Osteoblast and bone tissue response to surface modified zirconia and titanium implant materials

Dental Materials

Volumn 29, Issue 7, 2013, Pages 763-776

  Kohal, Ralf J ^a   Bächle, Maria ^a   Att, Wael ^a   Chaar, Saad ^a   Altmann, Brigitte ^a   Renz, Alexander ^b   Butz, Frank ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF FREIBURG   (Germany)

^b FRAUNHOFER INSTITUTE FOR MECHANICS OF MATERIALS IWM   (Germany)

Author keywords

Cell culture study; Dental implants; Histomorphometry; Push in test; Rats; Surface topography; Zirconia

Indexed keywords

BIOMECHANICAL TESTING; BIOMECHANICAL TESTS; CELL-CULTURE STUDY; EXTRACELLULAR MATRICES; HISTOLOGIC ANALYSIS; HISTOMORPHOMETRY; PUSH-IN TESTS; VARIOUS SUBSTRATES;

BIOMECHANICS; BONE; CELL PROLIFERATION; DENTAL PROSTHESES; GENE EXPRESSION; OSTEOBLASTS; RATS; SCANNING ELECTRON MICROSCOPY; SURFACE TOPOGRAPHY; SURFACES; TISSUE; TITANIUM;

ZIRCONIA;

TITANIUM; TRANSCRIPTION FACTOR RUNX3; YTTRIA STABILIZED TETRAGONAL ZIRCONIA; YTTRIUM; ZIRCONIUM;

ANALYSIS OF VARIANCE; ANIMAL; ARTICLE; BONE; BONE REGENERATION; CELL CULTURE; CELL PROLIFERATION; COMPARATIVE STUDY; CONFOCAL MICROSCOPY; DRUG EFFECT; FEMUR; GENE EXPRESSION REGULATION; GENETICS; HUMAN; IMPLANT; MALE; MATERIALS TESTING; NONPARAMETRIC TEST; OSTEOBLAST; RAT; REVERSE TRANSCRIPTION POLYMERASE CHAIN REACTION; SPRAGUE DAWLEY RAT; SURFACE PROPERTY; TOOTH IMPLANT; TRANSCRIPTION INITIATION;

ANALYSIS OF VARIANCE; ANIMALS; BONE AND BONES; CELL PROLIFERATION; CELLS, CULTURED; CORE BINDING FACTOR ALPHA 3 SUBUNIT; DENTAL IMPLANTS; FEMUR; GENE EXPRESSION REGULATION; HUMANS; IMPLANTS, EXPERIMENTAL; MALE; MATERIALS TESTING; MICROSCOPY, CONFOCAL; OSSEOINTEGRATION; OSTEOBLASTS; RATS; RATS, SPRAGUE-DAWLEY; REVERSE TRANSCRIPTASE POLYMERASE CHAIN REACTION; STATISTICS, NONPARAMETRIC; SURFACE PROPERTIES; TITANIUM; TRANSCRIPTIONAL ACTIVATION; YTTRIUM; ZIRCONIUM;

EID: 84878887790     PISSN: 01095641     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.dental.2013.04.003     Document Type: Article

References (76)

1. I. Denry, and J.R. Kelly State of the art of zirconia for dental applications Dental Materials 24 2008 299 307
2. S. Holst, M.B. Blatz, E. Hegenbarth, M. Wichmann, and S. Eitner Prosthodontic considerations for predictable single-implant esthetics in the anterior maxilla Journal of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery 63 2005 89 96
3. L. Levin, S. Pathael, E. Dolev, and D. Schwartz-Arad Aesthetic versus surgical success of single dental implants: 1- to 9-year follow-up Practical Procedures and Aesthetic Dentistry 17 2005 533 538
4. I. Sailer, A. Philipp, A. Zembic, B.E. Pjetursson, C.H. Hämmerle, and M. Zwahlen A systematic review of the performance of ceramic and metal implant abutments supporting fixed implant reconstructions Clinical Oral Implants Research 20 Suppl 4 2009 4 31
5. D. Weingart, S. Steinemann, W. Schilli, J.R. Strub, U. Hellerich, and J. Assenmacher Titanium deposition in regional lymph nodes after insertion of titanium screw implants in maxillofacial region International Journal of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery 23 1994 450 452
6. P.D. Bianco, P. Ducheyne, and J.M. Cuckler Local accumulation of titanium released from a titanium implant in the absence of wear Journal of Biomedical Materials Research 31 1996 227 234
7. H. Egusa, N. Ko, T. Shimazu, and H. Yatani Suspected association of an allergic reaction with titanium dental implants: a clinical report Journal of Prosthetic Dentistry 100 2008 344 347
8. A. Sicilia, S. Cuesta, G. Coma, I. Arregui, C. Guisasola, and E. Ruiz Titanium allergy in dental implant patients: a clinical study on 1500 consecutive patients Clinical Oral Implants Research 19 2008 823 835
9. R. Adell, U. Lekholm, B. Rockler, and P.I. Brånemark A 15-year study of osseointegrated implants in the treatment of the edentulous jaw International Journal of Oral Surgery 10 1981 387 416
10. R. Adell, B. Eriksson, U. Lekholm, P.I. Brånemark, and T. Jemt Long-term follow-up study of osseointegrated implants in the treatment of totally edentulous jaws International Journal of Oral and Maxillofacial Implants 5 1990 347 359
11. D. van Steenberghe A retrospective multicenter evaluation of the survival rate of osseointegrated fixtures supporting fixed partial prostheses in the treatment of partial edentulism Journal of Prosthetic Dentistry 61 1989 217 223
12. T. Jemt Modified single and short-span restorations supported by osseointegrated fixtures in the partially edentulous jaw Journal of Prosthetic Dentistry 55 1986 243 247
13. M. Esposito, L. Murray-Curtis, M.G. Grusovin, P. Coulthard, and H.V. Worthington Interventions for replacing missing teeth: different types of dental implants Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews 2007 CD003815
14. J. Chevalier What future for zirconia as a biomaterial? Biomaterials 27 2006 535 543
15. M. Andreiotelli, H.J. Wenz, and R.J. Kohal Are ceramic implants a viable alternative to titanium implants? A systematic literature review Clinical Oral Implants Research 20 Suppl. 4 2009 32 47
16. M. Andreiotelli, and R.J. Kohal Fracture strength of zirconia implants after artificial aging Clinical Implant Dentistry and Related Research 11 2009 158 166
17. R.J. Kohal, G. Klaus, and J.R. Strub Zirconia-implant-supported all-ceramic crowns withstand long-term load: a pilot investigation Clinical Oral Implants Research 17 2006 565 571
18. N.R. Silva, P.G. Coelho, C.A. Fernandes, J.M. Navarro, R.A. Dias, and V.P. Thompson Reliability of one-piece ceramic implant Journal of Biomedical Materials Research Part B: Applied Biomaterials 88 2009 419 426
19. R.J. Kohal, M. Wolkewitz, and C. Mueller Alumina-reinforced zirconia implants: survival rate and fracture strength in a masticatory simulation trial Clinical Oral Implants Research 21 2010 1345 1352
20. Y. Akagawa, R. Hosokawa, Y. Sato, and K. Kamayama Comparison between freestanding and tooth-connected partially stabilized zirconia implants after two years' function in monkeys: a clinical and histologic study Journal of Prosthetic Dentistry 80 1998 551 558
21. A. Scarano, F. Di Carlo, M. Quaranta, and A. Piattelli Bone response to zirconia ceramic implants: an experimental study in rabbits Journal of Oral Implantology 29 2003 8 12
22. R.J. Kohal, D. Weng, M. Bächle, and J.R. Strub Loaded custom-made zirconia and titanium implants show similar osseointegration: an animal experiment Journal of Periodontology 75 2004 1262 1268
23. R.J. Kohal, M. Wolkewitz, M. Hinze, J.S. Han, M. Bächle, and F. Butz Biomechanical and histological behavior of zirconia implants: an experiment in the rat Clinical Oral Implants Research 20 2009 333 339
24. J. Lee, J.H. Sieweke, N.A. Rodriguez, P. Schüpbach, H. Lindström, and C. Susin Evaluation of nano-technology-modified zirconia oral implants: a study in rabbits Journal of Clinical Periodontology 36 2009 610 617
25. I. Rocchietta, F. Fontana, A. Addis, P. Schupbach, and M. Simion Surface-modified zirconia implants: tissue response in rabbits Clinical Oral Implants Research 20 2009 844 850
26. P.I. Brånemark, B.O. Hansson, R. Adell, U. Breine, J. Lindström, and O. Hallén Osseointegrated implants in the treatment of the edentulous jaw. Experience from a 10-year period Scandinavian Journal of Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery Suppl 16 1977 1 132
27. P.R. Klokkevold, R.D. Nishimura, M. Adachi, and A. Caputo Osseointegration enhanced by chemical etching of the titanium surface. A torque removal study in the rabbit Clinical Oral Implants Research 8 1997 442 447
28. D. Baker, R.M. London, and R. O'Neal Rate of pull-out strength gain of dual-etched titanium implants: a comparative study in rabbits International Journal of Oral and Maxillofacial Implants 14 1999 722 728
29. T. Ogawa, S. Ozawa, J.H. Shih, K.H. Ryu, C. Sukotjo, and J.M. Yang Biomechanical evaluation of osseous implants having different surface topographies in rats Journal of Dental Research 79 2000 1857 1863
30. F. Butz, H. Aita, C.J. Wang, and T. Ogawa Harder and stiffer bone osseointegrated to roughened titanium Journal of Dental Research 85 2006 560 565
31. C. Galli, S. Guizzardi, G. Passeri, D. Martini, A. Tinti, and G. Mauro Comparison of human mandibular osteoblasts grown on two commercially available titanium implant surfaces Journal of Periodontology 76 2005 364 372
32. K.T. Bowers, J.C. Keller, B.A. Randolph, D.G. Wick, and C.M. Michaels Optimization of surface micromorphology for enhanced osteoblast responses in vitro International Journal of Oral and Maxillofacial Implants 7 1992 302 310
33. D.M. Brunette The effects of implant surface topography on the behavior of cells International Journal of Oral and Maxillofacial Implants 3 1988 231 246
34. B. Groessner-Schreiber, and R.S. Tuan Enhanced extracellular matrix production and mineralization by osteoblasts cultured on titanium surfaces in vitro Journal of Cell Science 101 1992 209 217
35. J.L. Ong, C.W. Prince, G.N. Raikar, and L.C. Lucas Effect of surface topography of titanium on surface chemistry and cellular response Implant Dentistry 5 1996 83 88
36. H. Zreiqat, and C.R. Howlett Titanium substrata composition influences osteoblastic phenotype: in vitro study Journal of Biomedical Materials Research 47 1999 360 366
37. Z.M. Isa, G.B. Schneider, R. Zaharias, D. Seabold, and C.M. Stanford Effects of fluoride-modified titanium surfaces on osteoblast proliferation and gene expression International Journal of Oral and Maxillofacial Implants 21 2006 203 211
38. S.J. Ferguson, J.D. Langhoff, K. Voelter, B. von Rechenberg, D. Scharnweber, and S. Bierbaum Biomechanical comparison of different surface modifications for dental implants International Journal of Oral and Maxillofacial Implants 23 2008 1037 1046
39. B. Bacchelli, G. Giavaresi, M. Franchi, D. Martini, V. De Pasquale, and A. Trire Influence of a zirconia sandblasting treated surface on peri-implant bone healing: an experimental study in sheep Acta Biomaterialia 5 2009 2246 2257
40. J. Lee, J.H. Sieweke, N.A. Rodriguez, P. Schupbach, H. Lindstrom, and C. Susin Evaluation of nano-technology-modified zirconia oral implants: a study in rabbits Journal of Clinical Periodontology 36 2009 610 617
41. L. Sennerby, A. Dasmah, B. Larsson, and M. Iverhed Bone tissue responses to surface-modified zirconia implants: a histomorphometric and removal torque study in the rabbit Clinical Implant Dentistry and Related Research 7 Suppl 1 2005 S13 S20
42. O. Hoffmann, N. Angelov, G.G. Zafiropoulos, and S. Andreana Osseointegration of zirconia implants with different surface characteristics: an evaluation in rabbits The International Journal of Oral & Maxillofacial Implants 27 2012 352 358
43. M. Subramaniam, S.M. Jalal, D.J. Rickard, S.A. Harris, M.E. Bolander, and T.C. Spelsberg Further characterization of human fetal osteoblastic hfob 1.19 and hfob/er alpha cells: bone formation in vivo and karyotype analysis using multicolor fluorescent in situ hybridization Journal of Cellular Biochemistry 87 2002 9 15
44. M.W. Pfaffl A new mathematical model for relative quantification in real-time RT-PCR Nucleic Acids Research 29 2001 e45
45. K. Donath, and G. Breuner A method for the study of undecalcified bones and teeth with attached soft tissues. The Sage-Schliff (sawing and grinding) technique Journal of Oral Pathology 11 1982 318 326
46. S. Ozawa, T. Ogawa, K. Iida, C. Sukotjo, H. Hasegawa, and R.D. Nishimura Ovariectomy hinders the early stage of bone-implant integration: histomorphometric, biomechanical, and molecular analyses Bone 30 2002 137 143
47. D. Levanon, V. Negreanu, Y. Bernstein, I. Bar-Am, L. Avivi, and Y. Groner Aml1, aml2, and aml3, the human members of the runt domain gene-family: cDNA structure, expression, and chromosomal localization Genomics 23 1994 425 432
48. T. Komori Regulation of osteoblast differentiation by transcription factors Journal of Cellular Biochemistry 99 2006 1233 1239
49. M. Mizuno, R. Fujisawa, and Y. Kuboki Bone chondroadherin promotes attachment of osteoblastic cells to solid-state substrates and shows affinity to collagen Calcified Tissue International 59 1996 163 167
50. S. Imai, M. Kaksonen, E. Raulo, T. Kinnunen, C. Fages, and X. Meng Osteoblast recruitment and bone formation enhanced by cell matrix-associated heparin-binding growth-associated molecule (hb-gam) Journal of Cell Biology 143 1998 1113 1128
51. J.E. Davies Mechanisms of endosseous integration International Journal of Prosthodontics 11 1998 391 401
52. S. Verrier, M. Peroglio, C. Voisard, B. Lechmann, and M. Alini The osteogenic differentiation of human osteoprogenitor cells on anodic-plasma-chemical treated ti6al7nb Biomaterials 32 2011 672 680
53. D.O. Meredith, L. Eschbach, M.O. Riehle, A.S. Curtis, and R.G. Richards Microtopography of metal surfaces influence fibroblast growth by modifying cell shape, cytoskeleton, and adhesion Journal of Orthopaedic Research 25 2007 1523 1533
54. T.S. Silva, D.C. Machado, C. Viezzer, A.N. Silva Junior, and M.G. de Oliveira Effect of titanium surface roughness on human bone marrow cell proliferation and differentiation: an experimental study Acta Cirúrgica Brasileira 24 2009 200 205
55. T.P. Kunzler, T. Drobek, M. Schuler, and N.D. Spencer Systematic study of osteoblast and fibroblast response to roughness by means of surface-morphology gradients Biomaterials 28 2007 2175 2182
56. B. Setzer, M. Bächle, M.C. Metzger, and R.J. Kohal The gene-expression and phenotypic response of hfob 1.19 osteoblasts to surface-modified titanium and zirconia Biomaterials 30 2009 979 990
57. A.M. Moursi, C.H. Damsky, J. Lull, D. Zimmerman, S.B. Doty, and S. Aota Fibronectin regulates calvarial osteoblast differentiation Journal of Cell Science 109 1996 1369 1380
58. A.J. Garcia, and D. Boettiger Integrin-fibronectin interactions at the cell-material interface: initial integrin binding and signaling Biomaterials 20 1999 2427 2433
59. M.A. Schwartz, M.D. Schaller, and M.H. Ginsberg Integrins: emerging paradigms of signal transduction Annual Review of Cell and Developmental Biology 11 1995 549 599
60. A. Howe, A.E. Aplin, S.K. Alahari, and R.L. Juliano Integrin signaling and cell growth control Current Opinion in Cell Biology 10 1998 220 231
61. T. Ogawa, and I. Nishimura Different bone integration profiles of turned and acid-etched implants associated with modulated expression of extracellular matrix genes International Journal of Oral and Maxillofacial Implants 18 2003 200 210
62. M.H. Helfrich, S.A. Nesbitt, P.T. Lakkakorpi, M.J. Barnes, S.C. Bodary, and G. Shankar Beta 1 integrins and osteoclast function: involvement in collagen recognition and bone resorption Bone 19 1996 317 328
63. M. McCracken, J.E. Lemons, and K. Zinn Analysis of ti-6al-4v implants placed with fibroblast growth factor 1 in rat tibiae International Journal of Oral and Maxillofacial Implants 16 2001 495 502
64. C.R. Howlett Early bone formation around calcium-ion-implanted titanium inserted into rat tibia Journal of Biomedical Materials Research 44 1999 352 353
65. R. Brånemark, L.O. Ohrnell, P. Nilsson, and P. Thomsen Biomechanical characterization of osseointegration during healing: an experimental in vivo study in the rat Biomaterials 18 1997 969 978
66. A. Abron, M. Hopfensperger, J. Thompson, and L.F. Cooper Evaluation of a predictive model for implant surface topography effects on early osseointegration in the rat tibia model Journal of Prosthetic Dentistry 85 2001 40 46
67. D.D. Deligianni, N. Katsala, S. Ladas, D. Sotiropoulou, J. Amedee, and Y.F. Missirlis Effect of surface roughness of the titanium alloy Ti-6Al-4V on human bone marrow cell response and on protein adsorption Biomaterials 22 2001 1241 1251
68. A. Wennerberg, T. Albrektsson, and B. Andersson Bone tissue response to commercially pure titanium implants blasted with fine and coarse particles of aluminum oxide International Journal of Oral and Maxillofacial Implants 11 1996 38 45
69. K. Gotfredsen, T. Berglundh, and J. Lindhe Anchorage of titanium implants with different surface characteristics: an experimental study in rabbits Clinical Implant Dentistry and Related Research 2 2000 120 128
70. D.L. Cochran, P.V. Nummikoski, F.L. Higginbottom, J.S. Hermann, S.R. Makins, and D. Buser Evaluation of an endosseous titanium implant with a sandblasted and acid-etched surface in the canine mandible: radiographic results Clinical Oral Implants Research 7 1996 240 252
71. C.H. Turner, and D.B. Burr Basic biomechanical measurements of bone: a tutorial Bone 14 1993 595 608
72. L.P. Garetto, J. Chen, J.A. Parr, and W.E. Roberts Remodeling dynamics of bone supporting rigidly fixed titanium implants: a histomorphometric comparison in four species including humans Implant Dentistry 4 1995 235 243
73. K. Suzuki, K. Aoki, and K. Ohya Effects of surface roughness of titanium implants on bone remodeling activity of femur in rabbits Bone 21 1997 507 514
74. A. Wennerberg, and T. Albrektsson Effects of titanium surface topography on bone integration: a systematic review Clinical Oral Implants Research 20 Suppl 4 2009 172 184
75. M. Gahlert, S. Röhling, M. Wieland, C.M. Sprecher, H. Kniha, and S. Milz Osseointegration of zirconia and titanium dental implants: a histological and histomorphometrical study in the maxilla of pigs Clinical Oral Implants Research 20 2009 1247 1253
76. F.P. Koch, D. Weng, S. Kramer, S. Biesterfeld, A. Jahn-Eimermacher, and W. Wagner Osseointegration of one-piece zirconia implants compared with a titanium implant of identical design: a histomorphometric study in the dog Clinical Oral Implants Research 21 2010 350 356