Comparison of treatment effects of guided tissue regeneration on infrabony lesions between animal and human studies: A systematic review and meta-analysis

Journal of Periodontal Research

Volumn 49, Issue 4, 2014, Pages 415-424

  Yen, C C ^a   Tu, Y K ^b   Chen, T H ^a   Lu, H K ^a  

^a TAIPEI MEDICAL UNIVERSITY HOSPITAL   (Taiwan)

^b NATIONAL TAIWAN UNIVERSITY   (Taiwan)

Author keywords

Animal model; Guided tissue regeneration; Heterogeneity; Replication

Indexed keywords

ALVEOLAR BONE LOSS; ANIMAL; BONE DEVELOPMENT; BONE TRANSPLANTATION; COMPARATIVE STUDY; DISEASE MODEL; HUMAN; META ANALYSIS; PERIODONTICS; PHYSIOLOGY; PROCEDURES; STANDARDS; TOOTH DEVELOPMENT; TREATMENT OUTCOME;

ALVEOLAR BONE LOSS; ANIMALS; BONE TRANSPLANTATION; CEMENTOGENESIS; DISEASE MODELS, ANIMAL; GUIDED TISSUE REGENERATION, PERIODONTAL; HUMANS; OSTEOGENESIS; TREATMENT OUTCOME;

EID: 84904042386     PISSN: 00223484     EISSN: 16000765     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1111/jre.12130     Document Type: Review

References (99)

1. Pearce AI, Richards RG, Milz S, Schneider E, Pearce SG. Animal models for implant biomaterial research in bone: a review. Eur Cell Mater 2007;13:1-10.
2. Rowan AN. Refinement of animal research technique and validity of research data. Fundam Appl Toxicol 1990;15:25-32.
3. Perel P, Roberts I, Sena E et al. Comparison of treatment effects between animal experiments and clinical trials: systematic review. BMJ 2007;334:197.
4. Hackam DG, Redelmeier DA. Translation of research evidence from animals to humans. JAMA 2006;296:1731-1732.
5. Selvig KA. Discussion: animal models in reconstructive therapy. J Periodontol 1994;65:1169-1172.
6. Giannobile WV, Finkelman RD, Lynch SE. Comparison of canine and non-human primate animal models for periodontal regenerative therapy: results following a single administration of PDGF/IGF-I. J Periodontol 1994;65:1158-1168.
7. Schou S, Holmstrup P, Kornman KS. Non-human primates used in studies of periodontal disease pathogenesis: a review of the literature. J Periodontol 1993;64:497-508.
8. Socransky SS, Haffajee AD. The bacterial etiology of destructive periodontal disease: current concepts. J Periodontol 1992;63:322-331.
9. Giardino A, Ebersole JL, Holt SC. Characteristics of systemic antibody responses of nonhuman primates following active immunization with Porphyromonas gingivalis, Prevotella intermedia and Bacteroides fragilis. Oral Microbiol Immunol 1996;11:79-87.
10. Ebersole JL, Cappelli D, Mathys EC et al. Periodontitis in humans and non-human primates: oral-systemic linkage inducing acute phase proteins. Ann Periodontol 2002;7:102-111.
11. Gottlow J, Nyman S, Karring T, Lindhe J. New attachment formation as the result of controlled tissue regeneration. J Clin Periodontol 1984;11:494-503.
12. Gottlow J, Nyman S, Lindhe J, Karring T, Wennstrom J. New attachment formation in the human periodontium by guided tissue regeneration. Case reports. J Clin Periodontol 1986;13:604-616.
13. Nyman S, Gottlow J, Karring T, Lindhe J. The regenerative potential of the periodontal ligament. An experimental study in the monkey. J Clin Periodontol 1982;9:257-265.
14. Nyman S, Lindhe J, Karring T, Rylander H. New attachment following surgical treatment of human periodontal disease. J Clin Periodontol 1982;9:290-296.
15. Murphy KG, Gunsolley JC. Guided tissue regeneration for the treatment of periodontal intrabony and furcation defects. A systematic review. Ann Periodontol 2003;8:266-302.
16. Melcher AH. On the repair potential of periodontal tissues. J Periodontol 1976;47:256-260.
17. Needleman IG, Worthington HV, Giedrys-Leeper E, Tucker RJ. Guided tissue regeneration for periodontal infra-bony defects. Cochrane Database Syst Rev 2006;2:CD001724.
18. Palmer RM, Cortellini P. Periodontal tissue engineering and regeneration: consensus Report of the Sixth European Workshop on Periodontology. J Clin Periodontol 2008;35:83-86.
19. Reddy MS, Jeffcoat MK. Methods of assessing periodontal regeneration. Periodontol 2000 1999;19:87-103.
20. Lindhe J, Echeverria J. Consensus report of session II. In: Lang N, Karring T, eds. Proceedings on the 1st European workshop on periodontology. London: Quintessence Publishing Co, 1994:210-214.
21. Cortellini P, Tonetti MS. Focus on intrabony defects: guided tissue regeneration. Periodontol 2000 2000;22:104-132.
22. Windisch P, Sculean A, Klein F et al. Comparison of clinical, radiographic, and histometric measurements following treatment with guided tissue regeneration or enamel matrix proteins in human periodontal defects. J Periodontol 2002;73:409-417.
23. Sculean A, Nikolidakis D, Schwarz F. Regeneration of periodontal tissues: combinations of barrier membranes and grafting materials - biological foundation and preclinical evidence: a systematic review. J Clin Periodontol 2008;35:106-116.
24. Faggion CM Jr, Chambrone L, Gondim V, Schmitter M, Tu YK. Comparison of the effects of treatment of peri-implant infection in animal and human studies: systematic review and meta-analysis. Clin Oral Implants Res 2010;21:137-147.
25. Needleman IG. A guide to systematic reviews. J Clin Periodontol 2002;29(suppl 3):6-9; discussion 37-38.
26. Tu YK, Woolston A, Faggion CM Jr. Do bone grafts or barrier membranes provide additional treatment effects for infrabony lesions treated with enamel matrix derivatives? A network meta-analysis of randomized-controlled trials. J Clin Periodontol 2010;37:59-79.
27. Eickholz P, Kim TS, Holle R. Guided tissue regeneration with non-resorbable and biodegradable barriers: 6 months results. J Clin Periodontol 1997;24:92-101.
28. Reynolds MA, Aichelmann-Reidy ME, Branch-Mays GL, Gunsolley JC. The efficacy of bone replacement grafts in the treatment of periodontal osseous defects. A systematic review. Ann Periodontol 2003;8:227-265.
29. Jadad AR, Moore RA, Carroll D et al. Assessing the quality of reports of randomized clinical trials: is blinding necessary? Control Clin Trials 1996;17:1-12.
30. Higgins J, Green S. Assessment of study quality. In: Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Interventions 4.2.6. In: The Cochrane Library, Issue 4; Chichester, UK: John Wiley & Sons, Ltd 2006;79-84.
31. Macleod MR, O'Collins T, Howells DW, Donnan GA. Pooling of animal experimental data reveals influence of study design and publication bias. Stroke 2004;35:1203-1208.
32. Dhingra K, Vandana KL. Prophylactic vaccination against periodontal disease: a systematic review of preclinical studies. J Periodontol 2010;81:1529-1546.
33. Artzi Z, Weinreb M, Tal H et al. Experimental intrabony and periodontal defects treated with natural mineral combined with a synthetic cell-binding Peptide in the canine: morphometric evaluations. J Periodontol 2006;77:1658-1664.
34. Artzi Z, Givol N, Rohrer MD, Nemcovsky CE, Prasad HS, Tal H. Qualitative and quantitative expression of bovine bone mineral in experimental bone defects. Part 2: morphometric analysis. J Periodontol 2003;74:1153-1160.
35. Colangelo P, Piattelli A, Barrucci S, Trisi P, Formisano G, Caiazza S. Bone regeneration guided by resorbable collagen membranes in rabbits: a pilot study. Implant Dent 1993;2:101-105.
36. Lysiak-Drwal K, Dominiak M, Solski L et al. Early histological evaluation of bone defect healing with and without guided bone regeneration techniques: experimental animal studies. Postepy Hig Med Dosw (Online) 2008;62:282-288.
37. Sculean A, Donos N, Reich E, Karring T, Brecx M. Regeneration of oxytalan fibres in different types of periodontal defects: a histological study in monkeys. J Periodontal Res 1998;33:453-459.
38. Sculean A, Junker R, Donos N, Berakdar M, Brecx M, Dunker N. Immunohistochemical evaluation of matrix molecules associated with wound healing following regenerative periodontal treatment in monkeys. Clin Oral Investig 2002;6:175-182.
39. Marouf HA, al-Khateeb TL, Cataldo E. Enhancement of bone ingrowth into collagen/HA composite implants using e-PTFE membranes. J Ir Dent Assoc 1999;45:52-57.
40. Sculean A, Donos N, Brecx M, Reich E, Karring T. Treatment of intrabony defects with guided tissue regeneration and enamel-matrix-proteins. An experimental study in monkeys. J Clin Periodontol 2000;27:466-472.
41. Yun JH, Hwang SJ, Kim CS et al. The correlation between the bone probing, radiographic and histometric measurements of bone level after regenerative surgery. J Periodontal Res 2005;40:453-460.
42. Laurell L, Bose M, Graziani F, Tonetti M, Berglundh T. The structure of periodontal tissues formed following guided tissue regeneration therapy of intra-bony defects in the monkey. J Clin Periodontol 2006;33:596-603.
43. Onodera H, Shibukawa Y, Sugito H, Ota M, Yamada S. Periodontal regeneration in intrabony defects after application of enamel matrix proteins with guided tissue regeneration: an experimental study in dogs. Biomed Res 2005;26:69-77.
44. Sakata J, Abe H, Ohazama A et al. Effects of combined treatment with porous bovine inorganic bone grafts and bilayer porcine collagen membrane on refractory one-wall intrabony defects. Int J Periodontics Restorative Dent 2006;26:161-169.
45. Nevins ML, Camelo M, Rebaudi A, Lynch SE, Nevins M. Three-dimensional micro-computed tomographic evaluation of periodontal regeneration: a human report of intrabony defects treated with Bio-Oss collagen. Int J Periodontics Restorative Dent 2005;25:365-373.
46. Sculean A, Donos N, Chiantella GC, Windisch P, Reich E, Brecx M. GTR with bioresorbable membranes in the treatment of intrabony defects: a clinical and histologic study. Int J Periodontics Restorative Dent 1999;19:501-509.
47. Sculean A, Donos N, Windisch P et al. Healing of human intrabony defects following treatment with enamel matrix proteins or guided tissue regeneration. J Periodontal Res 1999;34:310-322.
48. Blumenthal N, Steinberg J. The use of collagen membrane barriers in conjunction with combined demineralized bone-collagen gel implants in human infrabony defects. J Periodontol 1990;61:319-327.
49. Chung KM, Salkin LM, Stein MD, Freedman AL. Clinical evaluation of a biodegradable collagen membrane in guided tissue regeneration. J Periodontol 1990;61:732-736.
50. Mellado JR, Salkin LM, Freedman AL, Stein MD. A Comparative study of ePTFE periodontal membranes with and without decalcified freeze-dried bone allografts for the regeneration of interproximal intraosseous defects. J Periodontol 1995;66:751-755.
51. Camargo PM, Lekovic V, Weinlaender M et al. A controlled re-entry study on the effectiveness of bovine porous bone mineral used in combination with a collagen membrane of porcine origin in the treatment of intrabony defects in humans. J Clin Periodontol 2000;27:889-896.
52. Camargo PM, Lekovic V, Weinlaender M, Vasilic N, Madzarevic M, Kenney EB. Platelet-rich plasma and bovine porous bone mineral combined with guided tissue regeneration in the treatment of intrabony defects in humans. J Periodontal Res 2002;37:300-306.
53. Camargo PM, Lekovic V, Weinlaender M, Divnic-Resnik T, Pavlovic M, Kenney EB. A surgical reentry study on the influence of platelet-rich plasma in enhancing the regenerative effects of bovine porous bone mineral and guided tissue regeneration in the treatment of intrabony defects in humans. J Periodontol 2009;80:915-923.
54. Gingerich W, Stepaniuk K. Guided tissue regeneration for infrabony pocket treatment in dogs. J Vet Dent 2011;28:282-288.
55. Stavropoulos A, Chiantella G, Costa D, Steigmann M, Windisch P, Sculean A. Clinical and histologic evaluation of a granular bovine bone biomaterial used as an adjunct to GTR with a bioresorbable bovine pericardium collagen membrane in the treatment of intrabony defects. J Periodontol 2011;82:462-470.
56. Paolantonio M, Femminella B, Coppolino E et al. Autogenous periosteal barrier membranes and bone grafts in the treatment of periodontal intrabony defects of single-rooted teeth: a 12-month reentry randomized controlled clinical trial. J Periodontol 2010;81:1587-1595.
57. Gowda VS, Chava V, Kumara AE. An evaluation of a resorbable (semirigid) GTR membrane in human periodontal intraosseous defects: a clinicoradiological re-entry study. J Indian Soc Periodontol 2011;15:393-397.
58. Hurzeler MB, Quinones CR, Caffesse RG, Schupbach P, Morrison EC. Guided periodontal tissue regeneration in interproximal intrabony defects following treatment with a synthetic bioabsorbable barrier. J Periodontol 1997;68:489-497.
59. Joly JC, Palioto DB, de Lima AF, Mota LF, Caffesse R. Clinical and radiographic evaluation of periodontal intrabony defects treated with guided tissue regeneration. A pilot study. J Periodontol 2002;73:353-359.
60. Blumenthal NM, Alves ME, Al-Huwais S, Hofbauer AM, Koperski RD. Defect-determined regenerative options for treating periodontal intrabony defects in baboons. J Periodontol 2003;74:10-24.
61. Felipe ME, Andrade PF, Novaes AB Jr et al. Potential of bioactive glass particles of different size ranges to affect bone formation in interproximal periodontal defects in dogs. J Periodontol 2009;80:808-815.
62. Kim CK, Kim HY, Chai JK et al. Effect of a calcium sulfate implant with calcium sulfate barrier on periodontal healing in 3-wall intrabony defects in dogs. J Periodontol 1998;69:982-988.
63. Kim IY, Jung UW, Kim CS et al. Effects of a tetracycline blended polylactic and polyglycolic acid membrane on the healing of one-wall intrabony defects in beagle dogs. Biomed Mater 2007;2:S106-S110.
64. Ling LJ, Lai YL. Guided tissue regeneration in surgically created 3-walled and 2-walled periodontal osseous defects in monkeys. Zhonghua Yi Xue Za Zhi (Taipei) 1994;54:209-216.
65. Ozmeric N, Bal B, Oygur T, Balos K. The effect of a collagen membrane in regenerative therapy of two-wall intrabony defects in dogs. Periodontal Clin Investig 2000;22:22-30.
66. Song WS, Kim CS, Choi SH et al. The effects of a bioabsorbable barrier membrane containing safflower seed extracts on periodontal healing of 1-wall intrabony defects in beagle dogs. J Periodontol 2005;76:22-33.
67. Yamada S, Shima N, Kitamura H, Sugito H. Effect of porous xenographic bone graft with collagen barrier membrane on periodontal regeneration. Int J Periodontics Restorative Dent 2002;22:389-397.
68. Yeo YJ, Jeon DW, Kim CS et al. Effects of chitosan nonwoven membrane on periodontal healing of surgically created one-wall intrabony defects in beagle dogs. J Biomed Mater Res B Appl Biomater 2005;72:86-93.
69. Becker W, Becker BE. Treatment of mandibular 3-wall intrabony defects by flap debridement and expanded polytetrafluoroethylene barrier membranes. Long-term evaluation of 32 treated patients. J Periodontol 1993;64:1138-1144.
70. Cortellini P, Pini Prato G, Tonetti MS. Periodontal regeneration of human infrabony defects. II. Re-entry procedures and bone measures. J Periodontol 1993;64:261-268.
71. Saini A, Singh M, Lal N, Dixit J. Assessment of combination techniques in enhancing the regenerative potential of tricalcium phosphate graft in treatment of infrabony periodontal defects. Indian J Dent Res 2011;22:391-395.
72. Teparat T, Solt CW, Claman LJ, Beck FM. Clinical comparison of bioabsorbable barriers with non-resorbable barriers in guided tissue regeneration in the treatment of human intrabony defects. J Periodontol 1998;69:632-641.
73. Chen CC, Wang HL, Smith F, Glickman GN, Shyr Y, O'Neal RB. Evaluation of a collagen membrane with and without bone grafts in treating periodontal intrabony defects. J Periodontol 1995;66:838-847.
74. Walters SP, Greenwell H, Hill M, Drisko C, Pickman K, Scheetz JP. Comparison of porous and non-porous teflon membranes plus a xenograft in the treatment of vertical osseous defects: a clinical reentry study. J Periodontol 2003;74:1161-1168.
75. Mattson JS, Gallagher SJ, Jabro MH. The use of 2 bioabsorbable barrier membranes in the treatment of interproximal intrabony periodontal defects. J Periodontol 1999;70:510-517.
76. Machtei EE. Outcome variables for the study of periodontal regeneration. Ann Periodontol 1997;2:229-239.
77. Ho SP, Yu B, Yun W, Marshall GW, Ryder MI, Marshall SJ. Structure, chemical composition and mechanical properties of human and rat cementum and its interface with root dentin. Acta Biomater 2009;5:707-718.
78. Wikesjo UM, Kean CJ, Zimmerman GJ. Periodontal repair in dogs: supraalveolar defect models for evaluation of safety and efficacy of periodontal reconstructive therapy. J Periodontol 1994;65:1151-1157.
79. Caton J, Mota L, Gandini L, Laskaris B. Non-human primate models for testing the efficacy and safety of periodontal regeneration procedures. J Periodontol 1994;65:1143-1150.
80. Weinberg MA, Bral M. Laboratory animal models in periodontology. J Clin Periodontol 1999;26:335-340.
81. Cortellini P, Pini Prato G, Tonetti MS. Periodontal regeneration of human infrabony defects. II. Re-entry procedures and bone measures. J Periodontol 1993;64:261-268.
82. Cortellini P, Pini Prato G, Tonetti MS. Periodontal regeneration of human infrabony defects. I. Clinical measures. J Periodontol 1993;64:254-260.
83. Renvert S, Nilveus R, Egelberg J. Healing after treatment of periodontal intraosseous defects. V. Effect of root planing versus flap surgery. J Clin Periodontol 1985;12:619-629.
84. Pound P, Ebrahim S, Sandercock P, Bracken MB, Roberts I. Where is the evidence that animal research benefits humans? BMJ 2004;328:514-517.
85. Cohen RL, Alves ME, Crawford JM, McSwiggin T, Chambers DA. Association of gingival crevicular fluid aspartate aminotransferase levels with histopathology during ligature-induced periodontitis in the beagle dog. J Dent Res 1991;70:984-987.
86. Pavlica Z, Petelin M, Nemec A, Erzen D, Skaleric U. Measurement of total antioxidant capacity in gingival crevicular fluid and serum in dogs with periodontal disease. Am J Vet Res 2004;65:1584-1588.
87. Egelberg J. Local effect of diet on plaque formation and development of gingivitis in dogs. I. Effect of hard and soft diets. Odontol Revy 1965;16:31-41.
88. Hamp SE, Lindhe J, Loe H. Experimental periodontitis in the beagle dog. J Periodontal Res 1972;10:13-14.
89. Faggion CM Jr, Schmitter M, Tu YK. Assessment of replication of research evidence from animals to humans in studies on peri-implantitis therapy. J Dent 2009;37:737-747.
90. Oz HS, Puleo DA. Animal models for periodontal disease. J Biomed Biotechnol 2011;2011:754857.
91. Kornman KS, Holt SC, Robertson PB. The microbiology of ligature-induced periodontitis in the cynomolgus monkey. J Periodontal Res 1981;16:363-371.
92. Schwarz F, Herten M, Sager M, Bieling K, Sculean A, Becker J. Comparison of naturally occurring and ligature-induced peri-implantitis bone defects in humans and dogs. Clin Oral Implants Res 2007;18:161-170.
93. Berglundh T, Zitzmann NU, Donati M. Are peri-implantitis lesions different from periodontitis lesions? J Clin Periodontol 2011;38(suppl 11):188-202.
94. Guillemin MR, Mellonig JT, Brunsvold MA. Healing in periodontal defects treated by decalcified freeze-dried bone allografts in combination with ePTFE membranes (I). Clinical and scanning electron microscope analysis. J Clin Periodontol 1993;20:528-536.
95. Mora F, Etienne D, Ouhayoun JP. Treatment of interproximal angular defects by guided tissue regeneration: 1 year follow-up. J Oral Rehabil 1996;23:599-606.
96. Camelo M, Nevins ML, Schenk RK, et al. Clinical, radiographic, and histologic evaluation of human periodontal defects treated with Bio-Oss and Bio-Gide. Int J Periodontics Restorative Dent 1998;18:321-331.
97. Hartman GA, Arnold RM, Mills MP, Cochran DL, Mellonig JT. Clinical and histologic evaluation of anorganic bovine bone collagen with or without a collagen barrier. Int J Periodontics Restorative Dent 2004;24:127-135.
98. Nevins ML, Camelo M, Lynch SE, Schenk RK, Nevins M. Evaluation of periodontal regeneration following grafting intrabony defects with bio-oss collagen: a human histologic report. Int J Periodontics Restorative Dent 2003;23:9-17.
99. Sculean A, Stavropoulos A, Windisch P, Keglevich T, Karring T, Gera I. Healing of human intrabony defects following regenerative periodontal therapy with a bovine-derived xenograft and guided tissue regeneration. Clin Oral Investig 2004;8:70-74.