Advantages and limitations of exergy indicators to assess sustainability of bioenergy and biobased materials

Environmental Impact Assessment Review

Volumn 45, Issue , 2014, Pages 19-29

  Maes, Dries ^a,b   Van Passel, Steven ^a,b  

^a HASSELT UNIVERSITY   (Belgium)

^b NONE   (Belgium)

Author keywords

Biobased materials; Bioenergy; Composite indicators; Cumulative exergy content; Sustainability assessment

Indexed keywords

BIOMASS; SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT;

BIO-BASED MATERIALS; BIO-ENERGY; COMPOSITE INDICATORS; CUMULATIVE EXERGIES; SUSTAINABILITY ASSESSMENT;

EXERGY;

BIOENERGY; BIOMASS POWER; ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT; EXERGY; SUSTAINABILITY;

EID: 84889645104     PISSN: 01959255     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.eiar.2013.11.002     Document Type: Article

References (113)

1. Abusoglu A., Kanoglu M. Exergoeconomic analysis and optimization of combined heat and power production: a review. Renew Sustain Energy Rev 2009, 13:2295-2308.
2. Acosta-Alba I., Van der Werf H.M. The use of reference values in indicator-based methods for the environmental assessment of agricultural systems. Sustainability 2011, 3:424-442.
3. Apaiah R.K., Linnemann A.R., van der Kooi H.J. Exergy analysis: a tool to study the sustainability of food supply chains. Food Res Int 2006, 39:1-11.
4. Ayres R. On the life cycle metaphor: where ecology and economics diverge. Ecol Econ 2004, 48:425-438.
5. Bakshi B.R. A thermodynamic framework for ecologically conscious process systems engineering. Comput Chem Eng 2000, 24:1767-1773.
6. Banerjee A., Tierney M. Comparison of five exergoenvironmental methods applied to candidate energy systems for rural villages in developing countries. Energy 2011, 36:2650-2661.
7. Baral A., Bakshi B.R. Thermodynamic metrics for aggregation of natural resources in life cycle analysis: insight via application to some transportation fuels. Environ Sci Technol 2010, 44:800-807.
8. Bastianoni S., Nielsen S.N., Marchettini N., Jørgensen S.E. Use of thermodynamic functions for expressing some relevant aspects of sustainability. Int J Energy Res 2005, 29:53-64.
9. Bastianoni S., Facchini A., Susani L., Tiezzi E. Emergy as a function of exergy. Energy 2007, 32:1158-1162.
10. 2 enrichment on canopy photosynthesis, water use efficiency and early development of tomato and pepper hybrids. Acta Agron Hung 2011, 59:275-284.
11. Benetto E., Tiruta-Barna L., Perrodin Y. Combining lifecycle and risk assessments of mineral waste reuse scenarios for decision making support. Environ Impact Assess Rev 2007, 27:266-285.
12. Berbigier P., Bonnefond J.M., Mellmann P. CO2 and water vapour fluxes for 2years above Euroflux forest site. Agr Forest Meteorol 2001, 108:183-197.
13. Berkes F., Folke C. Investing in cultural capital for sustainable use of natural capital. Investing in natural capital: the ecological economics approach to sustainability Island Press 1994, 128-149. Island Press, Washington, DC, USA. A. Jansson, M. Hammer, C. Folke, R. Costanza (Eds.).
14. Bösch M., Hellweg S., Huijbregts M., Frischknecht R. Applying cumulative exergy demand (CExD) indicators to the ecoinvent database. Int J Life Cycle Assess 2007, 12:181-190.
15. Bozell J.J. Feedstocks for the future-biorefinery production of chemicals from renewable carbon. CLEAN-Soil Air Water 2008, 36:641-647.
16. Brehmer B., Struik P.C., Sanders J. Using an energetic and exergetic life cycle analysis to assess the best applications of legumes within a biobased economy. Biomass Bioenergy 2008, 32:1175-1186.
17. Brown M., Bardi E. Handbook of emergy evaluation folio 3: emergy of ecosystems 2001, 94. Center for Environmental Policy Environmental Engineering Sciences.
18. Buchgeister J. Exergoenvironmental analysis - a new approach to support the design for environment of chemical processes?. Chem Eng Technol 2010, 33:593-602.
19. Chen G., Jiang M., Yang Z., Chen B., Ji X., Zhou J. Exergetic assessment for ecological economic system: Chinese agriculture. Ecol Model 2009, 220:397-410.
20. Christopher K., Dimitrios R. A review on exergy comparison of hydrogen production methods from renewable energy sources. Energy Environ Sci 2012, 5:6640-6651.
21. Coelli T., Rao D.S.P., O'Donnell C.J., Battese G.E. An introduction to efficiency and productivity analysis 2005, Springer Verlag. 2nd ed.
22. Corning P.A., Kline S.J. Thermodynamics, information and life revisited, part I: 'To be or entropy'. Syst Res Behav Sci 1998, 15:273-295.
23. Corning P.A., Kline S.J. Thermodynamics, information and life revisited, part II: 'Thermoeconomics' and 'control information'. Syst Res Behav Sci 1998, 15:453-482.
24. Daniel S.E., Tsoulfas G.T., Pappis C.P., Rachaniotis N.P. Aggregating and evaluating the results of different environmental impact assessment methods. Ecol Indic 2004, 4:125-138.
25. De Meester S., Callewaert C., De Mol E., Van Langenhove H., Dewulf J. The resource footprint of biobased products: a key issue in the sustainable development of biorefineries. Biofuels Bioprod Bioref 2011, 5:570-580.
26. De Meester S., Demeyer J., Velghe F., Peene A., Van Langenhove H., Dewulf J. The environmental sustainability of anaerobic digestion as a biomass valorization technology. Bioresour Technol 2012, 121:396-403.
27. Dewulf J., Van Langenhove H. Assessment of the sustainability of technology by means of a thermodynamically based life cycle analysis. Environ Sci Pollut Res 2002, 9:267-273.
28. Dewulf J.P., Van Langenhove H.R. Quantitative assessment of solid waste treatment systems in the industrial ecology perspective by exergy analysis. Environ Sci Technol 2002, 36:1130-1135.
29. Dewulf J., Van Langenhove H., Mulder J., van den Berg M.M.D., van der Kooi H.J., de Swaan Arons J. Illustrations towards quantifying the sustainability of technology. Green Chem 2000, 2:108-114.
30. Dewulf J., Van Langenhove H., Van de Velde B. Exergy-based efficiency and renewability assessment of biofuel production. Environ Sci Technol 2005, 39:3878-3882.
31. Dewulf J., Bösch M.E., Meester B.D., Vorst GVd, Langenhove H.V., Hellweg S., et al. Cumulative Exergy Extraction from the Natural Environment (CEENE): a comprehensive Life Cycle Impact Assessment method for resource accounting. Environ Sci Technol 2007, 41:8477-8483.
32. Dewulf J., Van Langenhove H., Muys B., Bruers S., Bakshi B.R., Grubb G.F., et al. Exergy: its potential and limitations in environmental science and technology. Environ Sci Technol 2008, 42:2221-2232.
33. Dincer I. The role of exergy in energy policy making. Energy Policy 2002, 30:137-149.
34. Evans A., Strezov V., Evans T.J. Assessment of sustainability indicators for renewable energy technologies. Renew Sustain Energy Rev 2009, 13:1082-1088.
35. Fatih Demirbas M. Biorefineries for biofuel upgrading: a critical review. Appl Energy 2009, 86:S151-S161.
36. Fisher B., Turner R.K., Morling P. Defining and classifying ecosystem services for decision making. Ecol Econ 2009, 68:643-653.
37. Fonseca J.C., Marques J.C., Paiva A.A., Freitas A.M., Madeira V., Jørgensen S.E. Nuclear DNA in the determination of weighing factors to estimate exergy from organisms biomass. Ecol Model 2000, 126:179-189.
38. Gasparatos A., El-Haram M., Horner M. A critical review of reductionist approaches for assessing the progress towards sustainability. Environ Impact Assess Rev 2008, 28:286-311.
39. Gasparatos A., El-Haram M., Horner M. Assessing the sustainability of the UK society using thermodynamic concepts: part 2. Renew Sustain Energy Rev 2009, 13:956-970.
40. Goedkoop M., Spriensma R., van Volkshuisvesting M., en Milieubeheer R.O., Communicatie C.D. The eco-indicator 99: a damage oriented method for life cycle impact assessment 1999, Ministerie van Volkshuisvesting, Ruimtleijke Ordening en Milieubeheer.
41. Gontier M., Balfors B., Mörtberg U. Biodiversity in environmental assessment-current practice and tools for prediction. Environ Impact Assess Rev 2006, 26:268-286.
42. Gowdy J., Erickson J.D. The approach of ecological economics. Camb J Econ 2005, 29:207-222.
43. Hammond A.L., Adriaanse A., Rodenburg E., Bryant D., Woodward R. Environmental indicators: a systematic approach to measuring and reporting on environmental policy performance in the context of sustainable development 1995, World Resources Institute, Washington, DC.
44. Hau J.L., Bakshi B.R. Expanding exergy analysis tot account or ecological inputs 2003, Ohio State University. Engineering DoC (Ed.).
45. Hau J.L., Bakshi B.R. Promise and problems of emergy analysis. Ecol Model 2004, 178:215-225.
46. Hepbasli A. A key review on exergetic analysis and assessment of renewable energy resources for a sustainable future. Renew Sustain Energy Rev 2008, 12:593-661.
47. Hoang V.-N., Alauddin M. Analysis of agricultural sustainability: a review of exergy methodologies and their application in OECD countries. Int J Energy Res 2011, 35:459-476.
48. Hoang V.-N., Rao D.S.P. Measuring and decomposing sustainable efficiency in agricultural production: a cumulative exergy balance approach. Ecol Econ 2010, 69:1765-1776.
49. Huang L., Chen G., Zhang Y., Chen B., Luan S. Exergy as a unified measure of water quality. Commun Nonlinear Sci Numer Simul 2007, 12:663-672.
50. Illge L., Hahn T., Figge F. Applying and extending the sustainable value method related to agriculture - an overview 2008, European Association of Agricultural Economists.
51. Jørgensen S.E. Integration of ecosystem theories: a pattern 2002, Kluwer Academic Pub.
52. Jørgensen S.E. Eco-exergy as sustainability 2006, Wit Pr/Computational Mechanics.
53. Jørgensen S.E. Evolution and exergy. Ecol Model 2007, 203:490-494.
54. Jorgensen S.E., Svirezhev Y.M. Towards a thermodynamic theory for ecological systems 2004, Pergamon. 1st ed.
55. Jorgensen S.E., Xu L., Costanza R. Handbook of ecological indicators for assessment of ecosystem health 2004.
56. Junginger M., de Wit M., Sikkema R., Faaij A. International bioenergy trade in the Netherlands. Biomass Bioenergy 2008, 32:672-687.
57. Kaushik S., Reddy V.S., Tyagi S. Energy and exergy analyses of thermal power plants: a review. Renew Sustain Energy Rev 2011, 15:1857-1872.
58. Kim D. A new thermoeconomic methodology for energy systems. Energy 2010, 35:410-422.
59. Kim S.-M., Oh S.-D., Kwon Y.-H., Kwak H.-Y. Exergoeconomic analysis of thermal systems. Energy 1998, 23:393-406.
60. Kirova-Yordanova Z. Application of the exergy method to environmental impact estimation: the ammonium nitrate production as a case study. Energy 2010, 35:3221-3229.
61. Kline S.J. The low-down on entropy and interpretive thermodynamics: for the students and teachers of the subject 1999, DCW Industries.
62. Lems S., Kooi H.J., Arons J.S. Quantifying technological aspects of process sustainability: a thermodynamic approach. Clean Technol Environ Policy 2003, 5:248-253.
63. Liao W., Heijungs R., Huppes G. Is bioethanol a sustainable energy source? An energy-, exergy-, and emergy-based thermodynamic system analysis. Renew Energy 2011, 36:3479-3487.
64. Melis A. Solar energy conversion efficiencies in photosynthesis: minimizing the chlorophyll antennae to maximize efficiency. Plant Sci 2009, 177:272-280.
65. Nardo M., Saisana M., Saltelli A., Tarantola S., Hoffman A., Giovannini E. Handbook on constructing composite indicators: methodology and user guide 2005, OECD Publishing.
66. Neupane B., Halog A., Lilieholm R.J. Environmental sustainability of wood-derived ethanol: a life cycle evaluation of resource intensity and emissions in Maine, USA. J Cleaner Prod 2013, 44:77-84.
67. Nzihou A., Stanmore B. The fate of heavy metals during combustion and gasification of contaminated biomass - a brief review. J Hazard Mater 15 July 2013, 256-257:56-66.
68. Odum H.T. Environmental accounting: emergy and environmental decision making 1996, John Wiley & Sons.
69. Odum H.T., Brown M.T., Brandt-Williams S. Folio# 1: introduction and global budget. Handbook of Emergy Evaluation: A Compendium of Data for Emergy Computation Issued in a Series of Folios 2000, Center for Environmental Policy, Univ of Florida, Gainesville.
70. Özilgen M., Sorgüven E. Energy and exergy utilization, and carbon dioxide emission in vegetable oil production. Energy 2011, 36:5954-5967.
71. Pick D., Dieterich M., Heintschel S. Biogas production potential from economically usable green waste. Sustainability 2012, 4:682-702.
72. Raugei M. Emergy indicators applied to human economic systems - a word of caution. Ecol Model 2011, 222:3821-3822.
73. Rezende F.C., Frizzone J.A., Oliveira R.F., Pereira A.S. CO2 and irrigation in relation to yield and water use of the bell pepper crop. Sci Agric 2003, 60:7-12.
74. Rosen M. A concise review of exergy-based economic methods. 3rd IASME/WSEAS international Conference on Energy & Environment 2008, University of Cambridge, UK.
75. Rubio Rodríguez M.A., Ruyck J.D., Díaz P.R., Verma V.K., Bram S. An LCA based indicator for evaluation of alternative energy routes. Appl Energy 2011, 88:630-635.
76. Sciubba E. Beyond thermoeconomics? The concept of Extended Exergy Accounting and its application to the analysis and design of thermal systems. Int J Exergy 2001, 1:68-84.
77. Sciubba E. On the second-law inconsistency of emergy analysis. Energy 2010, 35:3696-3706.
78. Sciubba E. A revised calculation of the econometric factors α- and β for the extended exergy accounting method. Ecol Model 2011, 222:1060-1066.
79. Sciubba E., Wall G. A brief commented history of exergy, from the beginnings to 2004. Int J Thermodyn 2007, 10:1-26.
80. Sewalt M., Toxopeus M., Hirs G.G. Thermodynamics based sustainability concept. Int J Thermodyn 2001, 4:35-41.
81. Silow E.A., Mokry A.V. Exergy as a tool for ecosystem health assessment. Entropy 2010, 12:902-925.
82. Simpson A.P., Edwards C.F. An exergy-based framework for evaluating environmental impact. Energy 2011, 36:1442-1459.
83. Soares S.R., Toffoletto L., Deschênes L. Development of weighting factors in the context of LCIA. J Cleaner Prod 2006, 14:649-660.
84. Stougie L., Van der Kooi H. The relation between exergy and sustainability according to literature 2011, ELCAS.
85. Szargut J. Exergy method, technical and ecological applications 2005, WIT Press, Gateshead.
86. Szargut J, Morris D, Steward F. Exergy analysis of thermal, chemical and metallurgical processes. Berlin: Hemisphere Puhl Corp, New York: Springer Verlag, 1988.
87. Szargut J., Valero A., Stanek W., Valero A. Towards an international legal reference environment 2005, ECOS, Trondheim. S. Kjelstrup, J.E. Hustad, G. Tsatsaronis, T. Gundersen, A. Rosjorde (Eds.).
88. Taelman S., DE Meester S., Roef L., Michiels M., Dewulf J. The environmental sustainability of microalgae as feed for aquaculture: a life cycle perspective. Bioresour Technol 2013, (Available online 14 August 2013, in press). 10.1016/j.biortech.2013.08.044.
89. Talens Peiró L., Villalba Méndez G., Sciubba E. Gabarrell i Durany X. Extended exergy accounting applied to biodiesel production. Energy 2010, 35:2861-2869.
90. Tremblay N., Gosselin A. Effect of carbon dioxide enrichment and light. HortTechnology 1998, 8:524-528.
91. Tsatsaronis G. Application of thermoeconomics to the design and synthesis of energy plants. Exergy, energy system analysis and optimization. Encyclopaedia of Life Support Systems (EOLSS), Developed under the Auspices of the UNESCO 2006, Eolss Publishers, Oxford, UK. C.A. Frangopoulos (Ed.).
92. Tsatsaronis G., Pisa J. Exergoeconomic evaluation and optimization of energy systems-application to the CGAM problem. Energy 1994, 19:287-321.
93. Ukidwe N.U. Thermodynamic input-output analysis of economic and ecological systems for sustainable engineering 2005, The Ohio State University.
94. Urban R.A., Bakshi B.R. 1,3-Propanediol from fossils versus biomass: a life cycle evaluation of emissions and ecological resources. Ind Eng Chem Res 2009, 48:8068-8082.
95. Valero A. Exergy accounting: capabilities and drawbacks. Energy 2006, 31:164-180.
96. Valero A., Botero E. An assessment of the earth's clean fossil exergy capital based on exergy abatement costs 2002, 151-157.
97. Valero A., Lozano M.A., Munoz M. A general theory of exergy saving: part I. On the exergetic cost. Second law analysis and Modelling 1986, Vol. 3. The American Society of Mechanical Engineers, U.S.A. R.A. Gaggioli (Ed.).
98. Valero A., Lozano M.A., Serra L., Tsatsaronis G., Pisa J., Frangopoulos C., et al. CGAM problem: definition and conventional solution. Energy 1994, 19:279-286.
99. Van Dael M., Van Passel S., Pelkmans L., Guisson R., Reumermann P., Luzardo N.M., et al. A techno-economic evaluation of a biomass energy conversion park. Appl Energy 2013, 104:611-622.
100. van der Werf H.M.G., Tzilivakis J., Lewis K., Basset-Mens C. Environmental impacts of farm scenarios according to five assessment methods. Agric Ecosyst Environ 2007, 118:327-338.
101. Van Passel S., Meul M. Multilevel and multi-user sustainability assessment of farming systems. Environ Impact Assess Rev January 2012, 32(1):170-180.
102. Van Passel S., Van Huylenbroeck G., Lauwers L., Mathijs E. Sustainable value assessment of farms using frontier efficiency benchmarks. J Environ Manage 2009, 90:3057-3069.
103. Verdesca D., Federici M., Torsello L., Basosi R. Exergy-economic accounting for sea-coastal systems: a novel approach. Ecol Model 2006, 193:132-139.
104. Wang J.-J., Jing Y.-Y., Zhang C.-F., Zhao J.-H. Review on multi-criteria decision analysis aid in sustainable energy decision-making. Renew Sustain Energy Rev 2009, 13:2263-2278.
105. Warner J.C., Cannon A.S., Dye K.M. Green chemistry. Environ Impact Assess Rev 2004, 24:775-799.
106. Weiland P., Verstraete W., Van Haandel A. Biomass digestion to methane in agriculture: a successful pathway for the energy production and waste treatment worldwide 2009, 171-195. John Wiley & Sons, Ltd, Biofuels.
107. Yang Q., Chen B., Ji X., He Y.F., Chen G.Q. Exergetic evaluation of corn-ethanol production in China. Communications in Nonlinear Science and Numerical Simulation. 2009, 14:2450-2461.
108. Yi H., Hau J.L., Ukidwe N.U., Bakshi B.R. Hierarchical thermodynamic metrics for evaluating the environmental sustainability of industrial processes. Environ Prog 2004, 23:302-314.
109. Zah R., Böni H., Gauch M., Hischier R., Lehmann M., Wäger P. Life cycle assessment of energy products: environmental assessment of biofuels. Report produced under a contract from the Swiss Federal Office for Energy, the Swiss Federal Office for the Environment and the Swiss Federal Office for Agriculture 2007, 19. Empa Technology and Society Lab Bern, Switzerland.
110. Zah R., Faist M., Reinhard J., Birchmeier D. Standardized and simplified life-cycle assessment (LCA) as a driver for more sustainable biofuels. J Cleaner Prod 2009, 17(Supplement 1):S102-S105.
111. Zhang B., Chen G. Physical sustainability assessment for the China society: exergy-based systems account for resources use and environmental emissions. Renew Sustain Energy Rev 2010, 14:1527-1545.
112. Zhu P., Feng X., Shen R. An extension to the cumulative exergy consumption applied to environmental impact analysis of industrial processes. Process Saf Environ Prot 2005, 83:257-261.
113. Zhu X.G., Long S.P., Ort D.R. What is the maximum efficiency with which photosynthesis can convert solar energy into biomass?. Curr Opin Biotechnol 2008, 19:153-159.