Secrecy and justice in the ongoing saga of DBCP litigation

International Journal of Occupational and Environmental Health

Volumn 18, Issue 2, 2012, Pages 154-161

  Boix, Vicent ^a   Bohme, Susanna R ^b  

^a UNIVERSITAT POLITÈCNICA DE VALÈNCIA   (Spain)

^b IJOEH   (United States)

Author keywords

Dibromochloropropane; Nicaragua; Occupational health; Transnational litigation; United States of America

Indexed keywords

CENTRAL AMERICA; CONFIDENTIALITY; HUMAN; LEGAL LIABILITY; SOCIAL JUSTICE; UNITED STATES;

CENTRAL AMERICA; CONFIDENTIALITY; HUMANS; LIABILITY, LEGAL; SOCIAL JUSTICE; UNITED STATES;

EID: 84865334900     PISSN: 10773525     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1179/1077352512Z.00000000010     Document Type: Article

References (81)

1. Torkelson TR, Sadek SE, Rowe VK. Toxicological investigations of 1,2-dibromo-3-chloropropane. Toxicol Appl Pharmacol. 1961;3:545-59.
2. Anderson EJ. Toxicity of BBC-a warning. PRI News. 1963;11(5).
3. Anderson EJ. Deposition. In: Coordination Proceeding Special Title (Rule 1550 b); Chemical Exposure Cases; Judicial Council Coordination Proceeding No. 954. San Francisco (CA): In the Superior Court of the State of California in and for the County of San Francisco, 1981.
4. From the Editor. Pineapple News [Internet]. 1977 [cited 12 November 2011], 3(1): 1. Available from: http://tpss.hawaii.edu/ pineapple/PineNews-03.pdf
5. History: 1970-present. Dole Food Company [cited 29 December 2005]. Available from: http://www.dole.com/ CompanyInfo/About/Timeline/2.jsp
6. Notice of Registration under the Federal Insecticide, Fungicide, and Rodenticide Act: Nemagon C soil fumigant. Registration Number 201-140. US Department of Agriculture, 1964.
7. Ward JM, Habermann RT. Pathology of stomach cancer in rats and mice induced with the agricultural chemicals ethylene dibromide and dibromochloropropane. Bull Soc Pharmacol Environ Pathol. 1974;2(2):10-11.
8. Olson WA, Habermann RT, Weisburger EK, Ward JM, Weisburger JH. Brief communication: induction of stomach cancer in rats and mice by halogenated aliphatic fumigants. J Natl Cancer Instit. 1973;51:1993-5.
9. Occupational Safety and Health Administration. Occupational exposure to DBCP. Federal Regist. 1978: 43:11514-33.
10. Occupational Safety and Health Administration. Emergency temporary standard for exposure to 1,2-dibromo-3-chloropropane. Federal Regist. 1977; 42:45536-49.
11. Dibromochloropropane (DBCP): Suspension order and notice of intent to cancel. Fed Regist. 1979;44:65135-79.
12. Cassity H. Telex to Bud Daley. San Francisco (CA): Castle and Cooke; 1977.
13. Dow Chemical Company and Standard Fruit Company. Letter agreement. Midland MI: Dow Chemical Company; 1978.
14. DeMent J. Letter to distribution, subject: DBCP safe handling procedures. San Francisco (CA): Castle and Cooke Foods; 1978.
15. Thrupp LA. Sterilization of workers from pesticide exposure: the causes and consequences of DBCP-induced damage in Costa Rica and beyond. Int J Health Serv. 1991;21(4):731-57.
16. Weir P, Shapiro D. Circle of poison: pesticides and people in a hungry world. San Francisco (CA): Institute for Food and Development Policy; 1981.
17. Ballesteros P. Memo to Lic. M. A. Gurdian; Reporte de Operaciones Agricolas Division de Nicaragua [Report of agricultural operations, Nicaragua Division]. Standard Fruit Company; 1981.
18. Rosenberg B, Levenstein C. Unintended consequences: Impacts of pesticide bans on industry, workers, the public, and the environment. Methods and policy report; Toxic Use Reduction Institute; University of Massachusetts Lowell [Internet]. 1995;13:1-64 [cited 2009 Dec 6]. Available from: http://www.p2pays.org/ref/23/22115.pdf.
19. German Munoz Moncada, "Deposition", Jorge Colindres Carcamo et al. vs. Shell Oil Company et al.: District Court of Brazoria County, Texas; 23rd Judicial District; No. 93-C-2290, 1994 Mar 3.
20. Manuel Antonio Balderamos Erazo, "Deposition", Manuel Antonio Balderamos Erazo vs. Shell Oil Company; No. C-3665-93-D: In the District Court of Hildalgo County, Texas, 206th Judicial District, 1996 Jul 12.
21. Dole Food Company. DBCP facts [cited 13 May 2011]. Available from: http://www.dole.com/CompanyInformation/ DBCPFacts/tabid/1260/Default.aspx.
22. Ramirez AL, Ramirez CM. Esterilidad Masculina Causado por la Exposicion Laboral al Nematicida 1,2-Dibromo-3-Chlorpropano [Male sterility caused by occupational exposure to the nematocide 1,2-dibromo-3-chlorpropane]. Acta Med Costarr. 1980;23(2): 219-222.
23. Slutsky M, Levin JL, Levy BS. Azoospermia and oligospermia among a large cohort of DBCP applicators in twelve countries. Int J Occup Environ Health. 1999;5(2):116-22.
24. Rosenthal E. The DBCP pesticide cases: seeking access to justice to make agribusiness accountable in the global economy; in: Jansen K and Vellema S, eds. Agribusiness and Society: corporate responses to environmentalism, market opportunities and public regulation. London and New York: Zed Books, 2004.
25. Mayer D, Sable K. Yes! We have no bananas: forum non conveniens and corporate evasion. Int Business Law Rev. 2004;4:131-164.
26. Gonzalez D, Loewenberg S. Banana workers get day in court. New York Times. 2003 Jan 18.
27. Silva JA. El Otro Infierno: La Marana de Intereses en el Caso Nemagon [The other hell: the tangle of interests in the Nemagon case]. La Prensa. 2002 Sep 30 [cited 2011 Nov 2]. Available at: http://archivo.laprensa.com.ni/archivo/2003/ noviembre/13/nacionales/nacionales-20031113-05.html
28. Enriquez O. Inso lito Abuso del Procurador [Rare imposition by Attorney General]. El Nuevo Diario. 2002 Oct 8 [cited 2011 Nov 2]. Available at: http://archivo.elnuevodiario.com.ni/2002/ octubre/08-octubre-2002/nacional/nacional2.html
29. Enriquez O, Bow JC. Embusa Intervino en Caso Nemagon [US Embassy Intervenes in Nemagon Case]. El Nuevo Diario. 2002 Oct 9 [cited 2011 Nov 2]. Available from: http://archivo. elnuevodiario.com.ni/2002/octubre/09-octubre-2002/nacional/ nacional2.html
30. Enriquez O. "Invitacion a la Impunidad" ["Invitation to inpunity"]. El Nuevo Diaro. 2002 Oct 10 [Cited 2011 Nov 5]. Available from: http://archivo.elnuevodiario.com.ni/2002/ octubre/10-octubre-2002/nacional/nacional8.html.
31. Santoyo P. Bananas of wrath: how Nicaragua may have dealt forum non conveniens a fatal blow removing the doctrine as an obstacle to achieving corporate accountability. Houston J Int Law 27. Spring 2005; 718.
32. Bohme SR. Pesticide regulation, citizen action, and toxic trade: the role of the nation-state in the transnational history of DBCP in Melling J and Sellers C., eds. Dangerous Trade: Histories of Industrial Hazard across a Globalizing World. Philadelphia: Temple University, 2012.
33. Spano J. Dole must pay $2.5 million to farmhands. Los Angeles Times. 2007 Nov 16 [cited 2007 Nov 16]. Available at: http:// articles.latimes.com/2007/nov/16/local/me-dole16.
34. Spano J. Dole must pay farmworkers $3.2 million. Los Angeles Times. 2007 Nov 6 [cited 2007 Nov 16]. Available at:http:// articles.latimes.com/2007/nov/06/local/me-dole6.
35. Spano J. Damages in Dole case are reduced. Los Angeles Times. 2008 Mar 11 [cited 2008 March 30]. Available from: http://articles.latimes.com/2008/mar/11/local/me-dole11.
36. Chaney VG. Oral Ruling. Mejia vs. Dole et al., Case No. BD40049; 2009 April 23. Los Angeles: Superior Court for the State of California for the County of Los Angeles.
37. Austin JE. Standard Fruit Co. in Nicaragua. Boston (MA): Harvard University; 1994.
38. Republic of Nicaragua vs Standard Fruit Company, Standard Fruit and Steamship Company, and Castle & Cooke, Inc., United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit; 937 F.2d 469;1991.
39. Ley Organica de Seguridad Social. Gaceta (Nicaragua) 56; 1956 Jan 1 [cited 2012 Apr 2]. Available from: http://legislacion. asamblea.gob.ni/Normaweb.nsf/%28$All%29/8BCCF85E103820 780625718C004D43E3?OpenDocument
40. Integrated Risk Information System (IRIS-EPA). 1,2-dibromo-3-chloropropane (DBCP); CASRN 96-12-8 [Internet]. 1991 Jan 10 [updated 2006 May 2; cited 2009 Oct 22]. Available from: http://www.epa.gov/iris/subst/0414.htm.
41. Egnatz DG, Townsend JC, Olson RD, Johns DB. DBCP and testicular effects in chemical workers: an epidemiological survey in Midland, Michigan. J Occup Med. 1980;22(11):727-32.
42. Hearing transcript. Mejia vs. Dole et al. (BC340049) and Rivera vs. Dole et al. (BC379820). 2009 April 21-23. Los Angles (CA): Superior Court of the State of California for the County of Los Angeles; 2009.
43. Chaney VG. Findings of fact and conclusions of law supporting order terminating Mejia and Rivera cases for fraud on the court; redacted version of document filed under seal. Mejia v. Dole et al. (BC340049) and Rivera v. Dole et al. (BC379820). 2009 June 17. Los Angles (CA): Superior Court of the State of California for the County of Los Angeles.
44. Olivas R. Abogados Se Defienden y Afectados No Se Rendiran [Attorneys defend themselves and the affecteds will not give up]. El Nuevo Diario [Internet]. 2009 Apr 25 [cited 2012 Apr 4]. Available from: http://www.elnuevodiario.com.ni/nacionales/ 46140
45. Hechler D. The kill step. Corporate Counsel [internet].2009 Oct [cited 2010 November 12]. Available from: http://www.law.com/ jsp/cc/PubArticleCC.jsp?id51202433709311.
46. Plaintiffs' response in opposition to Dole Food Company, Inc. and the Dow Chemical Company's motion of entry of protective order pursuant to FRCP 26(C). In: Miguel Angel Sanchez Osorio et al., vs. Dole Food Company, Inc et al. Miami (FL): United States District Court, Southern District of Florida; 2009.
47. Kim V. Judge throws out verdict awarding millions to Dole workers. Los Angeles Times. 2010 Jul 16 [Cited 2012 Apr 2]. Available from: http://articles.latimes.com/2010/jul/16/local/ la-me-dole-20100716
48. Huck PC. Order denying recognition of judgment; case Miguel A ngel Sanchez Osorio, et al. vs. Dole Food Company, et al. Miami (FL): US District Court Southern District of Florida; 2009 Oct 20.
49. Deutsch L. LA judge dismisses sterility verdict against Dole. Associated Press. 15 July 2011 [Cited 30 July 2011]. Available from: http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/feedarticle/9175673
50. Toruno Martinez S, Certificacion: Sentencia #0271-2005; Sumario-Pago de Indeminza-cion por Danos y Perjuicios; Demanda #0214-0425-02cv Febrero". Chinandega, (Nicaragua): Juzgado Segundo de Distrito Civil y Laboral de Chinandega; 2005. p. 4, 10, 11, 15, 17.
51. Toruno Martinez S. Declaracion Jurada [Affadavit]. ed. trans. Martin Iglesias. Chinandega (Nicaragua); 05 Aug 2009.
52. Altamirano Tercero RA. Declaracion Jurada de Ramon Andres Altamirano Tercero [Sworn Testimony of Ramon Andres Altamirano Tercero]. Chinandega (Nicaragua). 06 Aug 2009.
53. Berrios MJ. Declaracion Jurada de Mario Justino Berrios [Sworn Testimony of Mario Justino Berrios]. Chinandega (Nicaragua). 25 June 2009
54. Palacios Ramos JF. Testimonio [Testimony]. Chinandega, (Nicaragua); 25 Aug 2009.
55. Plaintiffs' response in opposition to Dole Food Company, Inc. and the Dow Chemical Company's motion of entry of protective order pursuant to FRCP 26(C).
56. Vicent Boix Bornay. El Parque de Las Hamacas: El Quimico Que Golpeo a los Pobres (Icaria Editorial, 2008).
57. Olivas R. La Dole nos soborno para declarar contra victimas del Nemagon [Dole bribed us to testify against victims of nemagon]. El Nuevo Diario [Internet]. 2010 May 10 [cited 2010 May 11]. Available at: http://www.elnuevodiario.com.ni/nacionales/74115.
58. Davila Gutierrez FA. Acta de Absolucion de Posiciones [Transcript of Answer to Interrogatories]. Chinandega (Nicaragua): Juzgado Primero de Distrito Civil; 04 Sept 2009.
59. Herrera Jarquin BF. Acta de Absolucion de Posiciones [Transcript of Answer to Interrogatories]. Chinandega (Nicaragua): Juzgado Primero de Distrito Civil. 25 Aug 2009.
60. Herrera Jarquin JJ. Acta de Absolucion de Posiciones [Transcript of answer to interrogatories]. Chinandega (Nicaragua): Juzgado Primero de Distrito Civil; 16 Sept 2009.
61. Castro Aguero. Testimonio [Testimony]. Managua (Nicaragua); 22 April 2009.
62. Alvarado Mercado JR. Acta de Absolucion de Posiciones [Transcript of answer to interrogatories]. Chinandega (Nicaragua): Juzgado Primero de Distrito Civil. 24 Aug 2009.
63. Ruiz Torrez JR; Acta de Absolucio n de Posiciones[Transcript of answer to interrogatories]. Chinandega (Nicaragua): Juzgado Primero de Distrito Civil. 18 Sept 2009.
64. Padilla LA. Acta de Absolucion de Posiciones [Transcript of answer to interrogatories]. Chinandega (Nicaragua): Juzgado Primero de Distrito Civil. 25 Aug 2009.
65. Glaser J. Interview with the Author (SRB). 2010 Aug 5.
66. John Doe "A". Deposition. Chinandega (Nicaragua): Juzgado Primero del Distrito Civil; 2009 Sep 4.
67. Sanderson G. Temporary restraining order and order setting hearing for preliminary injunction; case Provost & Umphrey Law Firm, LLP vs. Dole Food Company Inc. Beaumont (TX):District Court of Jefferson County, 172 Judicial District. 2006 Jun 9;
68. Imhof V. Juez de Texas reprende al vicepresidente de la Dole [Texas judge rebukes the Dole's vice president]. El Nuevo Diario [Internet]. 2006 Jun 16 [cited 2009 Nov 15]. Available from: http://impreso.elnuevodiario.com.ni/2006/06/16/nacionales/ 21945
69. Melendez Aguirre DH. El Expediente de la Marcha Sin Retorno. Managua Centro Alexander Von Humbolt and Centro de Informacion y Servicios de Asesoria en Salud; 2006.
70. Amorin C. Los damnificados negocian directamente con las empresas. [The victims negotiate directly with companies]. REL-UITA [Internet]. 2005 Oct 18 [cited 2009 Nov 19]. Available from: http://www.rel-uita.org/agricultura/agrotoxicos/ nemagon/con_victorino_espinales.htm
71. Carter M, Espinales V, Sanchez J, Zapata D, Poveda M, Garcia S, Gonza lez J, Hernandez M. Letter to Daneil Ortega. 2007 June 28. 2 leafs. Located at: National Assembly of Nicaragua, Managua.
72. Trucchi G. Comunicado conjunto de afectados del Nemagon y Dole. [Joint Communication from those affected by Nemagon and Dole]. REL-UITA [Internet].2007 Jul 9 [cited 2009 Nov 19]. Available from: http://www.rel-uita.org/agricultura/ agrotoxicos/nemagon/comunicado-nemagon-dole.htm.
73. Ruiz JR. Deposition. Chinandega (Nicaragua): Juzgado Primero del Distrito Civil; 2009 Sep 18.
74. Sanctioned Chevron lawyers violating new court order in Ecuador environmental trial. PR Newswire [Internet]. 2010 Nov 19 [cited 2012 Jan 15] Available from: http://www.prnewswire.com/newsreleases/ sanctioned-chevron-lawyers-violating-new-court-order-inecuador-environmental-trial-111058134.html.
75. Towery JE, Lawrence MJ. Letter to Robert S. Condie; Re: CaseNo.: 10-O-9450 et al., Respondent: Edelman, Perrino, Carter. Los Angeles (CA): The State Bar of California; 2011.
76. Graham WE. Letter to Susan Margolis; Re: Respondent: Juan J. Dominguez, Case Number: 09-O-13650, State Bar Investigation. Los Angeles (CA): The State Bar of California; 2011.
77. Update: Tellez v. Dole food company, inc.; allegations against plaintiffs' attorneys found false; case dismissed despite false testimony; thousands of cases in jeopardy as courts await appeal [Internet]. 2011 March 14 [cited 2011 December 23]. Available from: http://www.provostumphrey.com/Press-Releases/Update-Tellez-v-Dole-Food-Company-Inc.shtml.
78. Dole food company signs definitive settlement agreement with provost & umphrey regarding banana workers' alleged exposure to dbcp [Internet]. 2011 October 13 [cited 2012 March 14]. Available from: http://www.dole.com/CompanyInformation/ PressReleases/PressReleaseDetails/tabid/1268/Default.aspx?onten ctid513323
79. Raymond N. Dole reaches settlement with Nicaraguan plantation workers. The American Lawyer. 2011 Oct 6. Available from: http://www.law.com/jsp/cc/PubArticleCC.jsp?id51202517908231.
80. Illegitimate judgment against Chevron in Ecuador Lawsuit: Chevron to appeal in Ecuador, enforcement blocked by US and international tribunals. Chevron Corporation [Internet]. Available from: http:// www.chevron.com/chevron/pressreleases/article/02142011_illegitimat ejudgmentagainstchevroninecuadorlawsuit.news
81. US judge delays decision in Chevron-Ecuador case. Thomson Reuters [Internet]. 2011 Feb 18 [cited 2012 Apr 2]. Available from: http://www.reuters.com/article/2011/02/18/us-chevronecuador-idUSTRE71H4R520110218