Contrasting the spatial management of nitrogen and phosphorus for improved water quality: Modelling studies in New Zealand and France

European Journal of Agronomy

Volumn 57, Issue , 2014, Pages 52-61

  McDowell, R W ^a   Moreau, P ^b   Salmon Monviola, J ^b   Durand, P ^b   Leterme, P ^b   Merot, P ^b  

^a INVERMAY AGRICULTURAL CENTRE   (New Zealand)

^b UMR SAS   (France)

Author keywords

Buffer; Cost effectiveness; Critical source area(s); Grassland; Mitigation strategy

Indexed keywords

AGRICULTURAL LAND; AGRICULTURAL PRODUCTION; CATCHMENT; COST-BENEFIT ANALYSIS; ECOLOGICAL MODELING; GRASSLAND; MANAGEMENT PRACTICE; NITROGEN; PHOSPHORUS; SPATIAL ANALYSIS; WATER QUALITY;

FRANCE; NEW ZEALAND;

EID: 84901267108     PISSN: 11610301     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.eja.2013.09.011     Document Type: Article

References (80)

1. Arnold J.G., Allen P.M. Automated methods for estimating baseflow and groundwater recharge from streamflow records. J. Am. Water Resour. Assoc. 1999, 35:411-424.
2. Barlow K., Nash D., Grayson R.B. Phosphorus export at the paddock, farm-section, and whole farm scale on an irrigated dairy farm in south-eastern Australia. Aust. J. Soil Res. 2005, 56:1-9.
3. Beaujouan V., Durand P., Ruiz L., Aurousseau P., Cotteret G. A hydrological model dedicated to topography-based simulation of nitrogen transfer and transformation: rationale and application to the geomorphology-denitrification relationship. Hydrol. Process 2002, 162:493-507.
4. Beven K.J., Kirkby M.J. A physically based, variable contributing area model of basin hydrology. Hydrolog. Sci. Bull. 1979, 24:43-69.
5. Brisson N., Mary B., Ripoche D., Jeuffroy M.H., Ruget F., Nicoullaud B., Gate P., Devienne-Barret F., Antonioletti R., Durr C., Richard G., Beaudoin N., Recous S., Tayot X., Plenet D., Cellier P., Machet J.-M., Meynard J.-M., Delécolle R. STICS: a generic model for the simulation of crops and their water and nitrogen balances. I. Theory and parameterization applied to wheat and corn. Agronomie 1998, 18:311-346.
6. Cellier, P., Durand, P., Hutchings, N., Dragosits, U., Theobald, M., Drouet, J.L., Oenema, Bleeker, A., Breuer, L., Dalgaard, T., Duretz, S., Kros, J., Loubet, B., Olesen, J.E., Mérot, P., Viaud, V., Vries W., d., Sutton, M., 2011. Nitrogen flows and fate in rural landscapes. In: Sutton, M.A., C. M. H., Jan Willem Erisman, Gilles Billen, Albert Bleeker, Peringe Grennfelt, Hans van Grinsven, Bruna Grizzetti (Eds.), The European Nitrogen Assessment Sources, Effects and Policy Perspectives, Cambridge, UK, pp. 229-248.
7. Cheverry C. Agriculture intensive et qualité des eaux 1998, INRA, Paris, France.
8. Curran Cournane F., McDowell R.W., Littlejohn R., Condron L. Effects of cattle, sheep and deer grazing on soil physical quality and losses of phosphorus and suspended sediment losses in surface runoff. Agric. Ecosyst. Environ. 2011, 140:264-272.
9. de Klein C.A.M., Ledgard S.F. An analysis of environmental and economic implications of nil and restricted grazing systems designed to reduce nitrate leaching from New Zealand dairy farms. I. Nitrogen losses. N. Zeal. J. Agric. Res. 2001, 44:201-215.
10. Di H.J., Cameron K.C. Reducing environmental impacts of agriculture by using a fine particle suspension nitrification inhibitor to decrease nitrate leaching from grazed pastures. Agric. Ecosyst. Environ. 2005, 109:202-212.
11. Durand. P., Ferchaud, F., Salmon-Monviola, J., Goetschel, F., Martin C., 2006. Etude sur l'évolution des paramètres nitrates dans les eaux brutes des bassins versants Bretagne Eau Pure et des autres bassins versants bretons. Démarche Evaluation Programme Bretagne Eau Pure, Rapport INRA, France.
12. European Commission, 2012. Glossary: Livestock unit (LSU). Available at: (accessed January, 2012). http://epp.eurostat.ec.europa.eu/statistics_explained/index.php/Glossary%3ALSU.
13. Ferrant S., Oehler F., Durand P., Ruiz L., Salmon-Monviola J., Justes E., Dugast P., Probst A., Probst J.-L., Sanchez-Perez J.-M. Understanding nitrogen transfer dynamics in a small agricultural catchment: comparison of a distributed (TNT2) and a semi distributed (SWAT) modeling approaches. J. Hydol. 2011, 406:1-15.
14. Fleming P.H. Farm Technical Manual 2003, Lincoln University, Canterbury, New Zealand.
15. Gburek W.L., Sharpley A.N., Pionke H.B. Identification of critical sources for phosphorus export from agricultural catchments. Advances in Hillslope Processes 1996, 263-282. Wiley, Chichester, UK. M.G. Anderson, S.M. Brooks (Eds.).
16. Gillingham A.G., Gray M.G. Measurement and modelling of runoff and phosphate movement from seasonally dry hill-country pastures. N. Z. J. Agric. Res. 2006, 49:233-245.
17. Hanly J.A., Hedley M.J., Horne D.J. Evaluation of tephra for removing phosphorus from dairy farm drainage waters. Aust. J. Soil Res. 2008, 46:542-551.
18. Haycock N.E., Burt T.P., Goulding K.W.T., Pinay G. Buffer Zones: Their Processes and Potential in Water Protection 1997, Quest Environmental, Hertfordshire, UK.
19. Headley T.R., Tanner C.C. Floating Wetlands for Stormwater Treatment: Removal of Copper, Zinc and Fine Particulates 2007, Technical Publication, Auckland Regional Council, New Zealand.
20. Heathwaite L., Sharpley A.N., Gburek W. A conceptual approach for integrating phosphorus and nitrogen management at watershed scales. J. Environ. Qual. 2000, 29:158-166.
21. Hefting M., Beltman B., Karssenberg D., Rebel K., van Riessen M., Spijker M. Water quality dynamics and hydrology in nitrate loaded riparian zones in the Netherlands. Environ. Pollut. 2006, 139:143-156.
22. Henault C., Germon J.C. NEMIS, a predictive model of denitrification on the field scale. Eur. J. Soil Sci. 2000, 512:257-270.
23. Hoogendoorn C.J., Betteridge K., Ledgard S.F., Costall D.A., Park Z.A., Theobald P.W. Nitrogen leaching from sheep-, cattle- and deer-grazed pastures in the Lake Taupo catchment in New Zealand. Anim. Prod. Sci. 2011, 51:416-425.
24. Houlbrooke D.J., Carey P., Williams R. Management practices to minimize wipe-off losses from border dyke irrigated land. Carbon and Nutrient Management in Agriculture. Occasional report No 21 2008, 249-255. Fertilizer and Lime Research Centre, Massey University, Palmerston North, New Zealand. L.D. Currie, L.J. Yates (Eds.).
25. Houlbrooke D.J., Horne D.J., Hedley M.J., Snow V.O., Hanly J.A. Land application of farm dairy effluent to a mole and pipe drained soil: implications for nutrient enrichment of winter-spring drainage. Aust. J. Soil Res. 2008, 46:45-52.
26. Hudson H.R. Development of an in-channel coarse sediment trap best management practice. Environmental Management Associates Ltd Report 2002-10 2002, Ministry of Agriculture and Forestry Project FRM500, Available at:, (accessed 1 September, 2012). http://www.landcare.org.nz/files/file/177/in-channel-sediment-traps-2002.pdf.
27. James E., Kleinman P., Stedman R., Sharpley A. Phosphorus contributions from pastured dairy cattle to streams of the Cannonsville Watershed, New York. J. Soil Water Conser. 2007, 62:40-47.
28. Johnes P.J. Uncertainties in annual riverine phosphorus load estimation: Impact of load estimation methodology, sampling frequency, baseflow index and catchment population density. J. Hydrol. 2007, 332:241-258.
29. Johnes P.J., O'Sullivan P.E. The natural history of Slapton Ley nature reserve. Nitrogen and phosphorus losses from the catchment: an export coefficient approach. Field Stud. 1989, 7:285-309.
30. Ledgard S.F., Penno J.W., Sprosen M.S. Nitrogen inputs and losses from clover/grass pastures grazed by dairy cows, as affected by nitrogen fertilizer application. J. Agric. Sci. 1999, 132:215-225.
31. Line D.E. Changes in land use/management and water quality in the Long Creek watershed. J. Am. Water Resour. Assoc. 2002, 38:1691-1701.
32. Liu J., Aronsson H., Blombäck K., Persson K., Bergström L. Long-term measurements and model simulations of phosphorus leaching from a manured sandy soil. J. Soil Water Conserv. 2012, 67:101-110.
33. Longhurst B. On-farm mitigations to prevent phosphate movement to Lake Rerewhakaaitu. Report prepared for SFF/DairyNZ 2009, Ruakura Research Centre, Hamilton, New Zealand.
34. Maag M., Vinther F.O. Nitrous oxide emission by nitrification and denitrification in different soil types and at different soil moisture contents and temperatures. Appl. Soil Ecol. 1996, 4:5-14.
35. McDowell R.W. Water quality in headwater catchments with deer wallows. J. Environ. Qual. 2007, 36:1377-1382.
36. McDowell R.W. Assessment of altered steel melter slag and P-socks to remove phosphorus from streamflow and runoff from lanes. Report to Environment B.O.P., Land & Environmental Management Group 2007, AgResearch, Invermay Agricultural Centre, Private Bag 50034, Mosgiel, New Zealand.
37. McDowell R.W. Water quality of a stream recently fenced-off from deer. N. Z. J. Agric. Res. 2008, 51:291-298.
38. McDowell R.W. The use of alternative wallows to improve water quality in deer farmed catchments. N. Z. J. Agric. Res. 2008, 52:81-90.
39. McDowell R.W. Maintaining good water and soil quality in agricultural catchments in New Zealand that contain deer farms. J. River Basin Res. 2009, 7:187-195.
40. McDowell R.W. Evaluation of two management options to improve the water quality of Lake Brunner, New Zealand. N. Z. J. Agric. Res. 2010, 53:59-69.
41. McDowell R.W., Drewry J.J., Muirhead R.W., Paton R.J. Cattle treading and phosphorus and sediment loss in overland flow from grazed cropland. Aust. J. Soil Res. 2003, 41:1521-1532.
42. McDowell R.W., Drewry J.J., Muirhead R.W., Paton R.J. Restricting cattle treading to decrease phosphorus and sediment loss in overland flow from grazed cropland. Aust. J. Soil Res. 2005, 43:61-66.
43. McDowell R.W., Drewry J.J., Paton R.J. Effects of Deer and fence-line pacing on water and soil quality. Soil Use Manage. 2004, 20:302-307.
44. McDowell R.W., Hawke M., McIntosh J.J. Assessment of a technique to remove phosphorus from streamflow. N. Z. J. Agric. Res. 2007, 50:503-510.
45. McDowell R.W., Houlbrooke D.J. Management options to decrease phosphorus and sediment losses from irrigated cropland grazed by cattle and sheep. Soil Use Manage. 2009, 25:224-233.
46. McDowell R.W., Houlbrooke D.J., Muirhead R.W., Müller K., Shepherd M., Cuttle S.P. Grazed Pasture and Surface Water Quality 2008, NOVA Science Publications, Inc, New York.
47. McDowell R.W., Larned S.T., Houlbrooke D.J. Nitrogen and phosphorus in New Zealand streams and rivers: control and impact of eutrophication and the influence of land management. N. Zeal. J. Mar. Freshw. Res. 2009, 43:985-995.
48. McDowell R.W., Littlejohn R.P., Blennerhassett J.D. Phosphorus fertiliser form affects phosphorus loss to waterways: a paired catchment study. Soil Use Manage. 2010, 26:365-373.
49. McDowell R.W., McGrouther N., Morgan G., Srinivasan M.S., Stevens D.R., Johnson M., Copland R. Environmentally sustainable deer farming: the Otago and Southland deer focus farms. Proc. N. Zeal. Grass. Assoc. 2006, 68:183-188.
50. McDowell R.W., Monaghan R.M., Morton J. Soil phosphorus concentrations to minimize potential P loss to surface waters in Southland. N. Zeal. J. Agric. Res. 2003, 46:239-254.
51. McDowell R.W., Sharpley A.N., Bourke B. Treatment of drainage water with industrial by-products to prevent phosphorus loss from tile-drained land. J. Environ. Qual. 2008, 37:1575-1582.
52. McDowell R.W., Smith L.C. Potential water quality impact and agronomic effectiveness of different phosphorus fertilisers under grazed dairying in Southland. Proc. N. Zeal. Grass. Assoc. 2012, 74:225-229.
53. McDowell R.W., Srinivasan M.S. Identifying critical source areas for water quality: 2. Validating the approach for phosphorus and sediment losses in grazed headwater catchments. J. Hydrol. 2009, 379:68-80.
54. McDowell R.W., Stevens D.R., Cave V., Paton R.J., Johnson M. Effects of trees on fence-line pacing of deer and associated impacts on water and soil quality. Soil Use Manage. 2006, 22:158-164.
55. McKergow L., Taylo A., Stace C., Costley K., Timpany G., Paterson J. Landscape grass filter strips in the Rotorua Lakes catchment. Designing Sustainable Farms: Critical Aspects of Soil and Water Management, Occasional Report No. 20 2007, 322-330. Fertilizer and Lime Research Centre, Massey University, Palmerston North, New Zealand. L.D. Currie, L.J. Yates (Eds.).
56. McKergow L.A., Tanner C.C., Monaghan R.M., Anderson G. Stocktake of diffuse pollution attenuation tools for New Zealand pastoral farming systems. Report HAM2007-161, Prepared for Pastoral 21 Research Consortium 2007, National Institute of Water and Atmospheric Research, Hamilton, New Zealand.
57. Moreau P., Ruiz L., Mabon F., Raimbault T., Durand P., Delaby L., Devienne S., Vertès F. Reconciling technical, economic and environmental efficiency of farming systems in vulnerable areas. Agric. Ecosyst. Environ. 2012, 147:89-99.
58. Moreau P., Ruiz L., Raimbault T., Vertès F., Cordier M.O., Gascuel-Odoux C., Masson V., Salmon-Monviola J., Durand P. Modeling the potential benefits of catch-crop introduction in fodder crop rotations inWestern Europe landscape. Sci. Tot. Environ. 2012, (in press).
59. Morton J., Roberts A. Fertiliser use on New Zealand sheep and Beef Farms 2009, New Zealand Fertiliser Manufacturers' Research Association, Auckland, New Zealand.
60. Nash D.M. Phosphorus transfer from land to water in pasture-based grazing systems, PhD Thesis 2002, 215. Institute of Land and Food Resources, University of Melbourne, Melbourne, Australia.
61. Nguyen M.L., Downes M.T., Mehlhorn J., Stroud M.J. Riparian wetland processing of nitrogen, phosphorus and suspended sediment inputs from a hill country sheep-grazed catchment in New Zealand. Second Australian Stream Management Proceedings: The Challenge of Rehabilitating Australia's Streams 1999, 481-485. I. Rutherford, R. Bartly (Eds.).
62. Oehler F., Bordenave P., Durand P. Variations of denitritication in a farming catchment area. Agric. Ecosyst. Environ. 2007, 120:313-324.
63. Olsen S.R., Cole C.V., Watanabe F.S., Dean L.A. Estimation of available phosphorus in soils by extraction with sodium bicarbonate, United States Department of Agriculture Circular No. 939 1954, United States Government Print Office, Washington, D.C., USA.
64. Otago Regional Council GrowOtago climate and soils maps 2004, Otago Regional Council Limited, Dunedin, New Zealand, Available at:, (accessed January 2012). http://www.govt.orc.nz/.
65. Pain B., Menzi H. Glossary of terms on livestock and manure management, Recycling Agricultural, Municipal and Industrial Residues in Agriculture Network 2003, Available at:, (accessed 1 September 2012). http://www.ramiran.net/DOC/Glossary2003.pdf.
66. Redding M.R., Welten B., Kear M. Enhancing the P trapping of pasture filter strips: successes and pitfalls in the use of water supply residue and polyacrylamide. Eur. J. Soil Sci. 2008, 59:257-264.
67. Rowe E.C., Evans C.D., Emmett B.A., Reynolds B., Helliwell R.C., Coull M.C., Curtis C.J. Vegetation type affects the relationship between soil carbon to nitrogen ratio and nitrogen leaching. Water Air Soil Pollut. 2006, 177:335-347.
68. Schneiderman E.M., Steenhuis T.S., Thongs D.J., Easton Z.M., Zion M.S., Mendoza G.F., Walter M.T., Neal A.C. Incorporating variable source area hydrology into curve number based watershed loading functions. Hydrol. Process. 2007, 21:3420-3430.
69. Sharpley A.N., Syers J.K. Effect of aerial topdressing with superphosphate on the loss of phosphate from a pasture catchment. N. Z. J. Agric. Res. 1979, 22:273-277.
70. Smith C.M. Riparian pasture retirement effects on sediment, phosphorus, and nitrogen in channelised surface run-off from pastures. N. Z. J. Mar. Freshw. Res. 1989, 23:139-146.
71. Srinivasan M.S., McDowell R.W. Identifying critical source areas for water quality: 1. Mapping and validating transport areas in three headwater catchments in Otago, New Zealand. J. Hydrol. 2009, 379:54-67.
72. Summers R. The use of red mud residue from alumina refining to reduce phosphorus leaching and increase yield potential on sandy soils, PhD Thesis 2001, University of Western Australia, Australia.
73. Summers R., Rivers M., Clarke M. The use of bauxite residue to control diffuse pollution on Western Australia - a win-win-win outcome. Proc. 6th Int Alumina Quality Workshop, Brisbane 2002, 262-269. Available at http://www.ecohydrology.uwa.edu.au/__data/page/135438/Summers,_Rivers_&_Clarke_(2002)_The_use_of_bauxite_residue_1.pdf (accessed January, 2011).
74. Summers R., Smirk D., Karafilis D. Phosphorus retention and leachate from sandy soil amended with bauxite residue (red mud). Aust. J. Soil Res. 1996, 34:555-567.
75. Tanner C.C., Nguyen M.L., Sukias J.P.S. Nutrient removal by a constructed wetland treating subsurface drainage from grazed dairy pasture. Agric. Ecosyst. Environ. 2005, 105:145-162.
76. Viaud V., Durand P., Merot Ph., Sauboua E., Saadi Z. Modeling the impact of the spatial structure of a hedge network on the hydrology of a small temperate catchment. Agric. Water Manage. 2005, 74:135-163.
77. Vlahos S., Summers K.J., Bell D.T., Gilkes R.J. Reducing phosphorus leaching from sand soils with red mud bauxite processing residues. Aust. J. Soil Res. 1989, 27:651-662.
78. Ward R.C. On the response to precipitation of headwater streams in humid areas. J. Hydrol. 1984, 74:171-189.
79. 3 extracts from soil. Soil Soc. Am. Proc. 1965, 29:677-678.
80. Wilcock R.J., Biggs B.J.F., Death R., Hickey D., Larned S., Quinn J. Limiting nutrients for controlling undesirable periphyton growth. NIWA Client Report HAM2007-006 2007, National Institute of Water and Atmospheric Research Ltd, Hamilton, New Zealand.