Is recursion language-specific? Evidence of recursive mechanisms in the structure of intentional action

Consciousness and Cognition

Volumn 26, Issue 1, 2014, Pages 169-188

  Vicari, Giuseppe ^a,b   Adenzato, Mauro ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF TURIN   (Italy)

^b UNIVERSITY OF PALERMO   (Italy)

Author keywords

Action grammar; Basal ganglia; Causal self referentiality; Communicative intention; Infinite generativity; Intentional action; Linguistic recursion; Motor intentional recursion; Self embedding

Indexed keywords

ARTICLE; HUMAN; LANGUAGE; LINGUISTICS; NEUROSCIENCE; PSYCHOLOGY; RECURSION LANGUAGE; SENSORIMOTOR FUNCTION; BEHAVIOR; LOGIC; MOTOR ACTIVITY; PHYSIOLOGY; THINKING;

HUMANS; INTENTION; LANGUAGE; LOGIC; MOTOR ACTIVITY; THINKING;

EID: 84901188117     PISSN: 10538100     EISSN: 10902376     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.concog.2014.03.010     Document Type: Article

References (123)

1. Abe K., Watanabe D. Songbirds possess the spontaneous ability to discriminate syntactic rules. Nature Neuroscience 2011, 14:1067-1074.
2. Adenzato M., Bucciarelli M. Recognition of mistakes and deceits in communicative interactions. Journal of Pragmatics 2008, 40:608-629.
3. Adenzato M., Garbarini F. The As If in cognitive science, neuroscience and anthropology: A journey among robots, blacksmiths, and neurons. Theory and Psychology 2006, 16:747-759.
4. Airenti G., Bara B.G., Colombetti M. Conversation and behavior games in the pragmatics of dialogue. Cognitive Science 1993, 17:197-256.
5. Aldridge J.W., Berridge K.C., Herman M., Zimmer L. Neuronal coding of serial order: Syntax of grooming in the neostriatum. Psychological Science 1993, 4:391-393.
6. Alexander M.P., Naeser M.A., Palumbo C.L. Correlations of subcortical CT lesions sites and aphasia profiles. Brain 1987, 110:961-991.
7. Anderson J. A notional theory of syntactic categories 1997, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
8. Arbib M.A. From monkey-like action recognition to human language: An evolutionary framework for neurolinguistics. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 2005, 28:105-167.
9. Austin J.L. How to do things with words 1962, Oxford University Press, Oxford.
10. Bach K., Harnish R.M. Linguistic communication and speech acts 1979, MIT Press, Cambridge, MA.
11. Bahlmann J., Schubotz R.I., Friederici A.D. Hierarchical sequencing engages Broca's area. NeuroImage 2008, 42:525-534.
12. Bahlmann J., Schubotz R.I., Mueller J.L., Koester D., Friederici A.D. Neural circuits of hierarchical visuo-spatial sequence processing. Brain Research 2009, 1298:161-170.
13. Bara B.G. Cognitive pragmatics 2010, MIT Press, Cambridge, MA.
14. Bara B.G., Ciaramidaro A., Walter H., Adenzato M. Intentional minds: A philosophical analysis of intention tested through fMRI experiments involving people with schizophrenia, people with autism, and healthy individuals. Frontiers in Human Neuroscience 2011, 5(7):1-11.
15. Bayne T., Levy N. The feeling of doing: Deconstructing the phenomenology of agency. Disorders of volition 2006, 49-68. MIT Press, Cambridge, MA. N. Sebanz, W. Prinz (Eds.).
16. Bedny M., Caramazza A. Perception, action, and word meanings in the human brain: The case from action verbs. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences 2011, 1224:81-95.
17. Berridge K.C., Whitshaw I.Q. Cortex, striatum, and cerebellum: Control of serial order in a grooming sequence. Experimental Brain Research 1992, 90:275-290.
18. Bloomfield T.C., Gentner T.Q., Margoliash D. What birds have to say about language. Nature Neuroscience 2011, 14:947-948.
19. Brattico P. Recursion hypothesis considered as a research program in cognitive science. Minds and Machines 2010, 20:213-241.
20. Chisholm R. Freedom and action. Freedom and determinism 1966, 11-44. Random House, New York. K. Lehrer (Ed.).
21. Chomsky N. Syntactic structures 1957, Mouton, The Hague.
22. Chomsky N. The minimalist program 1995, MIT Press, Cambridge, MA.
23. Chomsky N. The architecture of language 2000, Oxford University Press, Oxford.
24. Chomsky N. Some simple evo devo theses: How true they might be for language?. The evolution of human language. Biological perspectives 2010, 45-62. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge. R.K. Larson, V. Deprez, H. Yamakido (Eds.).
25. Christiansen M.H., MacDonald M.C. A usage-based approach to recursion in sentence processing. Language Learning 2009, 59:126-161.
26. Clark A. Being there: Putting brain, body and world together again 1997, MIT Press, Cambridge, MA.
27. Clerget E., Andres M., Olivier E. Deficit in complex sequence processing after a virtual lesion of left BA45. PLoS ONE 2013, 8(6):e63722.
28. Clerget E., Badets A., Duqué J., Olivier E. Role of Broca's area in motor sequence programming: A cTBS study. NeuroReport 2011, 22:965-969.
29. Clerget E., Poncin W., Fadiga L., Olivier E. Role of Broca's area in implicit motor skill learning: Evidence from continuous theta-burst magnetic stimulation. Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience 2012, 24:80-92.
30. Clerget E., Winderickx A., Fadiga L., Olivier E. Role of Brocas area in encoding sequential human actions: A virtual lesion study. NeuroReport 2009, 20:1496-1499.
31. Corballis M. Recursion, language, and starlings. Cognitive Science 2007, 31:697-704.
32. Corballis M. The recursive mind. The origins of human language, thought, and civilization 2011, Princeton University Press, Princeton/Oxford.
33. Davidson D. Freedom to act. Essays on actions and events 1980, 63-81. Oxford University Press, Oxford. D. Davidson (Ed.).
34. D'Esposito M.A., Alexander M.P. Subcortical aphasia: Distinct profiles following left putaminal hemorrhage. Neurology 1995, 45:38-41.
35. Di Lorenzo Ajello F. Mente, azione e linguaggio nel pensiero di John R. Searle 2001, Franco Angeli, Milano.
36. Dronkers N.F., Shapiro J.K., Redfern B., Knight R.T. The role of Broca's area in Broca's aphasia. Journal of Clinical and Experimental Neuropsychology 1992, 14:52-53.
37. Edelman G. The remembered present: A biological theory of consciousness 1989, Basic Books, New York.
38. Elman J.L. Finding structure in time. Cognitive Science 1990, 14:179-211.
39. Enrici I., Adenzato M., Cappa S., Bara B.G., Tettamanti M. Intention processing in communication: A common brain network for language and gestures. Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience 2011, 23:2415-2431.
40. Fazio P., Cantagallo A., Craighero L., D'Ausilio A., Roy A.C., Pozzo T., et al. Encoding of human action in Broca's area. Brain 2009, 132:1980-1988.
41. Fitch W.T. Three meanings of "recursion": Key distinctions for biolinguistics. The evolution of human language. Biological perspectives 2010, 73-90. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge. R.K. Larson, V. Deprez, H. Yamakido (Eds.).
42. Fitch W.T., Friederici A.D. Artificial grammar learning meets formal language theory: An overview. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 2012, 367:1933-1955.
43. Fitch W.T., Hauser M.D. Computational constraints on syntactic processing in a nonhuman primate. Science 2004, 303:377-380.
44. Fitch W.T., Hauser M.D., Chomsky N. The evolution of the language faculty: Clarifications and implications. Cognition 2005, 97:179-210.
45. Friederici A.D., Bahlmann J., Friedrich R., Makuuchi M. The neural basis of recursion and complex syntactic hierarchy. Biolinguistics 2011, 5:87-104.
46. Gallese V., Sinigaglia C. The bodily self as power for action. Neuropsychologia 2010, 48:746-755.
47. Garbarini F., Adenzato M. At the root of embodied cognition: Cognitive science meets neuropsychology. Brain and Cognition 2004, 56:100-106.
48. Gentner T.Q., Fenn K.M., Margoliash D., Nusbaum H.C. Recursive syntactic pattern learning by songbirds. Nature 2006, 440:1204-1207.
49. Geschwind N. The apraxias: Neural mechanisms of disorders of learned movement. American Scientist 1975, 63:188-195.
50. Goldin-Meadow S. The role of gesture in communication and thinking. Trends in Cognitive Science 1999, 9:419-429.
51. Goldin-Meadow S. Hearing gesture: How our hands help us to think 2003, Belknap, Cambridge, MA.
52. Goldin-Meadow S., Singer M.A. From children's hands to adults' ears: Gesture's role in the learning process. Developmental Psychology 2003, 39:509-520.
53. Goldin-Meadow S., Wagner S.M. How our hands help us learn. Trends in Cognitive Science 2005, 9:234-241.
54. Greenfield P. Language, tools and brain: The ontogeny and phylogeny of hierarchically organized sequential behavior. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 1991, 14:531-595.
55. Grice P.H. Studies in the way of words 1989, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA.
56. Hauser M.D., Chomsky N., Fitch W.T. The faculty of language: What is it, who has it, and how did it evolve?. Science 2002, 298:1569-1579.
57. Hickok G. Eight problems for the mirror neuron theory of action understanding in monkeys and humans. Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience 2009, 21:1229-1243.
58. Hochmann J.-R., Azadpour M., Mehler J. Do humans really learn AnBn artificial grammars from exemplars?. Cognitive Science 2008, 32:1021-1036.
59. Hurley S. Consciousness in action 1998, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA.
60. Iacoboni M., Molnar-Szakacs I., Gallese V., Buccino G., Mazziotta J.C., Rizzolatti G. Grasping the intentions of others with one's own mirror neuron system. PLoS Biology 2005, 3:529-535.
61. Jackendoff R. Précis of "Foundations of language: Brain, meaning, grammar, evolution". Behavioral and Brain Sciences 2003, 26:651-665.
62. Jackendoff R., Pinker S. The nature of the language faculty and its implications for evolution of language (Reply to Fitch, Hauser, and Chomsky). Cognition 2005, 97:211-225.
63. Karlsson F. Recursion and iteration. Recursion and human language 2011, 43-67. De Gruyter, Berlin/New York. H. van der Hulst (Ed.).
64. Koechlin E., Jubault T. Broca's area and the hierarchical organization of human behavior. Neuron 2006, 50:963-974.
65. Lashley K.S. The problem of serial order in behavior. Cerebral mechanisms in behavior. The Hixon symposium 1951, 112-146. Wiley, New York. L.A. Jeffress (Ed.).
66. Lau H.C., Rogers R.D., Passingham R.E. Manipulating the experienced onset of intention after action execution. Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience 2007, 19:81-90.
67. Laury R., Ono T. Recursion in conversation: What speakers of Finnish and Japanese know how to do. Recursion and human language 2011, 43-67. De Gruyter, Berlin/New York. H. van der Hulst (Ed.).
68. Libet B. Unconscious cerebral initiative and the role of conscious will in voluntary action. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 1985, 8:529-566.
69. Libet B., Gleason C.A., Wright E.W., Pearl D.K. Time of conscious intention to act in relation to onset of cerebral activity (readiness-potential). The unconscious initiation of a freely voluntary act. Brain 1983, 106:623-642.
70. Lieberman P. Toward an evolutionary biology of language 2006, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA.
71. Lieberman P. The creative capacity of language, in what manner is it unique, and who had it?. The evolution of human language. Biological perspectives 2010, 163-175. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge. R.K. Larson, V. Deprez, H. Yamakido (Eds.).
72. Lobina D.J. Recursion and the competence/performance distinction in AGL tasks. Language and Cognitive Processes 2011, 26:1563-1586.
73. Luuk E., Luuk H. The redundancy of recursion and infinity for natural language. Cognitive Processing 2011, 12:1-11.
74. Makuuchi M., Bahlmann J., Anwander A., Friederici A.D. Segregating the core computational faculty of human language from working memory. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 2009, 106:8362-8367.
75. Marr D. Vision 1982, Freeman, San Francisco.
76. Martins M. Distinctive signatures of recursion. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 2012, 367:2055-2064.
77. Martins M., Fitch W.T. Fractal geometry and visual recursion 2011, University of Vienna, Vienna.
78. Mele A. Effective intentions: The power of conscious will 2009, Oxford University Press, Oxford.
79. Mengotti P., Corradi-Dell'Acqua C., Negri G.A.L., Ukmar M., Pesavento V., Rumiati R.I. Selective imitation impairments differentially interact with language processing. Brain 2013, 136:2602-2618.
80. Merleau-Ponty, M. (1962). Phenomenology of perception (C. Smith, Trans.). London: Routledge (Original work published 1945).
81. Miller G.A., Galanter E., Pribram K.H. Plans and the structure of behavior 1960, Holt, Rinehart and Winston, New York.
82. Monchi O., Petrides M., Petre V., Worsley K., Dagher A. Wisconsin card sorting test revisited: Distinct neural circuits participating in different stages of the task identified by event-related functional magnetic resonance imaging. Journal of Neuroscience 2001, 21:7733-7741.
83. Noë A. Action in perception 2004, MIT Press, Cambridge, MA.
84. Papagno C., Della Sala S., Basso A. Ideomotor apraxia without aphasia and apraxia without apraxia: The anatomical support for a double dissociation. Journal of Neurology, Neurosurgery, and Psychiatry 1993, 56:286-289.
85. Pastra K., Aloimonos Y. The minimalist grammar of action. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 2012, 367:103-117.
86. Perruchet P., Rey A. Does the mastery of center-embedded linguistic structures distinguish humans from nonhuman primates?. Psychonomic Bulletin and Review 2005, 12:307-313.
87. Piaget J. Biology and knowledge 1971, University of Chicago Press, Chicago, (Original work published 1967).
88. Piaget J. The principles of genetic epistemology 1972, Basic Books, New York, (Original work published 1950).
89. Piattelli-Palmarini M. What is language, that it may have evolved, and what is evolution, that it may apply to language. The evolution of human language. Biological perspectives 2010, 148-162. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge. R.K. Larson, V. Deprez, H. Yamakido (Eds.).
90. Pinker S. The language instinct: The new science of language and mind 1994, Penguin Books, London/New York.
91. Pinker S., Jackendoff R. The faculty of language: What's special about it?. Cognition 2005, 95:201-236.
92. Plunkett K., Bandelow S. Stochastic approaches to understanding dissociations in inflectional morphology. Brain and Language 2006, 98:194-209.
93. Rizzolatti G., Sinigaglia C. Mirrors in the brain. How our minds share actions and emotions 2008, Oxford University Press, Oxford.
94. Sartori L., Becchio C., Bara B.G., Castiello U. Does the intention to communicate affect action kinematics?. Consciousness and Cognition 2009, 18:766-772.
95. Schreuder M., Gilbers D., Quené H. Recursion in phonology. Lingua 2009, 119:1243-1252.
96. Searle J.R. Speech acts 1969, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
97. Searle J.R. Expression and meaning 1979, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
98. Searle J.R. Intentionality 1983, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
99. Searle J.R. Response to Brian O'Shaughnessy. John Searle and His Critics 1991, 295-299. Blackwell, Oxford. E. Lepore, R. Van Gulick (Eds.).
100. Searle J.R. Rationality in action 2001, MIT Press, Cambridge, MA.
101. Searle, J. R. (2006). What is language: Some preliminary remarks. In G. Abel (Ed.), Kreativität (Kolloquienbeiträge). XX. Deutscher Kongreß für Philosophie (pp. 1223-1248). Berlin: Felix Meiner Verlag.
102. Searle J.R. Coscienza, linguaggio, società 2009, Rosenberg & Sellier, Torino.
103. Shallice T. From neuropsychology to mental structure 1988, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
104. Soon C.S., Brass M., Heinze H.-J., Haynes J.-D. Unconscious determinants of free decisions in the human brain. Nature Neuroscience 2008, 11:543-545.
105. Stowe L.A., Paans A.M.J., Wijers A.A., Zwarts F. Activation of motor and other non-language structures during sentence comprehension. Brain and Language 2004, 89:290-299.
106. Stuss D.T., Benson D.F. The frontal lobes 1986, Raven Press, New York.
107. Tempia F. Decisioni libere e giudizi morali: la mente conta. Siamo davvero liberi? Le neuroscienze e il mistero del libero arbitrio 2010, 87-108. Codice, Torino. M. De Caro, A. Lavazza, G. Sartori (Eds.).
108. Tettamanti M., Weniger D. Broca's area: A supramodal hierarchical processor?. Cortex 2006, 42:491-494.
109. Tomalin M. Reconsidering recursion in syntactic theory. Lingua 2007, 117:1784-1800.
110. Tomasello M. Origins of human communication 2008, MIT Press, Cambridge, MA.
111. Traxler M.J., Boudewyn M., Loudermilk J. What's special about human language? The contents of the "Narrow Language Faculty" revisited. Linguistics and Language Compass 2012, 6:611-621.
112. Umiltà M.A., Kohler E., Gallese V., Fogassi L., Fadiga L., Keysers C., et al. 'I know what you are doing': A neurophysiological study. Neuron 2001, 32:91-101.
113. van der Hulst H. Re recursion. Recursion and human language 2011, xv-liii. De Gruyter, Berlin/New York. H. van der Hulst (Ed.).
114. van Heijningen C.A.A., de Visser J., Zuidema W., ten Cate C. Simple rules can explain discrimination of putative recursive syntactic structures by a songbird species. Proceedings of the National Academy of Science of the United States of America 2009, 106:20538-20543.
115. Varela F., Thompson E., Rosch E. The embodied mind: Cognitive science and human experience 1991, MIT Press, Cambridge, MA.
116. Vicari, G. (2008a). Incorporazione non riduttiva e autoreferenzialità causale. Note per una concezione realista del sé nella filosofia della mente di John R. Searle e nella teoria neurobiologica della coscienza di A. Damasio. In F. Di Lorenzo Ajello (Ed.), Razionalità, verità e mente [Rationality, truth and mind] (pp. 207-220). Milano: Mondadori.
117. Vicari G. Beyond conceptual dualism. Ontology of consciousness, mental causation, and holism in John R. Searle's philosophy of mind 2008, Rodopi, Amsterdam/New York.
118. Vicari G. The self between vehicle-externalism and the myth of the Cartesian theatre, Teorema. International Journal of Philosophy 2011, 30:111-128.
119. Wegner D.M. The illusion of conscious will 2002, MIT Press, Cambridge, MA.
120. Wegner D.M., Wheatley T. Apparent mental causation: Sources of the experience of will. American Psychologist 1999, 54:480-492.
121. Weiskrantz L. Varieties of residual experience. The Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology 1980, 32:365-386.
122. Weiskrantz L. Prime-sight and blindsight. Consciousness and Cognition 2002, 11:568-581.
123. Zimmerer V., Varley R.A. Recursion in severe agrammatism. Recursion and human language 2010, 393-405. De Gruyter, Berlin/New York. H. van der Hulst (Ed.).