Towards an architecture of dissensus: Participatory urbanism in South-East Asia

Footprint

Volumn , Issue 13, 2013, Pages 41-62

  Boano, Camillo ^a   Kelling, Emily ^a,b  

^a UNIVERSITY COLLEGE LONDON   (United Kingdom)

^b TECHNISCHE UNIVERSITÄT BERLIN   (Germany)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

EID: 84890465048     PISSN: 18751504     EISSN: 18751490     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: None     Document Type: Article

References (127)

1. Somsook Boonyabancha, Norberto Carcellar and Thomas Kerr, 'How Poor Communities are Paving their own Pathways to Freedom', in Environment and Urbanization, 24, 2 (Autumn 2012), pp. 441-62 (p. 461).
2. This paper is based on a research collaboration between the Development Planning Unit (DPU) and the Community Organisations Development Institute (CODI), the Asian Coalition for Housing Rights (ACHR), and the Community Architect Networks (CAN). In particular, it is the result of reflections on the Baan Mankong Housing Programme that have emerged in the course of three research projects by two of the DPU's Masters programmes (MSc Building and Urban Design in Development and MSc Urban Development Planning), which took place in 2011, 2012 and 2013 in Bangkok, where several communities at different stages of implementation were involved.
3. Mark Purcell, The Down-Deep Delight of Democracy (London: Blackwell-Wiley, 2013).
4. Slavoj Žižek, The Ticklish Subject: The Absent Centre of Political Ontology, (London: Verso, 1999).
5. Chantal Mouffe, On the Political (London: Routledge, 2005).
6. Bill Cooke and Uma Kothari, Participation: The New Tyranny?, (London; New York: Zed Books Ltd, 2001).
7. Markus Miessen, The Nightmare of Participation (Berlin: Sternberg, 2010).
8. Ronan Paddison, 'Some Reflections on the Limitations to Public Participation in the Post-Political City', L'Espace Politique, 8, 2 (2009), < http://espacepolitique.revues.org/1393 > [accessed 01 August 2013].
9. Gui Bonsiepe, 'Design and democracy', Design Issue, 21, 2 (2006), pp. 3-12.
10. Paddison, 'Some Reflections on the Limitations to Public Participation in the Post-Political City'.
11. Paddison, 'Some Reflections on the Limitations to Public Participation in the Post-Political City'.
12. Alexandre Apsan Frediani and Camillo Boano, 'Processes for Just Products: The Capability Space of Participatory Design', in The Capability Approach, Technology and Design, ed. by Ilse Oosterlaken and Jeroen van den Hoven (= Philosophy of Engineering and Technology, 5 (2012), pp. 203-22.
13. Bechir Kenzari, Architecture and violence (Barcelona: Actar, 2011).
14. Nadir Lahiji, 'Is Building the Practice of Dissensus? Architecture between Aesthetics and Politics'. Paper presented at Architecture and the Political, Fourth International Symposium on Architectural Theory, Beirut, Lebanon, 10-12 November 2011, [accessed 04 March 2013].
15. Mustafa Dikeç, 'Politics is Sublime', Environment and Planning D: Society and Space, 30 (2012), pp. 262-79.
16. Mustafa Dikeç, 'Immigrants, Banlieues, and Dangerous Things: Ideology as an Aesthetic Affair', Antipode, 45, 1 (2013), pp. 23-42.
17. Purcell, The Down-Deep Delight of Democracy.
18. C. Greig Crysler, Stephen Cairns and Hilde Heynen, 'Introduction', in The SAGE Handbook of Architectural Theory, ed. by C. Greig Crysler, Stephen Cairns and Hilde Heynen (Cornwell: SAGE Publications, 2012), pp. 1-38.
19. Reinhold Martin, Utopia's Ghost (Minneapolis; London: Minnesota University Press, 2005).
20. Jeremy Till, Architecture Depends (Cambridge, Mass., MIT Press, 2009).
21. Ole W. Fischer, 'Architecture, Capitalism and Criticality', in The SAGE Handbook of Architectural Theory, ed. by C. Greig Crysler and others, pp. 56-69.
22. Henry Sanoff, Community Participation Methods in Design and Planning (New York: Wiley, 2000).
23. Henry Sanoff, 'Multiple Views on Participatory Design', International Journal of Architectural Research, 2, 1 (2007), pp. 57-69.
24. Jaime Hernandez-Garcia, 'Slum Tourism, City Branding and Social Urbanism: the Case of Medellin, Colombia', Journal of Place Management and Development, 6, 1 (2013), pp. 43-51.
25. Kurt Iveson, 'Cities Within the City: Do It Yourself Urbanism and the Right to the City', in International Journal of Urban Research, 37, 3 (2013), pp. 941-56.
26. Margit Mayer, 'First World Urban Activism: Beyond Austerity Urbanism and Creative City Politics', City, 7, 1 (2013), pp. 5-19.
27. Purcell, The Down-Deep Delight of Democracy.
28. As Ettore Sottsass eloquently commented in the late 1960s, 'design is a way of discussing life... of discussing society, politics, eroticism, food and even design. At the end, it is a way of building up a possible figurative utopia or metaphor about life' (Paola Antonelli, 'States of Design 04: Critical Design', Domus, [Accessed 21 February 2013]). Hence, design becomes a condition of possibility in which excess rudely intrudes into otherwise ontologically and politically stable orders, allowing what was previously invisible or unheeded to emerge within a societal and political realm.
29. This recent shift in architectural, design and development debates seems to have two angles. On one side, design practitioners are searching for a specific ethical role by investigating the complexities of architecture and urbanism. This shift comprises designing spaces, places and interventions that enable socially just development, produce alternative means of engagement, and reconsider citizenship and participation (see Ann Thorpe, 'Design as Activism: A Conceptual Tool' presented at the Changing the Change, Turin, Italy, 2010.
30. Carl DiSalvo, 'Design, Democracy and Agonistic Pluralism', in Proceedings of the Design Research Society Conference, Montreal, (2010), [accessed 06 August 2013].
31. Alastair Fuad-Luke, Design Activism, Beautiful Strangeness for a Sustainable World (London: Earthscan, 2009).
32. Thomas Markussen, 'The Disruptive Aesthetics of Design Activism: Enacting Design Between Art and Politics', in Making Design Matter, Nordes, the 4th Nordic Design Research Conference, 29-31 May 2011, School of Art and Design, Aalto University, Helsinki, pp. 1-9; < http://ocs.sfu.ca/nordes/index.php/nordes/2011/paper/view/406 > [accessed 07 August 2013].
33. Nadir Lahiji, The Political Unconscious of Architecture. Re-opening Jameson's Narrative (Farnham, Surrey.
34. Pierluigi Nicolin, 'Architecture Meets People', Lotus International, 145 (2011), pp. 12-14.
35. Beyond Shelter. Architecture and Human Dignity, ed. by Marie Aquilino (New York; Los Angeles: Metropolis Book, 2011).
36. Yet, despite interesting methodological innovations and a clear emphasis on agency, the political dimension remains unquestioned.
37. Jacques Rancière, Hatred of Democracy, (London: Verso, 2006), p. 13.
38. Jacques Rancière, Disagreement: Politics and Philosophy, trans. by Julie Rose, (Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press, 1999), p. 30.
39. Peter Hallward, 'Jacques Rancière and the Subversion of Mastery', in Jacques Rancière: Aesthetics, Politics, Philosophy, ed. by Mark Robson (Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press, 2005), pp. 26-45 (p. 26).
40. Jacques Rancière, 'The Thinking of Dissensus: Politics and Aesthetics', in Reading Rancière: Critical Dissensus, ed. by Paul Bowman and Richard Stamp (London; New York: Continuum, 2011), pp. 1-17 (p. 7).
41. The Community Organisations Development Institute (CODI) was established in July 2000 as a public organisation under the Ministry of Social Development and Human Security in Thailand following the merge between the Urban Community Development Office (UCDO) and the Rural Development Fund (see Somsook Boonyabancha, 'A Decade of Change: From the Urban Community Development Office (UCDO) to the Community Organizations Development Institute (CODI) in Thailand: Increasing Community Options Through a National Government Development Programme' IIED Working Paper 12 on Poverty Reduction in Urban Areas (2003), pp. i-36).
42. CODI website, 'CODI Results: Statistics January 2011' < http://www.codi.or.th/housing/results.html > [accessed 26 February 2013].
43. Guided by the premises of 'unlocking people energy' (Somsook Boonyabancha, 'Unlocking People Energy', in Our Planet: The magazine of the United Nations Environment Programme, 16, 1 (2005), pp. 22-3) and placing people as subjects, rather than objects, of development, it supports and empowers urban and rural community organisations through financial assistance and skills training in the process of housing development. In addition, ACHR was formed in 1988 as the first platform for the exchange of knowledge and experience by different urban activist organisations in the Asian region. They aimed to advance housing rights and tackle urban poverty in a context of increasing forced evictions. While initially focused on forced evictions, a DFID grant allowed for capacity-development towards a regional intervention process. Since 2000, ACHR has been working with community savings and the model of the Community Development Fund. In some countries, ACHR receives support from governments whereas in others it has managed to up-scale its programmes independently. The Asian Coalition for Community Action Programme (ACCA) is the culmination of ACHR's efforts and in the three years it has been running, 2010-2013, it has reached 165 cities in 19 countries.
44. 'About ACHR', < http://www.achr.net/ > [accessed 18 July 2013]).
45. Though Rancière shares some common ground with other Left-leaning thinkers who sought an alternative to Marxism, especially after his break with Althusserian structuralism and philosophy due to its elitism. He rejected the rigid and hierarchical distinction between science and ideology that this philosophy presupposed, accusing it of distrusting spontaneous popular movements. Refusing the Althusserian approach, he turned instead to the archive in the form of an intellectual history of labour. This was an attempt to recover the virtue of 'the worker' by showing that workers resist not merely the hardship of work but the very system that confines them to the role of worker in the first place (Samuel A. Chambers, 'Jacques Rancière and the Problem of Pure Politics, European Journal of Political Theory, 10, 3 (2010), pp. 303-26).
46. The Philosopher and his Poor (Durham: Duke University Press, 2004).
47. Jacques Rancière, 'Ten Theses on Politics' Theory & Event, 5, 3 (2001) < http://muse.jhu.edu/journals/theory_and_event/v005/5.3ranciere.html > [accessed 05 January 2013].
48. Samuel A. Chambers, 'Jacques Rancière and the Problem of Pure Politics'.
49. Andrew Schaap, 'Hannah Arendt and the Philosophical Repression of Politics' in Jacques Rancière and the Contemporary Scene. The Philosophy of Radical Equality, Jean-Philippe Deranty and Alison Ross (London: Continuum, 2012), pp. 145-166; Reading Rancière, ed. by Bowman and Stamp.
50. Michel Foucault, The History of Sexuality, Vol. 1: An Introduction, trans. by Robert Hurley (London: Penguin, 1980), p. 93.
51. Rancière, Disagreement: Politics and Philosophy, p. 29.
52. Rancière, 'Ten Theses on Politics'.
53. Maria Muhle, 'Politics, Police and Power: From Foucault and Rancière' (unpublished paper presented at the Jan Van Eyck Akademie, Maastricht, 8th November 2007); Reading Rancière, ed. by Bowman and Stamp.
54. Not surprisingly, like many other postwar French speaking intellectuals who worked on language as a place where 'perilous crossings of epistemic thresholds leave their material traces (Rey Chow and Julian Rohrhuber, 'On Captivation: a Remainder from the Indistinction of Art and Nonart' in Reading Rancière, ed. by Bowman and Stamp, pp. 44-72 (p. 33).
55. Mustafa Dikeç, 'Police, Politics, and the Right to the City', GeoJournal, 58, 2-3 (2002), pp. 91-8.
56. Giuseppina Mecchia, 'The Classics and Critical Theory in Postmodern France: The case of Jacques Rancière' in Jacques Rancière: History, Politics, Aesthetics, ed. by Gabriel Rockhill and Philip Watts (Duke University Press, 2009), p. 77.
57. Jacques Rancière, 'Xénophobie et politique, entretien avec Jacques Rancière' [Xenophobia and politics, talks with Jacques Rancière], in La xénophobie en banlieue, effets et expressions, ed. By Florence Haegel, Henri Rey and Yves Sintomer (Paris: L'Harmattan, 2000), p. 215.
58. Mark Angélil and Cary Siress, 'The Paris Banlieue: Peripheries of Inequity', Journal of International Affairs, 65, 2 (Spring/Summer 2012), pp. 57-67 (p. 64).
59. Dikeç, 'Police, Politics, and the Right to the City'.
60. Derek Ruez, '"Partitioning the Sensible" at Park 51.
61. Jacques Rancière, Dissensus on Politics and Aesthetics, trans. and ed. by Steven Corcoran (London: Continuum, 2010), p. 22.
62. Jacques Rancière, The Philosopher and his Poor, trans. by John Drury, Corinne Oster and Andrew Parker, ed. by Andrew Parker (Durham: Duke University Press, 2004), p. 13.
63. Purcell, The Down-Deep Delight of Democracy.
64. Rancière, Disagreement: Politics and Philosophy, p. 30.
65. Jacques Rancière, The Politics of Aesthetics: The Distribution of the Sensible, trans. by Gabriel Rockhill (London; New York: Continuum, 2006), p. 13.
66. J. M. Bernstein, 'Movies and the Great Democratic Art form of the Modern World (Notes on Rancière)', in Jacques Rancière and the Contemporary Scene, ed. by Deranty and Ross, pp. 15-42 (p. 269).
67. John Holloway, Change the World Without Taking Power (London: Pluto Press, 2005).
68. Mustafa Dikeç, 'Space, Politics, and the Political', Environment and Planning D: Society and Space, 23 (2005), p. 172.
69. Rancière, Disagreement: Politics and Philosophy, p. 29.
70. Bernstein, 'Movies and the great democratic art form of the modern world', p. 25.
71. Ruez, '"Partitioning the Sensible" at Park 51', p. 2.
72. Boonyabancha, Carcellar and Kerr, 'How Poor Communities are Paving Their Own Pathways to Freedom', p. 443.
73. Boonyabancha, Carcellar and Kerr, 'How Poor Communities are Paving Their Own Pathways to Freedom', p. 443.
74. Boonyabancha, Carcellar and Kerr, 'How Poor Communities are Paving Their Own Pathways to Freedom', p. 443.
75. Boonyabancha, 'A Decade of Change', p. 15.
76. Asha Ghosh and Lalitha Kamath, 'Decentralisation and Local Government Innovation in Providing Urban Services for the Poor in South and South-East Asia' Space and Polity, 16, 1 (2012), pp. 49-71 (p. 59).
77. Diane Archer, 'Baan Mankong Participatory Slum Upgrading in Bangkok, Thailand: Community Perceptions of Outcomes and Security of Tenure', Habitat International, 36 (2012), pp. 178-84.
78. Diane Archer, 'Baan Mankong Participatory Slum Upgrading in Bangkok, Thailand: Community Perceptions of Outcomes and Security of Tenure', Habitat International, 36 (2012), pp. 178-84.
79. ACCA website, 'Home', < http://www.achr.net/ACCA/ACCA%20home.html > [accessed 18 July 2013].
80. Somsook Boonyabancha and Diana Mitlin, 'Urban Poverty Reduction: Learning by Doing in Asia', Environment and Urbanization, 24, 2 (2012), pp. 403-21 (p. 417).
81. Ghosh and Kamath, 'Decentralisation and Local Government Innovation', p. 70.
82. Boonyabancha, Carcellar and Kerr, 'How Poor Communities Are Paving Their Own Pathways to Freedom', p. 447.
83. Boonyabancha, 'Unlocking People Energy', p. 22.
84. Speaking is a community member from Iloilo, cited in Ruby Papeleras, Ofelia Bagotlo, and Somsook Boonyabancha, 'A Conversation About Change-Making by Communities: Some Experiences from ACCA', Environment and Urbanization, 24, 2 (2012), pp. 463-80 (p. 473).
85. Student Report of the MSc Urban Development Planning on Co-production of Slum-Upgrading in Bangkok, The Bartlett Development Planning Unit, University College London, 2012.
86. Diana Mitlin, 'With and Beyond the State-Co-production as a Route to Political Influence, Power and Transformation for Grassroots Organisations', Environment and Urbanization, 20, 2 (2008), pp. 339-60.
87. Papeleras, Bagotlo and Boonyabancha, 'A Conversation about Change-Making by Communities', p. 465.
88. Boonyabancha and Mitlin, 'Urban Poverty Reduction', p. 403.
89. Boonyabancha and Mitlin, 'Urban Poverty Reduction', p. 403.
90. Boonyabancha and Mitlin, 'Urban Poverty Reduction'.
91. Boonyabancha, Carcellar and Kerr, 'How Poor Communities Are Paving Their Own Pathways to Freedom', p. 445.
92. Boonyabancha and Mitlin, 'Urban Poverty Reduction', p. 445.
93. Diane Archer, 'Finance as the Key to Unlocking Community Potential: Savings, Funds and the ACCA Programme' Environment and Urbanization, 24, 2 (2012), pp. 423-40.
94. Papeleras, Bagotlo and Boonyabancha, 'A Conversation about Change-Making by Communities', p. 475.
95. Boonyabancha, Carcellar and Kerr, 'How Poor Communities Are Paving Their Own Pathways to Freedom', p. 453.
96. William Hunter, 'Decoding Bangkok's Pocket-Urbanization: Social Housing Provision and the Role of Community Architects', Archinect (2011) < http://archinect.com/features/article/25485248/decoding-bangkok-s-pocket-urbanization-social-housing-provision-and-the-role-of-community-architects > [accessed 26 February 2013]
97. Rittirong Chutapruttikorn, 'Squatter Life in Transition: An Evaluation of Participatory Housing Design', FORUM Ejournal: International Ejournal for Postgraduate Studies in Architecture, Planning and Landscape, 9, 1 (2009), pp. 13-30 (p. 19).
98. Papeleras, Bagotlo and Boonyabancha, 'A Conversation about Change-Making by Communities', p. 476.
99. Papeleras, Bagotlo and Boonyabancha, 'A Conversation about Change-Making by Communities', p. 476.
100. Archer, 'Baan Mankong Participatory Slum Upgrading in Bangkok, Thailand', p. 180.
101. Archer, 'Baan Mankong Participatory Slum Upgrading in Bangkok, Thailand', p. 180.
102. Archer, 'Baan Mankong Participatory Slum Upgrading in Bangkok, Thailand', p. 180.
103. Boonyabancha, Carcellar and Kerr, 'How Poor Communities Are Paving Their Own Pathways to Freedom', p. 451.
104. Papeleras, Bagotlo and Boonyabancha, 'A Conversation about Change-Making by Communities', p. 477.
105. Bart Wissink, Renske Dijkwel and Ronald Meijer, 'Bangkok Boundaries: Social Networks in the City of Mubahnchatsan', Journal of Environmental Design, 1 (2006), pp. 59-74.
106. Chutapruttikorn, 'Squatter Life in Transition', p. 19.
107. Archer, 'Baan Mankong Participatory Slum Upgrading in Bangkok, Thailand', p. 180.
108. Rancière, Disagreement: Politics and Philosophy, p. 15.
109. Rancière, Disagreement: Politics and Philosophy, p. 15.
110. Caren Levy, 'Defining Collective Strategic Action Led by Civil Society Organizations: the Case of CLIFF, India', 8th N-AERUS Conference, September 6th-8th 2007 (London: N-AERUS), pp. 1-29.
111. Chawanad Luansang, Supawut Boonmahathanakorn and Marie Lourdes Domingo-Price, 'The Role of Community Architects in Upgrading; Reflecting on the Experience in Asia' Environment and Urbanization 24, 2, (2012), p. 502.
112. R. Papeleras, O. Bagotlo, S. Boonyabancha, 'A Conversation about Change-Making by Communities: Some Experiences from ACCA' Environment and Urbanization 24,2, (2012), p. 477-9.
113. Luansang, Boonmahathanakorn and Domingo-Price, 'The Role of Community Architects in Upgrading; Reflecting on the Experience in Asia' (p. 500).
114. Hunter, 'Decoding Bangkok's Pocket-Urbanization'.
115. CAN [Community Architects Network], CAN, community architects network documentary film Feb 2013. [Online video] < https://www.facebook.com/CommunityArchitectsNetwork > [accessed 26 February 2013].
116. John F. C. Turner, Housing by People, (London: Marion Boyars, 1979).
117. Prapart Sangpradap [Bang Bua community leader], in CAN, community architects network documentary film Feb 2013', ed. by CAN [Community Architects Network], < https://www.facebook.com/CommunityArchitectsNetwork > [accessed 26 February 2013].
118. Luansang, Boonmahathanakorn and Domingo-Price, 'The Role of Community Architects in Upgrading', p. 502.
119. Luansang, Boonmahathanakorn and Domingo-Price, 'The Role of Community Architects in Upgrading', p. 502.
120. Boonyabancha, Carcellar and Kerr, 'How Poor Communities Are Paving Their Own Pathways to Freedom', p. 461.
121. Jacques Rancière, The Emancipated Spectator, (London: Continuum, 2009), p. 56.
122. Erik Swyngedouw, 'Designing the Post-Political City and the Insurgent Polis', in Civic City Cahier, 5 (London: Bedford Press, 2011) p. 25.
123. Miessen, The Nightmare of Participation.
124. Rancière, Disagreement: Politics and Philosophy, p. 30.
125. Rancière, Disagreement: Politics and Philosophy, p. 30.
126. Purcell, The Down-Deep Delight of Democracy, p. 81.
127. Swyngedouw, 'Designing the Post-Political City and The Insurgent Polis', p. 25.