Surgical treatment of recurrent stress urinary incontinence in women: A systematic review and meta-analysis of randomised controlled trials

European Urology

Volumn 64, Issue 2, 2013, Pages 323-336

  Agur, Wael ^a   Riad, Mohamed ^a   Secco, Silvia ^b   Litman, Heather ^c   Madhuvrata, Priya ^d   Novara, Giacomo ^b   Abdel Fattah, Mohamed ^e  

^a NHS AYRSHIRE AND ARRAN   (United Kingdom)

^b UNIVERSITY OF PADOVA   (Italy)

^c NEW ENGLAND RESEARCH INSTITUTES   (United States)

^d SHEFFIELD TEACHING HOSPITALS NHS FOUNDATION TRUST   (United Kingdom)

^e UNIVERSITY OF ABERDEEN   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

Colposuspension; Complications; Recurrent urinary incontinence; Suburethral slings; Tension free vaginal tape; Transobturator tape; Urodynamic stress incontinence

Indexed keywords

ARTICLE; COLPOSUSPENSION; FOLLOW UP; HEALTH ECONOMICS; HUMAN; META ANALYSIS; PEER REVIEW; POSTOPERATIVE COMPLICATION; PRIORITY JOURNAL; RANDOMIZED CONTROLLED TRIAL (TOPIC); RECURRENT STRESS URINARY INCONTINENCE; RETROPUBIC TENSION FREE VAGINAL TAPE; STRESS INCONTINENCE; SYSTEMATIC REVIEW; TENSION FREE VAGINAL TAPE; TRANSOBTURATOR TENSION FREE VAGINAL TAPE;

COLPOSUSPENSION; COMPLICATIONS; RECURRENT URINARY INCONTINENCE; SUBURETHRAL SLINGS; TENSION-FREE VAGINAL TAPE; TRANSOBTURATOR TAPE; URODYNAMIC STRESS INCONTINENCE;

CHI-SQUARE DISTRIBUTION; FEMALE; HUMANS; ODDS RATIO; RANDOMIZED CONTROLLED TRIALS AS TOPIC; RECOVERY OF FUNCTION; RECURRENCE; RISK FACTORS; SUBURETHRAL SLINGS; TREATMENT OUTCOME; URINARY INCONTINENCE, STRESS; URODYNAMICS; UROLOGIC SURGICAL PROCEDURES;

EID: 84879994922     PISSN: 03022838     EISSN: 18737560     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.eururo.2013.04.034     Document Type: Article

References (68)

1. M. Abdel-Fattah, A. Familusi, S. Fielding, J. Ford, and S. Bhattacharya Primary and repeat surgical treatment for female pelvic organ prolapse and incontinence in parous women in the UK: a register linkage study BMJ Open 1 2011 e000206
2. Fialkow M, Symons RG, Flum D. Reoperation for urinary incontinence. Am J Obstet Gynecol 2008;199:546:e1-8.
3. M.A. Denman, W.T. Gregory, and S.H. Boyles Reoperation 10 years after surgically managed pelvic organ prolapse and urinary incontinence Am J Obstet Gynecol 198 2008 555:e1-5
4. Guidelines for the evaluation and treatment of recurrent urinary incontinence following pelvic floor surgery. Society of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists of Canada (SOGC) Web site. www.sogc.org/guidelines/documents/ gui248CPG1009E-000.pdf.
5. Riad M, Familusi A, El Sayed M, Abdel-Fattah M. Current practice in the UK for the assessment and management of recurrent stress urinary incontinence in women. Int Urogynecol J 2011;22(Suppl 1):S1-195.
6. A. Pradhan, P. Jain, and P.M. Latthe Effectiveness of midurethral slings in recurrent stress urinary incontinence: a systematic review and meta-analysis Int Urogynecol J 23 2012 831 841
7. D. Moher, A. Liberati, J. Tetzlaff, D.G. Altman PRISMA Group Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: the PRISMA statement Ann Intern Med 151 2009 264 269
8. W.R. Shadish, and C.K. Haddock Combining estimates of effect size H. Cooper, L.V. Hedges, The handbook of research synthesis 1994 Russell Sage Foundation New York, NY
9. H. Enzelsberger, H. Helmer, and C. Schatten Comparison of Burch and Lyodura sling procedures for repair of unsuccessful incontinence surgery Obstet Gynecol 88 1996 251 256
10. R. Aniuliene Tension-free vaginal tape versus tension-free vaginal tape obturator (inside-outside) in the surgical treatment of female stress urinary incontinence Medicina (Kaunas) 45 2009 639 643
11. C. Barry, Y.N. Lim, and R. Muller A multi-centre, randomised clinical control trial comparing the retropubic (RP) approach versus the transobturator approach (TO) for tension-free, suburethral sling treatment of urodynamic stress incontinence: the TORP study Int Urogynecol J Pelvic Floor Dysfunct 19 2008 171 178
12. M. Porena, E. Costantini, and B. Frea Tension-free vaginal tape versus transobturator tape as surgery for stress urinary incontinence: results of a multicentre randomised trial Eur Urol 52 2007 1481 1490
13. A.S. El-Hefnawy, B.S. Wadie, M. El Mekresh, A. Nabeeh, and M.A. Bazeed TOT for treatment of stress urinary incontinence: how should we assess its equivalence with TVT? Int Urogynecol J 21 2010 947 953
14. H.E. Richter, M.E. Albo, and H.M. Zyczynski Urinary Incontinence Treatment Network. Retropubic versus transobturator midurethral slings for stress incontinence N Engl J Med 362 2010 2066 2076
15. F. Sharifiaghdas, and N. Mortazavi Tension-free vaginal tape and autologous rectus fascia pubovaginal sling for the treatment of urinary stress incontinence: a medium-term follow-up Med Princ Pract 17 2008 209 214
16. B.S. Wadie, A. Edwan, and A.M. Nabeeh Autologous fascial sling vs polypropylene tape at short-term followup: a prospective randomized study J Urol 174 2005 990 993
17. C. Maher, A. Qatawneh, K. Baessler, M. Cropper, and P. Schluter Laparoscopic colposuspension or tension-free vaginal tape for recurrent stress urinary incontinence and or ISD: a randomised control trial [abstract 25] Neurourol Urodynam 23 2004 433 434
18. M.E. Albo, H.E. Richter, and L. Brubaker Urinary Incontinence Treatment Network. Burch colposuspension versus fascial sling to reduce urinary stress incontinence N Engl J Med 356 2007 2143 2155
19. M. Abdel-Fattah, I. Ramsay, and S. Pringle Randomised prospective single-blinded study comparing 'inside-out' versus 'outside-in' transobturator tapes in the management of urodynamic stress incontinence: 1-year outcomes from the E-TOT study BJOG 117 2010 870 878
20. G. Novara, and W. Artibani Multi operated recurrent incontinence/ prolapse. In Continence: current concepts and treatment strategies 2009 Springer London, UK
21. R. Thakar, S. Stanton, and L. Prodigalidad Secondary colposuspension: results of a prospective study from a tertiary referral centre BJOG 109 2002 1115 1120
22. S.E. Litwiller, R.E. Nelson, and P.D. Fone Vaginal wall sling: long-term outcome analysis of factors contributing to patient satisfaction and surgical success J Urol 157 1997 1279 1282
23. M. Rezapour, and U. Ulmsten Tension-free vaginal tape (TVT) in women with recurrent stress urinary incontinence - a long-term follow up Int Urogynecol J Suppl 2 2001 S9 S11
24. N. Kuuva, and C.G. Nilsson Tension-free vaginal tape procedure: an effective minimally invasive operation for the treatment of recurrent stress urinary incontinence? Gynecol Obstet Invest 56 2003 93 98
25. P. Costa, G. Poinas, and K. Ben Naoum Long-term results of artificial urinary sphincter for women with type III stress urinary incontinence Eur Urol 63 2013 753 758
26. S.R. Aboseif, P. Sassani, and E.I. Franke Treatment of moderate to severe female stress urinary incontinence with the adjustable continence therapy (ACT) device after failed surgical repair World J Urol 29 2011 249 253
27. B. Vayleux, F. Luyckx, and S. Thélu Adjustable Continence Therapy in women, middle-term follow-up and a new technique for balloon positioning [in French] Prog Urol 20 2010 520 526
28. E. Kocjancic, S. Crivellaro, S. Ranzoni, D. Bonvini, B. Grosseti, and B. Frea Adjustable continence therapy for severe intrinsic sphincter deficiency and recurrent female stress urinary incontinence: long-term experience J Urol 184 2010 1017 1021
29. G. Novara, V. Ficarra, and R. Boscolo-Berto Tension-free midurethral slings in the treatment of female stress urinary incontinence: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials of effectiveness Eur Urol 52 2007 663 679
30. G. Novara, A. Galfano, and R. Boscolo-Berto Complication rates of tension-free midurethral slings in the treatment of female stress urinary incontinence: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials comparing tension-free midurethral tapes to other surgical procedures and different devices Eur Urol 53 2008 288 309
31. G. Novara, W. Artibani, and M.D. Barber Updated systematic review and meta-analysis of the comparative data on colposuspensions, pubovaginal slings, and midurethral tapes in the surgical treatment of female stress urinary incontinence Eur Urol 58 2010 218 238
32. P.M. Latthe, P. Singh, R. Foon, and P. Toozs-Hobson Two routes of transobturator tape procedures in stress urinary incontinence: a meta-analysis with direct and indirect comparison of randomized trials BJU Int 106 2010 68 76
33. M. Abdel-Fattah, J.A. Ford, and C.P. Lim Single-incision mini-slings versus standard midurethral slings in surgical management of female stress urinary incontinence: a meta-analysis of effectiveness and complications Eur Urol 60 2011 468 480
34. A.R.B. Smith, R. Dmochowski, and P. Hilton Surgery for urinary incontinence P. Abrams, L. Cardozo, S. Khoury, A. Wein, Incontinence 2009 Health Publication Plymouth, UK
35. L. Schierlitz, P.L. Dwyer, and A. Rosamilia Effectiveness of tension-free vaginal tape compared with transobturator tape in women with stress urinary incontinence and intrinsic sphincter deficiency: a randomized controlled trial Obstet Gynecol 112 2008 1253 1261
36. K.S. Lee, D.H. Han, and Y.S. Choi A prospective trial comparing tension-free vaginal tape and transobturator vaginal tape inside-out for the surgical treatment of female stress urinary incontinence: 1-year followup J Urol 177 2007 214 218
37. E. David-Montefiore, J.L. Frobert, and M. Grisard-Anaf Peri-operative complications and pain after the suburethral sling procedure for urinary stress incontinence: a French prospective randomised multicentre study comparing the retropubic and transobturator routes Eur Urol 49 2006 133 138
38. M.D. Barber, S. Kleeman, and M.M. Karram Transobturator tape compared with tension-free vaginal tape for the treatment of stress urinary incontinence: a randomized controlled trial Obstet Gynecol 111 2008 611 621
39. F. Wang, Y. Song, and H. Huang Prospective randomized trial of TVT and TOT as primary treatment for female stress urinary incontinence with or without pelvic organ prolapse in Southeast China Arch Gynecol Obstet 281 2010 279 286
40. W. Wang, L. Zhu, and J. Lang Transobturator tape procedure versus tension-free vaginal tape for treatment of stress urinary incontinence Int J Gynaecol Obstet 104 2009 113 116
41. deTayrac R, Deffieux X, Droupy S, Chauveaud-Lambling A, Calvanèse-Benamour L, Fernandez H. A prospective randomized trial comparing tension-free vaginal tape and transobturator suburethral tape for surgical treatment of stress urinary incontinence. Am J Obstet Gynecol 2004;190:602-8. Retraction in Am J Obstet Gynecol 2005;192:339.
42. Y.N. Lim, R. Muller, A. Corstiaans, H.P. Dietz, C. Barry, and A. Rane Suburethral slingplasty evaluation study in North Queensland, Australia: the SUSPEND trial Aust N Z J Obstet Gynaecol 45 2005 52 59
43. M. Abdel-Fattah Pelvicol pubovaginal sling versus tension-free vaginal tape for treatment of urodynamic stress incontinence: a prospective randomized three year follow-up study Eur Urol 46 2004 629 635
44. M. Tcherniakovsky, C.E. Fernandes, C.A. Bezerra, C.A. Del Roy, and E.R. Wroclawski Comparative results of two techniques to treat stress urinary incontinence: synthetic transobturator and aponeurotic slings Int Urogynecol J 20 2009 961 966
45. P.K. Sand, H. Winkler, D.W. Blackhurst, and P.J. Culligan A prospective randomized study comparing modified Burch retropubic urethropexy and suburethral sling for treatment of genuine stress incontinence with low-pressure urethra Am J Obstet Gynecol 182 2000 30 34
46. P. Drahorádová, J. Masata, A. Martan, and K. Svabík Comparative development of quality of life between TVT and Burch colposuspension Ceska Gynekol 69 2004 506 510
47. K.-S. Lee, M. Choo, and Y. Lee Prospective comparison of the 'inside-out' and 'outside-in' transobturator-tape procedures for the treatment of female stress urinary incontinence Int Urogynecol J 19 2008 577 582
48. Y. Ustun, Y. Engin-Ustun, M. Gungor, and S. Tezcan Tension-free vaginal tape compared with laparoscopic Burch urethropexy J Am Assoc Gynecol Laparosc 10 2003 386 389
49. L. Zhu, J. Lang, N. Hai, and F. Wong Comparing vaginal tape and transobturator tape for the treatment of mild and moderate stress incontinence Int J Gynecol Obstet 99 2007 14 17
50. C.M. Juang, K.J. Yu, and P. Chou Efficacy analysis of trans-obturator tension-free vaginal tape (TVT-O) plus modified Ingelman-Sundberg procedure versus TVT-O alone in the treatment of mixed urinary incontinence: a randomized study Eur Urol 51 2007 1671 1679
51. H.E. Lord, J.D. Taylor, and J.C. Finn A randomized controlled equivalence trial of short-term complications and efficacy of tension-free vaginal tape and suprapubic urethral support sling for treating stress incontinence BJU Int 98 2006 367 376
52. K.A. German, H. Kynaston, S. Weight, and T.P. Stephenson A prospective randomized trial comparing a modified needle suspension procedure with the vagina/obturator shelf procedure for genuine stress incontinence Br J Urol 74 1994 188 190
53. J. de Leval, A. Thomas, and D. Waltregny The original versus a modified inside-out transobturator procedure: 1-year results of a prospective randomized trial Int Urogynecol J 22 2011 145 156
54. T. Rechberger, K. Rzezniczuk, and P. Skorupski A randomized comparison between monofilament and multifilament tapes for stress incontinence surgery Int Urogynecol J 14 2003 432 436
55. K. Guerrero, A. Watkins, and S. Emery A randomised controlled trial comparing two autologous fascial sling techniques for the treatment of stress urinary incontinence in women: short, medium and long-term follow-up Int Urogynecol J Pelvic Floor Dysfunct 18 2007 1263 1270
56. H.J. Cholhan, and P.M. Lotze Voiding function after a modified no-tension pubovaginal sling Int Urogynecol J 15 2004 249 256
57. G. Barbalias, E. Liatsikos, and D. Barbalias Use of slings made of indigenous and allogenic material (Goretex) in type III urinary incontinence and comparison between them Eur Urol 31 1997 394 400
58. H. Fatthy, M. El Hao, I. Samaha, and K. Abdallah Modified Burch colposuspension: laparoscopy versus laparotomy J Am Assoc Gynecol Laparosc 8 2001 99 106
59. L. Djehdian, M. Araujo, and C. Takano Randomised trial of Ophira mini-sling system and Unitape for the treatment of stress incontinence in women. First experiences after a follow-up of 6 months [abstract] Int Urogynecol J 21 Suppl 1 2010 1 428
60. C.F. Maher, B.A. O'Reilly, P.L. Dwyer, M.P. Carey, A. Cornish, and P. Schluter Pubovaginal sling versus transurethral Macroplastique for stress urinary incontinence and intrinsic sphincter deficiency: a prospective randomised controlled trial BJOG 112 2005 797 801
61. G. Ghoniem, J. Corcos, C. Comiter, P. Bernhard, O.L. Westney, and S. Herschorn Cross-linked polydimethylsiloxane injection for female stress urinary incontinence: results of a multicenter, randomized, controlled, single-blind study J Urol 181 2009 204 210
62. R. Dmochowski, S. Herschorn, and J. Corcos Multicenter randomized controlled study to evaluate Uryx urethral bulking agent in treating female stress urinary incontinence J Urol 167 2002 LB-10(A)
63. F. Bano, J.W. Barrington, and R. Dyer Comparison between porcine dermal implant (Permacol) and silicone injection (Macroplastique) for urodynamic stress incontinence Int Urogynecol J 6 2005 147 150 discussion 150
64. J.A. Schulz, C.W. Nager, S.L. Stanton, and K. Baessler Bulking agents for stress urinary incontinence: short-term results and complications in a randomized comparison of periurethral and transurethral injections Int Urogynecol J 15 2004 261 265
65. R. Mayer, R. Dmochowski, and R. Appell Multicenter prospective randomized 52-week trial of calcium hydroxylapatite versus bovine dermal collagen for treatment of stress urinary incontinence Urology 69 2007 876 880
66. P.E. Lee, R.C. Kung, and H.P. Drutz Periurethral autologous fat injection as treatment for female stress urinary incontinence: a randomized double-blind controlled trial J Urol 165 2001 153 158
67. R.C. Andersen Long-term follow-up comparison of Durasphere and Contigen in the treatment of stress urinary incontinence J Lower Genital Tract Dis 6 2002 239 243
68. S. Andonian, B. St-Denis, M. Lemieux, and J. Corcos Prospective clinical trial comparing Obtape and DUPS to TVT: one-year safety and efficacy results Eur Urol 52 2007 245 252