis. Psychother. Res., 18(1): 5-14. doi:10.1080/10503300701472131
79. Pine, F. (1988), The four psychologies of psychoanalysis and their place in clinical work. J. Amer. Psychoanal. Assn., 36(3): 571-596.
80. Plomin, R., & O. S. Davis. (2009), The future of genetics in psychology and psychiatry: Microarrays, genome-wide association, and non-coding RNA. J. Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 50: 63-71.
81. -, J. C. DeFries, V. S. Knopik, & J. M. Neiderhiser. (2013), Behavioral Genetics, 6th edition. New York: Worth.
82. Rapaport, D., & M. M. Gill. (1959), The points of view and assumptions of metapsychology. Internat. J. Psycho-Anal., 40: 153-162.
83. Roazen, P. (1995), How Freud Worked: First-Hand Accounts of Patients. Northvale, NJ: Jason Aronson.
84. Roisman, G. I., C. Booth-Laforce, J. Belsky, K. B. Burt, & A. M. Groh. (2013), Molecular-genetic correlates of infant attachment: A cautionary tale. Attachment & Human Develop., 15(4): 384-406. doi:10.1080/14616734.2013.768790
85. Rutter, M. (2009), Understanding and testing risk mechanisms for mental disorders. J. Child Psychology and Psychiatry and Allied Disciplines, 50(1-2): 44-52. doi:10.1111/j.1469-7610.2008.01976.x
86. Shahar, G. (2010), Poetics, pragmatics, schematics, and the psychoanalysis-research dialogue. Psychoanal. Psychother., 24(4): 315-328. doi:10.1080/02668734.2010.513544
87. Sifneos, P. E. (1979), Short-Term Dynamic Psychotherapy: Evaluation and Technique. New York: Plenum Press.
88. Spence, D. P. (1994), The failure to ask the hard questions. In: Psychotherapy Research and Practice. Bridging the Gap, ed. P. F. Talley, H. H. Strupp, & S. F. Butler. New York: Basic Books, pp. 19-38.
89. Taubner, S., A. Buchheim, R. Rudyk, H. Kachele, & G. Bruns. (2012), How does neurobiological research influence psychoanalytic treatments. Clinical observations and reflections from a study on the interface of clinical psychoanalysis and neuroscience. Amer. J. Psychoanal., 72(3): 269-286.
90. Vaillant, G. E. (1977), Adaptation to Life. Toronto, Canada: Little, Brown, & Co.
91. Wampold, B. E., T. Minami, T. W. Baskin, & S. Callen Tierney. (2002), A meta-(re)analysis of the effects of cognitive therapy versus 'other therapies' for depression. J. Affective Disord., 68(2-3): 159-165.
92. Way, B. M., & M. D. Lieberman. (2010), Is there a genetic contribution to cultural differences? Collectivism, individualism and genetic markers of social sensitivity. Social Cognitive and Affective Neuroscience, 5(2-3): 203-211. doi:10.1093/scan/nsq059
93. Westen, D. (1990), Towards a revised theory of borderline object relations: Contributions of empirical research. Internat. J. Psycho-Anal., 71: 661-694.
94. -, N. Lohr, K. Silk, L. Gold, & K. Kerber. (1990), Object relations and social cognition in borderlines, major depressives, and normals: A TAT analysis. Psychological Assessment: A Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 2: 355-364.
95. Winnicott, D. W. (1971), Playing and Reality. London: Tavistock.
96. Young, P. J. E., P. J. S. Klosko, & M. E. Weishaar. (2003), Schema Therapy: A Practioner's Guide. New York: Guilford.