Pigs in the City: Reflective Deliberations on the Boundary Concept of Agroparks in The Netherlands

Journal of Environmental Policy and Planning

Volumn 20, Issue 6, 2018, Pages 675-692

  Metze, T A P ^a   Van Zuydam, S ^a  

^a TILBURG UNIVERSITY   (Netherlands)

Author keywords

boundary concept; Reflective deliberation; reflexive governance; sustainable agriculture

Indexed keywords

EID: 84883446281     PISSN: 1523908X     EISSN: 15227200     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1080/1523908X.2013.819780     Document Type: Article

References (70)

1. AgriHolland Nieuws (2000) Brinkhorst wil proef met agroproductiepark, October 4. Available at http://www.agriholland.nl/nieuws/2000/40/22688.html (accessed 10 January 2012)
2. Alterra (2011) Metropolitan food clusters and sustainable development: The seven main components of an Agropark. Available at: http://www.alterra.wur.nl/NL/onderzoek/Dossiers/Metropolitan+Food+Clusters+en+Agroparks/Metropolitan+Food+Clusters+and+Sustainable+development/ (accessed 10 January 2012)
3. van Asselt M. B. A., van't Klooster S. A., van Notten P. W. F., Verkennen in onzekerheid Beleid en Maatschappij—Themanummer Toekomstscenario's en beleid 2003 30 4 230 241
4. Beck U., Giddens T., Lash S., Reflexive Modernisation Polity Press Cambridge 1994
5. Beck U., Bonss W., Lau C., The theory of reflexive modernization problematic, hypotheses and research programme Theory, Culture & Society 2003 20 2 1 33doi:10.1177/0263276403020002001
6. Brandwein P., Studying the careers of knowledge claims: Applying science studies to legal studies Interpretation and Method: Empirical Research Methods and the Interpretive Turn Yanow D., Schwartz-Shea P., Turn M.E. Sharpe, Inc New York 2006 228 243
7. Bröer C., Beleid Vormt Overlast Askant Amsterdam 2006
8. Dewey J., Experience and Education MacMillan New York 1933
9. Dewulf A., Craps M., Bouwen R., Taillieu T., Pahl-Wostl C., Integrated management of natural resources: Dealing with ambiguous issues, multiple actors and diverging frames Water Science & Technology 2005 52 6 115 124
10. Dryzek J. S., Deliberative Democracy and Beyond: Liberals, Critics, Contestations Oxford University Press Oxford 2000
11. Goffman E., Frame Analysis: An Essay on the Organization of Experience Harper and Row New York 1974
12. Goodin R. E., Reflective Democracy Oxford University Press Oxford 2003
13. Goodin R. E., Niemeyer S. J., When does deliberation begin? Internal reflection versus public discussion in deliberative democracy Political Studies 2003 51 4 627 649doi:10.1111/j.0032-3217.2003.00450.x
14. Grin J., Reflexive modernization as a governance issue—or: Designing and shaping re-structuration Reflexive Governance for Sustainable Development Voß J. P., Bauknecht D., Kemp R., EdwardElgar Cheltenham 2006 54 81
15. Grin J., van Staveren A., Werken aan systeeminnovaties: Lessen uit de praktijk Van Gorcum AssenThe Netherlands 2007
16. Grin J., Felix F., Bos B., Spoelstra S., Practices for reflexive design: Lessons from a Dutch programme on sustainable agriculture International Journal Foresight and Innovation Policy 2004 1 1/2 126 149doi:10.1504/IJFIP.2004.004618
17. Gutmann A., Thompson D., Democracy & Disagreement Harvard University Press Cambridge 1996
18. Hajer M., Versteeg W., A decade of discourse analysis of environmental politics: Achievements, challenges, perspectives Journal of Environmental Policy & Planning 2005 7 3 175 184doi:10.1080/15239080500339646
19. Hendriks C. M., When the forum meets interest politics: Strategic uses of public deliberation Politics & Society 2006 34 4 571 602doi:10.1177/0032329206293641
20. Hendriks C. M., Grin J., Contextualising reflexive governance: The politics of Dutch transitions to sustainability Journal of Environmental Policy & Planning 2007 9 3–4 333 350doi:10.1080/15239080701622790
21. Hinssen J., Smulders H., Van dingen beter doen naar betere dingen doen: Vergelijkende analyse Agroparken in Nederland Telos—TSC—TransForum en Erac TilburgThe Netherlands 2011
22. Hoes A.-C., Regeer B., Zweekhorst M., Innovation projects and visions on the future: Ambition and commitment in the Agropark case Journal of Chain and Network Science 2012a 12 2 111 124doi:10.3920/JCNS2012.x007
23. Hoes A. C., Beekman V., Regeer B. J., Bunders J. F. G., Unravelling the dynamics of adopting novel technologies: An account of how the closed greenhouse opened-up International Journal of Foresight and Innovation Policy 2012b 8 1 37 59 http://dx.doi.org/10.1504/IJFIP.2012.044286
24. Verguld en verguisd: Agroparken in de mediaInnovation Network Green Space and Agrocluster (2004) Report No. 04.2.075, Den Haag, The Netherlands: Innovation Network
25. Agroparken: Het concept, de ontvangst, de praktijkInnovation Network Green Space and Agrocluster (2005) Report No. 05.2.095, Utrecht: Innovation Network
26. In't Veld R. J., Eerherstel voor Cassandra Lemma Utrecht 2001
27. Lasswell H. D., The policy orientation The Policy Sciences: Recent Developments in Scope and Method Lerner L. D., Lasswell H. D., Stanford University Press Standford 1951 3 15
28. Loorbach D., Rotmans J., Managing transitions for sustainable development Understanding Industrial Transformation: Views from Different Disciplines Olshoorn X., Wieczorek A. J., Springer Dordrecht 2006 187 206
29. Lynch M., Against reflexivity as an academic virtue and source of privileged knowledge Theory, Culture & Society 2000 17 3 26 54doi:10.1177/02632760022051202
30. Manin B., On legitimacy and political deliberation Political Theory 1987 15 3 338 368
31. Meadowcroft J., Who is in charge here? Governance for sustainable development in a complex world Journal of Environmental Policy & Planning 2007 9 3–4 299 314doi:10.1080/15239080701631544
32. Metze T., Innovation Ltd.: Boundary Work in Experiments with Deliberative Governance in Land Use and Planning Eburon Delft 2010
33. Rein M., From Policy to Practice M.E. Scharpe New York 1983
34. Rein M., Schön D., Reframing policy discourse The Argumentative Turn in Policy Analysis Fischer F., Forester J., Duke University Press DurhamNC 1993 145 166
35. Schön D., Rein M., Frame Reflection: Toward the Resolution of Intractable Policy Controversies Basic Books New York 1994
36. Smeets P., Expedition Agroparks: Research by Design into Sustainable Development and Agriculture in Network Society Wageningen Academic Publishers Wageningen 2011
37. Star S. L., Griesemer J. R., Institutional ecology, translations and boundary objects: Amateurs and professionals in Berkeley's museum of vertebrate zoology Social Studies of Science 1989 19 3 387 420doi:10.1177/030631289019003001
38. United Nations World Urbanization Prospects: The 2007 Revision Population Database United Nations New York 2007
39. Voß J. P., Bauknecht D., Kemp R., Reflexive Governance for Sustainable Development Edgar Elgar Publishing Limited Cheltenham 2006
40. Wagenaar H., Meaning in Action: Interpretation and Dialogue in Policy Analysis M.E. Sharpe New York 2012
41. WUR & Buck Consultants and Rijnconsult (2003) Eindverslag KLICT: A1 Eiwitcorridor (Commissioned by Oost NV) (Deventer, Dutch: WUR & Buck Consultants and Rijnconsult)
42. Yanow, D. (2000) Conducting Interpretive Policy Analysis (Qualitative research methods series 47) (Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications)
43. References to Interviews and Transcripts
44. Interview de Wilt, J. (2004) Interview Jan de Wilt, Innovatienetwerk. Interviewed by T. Metze, 30-11-2004 (Utrecht)
45. Interview-Smeets, P. (2005) Interview Peter Smeets, Researcher/Advisor. Interviewed by T. Metze (Zoetermeer)
46. Transcript SWPA1 (2004) Transcript Scenario Workshop Scenario Expansion (Zwolle)
47. Transcript SWPA2 (2004) Transcript Scenario Workshop the Financial How (Zwolle)
48. Transcript SWPL1 (2004) Transcript Scenario Workshop Plenary Introduction 1a and 1b (Zwolle)
49. Transcript SWPL3 (2004) Transcript Scenario Workshop Plenary Start in the Afternoon (Zwolle)
50. Transcript SWPL4 (2004) Transcript Scenario Workshop Plenary Closing, Afternoon (Zwolle)
51. References to Newspapers
52. NRC (2007) Industrieel boeren: Wageningse onderzoeker Peter Smeets bepleit agropark in de stad, February 3
53. NRC (2008) Superboerderijen passen goed op industrieterrein: megastallen, extreme grootschalige veehouderij is omstreden, maar bidet dier, milieu en landschap voordelen, September 30
54. NRC (2009) Dieren willen best op de tweede verdieping liggen, July 30
55. NRC (2010) Noord-Brabant bezint zich op megastallen: Q-koorts aanleiding voor debat Provinciale Staten over gezondheidsrisico’s van grootschalige veeteelt, March 18
56. NRC (2011) Brieven: megastal is veel meer dan een inpassingsconflict’, September 26
57. Telegraaf (2007) Geen rem op varkensflats: Kabinet gaat boeren geen regels opleggen, December 20
58. Telegraaf (2011) Beslissing megastal bij lagere overheid, November 24
59. Trouw (2008a) Megastal geen probleem voor Tweede Kamer, February 29.
60. Trouw (2008b) Discussie over megastal hoort in Den Haag: Groningen beperkt intensieve veehouderij in tegenstelling tot andere provincies, August 19.
61. Trouw (2008c) Steriele lapjes vlees, October 4.
62. Trouw (2008d) Gezondheid vergeten in discussie megastal, December 23.
63. Trouw (2009) Ook wetenschap laat bewuste boer vallen, June 19
64. Trouw (2011) PvdA wil eind maken aan intensieve veehouderij, December 5
65. Volkskrant (2008a) Megastal vandaag in Staten Overijssel, May 7.
66. Volkskrant (2008b) Het varken betaalt een hoge prijs: Proef, June 28.
67. Volkskrant (2009) GGD: megastal is geen gevaar voor gezondheid bewoners, October 2
68. Volkskrant (2010) Megastallen horen bij bedrijven, March 17
69. Volkskrant (2011a) Als deze stal niet mag, dan houdt het op, April 19.
70. Volkskrant (2011b) Archetype: dwarsverbanden tussen kunst en actualiteit, April 22.