The dilemma of controlling cultural eutrophication of lakes

Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences

Volumn 279, Issue 1746, 2012, Pages 4322-4333

  Schindler, David W ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF ALBERTA   (Canada)

Author keywords

Lake fertilization; Oligotrophication; Phosphorus

Indexed keywords

BIOGEOCHEMISTRY; ECOSYSTEM RESILIENCE; EUTROPHICATION; LAKE ECOSYSTEM; MESOCOSM; NUTRIENT CYCLING; NUTRIENT LIMITATION; OLIGOTROPHIC ENVIRONMENT; PHOSPHORUS;

EID: 84866876144     PISSN: 09628452     EISSN: 14712954     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1098/rspb.2012.1032     Document Type: Review

References (81)

1. Schindler, D. W. & Vallentyne, J. R. 2008 The algal bowl: overfertilization of the world's freshwaters and estuaries. Edmonton, Canada: University of Alberta Press.
2. Schindler, D. W. 1974 Eutrophication and recovery in experimental lakes: implications for lake management. Science 184, 897-899. (doi:10.1126/science.184.4139.897)
3. Schindler, D. W. 1977 Evolution of phosphorus limitation in lakes: natural mechanisms compensate for deficiencies of nitrogen and carbon in eutrophied lakes. Science 195, 260-262. (doi:10.1126/science.195.4275.260)
4. Howarth, R.W. & Marino, R. 2006 Nitrogen as the limiting nutrient for eutrophication in coastal marine ecosystems: evolving views over three decades. Limnol. Oceanogr. 51, 364-376. (doi:10.4319/lo.2006.51.1_part_2.0364)
5. Lewis Jr, W. M. & Wurtsbaugh, W. A. 2008 Control of lacustrine phytoplankton by nutrients: erosion of the phosphorus paradigm. Int. Rev. Hydrobiol. 93, 446-465. (doi:10.1002/iroh.200811065)
6. Conley, D. J., Paerl, H. W., Howarth, R. W., Boesch, D. F., Seitzinger, S. P., Havens, K. E., Lancelot, C. & Likens, G. E. 2009 Controlling eutrophication: nitrogen and phosphorus. Science 323, 1014-1015. (doi:10.1126/science.1167755)
7. Xu, H., Paerl, H. W., Qin, B., Zhu, G. & Gao, G. 2010 Nitrogen and phosphorus inputs control phytoplankton growth in eutrophic Lake Taihu, China. Limnol. Oceanogr. 55, 420-432. (doi:10.4319/lo.2010.55.1.0420)
8. Scott, J. T. & McCarthy, M. J. 2010 Nitrogen fixation may not balance the nitrogen pool in lakes over timescales relevant to eutrophication management. Limnol. Oceanogr. 55, 1265-1270. (doi:10.4319/lo.2010.55.3.1265)
9. Lewis Jr, W. M., Wurtsbaugh, W. A. & Paerl, H. W. 2011 Rationale for control of anthropogenic nitrogen and phosphorus to reduce eutrophication of inland waters. Environ. Sci. Technol. 45, 10300-10305. (doi:10.1021/es202401p)
10. Bryhn, A. C. 2009 Sustainable phosphorus loadings from effective and cost-effective phosphorus management around the Baltic Sea. PLoS ONE 4, e5417. (doi:10. 1371/journal.pone.0005417)
11. Schindler, D. W., Hecky, R. E. & McCullough, G. K. 2012 The rapid eutrophication of Lake Winnipeg: greening under global change. J. Great Lakes Res. 38, 6-13. (doi:10.1016/j.jglr.2012.04.003)
12. Bryhn, A. C. & Håkanson, L. 2009 Coastal eutrophication: whether N and/or P should be abated depends on the dyamic mass balance. Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 106, E3. (doi:10.1073/pnas.0810905106)
13. Schindler, D. W. 1998 Replication versus realism: the need for ecosystem-scale experiments. Ecosystems 1, 323-334. (doi:10.1007/s100219900026)
14. Carpenter, S. R. 1996 Microcosm experiments have limited relevance for community and ecosystem ecology. Ecology 77, 677-680. (doi:10.2307/2265490)
15. Hecky, R. E. & Kilham, P. 1988 Nutrient limitation of phytoplankton in freshwater and marine environments: a review of recent evidence on the effects of enrichment. Limnol. Oceanogr. 33, 796-822. (doi:10.4319/lo.1988.33.4_part_2.0796)
16. Schindler, D. W., Hesslein, R. H. & Turner, M. A. 1987 Exchange of nutrients between sediments and water after 15 years of experimental eutrophication. Can. J. Fish. Aquat. Sci. 44(Suppl. 1), 26-33. (doi:10.1139/f87-277)
17. Schindler, D.W., Hecky, R. E., Findlay, D. L., Stainton, M. P., Parker, B. R., Paterson, M., Beaty, K. G., Lyng, M. & Kasian, S. E. M. 2008 Eutrophication of lakes cannot be controlled by reducing nitrogen input: results of a 37 year whole ecosystem experiment. Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 105, 11254-11258. (doi:10.1073/pnas.0805108105)
18. Paterson, M. J., Schindler, D. W., Hecky, R. E., Findlay, D. L. & Rondeau, K. J. 2011 Comment: Lake 227 shows clearly that controlling inputs of nitrogen will not reduce or prevent eutrophication of lakes. Limnol. Oceanogr. 56, 1545-1547. (doi:10.4319/lo.2011.56.4.1545)
19. Vitousek, P. M., Porder, S., Houlton, B. Z. & Chadwick, O. A. 2010 Terrestrial phosphorus limitation: mechanisms, implications, and nitrogen-phosphorus interactions. Ecol. Appl. 20, 5-15. (doi:10.1890/08-0127.1)
20. Hendzel, L. L., Hecky, R. E. & Findlay, D. L. 1994 Recent changes of nitrogen fixation in Lake 227 in response to reduction of the N: P loading ratio. Can. J. Fish. Aquat. Sci. 51, 2247-2253. (doi:10.1139/f94-228)
21. Elser, J. J. et al. 2007 Global analysis of nitrogen and phosphorus limitation of primary production in freshwater, marine, and terrestrial ecosystems. Ecol. Lett. 10, 1135-1142. (doi:10.1111/j.1461-0248.2007.01113.x)
22. Elser, J. J., Andersen, T., Baron, J. S., Bergstrom, A. K., Jansson, M., Kyle, M., Nydick, K. R., Steger, L. & Hessen, D. O. 2009 Shifts in lake N: P stoichiometry and nutrient limitation driven by atmospheric nitrogen deposition. Science 326, 835-837. (doi:10.1126/science.1176199)
23. Scott, J.T. & McCarthy, M. J. 2011 Response to comment: nitrogen fixation has not offset declines in the Lake 227 nitrogen pool and shows that nitrogen control deservesconsideration in aquatic ecosystems. Limnol. Oceanogr. 56, 1548-1550. (doi:10.4319/lo.2011.56.4.1548)
24. Spivak, A.C., Vanni, M. J. & Mette, E.M. 2011 Moving on up: can results fromsimple aquatic mesocosm experiments be applied across broad spatial scales? Freshwater Biol. 56, 279-291. (doi:10.1111/j.1365-2427.2010.02495.x)
25. Welch, E. B. 2009 Should nitrogen be reduced to manage eutrophication if it is growth limiting? Evidence from Moses Lake. Lake Reservoir Manage. 24, 401-409. (doi:10.1080/07438140903323757)
26. Levine, S. N. & Schindler, D.W. 1992 Modification of the N: P ratio in lakes through in situ processes. Limnol. Oceanogr. 37, 917-935. (doi:10.4319/lo.1992.37.5.0917)
27. Levine, S. N. & Schindler, D. W. 1999 Influence of N: P supply ratios and physicochemical conditions on cyanobacteria and phytoplankton species composition in the Experimental Lakes Area, Canada. Can. J. Fish. Aquat. Sci. 56, 451-466. (doi:10.1139/f98-183)
28. Lund, J. W. G. & Reynolds, C. S. 1982 The development and operation of large limnetic enclosures in Blelham Tarn, English Lake District, and their contribution to phytoplankton ecology. Prog. Phycol. Res. 1, 1-65.
29. Quay, P. D., Hesslein, R. H., Broecker, W. S. & Schindler, D W. 1978 The vertical and horizontal distribution of injections of tritiated water in experimental lakes and limnocorrals. Can. Fish. Mar. Serv. Data Rep. 43, 639.
30. Ibelings, B. W., Portielje, R., Lammens, E. H. R. R., Noordhuis, R., van den Berg, M. S., Joosse, W. & Meijer, M. L. 2007 Resilience of alternative stable states during the recovery of shallow lakes from eutrophication: Lake Veluwe as a case study. Ecosystems 10, 4-16. (doi:10.1007/s10021-006-9009-4)
31. Sommer, U., Sommer, F., Santer, B., Zöllner, E., Jürgens, K., Jamieson, C., Boersma, M. & Gocke, K. 2003 Daphnia versus copepod impact on summer phytoplankton: functional compensation at both trophic levels. Oecologia 135, 639-647.
32. Scheffer, M., Carpenter, S., Foley, J. A., Folke, C. & Walker, B. 2001 Catastrophic shifts in ecosystems. Nature 413, 591-596. (doi:10.1038/35098000)
33. Bayley, S. E., Creed, I. F., Sass, G. Z. & Wong, A. S. 2007 Frequent shifts in trophic states in shallow lakes on the Boreal Plain: alternative 'unstable' states? Limnol. Oceanogr. 52, 2002-2012. (doi:10.4319/lo.2007.52.5.2002)
34. Ahlgren, I. 1977 Role of sediments in the process of recovery of a eutrophicated lake. In Interactions between sediments and freshwater (ed. H. L. Golterman), pp. 372-377. Wageningen, The Netherlands: Pudoc.
35. Jeppesen, E. et al. 2005 Lake responses to reduced nutrient loading: an analysis of contemporary long-term data from 35 case studies. Freshwater Biol. 50, 1747-1771. (doi:10.1111/j.1365-2427.2005.01415.x)
36. Moss, B., Barker, T., Stephen, D., Williams, A. E., Balayla, D., Beklioglu, M. & Carvalho, L. 2005 Consequences of reduced nutrient loading on a lake system in a lowland catchment: deviations from the norm? Freshwater Biol. 50, 1687-1705. (doi:10.1111/j.1365-2427.2005.01416.x)
37. Köhler, J., Hilt, S., Adrian, R., Nicklisch, A., Kozerski, H. P. & Walz, N. 2005 Long-term response of a shallow, moderately flushed lake to reduced external phosphorus and nitrogen loading. Freshwater Biol. 50, 1639-1650. (doi:10.1111/j.1365-2427.2005.01430.x)
38. Carpenter, S. R. 2005 Eutrophication of aquatic ecosystems: bistability and soil phosphorus. Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 102, 10002-10005. (doi:10.1073/pnas.0503959102)
39. Joosse, P. J. & Baker, C. B. 2011 Context for re-evaluating agricultural source phosphorus loadings to the Great Lakes. Can. J. Soil Sci. 91, 317-327. (doi:10.4141/cjss10005)
40. Bunting, L., Leavitt, P. R., Gibson, C. E., McGee, E. J. & Hall, V. A. 2007 Degradation of water quality in Lough Neagh, Northern Ireland, by diffuse nitrogen flux from a phosphorus-rich catchment. Limnol. Oceanogr. 52, 354-369. (doi:10.4319/lo.2007.52.1.0354)
41. Havens, K. E., James, R. T., East, T. L. & Smith, V. H. 2003 N: P ratios, light limitation, and cyanobacterial dominance in a subtropical lake impacted by non-point source nutrient pollution. Environ. Pollut. 122, 379-390. (doi:10.1016/S0269-7491(02)00304-4)
42. Teubner, K., Feyerabend, R., Henning, M., Nicklisch, A., Woitke, P. & Kohl, J.-G. 1999 Alternative blooming of Aphanizomenon flos-aquae or Planktothrix agardhii induced by the timing of the critical nitrogen: phosphorus ratio in hypertrophic riverine lakes. Arch. Hydrobiol. Special Issues Adv. Limnol. 54, 325-344.
43. Chan, Y. K. & Campbell, N. E. R. 1980 Denitrification in Lake 227 during summer stratification. Can. J. Fish. Aquat. Sci. 37, 506-512. (doi:10.1139/f80-065)
44. Mugidde, R., Hecky, R. E., Hendzel, L. L. & Taylor, W. D. 2003 Pelagic nitrogen fixation in Lake Victoria (East Africa). J. Great Lakes Res. 29, 76-88. (doi:10.1016/S0380-1330(03)70540-1)
45. Kenney, B. C. 1982 Beware of spurious self-correlations. Water Resour. Res. 18, 1041-1048. (doi:10.1029/WR018i004p01041)
46. Fee, E. J. 1979 A relation between lake morphometry and primary productivity and its use in interpreting wholelake eutrophication experiments. Limnol. Oceanogr. 24, 410-416. (doi:10.4319/lo.1979.24.3.0401)
47. Findlay, D. L. & Kasian, S. E. M. 1987 Phytoplankton community responses to nutrient addition in Lake 226, Experimental Lakes Area, northwestern Ontario. Can. J. Fish. Aquat. Sci. 44, 35-46. (doi:10.1139/f87-278)
48. Shearer, J. A., Fee, E. J., DeBruyn, E. R. & DeClercq, D. R. 1987 Phytoplankton primary production and light attenuation responses to the experimental acidification of a small Canadian shield lake. Can. J. Fish. Aquat. Sci. 44, 83-90. (doi:10.1139/f87-283)
49. Rudd, J. W. M., Kelly, C. A., Schindler, D. W. & Turner, M. A. 1990 A comparison of the acidification efficiencies of nitric and sulfuric acids by two whole-lake addition experiments. Limnol. Oceanogr. 35, 663-679. (doi:10.4319/lo.1990.35.3.0663)
50. Fee, E. J. & Hecky, R. E. 1992 Introduction to the Northwest Ontario Lake Size Series(NOLSS). Can. J. Fish. Aquat. Sci. 49, 2434-2444. (doi:10.1139/f92-269)
51. Bergmann, M. A. & Welch, H. E. 1990 Nitrogen fixation by epilithic periphyton in small arctic lakes in response to experimental nitrogen and phosphorus fertilization. Can. J. Fish. Aquat. Sci. 47, 1545-1550. (doi:10.1139/f90-174)
52. Welch, H. E., Legault, J. A. & Kling, H. J. 1989 Phytoplankton, nutrients, and primary production at Saqvaqjuac, NWT. Can. J. Fish. Aquat. Sci. 46, 90-107. (doi:10.1139/f89-013)
53. Holmgren, S. K. 1984 Experimental lake fertilization in the Kuokkel area, northern Sweden. Phytoplankton biomass and algal composition in natural and fertilized subarctic lakes. Int. Rev. Ges. Hydrobiol. 69, 781-817. (doi:10.1002/iroh.19840690603)
54. Jansson, M. 1978 Experimental lake fertilization in the Kuokkel area, northern Sweden: budget calculations and the fate of nutrients. Verh. Int. Verein. Limnol. 20, 857-862.
55. Smith, V. H., Rigler, F. H., Choulik, O., Diamond, M. M., Griesbach, S. & Skraba, D. 1984 Effects of phosphorus fertilizer on phytoplankton biomass and phosphorus retention in subarctic Quebec lakes. Verh. Int. Verein. Limnol. 22, 376-382.
56. Higgins, S., Hecky, R. E. & Taylor, W. D. 2001 Epilithic nitrogen fixation in the rocky littoral zones of Lake Malawi, Africa. Limnol. Oceanogr. 46, 976-982. (doi:10.4319/lo.2001.46.4.0976)
57. Gondwe, M., Guildford, S. J. & Hecky, R. E. 2008 Planktonic nitrogen fixation in Lake Malawi(East Africa). Hydrobiologia 596, 251-267. (doi:10.1007/s10750-007-9101-6)
58. Fee, E. J. 1978 Studies of hypolimnion chlorophyll peaks in the Experimental Lakes Area, Northwestern Ontario. Technical report 754. Winnipeg, Canada: Fisheries and Marine Service, Department of Fisheries and the Environment.
59. Kelly, C. A., Rudd, J. W. M. & Schindler, D. W. 1990 Acidification by nitric acid-future considerations. Water Air Soil Pollut. 50, 49-61.
60. Schindler, D. W., Armstrong, F. A. J., Holmgren, S. K. & Brunskill, G. J. 1971 Eutrophication of Lake 227, Experimental Lakes Area, northwestern Ontario, by addition of phosphate and nitrate. J. Fish. Res. Board Can. 28, 1763-1782. (doi:10.1139/f71-261)
61. Carpenter, S. R., Kitchell, J. F., Cottingham, K. L., Schindler, D. E., Christensen, D. L., Post, D. M. & Voichick, N. 1996 Chlorophyll variability, nutrient input, and grazing: evidence from whole-lake experiments. Ecology 77, 725-735. (doi:10.2307/2265497)
62. Levine, S. N. & Schindler, D. W. 1989 Phosphorus, nitrogen and carbon dynamics of Lake 303 during recovery from eutrophication. Can. J. Fish. Aquat. Sci. 46, 2-10. (doi:10.1139/f89-001)
63. O'Brien, W. J., Barfield, M., Bettez, N., Hershey, A. E., Hobbie, J. E., Kipphut, G., Kling, G. & Miller, M. C. 2005 Long-term response and recovery to nutrient addition of a partitioned arctic lake. Freshwater Biol. 50, 731-741. (doi:10.1111/j.1365-2427.2005.01354.x)
64. Stich, H. B. & Brinker, A. 2005 Oligotrophication outweighs effects of global warming in a large, deep, stratified lake ecosystem. Glob. Change Biol. 16, 877-888. (doi:10.1111/j.1365-2486.2009.02005.x)
65. Salmaso, N., Morabito, G., Garibaldi, L. & Mosello, R. 2007 Trophic development of the deep lakes south of the Alps: a comparative analysis. Arch.Hydrobiol. 170, 177-196.
66. Gerdeaux, D., Anneville, O. & Hefti, D. 2006 Fishery changes during re-oligotrophication in 11 peri-alpine Swiss and French lakes over the past 30 years. Acta Oecol. 30, 161-167. (doi:10.1016/j.actao.2006.02.007)
67. Willén, E. 2001 Phytoplankton and water quality characterization: experiences from the Swedish large lakes Mälaren, Hjälmaren, Vättern and Vänern. Ambio 30, 529-537.
68. Edmondson, W. T. & Lehman, J. T. 1981 The effect of changes in the nutrient income on the condition of Lake Washington. Limnol. Oceanogr. 26, 1-29. (doi:10.4319/lo.1981.26.1.0001)
69. Jeppesen, E., Meerhoff, M., Jacobsen, B. A., Hansen, R. S., Søndergaard, M., Jensen, J. P., Lauridsen, T. L., Mazzeo, N. & Branco, C.W. C. 2007 Restoration of shallow lakes by nutrient control and biomanipulation: the successful strategy varies with lake size and climate. Hydrobiologia 581, 269-285. (doi:10.1007/s10750-006-0507-3)
70. Barica, J. 1975 Geochemistry and nutrient regime of saline eutrophic lakes in the Erickson-Elphinstone district of southwestern Manitoba. Fish. Mar. Serv. Can. Tech. Rep. 511, 82.
71. Barica, J., Kling, H. & Gibson, J. 1980 Experimental manipulation of algal bloom composition by nitrogen addition. Can. J. Fish. Aquat. Sci. 37, 1175-1183. (doi:10.1139/f80-150)
72. Brownlee, B. G. & Murphy, T. P. 1983 Nitrogen fixation and phosphorus turnover in a hypertrophic prairie lake. Can. J. Fish. Aquat. Sci. 40, 1853-1860. (doi:10.1139/f83-215)
73. Leonardson, L. & Ripl, W. 1980 Control of undesirable algae and induction of algal successions in hypertrophic lake ecosystems. In Hypertrophic ecosystems developments in hydrobiology, vol. 2 (eds J. Barica & L. R. Mur), pp. 57-65. The Hague, The Netherlands: Junk.
74. Effler, A. J. P., Gelda, R. K., Effler, S. W., Matthews, D. A., Field, S. D. & Hassett, J. M. 2008 Decreases in primary production in Onondaga Lake from reductions in point source inputs of phosphorus. Arch. Hydrobiol. 172, 239-253.
75. Effler, S. W., O'Donnell, S. M., Prestigiacomo, A. R., O'Donnell, D. M., Gelda, R. K. & Matthews, D. A. 2010 The effect of municipal wastewater effluent on nitrogen levels in Onondaga Lake, a 36-year record. Water Environ. Res. 82, 3-19. (doi:10.2175/106143009X407384)
76. Lathrop, R. C. 1990 Response of Lake Mendota (Wisconsin, USA) to decreased phosphorus loadings and the effect on downstream lakes. Verh. Internat. Verein. Limnol. 24, 457-463.
77. Vollenweider, R. A. 1975 Input-output models with special reference to the phosphorus loading concept in limnology. Schweiz. Z. Hydrol. 27, 53-84. (doi:10.1007/BF02505178)
78. Vollenweider, R. A. 1976 Advances in defining critical loading levels for phosphorus in lake eutrophication. Mem. Ist. Ital. Idrobiol. 33, 53-83.
79. McCullough, G. K., Page, S., Hesslein, R. H., Stainton, M. P., Kling, H. J., Salki, A. & Barger, D. G. 2012 Hydrological forcing of a recent trophic surge in Lake Winnipeg. J. Great Lakes Res. 38, 95-105. (doi:10.1016/j.jglr.2011.12.012)
80. Brattberg, G. 1986 Decreased phosphorus loading changes phytoplankton composition and biomass in the Stockholm archipelago. Vatten 42, 141-153.
81. Boesch, D., Hecky, R., O'Melia, C., Schindler, D. W. & Seitzinger, S. 2006 Eutrophication of Swedish Seas. Final Report. Stockholm, Sweden: Swedish Environmental Protection Agency.