Characterizing obsidian sources with portable XRF: Accuracy, reproducibility, and field relationships in a case study from Armenia

Journal of Archaeological Science

Volumn 49, Issue 1, 2014, Pages 105-125

  Frahm, Ellery ^a,b  

^a UNIVERSITY OF MINNESOTA   (United States)

^b University of Minnesota   (United States)

Author keywords

Accuracy; Field methods; Obsidian sourcing; Pokr Arteni; PXRF; Reproducibility; Source characterization

Indexed keywords

ARTIFACT; FIELD METHOD; OBSIDIAN; X-RAY FLUORESCENCE;

ARMENIA [WEST ASIA];

EID: 84901612491     PISSN: 03054403     EISSN: 10959238     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.jas.2014.05.003     Document Type: Article

References (94)

1. Adler D.S., Yeritsyan B., Wilkinson K., Pinhasi R., Bar-Oz G., Nahapetyan S., Bailey R., Schmidt B.A., Glauberman P., Wales N., Gasparian B. The Hrazdan Gorge Palaeolithic Project, 2008-2009. Archaeology of Armenia in Regional Context, Proceedings of the International Conference Dedicated to the 50th Anniversary of the Institute of Archaeology and Ethnography Held on September 15--17, 2009 in Yerevan, Armenia 2012, 21-37. NAS RA Gitutyn Publishing House, Yerevan. P. Avetisyan, A. Bobokhyan (Eds.).
2. Ambroz J.A., Glascock M.D., Skinner C.E. Chemical differentiation of obsidian within the glass buttes complex, Oregon. J.Archaeol. Sci. 2001, 28(7):741-746.
3. Badalian R., Bigazzi G., Cauvin M.-C., Chataigner C., Jrbashyan R., Karapetyan S.G., Oddone M., Poidevin J.-L. An international research project on armenian archaeological sites: fission-track dating of obsidians. Radiat. Meas. 2001, 34(1-6):373-378.
4. Badalyan R., Chataigner C., Kohl P. Trans-Caucasian Obsidian: the Exploitation of the Sources and their Distribution. AView from the Highlands: Archaeological Studies in Honour of Charles Burney 2004, 437-465. Ancient Near Eastern Studies. A. Sagona (Ed.).
5. Badalyan R., Lombard P., Avetisyan P., Chataigner C., Chabot J., Vila E., Hovsepyan R., Willcox G., Pessin H. New data on the late prehistory of the Southern Caucasus. The excavations at Aratashen (Armenia): preliminary report. Les Cultures du Caucase (VIe-IIIe millénaires avant notre ère). Leurs relations avec le Proche-Orient 2007, 37-61. CNRS éditions. B. Lyonnet (Ed.).
6. Badalyan R., Harutyunyan A., Chataigner C., Le Mort F., Chabot J., Brochier J.-E., Balasescu A., Radu V., Hovsepyan R. The Settlement of Aknashen-Khatunarkh, a neolithic site in the Ararat Plain (Armenia): excavation results 2004-2009. Tüba-Ar 2010, 13:187-220.
7. Bartholomew D.J. The Statistical Approach to Social Measurement 1996, Academic Press, San Diego.
8. Blackman M. Provenance Studies of Middle Eastern Obsidian from Sites in Highland Iran. Archaeological Chemistry III 1984, 19-50. J.B. Lambert (Ed.).
9. Blackman M.J., Badalian R., Kikodze Z., Kohl P. Chemical characterization of Caucasian Obsidian Geological Sources. BAR International Series 1998, 205-231. M.-C. Cauvin, A. Gourgaud, B. Gratuze, N. Arnaud, G. Poupeau, J.L. Poidevin, C. Chataigner (Eds.).
10. Bohrnstedt G.W., Knoke D. Statistics for Social Data Analysis 1988, F. E. Peacock Publishers, Itasca, IL. second ed.
11. Bowman H., Asaro F., Pearlman I. Composition variations in obsidian sources and the archaeological implications. Archaeometry 1973, 15(1):123-127.
12. Bowman H., Asaro F., Pearlman I. On the uniformity of composition in obsidians and evidence for magmatic mixing. J.Geol. 1973, 81(3):312-327.
13. Brandt S., Johnson L.M., Chase A. AComparative Study of Multiple Bruker Tracer III Calibrated Instruments Using Identical Analytical and Operational Procedures: Implications for Past, Present, and Future Obsidian Studies. 78th Annual Meeting, Honolulu, Hawaii, 3-7 April 2013 2013, Society for American Archaeology.
14. Burley D.V., Sheppard P.J., Simonin M. Tongan and Samoan volcanic glass: pXRF analysis and implications for constructs of ancestral Polynesian society. J.Archaeol. Sci. 2011, 38(10):2625-2632.
15. Carmines E.G., Zeller R.A. Reliability and Validity Assessment. Quantitative Applications in the Social Sciences 1979, Sage Publications.
16. Cecil L.G., Moriarity M.D., Speakman R.J., Glascock M.D. Feasibility of field-portable XRF to identify obsidian sources in central Peten, Guatemala. ACS Symposium Series No. 968 2007, 506-521. American Chemical Society, Washington, DC. M.D. Glascock, R.J. Speakman, R.S. Popelka-Filcoff (Eds.).
17. Chataigner C., Badalian R., Bigazzi G., Cauvin M.-C. Provenance studies of obsidian artefacts from armenian archaeological sites using the fission-track dating method. J.Non-Crystalline Solids 2003, 323:172-179.
18. Chataigner C., Gratuze B. New data on the exploitation of obsidian in the southern caucasus (Armenia, Georgia) and eastern Turkey, Part 1: source characterization. Archaeometry 2014, 56:25-47.
19. Chataigner C., Gratuze B. New data on the exploitation of obsidian in the southern caucasus (Armenia, Georgia) and eastern Turkey, Part 2: obsidian procurement from the Upper palaeolithic to the late Bronze age. Archaeometry 2014, 56:48-69.
20. Cheng C.F., Schwitter C.M. Nickel in ancient Bronzes. Am. J. Archaeol. 1957, 61:351-365.
21. Chernyshev I.V., Lebedev V.A., Arakelyants M.M. K-Ar dating of Quaternary volcanics: methodology and interpretation of results. Petrology 2006, 14:62-80.
22. Cherry J.F., Faro E.Z., Minc L. Field survey and geochemical characterization of the southern armenian obsidian sources. J.Field Archaeol. 2010, 35(2):147-163.
23. Church T. Comment on "neutron activation analysis of stone from the Chadron formation and a Clovis site on the Great Plains" by Hoard etal. (1992). J.Archaeol. Sci. 1995, 22:1-5.
24. Clark B.J., Mayo K. Freshmen Sourcing Obsidian? Using PXRF in the Introductory Archaeology Classroom. Society for American Archaeology, 77th Annual Meeting. Memphis, Tennessee, 18-22 April 2012 2012.
25. Conrey R.M., Goodman-Elgar M., Bettencourt N., Seyfarth A., Van Hoose A., Wolff J.A. Calibration of a portable X-ray fluorescence spectrometer in the analysis of archaeological samples using influence coefficients. Geochem. Explor. Environ. Anal. 2014, 10.1144/geochem2013-198.
26. Craig N., Speakman R.J., Popelka-Filcoff R., Glascock M.D., Robertson J., Shackley M.S., Aldenderfer M. Comparison of XRF and PXRF for analysis of archaeological obsidian from southern Perú. J.Archaeol. Sci. 2007, 34:2012-2024.
27. Craig N., Speakman R.J., Popelka-Filcoff R., Aldenderfer M., Blanco L., Vega M., Glascock M.D., Stanish C. Macusani obsidian from southern Peru: a characterization of its elemental composition with a demonstration of its ancient use. J.Archaeol. Sci. 2010, 37:569-576.
28. Dybowski D. pXRF/WDXRFS inter-unit data comparison of Arizona obsidian samples. J.Ariz. Archaeol. 2012, 2:1-7.
29. Forster N., Grave P. Non-destructive PXRF analysis of museum-curated obsidian from the Near East. J.Archaeol. Sci. 2012, 39:728-736.
30. Frahm E. An Evaluation of Portable X-Ray Fluorescence for Artifact Sourcing in the Field: Can a Handheld Device Differentiate Anatolian Obsidian Sources? Session: Sourcing Techniques in Archaeology. Geological Society of America Annual Meeting, Denver, Colorado, 28-31 October 2007.
31. Frahm E. The Bronze-age obsidian industry at Tell Mozan (ancient Urkesh), Syria 2010, Ph.D. dissertation, Department of Anthropology, University of Minnesota, Published online through the University of Minnesota's Digital Conservancy:. http://purl.umn.edu/99753.
32. Frahm E. Evaluation of archaeological sourcing techniques: reconsidering and re-deriving hughes' four-fold assessment scheme. Geoarchaeology 2012, 27(2):166-174.
33. Frahm E. Non-Destructive sourcing of Bronze-age near eastern obsidian artefacts: redeveloping and reassessing electron microprobe analysis for obsidian sourcing. Archaeometry 2012, 54(4):623-642.
34. Frahm E. Validity of "off-the-shelf" handheld portable XRF for sourcing Near Eastern obsidian chip debris. J.Archaeol. Sci. 2013, 40:1080-1092.
35. Frahm E., Doonan R., Kilikoglou V. Handheld portable X-ray fluorescence of aegean obsidians. Archaeometry 2014, 56:228-260.
36. Frahm E., Schmidt B., Gasparyan B., Yeritsyan B., Karapetian S., Meliksetian Kh, Adler D.S. Ten seconds in the field: rapid armenian obsidian sourcing with portable XRF to inform excavations and surveys. J.Archaeol. Sci. 2014, 41:333-348.
37. Gauthier G., Burke A.L. The effects of surface weathering on the geochemical analysis of archaeological lithic samples using non-destructive polarized energy dispersive XRF. Geoarchaeology 2011, 26(2):269-291.
38. Glascock M.D. An inter-laboratory comparison of element compositions for two obsidian sources. Int. Assoc. Obsidian Stud. Bull. 1999, 23:13-25.
39. Glascock M.D. Comparison and contrast between XRF and NAA: used for characterization of Obsidian sources in Central Mexico. X-Ray Fluorescence Spectrometry (XRF) in Geoarchaeology 2011, 161-192. Springer. M.S. Shackley (Ed.).
40. Glascock M.D., Ferguson J.R. Report on the Analysis of Obsidian Source Samples byMultiple Analytical Methods 2012, Archaeometry Laboratory, University of Missouri, January 2012.
41. Glascock M.D., Braswell G., Cobean R.H. ASystematic approach to Obsidian source characterization. Archaeological Obsidian Studies: Method and Theory 1998, 15-65. Society for Archaeological Sciences. M.S. Shackley (Ed.).
42. Glascock M.D., Speakman R.J., Neff H. Archaeometry at the University of Missouri research reactor and the provenance of obsidian Artefacts in North America. Archaeometry 2007, 49(2):343-357.
43. Glauberman P.J., Gasparyan B., Wilkinson K., Frahm E., Raczynski-Henk Y., Adler D.S. Barozh 12: A New Middle Palaeolithic Open-Air Site on the Edge of the Ararat Plain, Armenia. The Role of the Southern Caucasus on Early Human Evolution and Expansion: Refuge, Hub or Source Area? Tbilisi, Georgia, 15-20 October 2013 2013.
44. Goldstein J.I., Newberry D.E., Echlin P., Joy D.C., Fiori C., Lifshin E. Scanning Electron Microscopy and X-ray Microanalysis: a Text for Biologists, Materials Scientists, and Geologists 1981, Plenum Press, New York.
45. Goodale N., Bailey D., Jones G., Prescott C., Scholz E., Stagliano N., Lewis C. pXRF: a study of inter-instrument performance. J.Archaeol. Sci. 2012, 39:875-883.
46. Hancock R.G.V., Carter T. How reliable are our published archaeometric analyses? Effects of analytical techniques through time on the elemental analysis of obsidians. J.Archaeol. Sci. 2010, 37(2):243-250.
47. Heginbotham A., Bezur A., Bouchard M., Davis J.M., Eremin K., Frantz J.H., Glinsman L., Hayek L.-A., Hook D., Kantarelou V., Germanos Karydas A., Lee L., Mass J., Matsen C., McCarthy B., McGath M., Shugar A., Sirois J., Smith D., Speakman R.J. An evaluation of inter-laboratory reproducibility for quantitative XRF of historic copper alloys. Metal 2010. Proceedings of the International Conference on Metal Conservation, Charleston, South Carolina, USA, October 11-15, 2010 2010, 244-255. Clemson University Press. P. Mardikian (Ed.).
48. Hoard R.J., Holen S.R., Glascock M.D., Neff H., Elam J.M. Neutron activation analysis of stone from the Chadron Formation and a Clovis site on the Great Plains. J.Archaeol. Sci. 1992, 19:655-665.
49. Hughes R.E. On reliability, validity, and scale in obsidian sourcing research. Unit Issues in Archaeology: Measuring Time, Space, and Material 1998, 103-114. University of Utah Press. A.F. Ramenofsky, A. Steffen (Eds.).
50. Hughes R.E., Smith R.L. Archaeology, Geology, and Geochemistry of Obsidian Provenance Studies. GSA Special Paper, volume 283 1993, 79-91. Geological Society of America, Boulder, Colorado. J.K. Stein, A.R. Linse (Eds.).
51. Jack R.N., Heizer R.F. "Finger-printing" of some Mesoamerican obsidian artifacts. Contributions of the University of California Archaeological Research Facility 1968, vol. 5:81-100.
52. Jia P., Doelman T., Chen C., Zhao H., Lin S., Torrence R., Glascock M.D. Moving sources: a preliminary study of volcanic glass artifact distributions in northeast China using PXRF. J.Archaeol. Sci. 2010, 37:1670-1677.
53. Jia P., Doelman T., Torrence R., Glascock M.D. New pieces: the acquisition and distribution of volcanic glass sources in northeast China during the Holocene. J.Archaeol. Sci. 2013, 40:971-982.
54. Kandel A.W., Gasparyan B., Frahm E., Taller A., Weissbrod L. Latest Results from Aghitu-3, an Early Upper Paleolithic Cave Site in Armenia. Hugo Obermaier Society for Quaternary Research and Archaeology of the Stone Age Meeting, Vienna, 2-6 April 2013.
55. Kaplan A. The conduct of inquiry: methodology for behavioral science 1964, Chandler Publishing Company, San Francisco.
56. Karapetian S.G., bashian R., Mnatsakanian A. Kh Late collision rhyolitic volcanism in the north-eastern part of the Armenian Highland. J.Volcanol. Geotherm. Res. 2001, 112:189-220.
57. Keller J., Djerbashian E., Pernicka E., Karapetian S., Nasedkin V. Armenian and Caucasian obsidian Occurrences as sources for the neolithic trade: volcanological Setting and chemical characteristics. Archaeometry 94: the Proceedings of the 29th International Symposium on Archaeometry, Ankara, 9-14 May 1994 1996, 69-86.
58. Keller J., Seifried C. The Present Status of obsidian source Identification in anatolia and the near east. PACT 25: volcanology and archaeology. Proceedings of the European Workshops of Ravello 1990, vol. 25:57-87.
59. Kellett L.C., Golitko M., Bauer B.S. Aprovenance study of archaeological obsidian from the Andahuaylas region of southern Peru. J.Archaeol. Sci. 2013, 40:1890-1902.
60. Kilikoglou V., Vekinis G., Maniatis Y., Day P.M. Mechanical performance of quartz-tempered ceramics: part I, strength and toughness. Archaeometry 1998, 40:261-279.
61. Komarov A.N., Skovorodkin N.V., Karapetian S.G. Determination of the age of natural glasses according to tracks of uranium fission fragments. Geochimia 1972, N6:693-698. (in Russian).
62. Lemonnier P. Elements for an Anthropology of Technology. Anthropological Papers Museum of Anthropology 1992, vol. 88. University of Michigan.
63. Leroi-Gourhan A. Gesture and Speech 1993, Translated from Le Geste et la parole [1964] by A.B. Berger, Massachusetts Institute of Technology Press.
64. Liritzis I. Assessment of Aegean obsidian sources by a portable ED-XRF analyser: grouping, provenance and accuracy. Archaeometry Studies in the Aegean: Reviews and Recent Developments 2008, 399-406. Archaeopress, Oxford. Y. Facorellis, N. Zacharias, K. Polikreti, T. Vakoulis, Y. Bassiakos, V. Kiriatzi, E. Aloupi (Eds.).
65. Liritzis I., Zacharias N. Chapter 6: portable XRF of archaeological artifacts: current research, potentials and limitations. X-ray Fluorescence Spectrometry (XRF) in Geoarchaeology 2011, 109-142. Springer. M.S. Shackley (Ed.).
66. Macdonald R., Davies G.R., Bliss C.M., Leat P.T., Bailey D.K., Smith R.L. Geochemistry of high-silica peralkaline rhyolites, Naivasha, Kenya rift valley. J.Petrol. 1987, 28:979-1008.
67. Mahood G.A., Hildreth E.W. Large partition coefficients for trace elements in high-silica rhyolites. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 1983, 47:11-30.
68. Mahood G.A., Stimac J.A. Trace-element partitioning in pantellerites and trachytes. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 1990, 54:2257-2276.
69. Mark H., Workman J. Statistics in Spectroscopy 2003, Elsevier Academic Press. second ed.
70. Mauss M. Techniques of the Body. Econ. Soc. 1973, 2:70-88.
71. McCoy M., Mills P., Lundblad S., Rieth T., Kahn J., Gard R. Acost surface model of volcanic glass quarrying and exchange in Hawai'i. J.Archaeol. Sci. 2011, 38:2547-2560.
72. Millhauser J., Rodríguez-Alegría E., Glascock M.D. Testing the accuracy of portable X-ray fluorescence to study Aztec and Colonial obsidian supply at Xaltocan, Mexico. J.Archaeol. Sci. 2011, 38:3141-3152.
73. Milić M. PXRF characterisation of obsidian from central Anatolia, the Aegean and central Europe. J.Archaeol. Sci. 2014, 41:285-296.
74. Nazaroff A., Prufer K., Drake B. Assessing the applicability of portable X-ray fluorescence spectrometry for obsidian provenance research in the Maya lowlands. J.Archaeol. Sci. 2010, 37:885-895.
75. Oddone M., Bigazzi G., Keheyan Y., Meloni S. Characterisation of armenian Obsidians: implications for raw material supply for Prehistoric artifacts. J.Radioanal. Nucl. Chem. 2000, 243(3):673-682.
76. Reed S.J.B. Electron Microprobe Analysis and Scanning Electron Microscopy in Geology 1996, Cambridge University Press.
77. Rodríguez-Alegría E., Millhauser J.K., Stoner W.D. Trade, tribute, and neutron activation: the colonial political economy of Xaltocan, Mexico. J.Anthropol. Archaeol. 2013, 32:397-414.
78. Scharlotta I. Groundmass microsampling using laser ablation time-of-flight inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (LA-TOF-ICP-MS): potential for rhyolite provenance research. J.Archaeol. Sci. 2010, 37:1929-1941.
79. Shackley M.S. Intrasource chemical variability and secondary depositional processes: lessons from the american southwest. In archaeological obsidian studies: Method and Theory. Advances in Archaeological and Museum Science 3 1998, 82-102. Plenum Press. M.S. Shackley (Ed.).
80. Shackley M.S. Obsidian: Geology and Archaeology in the North American Southwest 2005, University of Arizona.
81. Shackley M.S. Is there reliability and validity in portable X-ray fluorescence spectrometry (PXRF)? The SAA Archaeological Record. Novemb. issue 2010, 17-20.
82. Shackley M.S. An introduction to X-Ray Fluorescence (XRF) analysis in archaeology. X-Ray Fluorescence Spectrometry (XRF) in Geoarchaeology 2011, 7-44. Springer. M.S. Shackley (Ed.).
83. Shackley M.S. Portable X-ray Fluorescence Spectrometry (pXRF): the Good, the Bad, and the Ugly (online essay). Archaeol. Southwest Mag. 2012, 26(Spring issue).
84. Sheppard P., Irwin G., Lin S., McCaffrey C. Characterization of New Zealand obsidian using PXRF. J.Archaeol. Sci. 2011, 38:45-56.
85. Speakman R.J. Evaluation of Bruker's Tracer Family Factory Obsidian Calibration for Handheld Portable XRF Studies of Obsidian 2012, Report Prepared for Bruker AXS, Kennewick, WA.
86. Speakman R.J., Shackley M.S. Commentary: Silo science and portable XRF in archaeology: a Response to Frahm. J.Archaeol. Sci. 2013, 40:1435-1443.
87. Speakman R.J., Little N.C., Creel D., Miller M.R., Iñañe J.G. Sourcing ceramics with portable XRF spectrometers? A comparison with INAA using Mimbres pottery from the American Southwest. J.Archaeol. Sci. 2011, 38:3483-3496.
88. Taylor J.R. Introduction to Error Analysis: the Study of Uncertainties in Physical Measurements 1996, University Science Books. second ed.
89. Taylor B.N., Kuyatt C.E. Guidelines for Evaluating and Expressing the Uncertainty of NIST Measurement Results 1994, NIST Technical Note 1297.
90. Tykot R.H., Lai L., Tozzi C. Intra-site Obsidian subsource patterns at Contraguda, Sardinia (Italy). Proceedings of the 37th International Symposium on Archaeometry 2011, 321-328. Springer. I. Turbanti-Memmi (Ed.).
91. Tykot R.H., Freund K.P., Vianello A. Source analysis of Prehistoric Obsidian Artifacts in Sicily (Italy) using pXRF. Archaeological Chemistry VIII 2013, 195-210. R.A. Armitage, J.H. Burton (Eds.).
92. Tykot R.H., White N.M., Du Vernay J.P., Freeman J.S., Hays C.T., Koppe M., Hunt C.N., Weinstein R.A., Woodward D.S. Advantages and disadvantages of PXRF for archaeological ceramic analysis: prehistoric pottery distribution and trade in NW Florida. ACS Symposium Series 2013, vol. 1147:233-244. American Chemical Society. R.A. Armitage, J.H. Burton (Eds.).
93. Wagner G.A., Weiner K.L. Deutches Archaeologisches Institut Demircihoyuk. Die Ergebenisse des Ausgrabungen 1975-1978. Naturwissenschaftliche Untersuchungen 1987, Band II:26-29. Verlag Philipp von Zabern, Mainz, Germany.
94. Williams P.R., Dussubieux L., Nash D. Provenance of Peruvian Wari obsidian: comparing INAA, LA-ICP-MS, and portable XRF. Obsidian and Ancient Manufactured Glasses 2012, 75-85. University of New Mexico Press. I. Liritzis, C. Stevenson (Eds.).