Resurrecting the third variable: A critique of Pearl's causal analysis of Simpson's Paradox

American Statistician

Volumn 68, Issue 1, 2014, Pages 1-7

  Armistead, Timothy W ^a  

^a Armistead Investigative Services   (United States)

Author keywords

Causality; Confounding; Inference; Intermediate variable; Reversal effect; Spurious correlation

Indexed keywords

EID: 84901753495     PISSN: 00031305     EISSN: 15372731     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1080/00031305.2013.807750     Document Type: Article

References (39)

1. Agresti, A. (1983), "Fallacies, Statistical, " in Encyclopedia of Statistical Science (Vol. 3), eds. S. Kotz and N. L. Johnson, New York: Wiley, pp. 24-28. [2]
2. Aldrich, J. (1995), "Correlations Genuine and Spurious in Pearson and Yule, " Statistical Science, 10, 364-376. [1]
3. Alin, A. (March/April 2010), "Simpson's Paradox, " WIREs Computational Statistics, 2, 247-250. [1]
4. Bickel, P. J., Hammel, E. A., and O'Connell, J.W. (1975), "Sex Bias in Graduate Admissions: Data From Berkeley, " Science, 187, 398-404. [1]
5. Bishop, Y. M. M., Fienberg, S. E., and Holland, P. W. (1975), Discrete Multivariate Analysis: Theory and Practice, Cambridge, MA: MIT Press. [4]
6. Blyth, C. R. (1972), "On Simpson's Paradox and the Sure-Thing Principle, " Journal of the American Statistical Association, 67, 364-366. [1]
7. Breslow, N. E., and Day, N. E. (1980), Statistical Methods in Cancer Research, Vol. 1: The Analysis of Case Control Studies, Lyon, France: WHO, International Agency for Research on Cancer. [2]
8. Cartwright, N. (1979), "Causal Laws and Effective Strategies, " Noûs, 13, 419-437. [2,12]
9. Cartwright, N. (1983), How the Laws of Physics Lie, New York: Oxford University Press. [2]
10. Cartwright, N. (2001), "What is Wrong With Bayes Nets?" The Monist, 84, 242-265. [2]
11. Cohen, M. R., and Nagel, E. (1934), An Introduction to Logic and Scientific Method, New York: Harcourt, Brace and Co. [1]
12. Cornfield, J., Haenszel, W., Hammond, E., Lilienfeld, A., Shimkin, M., and Wynder, E. (1959), "Smoking and Lung Cancer: Recent Evidence and a Discussion of Some Questions, " Journal of the National Cancer Institute, 22, 173-203. [4,12]
13. Cox, D. R., and Wermuth, N. (2004), "Causality: A Statistical View, " International Statistical Review, 72, 285-305. [4]
14. Dupre, J., and Cartwright, N. (1988), "Probability and Causality: Why Hume and Indeterminism Don't Mix, " Noûs, 22, 521-536. [2]
15. Fisher, R. A. (1934), Statistical Methods for Research Workers, Edinburgh, Scotland: Oliver and Boyd. [1]
16. Greenland, S., and Neutra, R. (1980), "Control of Confounding in the Assessment of Technology, " International Journal of Epidemiology, 9, 361-367. [2]
17. Greenland, S., Pearl, J., and Robins, J. M. (1999), "Causal Diagrams for Epidemiologic Research, " Epidemiology, 10, 37-48. [2]
18. Gunasekara, F. I., Carter, K., and Blakely, T. (2008), "Glossary for Econometrics and Epidemiology, " Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health, 62, 858-861. [4]
19. Knapp, T. R. (June 1985), "Instances of Simpson's Paradox, " College Mathematics Journal, 16, 209-211. [1]
20. Lesser, L. M. (2001), "Representations of Reversal: An exploration of Simpson's Paradox, " National Council of Teachers of Mathematics. Available at www.statlit.org/pdf/2001LesserNCTM.pdf. [1]
21. Lindley, D. V., and Novick, M. R. (1981), "The Role of Exchangeability in Inference, " The Annals of Statistics, 9, 45-58. [2,4]
22. Malinas, G., and Bigelow, J. (2009), "Simpson's Paradox, " in Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, eds. E. N. Zalta. Available at http://plato.stanford. edu/archives/fall2009/entries/paradox-simpson/. [1]
23. Niles, H. E. (May 1922), "Correlation, Causation, and Wright's Theory of 'Path Coefficients,'" Genetics, 7, 258-273. [1]
24. Ooi, Y. H. (1 April 2004), "Simpson's Paradox-A Survey of Past, Present, and Future Research, " Wharton Research Scholars Journal, University of Pennsylvania Scholarly Commons. Available at http://repository.upenn. edu/wharton research scholars/15. [1]
25. Pearl, J. (2009), Causality: Models, Reasoning, and Inference (2nd ed.), New York: Cambridge University Press. [1,2,4,5]
26. Pearson, K., Lee, A., and Bramley-Moore, L. (1899), "Genetic (Reproductive) Selection: Inheritance of Fertility in Man and of Fecundity in Thoroughbred Racehorses, " Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London, Series A, 192, 257-330. [1]
27. Robins, J.M. (1989), "The Control of Confounding by Intermediate Variables, " Statistics in Medicine, 8, 679-701. [4]
28. Rosenbaum, P. R. (1984), "The Consequences of Adjustment for a Concomitant Variable That Has Been Affected by the Treatment, " Journal of the Royal Statistical Society, Series A, 147, 656-666. [4]
29. Rosenbaum, P. R. (2003), "Does a Dose-Response Relationship Reduce Sensitivity to Hidden Bias?" Biostatistics, 4, 1-10. [4]
30. Rosenbaum, P. R., and Rubin, D. B., (1983), "The Central Role of the Propensity Score in Observational Studies for Causal Effects, " Biometrika, 70, 41-55. [4]
31. Rothman, K. J., Greenland, S., and Lash, T. L. (2008), Modern Epidemiology (3rd ed.), Philadelphia PA: Walters Kluwer {pipe} Lippincott, Williams and Wilkins. [4]
32. Schield, M. (1999), "Simpson's Paradox and Cornfield's Conditions, " paper presented at American Statistical Association, Joint Statistical Meeting 1999. Available at www.statlit.org/pdf/1999SchieldASA.pdf. [5]
33. Schield, M. (2006), "Beware the Lurking Variable: Understanding Confounding From Lurking Variables Using Graphs, " STATS Magazine, 46, Fall, 14-18. [4]
34. Schisterman, E. F., Cole, S. R., and Platt, R. W. (2009), "Overadjustment Bias and Unnecessary Adjustment in Epidemiologic Studies, " Epidemiology, 20, 488-495. [2]
35. Simpson, E. H. (1951), "The Interpretation of Interaction in Contingency Tables, " Journal of the Royal Statistical Society, Series B, 13, 238-241. [1]
36. Wainer, H., and Brown, L. M., (2004), "Two Statistical Paradoxes in the Interpretation of Group Differences, " The American Statistician, 58, 117-123. [1,4]
37. Weinberg, C. R. (1993), "Toward a Clearer Definition of Confounding, " American Journal of Epidemiology, 137, 1-8. [4]
38. Yule, G. U. (February 1903), "Notes on the Theory of Association of Attributes in Statistics, " Biometrika, 2, 121-134. [1]
39. Zidek, J., (1984), "Maximal Simpson-Disaggregations of 2 × 2 Tables, " Biometrika, 71, 187-190. [1]