Testing predictions of the Janzen-Connell hypothesis: A meta-analysis of experimental evidence for distance- and density-dependent seed and seedling survival

Journal of Ecology

Volumn 102, Issue 4, 2014, Pages 845-856

  Comita, Liza S ^a,b   Queenborough, Simon A ^a   Murphy, Stephen J ^a   Eck, Jenalle L ^a   Xu, Kaiyang ^a   Krishnadas, Meghna ^a   Beckman, Noelle ^a   Zhu, Yan ^c  

^a OHIO STATE UNIVERSITY   (United States)

^b SMITHSONIAN TROPICAL RESEARCH INSTITUTE   (Panama)

^c INSTITUTE OF BOTANY   (China)

Author keywords

Determinants of plant community diversity and structure; Herbivory; Maintenance of diversity; Natural enemies; Pathogens; Plant population and community dynamics; Review; Seed predation; Species coexistence; Tropical forest

Indexed keywords

COEXISTENCE; COMMUNITY DYNAMICS; COMMUNITY STRUCTURE; CONSPECIFIC; DENSITY DEPENDENCE; HERBIVORY; HYPOTHESIS TESTING; META-ANALYSIS; MORTALITY; NATURAL ENEMY; PATHOGEN; PLANT COMMUNITY; SEED; SEEDLING EMERGENCE; SPECIES DIVERSITY; SURVIVAL; TROPICAL FOREST;

EID: 84902994474     PISSN: 00220477     EISSN: 13652745     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1111/1365-2745.12232     Document Type: Article

References (65)

1. Adler, P.B., Ellner, S.P. & Levine, J.M. (2010) Coexistence of perennial plants: an embarrassment of niches. Ecology Letters, 13, 1019-1029.
2. Adler, P.B., HilleRisLambers, J. & Levine, J.M. (2007) A niche for neutrality. Ecology Letters, 10, 95-104.
3. Bagchi, R., Swinfield, T., Gallery, R.E., Lewis, O.T., Gripenberg, S., Narayan, L. & Freckleton, R.P. (2010) Testing the Janzen-Connell mechanism: pathogens cause overcompensating density dependence in a tropical tree. Ecology Letters, 13, 1262-1269.
4. Bagchi, R., Philipson, C.D., Slade, E.M., Hector, A., Phillips, S., Villanueva, J.F., Lewis, O.T., Lyal, C.H.C., Nilus, R., Madran, A., Scholes, J.D. & Press, M.C. (2011) Impacts of logging on density-dependent predation of dipterocarp seeds in a South East Asian rainforest. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B-Biological Sciences, 366, 3246-3255.
5. Bagchi, R., Gallery, R.E., Gripenberg, S., Gurr, S.J., Narayan, L., Addis, C.E., Freckleton, R.P. & Lewis, O.T. (2014) Pathogens and insect herbivores drive rainforest plant diversity and composition. Nature, 506, 85-88.
6. Barot, S. (2004) Mechanisms promoting plant coexistence: can all the proposed processes be reconciled? Oikos, 106, 185-192.
7. Begg, C.B. & Mazumdar, M. (1994) Operating characteristics of a rank correlation test for publication bias. Biometrics, 50, 1088-1101.
8. Bell, T., Freckleton, R.P. & Lewis, O.T. (2006) Plant pathogens drive density-dependent seedling mortality in a tropical tree. Ecology Letters, 9, 569-574.
9. Brenes-Arguedas, T., Coley, P.D. & Kursar, T.A. (2009) Pests vs. drought as determinants of plant distribution along a tropical rainfall gradient. Ecology, 90, 1751-1761.
10. Carson, W.P., Anderson, J.T., Leigh, E.G. & Schnitzer, S.A. (2008) Challenges associated with testing and falsifying the Janzen-Connell hypothesis: a review and critique. Tropical Forest Community Ecology (eds W.P. Carson & S.A. Schnitzer ), pp. 210-241. Wiley-Blackwell, Chichester, UK.
11. Chapman, C.A. & Chapman, L.J. (1996) Frugivory and the fate of dispersed and non-dispersed seeds of six African tree species. Journal of Tropical Ecology, 12, 491-504.
12. Chesson, P. (2000) Mechanisms of maintenance of species diversity. Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics, 31, 343-366.
13. Christensen, J.H., Hewitson, B., Busuioc, A., Chen, A., Gao, X., Held, R. et al. (2007) Regional climate projections. Climate Change 2007: The Physical Science Basis. Contribution of Working group I to the Fourth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (eds S. Solomon, D. Qin, M. Manning, Z. Chen, M. Marquis, K.B. Averyt, M. Tignor & H.L. Miller ), pp. 892-896. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK and New York, NY.
14. Clark, D.A. & Clark, D.B. (1984) Spacing dynamics of a tropical rain forest tree: evaluation of the Janzen-Connell model. American Naturalist, 124, 769-788.
15. Coley, P.D. & Barone, J.A. (1996) Herbivory and plant defenses in tropical forests. Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics, 27, 305-335.
16. Comita, L.S., Aguilar, S., Perez, R., Lao, S. & Hubbell, S.P. (2007) Patterns of woody plant species abundance and diversity in the seedling layer of a tropical forest. Journal of Vegetation Science, 18, 163-174.
17. Comita, L.S., Muller-Landau, H.C., Aguilar, S. & Hubbell, S.P. (2010) Asymmetric density dependence shapes species abundances in a tropical tree community. Science, 329, 330-332.
18. Connell, J.H. (1971) On the role of natural enemies in preventing competitive exclusion in some marine animals and in rain forest trees. Dynamics of Populations (eds P.J. den Boer & G.R. Gradwell ), pp. 298-312. Centre for Agricultural Publishing and Documentation, Wageningen, The Netherlands.
19. Corlett, R.T. (2013) Where are the Subtropics? Biotropica, 45, 273-275.
20. Csada, R.D., James, P.C. & Espie, R.H.M. (1996) The "file drawer problem" of non-significant results: does it apply to biological research? Oikos, 76, 591-593.
21. Dyer, L.A., Singer, M.S., Lill, J.T., Stireman, J.O., Gentry, G.L., Marquis, R.J. et al. (2007) Host specificity of Lepidoptera in tropical and temperate forests. Nature, 448, 696-699.
22. Freckleton, R.P. & Lewis, O.T. (2006) Pathogens, density dependence and the coexistence of tropical trees. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London Series B-Biological Sciences, 273, 2909-2916.
23. Givnish, T.J. (1999) On the causes of gradients in tropical tree diversity. Journal of Ecology, 87, 193-210.
24. Greenland, S. (1987) Quantitative methods in the review of epidemiologic literature. Epidemiologic Reviews, 9, 1-30.
25. Gurevitch, J. & Hedges, L.V. (1993) Meta-analysis: combining the results of independent experiments. Design and Analysis of Ecological Experiments (eds S.M. Scheiner & J. Gurevitch ), pp. 378-398. Chapman & Hall, New York, NY.
26. Hammond, D.S. & Brown, V.K. (1998) Disturbance, phenology and life history characteristics: factors influencing distance/density dependent attack on tropical seeds and seedlings. Dynamics of Tropical Communities (eds D.M. Newbery, H.H.T. Prins & N.D. Brown ), pp. 51-78. Blackwell, Oxford.
27. Hille Ris Lambers, J., Clark, J.S. & Beckage, B. (2002) Density-dependent mortality and the latitudinal gradient in species diversity. Nature, 417, 732-735.
28. Hubbell, S.P., Ahumada, J.A., Condit, R. & Foster, R.B. (2001) Local neighborhood effects on long-term survival of individual trees in a Neotropical forest. Ecological Research, 16, 859-875.
29. Hyatt, L.A., Rosenberg, M.S., Howard, T.G., Bole, G., Fang, W., Anastasia, J., Brown, K., Grella, R., Hinman, K., Kurdziel, J.P. & Gurevitch, J. (2003) The distance dependence prediction of the Janzen-Connell hypothesis: a meta-analysis. Oikos, 103, 590-602.
30. Janzen, D.H. (1970) Herbivores and the number of tree species in tropical forests. The American Naturalist, 104, 501-528.
31. Janzen, D.H. (1974) Tropical black water rivers, animals and mast fruiting by the Dipterocarpaceae. Biotropica, 6, 69-103.
32. Johnson, D.J., Beaulieu, W.T., Bever, J.D. & Clay, K. (2012) Conspecific negative density dependence and forest diversity. Science, 336, 904-907.
33. Jones, F.A. & Comita, L.S. (2010) Density-dependent pre-dispersal seed predation and fruit set in a tropical tree. Oikos, 119, 1841-1847.
34. Kelly, D. & Sork, V.L. (2002) Mast seeding in perennial plants: why, how, where? Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics, 33, 427-447.
35. Klironomos, J.N. (2002) Feedback with soil biota contributes to plant rarity and invasiveness in communities. Nature, 217, 67-70.
36. Kobe, R.K. & Vriesendorp, C.F. (2011) Conspecific density dependence in seedlings varies with species shade tolerance in a wet tropical forest. Ecology Letters, 14, 503-510.
37. Koricheva, J., Gurevitch, J. & Mengersen, K. (2013) Handbook of Meta-Analysis in Ecology and Evolution. Princeton University Press, Princeton.
38. Kulmatiski, A., Beard, K.H., Stevens, J.R. & Cobbold, S.M. (2008) Plant-soil feedbacks: a meta-analytical review. Ecology Letters, 11, 980-992.
39. Leigh, E.G., Davidar, P., Dick, C.W., Puyravaud, J.P., Terborgh, J., ter Steege, H. & Wright, S.J. (2004) Why do some tropical forests have so many species of trees? Biotropica, 36, 447-473.
40. Levine, J.M. & HilleRisLambers, J. (2009) The importance of niches for the maintenance of species diversity. Nature, 461, 254-257.
41. Liu, X., Liang, M., Etienne, R.S., Wang, Y., Staehelin, C. & Yu, S. (2012) Experimental evidence for a phylogenetic Janzen-Connell effect in a subtropical forest. Ecology Letters, 15, 111-118.
42. Mangan, S.A., Schnitzer, S.A., Herre, E.A., Mack, K.M.L., Valencia, M.C., Sanchez, E.I. & Bever, J.D. (2010) Negative plant-soil feedback predicts tree-species relative abundance in a tropical forest. Nature, 466, 752-755.
43. McCarthy-Neumann, S. & Kobe, R.K. (2010) Conspecific plant-soil feedbacks reduce survivorship and growth of tropical tree seedlings. Journal of Ecology, 98, 396-407.
44. Nathan, R. & Muller-Landau, H.C. (2000) Spatial patterns of seed dispersal, their determinants and consequences for recruitment. Trends in Ecology & Evolution, 15, 278-285.
45. Packer, A. & Clay, K. (2000) Soil pathogens and spatial patterns of seedling mortality in a temperate tree. Nature, 404, 278-281.
46. Paine, C.E.T. & Beck, H. (2007) Seed predation by neotropical rain forest mammals increases diversity in seedling recruitment. Ecology, 88, 3076-3087.
47. Paine, C.E.T., Harms, K.E., Schnitzer, S.A. & Carson, W.P. (2008) Weak competition among tropical tree seedlings: implications for species coexistence. Biotropica, 40, 432-440.
48. Peters, H.A. (2003) Neighbour-regulated mortality: the influence of positive and negative density dependence on tree populations in species-rich tropical forests. Ecology Letters, 6, 757-765.
49. Piao, T., Comita, L.S., Jin, G. & Kim, J.H. (2013) Density dependence across multiple life stages in a temperate old-growth forest of northeast China. Oecologia, 172, 207-217.
50. R Core Team (2013) R: A Language and Environment for Statistical Computing. R Foundation for Statistical Computing, Vienna, Austria.
51. Schemske, D.W., Mittelbach, G.G., Cornell, H.V., Sobel, J.M. & Roy, K. (2009) Is there a latitudinal gradient in the importance of biotic interactions? Annual Review of Ecology, Evolution, and Systematics, 40, 245-269.
52. Schoener, T.W. (1974) Resource partitioning in ecological communities. Science, 185, 27-39.
53. Schupp, E.W. (1992) The Janzen-Connell model for tropical tree diversity: population implications and the importance of spatial scale. American Naturalist, 140, 526-530.
54. Silvertown, J. (2004) Plant coexistence and the niche. Trends in Ecology & Evolution, 19, 605-611.
55. Steinitz, O., Troupin, D., Vendramin, G.G. & Nathan, R. (2011) Genetic evidence for a Janzen-Connell recruitment pattern in reproductive offspring of Pinus halepensis trees. Molecular Ecology, 20, 4152-4164.
56. Stoll, P. & Newbery, D.M. (2005) Evidence of species-specific neighborhood effects in the dipterocarpaceae of a Bornean rain forest. Ecology, 86, 3048-3062.
57. Swamy, V. & Terborgh, J.W. (2010) Distance-responsive natural enemies strongly influence seedling establishment patterns of multiple species in an Amazonian rain forest. Journal of Ecology, 98, 1096-1107.
58. Swinfield, T., Lewis, O.T., Bagchi, R. & Freckleton, R.P. (2012) Consequences of changing rainfall for fungal pathogen-induced mortality in tropical tree seedlings. Ecology and Evolution, 2, 1408-1413.
59. Terborgh, J. (2012) Enemies maintain hyperdiverse tropical forests. American Naturalist, 179, 303-314.
60. Uriarte, M., Canham, C.D., Thompson, J. & Zimmerman, J.K. (2004) A neighborhood analysis of tree growth and survival in a hurricane-driven tropical forest. Ecological Monographs, 74, 591-614.
61. Viechtbauer, W. (2010) Conducting meta-analyses in R with the metafor package. Journal of Statistical Software, 36, 1-48.
62. Wright, S.J. (2002) Plant diversity in tropical forests: a review of mechanisms of species coexistence. Oecologia, 130, 1-14.
63. Wright, S.J. (2003) The myriad consequences of hunting for vertebrates and plants in tropical forests. Perspectives in Plant Ecology, Evolution and Systematics, 6, 73-86.
64. Wright, S.J. & Duber, H.C. (2001) Poachers and forest fragmentation alter seed dispersal, seed survival, and seedling recruitment in the palm Attalea butyraceae, with implications for tropical tree diversity. Biotropica, 33, 583-595.
65. Wyatt, J.L. & Silman, M.R. (2004) Distance-dependence in two Amazonian palms: effects of spatial and temporal variation in seed predator communities. Oecologia, 140, 26-35.