Surface water withdrawals for marcellus shale gas development: Performance of alternative regulatory approaches in the upper ohio river basin

Environmental Science and Technology

Volumn 47, Issue 22, 2013, Pages 12669-12678

  Mitchell, Austin L ^a   Small, Mitchell ^a   Casman, Elizabeth A ^a  

^a CARNEGIE MELLON UNIVERSITY   (United States)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

ENVIRONMENTAL GROUPS; MARCELLUS SHALES; PENNSYLVANIA DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTIONS; REGULATORY AUTHORITIES; STREAMFLOW STATISTICS; SURFACE WATER SOURCES; WATER SOURCE; WATER WITHDRAWAL;

SHALE; STREAM FLOW; SURFACE WATERS; WATER MANAGEMENT; WATER SUPPLY;

WATERSHEDS;

SURFACE WATER; GAS; WATER; WATER POLLUTANT;

ANNUAL VARIATION; AQUATIC ECOSYSTEM; ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION; REGULATORY APPROACH; RIVER BASIN; SHALE; STATISTICAL ANALYSIS; STREAMFLOW; SURFACE WATER; WATER MANAGEMENT; WATER USE;

AQUATIC ENVIRONMENT; ARTICLE; ECOSYSTEM; ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT; FLOW MEASUREMENT; GAS; RIVER BASIN; SENSITIVITY ANALYSIS; UNITED STATES; WATER QUALITY; ANALYSIS; CHEMISTRY; ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION; RIVER; SEDIMENT; SOCIAL CONTROL; UNCERTAINTY; WATER POLLUTANT;

OHIO BASIN; PENNSYLVANIA; UNITED STATES;

CONSERVATION OF NATURAL RESOURCES; GASES; GEOLOGIC SEDIMENTS; OHIO; PENNSYLVANIA; RIVERS; SOCIAL CONTROL, FORMAL; UNCERTAINTY; WATER; WATER POLLUTANTS, CHEMICAL;

EID: 84888219641     PISSN: 0013936X     EISSN: 15205851     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1021/es403537z     Document Type: Article

References (81)

1. Durham, L. S. Marcellus gave no 'big play' hints AAPG Explorer 2010, 31 (4) 40-42
2. Whitacre, J., Carnegie Museum of Natural History Pennsylvania Unconventional Natural Gas Wells Geodatabase (v. 2012.07), (Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, 2013). Carnegie Museum of Natural History, http://www.carnegiemnh. org/powdermill/gis-wells.html (accessed February 8, 2013).
3. Jul-Dec 2012, Unconventional Wells; Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection, Bureau of Oil and Gas Management: Harrisburg, PA, 2013
4. Entrekin, S.; Evans-Whte, M.; Johnson, B.; Hagenbuch, E. Rapid expansion of natural gas development poses a threat to surface waters Front. Ecol. Environ. 2011, 9 (9) 503-511
5. Olmstead, S. M.; Muehlenbachs, L. A.; Shih, J.-S.; Chu, Z.; Krupnick, A. J. Shale gas development impacts on surface water quality in Pennsylvania. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. 2013, Early Edition
6. Drohan, P. J.; Brittingham, M. Topographic and soil constraints to shale-gas development in the northcentral Appalachians Soil Sci. Soc. Am. J.l 2012, 76 (5) 1696-1706
7. Vengosh, A.; Warner, N.; Jackson, R.; Darrah, T. The effects of shale gas exploration and hydraulic fracturing on the quality of water resources in the United States Procedia Earth Planet. Sci. 2013, 7 (0) 863-866
8. Vidic, R. D.; Brantley, S. L.; Vandenbossche, J. M.; Yoxtheimer, D.; Abad, J. D. Impact of shale gas development on regional water quality Science 2013, 340, 1235009
9. Osborn, S. G.; Vengosh, A.; Warner, N. R.; Jackson, R. B. Methane contamination of drinking water accompanying gas-well drilling and hydraulic fracturing Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. 2011, 108 (20) 8172-8176
10. Molofsky, L. J.; Connor, J. A.; Wylie, A. S.; Wagner, T.; Farhat, S. K. Evaluation of methane sources in groundwater in northeastern Pennsylvania Groundwater 2013, 51 (3) 333-349
11. Boyer, E. W.; Swistock, B. R.; Clark, J.; Madden, M.; Rizzo, D. E. The Impact of Marcellus Gas Drilling on Rural Drinking Water Supplies; The Center for Rural Pennsylvania: Harrisburg, PA, 2012; p 26, http://www.rural. palegislature.us/documents/reports/Marcellus-and-drinking-water-2012.pdf.
12. Jackson, R. B.; Vengosh, A.; Darrah, T. H.; Warner, N. R.; Down, A.; Poreda, R. J.; Osborn, S. G.; Zhao, K.; Karr, J. D. Increased stray gas abundance in a subset of drinking water wells near Marcellus shale gas extraction Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. 2013, 10.1073/pnas.1221635110
13. Myers, T. Potential contaminant pathways from hydraulically fractured shale to aquifers Ground Water 2012, 50 (6) 872-882
14. Warner, N. R.; Jackson, R. B.; Darrah, T. H.; Osborn, S. G.; Down, A.; Zhao, K.; White, A.; Vengosh, A. Geochemical evidence for possible natural migration of Marcellus Formation brine to shallow aquifers in Pennsylvania Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. 2012, 109 (30) 11961-11966
15. Engelder, T. Capillary tension and imbibition sequester frack fluid in Marcellus gas shale Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. 2012, 109 (52) E3625
16. Warner, N. R.; Jackson, R. B.; Darrah, T. H.; Osborn, S. G.; Down, A.; Zhao, K.; White, A.; Vengosh, A. Reply to Engelder: Potential for fluid migration from the Marcellus Formation remains possible Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. 2012, 109 (52) E3626-E3626
17. Rahm, B. G.; Riha, S. J. Toward strategic managment of shale gas development: Regional, collective impacts on water resources Environ. Sci. Policy 2012, 14 (1) 12-23
18. Hopey, D., DEP reviewing permit for hauler charged with illegal dumping. Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, 2011; http://www.post-gazette.com/stories/news/ environment/dep-reviewing-permit-for-hauler-charged-with-illegal-dumping-287620/ .
19. Wilson, J. M.; VanBriesen, J. M. Oil and gas produced water management and surface drinking water sources in Pennsylvania Environ. Pract. 2012, 14 (4) 288-300
20. States, S.; Casson, L.; Cypryck, G.; Monnell, J.; Stoner, M.; Wydra, F. In Bromide in the Allegheny River and THMs in Pittsburgh Drinking Water: A Link with Marcellus Shale Drilling, Water Quality Technology Conference, Phoenix, Arizona, 2011; American Water Works Association: Phoenix, AZ, 2011.
21. Ferrar, K. J.; Michanowicz, D. R.; Christen, C. L.; Mulcahy, N.; Malone, S. L.; Sharma, R. K. Assessment of effluent contaminants from three facilities discharging Marcellus Shale wastewater to surface waters in Pennsylvania Environ. Sci. Technol. 2013, 47 (7) 3472-3481
22. Haluszczak, L. O.; Rose, A. W.; Kump, L. R. Geochemical evaluation of flowback brine from Marcellus gas wells in Pennsylvania, USA Appl. Geochem. 2013, 28 (0) 55-61
23. Wilson, J.; Wang, Y.; VanBriesen, J. Sources of high total dissolved solids to drinking water supply in southwestern Pennsylvania J. Environ. Eng. 2013, 10.1061/(ASCE)EE.1943-7870.0000733
24. Warner, N. R.; Christie, C. A.; Jackson, R. B.; Vengosh, A. Impacts of shale gas wastewater disposal on water quality in western Pennsylvania. Environ. Sci. Technol. 2013, 47, 11849-11857.
25. Shale Gas Roundtable. Deliberations, Findings, and Recommendations; Institute of Politics, University of Pittsburgh: Pittsburgh, PA, 2013; p 139.
26. DePhilip, M.; Moberg, T. Ecosystem Flow Recommendations for the Susquehanna River Basin; The Nature Conservancy: Harrisburg, PA, November, 2010; p 101 http://www.srbc.net/policies/docs/ TNCFinalSusquehannaRiverEcosystemFlowsStudyReport-Nov10-20120327-fs135148v1.PDF.
27. Annear, T. C. Instream Flows for Riverine Resource Stewardship (rev. ed.); Instream Flow Council: Cheyenne, WY, 2004.
28. DePhilip, M.; Moberg, T. Ecosystem Flow Recommendations for the Upper Ohio River Basin in Western Pennsylvania; The Nature Conservancy: Harrisburg, PA, 2013; http://www.nature.org/media/pa/ecosystem-flow-recommendations-upper- ohio-river-pa-2013.pdf.
29. Denslinger, T. L.; Jackson, D. R.; Gast, W. A.; Lazorchick, G. J.; Hauenstein, J. J.; McSparran, J. E.; Heicher, D. W.; Stoe, T. W.; Henriksen, J.; Young, L. M. Instream flow studies Pennsylvania and Maryland; Susquehanna River Basin Commission: Harrisburg, PA, 1998; p 309 http://www.srbc.net/pubinfo/ techdocs/publications-1998/ifimreport-191.pdf.
30. Poff, N. L.; Allan, J. D.; Bain, M. B.; Karr, J. R.; Prestegaard, K. L.; Richter, B. D.; Sparks, R. E.; Stromberg, J. C. The natural flow regime BioScience 1997, 47 (11) 769-784
31. Bunn, S. E.; Arthington, A. H. Basic Principles and ecological consequences of altered flow regimes for aquatic biodiversity Environ. Manage. 2002, 30 (4) 492-507
32. Curtright, A. E.; Giglio, K. Coal Mine Drainage for Marcellus Shale Natural Gas Extraction; RAND Corporation: Santa Monica, CA, 2012; http://www.rand.org/pubs/conf-proceedings/CF300.html.
33. Utilization of Mine Influenced Water for Natural Gas Extraction Activities; Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection: Harrisburg, PA, 2013; http://files.dep.state.pa.us/Mining/Abandoned%20Mine%20Reclamation/ AbandonedMinePortalFiles/MIW/Final-MIW-White-Paper.pdf.
34. Revised Draft SGEIS on the Oil, Gas and Solution Mining Regulatory Program; Department of Environmental Conservation: Albany, NY, 2011; http://www.dec.ny.gov/energy/75370.html.
35. Act of Feb. 14, 2012, P.L. 87, No. 13. In OIL AND GAS (58 PA.C.S.), Session of 2012 ed.; 2012; Vol. Cl. 58.
36. Environmental Resources Research Institute. Networked streams of Pennsylvania; Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection: Harrisburg, PA, 1998; The Pennsylvania Geospatial Data Clearinghouse (accessed 2/8/2013).
37. Carter, K. Well Record and Completion Reports; Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection: Pittsburgh, PA, 2012; Pennsylvania Department of Conservation and Natural Resources (accessed 2/7/12).
38. Beauduy, T. W. Shale Gas Production and Water Resources to the Eastern United States. In US Senate Water and Power Subcommittee, 1 st Session ed.; Susquehanna River Basin Commission: Harrisburg, PA, 2011; p 11, http://www.energy.senate.gov/public/index.cfm/files/serve?File-id= 0da002e7-87d9-41a1-8e4f-5ab8dd42d7cf.
39. Kenny, J. F.; Barber, N. L.; Hutson, S. S.; Linsey, K. S.; Lovelace, J. K.; Maupin, M. A. Estimated Use of Water in the United States in 2005; U.S. Geological Survey: Reston, VA, 2011, (accessed 12/29/2011).
40. Nicot, J. P.; Scanlon, B. R. Water use for shale-gas production in Texas, US Env. Sci. Technol. 2012, 46, 3580-3586
41. New York State Department of Environmental Conservation (NYSDEC) Revised Draft of the Supplemental Generic Environmental Impact Statement on the Oil, Gas and Solution Mining Regulatory Program, Well Permit Issuance for Horizontal Drilling and High-Volume Hydraulinc Fractuing to Develop the Marcellus Shale and Other Low-Permeability Gas Reservoirs; Albany, NY, 2012; http://www.dec.ny.gov/ data/dmn/rdsgeisfull0911.pdf.
42. Arthur, J. D.; Uretsky, M.; Wilson, P. Water Resources and Use for Hydraulic Fracturing in the Marcellus Shale Region; ALL Consulting. 2010; http://www.netl.doe.gov/technologies/oil-gas/publications/ENVreports/ FE0000797-WaterResourceIssues.pdf.
43. Abdalla, C.; Drohan, J.; Rahm, B.; Jacquet, J.; Becker, J.; Collins, A.; Klaiber, A.; Poe, G.; Grantham, D. Water's Journey Through the Shale Gas Drilling and Production Processes in the Mid-Atlantic Region, EE0023; Penn State Extension: University Park, PA, 2012; http://pubs.cas.psu.edu/freepubs/pdfs/ ee0023.pdf.
44. U.S. Geological Survey Pennsylvania StreamStats. http://water.usgs.gov/ osw/streamstats/pennsylvania.html (accessed July 14, 2013)
45. Drohan, J.; Abdalla, C. Valuing Pennsylvania's Water Resources; 5M12/00ps#42643; Pennsylvania State University: State College, PA, 2000; http://pubs.cas.psu.edu/freepubs/pdfs/ua345.pdf.
46. Riggs, H. C. Low-Flow Investigations; U.S. Geological Survey 1972.
47. Ehlke, M. H.; Reed, L. A. Comparison of Methods for Computing Streamflow Statistics for Pennsylvania Streams; U.S. Geological Survey: Lemoyne, PA, 1999; p 86 http://wilkes.edu/Include/WaterResearch/PDFs/3676/Geological/ Stream%20Flow%20Geology.pdf.
48. Guidelines for Using and Determining Passby Flows and Conservation Releases for Surface-Water and Ground-Water withdrawal Approvals; Susquehanna River Basin Commission: Harrisburg, PA, 2002; Vol. 2003-01, http://www.srbc.net/ sitemap/Using&DeterminingPassbyFlows.htm.
49. Jostenski, D., Personal communication. In 2012.
50. Tennant, D. L. Instream flow regimens for fish, wildlife, recreation and related environmental resources Fisheries 1976, 1 (4) 6-10
51. Bovee, K. D. A Guide to Stream Habitat Analysis Using Instream Flow Incremental Methodology, Information Paper 12; US Fish and Wildlife Service: Fort Collins, CO, 1980.
52. Qualifying as High Quality or Exceptional Value Waters 25; Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection: Harrisburg, PA, 1999; Vol. § 93.4b.
53. Draft Policy for Protecting Aquatic Resources and Related Stream Uses in Processing Approvals for Water Rights Acquisitions in Certain Waters of the Commonwealth; Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection: Harrisburg, PA, 2007.
54. Susquehanna River Basin Commission. Technical Guidance for Low Flow Protection Related to Withdrawal Approvals; Susquehanna River Basin Commission: Harrisburg, PA, March 13, 2012; http://www.srbc.net/policies/docs/2012-01-LFPP- Technical-Guidance-for-Low-Flow-Protection-Related-to-Withdrawal-Approvals-12- 14-12-fs170477.PDF.
55. Moyer, B., Laurel Hill Creek: Almost a river, it's a stream of multiple personalities. Pittsburgh Post-Gazette March 16, 2008, http://www.post-gazette. com/stories/sports/hunting-fishing/laurel-hill-creek-almost-a-river-its-a- stream-of-multiple-personalities-385240/.
56. Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection. Water Allocation Application and Instructions, Rev. 9/2001; Bureau of Watershed Management: Harrisburg, PA, 2001; http://www.elibrary.dep.state.pa.us/dsweb/Get/Document- 67832/3900-PM-WM0001.pdf.
57. Stedinger, J. R.; Vogel, R. M.; Foufoula-Georgiou, E., Frequency analysis of extreme events. In Handbook of Hydrology, Maidment, D., Ed.; McGraw-Hill: New York, NY, 1993; pp 18.1-18.66.
58. Computing Low-Flow Statistics for Ungaged Locations on Pennsylvania Streams By Use of Drainage-Area Ratios; Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection, 2002; http://paapps.er.usgs.gov/flowstats/revised-deplowflow.pdf.
59. Stedinger, J. R.; Thomas, W. O., Jr Low-Flow Frequency Estimation Using Base-Flow Measurements; U.S. Geological Survey: Reston, VA, 1985.
60. Hirsch, R. M. A comparison of four streamflow record extension techniques Water Resour. Res. 1982, 18 (4) 1081-1088
61. Eng, K.; Kiang, J. E.; Chen, Y.; Carlisle, D. M.; Granato, G. E. Causes of systematic over-or underestimation of low streamflows by use of index-streamgage approaches in the United States Hydrol. Processes 2011, 25, 2211-2220
62. Stuckey, M. H. Low-Flow, Base-Flow, and Mean-Flow Regression Equations for Pennsylvania Streams; U.S. Geological Survey: New Cumberland, PA, 2006.
63. Tasker, G. D.; Stedinger, J. R. An operational GLS model for hydrologic regression J. Hydrol. 1989, 111 (1-4) 361-375
64. Stuckey, M. H.; Koerkle, E. H.; Ulrich, J. E. Estimation of Baseline Daily Mean Streamflows for Ungaged Locations on Pennsylvania Streams, Water Years 1960-2008; U.S. Geological Survey: New Cumberland, PA, 2012; p 61.
65. Hill, M. Water Management Plan; Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection: Harrisburg, PA, 2012; The Pennsylvania Geospatial Data Clearinghouse (accessed 2/13/12)
66. Requirements for Water Withdrawal Registration & Reporting, 25 Pa. Code Chapter 110; Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection: Harrisburg, PA, 2008.
67. Wade, S. A. Stream Flow Characterization Over Longwall Coal Mines in Pennsylvania, Ohio, and West Virginia; Department of Geology and Geography: Morgantown, WV, 2008.
68. Chaplin, J. J.; Cravotta, III, C. A.; Weitzel, J. B.; Klemow, K. M. Effects of Historical Coal Mining and Drainage from Abandoned Mines on Streamflow and Water Quality in Newport and Nanticoke Creeks, Luzerne County, Pennsylvania, 1999-2000; Scientific Investigations Report 2007-5061; U.S. Geological Survey: New Cumberland, PA, 2007; http://pubs.usgs.gov/sir/2007/5061/ .
69. Smakhtin, V. U. Low flow hydrology: A review J. Hydrol. 2001, 240, 147-186
70. Environmental Resources Research Institute, Major watershedboundaries for Pennsylvania conservation gap analysis, (PennsylvaniaGap Analysis Program, University Park, PA, (1998). The Pennsylvania State University (accessed 2/8/2013)
71. Mined Out Areas. In The Pennsylvania Geospatial Data Clearinghouse; Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection (Bureau of District Mining Operations): Harrisburg, PA, 2012, (accessed 8/7/12).
72. Longwall mining panels. The Pennsylvania Geospatial Data Clearinghouse; Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection (Bureau of District Mining Operations): Harrisburg, PA, 2012; (accessed 8/8/2012).
73. Fortin, V.; Bobee, B. Nonparametric bootstrap confidence intervals for the Log-Pearson type III distribution Trans. Ecol. Environ. 1994, 6, 351-358
74. Ames, D. P. Estimating 7Q10 confidence limits from data: A bootstrap approach J. Water Resour. Plann. Manage. 2006, 132 (3) 204-208
75. Mobley, J.; Culver, T. Design of outlet control structures for ecological detention ponds J. Water Resour. Plann. Manage. 2012, 10.1061/(ASCE)WR.1943- 5452.0000266
76. Vogel, R. M.; Fennessey, N. M. Flow duration curves: II. A review of applications in water resources planning Water Resour. Bull. 1995, 31, 1029-1039
77. Vogel, R. M.; Sieber, J.; Archfield, S. A.; Smith, M. P.; Apse, C. E.; Huber-Lee, A. Relations among storage, yield and instream flow Water Resour. Res. 2007, 43, 5
78. Groundwater Protection Council. Interstate Oil and Gas Commission Compact, FracFocus Chemical Disclosure Registry. In 1/1/2013 ed.; http://fracfocus.org/, 2013.
79. American Society of Civil Engineers. Task Committee on low-flow evaluation, methods, and needs of the Committee on Surface-Water Hydrology of the Hydraulics Division. ASCE J. Hydraul. 1980, 106, (HY5), 717-731.
80. Huh, S.; Dickey, D. A.; Meador, M. R.; Ruhl, K. E. Temporal analysis of the frequency and duration of low and high streamflow: years of record needed to characterize streamflow variability J. Hydrol. 2005, 310, 78-94
81. Richter, B. D.; Baumgartner, J. V.; Wigington, R.; Braun, D. P. How much water does a river need? Freshwater Biol. 1997, 37, 231-249