Revisiting the fit-performance thesis half a century later: A historical financial analysis of Chandler's own matched and mismatched firms

Business History

Volumn 56, Issue 3, 2014, Pages 341-371

  Aupperle, Kenneth E ^a   Acar, William ^b   Mukherjee, Debmalya ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF AKRON   (United States)

^b KENT STATE UNIVERSITY   (United States)

Author keywords

Chandler's thesis; fit performance thesis; SSP paradigm; strategy and structure

Indexed keywords

CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK; ECONOMIC ANALYSIS; ECONOMIC THEORY; FINANCIAL SYSTEM; HISTORICAL PERSPECTIVE; INDUSTRIAL ENTERPRISE; INDUSTRIAL STRUCTURE;

EID: 84897381379     PISSN: 00076791     EISSN: 17437938     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1080/00076791.2013.790369     Document Type: Article

References (94)

1. Acar, W., R. J.Keating, K. E.Aupperle, W.Hall, and R. A.Engdahl. "Peering at the Past Century's Corporate Strategy through the Looking Glass of Time-Series Analysis: Extrapolating from Chandler's Classic Mid-Century American Firms." Journal of Management Studies40 (2003): 1225-1254.
2. Ackoff, R. L.Scientific Method. New York: Wiley, 1962.
3. Amburgey, T. L., and T.Dacin. "As the Left Foot Follows the Right? The Dynamics of Strategic and Structural Change." Academy of Management Journal37 (1994): 1427-1452.
4. Ancona, D. G., P. S.Goodman, B. S.Lawrence, and M. L.Tushman. "Time: A New Research Lens." Academy of Management Review26 (2001): 645-663.
5. Ansoff, H. I.Corporate Strategy. New York: McGraw-Hill, 1965.
6. Armour, H. O., and D.Teece. "Organizational Structure and Economic Performance: A Test of the Multidivisional Hypothesis." Bell Journal of Economics9 (1978): 106-122.
7. Ashby, W. R.An Introduction to Cybernetics. London: Taylor & Francis, 1956.
8. Aupperle, K. "Spontaneous Organizational Reconfiguration: A Historical Example Based on Xenophon's Anabasis." Organization Science7 (1996): 445-459.
9. Binda, V., and A.Colli. "Changing Big Business in Italy and Spain, 1973-2003: Strategic Responses to a New Context." Business History53 (2011): 14-39.
10. Bowman, E. H., and H.Singh. "Corporate Restructuring: Reconfiguring the Firm." Strategic Management Journal14 (1993): 5-14.
11. Buhner, R., and P.Moller. "The Information Content of Corporate Disclosures of Divisionalization Decisions." Journal of Management Studies22 (1985): 309-326.
12. Bucheli, M., J. T.Mahoney, and P. M.Vaaler. "Chandler's Living History: The Visible Hand of Vertical Integration in 19th Century America Viewed under a 21st Century Transaction Cost Economics Lens." Journal of Management Studies47 (2010): 859-883.
13. Campbell, D. T., and J. C.Stanley. Experimental and Quasi-Experimental Designs for Research. Chicago: Rand-McNally, 1963.
14. Carmeli, A., and G. D.Markman. "Capture, Governance, and Resilience: Strategy Implications from the History of Rome." Strategic Management Journal32 (2011): 322-341.
15. Chandler, A. D.Strategy and Structure. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 1962.
16. Chandler, A. D.The Visible Hand: The Managerial Revolution in American Business. Cambridge, MA: Belknap Press, 1977.
17. Chandler, A. D.Scale and scope. Cambridge, MA: Belknap Press of Harvard University Press, 1990.
18. Channon, D.The Strategy and Structure of British Enterprise. London: Macmillan, 1973.
19. Child, J. "Organisational Structure, Environment and Performance: The Role of Strategic Choice." Sociology6 (1972): 1-22.
20. Colli, A., M. J.Iversen, and A.de Jong. "Mapping Strategy, Structure, Ownership and Performance in European Corporations: Introduction." Business History53 (2011): 1-13.
21. Cook, T. D., and D. T.Campbell. Quasi-Experimentation. Boston: Houghton-Mifflin, 1979.
22. D'Aveni, R. A.Hypercompetition: The Dynamics of Strategic Maneuvering. New York: Free Press, 1994.
23. De Jong, A., K.Sluyterman, and G.Westerhuis. "Strategic and Structural Responses to International Dynamics in the Open Dutch Economy, 1963-2003." Business History53 (2011): 63-84.
24. Dess, G. G., A. M. A.Rasheed, K. J.McLaughlin, and R. L.Priem. "The New Corporate Architecture." Academy of Management Executive9, no. 3 (1995): 7-20.
25. Dijksterhuis, M. S., F. A. J.Van den Bosch, and H. W.Volberda. "Where do New Organisational Forms Come From? Management Logics as a Source of Coevolution." Organization Science10 (1999): 569-582.
26. Donaldson, L.Performance-Driven Organizational Change: The Organizational Portfolio. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage, 1999.
27. Ehrhardt, O., and E.Nowak. "The Evolution of German Industrial Legends: The Case of Baden-Wurttemberg, 1940-2007." Business History53 (2011): 144-168.
28. Fayol, H.General and Industrial Management. Translated by J.A. Coubrough. Geneva: IMI, 1930.
29. Floyd, S. W., and B.Wooldridge. "Dinosaurs or Dynamos: Recognizing Middle Management's Strategic Role." Academy of Management Executive8 (1994): 47-57.
30. Franko, L.The European Multinationals. Greenwich, CT: Greylock Press, 1976.
31. Freeman, D.Margaret Mead and Samoa: The Making and Unmaking of an Anthropological Myth. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1983.
32. Friedman, W. A., and G.Jones. "Business History: A Time for Debate." Business History Review85 (2011): 1-8.
33. Freund, J. E.Mathematical Statistics. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall, 1962.
34. Galan, J. I., and M. J.Sanchez-Bueno. "The Continuing Validity of the Strategy-Structure Nexus: New Findings, 1993-2003." Strategic Management Journal30 (2009): 1234-1243.
35. Galbraith, J. R., and R. K.Kazanjian. Strategy Implementation: Structure, Systems, and Process., 2nd ed.St. Paul, MN: West Publishing, 1986.
36. Ginsberg, A. "Measuring and Modelling Changes in Strategy: Theoretical Foundations and Empirical Directions." Strategic Management Journal9 (1988): 559-575.
37. Grant, R. M., A. P.Jammine, and H.Thomas. "Diversity, Diversification, and Profitability among British Manufacturing Companies, 1972-84." Academy of Management Journal31 (1988): 771-801.
38. Grinyer, P. H., M.Yasai-Ardekani, and S.Al-Bazzaz. "Strategy, Structure, the Environment and Financial Performance in 48 United Kingdom Companies." Academy of Management Journal23 (1980): 193-220.
39. Habib, M. M., and B.Victor. "Strategy, Structure, and Performance of U.S. Manufacturing and Service MNCs: A Comparative Analysis." Strategic Management Journal12 (1991): 589-606.
40. Hall, D. J., and M. A.Saias. "Strategy Follows Structure!" Strategic Management Journal1 (1980): 149-163.
41. Hambrick, D., and M.Chen. "New Academic Fields as Admittance-seeking Social Movements: The Case of Strategic Management." Academy of Management Review33 (2008): 32-54.
42. Hamel, G., and C. K.Prahalad. Competing for the Future. Boston, MA: Harvard Business School Press, 1994.
43. Hampton, C.The Etruscan Survival. New York: Doubleday, 1969.
44. Hannan, M. T., and J.Freeman. Organizational Ecology. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1989.
45. Harris, B. C.Organization, The Effect of Large Corporations. Ann Arbor, MI: UMI Research Press, 1983.
46. Harris, B. C., and T. W.Ruefli. "The Strategy/Structure Debate: An Examination of the Performance Implications." Journal of Management Studies37, no. 4 (2000): 587-603.
47. Hill, C. W. L. "Internal Organization and Enterprise Performance." Managerial and Decision Economics6 (1985): 210-216.
48. Hill, C. W. L., and R. E.Hoskisson. "Strategy and Structure in the Multiproduct Firm." Academy of Management Review12 (1987): 331-341.
49. Higgins, D. M., and S.Toms. "Explaining Corporate Success: The Structure and Performance of British Firms, 1950-1984." Business History53 (2011): 85-118.
50. Hoskisson, R. E. "Corporate Growth Strategy and Implementation of the Multidivisional Structure: The Effect on Risk, Return, and Growth." Southwest Academy of Management Proceedings (1987): 33-37.
51. Hoskisson, R. E. "Multidivisional Structure and Performance: The Contingency of Diversification Strategy." Academy of Management Journal30 (1987): 625-644.
52. Hoskisson, R. E., and C. S.Galbraith. "The Effect of Quantum versus Incremental M-form Reorganization on Performance: A Time-series Exploration of Intervention Dynamics." Journal of Management11 (1985): 55-70.
53. Iversen, M. J., and M.Larsson. "Strategic Transformations in Danish and Swedish Big Business in an Era of Globalisation, 1973-2008." Business History53 (2011): 119-143.
54. Janis, I. L.Victims of Groupthink. Boston, MA: Houghton-Mifflin.
55. Kerlinger, F. N.Foundations of Behavioral Research. New York: Holt, Rinehart & Winston.
56. Kieser, A. "Why Organization Theory Needs Historical Analyses C and How This Should Be Performed." Organization Science5, no. 4 (1994): 608-623.
57. Lamont, B. T., R. J.Williams, and J. J.Hoffman. "Performance During 'M-form' reorganization and recovery time: The effects of prior strategy and implementation speed." Academy of Management Journal37 (1994): 153-166.
58. Larson, M. J., G.Schnyder, G.Westerhuis, and J.Wilson. "Strategic Responses to Global Challenges: The Case of European Banking, 1973-2000." Business History53 (2011): 40-62.
59. Lawrence, P., and J.Lorsch. Organization and Environment. Boston: Division of Research, Harvard Business School, 1967.
60. Lazonick, W. "The Chandlerian Corporation and the Theory of Innovative Enterprise." Industrial and Corporate Change1 (2010): 317-349.
61. Leonard-Barton, D. "A Dual Methodology for Case Studies: Synergistic Use of a Longitudinal Single Site with Replicated Multiple Sites." Organization Science1 (1990): 248-266.
62. Mahajan, V., S.Sharma, and R.Bettis. "The Adoption of the M-form Organizational Structure: A Test of Imitation Hypothesis." Management Science34 (1988): 1188-1201.
63. Malnight, T. W. "Emerging Structural Patterns within Multinational Corporations: Toward Process-based Structures." Academy of Management Journal44 (2001): 1187-1210.
64. Markides, C. C. "Diversification, Restructuring, and Economic Performance." Strategic Management Journal16 (1995): 101-118.
65. Menard, S.Longitudinal Research. Newbury Park, CA: Sage, 1991.
66. Michel, A., and I.Shaked. "Does Business Diversification Affect Performance?" Financial Management13 (1984): 18-25.
67. Miller, D., and P. H.Friesen. "The Longitudinal Analysis of Organizations: A Methodological Perspective." Management Science28 (1982): 1013-1034.
68. Miller, I., and J. E.Freund. Probability and Statistics for Engineers. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall, 1965.
69. Monge, P. R. "Theoretical and Analytical Issues in Studying Organizational Processes." Organization Science1 (1990): 406-430.
70. Mohr, L. B.Impact Analysis for Program Evaluation. Chicago: Dorsey, 1988.
71. Mosakowski, E. "Entrepreneurial Resources, Organizational Choices and Competitive Outcomes." Organization Science9 (1998): 625-643.
72. Novicevic, M., R.Buckley, R.Clayton, M.Moeller, and W.Williams. "Commemorating Chandler through the Lens of his Revisionists." Journal of Management History15 (2009): 313-322.
73. Nahavandi, A., and E.Aranda. "Restructuring Teams for the Re-engineered Organization." Academy of Management Executive8 (1994): 58-68.
74. Paterson, B. "Still Plausible Stories: A Review of Alfred Chandler's Classics." Academy of Management Review13 (1988): 653-656.
75. Pavan, R. J. "Strategy and Structure: The Italian Experience." Journal of Economics and Business28, no. 3 (1976): 254-260.
76. Pettigrew, A. M. "Longitudinal Field Research on Change: Theory and Practice." Organization Science1 (1990): 267-292.
77. Pfeffer, J.Organizations and Organization Theory. Cambridge, MA: Ballinger, 1982.
78. Pfeffer, J., Y.Salancik. The External Control of Organizations. A Resource Dependence Approach. New York: Harper and Row Publishers, 1978.
79. Rector, R. "Has Market Coordination been Replaced?" Critical Review (Fall 1987): 40-49.
80. Riecken, H. W., and R. F.Boruch. Social Experimentation: A Method for Planning and Evaluating Social Intervention. New York: Academic Press, 1974.
81. Ross, S. C. "An Improved Organizational Concept for High-technology Firms." Journal of Strategic Change3 (1994): 341-355.
82. Rumelt, R. P.Strategy, Structure, and Economic Performance. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1974.
83. Russo, M. V. "The Multidivisional Structure as an Enabling Device: A Longitudinal Study of Discretionary Cash as a Strategic Resource." Academy of Management Journal34 (1991): 718-733.
84. Stopford, J. M., and L. T.Wells. Managing the Multinational Enterprise. New York: Basic Books, 1972.
85. Teece, D. J. "Internal Organization and Economic Performance: An Empirical Analysis of the Profitability of Principal Firms." Journal of Industrial Economics30 (1981): 173-199.
86. Toms, S., and J. F.Wilson. "Scale, Scope, and Accountability: Toward a New Paradigm of British Business History." Business History45 (2003): 1-23.
87. Toms, S., and M.Wright. "Divergence and Convergence within Anglo-American Corporate Governance Systems: Evidence from the US and UK 1950-2000." Business History47 (2005): 267-295.
88. Thorelli, H. B.Strategy + Structure: the Strategic Planning Imperative. Bloomington, IN: Indiana University Press, 1977.
89. Victor, B., and C.Stephens. "The Dark Side of the New Organizational Forms: An Editorial Essay." Organization Science5 (1994): 479-482.
90. Volberda, H. W., and A. Y.Lewin. "Co-evolutionary Dynamics Within and Between Firms: From Evolution to Co-evolution." Journal of Management Studies40 (2003): 2111-2136.
91. Whittington, R. "More SSOP: Commentary on the Special Issue." Business History53 (2011): 169-173.
92. Williamson, O. E.Markets and Hierarchies: Analysis and Antitrust Implications. New York: Free Press, 1975.
93. Williamson, O. E. "Outsourcing: Transaction Cost Economics and Supply Chain Management." Journal of Supply Chain Management: A Global Review of Purchasing and Supply44 (2008): 5-16.
94. Wrigley, L. "Divisional Autonomy and Diversification." PhD diss., Harvard Business School, Boston, MA, 1970.