Roger Bacon and Richard Rufus on Aristotle's metaphysics: A search for the grounds of disagreement

Vivarium

Volumn 35, Issue 2, 1997, Pages 251-265

  Noone, Timothy B ^a  

^a NONE

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

EID: 84905325089     PISSN: 00427543     EISSN: 15685349     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1163/1568534972662556     Document Type: Article

References (29)

1. Roger Bacon, The Compendium of the Study of Theology, ed. Thomas Maloney, Leiden/Koln 1988, cap. 4, 86.
2. Roger Bacon, Opus maius, ed. J.H. Bridges, Oxford 1879, 108;
3. Compendium studii philosophies, in: Fratris Rogeri Bacon: Opera quaedam hactenus inedita, ed. J.S. Brewer, London 1859 469 472.
4. Daniel A. Callus, The Introduction of Aristotelian Learning to Oxford, in: Proceedings of the British Academy, 27 (1943), 229-81.
5. D.A. Callus, The Treatise of John Blund on the Soul, in: Autour dAnstote: Recueil d etudes de philosophie ancienne et medievale offert a Monseigneur A. Mansion, Louvain 1955, 471-95;
6. Iohannes Blund, Tractatus de anima, ed. D.A. Callus and R.W. Hunt, London 1970.
7. F. Pelster, Adam von Bocfeld (Bockingfold), ein Oxforder Erklarer des Aristoteles um die Mitte des 13 Jahrhunderts: Sein Leben une seine Schriften, in: Scholastik, 11 (1936), 196-224;
8. S.H. Thomson, A Note on the Works of Magister Adam de Bocfeld {Bochermerfort), in: Medievalia et humanistica, 2 (1944), 55-87;
9. A Further Note on Master Adam of Bocfeld, in: Medievalia et humanistica, 12 (1958), 28-32;
10. Louis Bataillon, Adam of Bocfeld: Further Manuscripts, in: Medievalia et humanistica, 13 (1960), 35-9.
11. For partial edition of Buckfield's commentary on Aristode's Metaphysics, see Armand Maurer, Adam ofBuckfield: Sententia super secundum Metaphysicae, in: Nine Mediaeval Thinkers: A Collection of Hitherto Unedited Texts, ed. J. Reginald O'Donnell, Toronto 1955, 99-144.
12. See Enya Macrae, Geoffrey ofAspalVs Commentaries on Aristotle, in: Mediaeval and Renaissance Studies, 4 (1968), 94-134
13. Roberto Plevano, Richard Rufus of Cornwall and Geoffrey of Aspall: Two Questions on the Instant of Change, in: Medioevo, 19 (1993), 167-232.
14. A.G. Litde and F. Pelster, Oxford Theology and Theologians: C. A.D. 1282-1302, Oxford 1934, 257-8;
15. P. Osmund Lewry, Oxford Logic 1250-1275: Nicholas and Peter of Cornwall on Past and Future Realities, in: P.O. Lewry (ed.), The Rise of British Logic: Acts of the Sixth European Symposium on Mediaeval Logic and Semantics, Balliol College, Oxford, 19-24 June 1983, Toronto 1983, 19-62
16. for a newly identified version of Clive's Metaphysics commentary, see Robert Andrews and Timothy B. Noone, A Newly Identified Redaction of Richard of Clive's Quaestiones Metaphysicae: With an Edition of Three Questions on Relation, in: Manuscripta (forthcoming).
17. Dorothea E. Sharp, Franciscan Philosophy at hford: In the Thirteenth Century', London 1930, 115;
18. Stewart C. Easton, Roger Bacon and his earchfor a Universal Science, New York 1952, 34; 44-5.
19. Ferdinand Van Steenberghen, La philosophie au XllT siecle, 2eme ed., Louvain 1991, 170.
20. Leonard J. Bowman, The Development of the Doctrine of the Agent Intellect in the Franciscan School of the Thirteenth Century, in: The Modern Schoolman, 50 (1973), 251-79;
21. Jean Rohmer, La theorie de l'abstraction dans I'ecole franciscaine de Alexandre de Hales a Jean Peckham, in: Archives d'histoire doctrinale et litteraire du moyen-age, 3 (1928), 105-84
22. Etienne Gilson, Pourquoi saint Thomas a critique saint Augustin, in: Archives d'histoire doctrinale et litteraire du moyen- A ge, 1 (1926-1927), 5-127; especially 81-111.
23. Richard C. Dales, Robert Grosseteste's Treatise De finitate motus et temporis, in: Traditio, 19 (1963), 256-60.
24. Cf. Anonymous, Logica cum sit nostra, ed. L.M. De Rijk, in: Id., Logica modernorum: A Contribution to the History of Early Terminist Logic, Vol. II, Part Two: Texts, Assen 1967, 429.
25. Neil Lewis, The First Recension of Robert Grosseteste's De libero arbitrio, in: Mediaeval Studies, 53 (1991), 6-8
26. Calvin Normore, Future Contingents, in: N. Kretzmann, et al, (ed.), The Cambridge History of Later Medieval Philosophy, Cambridge 1982, 358-81.
27. Timothy B. Noone, Richard Rufus on Creation, Divine Immutability, and Future Contingency in the Scriptum super Metaphysicam, in: Documenti e studi: Rivista della Societa Internazionale per lo Studio del Medioevo Latino, 4 (1993), 22.
28. Bacon, Supra undecimum primae, (VII, 106-107): "Similiter dicendum est quod omnia praevisa, in eo quod praevisa, sunt necessaria, non tamen in eo quod entia, et ita erunt quaedam contingentia quae ab ipso cognoscentur omnino.
29. Among such differences of interest, one might include Rufus' fascination with the ontological status of cognitive objects combined with mild interest in exploring the theory of divine ideas in the Scriptum, as compared to Bacon's careful attention to divine exem-plarity and relative neglect of issues pertaining to the status of cognitive objects.