Research on injury compensation and health outcomes: Ignoring the problem of reverse causality led to a biased conclusion

Journal of Clinical Epidemiology

Volumn 65, Issue 11, 2012, Pages 1219-1226

  Spearing, Natalie M ^a   Connelly, Luke B ^a,b   Nghiem, Hong S ^b   Pobereskin, Louis ^c  

^a UNIVERSITY OF QUEENSLAND   (Australia)

^b UNIVERSITY OF QUEENSLAND   (Australia)

^c DERRIFORD HOSPITAL   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

Association; Compensation; Observational studies; Reverse causality; Simultaneity; Whiplash

Indexed keywords

ADULT; ARTICLE; COMPENSATION; CONTROLLED STUDY; DECISION MAKING; FEMALE; HEADACHE; HEALTH CARE POLICY; HEALTH INSURANCE; HEALTH STATUS; HUMAN; LONGITUDINAL STUDY; MAJOR CLINICAL STUDY; MALE; MEDICAL RESEARCH; NECK PAIN; OBSERVATIONAL STUDY; OUTCOME ASSESSMENT; PEDAGOGICS; PRIORITY JOURNAL; REGRESSION ANALYSIS; SCIENTIST; TRAFFIC ACCIDENT; WHIPLASH INJURY;

ACCIDENTS, TRAFFIC; ADULT; BIAS (EPIDEMIOLOGY); CAUSALITY; COMPENSATION AND REDRESS; DATA INTERPRETATION, STATISTICAL; ENGLAND; FEMALE; HEALTH STATUS; HUMANS; LONGITUDINAL STUDIES; MALE; NECK PAIN; OUTCOME ASSESSMENT (HEALTH CARE); REGRESSION ANALYSIS; RESEARCH DESIGN; WHIPLASH INJURIES;

EID: 84866846770     PISSN: 08954356     EISSN: 18785921     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.jclinepi.2012.05.012     Document Type: Article

References (47)

1. L. Carroll, L.B. Connelly, N.M. Spearing, P. Cote, J. Buitenhuis, and J. Kenardy Complexities in understanding the role of compensation-related factors on recovery from whiplash-associated disorders. Discussion Paper 3 Spine 36 25 Suppl 2011 S316 S321
2. I. Harris, J. Mulford, M. Solomon, J. van Gelder, and J. Young Association between compensation status and outcome after surgery: a meta-analysis JAMA 293 2005 1644 1652
3. P. Cameron, and B. Gabbe The effect of compensation claims on outcomes after injury (Editorial) Injury 40 2009 905 906
4. S.M. Littleton, I.D. Cameron, S.J. Poustie, D.C. Hughes, B.J. Robinson, and T. Neeman The association of compensation on longer term health status for people with musculoskeletal injuries following road traffic crashes: emergency department inception cohort study Injury 42 2011 927 933
5. NSW Parliament Legislative Council. General Purpose Standing Committee No. 1: Inquiry into Personal Injury Compensation Law. Report 28 2005 NSW Parliament NSW Available at www.nsw.gov.au/ Accessed June 9, 2008
6. ACT Parliament. Road Transport (Third Party Insurance) Amendment Bill 2011. Presentation Speech. Available at www.hansard.act.gov.au/hansard/2011/ pdfs/20110217.pdf. Accessed August 20, 2011.
7. D. Cassidy, L. Carroll, P. Côté, M. Lemstra, A. Berglund, and A. Nygren Effect of eliminating compensation for pain and suffering on the outcome of insurance claims for whiplash injury N Eng J Med 342 2000 1179 1186
8. H. Schrader, D. Obelieniene, G. Bovim, D. Surkiene, D. Mickeviciene, and I. Miseviciene Natural evolution of late whiplash syndrome outside the medicolegal context Lancet 347 1996 1207 1211
9. C. O'Donnell Motor accident and workers' compensation insurance design for high quality health outcomes and cost containment Disabil Rehabil 22 2000 88 96
10. M. Sterling, J. Hendrikz, and J. Kenardy Compensation claim lodgement and health outcome developmental trajectories following whiplash injury: a prospective study Pain 150 2010 22 28
11. R.T. Gun, O.L. Osti, A. O'Riordan, F. Mpelasoka, C.G. Eckerwall, and J.F. Smyth Risk factors for prolonged disability after whiplash injury: a prospective study Spine 30 2005 386 391
12. C.C. Joslin, S.N. Khan, and G.C. Bannister Long-term disability after neck injury. A comparative study J Bone Joint Surg Br 86 2004 1032 1034
13. I.A. Harris, J.M. Young, B.B. Jalaludin, and M.J. Solomon The effect of compensation on general health in patients sustaining fractures in motor vehicle trauma J Orthop Trauma 22 2008 216 220
14. B.J. Gabbe, P.A. Cameron, O.D. Williamson, E.R. Edwards, S.E. Graves, and M.D. Richardson The relationship between compensable status and long-term patient outcomes following orthopaedic trauma Med J Aust 187 2007 14 27
15. M.L. O'Donnell, M.C. Creamer, A.C. McFarlane, D. Silove, and R.A. Bryant Does access to compensation have an impact on recovery outcomes after injury? Med J Aust 192 2010 328 333
16. J.A. Dufton, J.A. Kopec, H. Wong, J.D. Cassidy, J. Quon, and G. McIntosh Prognostic factors associated with minimal improvement following acute whiplash-associated disorders Spine 31 2006 E759 E765
17. R. Mayou, and B. Bryant Psychiatry of whiplash neck injury Br J Psychiatry 180 2002 441 448
18. N.M. Spearing, and L.B. Connelly Whiplash and "the compensation hypothesis" Spine 36 25 Suppl. 2011 S303 S308
19. K. Atherton, N.J. Wiles, F.E. Lecky, S.J. Hawes, A.J. Silman, and G.J. Macfarlane Predictors of persistent neck pain after whiplash injury Emerg Med J 23 2006 195 201
20. E.J. Hendriks, G.G. Scholten-Peeters, D.A. van der Windt, C.W. Neeleman-van der Steen, R.A. Oostendorp, and A.P. Verhagen Prognostic factors for poor recovery in acute whiplash patients Pain 114 2005 408 416
21. J. Stanhope The case for compulsory third party insurance reform in the Australian Capital Territory Canberra LR 10 2011 240 250
22. J.M. Wooldridge Introductory econometrics: a modern approach 4th ed. 2009 South-Western Cengage Learning Mason, OH
23. R.S. Pindyck, and D.L. Rubinfeld Econometric models and economic forecasts 4th ed. 1999 McGraw-Hill Singapore
24. F.I. Gunasekara, K. Carter, and T. Blakely Glossary for econometrics and epidemiology J Epidemiol Community Health 62 2008 858 861
25. L.H. Pobereskin Whiplash following rear end collisions: a prospective cohort study J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 76 2005 1146 1151
26. L. Carroll, L. Holm, S. Hogg-Johnson, P. Cote, J.D. Cassidy, and S. Haldeman Course and prognostic factors for neck pain in whiplash-associated disorders (WAD): results of the Bone and Joint Decade 2000-2010 Task Force on Neck Pain and Its Associated Disorders Spine 33 4 Suppl. 2008 S83 S92
27. M.P. Jensen, P. Karoly, and S. Braver The measurement of clinical pain intensity: a comparison of six methods Pain 27 1986 117 126
28. D.M. Walton, J. Pretty, J.C. MacDermid, and R.W. Teasell Risk factors for persistent problems following whiplash injury: results of a systematic review and meta-analysis J Orthop Sports Phys Ther 39 2009 334 350
29. S.J. Kamper, T.J. Rebbeck, C.G. Maher, J.H. McAuley, and M. Sterling Course and prognostic factors of whiplash: a systematic review and meta-analysis Pain 138 2008 617 629
30. F.C. Dunbar, and F. Sabry The propensity to sue: why do people seek legal actions? Bus Econ 42 2007 31 42
31. J. Biddle, and K. Roberts Claiming behaviour in workers' compensation J Risk Insur 70 2003 759 780
32. H. Kritzer, W. Bogart, and N. Vidmar The aftermath of injury: cultural factors in compensation seeking in Canada and the United States Law Soc Rev 25 1991 499 544
33. A.C. Cameron, and P.K. Trivedi Microeconometrics using Stata 2009 Stata Press Texas
34. D. Roodman Estimating fully observed recursive mixed-process models with cmp. CGD Working Paper 168 2009 Center for Global Development Washington, DC Available at www.cgdev.org/content/publications/ Accessed April 4, 2011
35. ® statistics/data analysis 2009 Statacorp LP College Station, TX
36. I. Kawachi, N. Adler, and W. Dow Money, schooling, and health: mechanisms and causal evidence Ann NY Acad Sci 1186 2010 56 68
37. A. Nichols Causal inference with observational data Stata J 7 2007 507 541
38. M.F. Gargan, and G.C. Bannister The rate of recovery following whiplash injury Eur Spine J 3 1994 162 164
39. S.H. Norris, and I. Watt The prognosis of neck injuries resulting from rear-end vehicle collisions J Bone Joint Surg Br 65 1983 608 611
40. J. Elliott, M. Sterling, J.T. Noteboom, J. Treleaven, G. Galloway, and G. Jull The clinical presentation of chronic whiplash and the relationship to findings of MRI fatty infiltrates in the cervical extensor musculature: a preliminary investigation Eur Spine J 18 2009 1371 1378
41. H. Levy, and D. Meltzer The impact of health insurance on health Annu Rev Pub Health 29 2008 399 409
42. J. Hadley Sicker and poorer - the consequences of being uninsured: a review of the research on the relationship between health insurance, medical care use, health, work, and income Med Care Res Rev 60 2003 3S 75S
43. J.M. McWilliams Health consequences of uninsurance among adults in the United States: recent evidence and implications Milbank Q 87 2009 443 494
44. J.D. Freeman, S. Kadiyala, J. Bell, and D.P. Martin The causal effect of health insurance on utilization and outcomes in adults: a systematic review of US studies Med Care 46 2008 1023 1032
45. F. Gunasekara, K. Carter, and T. Blakely Change in income and change in self-rated health: systematic review of studies using repeated measures to control for confounding bias Soc Sci Med 72 2011 193 201
46. J. Arendt Does education cause better health? A panel data analysis using school reforms for identification Econ Educ Rev 24 2005 149 160
47. N.M. Spearing, L.B. Connelly, S. Gargett, and M. Sterling Does injury compensation lead to worse health after whiplash? A systematic review Pain 153 2012 1274 1282