Balancing risks: Childhood inoculations and America's response to the provocation of paralytic polio

Social History of Medicine

Volumn 26, Issue 4, 2013, Pages 759-778

  Mawdsley, Stephen E ^a  

^a Clare Hall ^*  (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

Gamma globulin; Immunisation; Injections; Poliomyelitis; Precipitation; Provocation; Public health; Tonsillectomies; United States

Indexed keywords

EID: 84891941817     PISSN: 0951631X     EISSN: 14774666     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1093/shm/hkt043     Document Type: Article

References (124)

1. 'State Acts to Curb Polio Spread Peril, New York Times, 13 June 1951, 30.
2. James Colgrove, State of Immunity: The Politics of Vaccination in Twentieth-Century America (Berkeley and Los Angeles: University of California Press, 2006), ch. 3.
3. Naomi Rogers, Dirt and Disease: Polio Before FDR (New Brunswick: Rutgers University Press, 1996).
4. David M. Oshinsky, Polio: An American Story: The Crusade that Mobilized the Nation Against the 20th Centurys Most Feared Disease (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2005)
5. Jane S. Smith, Patenting the Sun: Polio and the Salk Vaccine (New York: William Morrow & Company, Inc., 1990).
6. Colgrove, State of Immunity, ch. 4
7. Sydney Ann Halpern, Lesser Harms: The Morality of Risk in Medical Research (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2006), ch. 2.
8. Mary Douglas and Aaron Wildavsky, Risk and Culture: An Essay on the Selection of Technological and Environmental Dangers (Berkeley: University of California Press, 1983), chs 1 and 3
9. Martin S. Pernick, A Calculus of Suffering: Pain, Professionalism, and Anesthesia in Nineteenth CenturyAmerica (New York: Columbia University Press, 1985)
10. Lee Clarke, Acceptable Risk? Making Decisions in a Toxic Environment (Berkeley: University of California Press, 1989), ch. 8
11. Bob Heyman (eds), Risk, Health, and Health Care: A Qualitative Approach (London: Arnold, 1998), ch. 2.
12. Oshinsky, Polio: An American Story, 8.
13. Richard Aldrich in A Paralyzing Fear: The Triumph over Polio in America (New York: TV Books, 1998), 113.
14. Smith, Patenting the Sun, 82.
15. Rogers, Dirt and Disease, 30.
16. Benjamin P. Sandler, Diet Prevents Polio (Lee Foundation for Nutritional Research, 1951)
17. R. K. Pu, 'Factors That Predispose to Polio, New York Times, 19 August 1951, 135.
18. Oshinsky, Polio: An American Story, 90.
19. Smith, Patenting the Sun, 45-7.
20. Oshinsky, Polio: An American Story, 8.
21. C. K. Mills, 'The Tonsillectomy-Poliomyelitis Problem, Laryngoscope, 56, 1951, 1188-94.
22. Fischer and Stillerman, 'Acute Anterior Poliomyelitis in New York in 1935, A Review of Six Hundred and Eighty-Six Cases, American Journal of Diseases of Children, 54, 1937, 984-1004
23. Gerald N. Grob, 'The Rise and Decline of Tonsillectomy in Twentieth-Century America, Journal of the History of Medicine and Allied Sciences, 62, 4, 2007, 383-421
24. D. M. Anderson and J. H. Dixon, 'Acute Bulbar Paralysis: Report of Two Cases, British Medical Journal, 1938, 1077-9.
25. Alfred E. Fischer, 'Poliomyelitis After Tonsillectomy, British Medical Journal, 1939, 533.
26. W. L. Aycock, 'Tonsillectomy and Poliomyelitis: Epidemiologic Considerations, Medicine, 21, 1942, 65-94.
27. T. Francis, C. E. Krill, J. A. Toomey, and W. N. Mack, Poliomyelitis Following Tonsillectomy in Five Members of a Family: An Epidemiologic Study, Journal of the American Medical Association, 119, 17, 1942, 1392-6
28. Poliomyelitis After Tonsillectomy, The Lancet, 1942, 552.
29. V. E. Negus, Poliomyelitis and Tonsillectomy, The Lancet, 1948, 72.
30. J. W. Traynor, Tonsillectomy and Poliomyelitis in Southern Iowa, 1948-1949, Journal of the Iowa Medical Society, 40, 1950, 400-402.
31. Claude D. Winborn and John R. Stansbury, Poliomyelitis and tonsillectomy, The Laryngoscope, 57, 8, 1947, 575-79.
32. J. Alison Glover, Poliomyelitis and Tonsillectomy, Public Health 1950, 154-5
33. J. Alison Glover, The Incidence of Tonsillectomy in School Children, Proceedings of the Royal Society of Medicine, 31, 10,1938, 1219-36.
34. Gaylord W. Anderson, The Risk of Poliomyelitis After Tonsillectomy, The Annals of Otology, Rhinology, and Laryngology, 59, 3,1950, 602.
35. Edwin P. Jordan, MD, The Doctor Answers, The Evening Capital, 23 June 1950, 4.
36. H. Kern, Ueber eine anstaltsendemie von Heine Medinscher krankheit,Muenchen Medizinische Wochenschrift, 61 (1914) 1053-55
37. Alterthum, Lues Congenita und Poliomyelitis, Deutsche Medizinische Wochenschrift., 13, 30 March 1928, 522.
38. M. DeTeyssien, Acute Poliomyelitis Following an Injection of Anti-Cholera Vaccine, Journal de médecine De Bordeaux, 92, 1921, 77-8
39. M. Jarmulowicz, Two Cases of Poliomyelitis Following Anti-Smallpox Vaccination, Review of Neurology, 37, January 1930, 92-3
40. E. Molinari, Poliomyelitis: Common Prodromal Symptoms and Therapy of Paralysis Following Anti-Smallpox Vaccination: Colibacillary Etiology, Gazzetta degli ospedali e delle cliniche, 55 February 1934, 226-32.
41. W. H. Bradley, Discussion on Poliomyelitis following Inoculations (Section of Epidemiology and State Medicine), Proceedings of the Royal Society of Medicine, 43, 1950, 775-82.
42. Harry Marks, The Progress of Experiment: Science and Therapeutic Reform in the United States, 1900-1990 (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1997), ch. 2.
43. H. V. Wyatt, Provocation Poliomyelitis: Neglected Clinical Observations from 1914 to 1950, Bulletin of the History of Medicine, 55, 4, 1981, 550.
44. Rogers, Dirt and Disease, 171-2.
45. Halpern, Lesser Harms, 48-57
46. John R. Paul, A History of Poliomyelitis (New Haven: Yale University Press, 1971), 393.
47. DeTeyssien, Acute Poliomyelitis, 77-8.
48. Elizabeth W. Etheridge, Sentinel for Health: A History of the Centers for Disease Control (Berkeley: University of California Press, 1992)
49. Mark E. Rushefsky and Deborah R. McFarlane, The Politics of Public Health in the United States (Armonk: M.E. Sharpe, 2005).
50. J. K. Martin, Local Paralysis in Children after Injections, Archives of Disease in Childhood, 25, 121, March 1950, 1-14.
51. Bertram P. McCloskey, The Relation of Prophylactic Inoculations to the Onset of Poliomyelitis, The Lancet, April 1950, 659-63.
52. McCloskey, The Relation of Prophylactic Inoculations, 662.
53. Arthur Gelb, Polio Link Sought to Immunity "Shots", New York Times, 29 September 1950, 23.
54. Gaylord W. Anderson and Audrey E. Skaar, Poliomyelitis Occurring After Antigen Injections, Pediatrics, 7, 6, June 1951, 741-59.
55. Donald J. Dean, Sophia M. Cohen, and Gilbert Dalldorf, The Effect of Unrelated Vaccines on the Localization of Paralysis in Mouse Encephalomyelitis, Proceedings of the Society for Experimental Biology & Medicine, 77, 1951, 834-36.
56. Editorial, The Journal of Pediatrics, 38, 6, June 1951, 781-2.
57. Martin, Local Paralysis in Children, 3.
58. Harold K. Faber, Postinoculation Poliomyelitis, Pediatrics, 7, 2, 1951, 300-4.
59. Harry Weaver, Editorial, June 1951, Series 3: Gamma Globulin Field Trial, Box 3, Surveys and Studies Records, March of Dimes Archives, White Plains, New York (henceforth denoted as MDA)
60. Robert F. Korns, Robert M. Albrecht, Frances B. Locke, The Association of Parenteral Injections With Poliomyelitis, American Journal of Public Health, 42, 2, February 1952, 153-69
61. Robert M. Albrecht and Frances B. Locke, Effect of Physical Activity on Prognosis of Poliomyelitis, Journal of theAmerican Medical Association, 146, 9, 1951, 769-71.
62. David M. Herszenhorn, Robert F. Korns, 82, Researcher Who Helped Test Polio Vaccine, New York Times, 16 October 1995, B7.
63. Proceedings of the Committee on Immunization of the National Foundation for Infantile Paralysis, 6 July 1951, Box 244, Folder 4, Dr Jonas E. Salk Papers, Mandeville Library, California, 1.
64. Anderson and Skaar, Poliomyelitis Occurring After Antigen Injections, 758.
65. Alton L. Blakeslee, Doctors Advise: Postpone Vaccinations for Children During Warm Polio Months, Dixon Evening Telegraph, 29 May 1951, 9.
66. R. K. Pu, Factors That Predispose to Polio, 135.
67. Colgrove, State of Immunity, ch. 3.
68. Betram P. McCloskey, The Relation of Prophylactic Inoculations to the Onset of Poliomyelitis, The Lancet, April 1950, 659.
69. Woman Files Suit Against Drug Co., Indiana Evening Gazette, 19 July 1947, 10
70. Couple Sues Firm for Antitoxin, Chester Times, 18 July 1947, 11.
71. Dr. Weaver, Editorial, June 1951, Series 3: Gamma Globulin Field Trial, Box 3, Surveys and Studies Records, MDA.
72. Polio Funds Views on Injection Ban,New York Times, 21 June 1951, 28.
73. Jens I. Zinn, Risk as Discourse: Interdisciplinary Perspectives, Critical Approaches to Discourse Analysis across Disciplines, 4, 2, 2010, 106-24.
74. Proceedings of the Committee on Immunization, 17 May 1951, 51.
75. U.S. Decries "Shots" In "Polio Season", New York Times, 22 June 1951, 27.
76. Hilleboe to State Public Health Physicians, 11 June 1951, Series 3: Gamma Globulin Field Trials, Box 3, Surveys and Studies Records, MDA.
77. State Acts to Curb Polio Spread Peril, New York Times, 13 June 1951, 30.
78. Polio Funds Views on Injection Ban, 28.
79. School Vaccination Law Relaxed for Polio Season, New York Times, 31 August 1951, 16.
80. Arthur Gelb, City Clinics Halt Diphtheria "Shots" For Summer as Polio Precaution, New York Times, 12 June 1951, 1.
81. Edward L. Bauer, Correspondence, Pediatrics, 8, 3, 1951, 452-3.
82. Health Director Advises Not to Delay Injections, Lowell Sunday Sun, 1 July 1951, 8.
83. Counsel on Polio Shots Given by District Health Director, The Washington Post, 19 July 1951, B1.
84. Kenton Kroker, Jennifer Keelan, and Pauline M. H. Mazumdar (eds), Crafting Immunity: Working Histories of Clinical Immunology (Aldershot: Ashgate Publishing, Ltd., 2008)
85. Colgrove, State of Immunity, chs 3 and 4.
86. William McD. Hammon, Lewis L. Coriell, and Joseph Stokes, Jr., Evaluation of Red Cross Gamma Globulin as a Prophylactic Agent for Poliomyelitis, Journal of the American Medical Association, 150, 8, 25 October 1952, 742.
87. L. Pearce Williams, Chapter VIII: Passive Immunity to Poliomyelitis, Preliminary Draft, 1956, Series 1: Passive Immunity, Box 1, History of the NFIP Records, MDA, 14-15.
88. Proceedings of the Committee on Immunization, 17 May 1951, 8, 12.
89. Paul, A History of Poliomyelitis, 393.
90. Proceedings of the Committee on Immunization, 17 May 1951, 62.
91. Proceedings of the Committee on Immunization, 6 July 1951.
92. Paul, A History of Poliomyelitis, 393.
93. Weaver to Hilleboe, 21 August 1951, Series 3:Gamma Globulin Field Trial, Box 3, Surveys and Studies Records, MDA.
94. Workers Badly Needed, Houston Informer, 5 July 1952, 1.
95. Hammonet al., Evaluation of Red CrossGamma Globulin, Part 1, 743.
96. Susan E. Lederer, Subjected to Science: Human Experimentation in America Before the Second World War (Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, 1997)
97. Allen M. Hornblum, Acres of Skin:HumanExperiments at Holmesburg Prison (New York: Routledge, 1999), ch. 4
98. Susan M. Reverby, "Normal Exposure" and Inoculation Syphilis:APHS "Tuskegee" Doctor in Guatemala, 1946-48, Journal of Policy History (January 2010)
99. Susan L. Smith, Mustard Gas and American Race-Based Human Experimentation in World War II, Journal of Law, Medicine & Ethics, 36, 3, Fall 2008, 517-21.
100. Report of Gamma Globulin Passive Immunization Field Project, Utah County, Utah, 1951, Series 14: Poliomyelitis, Gamma Globulin Program, Box 12, Medical Program Records, MDA, 9.
101. Proceedings of the Committee on Immunization, 4 December 1951, 10-11.
102. Use of Polio Vaccine During Epidemic Season, American Journal of Public Health, 45, July 1955, 956.
103. Health Department Warns Against Any "Shots" as Precaution Against Polio, The Norwich Sun (New York), 14 June, 1951, 1.
104. Some "Shots" Held Perilous in Polio Areas, The Washington Post, 10 May 1952, B5.
105. W. M. Hammon, L. L. Coriell, and J. Stokes Jr. Evaluation of Red Cross Gamma Globulin as a Prophylactic Agent for Poliomyelitis: 2. Conduct and Early Follow-up of 1952 Texas and Iowa-Nebraska Studies, Journal of the American Medical Association, 150, 1952, 750-6
106. W. M. Hammon, L. L. Coriell, P. F. Wehrle, C. R. Klimt, J. Stokes Jr., Evaluation of Red Cross Gamma Globulin as a Prophylactic Agent for Poliomyelitis: 3. Preliminary Report of Results Based on Clinical Diagnoses, Journal of the American Medical Association, 150, 1952, 757-60
107. W. M. Hammon, L. L. Coriell, P. F. Wehrle, J. Stokes Jr. Evaluation of Red Cross Gamma Globulin as a Prophylactic Agent for Poliomyelitis: 4. Final Report of Results Based on Clinical Diagnoses, Journal of the American Medical Association, 151, 1953, 1272-85
108. U.S. Polio Cases 1952-1962, U.S. Public Health Service Health Information Series, 8, 7, 1963
109. Oshinsky, Polio: An American Story, chs 12 and 13.
110. Charlene Pugleasa in A Paralyzing Fear, 133.
111. Oshinsky, Polio: An American Story, ch. 15.
112. H. V. Wyatt, Provocation Poliomyelitis: Neglected Clinical Observations from 1914 to 1950, Bulletin of the History of Medicine, 55, 1981, 543-37
113. H. V. Wyatt, Provocation of Poliomyelitis by Multiple Injections, Transactions of the Royal Society of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene, 79, 3, 1985, 355-8. (Pubitemid 15062128)
114. M. Varghese, I. Qadeer, and D. Mohan, Paralytic Poliomyelitis in a Rural Area of North India, The National Medical Journal of India, 10, 1, Jan-Feb 1997, 8-10. (Pubitemid 127606402)
115. K. A. Kohler, W. G. Hlady, K. Banerjee, and R. W. Sutter, Outbreak of Poliomyelitis Due to Type 3 Poliovirus, Northern India, 1999-2000: Injections a Major Contributing Factor, International Journal of Epidemiology, 32, 2, April 2003, 272-7. (Pubitemid 36622274)
116. J. Singh, S. Khare, R.S. Sharma, and T. Verghese, An Explosive Outbreak of Poliomyelitis in an Orphanage in Delhi: Risk Factors for the Unusually High Attack Rates, Indian Pediatrics, 34, 1997, 135-9. (Pubitemid 27115732)
117. J. Singh, S. Khare, R. S. Sharma, and T. Verghese, Reply, Indian Pediatrics 1997, 847-8.
118. H. V. Wyatt, S. Mahadevan, and S. Srinivasan, Unnecessary Injections and Paralytic Poliomyelitis in India, Transactions of the Royal Society of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene, 86, 1992, 546-9.
119. H. V. Wyatt, AView From The West: Health Warning: Injections Can Endanger Health, Issues in Medical Ethics, 4, 1, 1996, 14-15.
120. Ganapati Mudur, Flawed Immunisation Policies in India Led to Polio Paralysis, British Medical Journal, April 1998, 316.
121. Matthias Gromeier and Eckard Wimmer, Mechanism of Injury-Provoked Poliomyelitis, Journal of Virology, 72, 6, June 1998, 5056-60. (Pubitemid 28215685)
122. A. R. Bosley, G. Speirs, and N. I. Markham, Provocation Poliomyelitis: Vaccine Associated Paralytic Poliomyelitis Related to a Rectal Abscess in an Infant, Journal of Infection, 47, 1, 2003, 82-4. (Pubitemid 36850141)
123. Neal A. Halsey, Commentary: Poliomyelitis and Unnecessary Injections, International Journal of Epidemiology, 32, 2, 2003, 278-9 (Pubitemid 36622275)
124. Amitesh Narayan, Sailakshmi Ganesan, U. V. Shenoy, and E. Narayanan, Provocative Poliomyelitis Causing Postpolio Residual Paralysis Among Select Communities of Two Remote Villages of North Karnataka in India: A Community Survey, Indian Journal of Public Health, 55, 4, 2011, 309-12.