Maternal Infanticide in Australia: Mental Disturbance During the Postpartum Period

Psychiatry, Psychology and Law

Volumn 20, Issue 2, 2013, Pages 301-311

  De Bortoli, Lillian ^a   Coles, Jan ^a   Dolan, Mairead ^a,b  

^a MONASH UNIVERSITY   (Australia)

^b VICTORIAN INSTITUTE OF FORENSIC MENTAL HEALTH   (Australia)

Author keywords

Infanticide Act; maternal infanticide; mental disturbance; mental illness

Indexed keywords

EID: 84876069887     PISSN: 13218719     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1080/13218719.2012.719103     Document Type: Article

References (125)

1. L Glendinning, 'Inside the Mind of a Killer' [2003 25 October] The Age.
2. S Moynihan, 'Depressed Mother Killed Baby' [2004 18 September] The Age.
3. C Alder and K Polk, Child Victims of Homicide (Cambridge University Press, 2001).
4. P Resnick, 'Child Murder by Parents: A Psychiatric Review Of Filicide' [1969] American Journal of Psychiatry 126(3), 325-33.
5. NSW Law Reform Commission, People with Cognitive and Mental Health Impairments in the Criminal Justice System: Criminal Responsibility and Consequences (Lawlink: Attorney General and Justice, NSW Government, 2010) Contract No.: Consultation Paper 31; Criminal Law [database on the Internet] accessed 4 April 2011.
6. P Dean, 'Child Homicide and Infanticide in New Zealand' [2004] International Journal of Law and Psychiatry 27, 339-48.
7. M Oberman, 'A Brief History of Infanticide and the Law', in M Spinelli (ed.), Infanticide: Psychosocial and Legal Perspectices on Mothers Who Kill (American Psychiatric Publishing, 2003).
8. Victorian Law Reform Commission. Defences to Homicide (Final Report) (Melbourne, 2004).
9. RvCooper[2001] NSWSC,397
10. RvPope [2002] NSWSC, 397
11. R v Rg [2006] NSWSC, 21
12. R v Azzopardi [2004] VSC, 509
13. R v Li [2000] NSWSC, 1088
14. R v Sette [2000] NSWSC, 648
15. R v Richards [2002] NSWSC, 415
16. ABC Corporation, 'Mum Gets Suspended Sentence for Infanticide' (ABC News 8 August 2011) 5 http://www.abc.net.au/news/2008-02-27/mum-gets-sus pended-sentence-for-infanticide/10562964.
17. S Friedman and P Resnick, 'Postpartum Depression: An Update' [2009] Women's Health 5(3), 287-95
18. T Porter and H Gavin, 'Infanticide and Neonaticide: A Review of 40 Years of Research Literature on Incidence and Causes' [2010] Trauma, Violence and Abuse 11(3), 99-112.
19. Porter and Gavin (n. 10).
20. Friedman and Resnick (n. 10).
21. Porter and Gavin (n. 10)
22. I Lambie 'Mothers Who Kill' [2001] International Journal of Law and Psychiatry 24, 71-80.
23. Friedman and Resnick (n. 10).
24. C Akman, F Uguz and N Kaya 'Postpartum-Onset Major Depression is Associated with Personality Disorders' [2007] Comprehensive Psychiatry 48, 343-7.
25. Porter and Gavin (n. 10)
26. A Kauppi, K Kumpulainen, T Vanamo, J Merikanto and K Karkola 'Maternal Depression and Filicide - A Case Study of Ten Mothers' [2008] Archives of Women's Mental Health 11, 201-6.
27. Porter and Gavin (n. 10)
28. S Friedman, P Resnick and M Rosenthal 'Postpartum Psychosis: Strategies to Protect Infant and Mother from Harm' [2009] Current Psychiatry 8, 40-6.
29. Friedman and Gavin (n. 10).
30. Porter and Gavin (n. 10)
31. Friedman et al. (n. 17).
32. NSW Law Reform Commission (n. 5)
33. Victorian Law Reform Commission (n. 8)
34. Law Reform Commission of Western Australia, Review of the Law of Homicide: Final Report, Perth, 2007.
35. Alder and Polk (n. 3)
36. J Mouzos and C Rushforth, Family Homicide in Australia (Australian Institute of Criminology 2003).
37. Alder and Polk (n. 3)
38. M Herman-Giddens, G Brown, S Verbiest, P Carlson, E Hooten, E Howell et al. 'Underascertainment of Child Abuse Mortality in the United States' [1999] JAMA 281(5), 463-7.
39. Alder and Polk (n. 3)
40. M Overpeck 'Epidemiology of Infanticide', in M Spinelli (ed.), Infanticide: Psychosocial and Legal Perspectives on Mothers Who Kill (American Psychiatric Publishing 2003).
41. Alder and Polk (n. 3).
42. R V Sette (n. 9)
43. H Putkonen, G Weiz-mann-Henelius, J Collander, P Santtila and M Eronen 'Neonaticides may be More Preventable and Heterogeneous than Previously Thought - Neonaticides in Finland 1980-2000' [2007] Archives of Women's Mental Health 10, 15-23.
44. Parliament of Victoria. Parliamentary Debates (Hansard). Legislative Council on 31st August (Victorian Government Printer 2010) 4639.
45. Porter and Gavin (n. 10).
46. Alder and Polk (n. 3).
47. Dean (n. 6).
48. Alder and Polk (n. 3)
49. A Wallace, Homicide: The Social Reality (New South Wales Bureau of Crime Statistics and Research 1986).
50. S Friedman, S Horwitz and P Resnick 'Child Murder by Mothers: A Critical Analysis of the Current State of Knowledge and Research Agenda' [2005] American Journal of Psychiatry 162(9), 1578-87.
51. VCDRC, Annual Report of Inquiries into the Deaths of Children Known to Child Protection 2010 (State of Victoria, Office of the Child Safety Commissioner 2010).
52. VCDRC, Annual Report of Inquiries into the Deaths of Children Known to Child Protection 2008 (State of Victoria, Office of the Child Safety Commissioner 2008)
53. VCDRC, Annual Report of Inquiries into the Deaths of Children Known to Child Protection 2009 (State of Victoria, Office of the Child Safety Commissioner 2009)
54. VCDRC, Annual Report of Inquiries into the Deaths of Children Known to Child Protection 2011 (State of Victoria, Office of the Child Safety Commissioner 2011).
55. NSW Child Death Review Team, Fatal Assault of Children and Young People (NSW Commission for Children and Young People 2002).
56. NSW Child Death Review Team, Fatal Assault and Neglect of Children and Young People (NSW Commmission for Children and Young People 2003).
57. NSW Child Death Review Team (n. 34,35).
58. NSW Child Death Review Team (n. 35).
59. NSW Child Death Review Team, Trends in the Fatal Assault of Children in NSW: 1996-2005 (NSW Commission for Children and Young People 2008).
60. NSW Ombudsman, Report of Reviewable Deaths in 2008 & 2009 (NSW Ombudsman 2011)
61. NSW Ombudsman, Report of Reviewable Deaths in 2007 (NSW Ombudsman 2009).
62. NSW Ombudsman, Report of Reviewable Deaths in 2007 (n. 40).
63. Dean (n. 6).
64. NSW Ombudsman, Report of Reviewable Deaths in 2008 & 2009 (n. 40).
65. Mouzos and Rushforth (n. 21)
66. H Strang, Children as Victims of Homicide (Australian Institute of Criminology 1996)
67. M Irenyi and B Horsfall 'Fatal Child Abuse', in National Child Protection Clearinghouse (ed.), Resource Sheet (Australian Institute of Family Studies 2009).
68. C Alder and J Baker 'Maternal Filicide' [1997] Women and Criminal Justice 9(2), 15-39.
69. Alder and Polk (n. 3).
70. Wallace (n. 30).
71. O Nielssen, M Large, B Westmore and S Lackersteen 'Child Homicide in New South Wales from 1991 to 2005' [2009] The Medical Journal of Australia 190(1), 7-11.
72. S de Silva and R Oates 'Child Homicide -The Extreme of Child Abuse' [1993] The Medical Journal of Australia 158(1), 300-1.
73. I Wilkey, J Pearn, G Petrie and J Nixon 'Neonaticide, Infanticide and Child Homicide' [1982] Medical Science and the Law 22(1),31-4.
74. J Barr and C Beck 'Infanticide Secrets: Qualitative Study on Postpartum Depression' [2008] Canadian Family Physician 54: 1717e1-e5.
75. Kauppi et al. (n. 16)
76. Friedmanm et al. (n. 31).
77. D Bourget, J Grace and L Whitehurst 'A Review of Maternal and Paternal Filicide' [2007] Journal of the American Academy of Psychiatry and the Law 35(1), 74-82.
78. Resnick (n. 4).
79. Friedman et al. (n. 17).
80. Friedman et al. (n. 31).
81. P D'Orban 'Women Who Kill Their Children' [1979] British Journal of Psychiatry 134, 560-71.
82. Overpeck (n. 23).
83. Nielssen et al. (n. 48).
84. T Kajese, L Nguyen, G Pham, V Pham, K Melhorn and K Kallail 'Characteristics of Child Abuse Homicides in the State of Kansas from 1994-2007' [2011] Child Abuse and Neglect 35:147-54.
85. J Klevens and R Leeb 'Child Maltreatment Fatalities in Children Under 5: Findings from the National Violence Death Reporting System' [2010] Child Abuse and Neglect 34, 262-66.
86. Nielssen et al. (n. 48)
87. Kauppi et al. (n. 16).
88. Kauppi et al. (n. 16)
89. P Resnick 'Murder of the Newborn: A Psychiatric Review of Neonaticide' [1970] American Journal of Psychiatry 126(10), 1414-20
90. M Craig 'Perinatal Risk Factors for Neonaticide and Infant Homicides: Can We Identify Those at Risk?' [2004] Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine 97, 57-61
91. C Lewis and S Bunce 'Filicidal Mothers and the Impact of Psychosis on Maternal Filicide' [2003] Journal of the American Academy of Psychiatry and the Law 31, 459-70.
92. M Overpeck, R Brenner, A Trumble, L Trifiletti and H Berendes 'Risk Factors for Infant Homicide in the United States' [1998] New England Journal of Medicine 339,1211-16.
93. D'Orban (n. 57).
94. Nielssen et al. (n. 48).
95. Friedman et al. (n. 31).
96. Friedman et al. (n. 31)
97. D'Orban (n. 57)
98. Kajese et al. (n. 60)
99. S Friedman and P Resnick 'Child Murder by Mothers: Patterns and Prevention' [2007] World Psychiatry 6, 137-41.
100. S Friedman, D Hrouda, C Holden, S Noffsinger and P Resnick 'Child Murder Committed by Severely Mentally Ill Mothers: An Examination of Mothers Found Not Guilty by Reason of Insanity' [2005] Journal of Forensic Science 50(6), 1466-71.
101. Overpeck et al. (n. 64).
102. Alder and Peck (n. 31)
103. de Silva and Oates (n. 49)
104. R Krugman 'Fatal Child Abuse: Analysis of 24 Cases' [1983-5] Pediatrician 12(1),68-72.
105. Friedman et al. (n. 31)
106. Kajese et al. (n. 60)
107. L Wissow 'Infanticide (Editorials)' [1998] New England Journal of Medicine 339(17),1239-41.
108. Kajese et al. (n. 60)
109. Overpeck et al. (n. 64).
110. Overpeck et al. (n. 74).
111. VCDRC (n. 32, 33).
112. NSW Child Death Review Team (n. 34, 35).
113. Porter and Gavin (n. 10).
114. Lambie (n. 13)
115. M Marks 'Infanticide' [2008] Psychiatry 8(1),10-12.
116. D'Orban (n. 57).
117. Nielssen et al. (n. 48).
118. For example, Lewis and Bunce (n. 63).
119. Friedman and Resnick (n. 10)
120. Friedman et al. (n. 17)
121. S Friedman and J Friedman 'Parents Who Kill Their Children' [2010] Pediatrics in Review 31(2):e10-e6.
122. Friedman and Resnick (n. 10).
123. R Lawrence 'Understanding Fatal Assault of Children: A Typology and Explanatory Theory' [2004] Children and Youth Services Review 26, 837-52.
124. Wallace (n. 30).
125. Bourget et al. (n. 53).