Dispelling the myth of the naive investor during the British Railway Mania, 1845-1846

Business History Review

Volumn 86, Issue 1, 2012, Pages 3-41

  Campbell, Gareth ^a   Turner, John D ^a  

^a QUEEN'S UNIVERSITY BELFAST   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

EID: 84866444371     PISSN: 00076805     EISSN: 2044768X     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1017/S0007680512000025     Document Type: Review

References (81)

1. Michael J. Brennan, "How Did It Happen?" Economic Notes 33 (2004): 3
2. Charles P. Kindleberger, Manias, Panics, and Crashes: A History of Financial Crises (New York, 1996, 3rd ed.), 25-26
3. Kindleberger, A Financial History of Western Europe (London, 1984), 272
4. Charles Mackay, Memoirs of Extraordinary Popular Delusions and the Madness of Crowds (London, 1856, 3rd ed.), 14, 45, 89.
5. Notable exceptions include Robin Greenwood and Stefan Nagel, "Inexperienced Investors and Bubbles, " Journal of Financial Economics 93 (2009): 239-58
6. Ann M. Carlos and Larry Neal, "The Micro-Foundations of the Early London Capital Market: Bank of England Shareholders during and after the South Sea Bubble, " Economic History Review 59 (2006): 498-538
7. Peter Temin and Hans-Joachim Voth, "Riding the South Sea Bubble, " American Economic Review 94 (2004): 1654-68.
8. Mackay, Memoirs of Extraordinary Popular Delusions, 84
9. Anon., "The Beauty of Bubbles: Booms and Busts, " Economist 389 (2008): 115
10. Rande W. Kostal, Law and English Railway Capitalism (Oxford, 1994), 29.
11. Ranald C. Michie, "Gamblers, Fools, Victims, or Wizards? The British Investor in the Public Mind, 1850-1930, " in Men, Women, and Money: Perspectives on Gender, Wealth, and Investment 1850-1930, ed. David R. Green et al. [Oxford, 2011], 156-83
12. James Taylor, "Business in Pictures: Representations of Railway Enterprise in the Satirical Press in Britain, 1845-1870, " Past and Present 189 (2005): 118.
13. Ranald C. Michie, Money, Mania and Markets: Investment, Company Formation and the Stock Exchange in Nineteenth-Century Scotland (Edinburgh, 1981), 96
14. S. A. Broadbridge, "The Sources of Railway Share Capital, " in Railways in the Victorian Economy: Studies in Finance and Economic Growth, ed. M. C. Reed (New York, 1968), 204
15. Ranald C. Michie, Guilty Money: The City of London in Victorian and Edwardian Culture, 1815-1914 (London, 2009), 23-29
16. Broadbridge, "Sources of Railway Share Capital, " 204-6
17. Kindleberger, Mania, Panics and Crashes, 25
18. Anon., "History of Bank of England, " 512
19. Banker's Magazine 12 (1863): 510-11
20. Times, 15 July 1845, 5
21. John Francis, A History of the English Railway: Its Social Relations and Revelations, 1820-1845, 2 vols. (1851), 2: 195
22. Joseph Lee, "The Provision of Capital for Early Irish Railways, 1830-53, " Irish Historical Studies 16 (1968): 39
23. Herbert Spencer, Railway Morals and Railway Policy (London, 1855), 14.
24. Anon., "History of Bank of England, " 510-11
25. David M. Evans, The Commercial Crisis, 1847-1848 (London, 1849, 2nd ed.), 52.
26. Earl A. Thompson and Charles A. Hickson, "Predicting Bubbles, " Global Business and Economics Review 8 (2004): 217-46
27. Rob A. Bryer, "Accounting for the 'Railway M ania' of 1845-A Great Railway Swindle? " Accounting, Organisations and Society 16 (1991): 439-86.
28. Michie, "Gamblers, Fools, Victims or Wizards? ";
29. Josephine Maltby et al., "The Evidence for 'Democratization' of Share Ownership in Great Britain in the Early Twentieth Century, " in Men, Women, and Money: Perspectives on Gender, Wealth, and Investment 1850-1930, ed. David R. Green et al. (Oxford, 2011), 184-206
30. Janette Rutterford and Josephine Maltby, " 'The Widow, the Clergyman and the Reckless': Women Investors in England, 1830-1914, " Feminist Economics 12 (2006): 111-38.
31. Studies of bank investors in the nineteenth century include B. L. Anderson and Philip L. Cottrell, "Another Victorian Capital Market: A Study of Banking and Bank Investors on Mer-seyside, " Economic History Review 28 (1975): 600-15
32. Lucy Newton and Philip L. Cottrell, "Female Investors in the First English and Welsh Commercial Joint-Stock Banks, " Accounting, Business and Financial History 16 (2006): 315-40
33. John D. Turner, "Wider Share Ownership? Investors in English Bank Shares, 1826-1900, " Economic History Review 62 (2009): 167-92
34. Graeme G. Acheson and John D. Turner, "Investor Behaviour in a Nascent Capital Market: Scottish Bank Shareholders in the Nineteenth Century, " Economic History Review 64 (2011): 188-213.
35. "Sources of Railway Share Capital "; S. A. Broadbridge, Studies in Railway Expansion and the Capital Market in England, 1825-1873 (London, 1970)
36. Harold Pollins, "The Finances of the Liverpool and Manchester Railway, " Economic History Review 5 (1952): 90-97
37. M. C. Reed, "Railways and the Growth of the Capital Market, " in Railways in the Victorian Economy: Studies in Finance and Economic Growth, ed. M. C. Reed (New York, 1968)
38. M. C. Reed, Investment in Railways in Britain, 1820-1844: A Study in the Development of the Capital Market (Oxford, 1975)
39. Lee, "Provision of Capital ";
40. Wray Vamplew, "Sources of Scottish Railway Share Capital before 1860, " Scottish Journal of Political Economy 17 (1970): 425-40.
41. Harold Pollins, "The Marketing of Railway Shares in the First Half of the Nineteenth Century, " Economic History Review 7 (1954): 230-39
42. Pollins, "Marketing of Railway Shares, " 238.
43. Anon., The Railway Speculator's Memorandum Book, Ledger, and General Guide to Secure Share Dealing (London, 1845), 7
44. Reed, Investment in Railways, 89.
45. Anon., A Short and Sure Guide to Railway Speculation (London, 1845), 10.
46. Kostal, Law and English Railway Capitalism, 76-77.
47. Broadbridge, "Sources of Railway Share Capital, " 185
48. Broadbridge, "Sources of Railway Share Capital, " 185.
49. Anon., The Railway Investment Guide: How to Make Money in Railway Shares: A Series of Hints and Advice to Parties Speculating (London, 1845), 13.
50. British Parliamentary Papers, First and Second Reports from the S.C. of the House of Lords on Audit of Railway Accounts (London, 1849), QQ. 2624-25.
51. British Parliamentary Papers, Return of Railway Subscribers (London, 1845), 1.
52. British Parliamentary Papers, Return of Railway Subscribers (London, 1846).
53. Francis, A History of the English Railway, vol. 2, 193-94
54. British Parliamentary Papers, Report from the S.C. on the London and York Railway Subscription List (London, 1845), 136-37.
55. British Parliamentary Papers, Report from the S.C. on the London and York Railway Subscription List, 136-38.
56. Broadbridge, "Sources of Railway Share Capital, " 193.
57. Pollins, "Marketing of Railway Shares, " 238.
58. The Railway Shareholder's Pocket-book and Almanac (London, 1846), 56.
59. Broadbridge, "Sources of Railway Share Capital, " 194.
60. Anon., The Railway Investment Guide, 9.
61. Fischer Black, "Noise, " Journal of Finance 41 (1986): 529-43.
62. Reed, Investment in Railways, 110.
63. Spencer, Railway Morals, 16-20.
64. Brennan, "How Did It Happen? " 3.
65. Arthur D. Gayer, W. W. Rostow, and Anna Jacobson Schwartz, The Growth and Fluctuation of the British Economy (Oxford, 1953), 380, 410
66. Reed, "Railways and the Growth of the Capital Market, " 182.
67. Authors' calculations from Course of the Exchange, 31 Dec. 1844. There were over 43,000 shareholders in these banks. Authors' calculations based on data in The Banking Almanac (1845), 106-21.
68. Sheffi eld and Hallamshire Share Registers (598/1, 598/2), HSBC Archives, London.
69. Lucy A. Newton, "Regional Bank-Industry Relations during the Mid-Nineteenth Century: Links between Bankers and Manufacturing in Sheffi eld, c.1850 to c.1885, " Business History 38 (1996): 64-83.
70. Reed, Investment in Railways, 146-92
71. Broadbridge, "Sources of Railway Share Capital, " 186-87.
72. Broadbridge, "Sources of Railway Share Capital, " 193
73. Bryer, "Accounting for the 'Railway Mania,' " 483.
74. Broadbridge, "Sources of Railway Share Capital, " 193.
75. Lubos Pástor and Pietro Veronesi, "Technological Revolutions and Stock Prices, " American Economic Review 99 (2009): 1451-83
76. Larry Neal, "The Financial Crisis of 1825 and the Restructuring of the British Financial System, " Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis Review (May/June 1998): 53-76
77. Eugene N. White, "The Stock Market Boom and Crash of 1929 Revisited, " Journal of Economic Perspectives 4 (1990): 67-83
78. Tom Nicholas, "Does Innovation Cause Stock Market Runups? Evidence from the Great Crash, " American Economic Review 98 (2009): 1370-96
79. Mark Casson, The World's First Railway System: Enterprise, Competition, and Regulation on the Railway Network in Victorian Britain (Oxford, 2009).
80. A. G. Kenwood, "Railway Investment in Britain, " Economica 32 (1965): 318-19
81. David Chambers, Nicholas F. R. Crafts, and Brian R. Mitchell, "How Good was the Profi tability of British Railways, 1870-1912? " Economic History Review 64 (2011): 798-831.