Do intensivist staffing patterns influence hospital mortality following icu admission? A systematic review and meta-analyses

Critical Care Medicine

Volumn 41, Issue 10, 2013, Pages 2253-2274

  Wilcox, M Elizabeth ^a   Chong, Christopher A K Y ^b,c   Niven, Daniel J ^d   Rubenfeld, Gordon D ^e   Rowan, Kathryn M ^f   Wunsch, Hannah ^g,h   Fan, Eddy ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF TORONTO   (Canada)

^b LAKERIDGE HEALTH CORPORATION   (Canada)

^c QUEEN S UNIVERSITY   (Canada)

^d UNIVERSITY OF CALGARY   (Canada)

^e SUNNYBROOK RESEARCH INSTITUTE   (Canada)

^f and London School of Hygiene Tropical Medicine   (United Kingdom)

^g Columbia University ^*  (United States)

^h NONE   (United States)

Author keywords

critical care; intensivist; length of stay; meta analysis; mortality; physician staffing pattern; systematic review

Indexed keywords

COHORT ANALYSIS; CONSULTATION; CRITICALLY ILL PATIENT; HOSPITAL ADMISSION; HOSPITAL PERSONNEL MANAGEMENT; HOSPITALIZATION; HUMAN; INTENSIVE CARE UNIT; INTENSIVIST; LENGTH OF STAY; META ANALYSIS; MORTALITY; OBSERVATIONAL STUDY; PRIORITY JOURNAL; REVIEW; RISK ASSESSMENT; SCORING SYSTEM; SURGICAL RISK; SYSTEMATIC REVIEW;

CRITICAL ILLNESS; HOSPITAL MORTALITY; HOSPITALIZATION; HUMANS; INTENSIVE CARE UNITS; MEDICAL STAFF, HOSPITAL; MODELS, ORGANIZATIONAL; PERSONNEL STAFFING AND SCHEDULING;

EID: 84884900789     PISSN: 00903493     EISSN: 15300293     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1097/CCM.0b013e318292313a     Document Type: Review

References (90)

1. Angus DC, Shorr AF, White A, et al; Committee on Manpower for Pulmonary and Critical Care Societies (COMPACCS): Critical care delivery in the United States: Distribution of services and compliance with Leapfrog recommendations. Crit Care Med 2006; 34:1016-1024
2. Lilly CM, Zuckerman IH, Badawi O, et al: Benchmark data from more than 240,000 adults that reflect the current practice of critical care in the United States. Chest 2011; 140:1232-1242
3. Vincent JL, Artigas A, Bihari D, et al: Guidelines for the utilisation of intensive care units. Intensive Care Med 1994; 20:163-164
4. Fein IA, Fish DJ, Fisher CJ Jr, et al; Task Force on Guidelines Society of Critical Care Medicine: Guidelines for standards of care for patients with acute respiratory failure on mechanical ventilatory support. Crit Care Med 1991; 19:275-278
5. De Lange S, Van Aken H, Burchardi H: European Society of Intensive Care Medicine statement: Intensive care medicine in Europe- Structure, organisation and training guidelines of the Multidisciplinary Joint Committee of Intensive Care Medicine of the European Union of Medical Specialists. Intensive Care Med 2002; 28:1505-1511 (Pubitemid 36002496)
6. Pronovost PJ, Angus DC, Dorman T, et al: Physician staffing patterns and clinical outcomes in critically ill patients: A systematic review. JAMA 2002; 288:2151-2162 (Pubitemid 35276516)
7. Young MP, Birkmeyer JD: Potential reduction in mortality rates using an intensivist model to manage intensive care units. Eff Clin Pract 2000; 3:284-289
8. Levy MM, Rapoport J, Lemeshow S, et al: Association between critical care physician management and patient mortality in the intensive care unit. Ann Intern Med 2008; 148:801-809 (Pubitemid 351786927)
9. Hall JB: Organizational effects on outcome. In: Evaluating Critical Care: Using Health Services Research to Improve Quality (Update in Intensive Care and Emergency Medicine). Sibbald WJ, Bion J (Eds). Berlin, Heidelberg, Springer-Verlag, 2001, pp 281-291
10. Bach PB, Carson SS, Leff A: Outcomes and resource utilization for patients with prolonged critical illness managed by university-based or community-based subspecialists. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 1998; 158(5, Part 1):1410-1415
11. Carmel S, Rowan K: Variation in intensive care unit outcomes: A search for the evidence on organizational factors. Curr Opin Crit Care 2001; 7:284-296 (Pubitemid 32868480)
12. Mays N, Roberts E, Popay J: Synthesizing research evidence. In: Studying the Organization and Delivery of Health Services: Research Methods. Fulop N, Allen P, Clarke A (Eds). London, Routledge, 2001, pp 188-220
13. Altman DG: Practical Statistics for Medical Research. London, Chapman and Hall, 1991
14. Tai DY, Goh SK, Eng PC, et al: Impact on quality of patient care and procedure use in the medical intensive care unit (MICU) following reorganisation. Ann Acad Med Singapore 1998; 27:309-313 (Pubitemid 128524745)
15. Mayo E, Helman J, Siddappa R, et al: An intensivist-directed multidisciplinary pediatric cardiac critical care team model is associated with improved outcomes following pediatric cardiac surgery. Crit Care Med 2010; 38:A17
16. Topeli A: Effect of changing organization of intensive care unit from "open policy without critical care specialist" to "closed policy with critical care specialist." Am J Respir Crit Care Med 2000; 161:A397
17. Wells GA, Shea B, O'Connell D, et al: The Newcastle-Ottawa Scale (NOS) for assessing the quality of nonrandomised studies in metaanalyses. Available at: http://www.ohri.ca/programs/clinical-epidemiology/oxford.asp. Accessed February 12, 2013
18. Higgins JP, Thompson SG: Quantifying heterogeneity in a meta-analysis. Stat Med 2002; 21:1539-1558 (Pubitemid 34746062)
19. Higgins JP, Thompson SG, Deeks JJ, et al: Measuring inconsistency in meta-analyses. BMJ 2003; 327:557-560 (Pubitemid 37088507)
20. Egger M, Davey Smith G, Schneider M, et al: Bias in meta-analysis detected by a simple, graphical test. BMJ 1997; 315:629-634 (Pubitemid 27387172)
21. Fleiss JL: The statistical basis of meta-analysis. Stat Methods Med Res 1993; 2:121-145
22. Brown JJ, Sullivan G: Effect on ICU mortality of a full-time critical care specialist. Chest 1989; 96:127-129 (Pubitemid 19176428)
23. Gajic O, Afessa B, Hanson AC, et al: Effect of 24-hour mandatory versus on-demand critical care specialist presence on quality of care and family and provider satisfaction in the intensive care unit of a teaching hospital. Crit Care Med 2008; 36:36-44
24. Netzer G, Liu X, Shanholtz C, et al: Decreased mortality resulting from a multicomponent intervention in a tertiary care medical intensive care unit. Crit Care Med 2011; 39:284-293
25. Roberts RG, Svendsen A, Moya FT: Effects of implementing twentyfour hour resident consultant intensivist staffing on mortality within a critical care unit. Intensive Care Med 2008; S5:A0016
26. Kumar K, Zarychanski R, Bell DD, et al; Cardiovascular Health Research in Manitoba Investigator Group: Impact of 24-hour in-house intensivists on a dedicated cardiac surgery intensive care unit. Ann Thorac Surg 2009; 88:1153-1161
27. Blunt MC, Burchett KR: Out-of-hours consultant cover and case-mixadjusted mortality in intensive care. Lancet 2000; 356:735-736 (Pubitemid 30663245)
28. Carson SS, Stocking C, Podsadecki T, et al: Effects of organizational change in the medical intensive care unit of a teaching hospital: A comparison of 'open' and 'closed' formats. JAMA 1996; 276:322-328 (Pubitemid 26249538)
29. Ghorra S, Reinert SE, Cioffi W, et al: Analysis of the effect of conversion from open to closed surgical intensive care unit. Ann Surg 1999; 229:163-171 (Pubitemid 30191787)
30. Al-Asadi L, Dellinger RP, Deutch J, et al: Clinical impact of closed versus open provider care in a medical intensive care unit. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 1996; 153:A360
31. Hanson CW III, Deutschman CS, Anderson HL III, et al: Effects of an organized critical care service on outcomes and resource utilization: A cohort study. Crit Care Med 1999; 27:270-274 (Pubitemid 29113534)
32. Baldock G, Foley P, Brett S: The impact of organisational change on outcome in an intensive care unit in the United Kingdom. Intensive Care Med 2001; 27:865-872 (Pubitemid 32480515)
33. Gannon S, Mayer M, Johnson L, et al: Impact of a surgical intensivist team on ICU outcomes. Crit Care Med 2010; 38:A531 34. Marini CP, Nathan IM, Ritter G, et al: The impact of full-time surgical intensivists on ICU utilization and mortality. Crit Care Med 1995; 23:A235
34. Multz AS, Chalfin DB, Samson IM, et al: A 'closed' medical intensive care unit (MICU) improves resource utilization when compared with an 'open' MICU. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 2001; 157(5, Part 1):1468-1473
35. Varelas PN, Conti MM, Spanaki MV, et al: The impact of a neurointensivist-led team on a semi-closed neurosciences intensive care unit. Crit Care Med 2004; 32:2191-2198 (Pubitemid 39491797)
36. Goh AY, Lum LC, Abdel-Latif ME: Impact of 24 hour critical care physician staffing on case-mix adjusted mortality in paediatric intensive care. Lancet 2001; 357:445-446 (Pubitemid 32156149)
37. Singh RK, Azim A, Baronia A, et al: Impact of ICU model on outcome of severe acute pancreatitis. Intensive Care Med 2008; S74:A277
38. Zwaal JW, Baba R: Diagnostic accuracy in an open vs. closed intensive care unit. Intensive Care Med 2004; S80:A045
39. Kuo HS, Tang G-J, Chuang J-H, et al: Changing ICU mortality in a decade-The effect of full-time intensivist. Crit Care Shock 2000; 3:57-61
40. Li TC, Phillips MC, Shaw L, et al: On-site physician staffing in a community hospital intensive care unit. Impact on test and procedure use and on patient outcome. JAMA 1984; 252:2023-2027 (Pubitemid 14046201)
41. Hawari FI, Al Najjar TI, Zaru L, et al: The effect of implementing highintensity intensive care unit staffing model on outcome of critically ill oncology patients. Crit Care Med 2009; 37:1967-1971
42. Reich HS, Buhler L, David M, et al: Saving lives in the community, impact of intensive care leadership. Crit Care Med 1997; 25:A5
43. Reynolds HN, Haupt MT, Thill-Baharozian MC, et al: Impact of critical care physician staffing on patients with septic shock in a university hospital medical intensive care unit. JAMA 1988; 260:3446-3450 (Pubitemid 19003123)
44. Topeli A, Laghi F, Tobin MJ: Effect of closed unit policy and appointing an intensivist in a developing country. Crit Care Med 2005; 33:299-306 (Pubitemid 40216541)
45. Nathens AB, Brunet FP, Maier RV: Development of trauma systems and effect on outcomes after injury. Lancet 2004; 363:1794-1801 (Pubitemid 38698385)
46. DiCosmo BF: Addition of an intensivist improves ICU outcomes in a non-teaching community hospital. Chest 1999; 116:S238
47. Dimick JB, Pronovost PJ, Lipsett PA: The effect of ICU physician staffing and hospital volume on outcomes after hepatic resection. J Intensive Care Med 2002; 17:41-47 (Pubitemid 34111983)
48. Dimick JB, Pronovost PJ, Heitmiller RF, et al: Intensive care unit physician staffing is associated with decreased length of stay, hospital cost, and complications after esophageal resection. Crit Care Med 2001; 29:753-758 (Pubitemid 32299712)
49. Garland A, Kilkenny TM, Anderson MA, et al: Care of ICU patients by intensivist vs. non-intensivists. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 1996; 153:A362
50. Pronovost PJ, Jenckes MW, Dorman T, et al: Organisational characteristics of intensive care units related to outcomes of abdominal aortic surgery. JAMA 1999; 281:1310-1317 (Pubitemid 29174483)
51. Suarez JI, Zaidat OO, Suri MF, et al: Length of stay and mortality in neurocritically ill patients: Impact of a specialized neurocritical care team. Crit Care Med 2004; 32:2311-2317 (Pubitemid 39491814)
52. Lin HC, Xirasagar S, Chen CH, et al: Physician's case volume of intensive care unit pneumonia admissions and in-hospital mortality. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 2008; 177:989-994 (Pubitemid 351717593)
53. Lettieri CJ, Shah AA, Greenburg DL: An intensivist-directed intensive care unit improves clinical outcomes in a combat zone. Crit Care Med 2009; 37:1256-1260
54. Pollack MM, Katz RW, Ruttimann UE, et al: Improving the outcome and efficiency of intensive care: The impact of an intensivist. Crit Care Med 1988; 16:11-17
55. Pollack MM, Cuerdon TT, Patel KM, et al: Impact of quality-of-care factors on pediatric intensive care unit mortality. JAMA 1994; 272:941-946 (Pubitemid 24288548)
56. Thurlby JR, Grathwohl KW, Perkins JG, et al: Reduced mortality by an intensivist or intensivist-directed ICU team at a combat support hospital (CSH) in Iraq. Crit Care Med 2005; 33:A4
57. Rivera BM, Torres-Palacios A, Torres-Palacios J, et al: The impact of an intensivist at the ICU: A retrospective study. Crit Care Med 2009; 37:A722
58. Wallace DJ, Angus DC, Barnato AE, et al: Nighttime intensivist staffing and mortality among critically ill patients. N Engl J Med 2012; 366:2093-2101
59. McMillen MA, Boucher N, Keith D, et al: Maintaining quality of care 24/7 in a nontrauma surgical intensive care unit. J Trauma Acute Care Surg 2012; 73:202-208
60. Kim JH, Hong SK, Kim KC, et al: Influence of full-time intensivist and the nurse-to-patient ratio on the implementation of severe sepsis bundles in Korean intensive care units. J Crit Care 2012; 27:414.e11-414.e21
61. Kim IH, Park SB, Kim S, et al: The impact of implementing critical care team on open general intensive care unit. Tuberc Respir Dis (Seoul) 2012; 73:100-106
62. Nishisaki A, Pines JM, Lin R, et al: The impact of 24-hr, in-hospital pediatric critical care attending physician presence on process of care and patient outcomes. Crit Care Med 2012; 40:2190-2195
63. Petitti D, Bennett V, Chao Hu CK: Association of changes in the use of board-certified critical care intensivists with mortality outcomes for trauma patients at a well-established level I urban trauma center. J Trauma Manag Outcomes 2012; 6:3
64. Reriani M, Biehl M, Sloan JA, et al: Effect of 24-hour mandatory vs on-demand critical care specialist presence on long-term survival and quality of life of critically ill patients in the intensive care unit of a teaching hospital. J Crit Care 2012; 27:421.e1-421.e7
65. Sales AE, Lapham GG, Squires J, et al: Organizational factors associated with decreased mortality among Veterans Affairs patients with an ICU stay. Comput Inform Nurs 2011; 29:496-501
66. Samuels O, Webb A, Culler S, et al: Impact of a dedicated neurocritical care team in treating patients with aneurysmal subarachnoid hemorrhage. Neurocrit Care 2011; 14:334-340
67. Wise KR, Akopov VA, Williams BR Jr, et al: Hospitalists and intensivists in the medical ICU: A prospective observational study comparing mortality and length of stay between two staffing models. J Hosp Med 2012; 7:183-189
68. Treggiari MM, Martin DP, Yanez ND, et al: Effect of intensive care unit organizational model and structure on outcomes in patients with acute lung injury. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 2007; 176:685-690 (Pubitemid 47503076)
69. Resnick S, Jacques A, Patole S, et al: Does after-hours in-house senior physician cover improve standard of care and outcomes in high-risk preterm neonates? A retrospective cohort study. J Paediatr Child Health 2011; 47:795-801
70. Garland A, Roberts D, Graff L: Twenty-four-hour intensivist presence: A pilot study of effects on intensive care unit patients, families, doctors, and nurses. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 2012; 185:738-743
71. Lott JP, Iwashyna TJ, Christie JD, et al: Critical illness outcomes in specialty versus general intensive care units. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 2009; 179:676-683
72. Brower RG, Matthay MA, Morris A, et al: Ventilation with lower tidal volumes as compared with traditional tidal volumes for acute lung injury and the acute respiratory distress syndrome. N Engl J Med 2000; 342:1301-1308 (Pubitemid 30408714)
73. Pronovost P, Needham D, Berenholtz S, et al: An intervention to decrease catheter-related bloodstream infections in the ICU. N Engl J Med 2006; 355:2725-2732 (Pubitemid 46021509)
74. McCannon CJ, Schall MW, Calkins DR, et al: Saving 100,000 lives in US hospitals. BMJ 2006; 332:1328-1330
75. Resar R, Pronovost P, Haraden C, et al: Using a bundle approach to improve ventilator care processes and reduce ventilator-associated pneumonia. Jt Comm J Qual Patient Saf 2005; 31:243-248
76. Wunsch H, Angus DC, Harrison DA, et al: Variation in critical care services across North America and Western Europe. Crit Care Med 2008; 36:2787-2793, e1-e9.
77. Kahn JM, Matthews FA, Angus DC, et al: Barriers to implementing the Leapfrog Group recommendations for intensivist intensivist physician staffing: A survey of intensive care unit directors. J Crit Care 2007; 22:97-103 (Pubitemid 46843503)
78. Young LB, Chan PS, Lu X, et al: Impact of telemedicine intensive care unit coverage on patient outcomes: A systematic review and metaanalysis. Arch Intern Med 2011; 171:498-506
79. Gershengorn HB, Johnson MP, Factor P: The use of nonphysician providers in adult intensive care units. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 2012; 185:600-605
80. Golder S, Loke Y, McIntosh HM: Room for improvement? A survey of methods used in systematic reviews of adverse effects. BMC Med Res Methodol 2006; 6:1-6
81. Audrige L, Bhandari M, Griffin D, et al: Systematic reviews of nonrandomised clinical studies in the orthopaedic literature. Clin Orthop Relat Res 2004; 427:250-258
82. Deeks JJ, Dinnes J, D'Amico R, et al; International Stroke Trial Collaborative Group; European Carotid Surgery Trial Collaborative Group: Evaluating non-randomised intervention studies. Health Technol Assess 2003; 7:iii-x, 1-173
83. Stroup DF, Berlin JA, Morton SC, et al: Meta-analysis of observational studies in epidemiology: A proposal for reporting. JAMA 2000; 283:2008-2012 (Pubitemid 30214957)
84. Kaboli PJ, Barnett MJ, Fuehrer SM, et al: Length of stay as a source of bias in comparing performance in VA and private sector facilities: Lessons learned from a regional evaluation of intensive care outcomes. Med Care 2001; 39:1014-1024 (Pubitemid 33603658)
85. Diringer MN, Edwards DF, Aiyagari V, et al: Factors associated with withdrawal of mechanical ventilation in a neurology/neurosurgical intensive care unit. Crit Care Med 2001; 29:1792-1797 (Pubitemid 32848383)
86. Wachter RM, Katz P, Showstack J, et al: Reorganizing an academic medical service: Impact on cost, quality, patient satisfaction, and education. JAMA 1998; 279:1560-1565 (Pubitemid 28233012)
87. Moran JL, Bristow P, Soloman PJ, et al: Mortality and length-ofstay outcomes, 1993-2003 in the binational Australian and New Zealand intensive care adult patient database. Crit Care Med 2008; 36:46-61
88. Sivak ED, Perez-Trepichio A: Quality assessment in the medical intensive care unit. Continued evolution of a data model. Qual Assur Util Rev 1992; 7:42-49
89. Angus DC, Linde-Zwirble WT, Sirio CA, et al: The effect of managed care on ICU length of stay: Implications for medicare. JAMA 1996; 276:1075-1082 (Pubitemid 26332815)
90. Carson SS, Bach PB, Brzozowski L, et al: Outcomes after long-term acute care. An analysis of 133 mechanically ventilated patients. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 1999; 159(5, Part 1):1568-1573 (Pubitemid 29227871)