National identity cards: The impact on the relationship between the police and ethnic minority groups

Policing and Society

Volumn 8, Issue 4, 1998, Pages 401-424

  Beck, Adrian ^a   Broadhurst, Kate ^a  

^a Scarman Centre for the Study of Public Order

Author keywords

Ethnic minority groups; European Union; National identity cards; Policing; Racial discrimination

Indexed keywords

EID: 84869078676     PISSN: 10439463     EISSN: 14772728     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1080/10439463.1998.9964797     Document Type: Article

References (45)

1. Amnesty International. 1995. Information Catalogue: France, London: Amnesty International.
2. Association of Chief Police Officers. 1993. National Identity Card Scheme, London: Association of Chief Police Officers.
3. Beck, A., and Broadhurst, K., 1995. National Identity Cards in the European Union: The British Debate, Crime, Order and Policing Series. 8 Leicester: Centre for the Study of Public Order.
4. Benyon, J., Morris, S., Toye, M., Willis, A., and Beck, A., 1995. Police Forces in the New European Union: A Conspectus, Leicester: Centre for the Study of Public Order.
5. Bradley, A., 1987. Why National Registration Had To Go: The Judges’ Contribution. Public Administration., 65: 209–211.
6. Cherrett, K., 14 October 1994. Benefits in the High Street. Paper presented to the Council of Mortgage Lenders seminar ’A Question of Identity’ 14 October, Birmingham
7. Cohen, P., 1994. Frontiers of Identity: The British and Others, London: Longman.
8. Commission for Racial Equality. 1994. “ Identity Cards: A Preliminary Note ”. In Executive Policy Group, London: CRE.
9. Dix, A., Identity Cards in Germany. Paper presented to the Data Protection Registrar conference Identity Cards: Putting You in the Picture. June21, London.
10. Hadfield, R., Clark, D., and Broughton, F., 1996. “ Identity Cards: The Police Service Response to the Consultation Document ”. In Memorandum of Evidence to the Home Affairs Committee, Session 1995–96. Fourth Report. Identity Cards. Volume II. Minutes of Evidence and Appendices, Volume II, London: HMSO.
11. Hansard (1988a) Column 976. 21 June.
12. Hansard (1988b) Column 1262. 21 July.
13. Hansard (1989) Column 1267–1333. 10 February.
14. Hencke, D., 1995. Minister Acts on Junk Shop ID Card Find. The Guardian., 17 January
15. Home Office. 1995. Identity Cards: A Consultation Document, London: Home Office.
16. Howard, M., 1994. Conservative Party Conference Speech, London: Conservative Party Central Office.
17. House of Commons. 1996. Home Affairs Committee, Session 1995–96. Fourth Report. Identity Cards. Volume I. Report, together with the Proceedings of the Committee, Volume I, London: HMSO.
18. International Federation for Human Rights. September 1995. France. La Lettre Hebdomadaire de la FIDH, September, France: FIDH.
19. Liberty. 1989. Identity Cards and the Threat to Civil Liberties, Civil Liberties Briefing Number 12 London: Liberty.
20. Liberty. 1994. Identity Cards, Report by the National Council for Civil Liberties London: Liberty.
21. Liberty. 1996. “ A Solution Looking for a Problem ”. In Evidence to the Home Affairs Committee. Session 1995–96. Fourth Report. Identity Cards. Volume II. Minutes of Evidence and Appendices, Volume II, London: HMSO.
22. Lutz, H., 1993. “ ‘Migrant Women, Racism and the Dutch Labour Market’ ”. In Racism and Migration in Western Europe, Edited by: Wrench, J., and Solomos, J., 129–142. Oxford: Berg.
23. Lyon, D., 1991. British Identity Cards: The Unpalatable Logic of European Membership. The Political Quarterly., 62(3): 377–385.
24. MacKenzie, F., 1996. Evidence to the Home Affairs Committee. Session 1995–96. Fourth Report. Identity Cards. Volume II. Minutes of Evidence and Appendices, Volume II, London: HMSO.
25. Ministere de l'Interieur. 1992. Loi Sur la Fonction de Police, Royaume Belgique: Ministry for the Interior.
26. Muus, P., 1993. Internationale Migratie naar Europa, Amsterdam: SUA.
27. NACRO. 1997. Policing Local Communities: The Tottenham Experiment, London: NACRO.
28. Norris, P., Kemp, G, Fielding, N., and Fielding, J., 1992. Black and Blue: an analysis of the influence of race and being stopped by the police. British Journal of Sociology., 43(2): 207–224.
29. Rath, J., 1991. Minorisering: De Sociale Constructie van ‘Etnische Minderheden’, Amsterdam: SUA.
30. Small, S., 1993. “ ‘Unravelling Racialised Relations in the United States of America and the United States of Europe’ ”. In Racism and Migration in Western Europe, Edited by: Wrench, J., and Solomos, J., 233–250. Oxford: Berg.
31. Smith, DJ., and Gray, J., 1983. “ ‘Police and People in London ”. In The Police in Action, Vol. V, London: PSI.
32. September 1992. “ Identity Cards ”. In Statewatch Vol. 2, September, London (5)
33. Stevens, P., and Willis, C., 1979. Race, Crime and Arrests, Research and Planning Unit Paper No. 5 London: HMSO.
34. Tuck, M., and Southgate, P., 1981. Ethnic Minorities, Crime and Policing: a survey of the experiences of West Indians and whites, Home Office Research Study No. 70 London: HMSO.
35. Vrij, A., 1993. An Impression Formation Framework on Police Prejudice: An Overview of Experiments on Perceptual Bias in Police-Citizen Interaction. Police Studies., 16(1): 28–32.
36. Vrij, A., and Winkel, F., 1991. Encounters Between the Dutch Police and Minorities: Testing the Non-Cooperation Hypothesis of Different Treatment. Police Studies., 14(1): 17–21.
37. Vrij, A., and Winkel, F., 1992. Crosscultural Police-Citizen Interactions: The influence of Race, Beliefs and Nonverbal Communication on Impression Formation. Journal of Applied Social Psychology., 22(19): 546–1559.
38. Webster, P., and Wood, N., 1994. Cabinet Split Over Plans For National Identity Card. The Times., 12 October
39. Willis, C., 1983. The Use, Effectiveness and Impact of Police Stop and Search Powers, Research and Planning Unit. IS London: Home Office.
40. Wilpert, C., 1993. “ ‘The Ideological and Institutional Foundations of Racism in the Federal Republic of Germany’ ”. In Racism and Migration in Western Europe, Edited by: Wrench, J., and Solomos, J., 67–82. Oxford: Berg.
41. Winkel, F., 1991. Interaction Between the Police and Minority Group Members: Victimisation Through the Incorrect Interpretation of Nonverbal Behaviour. International Review of Victimology., 2(1): 15–27.
42. Wintour, P., 1990. The Taylor Report: PM Disregarded ID Scheme Doubts. The Guardian., 30 January
43. Witte, R., 1996. Racist Violence and the State: A Comparative Analysis of Britain, France and the Netherlands, London: Longman.
44. Wynn Davies, P., 1994. Delegates Press Howard For Action Over ID Cards. The Independent., 14 October
45. Zimmerman, D., 1986. Amendment to the Identity Card Act, Bonn: Ministry for the Interior.