Porcine xenografts vs. (cryopreserved) allografts in the management of partial thickness burns: Is there a clinical difference?

Burns

Volumn 40, Issue 3, 2014, Pages 408-415

  Hermans, Michel H E ^a  

^a Hermans Consulting Inc   (United States)

Author keywords

Cost; Cryopreserved allograft; Disease transfer; Healing; Partial thickness burns; Porcine xenograft

Indexed keywords

ANALGESIA; ARTICLE; BIOLOGICAL DRESSING; BURN; CRYOPRESERVATION; CRYOPRESERVED ALLOGRAFT; EXPERIMENTAL PIG; HEALTH CARE AVAILABILITY; HEALTH CARE COST; HUMAN; MEDICAL DECISION MAKING; NONHUMAN; PARTIAL THICKNESS BURN; SHELF LIFE; SKIN ALLOGRAFT; SKINFOLD THICKNESS; WOUND HEALING; XENOGRAFT; CLINICAL FEATURE; COMPARATIVE STUDY; COST; HEALING; PORCINE XENOGRAFT; RISK ASSESSMENT; SYSTEMATIC REVIEW; THICKNESS;

COST; CRYOPRESERVED ALLOGRAFT; DISEASE TRANSFER; HEALING; PARTIAL THICKNESS BURNS; PORCINE XENOGRAFT;

ALLOGRAFTS; ANIMALS; BURNS; CRYOPRESERVATION; GRAFT SURVIVAL; HETEROGRAFTS; HUMANS; SKIN TRANSPLANTATION; SWINE; TRANSPLANTATION, HETEROLOGOUS; TRANSPLANTATION, HOMOLOGOUS; TREATMENT OUTCOME;

EID: 84896089553     PISSN: 03054179     EISSN: 18791409     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.burns.2013.08.020     Document Type: Article

References (67)

1. H.J. Klasen History of burns 2004 Erasmus Publishing Rotterdam
2. I. Schechter Prolonged survival of glutaraldehyde-treated skin homografts Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 68 7 1971 1590 1593
3. S.F. Badylak Xenogeneic extracellular matrix as a scaffold for tissue reconstruction Transpl Immunol 12 3-4 2004 367 377
4. R.A. Ersek, and J.A. Navarro Maximizing wound healing with silver-impregnated porcine xenograft Todays Nurse 12 12 1990 4 9
5. J. Leon-Villapalos, M.G. Jeschke, and D.N. Herndon Topical management of facial burns Burns 34 7 2008 903 911
6. E. Lineen, and N. Namias Biologic dressing in burns J Craniofac Surg 19 4 2008 923 928
7. R.A. Ersek, and H.J. Hachen Porcine xenografts in the treatment of pressure ulcers Ann Plast Surg 5 6 1980 464 470
8. R.A. Ersek, and J. Lorio The most indolent ulcers of the skin treated with porcine xenografts and silver ions Surg Gynecol Obstet 158 5 1984 431 436
9. A.V. Kaisary A temporary biological dressing in the treatment of varicose ulcers and skin defects Postgrad Med J 53 625 1977 672 673
10. L. Klein, P. Mericka, H. Strakova, L. Jebavy, M. Nozickova, and M. Blaha et al. Biological skin covers in treatment of two cases of the Lyell's syndrome Ann Transplant 2 1 1997 45 48
11. J.A. Marvin, D.M. Heimbach, L.H. Engrav, and T.J. Harnar Improved treatment of the Stevens-Johnson syndrome Arch Surg 119 5 1984 601 605
12. N. Papanas, I. Eleftheriadou, N. Tentolouris, and E. Maltezos Advances in the topical treatment of diabetic foot ulcers Curr Diabetes Rev 8 3 2012 209 218
13. J.A. Taylor, B. Grube, D.M. Heimbach, and A.B. Bergman Toxic epidermal necrolysis. A comprehensive approach. Multidisciplinary management in a burn center Clin Pediatr (Phila) 28 9 1989 404 407
14. T.L. Khoo, A.S. Halim, A.Z. Saad, and A.A. Dorai The application of glycerol-preserved skin allograft in the treatment of burn injuries: an analysis based on indications Burns 36 6 2010 897 904
15. P. Vanstraelen Comparison of calcium sodium alginate (KALTOSTAT) and porcine xenograft (E-Z DERM) in the healing of split-thickness skin graft donor sites Burns 18 2 1992 145 148
16. D.A. Davis, and C.J. Arpey Porcine heterografts in dermatologic surgery and reconstruction Dermatol Surg 26 1 2000 76 80
17. D.S. Chatterjee A controlled comparative study of the use of porcine xenograft in the treatment of partial thickness skin loss in an occupational health centre Curr Med Res Opin 5 9 1978 726 733
18. R.E. Horch, M.G. Jeschke, G. Spilker, D.N. Herndon, and J. Kopp Treatment of second degree facial burns with allografts - preliminary results Burns 31 5 2005 597 602
19. S.N. Hosseini, A. Karimian, S.N. Mousavinasab, H. Rahmanpour, M. Yamini, and S.H. Zahmatkesh Xenoderm versus 1% silver sulfadiazine in partial-thickness burns Asian J Surg 32 4 2009 234 239
20. M.H. Hermans Preservation methods of allografts and their (lack of) influence on clinical results in partial thickness burns Burns 37 5 2011 873 881
21. M.L. Jarman-Smith, T. Bodamyali, C. Stevens, J.A. Howell, M. Horrocks, and J.B. Chaudhuri Porcine collagen crosslinking, degradation and its capability for fibroblast adhesion and proliferation J Mater Sci Mater Med 15 8 2004 925 932
22. L. Ge, L. Sun, J. Chen, X. Mao, Y. Kong, and F. Xiong et al. The viability change of pigskin in vitro Burns 36 4 2010 533 538
23. R.S. Boneva, and T.M. Folks Xenotransplantation and risks of zoonotic infections Ann Med 36 7 2004 504 517
24. S.J. Crabtree, J.L. Robertson, K.K. Chung, E.M. Renz, S.E. Wolf, and D.R. Hospenthal et al. Clostridium difficile infections in patients with severe burns Burns 37 1 2011 42 48
25. J.P. Pirnay, C. Vandenvelde, L. Duinslaeger, P. Reper, and A. Vanderkelen HIV transmission by transplantation of allograft skin: a review of the literature Burns 23 1 1997 1 5
26. H. Kobayashi, M. Kobayashi, R.L. McCauley, D.N. Herndon, R.B. Pollard, and F. Suzuki Cadaveric skin allograft-associated cytomegalovirus transmission in a mouse model of thermal injury Clin Immunol 92 2 1999 181 187
27. J.A. Clarke HIV transmission and skin grafts Lancet 1 8539 1987 983
28. G.P. Kealey Disease transmission by means of allograft J Burn Care Rehabil 18 1 Pt 2 1997 S10 S11
29. G.P. Kealey, J. Aguiar, R.W. Lewis 2nd, M.D. Rosenquist, R.G. Strauss, and J.F. Bale Jr. Cadaver skin allografts and transmission of human cytomegalovirus to burn patients J Am Coll Surg 182 3 1996 201 205
30. J.R. Barnett, R.L. McCauley, S. Schutzler, K. Sheridan, and J.P. Heggers Cadaver donor discards secondary to serology J Burn Care Rehabil 22 2 2001 124 127
31. E. Pianigiani, M. Risulo, F. Ierardi, P. Sbano, L. Andreassi, and M. Fimiani et al. Prevalence of skin allograft discards as a result of serological and molecular microbiological screening in a regional skin bank in Italy Burns 32 3 2006 348 351
32. L. Csonge, S. Pellet, A. Szenes, and J. Istvan Antibiotics in the preservation of allograft and xenograft skin Burns 21 2 1995 102 105
33. W.M. Switzer, R.E. Michler, V. Shanmugam, A. Matthews, A.I. Hussain, and A. Wright et al. Lack of cross-species transmission of porcine endogenous retrovirus infection to nonhuman primate recipients of porcine cells, tissues, or organs Transplantation 71 7 2001 959 965
34. C.A. Wilson Porcine endogenous retroviruses and xenotransplantation Cell Mol Life Sci 65 21 2008 3399 3412
35. J.H. Blusch, C. Roos, and H. Nitschko A polymerase chain reaction-based protocol for the detection of transmission of pig endogenous retroviruses in pig to human xenotransplantation Transplantation 69 10 2000 2167 2172
36. G. Mattiuzzo, Y. Takeuchi, and L. Scobie Potential zoonotic infection of porcine endogenous retrovirus in xenotransplantation Methods Mol Biol 885 2012 263 279
37. CfBEaR (CBER) Guidance for industry: source animal, product, preclinical, and clinical issues concerning the use of xenotransplantation products in humans 2008 CfBEaR (CBER)
38. FDA FDA regulation of human cells, tissues, and cellular and tissue-based products (HCT/P's) product list 2008 FDA
39. T. Chiu, and A. Burd "Xenograft" dressing in the treatment of burns Clin Dermatol 23 4 2005 419 423
40. R.J. Kagan, E.C. Robb, and R.T. Plessinger Human skin banking Clin Lab Med 25 3 2005 587 605
41. M.H. Hermans Results of an internet survey on the treatment of partial thickness burns, full thickness burns, and donor sites J Burn Care Res 28 6 2007 835 847
42. G.C. Oniscu, and J.L. Forsythe An overview of transplantation in culturally diverse regions Ann Acad Med Singapore 38 4 2009 365 375
43. F. Choukairi, A. Hussain, A. Rashid, and N. Moiemen Re: xenoderm dressing in the treatment of second degree burns Burns 34 6 2008 896 [author reply 97]
44. R.E. Salisbury, R. Carnes, and L.R. McCarthy Comparison of the bacterial clearing effects of different biologic dressings on granulating wounds following thermal injury Plast Reconstr Surg 66 4 1980 596 598
45. R.E. Salisbury, R.W. Carnes, and D. Enterline Biological dressings and evaporative water loss from burn wounds Ann Plast Surg 5 4 1980 270 272
46. X.S. Feng, Y.G. Pan, J.J. Tan, Q.H. Wu, R. Shen, and S.B. Ruan et al. [Treatment of deep partial thickness burns by a single dressing of porcine acellular dermal matrix] Chin J Surg 44 7 2006 467 470 [Abstract in English]
47. X.S. Feng, J.J. Tan, S.B. Ruan, Y.J. Du, and Y.G. Pan [Porcine acellular dermal matrix in the treatment of deep partial-thickness burns in human] Acad J First Med Coll PLA 22 9 2002 844 848 [abstract in English]
48. H.A. El-Khatib, A. Hammouda, A. Al-Ghol, B. Habib, and B. Al Aldehyde-treated porcine skin versus biobrane as biosynthetic skin substitutes for excised burn wounds: case series and review of the literature Ann Burns Fire Disasters 20 2 2007 78 82
49. S.N. Hosseini, S.N. Mousavinasab, and M. Fallahnezhat Xenoderm dressing in the treatment of second degree burns Burns 33 6 2007 776 781
50. B.E. Bromberg, and I.C. Song Pigskin heterografts Minn Med 48 12 1965 1605 1609
51. I. Rappaport, A.T. Pepino, and W. Dietrick Early use of xenografts as a biologic dressing in burn trauma Am J Surg 120 2 1970 144 148
52. F. Duteille, and P. Perrot Management of 2nd-degree facial burns using the Versajet((R)) hydrosurgery system and xenograft: a prospective evaluation of 20 cases Burns 38 5 2012 724 729
53. C.M. Healy, and J.G. Boorman Comparison of E-Z Derm and Jelonet dressings for partial skin thickness burns Burns Incl Therm Inj 15 1 1989 52 54
54. P. Bukovcan, and J. Koller Treatment of partial-thickness scalds by skin xenografts - a retrospective study of 109 cases in a three-year period Acta Chir Plast 52 1 2010 7 12
55. T. Sullivan, J. Smith, J. Kermode, E. McIver, and D.J. Courtemanche Rating the burn scar J Burn Care Rehabil 11 3 1990 256 260
56. X. Feng, J. Tan, Y. Pan, Q. Wu, S. Ruan, and R. Shen et al. Control of hypertrophic scar from inception by using xenogenic (porcine) acellular dermal matrix (ADM) to cover deep second degree burn Burns 32 3 2006 293 298
57. E.A. Deitch, T.M. Wheelahan, M.P. Rose, J. Clothier, and J. Cotter Hypertrophic burn scars: analysis of variables J Trauma 23 10 1983 895 898
58. J.K. Rose, M.H. Desai, J.M. Mlakar, and D.N. Herndon Allograft is superior to topical antimicrobial therapy in the treatment of partial-thickness scald burns in children J Burn Care Rehabil 18 4 1997 338 341
59. A. Eldad, A. Din, A. Weinberg, A. Neuman, H. Lipton, and H. Ben-Bassat et al. Cryopreserved cadaveric allografts for treatment of unexcised partial thickness flame burns: clinical experience with 12 patients Burns 23 7-8 1997 608 614
60. A.F. Vloemans, E. Middelkoop, and R.W. Kreis A historical appraisal of the use of cryopreserved and glycerol-preserved allograft skin in the treatment of partial thickness burns Burns 28 Suppl 1 2002 S16 S20
61. Wasiak JCH, Campbell F, Spinks A. Dressings for treating superficial and partial thickness burns: Cochrane summaries; 28 March 2013.
62. J. Howick Levels of evidence: Oxford center for evidence based medicine 2009 Oxford Center for Evidence Based Medicine Oxford
63. D. Bravo, T.H. Rigley, N. Gibran, D.M. Strong, and H. Newman-Gage Effect of storage and preservation methods on viability in transplantable human skin allografts Burns 26 4 2000 367 378
64. D.W. Raimer, A.R. Group, M.S. Petitt, N. Nosrati, M.L. Yamazaki, and N.A. Davis et al. Porcine xenograft biosynthetic wound dressings for the management of postoperative Mohs wounds Dermatol Online J 17 9 2011 1
65. E. Pianigiani, and J.L. Pierce Skin, specific recovery and processing issues F. Fehily, S. Brubaker, J. Kearney, L. Wolfinbarger, Tissue and cell processing: an essential guide 2012 John Wiley and Sons Chichester 217 228
66. F. Huss Nationell hudbank på Akademiska gynnar svårt brännskadade 2013 Akademiska Sjukhuset Uppsala
67. H. Ben-Bassat, M. Chaouat, N. Segal, E. Zumai, M.R. Wexler, and A. Eldad How long can cryopreserved skin be stored to maintain adequate graft performance? Burns 27 5 2001 425 431