Is obsidian sourcing about geochemistry or archaeology? A reply to Speakman and Shackley

Journal of Archaeological Science

Volumn 40, Issue 2, 2013, Pages 1444-1448

  Frahm, Ellery ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF SHEFFIELD   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

Accuracy; Obsidian sourcing; Portable XRF; Reliability; Validity

Indexed keywords

ACCURACY ASSESSMENT; ARCHAEOLOGICAL EVIDENCE; ARCHAEOLOGY; GEOCHEMISTRY; OBSIDIAN; RELIABILITY ANALYSIS;

EID: 84885371950     PISSN: 03054403     EISSN: 10959238     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.jas.2012.10.001     Document Type: Note

References (26)

1. Barberena, R., Hajduk, A., Gil, A., Neme, G., Duran, V., Glascock, M., Giesso, M., Borrazzo, K., de La Paz Pompei, M., Salgan, M., Cortegoso, V., Villarosa, G., Rughini, A., 2011. Obsidian in the south-central Andes: geological, geochemical, and archaeological assessment of north Patagonian sources (Argentina). Quaternary International 245 (1), 25e36.
2. Bernard, H., 2011. Research Methods in Anthropology: Qualitative and Quantitative Approaches, fifth ed. AltaMira Press, Lanham, Maryland.
3. Blomster, J., Glascock, M., 2011. Obsidian procurement in formative Oaxaca, Mexico: diachronic changes in political economy and interregional interaction. Journal of Field Archaeology 36, 21e41.
4. Carmines, E., Zeller, R., 1979. Reliability and Validity Assessment. Quantitative Applications in the Social Sciences. Sage Publications, Thousand Oaks, California.
5. Carter, T., Shackley, M., 2007. Sourcing obsidian from Neolithic çatalhöyük (Turkey) using energy dispersive X-ray fluorescence. Archaeometry 49, 437e454.
6. Craig, N., Speakman, R., Popelka-Filcoff, R., Glascock, M., Robertson, J., Shackley, M., Aldenderfer, M., 2007. Comparison of XRF and PXRF for analysis of archaeological obsidian from southern Perú. Journal of Archaeological Science 34, 2012e2024.
7. Dybowski, D., 2012. pXRF/WDXRFS inter-unit data comparison of Arizona obsidian samples. Journal of Arizona Archaeology 2, 1e7.
8. Frahm, E., 2010. The Bronze-Age Obsidian Industry at Tell Mozan (Ancient Urkesh), Syria. Ph.D. dissertation, Department of Anthropology, University of Minnesota. Available online at University of Minnesota's Digital Conservancy: http://purl. umn.edu/99753
9. Frahm, E., 2012. Evaluation of archaeological sourcing techniques: reconsidering and re-deriving Hughes' four-fold assessment scheme. Geoarchaeology 27, 166e174.
10. Giesso, M., Duran, V., Neme, G., Glascock, M., Cortegoso, V., Gil, A., Sanhueza, L., 2011. A study of obsidian source usage in the Central Andes of Argentina and Chile. Archaeometry 53, 1e21.
11. Glascock, M., Giesso, M., 2012. New perspectives on obsidian procurement and exchange at Tiwanaku, Bolivia. In: Liritzis, I., Stevenson, C. (Eds.), Obsidian and Ancient Manufactured Glasses. University of New Mexico Press.
12. Glascock, M., Beyin, A., Coleman, M., 2008. X-ray fluorescence and neutron activation analysis of obsidian from the Red Sea Coast of Eritrea. International Association for Obsidian Studies 38, 6e10.
13. Glascock, M., Kuzmin, Y., Grebennikov, A., Popov, V., Medvedev, V., Shewkomud, I., Zaitsev, N., 2011. Obsidian provenance for prehistoric complexes in the Amur River basin (Russian Far East). Journal of Archaeological Science 38, 1832e1841.
14. Glascock, M., 1999. An inter-laboratory comparison of element compositions for two obsidian sources. International Association for Obsidian Studies Bulletin 23, 13e25.
15. Jarosewich, E., Nelen, J., Norberg, J., 1980. Reference samples for electron microprobe analysis. Geostandards Newsletter 4, 43e47.
16. Latour, B., Woolgar, S., 1979. Laboratory Life: the Construction of Scientific Facts. Princeton University Press, Princeton.
17. Lemonnier, P., 1992. Elements for an Anthropology of Technology. University of Michigan Museum of Anthropology, Ann Arbor.
18. Lévi-Strauss, C., 1964. Le Cru et le Cuit (The Raw and the Cooked, 1969). Pion, Paris.
19. Mark, H., Workman Jr., J., 2003. Statistics in Spectroscopy, second ed. Elsevier Academic Press, San Diego, California.
20. Millhauser, J., Rodríguez-Alegría, E., Glascock, M., 2011. Testing the accuracy of portable X-ray fluorescence to study Aztec and Colonial obsidian supply at Xaltocan, Mexico. Journal of Archaeological Science 38, 3141e3152.
21. Nazaroff, A., Prufer, K., Drake, B., 2010. Assessing the applicability of portable X-ray fluorescence spectrometry for obsidian provenance research in the Maya lowlands. Journal of Archaeological Science 37, 885e895.
22. Neff, H., 1998. Units in chemistry-based ceramic provenance investigations. In: Ramenofsky, A., Steffen, A. (Eds.), Unit Issues in Archaeology: Measuring Time, Space, and Material. University of Utah Press, pp. 115e127.
23. Rowe, M., Thornber, C., Gooding, D., Pallister, S., 2008. Catalog of Mount St. Helens 2004e2005 Tephra Samples with Major- and Trace-element Geochemistry. United States Geological Survey, Open-File Report 2008-1131. Available online: http://pubs.usgs.gov/of/2008/1131/.
24. Shackley, M., Nov. 2010. Is There Reliability and Validity in Portable X-ray Fluorescence Spectrometry (PXRF)? The SAA Archaeological Record, pp. 17e 18, 20.
25. Streck, M., Wacaster, S., 2006. Plagioclase and pyroxene hosted melt inclusions in basaltic andesites of the current eruption of Arenal Volcano, Costa Rica. Journal of Volcanology and Geothermal Research 157, 236e253.
26. Taylor, B., Kuyatt, C., 1994. Guidelines for Evaluating and Expressing the Uncertainty of NIST Measurement Results. NIST Technical Note 1297. Available online: http://www.nist.gov/pml/pubs/tn1297/index.cfm.