Palliative sedation versus euthanasia: An ethical assessment

Journal of Pain and Symptom Management

Volumn 47, Issue 1, 2014, Pages 123-136

  Ten Have, Henk ^a   Welie, Jos V M ^b  

^a DUQUESNE UNIVERSITY   (United States)

^b CREIGHTON UNIVERSITY   (United States)

Author keywords

End of life care; ethics; euthanasia; hospice philosophy; palliative care; palliative sedation; physician assisted dying; terminal sedation

Indexed keywords

SEDATIVE AGENT; HYPNOTIC SEDATIVE AGENT;

ARTICLE; BEHAVIOR; EUTHANASIA; HOSPICE; HUMAN; MEDICAL ETHICS; MORALITY; PALLIATIVE THERAPY; PATIENT CARE; SEDATION; TERMINALLY ILL PATIENT; UNCONSCIOUSNESS; ASSISTED SUICIDE; ETHICS; HOSPICE CARE; PROCEDURES;

EUTHANASIA; HOSPICE CARE; HUMANS; HYPNOTICS AND SEDATIVES; MORALS; PALLIATIVE CARE; SUICIDE, ASSISTED;

EID: 84891829600     PISSN: 08853924     EISSN: 18736513     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.jpainsymman.2013.03.008     Document Type: Article

References (78)

1. R.E. Enck Drug-induced terminal sedation for symptom control Am J Hosp Palliat Care 8 1991 3 5
2. J.A. Billings, and S.D. Block Slow euthanasia J Palliat Care 12 1996 31 37
3. J. Howland Questions about palliative sedation: an act of mercy or mercy killing? Ethics Medics 30 2005 1 2
4. A. Simon, M. Kar, J. Hinz, and D. Beck Attitudes towards terminal sedation: an empirical survey among experts in the field of medical ethics BMC Palliat Care 16 2007 4
5. A. Chater, R. Viola, J. Paterson, and V. Jarvis Sedation for intractable distress in the dying - a survey of experts Palliat Med 12 1998 255 269
6. E.L. Krakauer Responding to intractable terminal suffering [letter] Ann Intern Med 133 2000 560
7. N.I. Cherny, and R. Portnoy Sedation in the management of refractory symptoms J Palliat Care 10 1994 31 38
8. B. Broeckaert Palliative sedation defined or why and when terminal sedation is not euthanasia [abstract] J Pain Symptom Manage 20 2000 S58
9. B. Broeckaert, and J.M. Nuñez Olarte Sedation in palliative care: facts and concepts H. Ten Have, D. Clark, The ethics of palliative care. European perspectives 2002 Open University Press Buckingham 166 180
10. M. Verkerk, E. van Wijlick, J. Legemaate, and A. de Graeff A national guideline for palliative sedation in the Netherlands J Pain Symptom Manage 34 2007 666 670
11. National Ethics Committee, and Veterans Health Administration The ethics of palliative sedation as a therapy of last resort Am J Hosp Palliat Care 23 2007 483 491
12. N.I. Cherny, and L. Radbruch European Association for Palliative Care (EAPC) recommended framework for the use of sedation in palliative care Palliat Med 23 2009 581 593
13. T.W. Kirk, and M.M. Mahon National Hospice and Palliative Care Organization (NHPCO) position statement and commentary on the use of palliative sedation in imminently dying terminally ill patients J Pain Symptom Manage 39 2010 914 923
14. P. Claessens, E. Genbrugge, and R. Vannuffelen et al. Palliative sedation and nursing: the place of palliative sedation within palliative nursing care J Hosp Palliat Nurs 9 2007 100 106
15. P. Claessens, J. Menten, P. Schotsmans, and B. Broeckaert Palliative sedation: a review of the research literature J Pain Symptom Manage 36 2008 310 333
16. P. Claessens, J. Menten, P. Schotsmans, and B. Broeckaert Palliative sedation, not slow euthanasia: a prospective, longitudinal study of sedation in Flemish palliative care units J Pain Symptom Manage 41 2011 14 24
17. B. Broeckaert Palliative sedation, physician-assisted suicide, and euthanasia: "same, same but different"? Am J Bioeth 11 2011 62 64
18. E. Inghelbrecht, J. Bilsen, F. Mortier, and L. Deliens Continuous deep sedation until death in Belgium: a survey among nurses J Pain Symptom Manage 41 2011 870 879
19. L. Vogel Framework urges physicians to proceed with caution on palliative sedation CMAJ 182 2011 174 175
20. R.L. Fainsinger Use of sedation by a hospital palliative care support team J Palliat Care 14 1998 51 54
21. K. Turner, R. Chye, and G. Aggarwal et al. Dignity in dying: a preliminary study of patients in the last three days of life J Palliat Care 12 1996 7 13
22. M. Maltoni, C. Pittureri, and E. Scarpi et al. Palliative sedation therapy does not hasten death: results from a prospective multicenter study Ann Oncol 20 2009 1163 1169
23. G. Miccinesi, J.A. Rietjens, L. Deliens EURELD Consortium Continuous deep sedation: physicians' experiences in six European countries J Pain Symptom Manage 31 2006 122 129
24. C. Seale End-of-life decisions in the UK involving medical practitioners Palliat Med 23 2009 198 204
25. C. Peruselli, P. Di Giulio, and F. Toscani et al. Home palliative care for terminal cancer patients: a survey on the final week of life Palliat Med 13 1999 233 241
26. K.C.P. Vissers, and J.G.J. Hasselaar Palliative sedation. Need for consensus guidelines and standards Arch Intern Med 170 2010 494 495
27. R.P. Reuzel, G.J. Hasselaar, and K.C. Vissers et al. Inappropriateness of using opioids for end-stage palliative sedation: a Dutch study Palliat Med 22 2008 641 646
28. R. Bayer, A. Caplan, and D. Daniels In search of equity. Health needs and the health care system 1983 Plenum Press New York
29. M. Kirejczyk Met technologie gezegend? Gender en de omstreden invoering van in vitro fertilisatie in de Nederlandse gezondheidszorg [Blessed with technology? Gender and the contested introduction of in vitro fertilisation in Dutch healthcare.] 1996 Uitgeverij Jan van Arkel Utrecht
30. J.A. Rietjens, J.J. van Delden, and A. van der Heide et al. Terminal sedation and euthanasia. A comparison of clinical practices Arch Intern Med 166 2006 749 753
31. B. Henry, M. Dean, V. Cellarius, L. Librach, and D. Oneschuk To "sleep until death" [letter] Hastings Cent Rep 41 2011 4
32. A. Van der Heide, A. Brinkman-Stoppelenburg, H. Van Delden, and B. Onwuteaka-Philipsen Euthanasie en andere medische beslissingen rond het levenseinde [Euthanasia and other medical decisions concerning the end of life]. Sterfgevallenonderzoek 2010 2012 ZonMw Den Haag
33. B.D. Onwuteaka-Philipsen, A. Brinkman-Stoppelenburg, and C. Penning et al. Trends in end-of-life practices before and after the enactment of the euthanasia law in the Netherlands from 1990 to 2010: a repeated cross-sectional survey Lancet 380 2012 908 915
34. M.Y. Rady, and J.L. Verheijde Continuous deep sedation until death: palliation or physician-assisted suicide? Am J Hosp Palliat Care 27 2010 205 214
35. K. Raus, S. Sterckx, and F. Mortier Is continuous sedation at the end of life an ethically preferable alternative to physician-assisted suicide? Am J Bioeth 11 2011 32 40
36. S.H. Lipuma The lacking of moral equivalence for continuous sedation and PAS Am J Bioeth 11 2011 48 49
37. M.P. Battin Terminal sedation: pulling the sheet over our eyes Hastings Cent Rep 38 2008 27 30
38. H.A.M.J. Ten Have, and J.V.M. Welie Death and medical power. An ethical analysis of the Dutch euthanasia practice 2005 Open University Press London
39. L.A. Jansen Disambiguating clinical intentions: the ethics of palliative sedation J Med Philos 35 2010 19 31
40. T.E. Quill The ambiguity of clinical intentions N Engl J Med 329 1993 1039 1040
41. J. Boyle Medical ethics and double effect: the case of terminal sedation Theor Med Bioeth 25 2004 51 60
42. H.M. Buiting, D.L. Willems, and H.R.W. Pasman et al. Palliative treatment alternatives and euthanasia consultations: a qualitative interview study J Pain Symptom Manage 42 2011 32 43
43. A controlled trial to improve care for seriously ill hospitalized patients. The study to understand prognoses and preferences for outcomes and risks of treatments (SUPPORT). The SUPPORT Principal Investigators JAMA 274 1995 1591 1598
44. S.J. Swart, J.A.C. Rietjens, and L. van Zuylen et al. Continuous palliative sedation for cancer and noncancer patients J Pain Symptom Manage 43 2012 172 181
45. S. Mercadante, G. Porzio, and A. Valle et al. Palliative sedation in patients with advanced cancer followed at home: a systematic review J Pain Symptom Manage 41 2011 754 760
46. N. Sykes, and A. Thorns Sedative use in the last week of life and the implications for end-of-life decision making Arch Intern Med 163 2003 341 344
47. J. Hallenbeck Terminal sedation for intractable distress. Not slow euthanasia but a prompt response to suffering West J Med 171 1999 222 223
48. J.A. Russell, M.A. Williams, and O. Drogan Sedation for the imminently dying. Survey results from the AAN Ethics Section Neurology 74 2010 1303 1309
49. J.G. Hasselaar, S.C. Verhagen, and A.P. Wolff et al. Changed patterns in Dutch palliative sedation practices after the introduction of a national guideline Arch Intern Med 169 2009 430 437
50. N. Juth, A. Lindblad, N. Lynöe, M. Sjöstrand, and G. Helgesson European Association for Palliative Care (EAPC) framework for palliative sedation: an ethical discussion BMC Palliat Care 9 2010 20
51. L.A. Jansen, and D.P. Sulmasy Proportionality, terminal suffering and the restorative goals of medicine Theor Med Bioeth 23 2002 321 337
52. K. Hauser, and D. Walsh Palliative sedation: welcome guidance on a controversial issue Palliat Med 23 2009 577 579
53. P. Boston, A. Bruce, and R. Schreiber Existential suffering in the palliative care setting: an integrated literature review J Pain Symptom Manage 41 2011 604 618
54. E.J. Cassell, and B.A. Rich Intractable end-of-life suffering and the ethics of palliative sedation Pain Med 11 2010 435 438
55. J.K. Inglehart A new era of for-profit hospice care - the Medicare benefit N Engl J Med 360 2009 2701 2703
56. M.W. Wachterman, E.R. Marcantonio, R.B. Davis, and E.P. McCarthy Association of hospice agency profit status with patient diagnosis, location of care and length of stay JAMA 305 2011 472 479
57. J.E. Perry, and R.C. Stone In the business of dying: questioning the commercialization of hospice J Law Med Ethics 39 2011 224 234
58. M.D.A. Carlson, W.T. Gallo, and E.H. Bradley Ownership status and patterns of care in hospice. Results from the National Home and Hospice Care Survey Med Care 42 2004 432 438
59. S.O. Gandhi Differences between non-profit and for-profit hospices: patient selection and quality Int J Health Care Finance Econ 12 2012 107 127
60. E.G. Kirby Strategic groups and outcomes in the US hospice care industry J Health Organ Manag 26 2012 641 654
61. J. Shea Palliative care "Killing me softly" 2004 Catholic Insight Toronto Available from http://www.mnfl.org/pdf/PalliativeCare-NO- format1.pdf Accessed May 13, 2013
62. Pontifical Council for Health Pastoral Care. Charter for health care workers. 1995. Available from http://www.ewtn.com/library/curia/pcpaheal.htm. Accessed February 1, 2012.
63. T.E. Quill, B. Lo, and D.W. Brock et al. Last-resort options for palliative sedation Ann Intern Med 151 2009 421 424
64. T.T. Reid, R.A. Demme, and T.E. Quill When there are no good choices: illuminating the borderland between proportionate palliative sedation and palliative sedation to unconsciousness Pain Manag 1 2011 31 40
65. J.T. Berger Preemptive use of palliative sedation and amyotrophic lateral sclerosis J Pain Symptom Manage 43 2012 802 805
66. M.A. Ramsay, T.M. Savege, B.R. Simpson, and R. Goodwin Controlled sedation with alphaxalone-alphadolone BMJ 2 1974 656 659
67. D. Gracia Palliative care and the historical background H. Ten Have, D. Clark, The ethics of palliative care. European perspectives 2002 Open University Press Buckingham 18 33
68. K. Chambaere, J. Bilsen, and J. Cohen et al. Continuous deep sedation until death in Belgium: a nationwide survey Arch Intern Med 170 2010 490 493
69. S. Mercadante, G. Porzio, and A. Valle et al. Palliative sedation in advanced cancer patients followed at home: a retrospective analysis J Pain Symptom Manage 43 2012 1126 1130
70. J. Rietjens, J. Van Delden, and B. Onwuteaka-Philipsen et al. Continuous deep sedation for patients nearing death in the Netherlands: descriptive study BMJ 336 2008 810 813
71. E. Kübler-Ross On death and dying 1969 Scribner New York
72. C. Saunders Watch with me. Inspiration for a life in hospice care 2003 Mortal Press Sheffield
73. P. Schotsmans Palliative care: a relational approach H. Ten Have, D. Clark, The ethics of palliative care. European perspectives 2002 Open University Press Buckingham/Philadelphia 126 140
74. D. Clark, and J. Seymour Reflections on palliative care 1999 Open University Press Buckingham/Philadelphia
75. F. Randall, and R.S. Downie The philosophy of palliative care. Critique and reconstruction 2006 Oxford University Press Oxford, New York
76. L. Thoresen, T. Wyller, and K. Heggen The significance of lifeworld and the case of hospice Med Health Care Philos 14 2011 257 263
77. J.H. Von Roenn, and C.F. Von Gunten Editorial. Are we putting the cart before the horse? Arch Intern Med 169 2009 429
78. A.J. Davis Brompton's cocktail: making goodbyes possible Am J Nurs 78 1978 610 612