Cost-effectiveness modeling of colorectal cancer: Computed tomography colonography vs colonoscopy or fecal occult blood tests

European Journal of Radiology

Volumn 81, Issue 7, 2012, Pages 1413-1419

  Lucidarme, Olivier ^a   Cadi, Mehdi ^a   Berger, Genevieve ^a   Taieb, Julien ^a   Poynard, Thierry ^a   Grenier, Philippe ^a   Beresniak, Ariel ^b,c  

^a PITIÉ SALPÊTRIÈRE HOSPITAL   (France)

^b DATA MINING INTERNATIONAL   (Switzerland)

^c et Institut de recherche et documentation en économie de la santé   (France)

Author keywords

Colonoscopy; Colorectal cancer; Computed colonography; Cost; Cost effectiveness; Fecal occult blood test; Modeling; Screening

Indexed keywords

ARTICLE; CANCER SCREENING; COLONOSCOPY; COLORECTAL CANCER; COMPUTED TOMOGRAPHIC COLONOGRAPHY; COST EFFECTIVENESS ANALYSIS; HEALTH CARE COST; HUMAN; OCCULT BLOOD TEST; PATIENT COMPLIANCE; PRIORITY JOURNAL; QUALITY ADJUSTED LIFE YEAR;

AGED; COLONOGRAPHY, COMPUTED TOMOGRAPHIC; COLONOSCOPY; COLORECTAL NEOPLASMS; COST-BENEFIT ANALYSIS; FEMALE; FRANCE; HUMANS; INCIDENCE; MALE; MASS SCREENING; MIDDLE AGED; MONTE CARLO METHOD; OCCULT BLOOD; PREVALENCE; QUALITY-ADJUSTED LIFE YEARS;

EID: 84861622518     PISSN: 0720048X     EISSN: 18727727     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.ejrad.2011.03.027     Document Type: Article

References (67)

1. A. Jemal, R. Siegel, and E. Ward Cancer statistics, 2006 CA Cancer J Clin 56 2 2006 106 130
2. A.J. Aldridge, and J.N. Simson Histological assessment of colorectal adenomas by size. Are polyps less than 10 mm in size clinically important? Eur J Surg 167 10 2001 777 781
3. B.C. Morson The evolution of colorectal carcinoma Clin Radiol 35 6 1984 425 431
4. G.J. Kelloff, R.L. Schilsky, and D.S. Alberts Colorectal adenomas: a prototype for the use of surrogate end points in the development of cancer prevention drugs Clin Cancer Res 10 11 2004 3908 3918
5. F. Citarda, G. Tomaselli, R. Capocaccia, S. Barcherini, and M. Crespi Efficacy in standard clinical practice of colonoscopic polypectomy in reducing colorectal cancer incidence Gut 48 6 2001 812 815
6. S.J. Winawer, A.G. Zauber, and M.N. Ho Prevention of colorectal cancer by colonoscopic polypectomy. The National Polyp Study Workgroup N Engl J Med 329 27 1993 1977 1981
7. J. Regula, M. Rupinski, and E. Kraszewska Colonoscopy in colorectal-cancer screening for detection of advanced neoplasia N Engl J Med 355 18 2006 1863 1872
8. A. Sieg, and H. Brenner Cost-saving analysis of screening colonoscopy in Germany Z Gastroenterol 45 9 2007 945 951
9. J. Faivre, V. Dancourt, and C. Lejeune Reduction in colorectal cancer mortality by fecal occult blood screening in a French controlled study Gastroenterology 126 7 2004 1674 1680
10. J.D. Hardcastle, J.O. Chamberlain, and M.H. Robinson Randomised controlled trial of faecal-occult-blood screening for colorectal cancer Lancet 348 9040 1996 1472 1477
11. O. Kronborg, C. Fenger, J. Olsen, O.D. Jorgensen, and O. Sondergaard Randomised study of screening for colorectal cancer with faecal-occult-blood test Lancet 348 9040 1996 1467 1471
12. J.S. Mandel, J.H. Bond, and T.R. Church Reducing mortality from colorectal cancer by screening for fecal occult blood. Minnesota Colon Cancer Control Study N Engl J Med 328 19 1993 1365 1371
13. H. Goulard, M. Boussac-Zarebska, R. Ancelle-Park, and J. Bloch French colorectal cancer screening pilot programme: results of the first round J Med Screen 15 3 2008 143 148
14. G. Grazzini, G. Castiglione, and C. Ciabattoni Colorectal cancer screening programme by faecal occult blood test in Tuscany: first round results Eur J Cancer Prev 13 1 2004 19 26
15. N. Malila, T. Oivanen, O. Malminiemi, and M. Hakama Test, episode, and programme sensitivities of screening for colorectal cancer as a public health policy in Finland: experimental design BMJ 337 2008 a2261
16. P.J. Pickhardt, C. Hassan, A. Laghi, and D.H. Kim CT colonography to screen for colorectal cancer and aortic aneurysm in the Medicare population: cost-effectiveness analysis AJR Am J Roentgenol 192 5 2009 1332 1340
17. P.J. Pickhardt, C. Hassan, A. Laghi, A. Zullo, D.H. Kim, and S. Morini Cost-effectiveness of colorectal cancer screening with computed tomography colonography: the impact of not reporting diminutive lesions Cancer 109 11 2007 2213 2221
18. D. Lee, D. Muston, A. Sweet, C. Cunningham, A. Slater, and K. Lock Cost effectiveness of CT colonography for UK NHS colorectal cancer screening of asymptomatic adults aged 60-69 years Appl Health Econ Health Policy 8 3 2010 141 154
19. B. Levin, D.A. Lieberman, and B. McFarland Screening and surveillance for the early detection of colorectal cancer and adenomatous polyps 2008: a joint guideline from the American Cancer Society, the US Multi-Society Task Force on colorectal cancer, and the American College of Radiology CA Cancer J Clin 58 2008 130 160 [Epub ahead of print]
20. D. Polsky, H. Glick, R. Wilke, and K. Schulman Confidence intervals for cost-effectiveness ratios: a comparison of four methods Health Econ 6 1997 243 252
21. M.E. Zalis, M.A. Barish, and J.R. Choi CT colonography reporting and data system: a consensus proposal Radiology 236 1 2005 3 9
22. E. Levy, J.P. Auray, J.N. Bail, C. Beraud, and A. Beresniak Guidelines and recommendations for French pharmaco-economic studies J d'économie médicale 16 4-5 1998 353 372
23. Com-Ruelle L, Lucas-Gabrielli V, Renaud T. Le coût du cancer du colon en Île-de-France Aspects géographiques, cliniques et thérapeutiques. The cost of colon cancer in Île-de-France Geographical, clinical and therapeutic considerations. In: Institut de recherche et documentation en économie de santé (IRDES); 2006. [available via IRDES http://www.irdes.fr/EspaceRecherche/BiblioResumeEtSommaire/2006/ rap1651.htm ].
24. A.M. Bouvier, L. Remontet, and E. Jougla Incidence of gastrointestinal cancers in France Gastroenterol Clin Biol 28 10 Pt 1 2004 877 881
25. S. Vijan, I. Hwang, and J. Inadomi The cost-effectiveness of CT colonography in screening for colorectal neoplasia Am J Gastroenterol 102 2 2007 380 390
26. A.M. Benhamiche Colonic cancer: descriptive epidemiology and high-risk groups Gastroenterol Clin Biol 22 3 Suppl 1998 S3 S11
27. T.C. Arminski, and D.W. McLean Incidence and distribution of adenomatous polyps of the colon and rectum based on 1,000 autopsy examinations Dis Colon Rectum 7 1964 249 261
28. J.H. Bond Polyp guideline: diagnosis, treatment, and surveillance for patients with colorectal polyps. Practice Parameters Committee of the American College of Gastroenterology Am J Gastroenterol 95 11 2000 3053 3063
29. J.H. Bond Clinical relevance of the small colorectal polyp Endoscopy 33 5 2001 454 457
30. B.C. Morson The polyp story Postgrad Med J 60 709 1984 820 824
31. R.R. Rickert, O. Auerbach, L. Garfinkel, E.C. Hammond, and J.M. Frasca Adenomatous lesions of the large bowel: an autopsy survey Cancer 43 5 1979 1847 1857
32. A.R. Williams, B.A. Balasooriya, and D.W. Day Polyps and cancer of the large bowel: a necropsy study in Liverpool Gut 23 10 1982 835 842
33. D.H. Kim, P.J. Pickhardt, and A.J. Taylor CT colonography versus colonoscopy for the detection of advanced neoplasia N Engl J Med 357 14 2007 1403 1412
34. S. Bensen, L.A. Mott, B. Dain, R. Rothstein, and J. Baron The colonoscopic miss rate and true one-year recurrence of colorectal neoplastic polyps. Polyp Prevention Study Group Am J Gastroenterol 94 1 1999 194 199
35. T.F. Gorski, L. Rosen, R. Riether, J. Stasik, and I. Khubchandani Colorectal cancer after surveillance colonoscopy: false-negative examination or fast growth? Dis Colon Rectum 42 7 1999 877 880
36. J.H. Haseman, G.T. Lemmel, E.Y. Rahmani, and D.K. Rex Failure of colonoscopy to detect colorectal cancer: evaluation of 47 cases in 20 hospitals Gastrointest Endosc 45 6 1997 451 455
37. L.J. Hixson, M.B. Fennerty, R.E. Sampliner, and H.S. Garewal Prospective blinded trial of the colonoscopic miss-rate of large colorectal polyps Gastrointest Endosc 37 2 1991 125 127
38. B.J. Miller, J.R. Cohen, D.E. Theile, D.J. Schache, and J.K. Ku Diagnostic failure in colonoscopies for malignant disease Aust N Z J Surg 68 5 1998 331 333
39. D.K. Rex, C.S. Cutler, and G.T. Lemmel Colonoscopic miss rates of adenomas determined by back-to-back colonoscopies Gastroenterology 112 1 1997 24 28
40. U. Ladabaum, and K. Song Projected national impact of colorectal cancer screening on clinical and economic outcomes and health services demand Gastroenterology 129 4 2005 1151 1162
41. K. Song, A.M. Fendrick, U. Ladabaum, and Fecal DNA testing compared with conventional colorectal cancer screening methods: a decision analysis Gastroenterology 126 5 2004 1270 1279
42. B. Towler, L. Irwig, P. Glasziou, J. Kewenter, D. Weller, and C. Silagy A systematic review of the effects of screening for colorectal cancer using the faecal occult blood test, hemoccult BMJ 317 7158 1998 559 565
43. P.J. Pickhardt, J.R. Choi, and I. Hwang Computed tomographic virtual colonoscopy to screen for colorectal neoplasia in asymptomatic adults N Engl J Med 349 23 2003 2191 2200
44. P.B. Cotton, V.L. Durkalski, and B.C. Pineau Computed tomographic colonography (virtual colonoscopy): a multicenter comparison with standard colonoscopy for detection of colorectal neoplasia JAMA 291 14 2004 1713 1719
45. P.J. Pickhardt, J.R. Choi, I. Hwang, and W.R. Schindler Nonadenomatous polyps at CT colonography: prevalence, size distribution, and detection rates Radiology 232 3 2004 784 790
46. D.C. Rockey, E. Paulson, and D. Niedzwiecki Analysis of air contrast barium enema, computed tomographic colonography, and colonoscopy: prospective comparison Lancet 365 9456 2005 305 311
47. A. Graser, P. Stieber, and D. Nagel Comparison of CT colonography, colonoscopy, sigmoidoscopy and faecal occult blood tests for the detection of advanced adenoma in an average risk population Gut 58 2 2009 241 248
48. C.D. Johnson, M.H. Chen, and A.Y. Toledano Accuracy of CT colonography for detection of large adenomas and cancers N Engl J Med 359 12 2008 1207 1217
49. M.C. Weinstein Recent developments in decision-analytic modelling for economic evaluation Pharmacoeconomics 24 11 2006 1043 1053
50. H. Shinya, and W.I. Wolff Morphology, anatomic distribution and cancer potential of colonic polyps Ann Surg 190 6 1979 679 683
51. S.J. Stryker, B.G. Wolff, C.E. Culp, S.D. Libbe, D.M. Ilstrup, and R.L. MacCarty Natural history of untreated colonic polyps Gastroenterology 93 5 1987 1009 1013
52. R.U. van Stolk, G.J. Beck, J.A. Baron, R. Haile, and R. Summers Adenoma characteristics at first colonoscopy as predictors of adenoma recurrence and characteristics at follow-up. The Polyp Prevention Study Group Gastroenterology 115 1 1998 13 18
53. S.A. Taylor, A. Laghi, P. Lefere, S. Halligan, and J. Stoker European Society of Gastrointestinal and Abdominal Radiology (ESGAR): consensus statement on CT colonography Eur Radiol 17 2 2007 575 579
54. Société Nationale Française de Gastroenté rologie, Fédération Nationale des centres de lutte contre le cancer, Agence Nationale d'accréditation de d'évaluation en santé. [Consensus conference: Prevention Screening and Management of the Colonic Cancers. Paris, France, January 29-30, 1998. Proceedings]. Gastroenterol Clin Biol 1998:22(3 suppl):S1-295.
55. G. Duru, J.P. Auray, A. Beresniak, M. Lamure, A. Paine, and N. Nicoloyannis Limitations of the methods used for calculating quality-adjusted life-year values Pharmacoeconomics 20 7 2002 463 473
56. A.L. Frazier, G.A. Colditz, C.S. Fuchs, and K.M. Kuntz Cost-effectiveness of screening for colorectal cancer in the general population JAMA 284 15 2000 1954 1961
57. S. Vijan, E.W. Hwang, T.P. Hofer, and R.A. Hayward Which colon cancer screening test? A comparison of costs, effectiveness, and compliance Am J Med 111 8 2001 593 601
58. A. Sonnenberg, F. Delco, and J.M. Inadomi Cost-effectiveness of colonoscopy in screening for colorectal cancer Ann Intern Med 133 8 2000 573 584
59. A. Pariente, C. Milan, J. Lafon, and J. Faivre Colonoscopic screening in first-degree relatives of patients with 'sporadic' colorectal cancer: a case-control study. The Association Nationale des Gastroenterologues des Hopitaux and Registre Bourguignon des Cancers Digestifs (INSERM CRI 9505) Gastroenterology 115 1 1998 7 12
60. M. Rasmussen, C. Fenger, and O. Kronborg Diagnostic yield in a biennial Hemoccult-II screening program compared to a once-only screening with flexible sigmoidoscopy and Hemoccult-II Scand J Gastroenterol 38 1 2003 114 118
61. N. Segnan, C. Senore, and B. Andreoni Randomized trial of different screening strategies for colorectal cancer: patient response and detection rates J Natl Cancer Inst 97 5 2005 347 357
62. D.A. Marshall, F.R. Johnson, K.A. Phillips, J.K. Marshall, L. Thabane, and N.A. Kulin Measuring patient preferences for colorectal cancer screening using a choice-format survey Value Health 10 5 2007 415 430
63. R.A. Hirth, M.E. Chernew, E. Miller, A.M. Fendrick, and W.G. Weissert Willingness to pay for a quality-adjusted life year: in search of a standard Med Decis Making 20 3 2000 332 342
64. A. Laupacis, D. Feeny, A.S. Detsky, and P.X. Tugwell Tentative guidelines for using clinical and economic evaluations revisited CMAJ 148 6 1993 927 929
65. D. Lieberman Nonpolypoid colorectal neoplasia in the United States: the parachute is open JAMA 299 9 2008 1068 1069
66. R.M. Soetikno, T. Kaltenbach, and R.V. Rouse Prevalence of nonpolypoid (flat and depressed) colorectal neoplasms in asymptomatic and symptomatic adults JAMA 299 9 2008 1027 1035
67. E.M. Tweedle, S. Chaudhri, B. Azadeh, and P.S. Rooney Small, flat colorectal cancers in the UK population: an analysis of resected specimens Colorectal Dis 9 7 2007 641 646