The suitability of sham treatments for use as placebo controls in trials of spinal manipulative therapy: A pilot study

Journal of Bodywork and Movement Therapies

Volumn 17, Issue 1, 2013, Pages 59-68

  Lougee, Hannah ^a   Johnston, Ross G ^b   Thomson, Oliver P ^a,c  

^a The British College of Osteopathic Medicine   (United Kingdom)

^b SWANSEA UNIVERSITY   (United Kingdom)

^c OXFORD BROOKES UNIVERSITY   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

Algometry; Manual therapy; Osteopathy; Placebo; Spinal manipulation

Indexed keywords

PLACEBO;

ADULT; ARTICLE; CERVICAL SPINE; CLINICAL EFFECTIVENESS; CONTROLLED STUDY; EFFECT SIZE; HIGH VELOCITY LOW AMPLITUDE THRUST TECHNIQUE; HUMAN; LIKERT SCALE; MALE; MANIPULATIVE MEDICINE; NORMAL HUMAN; PAIN PRESSURE THRESHOLD; PAIN THRESHOLD; PHYSICAL MEDICINE; PRESSURE; RANDOMIZED CONTROLLED TRIAL; SHAM PROCEDURE; SINGLE BLIND PROCEDURE; THORACIC SPINE; ULTRASOUND THERAPY;

ADULT; ANALYSIS OF VARIANCE; ANTHROPOMETRY; CERVICAL VERTEBRAE; CONFIDENCE INTERVALS; FEMALE; HUMANS; MALE; MANIPULATION, SPINAL; PAIN MEASUREMENT; PAIN THRESHOLD; PILOT PROJECTS; PLACEBOS; PRONE POSITION; REFERENCE VALUES; SINGLE-BLIND METHOD; SPINE; THORACIC VERTEBRAE; ULTRASONOGRAPHY, DOPPLER; YOUNG ADULT;

EID: 84872043692     PISSN: 13608592     EISSN: 15329283     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.jbmt.2012.06.005     Document Type: Article

References (92)

1. Altman D.G. Practical Statistics for Medical Research 1991, Chapman and Hall.
2. Amanzio M., Pollo A., et al. Response variability to analgesics: a role for non-specific activation of endogenous opioids. Pain 2001, 90(3):205-215.
3. Aron A., Aron E.N. Statistics for Psychology 1999, PrenticeHall. second ed.
4. Benedetti F., Colloca L., et al. Placebo-responsive Parkinson patients show decreased activity in single neurons of subthalamic nucleus. Nature Neuroscience 2004, 7(6):587-588.
5. Benedetti F., Arduino C., et al. Loss of expectation-related mechanisms in Alzheimer's disease makes analgesic therapies less effective. Pain 2006, 121(1-2):133-144.
6. Bialosky J.E., Bishop M.D., George S.Z., Robinson M.E. Placebo response to manual therapy: something out of nothing?. The Journal of Manual & Manipulative Therapy 2011, 19(1):11.
7. Bithell C. Evidence-based physiotherapy: some thoughts on best evidence. Physiotherapy 2000, 86(2):58-59.
8. Blikstad A., Gemmell H. Immediate effect of activator trigger point therapy and myofascial band therapy on non-specific neck pain in patients with upper trapezius trigger points compared to sham ultrasound: a randomised controlled trial. Clinical Chiropractic 2008, 11(1):23-29.
9. Brown W.A. The placebo effect. Scientific American 1998, 278(1):68-73.
10. Carnes D., Mullinger B., Underwood M. Defining adverse events in manual therapies: a modified Delphi consensus study. International Journal of Osteopathic Medicine 2010, 13(3):94-98.
11. Cassidy J., Lopes A., et al. The immediate effect of manipulation versus mobilization on pain and range of motion in the cervical spine: a randomized controlled trial. Journal of Manipulative and Physiological Therapeutics 1992, 15(9):570.
12. Chaves T.C., Nagamine H.M., et al. Intra-and interrater agreement of pressure pain threshold for masticatory structures in children reporting orofacial pain related to temporomandibular disorders and symptom-free children. Journal of Orofacial Pain 2007, 21(2):133.
13. Chesterton L.S., Barlas P., et al. Gender differences in pressure pain threshold in healthy humans. Pain 2003, 101(3):259-266.
14. Chiu T.W., Wright A. To compare the effects of different rates of application of a cervical mobilisation technique on sympathetic outflow to the upper limb in normal subjects. Manual Therapy 1996, 1(4):198-203.
15. Christian G., Stanton G., et al. Immunoreactive ACTH, [beta]-endorphin, and cortisol levels in plasma following spinal manipulative therapy. Spine 1988, 13(12):1411-1417.
16. Churchill W. Implications of evidence based medicine for complementary and alternative medicine. Journal of Chinese Medicine 1999, 59:32-35.
17. Dabbs V., Lauretti W.J. A risk assessment of cervical manipulation vs. NSAIDs for the treatment of neck pain. Journal of Manipulative and Physiological Therapeutics 1995, 18(8):530.
18. De la Fuente-Fernandez R., Ruth T.J., et al. Expectation and dopamine release: mechanism of the placebo effect in Parkinson's disease. Science 2001, 293(5532):1164.
19. Power Calculator. Decision Support Systems 2010, DSS Research, Available from:. http://www.dssresearch.com/toolkit/spcalc/power.asp.
20. Ernst E., Harkness E. Spinal manipulation: a systematic review of sham-controlled, double-blind, randomized clinical trials. Journal of Pain and Symptom Management 2001, 22(4):879-889.
21. Evans D. Placebo: The Belief Effect 2003, HarperCollins.
22. Fernández-Carnero J., Fernández-de-las-Peñas C., et al. Immediate hypoalgesic and motor effects after a single cervical spine manipulation in subjects with lateral epicondylalgia. Journal of Manipulative and Physiological Therapeutics 2008, 31(9):675-681.
23. Fernández-de-las-Peñas C., Pérez-de-Heredia M., et al. Immediate effects on pressure pain threshold following a single cervical spine manipulation in healthy subjects. The Journal of Orthopaedic and Sports Physical Therapy 2007, 37(6):325.
24. Fernández-de-las-Peñas C., Alonso-Blanco C., et al. Changes in pressure pain thresholds over C5-C6 zygapophyseal joint after a cervicothoracic junction manipulation in healthy subjects. Journal of Manipulative and Physiological Therapeutics 2008, 31(5):332-337.
25. Fischer A. Application of pressure algometry in manual medicine. Journal of Manual Medicine 1990, 5:145-150.
26. Fleckenstein J., Raab C., et al. Impact of acupuncture on vasomotor rhinitis: a randomized placebo-controlled pilot study. The Journal of Alternative and Complementary Medicine 2009, 15(4):391-398.
27. Fryer G., Carub J., et al. The effect of manipulation and mobilisation on pressure pain thresholds in the thoracic spine. Journal of Osteopathic Medicine 2004, 7(1):8-14.
28. Fryer G. Teaching critical thinking in osteopathy - integrating craft knowledge and evidence-informed approaches. International Journal of Osteopathic Medicine 2008, 11(2):56-61.
29. Fulda K.G., Slicho T., et al. Patient expectations for placebo treatments commonly used in osteopathic manipulative treatment (OMT) clinical trials: a pilot study. Osteopathic Medicine and Primary Care 2007, 1(1):1-8.
30. Gibbons P., Tehan P. HVLA thrust techniques: what are the risks?. International Journal of Osteopathic Medicine 2006, 9(1):4-12.
31. Gibbons P., Tehan P., et al. Manipulation of the Spine, Thorax and Pelvis: An Osteopathic Perspective 2009, Churchill Livingstone.
32. Hamilton L., Boswell C., et al. The effects of high-velocity, low-amplitude manipulation and muscle energy technique on suboccipital tenderness. International Journal of Osteopathic Medicine 2007, 10(2-3):42-49.
33. Hancock M.J., Maher C.G., et al. Selecting an appropriate placebo for a trial of spinal manipulative therapy. Australian Journal of Physiotherapy 2006, 52(2):135-138.
34. Hartman S.E. Why do ineffective treatments seem helpful? A brief review. Chiropractic & Osteopathy 2009, 17(1):1-7.
35. Herr H. Franklin, Lavoisier, and Mesmer: origin of the controlled clinical trial. Urologic Oncology 2005, 23(5):346.
36. Hong C.Z., Chen Y.C., et al. Immediate effects of various physical medicine modalities on pain threshold of an active myofascial trigger point. Journal of Musculoskeletal Pain 1993, 1(2):37-53.
37. Hrobjartsson A., Gøtzsche P.C. Is the placebo powerless? An analysis of clinical trials comparing placebo with no treatment. Obstetrical & Gynecological Survey 2001, 56(10):628.
38. Kaptchuk T.J., Goldman P., et al. Do medical devices have enhanced placebo effects?. Journal of Clinical Epidemiology 2000, 53(8):786-792.
39. Karason A.B., Drysdale I.P. Somatovisceral response following osteopathic HVLAT: a pilot study on the effect of unilateral lumbosacral high-velocity low-amplitude thrust technique on the cutaneous blood flow in the lower limb. Journal of Manipulative and Physiological Therapeutics 2003, 26(4):220-225.
40. Keating L., Lubke C., et al. Mid-thoracic tenderness: a comparison of pressure pain threshold between spinal regions, in asymptomatic subjects. Manual Therapy 2001, 6(1):34-39.
41. Koes B.W., Hoving J.L. The value of the randomized clinical trial in the field of physiotherapy. Manual Therapy 1998, 3(4):179-186.
42. Latey P. Placebo: a study of persuasion and rapport. Journal of Bodywork and Movement Therapies 2000, 4(2):123-136.
43. Latey P. PIacebo Responses in Bodywork'. Understanding the Placebo Effect in Complementary Medicine: Theory, Practice and Research 2001, pp. 147.
44. Licciardone J.C., Russo D.P. Blinding protocols, treatment credibility, and expectancy: methodologic issues in clinical trials of osteopathic manipulative treatment. JAOA: Journal of the American Osteopathic Association 2006, 106(8):457.
45. Licciardone J.C., Stoll S.T., et al. Osteopathic manipulative treatment for chronic low back pain: a randomized controlled trial. Spine 2003, 28(13):1355.
46. Mayberg H.S., Silva J.A., et al. The functional neuroanatomy of the placebo effect. American Journal of Psychiatry 2002, 159(5):728.
47. McSweeney T.P., Thomson O.P., Johnston R. The immediate effects of sigmoid colon manipulation on pressure pain thresholds in the lumbar spine. Journal of Bodywork and Movement Therapies 2012, 16(4):416-423.
48. Milanese S. The use of RCT's in manual therapy - Are we trying to fit a round peg into a square hole?. Manual therapy 2011, 16(4):403-405.
49. Miller F.G., Rosenstein D.L. The nature and power of the placebo effect. Journal of Clinical Epidemiology 2006, 59(4):331-335.
50. Munk N., Zanjani F. Relationship between massage therapy usage and health outcomes in older adults. Journal of Bodywork and Movement Therapies 2010.
51. Low Back Pain: Early Management of Persistent Non-specific Low Back Pain (Clinical Guideline 88) 2009, National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence, Available from:. http://www.nice.org.uk/cg88.
52. Nussbaum E.L., Downes L. Reliability of clinical pressure-pain algometric measurements obtained on consecutive days. Physical Therapy 1998, 78(2):160.
53. Oxman A.D., Lavis J.N., et al. Use of evidence in WHO recommendations. The Lancet 2007, 369(9576):1883-1889.
54. Pariente J., White P., et al. Expectancy and belief modulate the neuronal substrates of pain treated by acupuncture. Neuroimage 2005, 25(4):1161-1167.
55. Paungmali A., Vicenzino B., et al. Hypoalgesia induced by elbow manipulation in lateral epicondylalgia does not exhibit tolerance. Journal of Pain 2003, 4(8):448-454.
56. Petersen N., Vicenzino B., et al. The effects of a cervical mobilisation technique on sympathetic outflow to the upper limb in normal subjects. Physiotherapy Theory and Practice 1993, 9(3):149-156.
57. Petrovic P., Dietrich T., et al. Placebo in emotional processing-induced expectations of anxiety relief activate a generalized modulatory network. Neuron 2005, 46(6):957-969.
58. Potter L., McCarthy C., et al. Algometer reliability in measuring pain pressure threshold over normal spinal muscles to allow quantification of anti-nociceptive treatment effects. International Journal of Osteopathic Medicine 2006, 9(4):113-119.
59. Pratzel H.G. Application of pressure algometry in balneology for evaluation of physical therapeutic modalities and drag effects. Journal of Musculoskeletal Pain 1998, 6(1):111-137.
60. Rosner A. Fables or foibles: inherent problems with RCTs. Journal of Manipulative and Physiological Therapeutics 2003, 26(7):460-467.
61. Ruiz-Sáez M., Fernández-de-las-Peñas C., et al. Changes in pressure pain sensitivity in latent myofascial trigger points in the upper trapezius muscle after a cervical spine manipulation in pain-free subjects. Journal of Manipulative and Physiological Therapeutics 2007, 30(8):578-583.
62. Sackett D.L., Rosenberg W.M., et al. Evidence based medicine: what it is and what it isn't. British Medical Journal 1996, 312(7023):71-72.
63. Saíz-Llamosas J.R., Fernández-Pérez A.M., et al. Changes in neck mobility and pressure pain threshold levels following a cervical myofascial Induction technique in pain-free healthy subjects. Journal of Manipulative and Physiological Therapeutics 2009, 32(5):352-357.
64. Saunders G., Reinnert O., et al. Chiropractic adjustive manipulation on subjects with acute low back pain; visual analogue scores and plasma b-endorphin levels. Journal of Manipulative and Physiological Therapeutics 1990, 13:391-395.
65. Schiller L. Effectiveness of spinal manipulative therapy in the treatment of mechanical thoracic spine pain: a pilot randomized clinical trial* 1. Journal of Manipulative and Physiological Therapeutics 2001, 24(6):394-401.
66. Schmid A., Brunner F., et al. Paradigm shift in manual therapy? Evidence for a central nervous system component in the response to passive cervical joint mobilisation. Manual Therapy 2008, 13(5):387-396.
67. Senstad O., Leboeuf-Yde C., et al. Frequency and characteristics of side effects of spinal manipulative therapy. Spine 1997, 22(4):435.
68. Sterling M., Jull G., et al. Cervical mobilisation: concurrent effects on pain, sympathetic nervous system activity and motor activity. Manual Therapy 2001, 6(2):72-81.
69. Stevinson C., Ernst E. Risks associated with spinal manipulation. The American Journal of Medicine 2002, 112(7):566-571.
70. Struyf F., Nijs J., et al. Scapular positioning and motor control in children and adults: a laboratory study using clinical measures. Manual Therapy 2011, 16(2):155-160.
71. Taylor A.J., Kerry R. A 'system based' approach to risk assessment of the cervical spine prior to manual therapy. International Journal of Osteopathic Medicine 2010.
72. Thomson O., Haig L., et al. The effects of high-velocity low-amplitude thrust manipulation and mobilisation techniques on pressure pain threshold in the lumbar spine. International Journal of Osteopathic Medicine 2009, 12(2):56-62.
73. Thomson O.P., Petty N.J., Moore A.P. Clinical reasoning in osteopathy - more than just principles?. International Journal of Osteopathic Medicine 2011, 14(2):71-76.
74. Triano J.J., McGregor M., et al. Manipulative therapy versus education programs in chronic low back pain. Spine 1995, 20(8):948.
75. United Kingdom back pain exercise and manipulation (UK BEAM) randomised trial: effectiveness of physical treatments for back pain in primary care. British Medical Journal 2004, 329(7479):1377. UK BEAMS Trial Team.
76. Urbaniak G., Plous S. Research Randomizer 2007, [Online], Social psychology network, Available from:. http://www.randomizer.org/form.htm.
77. Vanderweeen L., Oostendorp R., et al. Pressure algometry in manual therapy. Manual Therapy 1996, 1(5):258-265.
78. Vase L., Riley J.L. A comparison of placebo effects in clinical analgesic trials versus studies of placebo analgesia. Pain 2002, 99(3):443-452.
79. Vase L., Robinson M.E., et al. The contributions of suggestion, desire, and expectation to placebo effects in irritable bowel syndrome patients: an empirical investigation. Pain 2003, 105(1-2):17-25.
80. Vaughan B., McLaughlin P., et al. Validity of an electronic pressure algometer. International Journal of Osteopathic Medicine 2007, 10(1):24-28.
81. Vernon H., Dhami M., et al. Spinal manipulation and beta-endorphin: a controlled study of the effect of a spinal manipulation on plasma beta-endorphin levels in normal males. Journal of Manipulative and Physiological Therapeutics 1986, 9(2):115.
82. Vernon H., Aker P., et al. Pressure pain threshold evaluation of the effect of spinal manipulation in the treatment of chronic neck pain: a pilot study. Journal of Manipulative and Physiological Therapeutics 1990, 13(1):13.
83. Vernon H., MacAdam K., et al. Validation of a sham manipulative procedure for the cervical spine for use in clinical trials. Journal of Manipulative and Physiological Therapeutics 2005, 28(9):662-666.
84. Vernon H., Humphreys K., et al. Chronic mechanical neck pain in adults treated by manual therapy: a systematic review of change scores in randomized clinical trials. Journal of Manipulative and Physiological Therapeutics 2007, 30(3):215-227.
85. Vicenzino B., Collins D., et al. The initial effects of a cervical spine manipulative physiotherapy treatment on the pain and dysfunction of lateral epicondylalgia. Pain 1996, 68(1):69-74.
86. Vicenzino B., Collins D., et al. An investigation of the interrelationship between manipulative therapy-induced hypoalgesia and sympathoexcitation. Journal of Manipulative and Physiological Therapeutics 1998, 21(7):448-453.
87. Vincent C., Lewith G. Placebo controls for acupuncture studies. Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine 1995, 88(4):199-204.
88. Wager T.D., Rilling J.K., et al. Placebo-induced changes in FMRI in the anticipation and experience of pain. Science 2004, 303(5661):1162.
89. Walker M.J., Boyles R.E., et al. The effectiveness of manual physical therapy and exercise for mechanical neck pain: a randomized clinical trial. Spine 2008, 33(22):2371.
90. Weir A., Jansen J., et al. Manual or exercise therapy for long-standing adductor-related groin pain: a randomised controlled clinical trial. Manual Therapy 2011, 16(2):148-154.
91. Willett E., Hebron C., et al. The initial effects of different rates of lumbar mobilisations on pressure pain thresholds in asymptomatic subjects. Manual Therapy 2010, 15(2):173-178.
92. Williams N.H., Wilkinson C., et al. Randomized osteopathic manipulation study (ROMANS): pragmatic trial for spinal pain in primary care. Family Practice 2003, 20(6):662.