Cold blood versus crystalloid cardioplegia for myocardial protection in adult cardiac surgery: A meta-analysis of randomized controlled studies

Journal of Cardiothoracic and Vascular Anesthesia

Volumn 28, Issue 3, 2014, Pages 674-681

  Zeng, Jinming ^a   He, Wenwu ^b   Qu, Zhanli ^a   Tang, Yanyan ^a   Zhou, Qiuxi ^a   Zhang, Bingdong ^a  

^a GUANGXI MEDICAL UNIVERSITY   (China)

^b AFFILIATED HOSPITAL OF NORTH SICHUAN MEDICAL COLLEGE   (China)

Author keywords

Cold blood cardioplegia; crystalloid cardioplegia; meta analysis; randomized controlled trials

Indexed keywords

ARTICLE; CARDIOPLEGIA; CARDIOVASCULAR SURGERY; CEREBROVASCULAR ACCIDENT; COLD BLOOD CARDIOPLEGIA; COMPARATIVE STUDY; CONTROLLED STUDY; CRYSTALLOID CARDIOPLEGIA; EMBASE; HEART ATRIUM FIBRILLATION; HEART INFARCTION; HEART PROTECTION; HEART SURGERY; HUMAN; INCIDENCE; MEDLINE; META ANALYSIS; MORTALITY; OUTCOME ASSESSMENT; PERIOPERATIVE PERIOD; PRIORITY JOURNAL; RANDOMIZED CONTROLLED TRIAL; RISK FACTOR; SINUS RHYTHM; ATRIAL FIBRILLATION; BLOOD TRANSFUSION; COLD; HEART ARREST; HEART DISEASES; POSTOPERATIVE COMPLICATIONS; PROCEDURES; RANDOMIZED CONTROLLED TRIAL (TOPIC); STROKE;

CARDIOPLEGIC AGENT; CRYSTALLOID; ISOTONIC SOLUTION;

ATRIAL FIBRILLATION; BLOOD TRANSFUSION; CARDIAC SURGICAL PROCEDURES; CARDIOPLEGIC SOLUTIONS; COLD TEMPERATURE; HEART ARREST, INDUCED; HEART DISEASES; HUMANS; ISOTONIC SOLUTIONS; POSTOPERATIVE COMPLICATIONS; RANDOMIZED CONTROLLED TRIALS AS TOPIC; STROKE;

EID: 84902266843     PISSN: 10530770     EISSN: 15328422     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1053/j.jvca.2013.06.005     Document Type: Article

References (45)

1. D.G. Melrose, B. Dreyer, and H.H. Bentall et al. Elective cardiac arrest Lancet 269 1955 21 22
2. P. Astrup, K. Engel, and J.W. Severinghaus et al. The influence of temperature and pH on the dissociation curve of oxyhemoglobin of human blood Scand J Clin Lab Invest 17 1965 515 523
3. R.B. Reeves, J.S. Park, and G.N. Lapennas et al. Oxygen affinity and Bohr coefficients of dog blood J Appl Physiol 53 1982 87 95
4. G. Gutierrez, A.R. Warley, and D.R. Dantzker Oxygen delivery and utilization in hypothermic dogs J Appl Physiol 60 1986 751 757
5. J.M. McCord, and I. Fridovich The biology and pathology of oxygen radicals Ann Intern Med 89 1978 122 127
6. B. Hammond, and M.L. Hess The oxygen free radical system: Potential mediator of myocardial injury J Am Coll Cardiol 6 1985 215 220
7. C.L. Myers, S.J. Weiss, and M.M. Kirsh et al. Effects of supplementing hypothermic crystalloid cardioplegic solution with catalase, superoxide dismutase, allopurinol, or deferoxamine on functional recovery of globally ischemic and reperfused isolated hearts J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 91 1986 281 289
8. J.M. Brown, M.A. Grosso, and L.S. Terada et al. Erythrocytes decrease myocardial hydrogen peroxide levels and reperfusion injury Am J Physiol 256 1989 H584 H588
9. J.D. Emerson, E. Burdick, and D.C. Hoaglin et al. An empirical study of the possible relation of treatment differences to quality scores in controlled randomized clinical trials Control Clin Trials 11 1990 339 352
10. S. Greenland Invited commentary: A critical look at some popular meta-analytic methods Am J Epidemiol 140 1994 290 296
11. P. Juni, A. Witschi, and R. Bloch et al. The hazards of scoring the quality of clinical trials for meta-analysis JAMA 282 1999 1054 1060
12. S.A. Lemaire, M.M. Jones, and L.D. Conklin et al. Randomized comparison of cold blood and cold crystalloid renal perfusion for renal protection during thoracoabdominal aortic aneurysm repair J Vasc Surg 49 2009 11 19
13. T.Z. Lajos, C.C. Espersen, and P.S. Lajos et al. Comparison of cold versus warm cardioplegia. Crystalloid antegrade or retrograde blood? Circulation 88 1993 II344 II349
14. W. Wandschneider, S. Winter, and M. Thalmann et al. Crystalloid versus blood cardioplegia in coronary by-pass surgery. A prospective, randomized, controlled study in 100 consecutive adults J Cardiovasc Surg (Torino) 35 1994 85 89
15. E.J. Pehkonen, P.J. Makynen, and M.J. Kataja et al. Atrial fibrillation after blood and crystalloid cardioplegia in CABG patients Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 43 1995 200 203
16. H. Pichon, S. Chocron, and K. Alwan et al. Crystalloid versus cold blood cardioplegia and cardiac troponin I release Circulation 96 1997 316 320
17. A.M. Elwatidy, M.A. Fadalah, and E.A. Bukhari et al. Antegrade crystalloid cardioplegia v antegrade/retrograde cold and tepid blood cardioplegia in CABG Ann Thorac Surg 68 1999 447 453
18. J.N. Young, I.O. Choy, and N.K. Silva et al. Antegrade cold blood cardioplegia is not demonstrably advantageous over cold crystalloid cardioplegia in surgery for congenital heart disease J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 114 1997 1002 1008
19. M. Caputo, P. Modi, and H. Imura et al. Cold blood versus cold crystalloid cardioplegia for repair of ventricular septal defects in pediatric heart surgery: A randomized controlled trial Ann Thorac Surg 74 2002 530 534
20. P. Modi, M.S. Suleiman, and B. Reeves et al. Myocardial metabolic changes during pediatric cardiac surgery: A randomized study of 3 cardioplegic techniques J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 128 2004 67 75
21. K. Amark, H. Berggren, and K. Bjork et al. Blood cardioplegia provides superior protection in infant cardiac surgery Ann Thorac Surg 80 2005 989 994
22. P. Modi, S.M. Suleiman, and B.C. Reeves et al. Changes in myocardial free amino acids during pediatric cardiac surgery: A randomised controlled trial of three cardioplegic techniques Eur J Cardiothorac Surg 30 2006 41 48
23. O. Bical, M.F. Gerhardt, and D. Paumier et al. Comparison of different types of cardioplegia and reperfusion on myocardial metabolism and free radical activity Circulation 84 1991 III375 III379
24. X.Y. Jin, D.G. Gibson, and J.R. Pepper Early changes in regional and global left ventricular function after aortic valve replacement. Comparison of crystalloid, cold blood, and warm blood cardioplegias Circulation 92 1995 II155 II162
25. A. Liebold, T. Langhammer, and F. Brunger et al. Cardiac interleukin-6 release and myocardial recovery after aortic cross-clamping. Crystalloid versus blood cardioplegia J Cardiovasc Surg 40 1999 633 636
26. J.R. Pepper, S. Mumby, and J.M. Gutteridge Blood cardioplegia increases plasma iron overload and thiol levels during cardiopulmonary bypass Ann Thorac Surg 60 1995 1735 1740
27. M. Caputo, W. Dihmis, and I. Birdi et al. Cardiac troponin T and troponin I release during coronary artery surgery using cold crystalloid and cold blood cardioplegia Eur J Cardiothorac Surg 12 1997 254 260
28. M.F. Ibrahim, G.E. Venn, and C.P. Young et al. A clinical comparative study between crystalloid and blood-based St Thomas' hospital cardioplegic solution Eur J Cardiothorac Surg 15 1999 75 83
29. M. Hendrikx, H. Jiang, and H. Gutermann et al. Release of cardiac troponin I in antegrade crystalloid versus cold blood cardioplegia J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 118 1999 452 459
30. Z. Gasior, M. Krejca, and P. Szmagala et al. Long term left ventricular systolic function assessment following CABG. A prospective, randomised study. Blood versus crystalloid cardioplegia J Cardiovasc Surg 41 2000 695 702
31. R. Brat, J. Tosovsky, and J. Januska et al. Comparison between blood and crystalloid cardioplegia in patients with left ventricular dysfunction undergoing coronary surgery Acta Medica (Hradec Kralove) 43 2000 107 110
32. J.E. Flack 3rd, J.R. Cook, and S.J. May et al. Does cardioplegia type affect outcome and survival in patients with advanced left ventricular dysfunction? Results from the CABG Patch Trial Circulation 102 2000 III84 III89
33. E. Ovrum, G. Tangen, and S. Tollofsrud et al. Cold blood cardioplegia versus cold crystalloid cardioplegia: A prospective randomized study of 1,440 patients undergoing coronary artery bypass grafting J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 128 2004 860 865
34. R. Brat, J. Tosovsky, and J. Januska Myocardial function in early hours after coronary artery bypass grafting in patients with left ventricular dysfunction: Comparison of blood and crystalloid cardioplegia J Cardiovasc Surg 45 2004 265 269
35. A. Barassi, G. Merlini, and S. Finazzi et al. Comparison of three strategies for myocardial protection during coronary artery bypass graft surgery based on markers of cardiac damage Clin Biochem 38 2005 504 508
36. E. Ovrum, G. Tangen, and S. Tollofsrud et al. Cold blood versus cold crystalloid cardioplegia: A prospective randomised study of 345 aortic valve patients Eur J Cardiothorac Surg 38 2010 745 749
37. B. Braathen, and T. Tonnessen Cold blood cardioplegia reduces the increase in cardiac enzyme levels compared with cold crystalloid cardioplegia in patients undergoing aortic valve replacement for isolated aortic stenosis J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 139 2010 874 880
38. H.B. Barner Blood cardioplegia: A review and comparison with crystalloid cardioplegia Ann Thorac Surg 52 1991 1354 1367
39. R.C. Chiu Cardioplegia: From the bedside to the laboratory and back again Ann Thorac Surg 52 1991 1209 1210
40. G.T. Christakis, J.P. Koch, and K.A. Deemar et al. A randomized study of the systemic effects of warm heart surgery Ann Thorac Surg 54 1992 449 457
41. P.J. Hendry, R.G. Masters, and A. Haspect Is there a place for cold crystalloid cardioplegia in the 1990s? Ann Thorac Surg 58 1994 1690 1694
42. G. Scrascia, P. Guida, and C. Rotunno et al. Myocardial protection during aortic surgery: Comparison between Bretschneider-HTK and cold blood cardioplegia Perfusion 26 2011 427 433
43. M. Runge, P. Hughes, and J. Peter Gotze et al. Evaluation of myocardial metabolism with microdialysis after protection with cold blood- or cold crystalloid cardioplegia. A porcine model Scand Cardiovasc J 40 2006 186 193
44. T.D. Martin, J.M. Craver, and J.P. Gott et al. Prospective, randomized trial of retrograde warm blood cardioplegia: Myocardial benefit and neurologic threat Ann Thorac Surg 57 1994 298 302
45. F. Bouchart, J.P. Bessou, and A. Tabley et al. How to protect hypertrophied myocardium? A prospective clinical trial of three preservation techniques Int J Artif Organs 20 1997 440 446