Uranium-series dating of carbonate formations overlying Paleolithic art: Interest and limitations

Bulletin de la Societe Prehistorique Francaise

Volumn 111, Issue 2, 2014, Pages 211-224

  Pons Branchu, Edwige ^a   Bourrillon, Raphaëlle ^c   Conkey, Margaret W ^b   Fontugne, Michel ^a   Fritz, Carole ^c   Gárate, Diego ^c   Quiles, Anita ^a   Rivero, Olivia ^c   Sauvet, Georges ^c   Tosello, Gilles ^c   Valladas, Hélène ^a   White, Randall ^d  

^a LABORATOIRE DES SCIENCES DU CLIMAT ET DE L ENVIRONNEMENT   (France)

^b UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA   (United States)

^c Maison de la Recherche   (France)

^d NEW YORK UNIVERSITY   (United States)

Author keywords

Calcite; Cantabrian region; Cave art; U Th dating; Upper Paleolithic

Indexed keywords

EID: 84901807260     PISSN: 02497638     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.3406/bspf.2014.14395     Document Type: Article

References (56)

1. ALCOLEA GONZALEZ J. J., BALBIN BEHRMANN R. DE (2007) - 14C et style. La chronologie de l'art pariétal á l'heure actuelle, L'Anthropologie, 111, pp. 435-466.
2. ARNOLD M., BARD E., MAURICE P., DUPLESSY J.-C. (1987) -14C dating with the Gif-sur-Yvette Tandetron accelerator: status report, Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research, B 29, pp. 20-123.
3. AUBERT M., O'CONNOR S., MCCULLOCH M., MORTIMER G., WATCHMAN A., RICHIER-LAFLECHE M. (2007) - Uranium-series dating rock art in East Timor, Journal of Archaeological Science, 34, pp. 991-996.
4. BARD E., HAMELIN B., FAIRBANKS R. G., ZINDLER A. (1990) - Calibration of the 14C timescale over the past 30,000 years using mass spectrometric U-Th ages from Barbados corals, Nature, 345, pp. 405-410.
5. B EDNARIK R. G. (2012) - U-Th analysis and rock art: a response to Pike et al., Rock Art Research, 29,2, pp. 244-246.
6. BISCHOFF J., GARCIA-DIEZ M., GONZALEZ MORALES M. R., SHARP W. (2003) - Aplicación del mètodo de series de Uranio al grafismo rupestre de estilo paleolitico: el caso de la cavidad de Covalanas (Ramales de la Victoria, Cantabria). Veleia,20,pp. 143-150.
7. BORDES J.-G. (2000) - La séquence aurignacienne de Cami-nade revisitée: l'apport des raccords d'intérêt stratigra-phique, Paleo, 12, pp. 387-407.
8. BORSATO A., QUINIF Y., BINI A., DUBLYANSKY Y. (2003) -Open-system alpine speleothems: implications for U-series dating and paleoclimate reconstructions, Studi Trentini di Scienze Naturali, Acta Geologica, 80, pp. 71-83.
9. BROGLIO A., DE STEFANI M., GURIOLI E, PALLECCHI R, GIACHI G., HIGHAM T., BROCK E (2009) - L'art aurignacien dans la décoration de la grotte de Fumane, L'Anthropologie, 113, pp. 753-761.
10. CABRERA-VALDES V., BERNALDO DE QUIRÓS F., MAILLO-FERNÁNDEZ J. M., VALLADAS H., LLORET M. (2002) - El Aurifiaciense arcaico de El Castillo (Cantabria): description tecnológica y objetivos de la producción, in F. Bon, J. M. Maillo-Fernández and D. Ortega (eds.), Autour des concepts de Protoaurignacien, d'Aurignacien archaïque, initial et ancien, Madrid, Universidad Nacional de Educa-cion a Distancia, Facultad de Geografia e Historia (Espacio, Tiempo y Forma, 15), pp. 67-86.
11. CHENG H., EDWARDS R. L., MURRELL M. T., BENJAMIN T. M. (1998) - Uranium-thorium-protactinium dating systematics, Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta, 6,21 -22, pp. 3437-3452.
12. CHIU T. C, FAIRBANKS R. G., CAO L., FAIRBANKS T. W., BLOOM A. L. (2006) - Redundant 230Th/238U, 231Pa/235U and 14C dating of fossil corals for accurate radiocarbon age calibration, Quaternary Science Reviews, 25,17-18, pp. 2431-2440.
13. CLOTTES J. (2012) - Datations U-Th, évolution de l'art et Néander-tal, International Newsletter on Rock Art, 64, pp. 1-6.
14. D'ERRICO F., ZILHAO I, JULLIEN M., BAFFIER D., PELEGRIN J. (1998) - Neanderthal acculturation in western Europe? A critical review of the evidence and its interpretation, Current Anthropology, 39, suppl., S1-44.
15. EDWARDS R. L., CHEN J. H., WASSERBURG G. J. (1987) -238U-234U-230Th-232Th systematics and the precise measurement of time over the past 500,000 years, Earth Planet, Science Letters, 81, pp. 175-192.
16. FLEISCHER K. L., RAABE O. G., (1978) - Recoiling alpha-emitting nuclei; mechanisms for uranium-series disequilibrium, Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta, 42, 7, pp. 973-978.
17. FONTUGNE M., SHAO Q., FRANK N., THIL F., GUIDON N., BOEDA E. (2013) - Cross dating (Th/U-14C) of calcite covering prehistoric paintings at Serra da Capivara National Park, Piaui, Brazil, Radiocarbon, 55,2-3, pp. 1191 -1198.
18. FRUUTIER C., ELLIOTT T., SCHLAGER W. (2000) - Mass-spec-trometric 234U-230Th ages from the Key Largo Formation, Florida Keys, United States: Constraints on diagenetic age disturbance, Geological Society of American Bulletin, 112, 2, pp. 267-277.
19. FORTEA PEREZ J. (1995) - Abrigo de la Vifia. Informe y primera valoración de las campafias 1991 a 1994, Excavaciones arqueológicas enAsturias 1991-94 (Oviedo), 3, pp. 19-32.
20. GÁRATE MAIDAGÁN D. (2010) - Las ciervas punteadas en las cuevas del Paleolitico. Una expresión pletórica propia de la cornisa cantábrica, Donostia, Sociedad de Ciencias (suple-mento Munibe, 33), 306 pp.
21. GENTY D., MASSAULT M., GILMOUR M., BAKER A., VERHEY-DEN S., KEPPENS E. (1999) - Calculation of past dead carbon proportion and variability by the comparison of AMS,14C and TIMS U/Th ages on two Holocene stalagmites, Radiocarbon, 41, 3, pp. 251-270.
22. GENTY D., BAKER A., MASSAULT M., PROCTOR C., PONS-BRANCHU E., HAMELIN B. (2001) - Dead carbon in stalagmites: carbonates bedrocks vs ageing of soil organic matter. Implications for l3C variations in speleothems, Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta, 65,20, pp. 3443-3457.
23. GHALEB B., PONS-BRANCHU E., DESCHAMPS P. (2004) -Improved method for radium extraction from environmental samples for determination by thermal ionization Mass spectrometry, Journal of Analytical Atomic Spectrometry, 19, 7, pp. 906-910.
24. GONZALEZ SAINZ C. (1999) - Algunos problemas actuales en la ordenación cronológica del arte paleolitico en Cantabria, in IEncuentro de Historia de Cantabria, proceedings of the conference (Santander, 16-19 December 1996), Santander, Universidad de Cantabria, pp. 149-166.
25. GONZALEZ SAINZ C. (2003) - El conjunto parietal paleolitico de la Galena inferior de La Garma (Cantabria). Avance de su organización interna, in R. de Balbin Behrmann and P. Bueno Ramirez (eds.), El arte prehistórico desde los ini-cios del siglo XXI, proceedings of the international symposium (Ribadesella, Spain, 2002), Oviedo, Asociación Cultural Amigos de Ribadesella, pp. 201 -222.
26. GONZALEZ SAINZ C. (2007) - Los grupos humanos del paleolitico superior y el primer arte figurativo, in M. Suárez Cortina (dir.), Historia de Cantabria, Santander, El Diario Montanes (supll. del 15-11-2007), pp. 25-32.
27. GONZALEZ SAINZ C., SAN MIGUEL LLAMOSAS C. (2001) - Las cuevas del desfiladero. Arte rupestre paleolitico en el valle del rio Carranza (Cantabria-Vizcaya), Santander, Universi-dad de Cantabria, 225 pp.
28. GOSLAR T., HERCHMAN H., PAZDUR A. (2000) - Comparison of U-series and radiocarbon dates of speleothems, Radiocarbon, 42,3, pp. 403-414.
29. HEDGES R. E. M., HOUSLEY R. A., BRONK RAMSEY G, VAN KLIKEN G. J. (1994) - Radiocarbon dates from the Oxford AMS system: Archaeometry Dateiist 18, Archaeometry, 36,2, pp. 337-374.
30. HELLSTROM J. (2006) - U-Th dating of speleothems with high initial 230Th using stratigraphical constraint, Quaternary Geochronology, 1,4, pp. 289-295.
31. HELLSTROM J., MCCULLOCH M. (2000) - Multi-proxy constraints on the climatic significance of trace elements records from a New Zealand speleothem, Earth and Planetary Science Letters, 179, pp. 287-297.
32. HIGHAM T., BASELL L., JACOBI R., WOOD E., BRONK RAMSEY C, CONARD N. J. (2012) - Testing models for the beginnings of the Aurignacian and the advent of figurative art and music: The radiocarbon chronology of Geißenklö sterle, Journal of Human Evolution, 62, pp. 664-676.
33. HOFFMANN D. L., WARREN BECK J., RICHARDS D. A., SMART P. L., SINGARAYER J. S., KETCHMARK T., HAWKESWORTH C. J. (2010) - Towards radiocarbon calibration beyond 28 ka using speleothems from the Bahamas, Earth and Planetary Science Letters, 289, pp. 1-10.
34. HUA Q., MCDONALD J., REDWOOD D., DRYSDALE R., LEE S., FALLON S., HELLSTROM J. (2012) - Robust chronological reconstruction for young speleothems using radiocarbon, Quaternary Geochronology, 14, pp. 67-80.
35. JAILLET S. (2000) - Un karst couvert de bas-plateau: le Bar-rois. Structure, fonctionnement, évolution, PhD thesis. Bordeaux 3 University.
36. LABONNE M., HILLAIRE-MARCEL G, GHALEB B., GOY J. L. (2002) - Multi-isotopic age assessment of dirty speleothem calcite: an example from Altamira Cave, Spain, Quaternary Science Reviews, 21, pp. 1099-1110.
37. LEROI-GOURHAN A. (1965) - Préhistoire de l'art occidental, Paris, Mazenod, 482 pp.
38. Li W. X., LUNDBERG J., DICKIN A. P., FORD D. G, SCHAWARCZ H. P., MCNUTT R., WILLIAMS D. (1989) - High-precision mass-spectrometric uranium-series dating of cave deposits and implications for palaeoclimate studies, Nature, 339, pp. 534-536.
39. MAÍLLO FERNÁNDEZ J. M., VALLADAS H., CABRERA VALDÉS V, BERNALDO DE QUIRÓS F. (2001) - Nuevas dataciones para el Paleolitico superior de Cueva Morín (Villanueva de Villaescusa, Cantabria). Serie I, Prehistoria y Arqueologia Espacio, Tiempo y Forma, 14, pp. 145-150.
40. MORTLOCK R. A., FAIRBANKS R. G., CHIU T.-G, RUBENSTONE J. (2005) - 320Th/234U and 231U ages from a single fossil coral fragment by multi-collector magnetic-sector inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry, Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta, 69,3, pp. 649-657.
41. OSMOND J. K., IVANOVICH M. (1992) - Uranium-series mobilization and surface hydrology, in M. Ivanovich and R. S. Harmon (eds.), Uranium-series disequilibrium; applications to earth, marine, and environmental sciences, Oxford, Clarendon Press, pp. 259-289.
42. PIKE A. W. G., GILMOUR M., PETTITT P., JACOBI R., RIPOLL S., BAHN P., Muńoz F. (2005) - Verification of the age of the Palaeolithic rock art at Creswell, Journal of Archaeological Science, 32, pp. 1649-1655.
43. PIKE A. W. G., HOFFMANN D. L., GARCÍA-DIEZ M., PETTITT P. B., ALCOLEA J., DE BALBÍN R., GONZÁLEZ SAINZ C, DE LAS HERAS C, LASHERAS J. A., MONTES R., ZILHAO J. (2012) - U-Series Dating of Paleolithic Art in 11 Caves in Spain, Science, 336 (15 June 2012), pp. 1409-1413 (supplementary materials: www.sciencemag.org/cgi/content/ full/336/6087/1409/DCl).
44. PLAGNES V., CAUSSE C, FONTUGNE M., VALLADAS H., CHA-ziNE J.-M., FAGE L.-H. (2003) - Cross dating (Th/U-14C) of calcite covering prehistoric paintings in Borneo, Quaternary Research, 60,2, pp. 172-179.
45. PONS-BRANCHU E. (2001) - Datation haute résolution de spé-léothèmes (230Th/234U et 226Ra/238U). Application aux reconstitutions environnementales autour des sites du Gard et de Meuse / Haute-Marne, PhD thesis. Aix-Marseille II University.
46. PONS-BRANCHU E., HILLAIRE-MARCEL C, GHALEB B., DESCHAMPS P., SINCLAIR D. (2005) - Early diagenesis impact on precise U-series dating of Deep-Sea corals. Example of a 100-200 years old Lophelia Pertusa sample from NE Atlantic, Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta, 69, 20, pp. 4865-4879.
47. REIMER P. J., BARD E., BAYLISS A., BECK J. W., BLACKWELL P. G., BRONK RAMSEY C, BUCK C. E., CHENG H., EDWARDS R. L., FRIEDRICH M., GROOTES P. M., GUIL-DERSON T. P., HAFLIDASON H., HAIDAS I., HATTÉ G, HEA-TON T. J., HOFFMAN D. L., HOGG A. G., HUGHEN K. A., KAISER K. F., KROMER B., MANNING S. W., REIMER R. W., RICHARDS D. A., SCOTT E. M., SOUTHON J. R., STAFF R. A., TORNEY G S. M., VAN DER PLICHT J. (2013) - IntCal13 and Marine 13 Radiocarbon Age Calibration Curves 0-50,000 Years cal. BP, Radiocarbon, 55 (4), pp. 1869-1887.
48. SZMIDT G, NORMAND G, BURR G. S., HODGINS G. W. L., LAMOTTA S. (2010) - AMS 14C dating the Protoaurigna-cian/Early Aurignacian of Isturitz, France. Implications for Neanderthal-modern human interaction and the timing of technical and cultural innovations in Europe, Journal of Archaeological Science, 37, pp. 758-768.
49. THURBER D. L., BROECKER W. S., BLANCHAR R. L., POTRATZ H. A. (1965) - Uranium-series ages of Pacific atoll coral, Science, 149, pp. 55-68.
50. VALLADAS H., TISNERAT-LABORDE N., CACHIER H., ARNOLD M., BERNALDO DE QUIRÓS E, CABRERA-VALDES V., CLOTTES J., COURTIN J., FORTEA PEREZ J., GONZALEZ SAINZ G, MOURE-ROMANILLO A. (2001a) - Radiocarbon AMS dates for Paleolithic cave paintings, Radiocarbon, 43, 2B, pp. 977-986.
51. VALLADAS H., CLOTTES J., GENESTE J. M., GARCIA M., ARNOLD M., CACHIER H., TISNERAT-LABORDE N. (2001b) - Evolution of Prehistoric Cave Art, Nature, 413,479.
52. VALLADAS H., GENTY D, KALTNECKER E., QUILES A., TISNERAT-LABORDE N., ARNOLD M., MOREAU G, BAFFIER D., CLEYET-MERLE J.-J., CLOTTES J., GIRARD M., MONNEY J., MONTES R., GONZALEZ SAINZ G, SANCHIDRIÁN J. L., SIMONNET R. (2013) - Dating French and Spanish prehistoric decorated caves in their archaeological contexts, Radiocarbon, 55 (2-3), pp. 1422-1431.
53. VAN N. H., LALOU G (1969) - Comportement géochimique des isotopes des familles de l'uranium et du thorium dans les concrétionnements des grottes: application á la datation des stalagmites, Comptes rendus hebdomadaires des séances de l'Académie des sciences, série D, 269, pp. 560-563.
54. VOGEL J. G, KRINFELD J. (1997) - Calibration of radiocarbon dates for the Late Pleistocene using U/Th dates on stalagmites, Radiocarbon, 39, pp. 27-32.
55. WHITE R., MENSAN R., BOURRILLON R., CRETIN G, HIGHAM T. E G., CLARKE A. E., SISK M. L., TARTAR E., GAR-DÈRE P., GOLDBERG P., PELEGRIN J., VALLADAS H.,TISNE-RAT-LABORDE N., DE SANOIT J., CHAMBELLAN D., CHIOTTI L. (2012) - Context and dating of Aurignacian vulvar representations from Abri Castanet, France, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, May 29, 109, 22, pp. 8450-8455.
56. ZHAO J. X., Yu K. E, FENG Y. X. (2009) - High-precision ́8U-234U-230Th disequilibrium dating of the recent past: a review, Quaternary Geochronology, 4, 5, pp. 423-433.