Nutrient emissions to water from septic tank systems in rural catchments: Uncertainties and implications for policy

Environmental Science and Policy

Volumn 24, Issue , 2012, Pages 71-82

  Withers, P J A ^a   May, L ^b   Jarvie, H P ^b   Jordan, P ^c   Doody, D ^d   Foy, R H ^d   Bechmann, M ^e   Cooksley, S ^f   Dils, R ^g   Deal, N ^h  

^a BANGOR UNIVERSITY   (United Kingdom)

^b CENTRE FOR ECOLOGY AND HYDROLOGY   (United Kingdom)

^c UNIVERSITY OF ULSTER   (United Kingdom)

^d AGRI FOOD AND BIOSCIENCES INSTITUTE   (United Kingdom)

^e NORWEGIAN INSTITUTE OF BIOECONOMY RESEARCH   (Norway)

^f SCOTTISH CROP RESEARCH INSTITUTE   (United Kingdom)

^g ENVIRONMENT AGENCY   (United Kingdom)

^h Department of Public Health Onsite Water Protection Branch ^*  (United States)

Author keywords

Nutrients; Phosphorus; Policy; Registration; Septic tank systems; Water pollution

Indexed keywords

ARTICLE; CATCHMENT; CONCENTRATION (PARAMETERS); EUTROPHICATION; NUTRIENT; POLICY; PRIORITY JOURNAL; RURAL AREA; SEPTIC TANK; SUMMER; UNCERTAINTY; WATER POLLUTION; WATER QUALITY;

EID: 84870240372     PISSN: 14629011     EISSN: 18736416     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.envsci.2012.07.023     Document Type: Article

References (47)

1. Ahmed W., Neller R., Katouli M. Evidence of septic system failure determined by a bacterial fingerprinting method. Journal of Applied Microbiology 2005, 98:910-920.
2. Anthony, S., Betson, M., Lord, E., Tagg, A., Panzeri, M., Abbott, C., Struve, J., Lilly, A., Dunn, S., DeGroote, J., Towers, W., Lewis, D., 2005. Provision of a screening tool to identify and characterise diffuse pollution pressures: phase II. Final Report WFD19 (230/8050). Sniffer.
3. Arnscheidt J., Jordan P., Li S., McCormick S., McFaul R., McGrogan H.J., Neal M., Sims J.T. Defining the sources of low-flow phosphorus transfers in complex catchments. Science of the Total Environment 2007, 382:1-13.
4. Ash T., Madge J., Murdoch N. Hampshire Avon: Analysis and Modelling of Phosphorus 2006, Report to the Environment Agency, SW Region.
5. Beal C.D., Gardner E.A., Menzies N.W. Process, performance, and pollution potential: a review of septic tank-soil absorption systems. Australian Journal of Soil Research 2005, 43:781-802.
6. Bechmann M., Deelstra J., Stalnacke P., Eggestad H.O., Øygarden L., Pengerud A. Monitoring catchment scale agricultural pollution in Norway: policy instruments, implementation of mitigation methods and trends in nutrient and sediment losses. Environmental Science and Policy 2008, 11:102-114.
7. Bergfur J., Demars B.O., Stutter M.I., Langan S.J., Friberg N. The Tarland Catchment Initiative and its effect on stream water quality and macroinvertebrate indices. Journal of Environmental Quality 2012, 41(2):314-321.
8. Butler D., Payne J. Septic tanks: problems and practice. Building and Environment 1995, 30:419-425.
9. C188/08, 2009. Failure of a Member State to fulfil obligations - directive 75/442/EEC - waste - domestic waste waters discharged through septic tanks in the countryside - waste not covered by other legislation - failure to transpose. Judgment of the European Court of Justice (Second Chamber) of Complaint Brought by Commission of the European Communities against Ireland. (29.10.09). http://curia.europa.eu/jurisp/cgi-bin/gettext.pl%3Flang=en%26num=79908970C19080188%26doc=T%26ouvert=T%26seance=ARRET.
10. Campbell E., Foy R.H. Lough Melvin Catchment Management Plan 2008, Northern Regional Fisheries Board, Ballyshannon Co., Donegal, Available at: http://www.afbini.gov.uk/index/research/hp-work-area-fisheries-aquatics/lough-melvin-cmp.htm.
11. Canter L.W., Knox R.C. Septic Tank System Effects on Groundwater Quality 1985, Lewis Publishers, Boca Raton, USA.
12. Cassidy R., Jordan P. Limitations of instantaneous water quality sampling in surface-water catchments: comparison with near-continuous phosphorus time-series data. Journal of Hydrology 2011, 405:182-193.
13. Centre Européen d'Etudes des Polyphosphates, 2008. SCOPE Newsletter August, 71, 2-5.
14. Cooksley S.L. Dee Catchment Management Plan 2007, Dee Catchment Partnership, Aberdeen, Scotland.
15. Day L. Septic systems as potential pollution sources in the Cannonsville Reservoir Watershed, New York. Journal of Environmental Quality 2004, 33:1989-1996.
16. de Madariaga B. Development of An European Quantitative Eutrophication Risk Assessment of Polyphosphates in Detergents 2007, Spanish National Research Institute INIA, published by the EU Commission.
17. Doody D.G., Higgins A.J., Matthews D.I., Foy R.H., Pilatova K., Duffy O., Watson C.J. Overland flow initiation from a drained drumlin grassland hillslope. Soil Use and Management 2010, 26:286-298.
18. Edwards A.C., Twist H., Codd G.A. Assessing the impact of terrestrially derived phosphorus on flowing water systems. Journal of Environmental Quality 2000, 29(1):117-124.
19. Environment Agency, 2009. Discharge Consents - Who Needs One? [Online]. Available at: (accessed Jan 2011). http://www.environment-agency.gov.uk/business/regulation/32038.aspx.
20. Environment Agency, 2009. Diffuse Pollution Programme Draft Briefing Paper: Tackling Contributions of Pollutants From Small Sewage Discharges.
21. EPA Code of Practice: Wastewater Treatment and Disposal Systems Serving Single Houses 2009, Environmental Protection Agency, Wexford, Ireland.
22. Gill L.W., O'Súilleabháin C., Misstear B.D.R., Johnston P.M. The treatment performance of different subsoils in Ireland receiving on-site wastewater effluent. Journal of Environmental Quality 2007, 36:1843-1855.
23. Gill L.W., O'Súilleabháin C., Misstear B.D.R., Johnston P.M. A comparison of stratified sand filters and percolation trenches for on-site wastewater treatment. ASCE Journal of Environmental Engineering 2009, 135(1):8-16.
24. Gill L.W., O'Luanaigh N., Johnston P.M., Misstear B.D.R., O'Suilleabhain C. Nutrient loading on subsoils from on-site wastewater effluent, comparing septic tank and secondary treatment systems. Water Research 2009, 43:2739-2749.
25. Girvan J.R., Foy R.H. Trophic stability in an Irish mesotrophic lake: Lough Melvin. Aquatic Conservation: Marine and Freshwater Ecosystems 2006, 16:623-636.
26. Heathwaite A.L., Dils R. Characterising phosphorus loss in surface and subsurface hydrological pathways. Science of the Total Environment 2000, 251-252:523-538.
27. Jarvie H.P., Neal C., Withers P.J.A. Sewage-effluent phosphorus: a greater risk to river eutrophication than agricultural phosphorus?. Science of the Total Environment 2006, 360:246-253.
28. Jarvie H.P., Withers P.J.A., Bowes M.J., Palmer-Felgate E.J., Harper D., Wasiak K., Wasiak P., Hodgkinson R.A., Bates A., Stoate C., Neal M., Whickham H.D., Harman S.A., Armstrong L.K. Streamwater phosphorus and nitrogen across a gradient in rural-agricultural land use intensity. Agriculture. Ecosystems and Environment 2010, 135:238-252.
29. Jarvie H.P., Withers P.J.A., Hodgkinson R., Bates A., Neal M., Wickham H.D., Harman S.A., Armstrong L. Influence of rural land use on streamwater nutrients and their ecological significance. Journal of Hydrology 2008, 350:166-186.
30. Johnes, P.J., 1996. Nutrient export modelling, River Bure, Norfolk. Final Report by Aquatic Environments Research Centre, University of Reading to National Rivers Authority, Anglian Region, 92 pp.
31. Johnes P.J., Whitehead P.G., Snook D., Davies S., Wade A., Butterfield D., Hoare D. Effectiveness of Eutrophication Control by Phosphorus Reduction, R&D Draft Project Record to Environment Agency 2003, Aquatic Environments Research Centre, University of Reading, 135 p.
32. Jordan P., Arnscheidt J., McGrogan H.J., McCormick S. Characterising phosphorus transfers in rural catchments using a continuous bank-side analyser. Hydrology and Earth Systems Science 2007, 11:372-381.
33. Kraft, P., Turtumøygard, S., 1997. GIS i kommunalt avløp. Delrapport 2, modellbeskrivelse. Jordforsk Report 94/1997 (in Norwegian).
34. Macintosh K.A., Jordan P., Cassidy R., Arnscheidt J., Ward C. Low flow water quality in rivers; septic tank systems and high-resolution phosphorus signals. Science of the Total Environment 2011, 412-413:58-65.
35. Moelants N., Janssen G., Smets I., van Impe J. Field performance assessment of onsite individual wastewater treatment systems. Water Science and Technology 2008, 58(1):1-6.
36. Palmer-Felgate E.J., Mortimer R.J.G., Krom M.D., Jarvie H.P. Impact of point-source pollution on phosphorus and nitrogen cycling in stream-bed sediments. Environmental Science and Technology 2010, 44:908-914.
37. Patrick S. Septic tanks as sources of phosphorus to Lough Erne, Ireland. Journal of Environmental Management 1988, 26:239-248.
38. Schmid Neset T.S., Bader H.P., Scheidegger R., Lohm U. The flow of phosphorus in food production and consumption - Linköping, Sweden, 1870-2000. Science of the Total Environment 2008, 396:111-120.
39. Sharpley A.N., Kleinman P.J.A., Heathwaite A.L., Gburek W.J., Folmar G.J., Schmidt J.P. Phosphorus loss from an agricultural watershed as a function of storm size. Journal of Environmental Quality 2008, 37:362-368.
40. Smith R.V. Domestic and agricultural contributions to the inputs of phosphorus and nitrogen to Lough Neagh. Water Research 1977, 11:453-459.
41. Smith R.V., Jordan C., Annett J.A. A phosphorus budget for Northern Ireland: inputs to inland and coastal waters. Journal of Hydrology 2005, 304:193-202.
42. USEPA Response to Congress on Use of Decentralized Wastewater Treatment Systems 1997, US EPA Office of Water, Office of Wastewater Management.
43. Water Service Amendment Bill, 2011. Irish Environment Protection Agency, 19 p.
44. Whelan B.R., Titamnis Z.V. Daily chemical variability of domestic septic tank effluent. Water Air and Soil Pollution 1982, 17:131-139.
45. White P.J., Hammond J.P. The source of phosphorus in the waters of Great Britain. Journal of Environmental Quality 2009, 38:13-26.
46. Withers P.J.A., Jarvie H.P. Delivery and cycling of phosphorus in UK rivers: a review. Science of the Total Environment 2008, 400:379-395.
47. Withers P.J.A., Jarvie H.P., Stoate C. Quantifying the impact of septic tank systems on eutrophication risk in rural headwaters. Environment International 2011, 37:644-653.