The impossibility of separating age, period and cohort effects

Social Science and Medicine

Volumn 93, Issue , 2013, Pages 163-165

  Bell, Andrew ^a   Jones, Kelvyn ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF BRISTOL   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

Age period cohort models; Collinearity; Model identification

Indexed keywords

AGE; AGE PERIOD AND COHORT EFFECT; EPIDEMIOLOGICAL DATA; HUMAN; NOTE; PROBABILITY; PROBLEM IDENTIFICATION; REGRESSION ANALYSIS; RISK ASSESSMENT; RISK FACTOR; SOCIAL ATTITUDE; STATISTICAL MODEL; SUICIDE;

AGE-PERIOD-COHORT MODELS; COLLINEARITY; MODEL IDENTIFICATION;

EMPLOYMENT; FEMALE; HUMANS; MALE; SUICIDE;

EID: 84881027772     PISSN: 02779536     EISSN: 18735347     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.socscimed.2013.04.029     Document Type: Note

References (16)

1. Bell A., Jones K. Another 'futile quest'? A simulation study of Yang andLand's Hierarchical Age-Period-Cohort model 2013, Working paper. Availableat:, Accessed 19.04.13, submitted for publication. http://www.mendeley.com/download/public/19138881/5392730501/d2fb15102177bd6fd8a32cab9e4193776576e41c/dl.pdf.
2. Bell A., Jones K. Current practice in the modelling of Age, Period and Cohort effects with panel data: A commentary on Tawfik etal (2012), Clarke etal (2009), and McCulloch (2012) 2013, Working paper. Available at:, Accessed 19.04.13, submitted for publication. http://www.mendeley.com/download/public/19138881/5392730511/2f76331fbd618b02e52ff33515ff809b01fdab7c/dl.pdf.
3. Glenn N.D. Cohort analysts futile quest - statistical attempts to separate age, period and cohort effects. American Sociological Review 1976, 41:900-904.
4. Glenn N.D. Cohort analysis 2005, Sage, London.
5. Goldstein H. Age, period and cohort effects - a confounded confusion. Journal of Applied Statistics 1979, 6:19-24.
6. Luo L., Hodges J. The cross-classified age-period-cohort model as a constrained estimator 2013, Working paper. Available at:, Accessed 16.04.13, submitted for publication. http://paa2013.princeton.edu/papers/132093.
7. McCulloch A. Cohort variation in the membership of voluntary organisations in Great Britain, 1991-2007 2012, Working paper. Available at:, Accessed 03.09.12. http://www.significancemagazine.org/SpringboardWebApp/userfiles/sig/file/Paper.pdf.
8. Mason K.O., Mason W.M., Winsborough H.H., Poole K. Some methodological issues in cohort analysis of archival data. American Sociological Review 1973, 38:242-258.
9. Osmond C., Gardner M.J. Age, period, and cohort models - non-overlapping cohorts don't resolve the identification problem. American Journal of Epidemiology 1989, 129:31-35.
10. Page A., Milner A., Morrell S., Taylor R. The role of under-employment and unemployment in recent birth cohort effects in Australian suicide. Social Science & Medicine 2013, (in this issue).
11. Robertson C., Boyle P. Age, period and cohort models - the use of individual records. Statistics in Medicine 1986, 5:527-538.
12. Ryder N.B. The cohort as a concept in the study of social-change. American Sociological Review 1965, 30:843-861.
13. Suzuki E. Time changes, so do people. Social Science & Medicine 2012, 75:452-456.
14. Tu Y.K., Smith G.D., Gilthorpe M.S. Anew approach to age-period-cohort analysis using partial least squares regression: the trend in blood pressure in the Glasgow Alumni cohort. Plos One 2011, 6.
15. Yang Y., Land K.C. Amixed models approach to the age-period-cohort analysis of repeated cross-section surveys, with an application to data on trends in verbal test scores. Sociological Methodology 2006, 36:75-97.
16. Yang Y., Schulhofer-Wohl S., Fu W.J.J., Land K.C. The intrinsic estimator for age-period-cohort analysis: what it is and how to use it. American Journal of Sociology 2008, 113:1697-1736.