A systematic review of medical practice variation in OECD countries

Health Policy

Volumn 114, Issue 1, 2014, Pages 5-14

  Corallo, Ashley N ^a   Croxford, Ruth ^a   Goodman, David C ^b   Bryan, Elisabeth L ^b   Srivastava, Divya ^c   Stukel, Therese A ^a,b,d  

^a INSTITUTE FOR CLINICAL EVALUATIVE SCIENCES   (Canada)

^b DARTMOUTH INSTITUTE FOR HEALTH POLICY AND CLINICAL PRACTICE   (United States)

^c OECD   (France)

^d UNIVERSITY OF TORONTO   (Canada)

Author keywords

Diagnostic techniques and procedures; Health policy; OECD; Physician practice patterns; Small area analysis; Systematic review; Variations

Indexed keywords

AMBULATORY CARE; ARTICLE; AUSTRALIA; AUSTRIA; BELGIUM; CANADA; DENMARK; ELECTIVE SURGERY; ESTONIA; FINLAND; FRANCE; GERMANY; GREECE; HEALTH CARE POLICY; HEALTH CARE SYSTEM; HOSPITAL; HOSPITAL ADMISSION; HUMAN; HUNGARY; IRELAND; ITALY; JAPAN; MEDICAL LITERATURE; MEDICAL PRACTICE; NETHERLANDS; NEW ZEALAND; NORWAY; PHYSICIAN; PORTUGAL; SPAIN; SWEDEN; SWITZERLAND; SYSTEMATIC REVIEW; UNITED KINGDOM; UNITED STATES; CLINICAL PRACTICE; HEALTH CARE DELIVERY; HOSPITALIZATION; ORGANISATION FOR ECONOMIC CO-OPERATION AND DEVELOPMENT; STATISTICS AND NUMERICAL DATA; SURGERY;

AMBULATORY CARE; DELIVERY OF HEALTH CARE; ELECTIVE SURGICAL PROCEDURES; HOSPITALIZATION; HUMANS; ORGANISATION FOR ECONOMIC CO-OPERATION AND DEVELOPMENT; PHYSICIAN'S PRACTICE PATTERNS; SURGICAL PROCEDURES, OPERATIVE;

EID: 84890961390     PISSN: 01688510     EISSN: 18726054     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.healthpol.2013.08.002     Document Type: Article

References (99)

1. Wennberg J.E., Gittelsohn A.M. Small area variations in health care delivery. Science 1973, 182(117):1102-1108.
2. Wennberg J.E., Dartmouth Atlas of Health Care Working Group The Dartmouth atlas of health care 1996, American Hospital Press International, Chicago.
3. Wennberg J.E., Dartmouth Atlas of Health Care Working Group The Dartmouth atlas of health care 1998 1998, Center for the Evaluative Clinical Sciences, Dartmouth Medical School, Hanover, NH.
4. Wennberg J.E., Dartmouth Atlas of Health Care Working Group The Dartmouth atlas of health care 1999 1999, American Hospital Press International, Hanover, NH.
5. McPherson K., Wennberg J.E., Hovind O.B., Clifford P. Small-area variations in the use of common surgical procedures: an international comparison of New England, England, and Norway. The New England Journal of Medicine 1982, 307(21):1310-1314.
6. Arthritis and related conditions in Ontario: ICES research atlas 2004, Institute for Clinical Evaluative Sciences, Toronto. 2nd ed. E.M. Badley, R.H. Glazier (Eds.).
7. Diabetes in Ontario: an ICES practice atlas 2003, Institute for Clinical Evaluative Sciences, Toronto. J.E. Hux, G.L. Booth, P.M. Slaughter, A. Laupacis (Eds.).
8. Primary care in Ontario: ICES atlas 2006, Institute for Clinical Evaluative Sciences, Toronto, ON. L. Jaakkimainen, R.E.G. Upshur, J.E. Klein-Geltink, A. Leong, S. Maaten, S.E. Schultz (Eds.).
9. CCORT Canadian cardiovascular atlas 2006, Pulsus Group Inc., Toronto. J.V. Tu, W. Ghali, L. Pilote, S. Brien (Eds.).
10. POWER Project for an Ontario women's health evidence-based report 2009, 1. ICES and St. Michael's Hospital, Toronto, ON.
11. POWER Project for an Ontario women's health evidence-based report 2010, 2. ICES and St. Michael's Hospital, Toronto, ON.
12. McGrail K.M., Schaub P., Black C.D. BC health atlas 2004, Centre for Health Services and Policy Research, University of British Columbia, Vancouver, BC. 2nd ed.
13. Morgan S., Raymond C., Mooney D., Martin D. The Canadian Rx atlas 2008, Centre for Health Services and Policy Research, University of British Columbia, Vancouver. 2nd ed.
14. Morgan S., Cunningham C., Hanley G., Mooney D. The British Columbia medical and hospital atlas 2009, Centre for Health Services and Policy Research, University of British Columbia, Vancouver.
15. NHS Right Care The NHS atlas of variation in healthcare, November 2010, National Health Service, London.
16. NHS Right Care The NHS atlas of variation in healthcare, November 2011, National Health Service, London.
17. National Health Performance Authority My hospitals 2013, http://www.myhospitals.gov.au/ (accessed 2.08.13).
18. VPM Atlas Group Atlas de Variaciones en la PracticaMedica en el SistemaNacional De Salud 2009, http://www.atlasvpm.org/ (accessed 2.08.13).
19. Wennberg J.E., McPherson K., Caper P. Will payment based on diagnosis-related groups control hospital costsα. The New England Journal of Medicine 1984, 311(5):295-300.
20. Wennberg J., Gittelsohn A. Variations in medical care among small areas. Scientific American 1982, 246(4):120-134.
21. Wennberg J.E. Population illness rates do not explain population hospitalization rates. A comment on Mark Blumberg's thesis that morbidity adjusters are needed to interpret small area variations. Medical Care 1987, 25(4):354-359.
22. Roos N.P., Wennberg J.E., McPherson K. Using diagnosis-related groups for studying variations in hospital admissions. Health Care Financing Review 1988, 9(4):53-62.
23. Wennberg J.E. Small area analysis and the medical care outcome problem. Research methodology: strengthening causal interpretations of nonexperimental data 1990, 177-206. U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Rockville, MD. L. Sechrest, E. Perrin, J. Bunker (Eds.).
24. Fisher E.S., Wennberg J.E., Stukel T.A., Sharp S.M. Hospital readmission rates for cohorts of Medicare beneficiaries in Boston and New Haven. The New England Journal of Medicine 1994, 331(15):989-995.
25. Fisher E.S., Wennberg D.E., Stukel T.A., Gottlieb D.J., Lucas F.L., Pinder E.L. The implications of regional variations in Medicare spending. Part 1: the content, quality, and accessibility of care. Annals of Internal Medicine 2003, 138(4):273-287.
26. Fisher E.D., Wennberg D.E., Stukel T.A., Gottlieb D.J., Lucas F.L., Pinder E.L. The implications of regional variations in Medicare spending. Part 2: health outcomes and satisfaction with care. Annals of Internal Medicine 2003, 138(4):288-298.
27. Stukel T.A., Lucas F.L., Wennberg D.E. Long-term outcomes of regional variations in intensity of invasive vs medical management of Medicare patients with acute myocardial infarction. Journal of the American Medical Association 2005, 293(11):1329-1337.
28. Goodman D.C., Fisher E.S., Gittelsohn A., Chang C.H., Fleming C. Why are children hospitalizedα The role of non-clinical factors in pediatric hospitalizations. Pediatrics 1994, 93(6 Pt 1):896-902.
29. Greenfield S., Nelson E.C., Zubkoff M., Manning W., Rogers W., Kravitz R.L., et al. Variations in resource utilization among medical specialties and systems of care. Results from the medical outcomes study. Journal of the American Medical Association 1992, 267(12):1624-1630.
30. Wennberg J.E., Barnes B.A., Zubkoff M. Professional uncertainty and the problem of supplier-induced demand. Social Science and Medicine 1982, 16(7):811-824.
31. Wennberg D.E., Kellett M.A., Dickens J.D., Malenka D.J., Keilson L.M., Keller R.B. The association between local diagnostic testing intensity and invasive cardiac procedures. Journal of the American Medical Association 1996, 275(15):1161-1164.
32. Wennberg D.E., Dickens J., Soule D., Kellett M., Malenka D., Robb J., et al. The relationship between the supply of cardiac catheterization laboratories, cardiologists and the use of invasive cardiac procedures in northern New England. Journal of Health Services Research and Policy 1997, 2(2):75-80.
33. Goodman D.C., Fisher E.S., Little G.A., Stukel T.A., Chang C.H., Schoendorf K.S. The relation between the availability of neonatal intensive care and neonatal mortality. The New England Journal of Medicine 2002, 346(20):1538-1544.
34. Chassin M.R. Explaining geographic variations. The enthusiasm hypothesis. Medical Care 1993, 31(5 Suppl.):YS37-YS44.
35. Pearson S.D., Goldman L., Orav E.J., Guadagnoli E., Garcia T.B., Johnson P.A., et al. Triage decisions for emergency department patients with chest pain: do physicians' risk attitudes make the differenceα. Journal of General Internal Medicine 1995, 10(10):557-564.
36. Allison J.J., Kiefe C.I., Cook E.F., Gerrity M.S., Orav E.J., Centor R. The association of physician attitudes about uncertainty and risk taking with resource use in a medicare HMO. Medical Decision Making 1998, 18(3):320-329.
37. Selby J.V., Grumbach K., Quesenberry C.P., Schmittdiel J.A., Truman A.F. Differences in resource use and costs of primary care in a large HMO according to physician specialty. Health Services Research 1999, 34(2):503-518.
38. Wennberg J.E., Fisher E.S., Skinner J.S. Geography and the debate over Medicare reform. Health Affairs (Millwood) 2002, (Suppl):W96-W114. Web exclusives.
39. Paul-Shaheen P., Clark J.D., Williams D. Small area analysis: a review and analysis of the North American literature. Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law 1987, 12(4):741-809.
40. Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development Value for money in health care: analysing variations in medical practices 2011, OECD, Paris.
41. Dombkowski K.J., Cabana M.D., Cohn L.M., Gebremariam A., Clark S.J. Geographic variation of asthma quality measures within and between health plans. American Journal of Managed Care 2005, 11(12):765-772.
42. Hudspeth M.P., Hill T.N., Lewis J.A., Van Meter E., Ragucci D. Post-hematopoietic stem cell transplant immunization practices in the pediatric blood and marrow transplant consortium. Pediatric Blood and Cancer 2010, 54(7):970-975.
43. Koller D., Mielck A. Regional and social differences concerning overweight, participation in health check-ups and vaccination. Analysis of data from a whole birth cohort of 6-year old children in a prosperous German city. BMC Public Health 2009, 9:43.
44. Romain S., Schillaci M.A. Childhood immunization: availability of primary care providers in Ontario. Canadian Family Physician 2009, 55(11):1104-1105.
45. Autier P., Ait O.D. Determinants of the number of mammography units in 31 countries with significant mammography screening. British Journal of Cancer 2008, 99(7):1185-1190.
46. Anttila A., von Karsa L., Aasmaa A., Fender M., Patnick J., Rebolj M., et al. Cervical cancer screening policies and coverage in Europe. European Journal of Cancer 2009, 45(15):2649-2658.
47. Cooper G.S., Koroukian S.M. Geographic variation among Medicare beneficiaries in the use of colorectal carcinoma screening procedures. The American Journal of Gastroenterology 2004, 99(8):1544-1550.
48. McDonald J.T., Sherman A. Determinants of mammography use in rural and urban regions of Canada. Canadian Journal of Rural Medicine 2010, 15(2):52-60.
49. Khan N., Kaestner R., Salmon J.W., Gutierrez B. Does supply influence mammography screeningα. American Journal of Health Behavior 2010, 34(4):465-475.
50. Coughlin S.S., Leadbetter S., Richards T., Sabatino S.A. Contextual analysis of breast and cervical cancer screening and factors associated with health care access among United States women, 2002. Social Science and Medicine 2008, 66(2):260-275.
51. Coory M.D., Fagan P.S., Muller J.M., Dunn N.A. Participation in cervical cancer screening by women in rural and remote Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander communities in Queensland. Medical Journal of Australia 2002, 177(10):544-547.
52. Santora L.M., Mahoney M.C., Lawvere S., Englert J.J., Symons A.B., Mirand A.L. Breast cancer screening beliefs by practice location. BMC Public Health 2003, 39.
53. Symons A.B., Mahoney M.C., Englert J., Mirand A.L. Variations in approaches to breast cancer screening among primary care physicians. Journal of Cancer Education 2002, 17(4):205-210.
54. Haggerty J., Tudiver F., Brown J.B., Herbert C., Ciampi A., Guibert R. Patients' anxiety and expectations: how they influence family physicians' decisions to order cancer screening tests. Canadian Family Physician 2005, 511658-511659.
55. You J.J., Purdy I., Rothwell D.M., Przbysz R., Fang J., Laupacis A. Indications for and results of outpatient computed tomography and magnetic resonance imaging in Ontario. Canadian Association of Radiologists Journal 2008, 59(3):135-143.
56. Coburn N., Przybysz R., Barbera L., Hodgson D., Sharir S., Lauacis A., et al. CT, MRI and ultrasound scanning rates: evaluation of cancer diagnosis, staging and surveillance in Ontario. Journal of Surgical Oncology 2008, 98(7):490-499.
57. Fox K.A., Cokkinos D.V., Deckers J., Keil U., Maggioni A., Steg G. The ENACT study: a pan-European survey of acute coronary syndromes. European network for acute coronary treatment. European Heart Journal 2000, 21(17):1440-1449.
58. Niemann T., Lous J., Thorsgaard N., Nielsen T.T. Regional variations in the use of diagnostic coronary angiography. A one-year population-based study of all diagnostic coronary angiographies performed in a rural and an urban Danish county. Scandinavian Cardiovascular Journal 2000, 34(3):286-292.
59. Filan P.M., Inder T.E., Anderson P.J., Doyle L.W., Hunt R.W. Monitoring the neonatal brain: a survey of current practice among Australian and New Zealand neonatologists. Journal of Paediatrics and Child Health 2007, 43(7-8):557-559.
60. Lysdahl K.B., Borretzen I. Geographical variation in radiological services: a nationwide survey. BMC Health Services Research 2007, 7:21.
61. Oh E.H., Imanaka Y., Evans E. Determinants of the diffusion of computed tomography and magnetic resonance imaging. International Journal of Technology Assessment in Health Care 2005, 21(1):73-80.
62. Garg P.P., Landrum M.B., Normand S.L., Ayanian J.Z., Hauptman P.J., Ryan T.J., et al. Understanding individual and small area variation in the underuse of coronary angiography following acute myocardial infarction. Medical Care 2002, 40(7):614-626.
63. Bipat S., van Leeuwen M.S., Ijzermans J.N., Bossuyt P.M., Greve J.W., Stoker J. Imaging and treatment of patients with colorectal liver metastases in the Netherlands: a survey. Netherlands Journal of Medicine 2006, 64(5):147-151.
64. Saigal C.S., Pashos C.L., Henning J.M., Litwin M.S. Variations in use of imaging in a national sample of men with early-stage prostate cancer. Urology 2002, 59(3):400-404.
65. Wunsch H., Angus D.C., Harrison D.A., Collange O., Fowler R., Hoste E.A., et al. Variation in critical care services across North America and Western Europe. Critical Care Medicine 2008, 36(10):2787-2793. [Review] [62 refs].
66. Fisher E.S., Wennberg J.E., Stukel T.A., Skinner J.S., Sharp S.M., Freeman J.L., et al. Associations among hospital capacity, utilization, and mortality of US Medicare beneficiaries, controlling for sociodemographic factors. Health Services Research 2000, 34(6):1351-1362.
67. Busato A., Matter P., Kunzi B. Factors related to treatment intensity in Swiss primary care. BMC Health Services Research 2009, 949.
68. Westert G.P., Groenewegen P.P., Boshuizen H.C., Spreeuwenberg P.M., Steultjens M.P. Medical practice variations in hospital care; time trends of a spatial phenomenon. Health Place 2004, 10(3):215-220.
69. Ansari Z., Carson N., Serraglio A., Barbetti T., Cicuttini F. The victorian ambulatory care sensitive conditions study: reducing demand on hospital services in Victoria. Australian Health Review 2002, 25(2):71-77.
70. Magan P., Otero A., Alberquilla A., Ribera J.M. Geographic variations in avoidable hospitalizations in the elderly, in a health system with universal coverage. BMC Health Services Research 2008, 842.
71. Chen L.W., Zhang W., Sun J., Mueller K.J. The magnitude, variation, and determinants of rural hospital resource utilization associated with hospitalizations due to ambulatory care sensitive conditions. Journal of Public Health Management and Practice 2009, 15(3):216-222.
72. Alter D.A., Austin P.C., Tu J.V., Canadian Cardiovascular Outcomes Research Team Community factors, hospital characteristics and inter-regional outcome variations following acute myocardial infarction in Canada. Canadian Journal of Cardiology 2005, 21(3):247-255.
73. Alter D.A., Naylor C.D., Austin P.C., Tu J.V. Long-term MI outcomes at hospitals with or without on-site revascularization. Journal of the American Medical Association 2001, 285(16):2101-2108.
74. Saleh S.S., Hannan E.L., Ting L. A multistate comparison of patient characteristics, outcomes, and treatment practices in acute myocardial infarction. American Journal of Cardiology 2005, 96(9):1190-1196.
75. Subramanian U., Weinberger M., Eckert G.J., L'Italien G.J., Lapuerta P., Tierney W. Geographic variation in health care utilization and outcomes in veterans with acute myocardial infarction. Journal of General Internal Medicine 2002, 17(8):604-611.
76. Kaul P., Newby L.K., Fu Y., Mark D.B., Califf R.M., Topol E.J., et al. International differences in evolution of early discharge after acute myocardial infarction. Lancet 2004, 363(9408):511-517.
77. Roberts C.M., Lowe D., Bucknall C.E., Ryland I., Kelly Y., Pearson M.G. Clinical audit indicators of outcome following admission to hospital with acute exacerbation of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease. Thorax 2002, 57(2):137-141.
78. Rowe B.H., Cydulka R.K., Tsai C.L., Clark S., Sinclair D., Camargo C.A. Comparison of Canadian versus United States emergency department visits for chronic obstructive pulmonary disease exacerbation. Canadian Respiratory Journal 2008, 15(6):295-301.
79. Koval K.J., Lurie J., Khou W., Sparks M.B., Cantu R.V., Sporer S.M., et al. Ankle fractures in the elderly: what you get depends on where you live and who you see. Journal of Orthopaedic Trauma 2005, 19(9):635-639.
80. Judge A., Welton N.J., Sandhu J., Ben-Shlomo Y. Geographical variation in the provision of elective primary hip and knee replacement: the role of socio-demographic, hospital and distance variables. Journal of Public Health 2009, 31(3):413-422.
81. Skinner J., Weinstein J.N., Sporer S.M., Wennberg J.E. Racial, ethnic, and geographic disparities in rates of knee arthroplasty among Medicare patients. The New England Journal of Medicine 2003, 349(14):1350-1359.
82. Rodrigues E.J., Simpson E., Richard H., Pilote L. Regional variation in the management of acute myocardial infarction in the province of Quebec. Canadian Journal of Cardiology 2002, 18(10):1067-1076.
83. Chang W.C., Midodzi W.K., Westerhout C.M., Boersma E., Cooper J., Barnathan E.S., et al. Are international differences in the outcomes of acute coronary syndromes apparent or realα A multilevel analysis. Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health 2005, 59(5):427-433.
84. Lucas F.L., Siewers A.E., Malenka D.J., Wennberg D.E. Diagnostic-therapeutic cascade revisited: coronary angiography, coronary artery bypass graft surgery, and percutaneous coronary intervention in the modern era. Circulation 2008, 118(25):2797-2802.
85. Restuccia J.D., Shwartz M., Kreger B.E., Payne S.M., Ash A.S., Iezzoni L.I., et al. Does more "appropriateness" explain higher rates of cardiac procedures among patients hospitalized with coronary heart diseaseα. Medical Care 2002, 40(6):500-509.
86. Lanham S., Basneett I., McCartney P., Normand C., Pickering J., Sheers D., et al. Addressing the inverse care law in cardiac services. Journal of Public Health Medicine 2003, 25(3):202-207.
87. Baicker K., Buckles K.S., Chandra A. Geographic variation in the appropriate use of cesarean delivery. Health Affairs (Millwood) 2006, 25(5):w355-w367.
88. Hueston W.J., Lewis-Stevenson S. Provider distribution and variations in statewide cesarean section rates. Journal of Community Health 2001, 26(1):1-10.
89. Brennan D.J., Robson M.S., Murphy M., O'Herlihy C. Comparative analysis of international cesarean delivery rates using 10-group classification identifies significant variation in spontaneous labor. American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology 2009, 201(3):308.
90. Coonrod D.V., Drachman D., Hobson P., Manriquez M. Nulliparous term singleton vertex cesarean delivery rates: institutional and individual level predictors. American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology 2008, 198(6):694-711.
91. Bragg F., Cromwell D.A., Edozien L.C., Gurol-Urganci I., Mahmood T.A., Templeton A., et al. Variation in rates of caesarean section among English NHS trusts after accounting for maternal and clinical risk: cross sectional study. British Medical Journal 2010, 341:c5065.
92. Hanley G.E., Janssen P.A., Greyson D. Regional variation in the cesarean delivery and assisted vaginal delivery rates. Obstetrics and Gynecology 2010, 115(6):1201-1208.
93. Linton A., Peterson M.R., Williams T.V. Clinical case mix adjustment of cesarean delivery rates in U.S. military hospitals, 2002. Obstetrics and Gynecology 2005, 105(3):598-606.
94. Gold H.T., Dick A.W., Gold H.T., Dick A.W. Variations in treatment for ductal carcinoma in situ in elderly women. Medical Care 2004, 42(3):267-275.
95. Mandelblatt J.S., Berg C.D., Meropol N.J., Edge S.B., Gold K., Hwang Y.T., et al. Measuring and predicting surgeons' practice styles for breast cancer treatment in older women. Medical Care 2001, 39(3):228-242.
96. Katz S.J., Hawley S.T., Abrahamse P., Morrow M., Friese C.R., Alderman A.K., et al. Does it matter where you go for breast surgeryα attending surgeon's influence on variation in receipt of mastectomy for breast cancer. Medical Care 2010, 48(10):892-899.
97. Caldon L.J., Walters S.J., Reed J.A., Murphy A., Worley A., Reed M.W. Case-mix fails to explain variation in mastectomy rates: management of screen-detected breast cancer in a UK region 1997-2003. British Journal of Cancer 2005, 92(1):55-59.
98. Downing A., Lansdown M., West R.M., Thomas J.D., Lawrence G., Forman D. Changes in and predictors of length of stay in hospital after surgery for breast cancer between 1997/98 and 2004/05 in two regions of England: a population-based study. BMC Health Services Research 2009, 9202.
99. van Steenbergen L.N., van de Poll-Franse L.V., Wouters M.W., Jansen-Landheer M.L., Coebergh J.W., Stuikmans H., et al. Variation in management of early breast cancer in the Netherlands, 2003-2006. European Journal of Surgical Oncology 2010, 36:Suppl 1S36-S43.