Exploring the evolutionary foundations of empathy: Consolation in monkeys

Evolution and Human Behavior

Volumn 35, Issue 4, 2014, Pages 341-349

  Palagi, Elisabetta ^a,b   Dall'Olio, Stefania ^c   Demuru, Elisa ^a,d   Stanyon, Roscoe ^c  

^a UNIVERSITY OF PISA   (Italy)

^b INSTITUTE OF COGNITIVE SCIENCES AND TECHNOLOGIES   (Italy)

^c UNIVERSITY OF FLORENCE   (Italy)

^d UNIVERSITY OF PARMA   (Italy)

Author keywords

Anxiety alleviation; Macaca fuscata; Macaca tonkeana; Social constraints; Sympathetic concern; Third party affiliation; Victim protection

Indexed keywords

EID: 84901846062     PISSN: 10905138     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.evolhumbehav.2014.04.002     Document Type: Article

References (91)

1. Altman J. Observational study of behaviour sampling methods. Behaviour 1974, 49:227-267.
2. Aureli F., Cords M., Van Schaik C.P. Conflict resolution following aggression in gregarious animals: a predictive framework. Animal Behaviour 2002, 64:325-343.
3. Aureli F., Das M., Veenema H.C. Differential kinship effect on reconciliation in three species of macaques (Macaca fascicularis, M. fuscata, and M. sylvanus). Journal of Comparative Psychology 1997, 111(1):91-99.
4. Aureli F., de Waal F.B.M. Inhibition of social behavior in chimpanzees under high-density conditions. American Journal of Primatology 1997, 41(3):213-228.
5. Aureli F., de Waal F.B.M. Natural conflict resolution 2000, University of California Press, Berkeley.
6. Aureli F., Veenema H.C., Vaneck C.J.V., Vanhooff J.A.R.A. Reconciliation, consolation, and redirection in Japanese macaques (Macaca fuscata). Behaviour 1993, 124:1-21.
7. Aureli F., Yates K. Distress prevention by grooming others in crested black macaques. Biology Letters 2010, 6:27-29.
8. Balasubramaniam K.N., Dittmar K., Berman C.M., Butovskaya M., Cooper M.A., Majolo B., et al. Hierarchical steepness, counter-aggression, and macaque social style scale. American Journal of Primatology 2012, 74(10):915-925.
9. Barash D.P., Lipton J.E. Payback: why we retaliate, redirect aggression, and take revenge 2011, Oxford University Press, New York.
10. Berman C.M. The ontogeny of social relationships with group companions among free-ranging infant rhesus monkeys: II. Differentiation and attractiveness. Animal Behaviour 1982, 30:163-170.
11. Butovskaya M. Kinship and different dominant styles in groups of three species of the genus Macaca (M. arctoides, M. mulatta, M. fascicularis). Folia Primatologica 1993, 60:210-224.
12. Butovskaya M. Social space and degrees of freedom. Macaque societies: A model for the study of social organization 2004, 182-185. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK. B. Thierry, M. Singh, W. Kaumanns (Eds.).
13. Butovskaya M.L., Kozintsev A.G. Gender-related factors affecting primate social behavior: grooming, rank, age, and kinship in heterosexual and all-male groups of stumptail macaques. American Journal of Physical Anthropology 1996, 101(1):39-54.
14. Call J., Aureli F., de Waal F.B.M. Postconflict third-party affiliation in stumptailed macaques. Animal Behaviour 2002, 63:209-216.
15. Ciani F., Dall'Olio S., Stanyon R., Palagi E. Social tolerance and adult play in macaque societies: a comparison with different human cultures. Animal Behaviour 2012, 84(6):1313-1322.
16. Clay Z., de Waal F.B.M. Bonobos respond to distress in others: consolation across the age spectrum. PloS One 2013, 8(1):e55206.
17. Clay Z., de Waal F.B.M. Development of socio-emotional competence in bonobos. Proceedings of National Academy of Science USA 2013, 110(45):18121-18126.
18. Cools A.K.A., Van Hout A.J.M., Nelissen M.H.J. Canine reconciliation and third-party-initiated postconflict affiliation: Do peacemaking social mechanisms in dogs rival those of higher primates?. Ethology 2008, 114(1):53-63.
19. Cordoni G., Palagi E. Response of captive lowland gorillas (Gorilla gorilla gorilla) to different housing conditions: testing the aggression-density and coping models. Journal of Comparative Psychology 2007, 121(2):171-180.
20. De Marco A., Cozzolino R., Dessi-Fulgheri F., Thierry B. Conflicts induce affiliative interactions among bystanders in a tolerant species of macaque (Macaca tonkeana). Animal Behaviour 2010, 80(2):197-203.
21. De Marco A., Cozzolino R., Dessi-Fulgheri F., Thierry B. Collective arousal when reuniting after temporary separation in Tonkean macaques. American Journal of Physical Anthropology 2011, 146:457-464.
22. de Waal F.B.M. Primates-a natural heritage of conflict resolution. Science 2000, 289(5479):586-590.
23. de Waal F.B.M. Putting the altruism back into altruism: the evolution of empathy. Annual Review of Psychology 2008, 59:279-300.
24. de Waal F.B.M., Aureli F. Consolation, reconciliation and a possible cognitive difference between macaques and chimpanzees. Reaching into thought: The minds of great apes 1996, 80-110. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge UK. K.A. Russon, S. Bard, S. Taylor Parker (Eds.).
25. de Waal F.B.M., Luttrell L.M. Toward a comparative socioecology of the genus Macaca - Different dominance styles in rhesus and stumptail monkeys. American Journal of Primatology 1989, 19(2):83-109.
26. de Waal F.B.M., Roosmalen A. Reconciliation and consolation among chimpanzees. Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology 1979, 5:55-66.
27. de Waal F.B.M., Suchak M. Prosocial primates: selfish and unselfish motivations. Philosophical Transaction of the Royal Society of London B Biological Science 2010, 365(1553):2711-2722.
28. de Waal F.B.M., Yoshihara D. Reconciliation and redirected affection in rhesus monkeys. Behaviour 1983, 85:224-241.
29. Decety J., Jackson P.L. A social-neuroscience perspective on empathy. Current Directions in Psychological Science 2006, 15:54-58.
30. Demaria C., Thierry B. A comparative study of reconciliation in rhesus and Tonkean macaques. Behaviour 2001, 138:397-410.
31. Dunbar R.I.M. Primate social systems 1988, Croom Helm, London.
32. Dunbar R.I.M. Functional significance of social grooming in primates. Folia Primatologica 1991, 57:121-131.
33. Eisenberg N. The caring child 1992, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA.
34. Ellemers N. The group self. Science 2012, 336(6083):848-852.
35. Esteban J., Mayoral L., Ray D. Ethnicity and conflict: theory and facts. Science 2012, 336(6083):858-865.
36. Flack J.C., de Waal F.B.M. Dominance style, social power, and conflict. Macaque societies: a model for the study of social organization 2004, 155-182. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK. B. Thierry, M. Singh, W. Kaumanns (Eds.).
37. Fraser O.N., Aureli F. Reconciliation, consolation and postconflict behavioral specificity in chimpanzees. American Journal of Primatology 2008, 70(12):1114-1123.
38. Fraser O.N., Bugnyar T. Do ravens show consolation? responses to distressed others. PloS One 2010, 5(5).
39. Fraser O.N., Koski S.E., Wittig R.M., Aureli F. Why are bystanders friendly to recipients of aggression?. Communicative and Integrative Biology 2009, 2(3):285-291.
40. Fraser O.N., Stahl D., Aureli F. Stress reduction through consolation in chimpanzees. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 2008, 105(25):8557-8562.
41. Fujisawa K.K., Kutsukake N., Hasegawa T. Peacemaking and consolation in Japanese preschoolers witnessing peer aggression. Journal of Comparative Psychology 2006, 120(1):48-57.
42. Hatfield E., Cacioppo J.T., Rapson R.L. Emotional contagion 1994, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
43. Hecht E.E., Patterson R., Barbey A.K. What can other animals tell us about human social cognition? An evolutionary perspective on reflective and reflexive processing. Frontiers in Human Neuroscience 2012, 6:224.
44. Iacoboni M. Imitation, empathy, and mirror neurons. Annual Review of Psychology 2009, 60:653-670.
45. Kaufman A.B., Rosenthal R. Can you believe my eyes? The importance of interobserver reliability statistics in observations of animal behaviour. Animal Behaviour 2009, 78(6):1487-1491.
46. Koski S.E., Sterck E.H.M. Triadic postconflict affiliation in captive chimpanzees: does consolation console?. Animal Behaviour 2007, 73:133-142.
47. Koski S.E., Sterck E.H. Post-conflict third-party affiliation in chimpanzees: what's in it for the third party?. American Journal of Primatology 2009, 71(5):409-418.
48. Kutsukake N., Castles D.L. Reconciliation and variation in post-conflict stress in Japanese macaques (Macaca fuscata): testing the integrated hypothesis. Animal Cognition 2001, 4(3-4):259-268.
49. Kutsukake N., Castles D.L. Reconciliation and post-conflict third-party affiliation among wild chimpanzees in the Mahale Mountains, Tanzania. Primates 2004, 45(3):157-165.
50. Light S.N., Zahn-Waxler C. Nature and forms of empathy in the first years of life. Empathy: from bench to bedside 2011, 109-130. MIT Press, Cambridge, MA. J. Decety (Ed.).
51. Maestripieri D. Maternal behaviour, infant handling and socialization. Macaque societies: A model for the study of social organization 2004, 231-234. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, MA. B. Thierry, M. Singh, W. Kaumanns (Eds.).
52. Majolo B., Ventura R., Koyama N. Postconflict behavior among male Japanese macaques. International Journal of Primatology 2005, 26(2):321-336.
53. Mancini G., Ferrari P.F., Palagi E. Rapid facial mimicry in geladas. Scientific Reports 2013, 3:1527. 10.1038/srep01527.
54. Mastripieri D., Schino G., Aureli F., Troisi A. A modest proposal: displacement activities as an indicator of emotions in primates. Animal Behaviour 1992, 44:967-979.
55. Matsumura S. The evolution of "egalitarian" and "despotic" social systems among macaques. Primates 1999, 40(1):23-31.
56. Mehelman P.T., Chapais B. Differential effect of kinship, dominance and the mating season on female allogrooming in a captive group of Macaca fuscata. Primates 1988, 29:195-217.
57. Nakamichi M., Shizawa Y. Distribution of grooming among adult females in a large, free-ranging group of Japanese macaques. International Journal of Primatology 2003, 24:607-625.
58. Palagi E., Cordoni G. Postconflict third-party affiliation in Canis lupus: do wolves share similarities with the great apes?. Animal Behaviour 2009, 78(4):979-986.
59. Palagi E., Cordoni G., Borgognini Tarli S. Possible roles of consolation in captive chimpanzees (Pan troglodytes). American Journal of Physical Anthropology 2006, 129(1):105-111.
60. Palagi E., Leone A., Mancini G., Ferrari P.F. Contagious yawning in gelada baboons as a possible expression of empathy. Proceedings of the National Academy of Science USA 2009, 106:19262-19267.
61. Palagi E., Norscia I. Scratching around stress: hierarchy and reconciliation make the difference in wild brown lemurs (Eulemur fulvus). Stress 2011, 14(1):93-97.
62. Palagi E., Norscia I. Bonobos protect and console friends and kin. PloS One 2013, 8(11):e79290. 10.1371/journal.pone.0079290.
63. Palagi E., Paoli T., Tarli S. Reconciliation and consolation in captive bonobos (Pan paniscus). American Journal of Primatology 2004, 62(1):15-30.
64. Panksepp J., Panksepp J.B. Toward a cross-species understanding of empathy. Trends in Neuroscience 2013, 36(8):489-496.
65. Paukner A., Suomi S.J., Visalberghi E., Ferrari P.F. Capuchin monkeys display affiliation toward humans who imitate them. Science 2009, 325:880-883.
66. Petit O., Abegg C., Thierry B. A comparative study of aggression and conciliation in three cercopithecine monkeys (Macaca fuscata, Macaca nigra, Papio papio). Behaviour 1997, 134:415-432.
67. Petit O., Thierry B. Aggressive and peaceful interventions in conflicts in Tonkean macaques. Animal Behaviour 1994, 48(6):1427-1436.
68. Preston S.D., de Waal F.B.M. Empathy: Its ultimate and proximate bases. Behavior Brain Science 2002, 25(1):1-20. (discussion 20-71).
69. Rizzolatti G., Sinigaglia C., Anderson F. Mirrors in the brain: How our minds share actions, emotions, and experience 2007, Oxford University Press, Oxford.
70. Romero T., Castellanos M.A., de Waal F.B.M. Consolation as possible expression of sympathetic concern among chimpanzees. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 2010, 107(27):12110-12115.
71. Romero T., de Waal F.B.M. Chimpanzee (Pan troglodytes) consolation: Third-party identity as a window on possible function. Journal of Comparative Psychology 2010, 124(3):278-286.
72. Schino G., Geminiani S., Rosati L., Aureli F. Behavioral and emotional response of Japanese macaque (Macaca fuscata) mothers after their offspring receive an aggression. Journal of Comparative Psychology 2004, 118(3):340-346.
73. Schino G., Marini C. Self-protective function of post-conflict bystander affiliation in mandrills. PloS One 2012, 7(6).
74. Sclafani V., Norscia I., Antonacci D., Palagi E. Scratching around mating: Factors affecting anxiety in wild Lemur catta. Primates 2012, 53(3):247-254.
75. Seed A.M., Clayton N.S., Emery N.J. Postconflict third-party affiliation in rooks, Corvus frugilegus. Current Biology 2007, 17(2):152-158.
76. Seyfarth R.M., Cheney D.L. Affiliation, empathy, and the origins of theory of mind. Proceedings of the National Academy of Science USA 2013, 110:10349-10356.
77. Shutt K., MacLarnon A., Heistermann M., Semple S. Grooming in Barbary macaques: better to give than to receive?. Biology Letters 2007, 3:231-233.
78. Silk J.B. Altruism among female Macaca radiata: explanations and analysis of patterns of grooming and coalition formation. Behaviour 1982, 79:162-188.
79. Singh M., D'Souza L., Singh M. Hierarchy, kinship and social interaction among Japanese monkeys (Macaca fuscata). Journal of Biosciences 1992, 17:15-27.
80. Thierry B. Social development in three species of macaque (Macaca mulatta, M. fascicularis, M. tonkeana): A preliminary report on the first ten weeks of life. Behavioural Processes 1985, 11(1):89-95.
81. Thierry B. Patterns of agonistic interactions in three species of macaque (Macaca mulatta, Macaca fascicularis, Macaca tonkeana). Aggressive Behavior 1985, 11(3):223-233.
82. Thierry B. Feedback loop between kinship and dominance: The macaque model. Journal of Theoretical Biology 1990, 145(4):511-522.
83. Thierry B. Covariation and conflict management patterns across macaque species. Natural conflict resolution 2000, 106-128. Berkeley University of California Press. F. Aureli, F.B.M. de Waal (Eds.).
84. Thierry B., Gauthier C., Peignot P. Social grooming in Tonkean macaques (Macaca tonkeana). International Journal of Primatology 1990, 11(4):357-375.
85. Thierry B., Singh M., Kaumanns W. Why macaque societies?. Macaque societies: a model for the study of social organization 2004, 3-10. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge UK. B. Thierry, M. Singh, W. Kaumanns (Eds.).
86. Troisi A. Displacement activities as a behavioral measure of stress in nonhuman primates and human subjects. Stress 2002, 5(1):47-54.
87. Vaish A., Warneken F. Social-cognitive contributors to young children's empathic and prosocial behavior. Empathy: from bench to bedside 2011, 131-146. MIT Press, Cambridge, MA. J. Decety (Ed.).
88. Watts D.P., Colmenares F., Arnold K. Redirection, consolation, and male policing. How targets of aggression interact with bystanders. Natural conflict resolution 2000, 281-301. Berkeley University of California Press. F. Aureli, F.B.M. de Waal (Eds.).
89. Wittig R.M., Boesch C. The choice of post-conflict interactions in wild chimpanzees (Pan troglodytes). Behaviour 2003, 140:1527-1559.
90. Wittig R.M., Boesch C. Receiving post-conflict affiliation from the enemy's friend reconciles former opponents. PloS One 2010, 5(11):e13995.
91. Zahn-Waxler C., Radke-Yarrow M. The origins of empathic concern. Motivation and Emotion 1990, 14(2):107-130.