Interoperability evaluation models: A systematic review

Computers in Industry

Volumn 65, Issue 1, 2014, Pages 1-23

  Rezaei, Reza ^a,b   Chiew, Thiam Kian ^a   Lee, Sai Peck ^a   Shams Aliee, Zeinab ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF MALAYA   (Malaysia)

^b ISLAMIC AZAD UNIVERSITY   (Iran)

Author keywords

Assessment; Evaluation; Interoperability; Measurement

Indexed keywords

ASSESSMENT; COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS; EVALUATION; EVALUATION MODELING; EVALUATION MODELS; SOFTWARE SYSTEMS; SYSTEMATIC REVIEW;

ENGINEERING; INDUSTRY; MEASUREMENTS;

INTEROPERABILITY;

EID: 84887989430     PISSN: 01663615     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.compind.2013.09.001     Document Type: Review

References (90)

1. C.E. Kuziemsky, and J.H. Weber-Jahnke An eBusiness-based framework for eHealth interoperability Journal of Emerging Technologies in Web Intelligence 1 2 2009 129 136
2. E. Kajan Electronic business interoperability: concepts, opportunities and challenges Business Science Reference 2011
3. M. Javanbakht, R. Rezaie, F. Shams, and M. Seyyedi A new method for decision making and planning in enterprises Information and Communication Technologies: From Theory to Applications, IEEE Damascus 2008 1 5
4. K. Breitfelder, and D. Messina IEEE 100 the authoritative dictionary of IEEE standards terms Standards Information Network IEEE Press 879 2000
5. J. Radatz, A. Geraci, and F. Katki IEEE Standard Glossary of Software Engineering Terminology,IEEE Std, (610121990) 1990 121990
6. A. Geraci, F. Katki, L. McMonegal, B. Meyer, J. Lane, P. Wilson, J. Radatz, M. Yee, H. Porteous, and F. Springsteel IEEE Standard Computer Dictionary: Compilation of IEEE Standard Computer Glossaries 1991 IEEE Press Piscataway
7. J. Pub Joint Publication 1-02, DoD Dictionary of Military and Associated Terms 12 2001
8. D. Defense Chairman of The Joint Chiefs of Staff Instruction, Policy (CJCSI 2800.01C) 2001
9. U.J.F. Command Capstone Requirements Document: Global Information Grid (GIG) 2001 JROCM 1 99
10. M. Kasunic, and W. Anderson Measuring Systems Interoperability: Challenges and Opportunities. Technical Note 2004 Software Engineering Institute, Carnegie Mellon University Pittsburgh
11. C.E. de Normalisation, and E.K. für Normung CEN/ISO 11354-1, Part 1: Framework for Enterprise Interoperability 2011
12. D. Chen Enterprise interoperability framework Proceedings of Enterprise Modelling and Ontologies for Interoperability, EMOI-Interop 2006
13. E.J. Morris, L. Levine, B.C. Meyers, and D. Plakosh System of Systems Interoperability (SOSI): Final Report 2004 Software Engineering Institute, Carnegie Mellon University Pittsburgh
14. D. Carney, and P. Oberndorf Integration and interoperability models for systems of systems Proceedings of the System and Software Technology Conference 2004 1 35
15. S. Munk An analysis of basic interoperability related terms, system of interoperability types Academic and Applied Research in Military Sciences 1 2002 117 131
16. S. Heiler Semantic Interoperability ACM Computing Surveys 27 2 1995 271 273
17. L. Levine, B.C. Meyers, and E.J. Morris Proceedings of the System of Systems Interoperability Workshop, Software Engineering Institute, Carnegie Mellon University, (CMU/SEI-2003-TN-016) 2003 1 37
18. Y. Naudet, T. Latour, W. Guedria, and D. Chen Towards a systemic formalisation of interoperability Computers in Industry 61 2 2010 176 185
19. A. Zutshi, A. Grilo, and R. Jardim-Goncalves The business interoperability quotient measurement model Computers in Industry 63 5 2012 389 404
20. M. Novakouski, and G.A. Lewis Interoperability in the e-Government Context 2012 SEI, Carnegie Mellon University Pittsburgh 1 35
21. Y. Charalabidis, and S. Pantelopoulos Enhancing Application Interoperability and Enabling B2B Transactions over the Internet for Small and Medium Enterprises: The PRAXIS Project CAiSE Workshops (3) 2004 257 260
22. T. Kinder Mrs. Miller moves house: the interoperability of local public services in Europe Journal of European Social Policy 13 2 2003 141 157
23. K. Kosanke ISO Standards for interoperability: a comparison Proceedings of INTEROP-ESA'05 Geneva, Swiss, February 21-25 2005, Springer-Verlag 2006 55 64
24. Y. Charalabidis, and D. Chen Achieving enterprise application interoperability: design patterns and directives, Workshop on Ontology and Enterprise Modelling: Ingredients for Interoperability 2004
25. H. Van der Veer, and A. Wiles Achieving Technical Interoperability - the ETSI Approach ETSI White Paper 3 2008
26. F. Lampathaki, S. Koussouris, C. Agostinho, R. Jardim-Goncalves, Y. Charalabidis, and J. Psarras Infusing scientific foundations into enterprise interoperability Computers in Industry 2012
27. Y. Charalabidis, F. Lampathaki, A. Kavalaki, and D. Askounis A review of electronic government interoperability frameworks: patterns and challenges International Journal of Electronic Governance 3 2 2010 189 221
28. Y. Charalabidis, S. Pantelopoulos, and Y. Koussos Enabling interoperability of transactional enterprise applications Workshop on Interoperability of Enterprise Systems, 18th European Conference on Object-Oriented Programming (ECOOP) Oslo 2004 14 18
29. G.A. Lewis, and L. Wrage Model Problems in Technologies for Interoperability: Web Services (CMU/SEI-2006-TN-021) 2006 1 37
30. L. Guijarro Semantic interoperability in eGovernment initiatives Computer Standards & Interfaces 31 1 2009 174 180
31. J. Hall, and S. Koukoulas Semantic Interoperability for E-Business in the ISP Service Domain, ICE-B 2008 26 29
32. Y. Charalabidis, R.J. Gonçalves, and K. Popplewell Towards a scientific foundation for interoperability Interoperability in Digital Public Services and Administration: Bridging E-Government and E-Business 2010 355 373
33. Y. Charalabidis, G. Gionis, K.M. Hermann, and C. Martinez Enterprise Interoperability Research Roadmap 2008 European Commission
34. G. Gionis, Y. Charalabidis, T. Janner, C. Schroth, S. Koussouris, and D. Askounis Enabling cross-organizational interoperability: a hybrid e-business architecture Enterprise Interoperability II 2007 Springer London 525 528
35. Y. Charalabidis, H. Panetto, E. Loukis, and K. Mertins Interoperability approaches for enterprises and administrations worldwide The Electronic Journal for E-Commerce Tools and Applications (eJeta) 2 3 2008 1 10
36. M. Vida, and L. Stoicu-Tivadar Measuring medical informatics systems interoperability using the LISI model IEEE 8th International Symposium on Intelligent Systems and Informatics, IEEE Subotica, Serbia 2010 33 36
37. D. Chen POP* Meta-Model For Enterprise Model Interoperability, Information Control Problems in Manufacturing 2009 V.A. Trapeznikov Institute of Control Sciences Russia 175 180
38. C. Legner, and K. Wende Towards an excellence framework for business interoperability Proceedings of 19th Bled eConference eValues 2006 5 7
39. E. Commission European interoperability framework for pan-european egovernment services IDA Working Document, Version 2 2004
40. F. Lillehagen, and H. Solheim ATHENA A1 deliverables, Deliverable DA1. 5.1: MPCE Specification 2004 Computas Oslo
41. A. Zutshi Framework for a Business Interoperability Quotient Measurement Model 2010 Departamento de Engenharia Mecânica e Industrial, Faculdade de Ciências e Tecnologia da Universidade Nova de Lisboa Portugal
42. J. Staff Joint Publication 1-02, DOD Dictionary of Military and Associated Terms 2008 US Govt Printing Office Washington, DC 1 495
43. J. Staff Joint Publication 1-02 2004 Department of Defense Dictionary of Military and Associated Terms Washington, DC
44. D.D. Directive Standardization and Interoperability of Weapons Systems and Equipment within the North Atlantic Treaty Organization 1980 DoD Washington
45. E. Morris, L. Levine, C. Meyers, P. Place, and D. Plakosh System of Systems Interoperability (SOSI): Final Report, Citeseer (ESC-TR-2004-004) 2004
46. K. Stewart Non-Technical Interoperability: The Challenge of Command Leadership in Multinational Operations 2004 QinetiQ Ltd./Centre for Human Sciences Farnborough, United Kingdom (ADA465749)
47. E.P. Presson Software Metrics and Interoperability Proceedings of AIAA Computers in Aerospace IV Conference Hartford 1983
48. D. Defense Realizing the Potential of C4I 1999 National Academy Press Washington, D.C.
49. S. Koussouris, F. Lampathaki, S. Mouzakitis, Y. Charalabidis, and J. Psarras Digging into the real-life enterprise interoperability areas definition and overview of the main research areas Proceedings of CENT 2011 19 22
50. T. Clark, and T. Moon Interoperability for joint and coalition operations Australian Defence Force Journal 2001
51. G.E. Lavean Interoperability in defense communications IEEE Transactions on Communications 28 9 1980 1445 1455
52. M.J. DiMario System of Systems Interoperability Types and Characteristics In Joint Command and Control 2006 Software Engineering Institute, Carnegie Mellon University 1 6
53. D. Mensh, R. Kite, and P. Darby A methodology for quantifying interoperability Naval Engineers Journal 1998
54. M. Amanowicz, and P. Gajewski Military communications and information systems interoperability 1 1996 280 283
55. DOD Levels of Information Systems Interoperability (LISI) 1998 Department of Defense United States 1 139
56. D. Chen, G. Doumeingts, and F. Vernadat Architectures for enterprise integration and interoperability: Past, present and future Computers in Industry 59 7 2008 647 659
57. M. Kasunic Measuring Systems Interoperability: Challenges and Opportunities, DTIC Document (074-0188) 2001 1 39
58. M. Kasunic Measuring Systems Interoperability 2003 Software Engineering Institute, Carnegie Mellon University Pittsburgh 1 18
59. K. Stewart, H. Clarke, P. Goillau, N. Verrall, and M. Widdowson Non-Technical Interoperability in Multinational Forces 2004 QinetiQ Ltd./Centre for Human Sciences Farnborough, United Kingdom
60. G. Kingston An Organisational Interoperability Agility Model 2005 Defence Science and Technology Organisation Canberra Australia 1 31
61. T. Cl ark, R. Jones, Organisational interoperability maturity model for C2, in, Proceedings of the Conference Name|, Conference Location|, Conference Date|, Publisher|, Year of Conference|, pp. Pages|.
62. U. Schade Towards the edge and beyond: the role of interoperability 10th International Command and Control Research and Technology Symposium 2005
63. Review Review of Operational Level Interoperability Between the Military Forces of Australia and the United States of America, United States and Australia 2004
64. B.C. Meyers, and J.D. Smith Programmatic Interoperability 2007 Software Engineering Institute, Carnegie Mellon University Pittsburgh
65. L. Brownsword, D.J. Carney, D. Fisher, G. Lewis, and C. Meyers Current Perspectives on Interoperability 2004 Software Engineering Institute, Carnegie Mellon University Pittsburgh
66. S. Fewell, and T. Clark Organisational interoperability: evaluation and further development of the OIM model 2003 Defence Science and Technology Organisation Edinburgh, Australia
67. M.J. Leite Interoperability assessment Proceedings of the 66th Military Operations Research Society Symposium Monterey, CA 1998
68. B.C. Meyers, I. Monarch, L. Levine, and J.I.I. Smith Including Interoperability in the Acquisition Process 2005 Software Engineering Institute, Carnegie Mellon University Pittsburgh 1 74
69. J.A. Hamilton Jr., J.D. Rosen, and P.A. Summers An Interoperability Road Map for C4ISR Legacy Systems, DTIC Document 2002
70. ATHENA D.A1.4.1: Framework for the Establishment and Management Methodology, Version 1.0 2005 ATHENA IP, Interoperability Research for Networked Enterprises Applications and Software
71. T. Ford, J. Colombi, S. Graham, and D. Jacques The interoperability score Proceedings of the Fifth Annual Conference on Systems Engineering Research 2007 1 10
72. T. Ford, J. Colombi, S. Graham, and D. Jacques Measuring System Interoperability (An i-Score Improvement), Air Force Institute of Technology CSER 2008
73. D. Sarantis, Y. Charalabidis, and J. Psarras Towards standardising interoperability levels for information systems of public administrations The Electronic Journal for E-commerce Tools & Applications (eJETA) Special Issue on Interoperability for Enterprises and Administrations Worldwide 2 2008
74. J. Mykkänen, and M. Tuomainen An evaluation and selection framework for interoperability standards Information and Software Technology 50 3 2008 176 197
75. F. Lampathaki, S. Mouzakitis, G. Gionis, Y. Charalabidis, and D. Askounis Business to business interoperability: a current review of XML data integration standards Computer Standards & Interfaces 31 6 2009 1045 1055
76. G. Gionis, Y. Charalabidis, K. Sourouni, and D. Askounis Enabling cross-border interoperability: modelling legal rules for electronic transactions in the European Union Enterprise Interoperability II 2007 Springer London 361 364
77. A. Vallecillo, J. Troya, and J. Hernández Object interoperability A. Moreira, Object-Oriented Technology ECOOP'99 Workshop Reader 1999 Springer Berlin Heidelberg 1 21
78. N. Gershenfeld, R. Krikorian, and D. Cohen The Internet of things Scientific American 291 4 2004 76 81
79. E. Commission Early Challenges regarding the "Internet of Things", Accompanying document to the Communication on future networks and the internet 6 2008 European Commission Brussels (Retrieved 6.10.2008)
80. E. Lusk, N. Desai, R. Bradshaw, A. Lusk, and R. Butler An interoperability approach to system software, tools, and libraries for clusters International Journal of High Performance Computing Applications 20 3 2006 401 408
81. C. Britton, and P. Bye IT Architectures and Middleware: Strategies for Building Large, Integrated Systems 2004 Pearson Education
82. T. Al-Naeem, F.A. Rabhi, B. Benatallah, and P.K. Ray Systematic approaches for designing B2B applications International Journal of Electronic Commerce 9 2 2005 41 70
83. M. Papazoglou Web Services: Principles and Technology 2008 Pearson Education
84. Y. Charalabidis, R.J. Gonçalves, and K. Popplewell Developing a science base for enterprise interoperability Enterprise Interoperability IV 2010 Springer London 245 254
85. F. Abel, N. Henze, and D. Krause Social semantic web at work: annotating and grouping social media content J. Cordeiro, S. Hammoudi, J. Filipe, Web Information Systems and Technologies 2009 Springer Berlin Heidelberg 199 213
86. J. Palfrey, and U. Gasser Interoperability DI. Digital Identity Interoperability Einnovation 2007 Berkman Center Research Publication, Harvard University
87. T. Dillon, C. Wu, and E. Chang Cloud computing: Issues and challenges, Advanced Information Networking and Applications (AINA), 2010 24th IEEE International Conference on, IEEE Perth, WA 2010 27 33
88. M. Janssen, Y. Charalabidis, and H. Krcmar Introduction to Cloud Infrastructures and Interoperability Minitrack, System Sciences (HICSS), 2013 46th Hawaii International Conference on, IEEE Wailea, HI, USA 2013 1641
89. Y. Charalabidis, M. Janssen, and O. Glassey Introduction to cloud infrastructures and interoperability minitrack Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences 2012 2177
90. T.C. Ford, J.M. Colombi, S.R. Graham, and D.R. Jacques Survey on Interoperability Measurement DTIC Document 2007