Shale gas vs. coal: Policy implications from environmental impact comparisons of shale gas, conventional gas, and coal on air, water, and land in the United States

Energy Policy

Volumn 53, Issue , 2013, Pages 442-453

  Jenner, Steffen ^a   Lamadrid, Alberto J ^b  

^a UNIVERSITY OF TÜBINGEN   (Germany)

^b LEHIGH UNIVERSITY   (United States)

Author keywords

Environmental protection; Lifecycle analysis; Unconventional gas

Indexed keywords

HEALTH AND SAFETY; LAND SURFACE; LIFE CYCLE ANALYSIS; LIFE-CYCLE ASSESSMENTS; METHANE LEAKAGE; POLICY IMPLICATIONS; POLICY REGULATIONS; QUALITY OF LIFE; RENEWABLE ENERGIES; SHALE GAS; TECHNICAL SOLUTIONS; WATER CONSUMPTION; WATER SAFETY;

COAL; ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT; ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION; GASES; LIFE CYCLE; METHANE; PUBLIC HEALTH; PUBLIC POLICY; SHALE; WATER SUPPLY;

GAS HAZARDS;

COAL; ENERGY POLICY; ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT; ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION; GREENHOUSE GAS; LAND SURFACE; LIFE CYCLE ANALYSIS; NATURAL GAS; PUBLIC HEALTH; RENEWABLE RESOURCE; SHALE;

UNITED STATES;

EID: 84871430623     PISSN: 03014215     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.enpol.2012.11.010     Document Type: Article

References (103)

1. 111th Congress, 2009. American Clean Energy and Security Act. 111th Congress of the United States of America. http://www.govtrack.us/congress/bills/111/hr2454.
2. Adams, M.B., Edwards, P.J., Ford, W.M., Johnson, J.B., Schuler, T.M., Thomas-Van Gundy, M., Wood, F., 2011. Effects of Development of a Natural Gas Well and Associated Pipeline on the Natural and Scientific Resources of the Fernow Experimental Forest. Technical Report. General Technical Report NRS-76. US Department of Agriculture, Forest Service, Northern Research Station, Newtown Square, PA.
3. Airlie, C., Carr, M., 2012. UK Fixes CO2 Levy at 4.94 Pounds a Ton for Utilities in 2013 http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2011-03-23/britain-sets-minimum-emission-costs-at-16-pound-a-ton-starting-in-2013.html.
4. Andersen M.S. Europe's experience with carbon-energy taxation. S.A.P.I.EN.S 2010, 3(2):1-11.
5. API, 2010. Water Management Associated with Hydraulic Fracturing. Technical Report. American Petroleum Institute. URL http://www.shalegas.energy.gov/resources/HF2_e1.pdf.
6. Arthur, J.D., Bohm, B., Layne, M., 2008. Hydraulic Fracturing Considerations for Natural Gas Wells of the Marcellus Shale. Technical Report, ALL Consulting URL http://www.dec.ny.gov/docs/materials_minerals_pdf/GWPCMarcellus.pdf.
7. Barker T., Junankar S., Pollitt H., Summerton P. Carbon leakage from unilateral environmental tax reforms in Europe 1995-2005. Energy Policy 2007, 35(12):6281-6292. URL http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0301421507002509.
8. Bernstein, 2010. US Utilities: Coal-Fired Generation is Squeezed in the Vice of EPA Regulation. Who Wins and Who Loses. Technical Report. Sanford C. Bernstein & Co., LLC, New York City, NY.
9. Blasing, T.J., 2011. Recent Greenhouse Gas Concentrations. Technical Report. US Carbon Dioxide Information Analysis Center, Oak Ridge, TN.
10. Burnett, D.B., 2009. Well site produced water management in oil & gas production. In: SPE Water Management ATW. Cooperstown, New York, March.
11. Callaway D., Hiskens I. Achieving controllability of electric loads. Proceedings of the IEEE 2011, 99(January (1)):184-199.
12. Christopherson, S., Rightor, N., 2011. How Should We Think About the Economic Consequences of Shale Gas Drilling? Technical Report. CRP Working Paper Series, Cornell University. URL http://www.greenchoices.cornell.edu/downloads/development/marcellus/Marcellus_SC_NR.pdf.
13. Considine, T.J., Watson, R.W., Considine, N.B., 2011. The Economic Opportunities of Shale Energy Development. Technical Report. The Manhattan Institute.
14. Dannenberg A., Mennel T., Moslener U. What does Europe pay for clean energy? Review of macroeconomic simulation studies. Energy Policy 2008, 36(4):1318-1330. URL http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0301421507005484.
15. Davis L.W. The effect of power plants on local housing values and rents. Review of Economics and Statistics 2010, 93(4):1391-1402.
16. DiGiulio, D.C., Wilkin, R.T., Miller, C., 2011. Investigation of Ground Water Contamination Near Pavillion, Wyoming. Technical Report. US Environmental Protection Agency Office of Research and Development National Risk Management Research Laboratory, 919 Kerr Research Drive Ada, OK 74820.
17. DSIRE, 2011. Database of State Incentives for Renewables and Efficiency. Technical Report. North Carolina Solar Center and the Interstate Renewable Energy Council, Raleigh, NC.
18. EIA, 2011a. Annual Energy Outlook 2011 with Projections to 2035. Technical Report. US Energy Information Administration, Washington, DC.
19. EIA, 2011b. Data. Electricity. Technical Report. US Energy Information Administration, Washington, DC. URL http://www.eia.gov/electricity/data.cfm.
20. EIA, 2011c. Emissions of Greenhouse Gases in the United States 2009. Technical Report. US Energy Information Administration, Washington, DC.
21. EIA, 2011d. Natural Gas. Shale Gas. Technical Report. US Energy Information Administration, Washington, DC. URL http://www.eia.gov/dnav/ng/ng_enr_shalegas_a_EPG0_R5301_Bcf_a.htm.
22. EIA, 2012. Annual Energy Outlook 2012 with Projections to 2035. Technical Report. US Energy Information Administration, Washington, DC.
23. Engelder T. Natural gas. should fracking stop? Counterpoint. No, it's too valuable. Nature 2011, 477(7364):271-275. September, URL http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/477271a.
24. EPA, 2012. Inventory of US Greenhouse Gas Emissions and Sinks 2012. Technical Report. US Environmental Protection Agency, Washington, DC URL http://www.epa.gov/climatechange/ghgemissions/usinventoryreport.html.
25. Epstein P.R., Buonocore J.J., Eckerle K., Hendryx M., Stout III B.M., Heinberg R., Clapp R.W., May B., Reinhart N.L., Ahern M.M., Doshi S.K., Glustrom L. Full cost accounting for the life cycle of coal. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences 2011, 1219(1):73-98. URL http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/j.1749-6632.2010.05890.x.
26. Fitzgerald T. Hydraulic fracturing in context. Key institutional features of an evolving technology. USAEE Dialogue 2011, 19(2).
27. Fountain, H., 2012. Disposal Halted at Well After New Quake in Ohio URL http://www.nytimes.com/2012/01/02/science/earth/youngstown-injection-well-stays-shut-after-earthquake.html.
28. Fthenakis V., Kim H.C. Land use and electricity generation. a life-cycle analysis. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 2009, 13(6-7):1465-1474. URL http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1364032108001354.
29. Gamper-Rabindran S. Did the EPA's voluntary industrial toxics program reduce emissions? A GIS analysis of distributional impacts and by-media analysis of substitution. Journal of Environmental Economics and Management 2006, 52(1):391-410. URL http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0095069606000027.
30. Gamper-Rabindran, S., Finger, S.R., 2011. Does Self-Regulation Reduce Pollution? Responsible Care in the Chemical Industry. Working Paper, Center for Industry Studies.
31. GEEnergy, 2010. New England Wind Integration Study. Technical Report. ISO New England.
32. Graham, J., 2011. Sick of Soot. Technical Report. American Lung Association.
33. Greenstone, M., Looney, A., 2011. A Strategy for America's Energy Future: Illuminating Energy's Full Costs. Technical Report. Brookings Institute, Washington, DC.
34. Grubert, E., Kitasei, S., 2011. How Energy Choices Affect Fresh Water Supplies: A Comparison of US Coal and Natural Gas. Briefing Paper, Worldwatch Institute.
35. Hakim, D., 2011. Cuomo Takes Tough Stance on Nuclear Reactors URL http://www.nytimes.com/2011/06/29/nyregion/cuomo-emphasizes-aim-to-close-indian-point-plant.html.
36. Harrison S.S. Contamination of aquifers by overpressuring the annulus of oil and gas wells. Ground Water 1985, 23(3):317-324. URL 10.1111/j.1745-6584.1985.tb00775.x.
37. Hayhoe K., Kheshgi H.S., Jain A., Wuebbles D. Substitution of natural gas for coal. climatic effects of utility sector emissions. Climatic Change 2002, 54:107-139.
38. Howarth R., Santoro R., Ingraffea A. Methane and the greenhouse-gas footprint of natural gas from shale formations. Climatic Change 2011, 106:679-690. 10.1007/s10584-011-0061-5.
39. Howarth R.W., Ingraffea A., Engelder T. Natural gas. should fracking stop? Point. Yes it's too high risk. Nature 2011, 477(September (7364)):271-275. URL 10.1038/477271a.
40. Husain, T.M., Yeong, L.C., Saxena, A., Cengiz, U., Ketineni, S., Khanzhode, A., Muhamad, H., 2011. Economic Comparison of Multi-lateral Drilling Over Horizontal Drilling for Marcellus Shale Field Development. EME 580: Integrative Design of Energy Mineral Engineering Systems, Pennsylvania State University, Philadelphia, PA.
41. IEA, 2011. World Energy Outlook 2011. Technical Report. International Energy Agency, Paris.
42. Jackson, R.B., Pearson, B.R., Osborn, S., Warner, N.R., Vengosh, A., 2011. Research and Policy Recommendations for Hydraulic Fracturing and Shale Gas Extraction. Working Paper, Nicholas School, Duke University.
43. Jiang M., Griffin W.M., Hendrickson C., Jaramillo P., VanBriesen J., Venkatesh A. Life cycle greenhouse gas emissions of Marcellus shale gas. Environmental Research Letters 2011, 6(3):034014. URL http://stacks.iop.org/1748-9326/6/i=3/a=034014.
44. Johnson, N., 2010. Pennsylvania Energy Impacts Assessment. Technical Report. The Nature Conservancy.
45. Jordaan S.M., Keith D.W., Stelfox B. Quantifying land use of oil sands production. a life cycle perspective. Environmental Research Letters 2009, 4(2):024004. URL http://stacks.iop.org/1748-9326/4/i=2/a=024004.
46. Kargbo D.M., Wilhelm R.G., Campbell D.J. Natural gas plays in the Marcellus shale. challenges and potential opportunities. Environmental Science & Technology 2010, 44(15):5679-5684. URL http://pubs.acs.org/doi/abs/10.1021/es903811p.
47. KEMA, 2010. Assessment of Plug-in Electric Assessment of Plug-in Electric Vehicle Integration with ISO/RTO Systems. Technical Report. KEMA.
48. Kenny, J.F., Barber, N.L., Hutson, S.S., Linsey, K.S., Lovelace, J.K., Maupin, M.A., 2009. Estimated Use of Water in the United States in 2005. US Geological Survey Circular 1344, US Department of the Interior, US Geological Survey, Washington, DC.
49. Kerr R.A. Not under my backyard, thank you. Science 2010, 328(5986):1625. URL http://www.sciencemag.org/content/328/5986/1625.short.
50. Kerr, R.A., August 2011. Federal Committee: Shale Gas Needs More Openness, Better Data. Science Insider.
51. King C.W., Webber M.E. Water intensity of transportation. Environmental Science & Technology 2008, 42(21):7866-7872. URL http://pubs.acs.org/doi/abs/10.1021/es800367m.
52. Kinnaman, T.C., 2011. The economic impact of shale gas extraction: a review of existing studies. Ecological Economics 70(7), 1243-1249, special Section: Ecological Economics and Environmental History URL http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0921800911000590.
53. Kintner-Meyer, M., Schneider, K., Pratt, R., 2007. Impacts Assessment of Plug-in Hybrid Vehicles on Electric Utilities and Regional US Power Grids. Part 1: Technical Analysis. Technical Report. Pacific Northwest National Laboratory.
54. Lauver L.S. Environmental health advocacy. an overview of natural gas drilling in northeast Pennsylvania and implications for pediatric nursing. Journal of Pediatric Nursing 2011, (0). URL http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0882596311005380.
55. Lesieutre B.C., Thomas R.J., Mount T.D. Identification of load pockets and market power in electric power systems. Decision Support Systems 2005, 40(October):517-528. URL 10.1016/j.dss.2004.09.010.
56. Levy J.I., Baxter L.K., Schwartz J. Uncertainty and variability in health-related damages from coal-fired power plants in the united states. Risk Analysis 2009, 29(7):1000-1014. URL 10.1111/j.1539-6924.2009.01227.x.
57. Moniz, E., Jacoby, H., Meggs, A., 2011. The Future of Natural Gas. Technical Report. MIT Energy Initiative (MITEI).
58. Myers, R., 2009. Where does all the salt water coming from and how do we dispose of it? In: SPE Water Management ATW. Cooperstown, New York, March.
59. Nature, 2009. The Shale Revolution. Nature 460, 551-552 URL, July. http://10.1038/460551b.
60. NERC, 2011. Reliability Standards for the Bulk Electric Systems of North America. North American Electric Reliability Corporation, Village Road, Princeton, NJ, 08540, pp. 116-390. URL http://www.nerc.com/files/Reliability_Standards_Complete_Set.pdf.
61. NETL, 2008. Estimating Freshwater Needs to Meet Future Thermoelectric Generation Requirements. Technical Report. US Department of Energy, National Energy Technology Laboratory, Washington, DC.
62. NETL, 2009. Modern Shale Gas Development in the United States. A Primer. Technical Report. US Department of Energy, National Energy Technology Laboratory, Washington, DC.
63. NETL, 2011a. Cost and Performance Baseline for Fossil Energy Plants. Technical Report. US Department of Energy, National Energy Technology Laboratory, Washington, DC.
64. NETL, 2011b. Life Cycle Greenhouse Gas Inventory of Natural Gas Extraction, Delivery and Electricity Production. Technical Report. US Department of Energy, National Energy Technology Laboratory, Washington, DC.
65. NREL, January 2010. Eastern Wind Integration and Transmission Study. Technical Report. EnerNex Corporation, The National Renewable Energy Laboratory, 1617 Cole Boulevard, Golden, CO 80401.
66. NYSERDA, 2009. New York State Energy Plan. Technical Report. New York State Energy Research & Development Authority. URL http://www.nysenergyplan.com/final/Natural_Gas_Assessment.pdf.
67. Oppel, R.A., 2011. Perry Urges Aggressive Energy Production Policy URL http://thecaucus.blogs.nytimes.com/2011/10/14/perry-urges-aggressive-energy-production-policy/?ref=naturalgas.
68. Osborn, S.G., Vengosh, A., Warner, N.R., Jackson, R.B., 2011. Methane contamination of drinking water accompanying gas-well drilling and hydraulic fracturing. In: Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. URL http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3100993/.
69. PANHP, 2011. Pennsylvania Natural Heritage Program URL http://www.naturalheritage.state.pa.us/cnhi/cnhi.htm.
70. Parry I.W.H., Bento A.M. Tax deductions, environmental policy, and the "double dividend" hypothesis. Journal of Environmental Economics and Management 2000, 39(1):67-96. URL 10.1006/jeem.1999.1093.
71. Pearce D. The role of carbon taxes in adjusting to global warming. The Economic Journal 1991, 101(407):938-948. URL http://www.jstor.org/stable/2233865.
72. Pickett, A., 2009. New Solutions Emerging to Treat and Recycle Water Used in Hydraulic Fracs. American Oil and Gas Reporter, March.
73. Powell, A., 2011. Weighing the Risks of Fracking URL http://news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2011/10/weighing-the-risks-of-fracking/.
74. Rahm D. Regulating hydraulic fracturing in shale gas plays: the case of Texas. Energy Policy 2011, 39(5):2974-2981. URL http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0301421511001893.
75. REN21, 2011. Renewable Energy Policy Network for the 21st Century URL http://www.ren21.net/.
76. RGGI, 2012. RGGI Auctions Historical Information. URL http://www.rggi.org/market/co2_auctions/results.
77. Riha, S., Rahm, B.G., 2011. Framework for Assessing Water Resource Impacts from Shale Gas Framework for Assessing Water Resource a Framework for Assessing Water Resource Impacts from Shale Gas Drilling. Technical Report. CRP Working Paper Series, Cornell University. URL http://www.greenchoices.cornell.edu/downloads/development/marcellus/Marcellus_Riha_Rahm.pdf.
78. Rogers H. Shale gas-the unfolding story. Oxford Review of Economic Policy 2011, 27(1):117-143. URL http://oxrep.oxfordjournals.org/content/27/1/117.abstract.
79. Rumbach, A., 2011. Natural Gas Drilling in the Marcellus Shale: Potential Impacts on the Tourism Economy of the Southern Tier. Technical Report. Southern Tier Central Regional Planning and Development Board. URL http://www.stcplanning.org/index.asp?pageId=195.
80. Sanders, N.J., 2011. Toxic Assets: How the Housing Market Responds to Environmental Information Shocks. Working Paper, Stanford.
81. Santoro, R.L., Howarth, R.W., Ingraffea, A., 2011. Indirect Emissions of Carbon Dioxide from Marcellus Shale Gas Development. Technical Report. Agriculture, Energy, & the Environment Program at Cornell University.
82. Shindell D.T., Faluvegi G., Koch D.M., Schmidt G.A., Unger N., Bauer S.E. Improved attribution of climate forcing to emissions. Science 2009, 326(5953):716-718. URL http://www.sciencemag.org/content/326/5953/716.abstract.
83. Siemens, 2011. Efficiency Record of Combined Cycle Power Plant. Technical Report. Siemens. URL http://www.siemens.com/innovation/en/news/2011/efficiency-record-of-combined-cycle-power-plant.htm.
84. Smil V. Energy in Nature and Society. General Energetics of Complex Systems 2008, MIT Press, URL http://books.google.com/books?id=ClAttEBYLHsC.
85. Solomon, S., Qin, D., Manning, M., Chen, Z., Marquis, M., Averyt, K., Tignor, M., Miller, H., 2007. Contribution of Working Group I to the Fourth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. Climate Change 2007. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, MA.
86. Spath, P.L., Mann, M.K., Kerr, D.R., 1999. Life Cycle Assessment of Coal-Fired Power Production. Technical Report. NREL/TP-570-25119, National Renewable Energy Laboratory.
87. Stern, N., 2007. The Economics of Climate Change: The Stern Review. The Stern Review. Cambridge University Press. URL http://books.google.com/books?id=U-VmIrGGZgAC.
88. The Economist, 2011a. The Future of Natural Gas. Coming Soon to a Terminal Near You. URL http://www.economist.com/node/21525381.
89. The Economist, 2011b. Natural Gas and the Environment. So Much Nicer than Coal. URL http://www.economist.com/node/21525380.
90. The Economist, 2011c. Natural Gas. Cleaner, Not Cooler URL http://www.economist.com/node/21525418.
91. UPitt, 2011. Health Effects of Shale Gas Extraction Conference. Technical Report. University of Pittsburgh Schools of the Health Sciences URL http://www.upmc.com/MediaRelations/NewsReleases/2011/Pages/Conference-on-Shale-Gas-Extraction.aspx.
92. Urbina, I., 2011a. Insiders Sound an Alarm Amid a Natural Gas Rush. URL http://www.nytimes.com/2011/06/26/us/26gas.html?_r=1&pagewanted=1&sq=marcellus&st=cse&scp=12.
93. Urbina, I., 2011b. Regulation Lax as Gas Wells' Tainted Water Hits Rivers. URL http://www.nytimes.com/2011/02/27/us/27gas.html?scp=5&sq=natural%20gas&st=cse.
94. Urbina, I., 2011c. S.E.C. Shift Leads to Worries of Overestimation of Reserves. URL http://www.nytimes.com/2011/06/27/us/27gasside.html?_r=3&pagewanted=1.
95. U.S. Department of Energy, 2009. Comments of New York Regional Interconnect, Inc. Technical Report. Department of Energy. URL http://congestion09.anl.gov/documents/09comments/NYRI_Comments_-_DOE_2009_Congestion_Study.pdf.
96. U.S. Department of Energy, 2011a. 90-Day Final Report. Technical Report. Natural Gas Subcommittee of the Secretary of Energy Advisory Board, Washington, DC. URL http://www.shalegas.energy.gov/resources/081811_90_day_report_final.pdf.
97. US Department of Energy, 2011b. Second 90-Day Report Draft. Technical Report. Natural Gas Subcommittee of the Secretary of Energy Advisory Board, Washington, DC. URL http://www.shalegas.energy.gov/resources/111011_90_day_report.pdf.
98. Valentine K., Temple W.G., Zhang K.M. Intelligent electric vehicle charging: rethinking the valley-fill. Journal of Power Sources 2011, 196(24):10717-10726. URL http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0378775311016223.
99. Varaiya P., Wu F., Bialek J. Smart operation of smart grid. risk-limiting dispatch. Proceedings of the IEEE 2011, 99(1):40-57.
100. Wang J., Ryan D., Anthony E.J. Reducing the greenhouse gas footprint of shale gas. Energy Policy 2011, 39(12):8196-8199. URL http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S030142151100797X.
101. Wigley T. Coal to gas. the influence of methane leakage. Climatic Change 2011, 108:601-608. 10.1007/s10584-011-0217-3.
102. Wood, R., Gilbert, P., Sharmina, M., Anderson, K., Footitt, A., Glynn, S., Nicholls, F., 2011. Shale Gas: A Provisional Assessment of Climate Change and Environmental Impacts.
103. Yin H., Powers N. Do state renewable portfolio standards promote in-state renewable generation. Energy Policy 2010, 38(2):1140-1149. URL http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0301421509008283.