Hospital board oversight of quality and patient safety: A narrative review and synthesis of recent empirical research

Milbank Quarterly

Volumn 91, Issue 4, 2013, Pages 738-770

  Millar, Ross ^a   Mannion, Russell ^a   Freeman, Tim ^b   Davies, Huw T O ^c  

^a UNIVERSITY OF BIRMINGHAM   (United Kingdom)

^b MIDDLESEX UNIVERSITY   (United Kingdom)

^c UNIVERSITY OF ST ANDREWS   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

g overning boards; patient safety; quality improvement; trustees

Indexed keywords

ARTICLE; BOARD OF TRUSTEES; EMPIRICAL RESEARCH; HEALTH CARE POLICY; HEALTH CARE QUALITY; HOSPITAL; HUMAN; PATIENT SAFETY; PRIORITY JOURNAL; PUBLICATION; TOTAL QUALITY MANAGEMENT; UNITED STATES;

GOVERNING BOARDS; PATIENT SAFETY; QUALITY IMPROVEMENT; TRUSTEES;

EMPIRICAL RESEARCH; GOVERNING BOARD; HOSPITAL ADMINISTRATION; HOSPITALS; HUMANS; PATIENT SAFETY; QUALITY OF HEALTH CARE;

EID: 84890260160     PISSN: 0887378X     EISSN: 14680009     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1111/1468-0009.12032     Document Type: Article

References (81)

1. Alexander, J.A., and, S.Y. Lee,. 2006. Does Governance Matter? Board Configuration and Performance in Not-for-Profit Hospitals. The Milbank Quarterly 84: 733-58.
2. Alexander, J.A., B.J. Weiner, and, M. Succi,. 2000. Community Accountability among Hospitals Affiliated with Health Care Systems. The Milbank Quarterly 78: 157-84.
3. Alexander, J.A., G.J. Young, B.J. Weiner, and, L.R. Hearld,. 2009. How Do System-Affiliated Hospitals Fare in Providing Community Benefit? Inquiry 46 (1): 72-91.
4. Bader, B.S., 1993. CQI Progress Reports: The Dashboard Approach Provides a Better Way to Keep Board Informed about Quality. Healthcare Executive 8: 8-11.
5. Bader, B.S., 2006. Best Practices for Board Quality Committees. Great Boards. Available at http://www.greatboards.org/newsletter/reprints/Board- quality-committees-best-practices.pdf (accessed July 10, 2013).
6. Baker, G.R., J.L. Denis, M.P. Pomey, and, A. MacIntosh-Murray,. 2010. Effective Governance for Quality and Patient Safety in Canadian Healthcare Organizations: A Report to the Canadian Health Services Research Foundation and the Canadian Patient Safety Institute. Ottawa: CHSRF/CPSI.
7. Belmont, E., C.C. Haltom, D.A. Hastings, et al. 2011a. Quality in Action: Paradigm for a Hospital Board-Driven Quality Program. Journal of Health Life Sciences and Law 24 (2): 95-145.
8. Belmont, E., C.C. Haltom, D.A. Hastings, et al. 2011b. A New Quality Compass: Hospital Boards' Increased Role under the Affordable Care Act. Health Affairs 30 (7): 1282-89.
9. Chambers, N., and, C. Cornforth,. 2010. The Role of Corporate Governance and Boards in Organisation Performance. In From Knowing to Doing: Connecting Knowledge and Performance in Public Services, ed., K. Walshe, and, G. Harvey, 99-127. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
10. Clarke, J.R., J.C. Lerner, and, W. Marella,. 2007. The Role for Leaders of Health Care Organizations in Patient Safety. American Journal of Medical Quality 22 (5): 311-18.
11. Clough, J., and, D.J. Nash,. 2007. Health Care Governance for Quality and Safety: The New Agenda. American Journal of Medical Quality 22 (5): 203-13.
12. Conway, J., 2008. Getting Boards on Board: Engaging Governing Boards in Quality and Safety. Joint Commission Journal on Quality and Patient Safety 34 (4): 214-20.
13. Curran, C.R., and, M. K. Totten,. 2010. Quality, Patient Safety, and the Board. Nursing Economics 28 (4): 273-75.
14. Davies, H.T.O., and, R. Mannion,. 2000. Clinical Governance: Striking a Balance between Checking and Trusting. In Reforming Health Care Markets: An Economic Perspective, ed., P. Smith, 247-67. Buckingham: Open University Press.
15. Department of Health. 2000. An Organisation with a Memory. London: Stationery Office.
16. Dixon-Woods, M., M. Leslie, J. Bion, and, C. Tarrant,. 2012. What Counts? An Ethnographic Study of Infection Data Reported to a Patient Safety Program. The Milbank Quarterly 90 (3): 548-91.
17. Evans, M., 2009. This Is a Test. Exams for Governance Boards on Quality Measures Could Be a Way to Improve Care, Accountability in Hospitals. Modern Healthcare 39 (46): 6-7.
18. Ford-Eickhoff, K., D.A. Plowman, and, R.R. McDaniel,. 2011. Hospital Boards and Hospital Strategic Focus: The Impact of Board Involvement in Strategic Decision Making. Health Care Management Review 36 (2): 145-54.
19. Francis, R., 2013. The Mid Staffordshire NHS Foundation Trust Public Inquiry. London: Stationery Office.
20. Frankel A., E. Graydon-Baker, C. Neppl, T. Simmonds, M. Gustafson, and, T.K. Gandhi,. 2003. Patient Safety Leadership WalkRounds. Joint Commission Journal on Quality and Patient Safety 29 (1): 16-26.
21. Gautam, K.S., 2005. A Call for Board Leadership on Quality in Hospitals. Quality Management in Health Care 14 (1): 18-30.
22. Goeschel, C.A., S.M. Berenholtz, R.A. Culbertson, L.D. Jin, and, P.J. Pronovost,. 2011. Board Quality Scorecards: Measuring Improvement. American Journal of Medical Quality 26 (4): 254-60.
23. Goeschel, C.A., C.G. Holzmueller, and, P.J. Pronovost,. 2010. Hospital Board Checklist to Improve Culture and Reduce Central Line Associated Bloodstream Infections. Joint Commission Journal on Quality and Patient Safety 36 (11): 525-28.
24. Gray, B.H., and, L. Weiss,. 2004. The Role of Trustees and the Ethics of Trusteeship: Findings from an Empirical Study. In The Ethics of Hospital Trustees, ed., B. Jennings, B.H. Gray, V.A. Sharpe, and, A.R. Fleischman, 90-133. Washington, DC: Georgetown University Press.
25. Greenhalgh, T., H. Potts, G. Wong, P. Bark, and, D. Swinglehurst,. 2009. Tensions and Paradoxes in Electronic Patient Record Research: A Systematic Literature Review Using the Meta-narrative Method. The Milbank Quarterly 87 (4): 729-88.
26. Greenhalgh, T., G. Robert, F. Macfarlane, P. Bate, O. Kyriakidou, and, R. Peacock,. 2005. Storylines of Research in Diffusion of Innovation: A Meta-narrative Approach to Systematic Review. Social Science & Medicine 61 (2): 417-30.
27. Healthcare Commission. 2009a. Safe in the Knowledge: How Do NHS Trust Boards Ensure Safe Care for Their Patients? London.
28. Healthcare Commission. 2009b. Safely Does It: Implementing Safer Care for Patients. London.
29. Heenan, M., H. Khan, and, D. Binkley,. 2010. From Boardroom to Bedside: How to Define and Measure Hospital Quality. Healthcare Quarterly 13 (1): 55-60.
30. Hood, C., 1999. Regulation inside Government. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
31. House of Commons Health Committee. 2009. Patient Safety: Sixth Report 2008-2009. House of Commons. London: Stationery Office.
32. IOM (Institute of Medicine). 1999. To Err Is Human: Building a Safer Health System. Washington, DC: National Academy Press.
33. IOM (Institute of Medicine). 2001. Crossing the Quality Chasm: A New Health System for the 21st Century. Washington, DC: National Academy Press.
34. Jennings, B., B.H. Gray, V.A. Sharpe, and, A.R. Fleischman,. 2004. The Ethics of Hospital Trustees. Washington, DC: Georgetown University Press.
35. Jha, A.K., and, A.M. Epstein,. 2010. Hospital Governance and the Quality of Care. Health Affairs 29 (1): 182-87.
36. Jha, A.K., and, A.M. Epstein,. 2012. Governance around Quality of Care at Hospitals That Disproportionately Care for Black Patients. Journal of General Internal Medicine 27 (3): 297-303.
37. Jha, A.K., and, A.M. Epstein,. 2013. A Survey of Board Chairs of English Hospitals Shows Greater Attention to Quality of Care Than Among Their US Counterparts. Health Affairs 32 (4): 677-85.
38. Jha, A.K., Z. Li, E.J. Orav, and, A.M. Epstein,. 2005. Care in U.S. Hospitals-The Hospital Quality Alliance Program. New England Journal of Medicine 353 (3): 265-74.
39. Jiang, H.J., C. Lockee, K. Bass, and, I. Fraser,. 2008. Board Engagement in Quality: Findings of a Survey of Hospital and System Leaders. Journal of Healthcare Management 53 (2): 121-34.
40. Jiang, H.J., C. Lockee, K. Bass, and, I. Fraser,. 2009. Board Oversight of Quality: Any Differences in Process of Care and Mortality? Journal of Healthcare Management 54 (1): 15-30.
41. Jiang, H.J., C. Lockee, and, I. Fraser,. 2011. Enhancing Board Oversight on Quality of Hospital Care: An Agency Theory Perspective. Health Care Management Review 37 (2): 144-53.
42. Joint Commission. 2011. 2011 Hospital: National Patient Safety Goals. Oakbrook Terrace, IL. Available at http://www.jointcommission.org/assets/1/6/ HAP-NPSG-6-10-11.pdf (accessed July 16, 2013).
43. Joshi, M.S., and, S. Hines,. 2006. Getting the Board on Board: Engaging Hospital Boards in Quality and Patient Safety. Joint Commission Journal on Quality and Patient Safety 32 (4): 179-87.
44. Kennedy, I., 2001. Learning from Bristol: Public Inquiry into Children's Heart Surgery at the Bristol Royal Infirmary 1984-1995. London: Stationery Office.
45. Kroch, E., T. Vaughn, M. Koepke, et al. 2006. Hospital Boards and Quality Dashboards. Journal of Patient Safety 2 (1): 10-19.
46. Landrigan, C.P., G.J. Parry, C.B. Bones, A.D. Hackbarth, D.A. Goldmann, and, P.J. Sharek,. 2010. Temporal Trends in Rates of Patient Harm Resulting from Medical Care. New England Journal of Medicine 363: 2124-34.
47. Lathrop, C.B., 1997. Using Graphs to Consolidate Reports to the Board. Journal for Healthcare Quality 19 (1): 26-33.
48. Leistikow, I.P., C.J. Kalkman, and, H. de Bruijn,. 2011. Why Patient Safety Is Such a Tough Nut to Crack. BMJ 342: d3447.
49. Machell, S., P. Gough, D. Naylor, V. Nath, and, K. Steward,. 2010. Putting Quality First in the Boardroom: Improving the Business of Caring. London: King's Fund.
50. MacLeod, L., 2010. Nursing Leadership: Ten Compelling Reasons for Having a Nurse Leader on the Hospital Board. Nurse Leader 8 (5): 44-47.
51. Marren, J.P., G.L. Feazell, and, M.W. Paddock,. 2003. The Hospital Board at Risk and the Need to Restructure the Relationship with the Medical Staff: Bylaws, Peer Review and Related Solutions. Annals of Health Law 12: 179-234.
52. Mastal, M.F., M. Joshi, and, K. Schulke,. 2007. Nursing Leadership: Championing Quality and Patient Safety in the Boardroom. Nursing Economics 25 (6): 323-30.
53. McCreaddie, M., and, S. Wiggins,. 2008. The Purpose and Function of Humour in Health, Healthcare and Nursing: A Narrative Review. Journal of Advanced Nursing 61 (6): 584-95.
54. Meyer, J.A., S. Silow-Carroll, T. Kutyla, L.S. Stepnick, and, L.S. Rybowski,. 2004. Hospital Quality: Ingredients for Success: Overview and Lessons Learned. New York: Commonwealth Fund.
55. Meyers, S., 2004. Data in, Safety out: Balanced Scorecards Help the Board Make Patient Safety Their No. 1 Priority. Trustee 57 (7): 12-14.
56. Meyers, S., 2008. Cultivating Trust: The Board-Medical Staff Relationship. Trustee 61 (10): 8-12.
57. Oetgen, W.J., 2009. The Governing Board's Role in the Quality Agenda: An Overview. Prescriptions for Excellence in Health Care 5: 1-3.
58. Paine, L.A., D.R. Baker, B. Rosenstein, and, P.J. Pronovost,. 2004. The Johns Hopkins Hospital: Identifying and Addressing Risks and Safety Issues. Joint Commission Journal on Quality and Patient Safety 30 (10): 543-50.
59. Popay, J., 2006. Moving beyond Effectiveness in Evidence Synthesis: Methodological Issues in the Synthesis of Diverse Sources of Evidence. London: National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence.
60. Popay, J., H. Roberts, A. Sowden, et al. 2006. Guidance on the Conduct of Narrative Synthesis in Systematic Reviews. Swindon: Economic and Social Research Council (ESRC) Methods Programme.
61. Powell, A.E., R.K. Rushmer, and, H.T.O. Davies,. 2009. A Systematic Narrative Review of Quality Improvement Models in Health Care. Edinburgh: Quality Improvement Scotland (QIS).
62. Prybil, L.D., 1991. A Perspective on Local-Level Governance in Multiunit Systems. Hospital and Health Services Administration 36: 3-12.
63. Prybil, L.D., 2007. Nursing Involvement in Hospital Governance. Journal of Nursing Care Quality 22: 1-3.
64. Prybil, L.D., 2009. Engaging Nurses in Governing Hospitals and Health Systems. Journal of Nursing Care Quality 24 (January-March): 5-9.
65. Prybil, L.D., 2013. Nurses in Health Care Governance: Is the Picture Changing? Journal of Nursing Care Quality 28 (2): 103-7.
66. Prybil, L.D., D.R. Bardach, and, D.W. Fardo,. 2013. Board Oversight of Patient Care Quality in Large Nonprofit Health Systems. American Journal of Medical Quality; doi: 10.1177/1062860613485407.
67. Prybil, L.D., R. Peterson, P. Brezinski, G. Zamba, W. Roach, and, A. Fillmore,. 2010. Board Oversight of Patient Care Quality in Community Health Systems. American Journal of Medical Quality 25 (1): 34-41.
68. Pugh, M., and, J. Reinertsen,. 2007. Reducing Harm to Patients: Using Patient Safety Dashboards at the Board Level. Healthcare Executive 22 (62): 64-65.
69. Ramsay, A., N. Fulop, A. Fresko, and, S. Rubenstein,. 2013. The Healthy NHS Board 2013: Review of Guidance and Research Evidence. Leeds: NHS Leadership Academy.
70. Ramsay, A., C. Magnusson, and, N. Fulop,. 2010. The Relationship between External and Local Governance Systems: The Case of Health Care Associated Infections and Medication Errors in One NHS Trust. Quality & Safety in Health Care 19 (6): 1-8.
71. Reinertsen, J.L., 2007. Hospital Boards and Clinical Quality: A Practical Guide. Toronto: Ontario Hospital Association.
72. Rodgers, M., A. Sowden, M. Petticrew, et al. 2009. Testing Methodological Guidance on the Conduct of Narrative Synthesis in Systematic Reviews: Effectiveness of Interventions to Promote Smoke Alarm Ownership and Function. Evaluation 15 (1): 47-71.
73. Sandrick, K., 2005. One Giant Leap for Quality. When Boards Get behind Quality Initiatives, Patient Care Benefits. Trustee 58 (3): 22-24.
74. Schyve, P.M., 2003. What You Can Do: The Trustee, Patient Safety, and JCAHO. Trustee 56 (2): 19-21.
75. Secretary of State. 1969. Report of the Committee of Inquiry into Allegations of Ill Treatment of Patients and Other Irregularities at the Ely Hospital, Cardiff (Cmnd 3975). Presented to Parliament by the Secretary of State of the Department of Health and Social Security by Command of Her Majesty, United Kingdom.
76. Slessor, S.R., J.B. Crandall, and, G.A. Nielsen,. 2008. Case Study: Getting Boards on Board at Allen Memorial Hospital, Iowa Health System. Joint Commission Journal on Quality and Patient Safety 34 (4): 221-27.
77. Vaughn, T., M. Koepke, E. Kroch, W. Lehrman, S. Sinha, and, S. Levey,. 2006. Engagement of Leadership in Quality Improvement Initiatives: Executive Quality Improvement Surveys. Journal of Patient Safety 2 (1): 2-9.
78. Vincent, C., 2011. Patient Safety. London: BMJI Books.
79. Wachter, R.M., 2010. Patient Safety at Ten: Unmistakable Progress, Troubling Gaps. Health Affairs 29 (1): 165-73.
80. Waring, J., E. Rowley, R. Dingwall, C. Palmer, and, T. Murcott,. 2010. A Narrative Review of the UK Patient Safety Research Portfolio. Journal of Health Services Research and Policy 15 (1): 26-32.
81. Weiner, B.J., S.M. Shortell, and, J. Alexander,. 1997. Promoting Clinical Involvement in Hospital Quality Improvement Efforts: The Effects of Top Management, Board, and Physician Leadership. Health Services Research 32 (4): 491-510.