Unwelcome stranger to the system: Vocational education in early twentieth-century China

Comparative Education

Volumn 49, Issue 2, 2013, Pages 226-241

  Schulte, Barbara ^a  

^a Nordic Institute of Asian Studies   (Denmark)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

EDUCATION POLICY; EDUCATIONAL DEVELOPMENT; HISTORICAL PERSPECTIVE; POLICY IMPLEMENTATION; TWENTIETH CENTURY; VOCATIONAL EDUCATION;

CHINA;

EID: 84877274246     PISSN: 03050068     EISSN: 13600486     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1080/03050068.2012.713581     Document Type: Article

References (80)

1. Anderson-Levitt, K. M. 2003. Local meanings, global schooling, Edited by: Anderson-Levitt, K. M. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
2. Bastid, M. 1987. " Servitude or liberation? The introduction of foreign educational practices and systems to China from 1840 to the present ". In China's education and the industrialized world. Studies in cultural transfer, Edited by: Hayhoe, R. and Bastid, M. 3 - 20. Armonk NY: Sharpe.
3. Bastid, M. 1988. L'argument économique dans les réformes de l'enseignement en Chine au XXe siècle. Interchange, 19 (3/4): 19 - 31. (doi:10.1007/BF01807098)
4. Bing, X. 2011. Ruhe Wanshan Zhengfu zai Zhongdeng Zhiye Jiaoyu zhong de Zuoyong [How to improve the government's effect on secondary vocational education]. Zhiye Jiaoyu, 18 (9): 173 - 174.
5. Cai, Y. 1912. Xin jiaoyu yijian [A view on new education]. Jiaoyu Zazhi, 3 (11): 18 - 27.
6. Cai, Y. 1921. Putong jiaoyu yu zhiye jiaoyu [General education and vocational education]. Jiaoyu Zazhi, 13 (1): 1 - 7.
7. Curran, T. 2005. Educational reform in Republican China. The failure of educators to create a modern nation, New York and Ontario: The Edwin Mellen Press.
8. Deissinger, T. 1994. The evolution of the modern vocational training systems in England and Germany: A comparative view. Compare: A Journal of Comparative and International Education, 24 (1): 17 - 36. (doi:10.1080/0305792940240103)
9. Eisenstadt, S. N. 1999. Multiple modernities in an age of globalization. The Canadian Journal of Sociology, 24 (2): 283 - 295. (doi:10.2307/3341732)
10. Foster, P. J. 1965. " The vocational school fallacy in development planning ". In Education and economic development, Edited by: Anderson, C. A. and Bowman, M. J. 142 - 166. London: Cass.
11. Gewurtz, M. S. 1978. Social reality and educational reform. The case of the Chinese Vocational Education Association 1917-1927. Modern China, 4 (2): 157 - 180. (doi:10.1177/009770047800400202)
12. Guo, T. 1925. Wo guo nongye jiaoyu de gaijin [The progress of agrarian education in our country]. Jiaoyu Zazhi, 17 (1): 1 - 10.
13. Hansen, M. H. and Woronov, T. E. Forthcoming. Demanding and resisting vocational education: A comparative study of schools in rural and urban China. Comparative Education,
14. Huang, J. and Xu, D. 2011. Cai Yuanpei zhiye jiaoyu sixiang tanxi [An analysis of Cai Yuanpei's vocational education ideas]. Qiyejia Tiandi (Lilunban), 9: 221 - 222.
15. Huang, Y. 1913. Xuexiao jiaoyu caiyong shiyongzhuyi zhi shangque [A discussion about using pragmatism in school education]. Jiaoyu Zazhi, 5 (7): 55 - 82.
16. Huang, Y. 1916. Bao Yi riji (xu ba) [Bao Yi's diary (eighth part)]. Jiaoyu Zazhi, 8 (10): 73 - 84.
17. Huang, Y. 1921. Zhiye jiaoyu [Vocational education]. Jiaoyu Zazhi, 13 (11): 61 - 63.
18. Huang, Y. 1922. Du quanguo zhiye jiaoyu zuijin tongji [The most recent national statistics from vocational education]. Jiaoyu yu Zhiye, 37: 1 - 3.
19. Huang, Y. 1923. Zhiye jiaoyu zhi jiao [The reef of vocational education]. Jiaoyu yu Zhiye, 41: 1 - 3.
20. Huang, Y. 1929. Xuyan [Preface]. Minguo Shiba Nian zhi Zhonghua Zhiye Jiaoyushe [The Chinese Association for Vocational Education in the eighteenth year of the Republic]. Shanghai Municipal Archive. Document no. Q 235-3-484
21. Huang, Y. 1931. " Sanshiwu nian lai Zhongguo zhi zhiye jiaoyu [Chinese vocational education over the last thirty-five years] ". In In Sanshiwu Nian Lai zhi Zhongguo Jiaoyu [Chinese education over the last thirty-five years], ed. Y. Zhang, 133-152. Shanghai: Commercial Press
22. Huang, Y. 1933. Zhiye jiaoyu gai zenmeyang ban [How to tackle vocational education]?. Zhonghua Zhiye Xuexiao Shiwu Zhounian Jinian [The fifteenth anniversary of the Chinese Vocational School]. Shanghai Municipal Archive. Document no. Q 235-3-486
23. Jia, F. 1914. Jiaoyu weiyan [Words of warning to education]. Jiaoyu Zazhi, 5 (12): 156 - 161.
24. Jia, G. 1933. Jia xu [Preface by Jia]. Zhonghua Zhiye Xuexiao Shiwu Zhounian Jinian [The fifteenth anniversary of the Chinese Vocational School]. Shanghai Municipal Archive. Document no. Q 235-3-486
25. Jiang, D. 2011. Zhongguo Zhiye Jiaoyu Gaige yu Fazhan Jianyan: Cuoshi yu Chuangxin [Suggestions on the reform and development of vocational education in China: Measures and innovation]. Zhiye Jishu Jiaoyu, 32 (28): 5 - 10.
26. Jiang, H. 1928. Rensheng xiye zeye ji fuwu shi suo ying ju de biyao tiaojian [Necessary conditions for learning and choosing a profession]. Jiaoyu yu Zhiye, 98: 535 - 543.
27. Jiang, M. 1918. Gaodeng xueshu wei jiaoyu zhi jichu [High level scholarship as the basics of education]. Jiaoyu Zazhi, 10 (1): 13 - 18.
28. Jiaoyushe (Zhonghua Zhiye Jiaoyushe [Chinese Association for Vocational Education]). 1920. Zhonghua Zhiye Xuexiao gaikuang [The situation of the Chinese Vocational School]. Jiaoyu yu Zhiye, 20: 1 - 6.
29. King, K. and Martin, C. 2002. The vocational school fallacy revisited: Education, aspiration and work in Ghana 1959-2000. International Journal of Educational Development, 22: 5 - 26. (doi:10.1016/S0738-0593(00)00083-3)
30. Kuhn, P. A. 1975. " Local self-government under the Republic: Problems of control, autonomy, and mobilization ". In Conflict and control in late imperial China, Edited by: Wakeman, F. Jr and Grant, C. 256 - 298. Berkeley CA: University of California Press.
31. Lai, M. and Lo, L. N.-K. 2006. Decentralisation and the development of vocational education in China. China: An International Journal, 4 (2): 287 - 301.
32. Li, C. 2006. Sociopolitical change and inequality in educational opportunity. Impact of family background and institutional factors on educational attainment (1940-2001). Chinese Sociology and Anthropology, 38 (4): 6 - 36. (doi:10.2753/CSA0009-4625380401)
33. Liang, Q. 1962. " Zhongguo jiaoyu zhi qiantu yu jiaoyujia zhi zijue [The future path of Chinese education and the self-consciousness of pedagogues] ". In In Zhongguo Jindai Jiaoyushi Ziliao [Materials on the history of modern Chinese education], ed. X. Shu, 954-961. Beijing: Renmin Jiaoyu Chubanshe. Original edition: 1917
34. Liu, G. 1997. Zhongguo Jindai Zhiye Jiaoyu Sixiangshi [History of ideas of vocational education in Republican China], Beijing: Gaodeng Jiaoyu Chubanshe.
35. Liu, Z. 1925. Zhiye zhidao de juti jihua [Concrete plans for vocational guidance]. Jiaoyu Zazhi, 17 (1): 1 - 20.
36. McCarthy, T. 2009. Race, empire, and the idea of human development, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
37. Meng, Y. 1999. Hybrid science versus modernity: The practice of the Jiangnan Arsenal, 1864-1897. East Asian Science, Technology, and Medicine, 16: 13 - 52.
38. Middleton, J., Ziderman, A. and Van Adams, A. 1993. Skills for productivity. Vocational education and training in developing countries, A World Bank Book, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
39. Minguo Shiba Nian (Minguo Shiba Nian zhi Zhonghua Zhiye Jiaoyushe [The Chinese Association for Vocational Education in the Eighteenth Year of the Republic]). 1929. Shanghai Municipal Archive. Document no. Q 235-3-484
40. Ministry of Education of the People's Republic of China (MOE). 2010. Zhongdeng Zhiye Jiaoyu Gaige Chuangxin Xingdong Jihua (2010-2012) [Action plan for the reform and innovation of secondary vocational education (2010-2012)], 27 November. Document no. (chinese source);(2010)13(chinese source). http://www.moe.edu.cn/ ewebeditor/uploadfile/20110111113735309.doc (accessed 22 December 2011)
41. Ministry of Education of the People's Republic of China (MOE). 2011a. Jiaoyubu Guanyu Tuijin Gaodeng Zhiye Jiaoyu Gaige Chuangxin Yinling Zhiye Jiaoyu Kexue Fazhan de Ruogan Yijian [Some views of the Ministry of Education on the scientific development of vocational education through advancing the reform and innovation of higher vocational education], 29 September 2011. Document no. (chinese source) [2011]12(chinese source). http://www.moe.gov.cn/publicfiles/business/htmlfiles/moe/A07_zcwj/201110/xxgk_125717.html (accessed 22 December 2011)
42. Ministry of Education of the People's Republic of China (MOE). 2011b. Jiaoyubu Guanyu Tuijin Zhongdeng he Gaodeng Zhiye Jiaoyu Xietiao Fazhan de Zhidao Yijian [Guiding views of the Ministry of Education on advancing the coordinated development of secondary and higher vocational education], 30 August 2011. Document no. (chinese source) [2011]9(chinese source). http://www.moe.gov.cn/publicfiles/business/htmlfiles/moe/A07_zcwj/201109/xxgk_124851.html (accessed 22 December 2011)
43. Mu, O. 1928. Kexue jiaoyu yu guohuo qiantu [Science education and the future of national products]. Jiaoyu yu Zhiye, 99: 603 - 605.
44. Oelsner, V. 2012a. Produzenten statt Parasiten [Producers instead of parasites], Frankfurt am Main: Peter Lang (forthcoming).
45. Oelsner, V. 2012b. 'Forging the Fatherland': Work and vocational education in Argentina during Peronism (1944-1955). Paedagogica Historica: International Journal of the History of Education, DOI:10.1080/00309230.2012.695378
46. Oelsner, V. and Schulte, B. 2006. Variationen des Anderen: Die Wahrnehmung ausländischer Bildungsmodelle in der argentinischen und chinesischen Modernisierungsdebatte im späten 19. und frühen 20. Jahrhundert [Variations of the other: The perception of foreign models of education in the Argentine and Chinese debates on modernisation in the late 19th and early 20th centuries]. COMPARATIV. Leipziger Beiträge zur Universalgeschichte und vergleichenden Gesellschaftsforschung 16, 3: 44-67
47. Pan, W. 1923. Zhiye xuexiao xuesheng ying bei zhi xingxing zhineng [Behaviour and qualities for which vocational students have to be prepared]. Jiaoyu yu Zhiye, 46: 1 - 4.
48. Pan, W. 1925. Zhiye jiaoyu yu zhiye xunlian [Vocational education and vocational training]. Jiaoyu Zazhi, 17 (1): 1 - 5.
49. Qin, H. 1925. Minguo shisan nian zhi zhiye jiaoyu [Vocational education in the thirteenth year of the Republic]. Jiaoyu yu Zhiye, 62: 107 - 116.
50. Reardon-Anderson, J. 1991. The study of change. Chemistry in China, 1840-1949, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
51. Schriewer, J. and Harney, K. 1999. " Beruflichkeit versus culture technique: Pour une sociogenèse de la sémantique du travail en France et en Allemagne ". In Le Travail et la Nation. Histoire croisée de la France et de l'Allemagne à l'horizon européen, Edited by: Didry, C., Wagner, P. and Zimmermann, B. 107 - 146. Paris: Editions de la Maison des Sciences de l'Homme.
52. Schriewer, J. and Martinez, C. 2004. " Constructions of internationality in education ". In In The global politics of educational borrowing and lending, Edited by: Steiner-Khamsi, G. 29 - 53. New York: Teachers College Press.
53. Schulte, B. 2008. 'Zur Rettung des Landes': Bildung und Beruf im China der Republikzeit ['Saving the nation': Education and profession in Republican China], Frankfurt am Main: Campus.
54. Schulte, B. 2009. " Zum Schutz von Körper und Land: Repräsentationen von Hygiene auf der Reise durch chinesische Köpfe und Körper [Protecting body and country: Representations of hygiene on their journey through Chinese minds and bodies] ". In Dem Anderen begegnen: Eigene und fremde Repräsentationen in sozialen Gemeinschaften [Encountering the other: Representations of self and other in social communities], ed. J. Baberowski, D. Feest and M. Lehmann, 141-163. Frankfurt am Main: Campus
55. Schulte, B. 2011. " The Chinese Dewey: Friend, fiend, and flagship ". In The global reception of John Dewey's thought, Edited by: Bruno-Jofre, R. and Schriewer, J. 83 - 115. London: Routledge.
56. Schulte, B. 2012. " Joining forces to save the nation: Corporate educational governance in Republican China ". In The Chinese corporatist state: Adaption, survival and resistance, Edited by: Hsu, J. and Hasmath, R. London: Routledge (in print). Routledge Contemporary China Series.
57. Shao, Q. 2004. Culturing modernity. The Nantong model, 1890-1930, Stanford CA: Stanford University Press.
58. Shu, X. 1925. Zhongxue zhiye zhidao de xianjue wenti [The prerequisites for vocational guidance at middle schools]. Jiaoyu Zazhi, 17 (1): 1 - 6.
59. Shu, X. 1928. Jindai Zhongguo Jiaoyu Sixiangshi [A history of ideas in modern Chinese education], Shanghai: Shanghai Zhonghua Shuju.
60. Stoler, L. and Cooper, F. 1997. " Between metropole and colony: Rethinking a research agenda ". In Tensions of empire. Colonial cultures in a bourgeois world, Edited by: Cooper, F. and Stoler, L. 1 - 56. Los Angeles and London: University of California Press.
61. Sun, H. 2004. Dui wo guo gaodeng zhiye jiaoyu fazhan zhuangkuang de fansi [Reflections on the development state of higher vocational education in China]. Weinan Shifan Xueyuan Xuebao, 19 (no. S2): 34 - 36.
62. Sun, S. 2011. Zhiye jiaoyu fenji zhidu jiben wenti [The basic problems of a differentiated system of vocational education]. Jiaoyu yu Zhiye, 22: 41 - 44.
63. Sun, Z. 1927. Shi nian lai Zhongguo zhi zhiye jiaoyu [Chinese vocational education over the last ten years]. Jiaoyu yu Zhiye, 85: 199 - 205.
64. Tao, X. 1918. Shenglizhuyi zhi Zhiye Jiaoyu [The principle of creating value in vocational education]. Jiaoyu yu Zhiye, 1 (3)
65. Wang, J. 1983. Zai shehui li sheng le gen de ren - Mianhuai Huang Yanpei xiansheng [A person rooted in society - My memories of Huang Yanpei]. Shehui Kexue, 7: 52 - 55.
66. Wang, M. 1920a. Jiaoyu shang shiyongzhuyi zhi weizhi [The position of pragmatism in education]. Jiaoyu Zazhi, 12 (7): 1 - 6.
67. Wang, M. 1920b. Suo qiu yu pingmin de jiaoyuzhe [What pedagogues are looking for among the common people]. Jiaoyu Zazhi, 12 (3): 1 - 10.
68. Wang, Y. C. 1961. Intellectuals and society in China 1860-1949. Comparative Studies in Society and History, 3 (4): 395 - 426. (doi:10.1017/S0010417500001080)
69. Watson, K. 1994. Technical and vocational education in developing countries: Western paradigms and comparative methodology. Comparative Education, 30 (2): 85 - 97. (doi:10.1080/0305006940300202)
70. Weber, E. 1977. Peasants into Frenchmen. The modernization of rural France 1870-1914, London: Chatto & Windus.
71. Wei, Q. 1928. Zhiye jiaoyu zai Zhongguo xuezhi shang de diwei [The position of vocational education in the Chinese educational system]. Jiaoyu yu Zhiye, 98: 527 - 534.
72. Wu, Y. 1988. The development of vocational education in Shenzhen SEZ. International Journal of Educational Development, 8 (3): 239 - 242. (doi:10.1016/0738-0593(88)90045-4)
73. Yang, E. 1928. Zui jin zhi Zhongguo zhiye jiaoyu [Chinese vocational education in recent times]. Jiaoyu yu Zhiye, 100: 729 - 734.
74. Yu, X. 2000. Jindai Zhongguo de zhiye jiaoyu (1866-1927) [Vocational education in China during the late Qing and early Republic (1866-1927)]. Lishi Dang'an, 2: 93 - 98.
75. Zhang, W. 2009. Issues of practical teaching in vocational-technical schools in China and their countermeasures. International Education Studies, 2 (4): 75 - 78.
76. Zhuang, Y. 1912. Lun jiaoyu fangzhen [Discussing the principles of education]. Jiaoyu Zazhi, 4 (1): 1 - 11.
77. Zhuang, Y. 1915. Qinlaozhuyi yu xunyu [The principle of diligence and moral education]. Jiaoyu Zazhi, 7 (9): 163 - 168.
78. Zou, E. 1924. Zhiye de zhen le [The real joy of a vocation]. Jiaoyu yu Zhiye, 56: 339 - 343.
79. Zou, E. 1925. Canguan Jiangsu zhiye jiaoyu hou de ganchu yu jianyi [Impressions and suggestions after investigating the vocational education in Jiangsu]. Jiaoyu Zazhi, 17 (7): 26373 - 26375.
80. Zou, T. 1988. The development of vocational education in China. International Journal of Educational Development, 8 (3): 237 - 246. (doi:10.1016/0738-0593(88)90044-2)