A synthesis of outcomes from the Warra Silvicultural Systems Trial, Tasmania: Safety, timber production, economics, biodiversity, silviculture and social acceptability

Australian Forestry

Volumn 75, Issue 3, 2012, Pages 147-162

  Neyland, Mark ^a   Hickey, John ^a   Read, Steve M ^a  

^a FORESTRY TASMANIA   (Australia)

Author keywords

Biodiversity; Economics; Eucalypts; Forest influences; Harvesting; Management; Old growth forests; Productivity; Public opinion; Regeneration; Safety; Silvicultural systems; Tasmania

Indexed keywords

ACCIDENT PREVENTION; BIODIVERSITY; ECOLOGY; ECONOMIC AND SOCIAL EFFECTS; ECONOMICS; ELECTRIC CIRCUIT BREAKERS; HARVESTING; MANAGEMENT; PRODUCTIVITY; REFORESTATION; SOCIAL ASPECTS; TIMBER;

EUCALYPTS; FOREST INFLUENCES; OLD-GROWTH FOREST; PUBLIC OPINIONS; REGENERATION; SILVICULTURAL SYSTEM; TASMANIA;

FORESTRY;

AGGREGATE; BIODIVERSITY; ECONOMICS; ELECTRIC CIRCUITS; HARVESTING; PRODUCTIVITY; REFORESTATION; SAFETY; SILVICULTURE; TASMANIA; WATER SUPPLY;

EID: 84873540344     PISSN: 00049158     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1080/00049158.2012.10676397     Document Type: Article

References (89)

1. Alcorn, P. J., 2002. “ The effects of light avaiLabillty on the growth of ”. In Eucalyptus obliqua seedlings. Honours thesis. The Australian National University, Canberra.
2. Alcorn, P. J., Dingle, J. K., and Hickey, J. E., 2001. Age and stand structure in a multi-aged wet eucalypt forest at the Warra silvicultural systems trial. Tasforests, 13:245–259.
3. Arnott, J. T., and Beese, W. J., 1997. Alternatives to clearcutting in BC coastal montane forests. The Forestry Chronicle, 73:670–678.
4. Attiwill, P. M., 1994. Ecological disturbance and the conservative management of eucalypt forests in Australia. Forest Ecology and Management, 63:301–346.
5. Aubry, K. B., Amaranthus, M. P., Halpern, C. B., White, J. D., Woodard, B. L., Peterson, C. E., Lagoudakis, C. A., and Horton, A. J., 1999. Evaluating the effects of varying levels and patterns of green-tree retention:experimental design of the DEMO study. Northwest Science, 73:12–26.
6. Baker, S. C., and Read, S. M., 2011. Variable retention silviculture in Tasmania's wet forests:ecological rationale, adaptive management and synthesis of biodiversity benefits. Australian Forestry, 74:218–232.
7. Baker, S. C., Grove, S. J., Forster, L., Bonham, K. J., and Bashford, D., 2009. Short-term responses of ground-active beetles to alternative silvicultural systems in the Warra Silvicultural Systems Trial, Tasmania, Australia. Forest Ecology and Management, 258:444–459.
8. Barclay, A., 2010. A Minefield in the Forests (online). CSIRO Australia. Accessed 3 November 2010, http://www.ecosmagazine.com/?paper=EC 10015
9. Bassett, O. D., and White, G. A., 2001. Review of the impact of retained overwood trees on stand productivity. Australian Forestry, 64:57–63.
10. Bassett, O. D., Edwards, L. G., and Plumpton, B. S., 2000. A comparison of four-year-old regeneration following six silvicultural treatments in a wet eucalypt forest in southern Tasmania. Tasforests, 12:35–54.
11. Bauhus, J., Puettmann, K., and Messier, C., 2009. Silviculture for old-growth attributes. Forest Ecology and Management, 258:525–537.
12. Beese, W. J., Dunsworth, B. C., Zielke, K., and Bancroft, B., 2003. Maintaining attributes of old-growth forests in coastal BC through variable retention. The Forestry Chronicle, 79:570–578.
13. Brown, M. J., Elliott, H. J., and Hickey, J. E., 2001. An overview of the Warra Long-Term Ecological Research Site. Tasforests, 13:1–8.
14. Chuter, R., 2007. Feasibility of Burning Debris from Wet Eucalypt Forests Harvested to an Aggregated Retention Prescription. Division of Forest Research and Development Technical Report No. 10/2007. Forestry Tasmania.
15. Commonwealth of Australia and State of Tasmania. 1997. Tasmanian Regional Forest Agreement between the Commonwealth of Australia and the State of Tasmania (online) Accessed 23 July 2009, http://www.daff.gov.au/_data/assets/pdf_file/0003/49278/ tas_rfa.pdf
16. Commonwealth of Australia and State of Tasmania. 2007. Sustainability Indicators for Tasmanian Forests 2001–2006. Prepared by the Tasmanian and Australian Governments for the 2007 Ten-Year review of the Tasmanian Regional Forest Agreement. Commonwealth of Australia and State ofTasmania, Hobart.
17. Cremer, K. W., 1969. Browsing of mountain ash regeneration by wallabies and possums in Tasmania. Australian Forestry, 33:201–210.
18. Cunningham, T. M., 1960. The Natural Regeneration of Eucalyptus regnans. Bulletin No. 1. University of Melbourne, School of Forestry, Melbourne.
19. Dignan, P., King, ML, Saveneh, A., and Walters, M., 1998. The regeneration of Eucalyptus regnans F. Muell. under retained overwood:seedling growth and density. Forest Ecology and Management, 102:1–7.
20. Elliott, H. J., Felton, K. C., Jarman, S. J., and Stone, M. G., 2008. A History of Innovation:Eighty-five Years of Research and Development at Forestiy Tasmania. Forestry Tasmania, Hobart.
21. Faunt, K. A., Geary, P. W., Cunningham, R. B., and Gibbons, P., 2006. The East Gippsland Silvicultural Systems Project. II:Germination and early survival of eucalypt regeneration. Australian Forestiy, 69:182–197.
22. Ford, R., Williams, K., Bishop, I., and Webb, T., 2005. Social acceptability of forest management systems:project overview. Melbourne:University of Melbourne.
23. Ford, R., Williams, K. J.H., Bishop, I. D., and Hickey, J. E., 2009a. Public judgements of the social acceptability of silvicultural alternatives in Tasmanian wet eucalypt forests. Australian Forestiy, 72:157–171.
24. Ford, R. M., Williams, K. J.H., Bishop, I. D., and Hickey, J. E., 2009b. Effects of information on the social acceptability of alternatives to clear-felling in Australian wet eucalypt forests. Environmental Management, 44:1149–1162.
25. Ford, R. M., Williams, K. J., Bishop, I. D., and Webb, T. J., 2009c. A value basis for the social acceptability of clear-felling in Tasmania, Australia. Landscape and Urban Planning, 90:196–206.
26. Forest Practices Board. 2000. Forest Practices Code. Forest Practices Board, Hobart, Tasmania.
27. Forestry Tasmania. 1998. Lowland Wet Eucalypt Forests. Native Forest Silviculture Technical Bulletin No. 8., Forestry Tasmania.
28. Forestry Tasmania. 1999. Monitoring and Protecting Eucalypt Regeneration. Native Forest Silviculture Technical Bulletin No. 12. Forestry Tasmania, Hobart.
29. Forestry Tasmania. 2003. Regeneration Surveys and Stocking Standards. Native Forest Silviculture Technical Bulletin No. 6. Forestry Tasmania, Hobart.
30. Forestry Tasmania. 2005a. High Intensity Prescribed Burning. Forestry Tasmania, Hobart.
31. Forestry Tasmania. 2005b. Towards a new silviculture in Tasmania's public old-growth forests:final advice to the Tasmanian Government. Forestry Tasmania, Hobart.
32. Forestry Tasmania. 2007a. Sustainable Forest Management Report 2005–2006. Forestry Tasmania, Hobart.
33. Forestry Tasmania. 2007b. Eucalypt Seed and Sowing. Native Forest Silviculture Technical Bulletin No. 1. Forestry Tasmania, Tasmania.
34. Forestry Tasmania. 2009. A New Silviculture for Tasmania s Public Forests:A review of the variable retention program. Forestry Tasmania, Hobart.
35. Frankcombe, D. W., 1966. The regeneration burn. Appita, 19:127–132.
36. Franklin, J. F., Berg, D. R., Thornburgh, D. A., and Tappeiner, J. C., 1997. “ Alternative silvicultural approaches to timber harvesting:variable retention harvest systems. ”. In Creating a Forestry for the 21st Century:The science of ecosystem management. Edited by:Kohm, K. A., and Franklin, J. F., 111–139. Washington, DC:Island Press.
37. Franklin, J. F., Norris, L. A., Berg, D. R., and Smith, G. R., 1999. The history of DEMO:an experiment in regeneration harvest of northwestern forest ecosystems. Northwest Science, 73:3–11.
38. Fries, C., Johansson, O., Pettersson, B., and Simonsson, P., 1997. Silvicultural models to maintain and restore natural stand structures in Swedish boreal forests. Forest Ecology and Management, 94:89–103.
39. Gates, G. M., 2009. “ Coarse woody debris, macrofungal assemblages and sustainable forest management in a ”. In Eucalyptus obliqua forest of southern Tasmania. PhD thesis, University of Tasmania.
40. Gilbert, J. M., 1959. Forest succession in the Florentine Valley, Tasmania. Papers and Proceedings of the Royal Society of Tasmania, 93:129–151.
41. Gustafsson, L., Baker, S., Bauhus, J., Beese, W., Brodie, A., Kouki, J., Lindenmayer, D. B., Lohmus, A., Martinez Pastur, G. J., Messier, C., Neyland, M., Palik, B., Sverdrup-Thygeson, A., Volney, J., Wayne, A., and Franklin, J. F., 2012. Retention forestry to maintain multifunctional forests:a world perspective. Bioscience, 62:633–645.
42. Hickey, J. E., 1994. A floristic comparison of vascular species in Tasmanian old-growth mixed forest with regeneration resulting from logging and wildfire. Australian Journal of Botany, 42:383–404.
43. Hickey, J. E., and Wilkinson, G. R., 1999. The development and current implementation of silvicultural practices in native forests in Tasmania. Australian Forestry, 62:245–254.
44. Hickey, J. E., Blakesley, A. J., and Turner, B., 1982. Seedfall and germination of Nothofagus cunninghamii (Hook.) Oerst., Eucryphia lucida (Labill.) Baill, and Atherosperma moschatum Labill. Implications for regeneration practice. Australian Forest Research, 13:21–28.
45. Hickey, J. E., Su, W., Rowe, P., Brown, M. J., and Edwards, L. G., 1999. Fire history of the tall wet eucalypt forests of the Warra ecological research site, Tasmania. Australian Forestry, 62:66–71.
46. Hickey, J. E., Neyland, M. G., and Bassett, O. D., 2001. Rationale and design for the Warra Silvicultural Systems Trial in wet Eucalyptus obliqua forests in Tasmania. Tasforests, 13:155–182.
47. Hickey, J. E., Neyland, M. G., Grove, S. J., and Edwards, L. G., 2006. From little things big things grow:The Warra Silvicultural Systems Trial in Tasmanian wet Eucalyptus obliqua forest. Allgemeine Forst und Jagdzeitung, 177:113–119.
48. Jarman, S. J., and Kantvilas, G., 2001a. Bryophytes and lichens at the Warra LTER Site. 1. An inventory of species in Eucalyptus obliqua wet sclerophyll forest. Tasforests, 13:193–216.
49. Jarman, S. J., and Kantvilas, G., 2001b. Bryophytes and lichens at the Warra LTER Site. II. Understorey habitats in Eucalyptus obliqua wet sclerophyll forest. Tasforests, 13:217–243.
50. Kantvilas, G., and Jarman, S. J., 2004. Lichens and bryophytes on Eucalyptus obliqua in Tasmania:management implications in production forests. Biological Conservation, 117:359–373.
51. Kantvilas, G., and Jarman, S. J., 2006. Recovery of lichens after logging:preliminary results from Tasmania's wet forests. The Lichenologist, 38:383–394.
52. Kantvilas, G., Jarman, J., and Minchin, P., 2008. Lichens and bryophytes:little plants, big message. 1 October 2010, http://oldforests.com. au/pages/Presentations/Kan tvilas.pdf
53. Keenan, R. J., and Kimmins, J. P., 1993. The ecological effects of clear-cutting. Environmental Review, 1:121–144.
54. Kimmins, H., 1997. Balancing Act:Environmental Issues in Forestry. Vancouver:University of British Columbia Press. 2nd edn. Canada
55. Kirkpatrick, J. B., Peacock, R. J., Cullen, P. J., and Neyland, M. G., 1988. The Wet Eucalypt Forests of Tasmania. Tasmanian Conservation Trust Inc., Hobart.
56. Laffan, M. D., 2001. Geology and soils of the Warra LTER site:a preliminary description. Tasforests, 13:23–30.
57. Larsen, J. B., 1995. Ecological stability of forests and sustainable silviculture. Forest Ecology and Management, 73:85–96.
58. Lefort, P., and Grove, S., 2009. Early responses of birds to clear-felling and its alternatives in lowland wet eucalypt forest in Tasmania, Australia. Forest Ecology and Management, 258:460–471.
59. Lindenmayer, D. B., and McCarthy, M. A., 2002. Congruence between natural and human forest disturbance:a case study from Australian montane ash forests. Forest Ecology and Management, 155:319–335.
60. Lindenmayer, D. B., Mackey, B. G., Mullen, I. C., McCarthy, M. A., Gill, A. M., Cunningham, R. B., and Donnelly, C. F., 1999. Factors affecting stand structure in forests—are there climatic and topographic determinants?. Forest Ecology and Management, 123:55–63.
61. Lindenmayer, D. B., Cunningham, R. B., Donnelly, C. F., and Franklin, J. F., 2000. Structural features of old-growth Australian montane ash forests. Forest Ecology and Management, 134:189–204.
62. Lutze, M. T., Campbell, R. G., and Fagg, P. C., 1999. Development of silviculture in the native state forests of Victoria. Australian Forestry, 62:236–244.
63. Marsden-Smedley, J. B., and Slijepcevic, A., 2001. Fuel characteristics and low-intensity burning in Eucalyptus obliqua wet forest at the Warra LTER site. Tasforests, 13:261–280.
64. Martinez Pastur, G., Lencinas, M. V., Peri, P. L., Moretto, A., Cellini, J. M., Mormeneo, I., and Vukasovic, R., 2007. Harvesting adaptation to biodiversity conservation in sawmill industry:technology innovation and monitoring program. Journal of Technology Management and Innovation, 2:58–70.
65. Mitchell, K., 1993. Safety of Forest Harvesting under Alternative Silvicultural Systems in a Mountain Ash Forest. VSP Technical Report No. 21. Conservation and Natural Resources, Victoria.
66. Mitchell, S. J., and Beese, W. J., 2002. The retention system:reconciling variable retention with the principles of silvicultural systems. The Forestry Chronicle, 78:397–403.
67. Mitchell, K., and Murphy, S., 1993. Review and Discussion of the Safety of Forest Harvesting in Mountain Ash Ecosystems. VSP internal report No. 13. Department of Conservation and Natural Resources, Victoria.
68. Mitchell, R., Driscoll, T., Healey, S., Mandryk, J., Hendrie, L., and Hull, B., 2001. Fatal injuries in forestry and logging work in Australia, 1989 to 1992. Journal of Occupational Health and Safety Australia and New Zealand, 17:567–577.
69. Mount, A. B., 1976. Some problems associated with small coupes. Search, 7:462
70. Neyland, M. G., 2001. Vegetation of the Warra silvicultural systems trial. Tasforests, 13:183–192.
71. Neyland, M. G., 2004. Selection, harvesting damage, burning damage and persistence of retained trees following dispersed retention harvesting in the Warra silvicultural systems trial in Tasmania. Tasforests, 15:55–66.
72. Neyland, M., 2010. The response of the vegetation to a range of alternatives to clear-felling of tall wet eucalypt forests at the Warra silvicultural systems trial, Tasmania, Australia. PhD Thesis, University of Tasmania, Hobart.
73. Neyland, M. G., and Edwards, L. G., 2011. Monitoring and Control of Browsing Mammal Damage to the Eucalypt Regeneration at the Warra Silvicultural Systems Trial. Division of Forest Research and Development, Technical Report No. 03/2011. Forestry Tasmania, Hobart.
74. Neyland, M. G., Wilkinson, G. R., and Edwards, L. G., 1999. The Forestier silvicultural systems trial:alternatives to clear-felling. Tasforests, 11:35–48.
75. Neyland, M. G., Brown, M. J., and Su, W., 2000. Assessing the representativeness of long-term ecological research sites:a case study at Warra in Tasmania. Australian Forestry, 63:194–198.
76. Neyland, M. G., Hickey, J. E., and Edwards, L. G., 2009a. Safety and productivity at the Warra silvicultural systems trial. Tasforests, 18:1–16.
77. Neyland, M., Hickey, J., Beadle, C., Bauhus, J., Davidson, N., and Edwards, L., 2009b. An examination of stocking and early growth in the Warra silvicultural systems trial confirms the importance of a burnt seedbed for vigorous regeneration in Eucalyptus obliqua forest. Forest Ecology and Management, 258:481–494.
78. Nyvold, U., Dawson, J. K., and Hickey, J. E., 2005. An assessment of timber values from alternative silvicultural systems tested in wet Eucalyptus obliqua forests in Tasmania. Tasforests, 16:19–34.
79. Public Land Use Commission. 1996. Tasmanian-Commonwealth Regional Forest Agreement Background Report Part C. Environment and Heritage Report Vol. Vol. 1, Tasmanian Public Land Use Commission, Hobart
80. Rosenvald, R., and Lohmus, A., 2008. For what, when, and where is green-tree retention better than clear-cutting? A review of the biodiversity aspects. Forest Ecology and Management, 255:1–15.
81. Scientific Panel for Sustainable Forest Practices in Clayoquot Sound. 1995. Sustainable Ecosystem Management in Clayoquot Sound Planning and Practices. Cortex Consultants Inc., Victoria, BC.
82. Smith, D. M., Larson, B. C., Kelty, M. J., and Ashton, P. M.S., 1997. The Practice of Silviculture:Applied Forest Ecology. New York, USA:John Wiley and Sons.
83. Squire, R., 1990. Report on the progress of the silvicultural systems project July 1986—June 1989. Department of Conservation and Environment, Melbourne.
84. Tabor, J., McElhinny, C., Hickey, J., and Wood, J., 2007. Colonisation of clear-felled coupe edges by rainforest tree species from mature mixed forest edges, Tasmania, Australia. Forest Ecology and Management, 240:13–23.
85. Turner, P. A., Grove, S. J., Barry, C., and Airey, C. M., 2008. “ Rethinking the paradigm of stand-replacing wildfire in Tasmania's southern forests. ”. In Old Forests, New Management:An international scientific conference on the conservation and use of old-growth forests in the 21st century. 17–21. February 2008. Hobart, Tasmania, p. 71
86. Vergara, P. M., and Schlatter, R. P., 2006. Aggregate retention in two Tierra del Fuego Nothofagus forests:short-term effects on bird abundance. Forest Ecology and Management, 225:213–224.
87. Wells, P., and Hickey, J. E., 1999. “ Wet sclerophyll, mixed and swamp forest. ”. In Vegetation of Tasmania. Edited by:Reid, J. B., Hill, R. S., Brown, M. J., and Hovenden, M., 224–243. Australian Biological Resources Study, Hobart
88. Whiteley, S. B., 1999. Calculating the sustainable yield of Tasmania's state forests. Tasforests, 11:23–34.
89. Wilkinson, G., and Neilsen, W. A., 1995. Implications of early browsing damage on the long-term productivity of eucalypt forests. Forest Ecology and Management, 74:117–124.