Efficacy of the use of evidence-based algorithmic guidelines in the acute care setting for pain assessment and management in older people: A critical review of the literature

International Journal of Older People Nursing

Volumn 7, Issue 2, 2012, Pages 127-140

  Harmon, Joanne R ^a   Higgins, Isabel ^a,b   Summons, Peter ^b   Bellchambers, Helen ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF NEWCASTLE   (Australia)

^b UNIVERSITY OF NEWCASTLE   (Australia)

Author keywords

Acute care; Algorithm; Assessment and management of pain; Critical literature review; Older people; Translational

Indexed keywords

ACUTE DISEASE; AGED; ALGORITHM; ANALGESIA; ARTICLE; ELDERLY CARE; EVIDENCE BASED NURSING; HUMAN; NURSING METHODOLOGY RESEARCH; PAIN ASSESSMENT; POPULATION DYNAMICS; PRACTICE GUIDELINE; STANDARD;

ACUTE DISEASE; AGED; ALGORITHMS; EVIDENCE-BASED NURSING; HEALTH SERVICES FOR THE AGED; HUMANS; NURSING METHODOLOGY RESEARCH; PAIN MANAGEMENT; PAIN MEASUREMENT; POPULATION DYNAMICS; PRACTICE GUIDELINES AS TOPIC;

EID: 84860349699     PISSN: 17483735     EISSN: 17483743     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1111/j.1748-3743.2010.00261.x     Document Type: Article

References (83)

1. Aitken L.M., Marshall A.P., Elliott R. & McKinley S. (2007) Critical care nurses' decision making: sedation assessment and management in intensive care. Journal of Clinical Nursing 18, 36-45.
2. Australian Institute of Health and Welfare (2008) Australia's Health: The Eleventh Biennial Health Report. Australian Institute of Health and Welfare, Canberra, pp. 624.
3. Baumann M.H., Lewis S.Z. & Gutterman D. (2007) ACCP Evidence-based guideline development a successful and transparent approach addressing conflict of interest, funding and patient-centred recommendations. Chest 132, 1015-1024.
4. Blenkharn A., Faughnan S. & Morgan A. (2002) Developing a pain assessment tool for use by nurses in an adult intensive care unit. Intensive and Critical Care Nursing 18, 332-342.
5. Bolster D. & Manias E. (2010) Person-centered interactions between nurses and patients during medication activities in an acute hospital setting: qualitative observation and interview study. International Journal of Nursing Studies 47, 154-165.
6. Borbasi S.A., Jackson D. & Langford R.W. (2004) Chapter 6. Qualitative Research: The Whole Picture. Elsevier, Marrickville, NSW, Australia.
7. Botti M., Bucknall T. & Manias E. (2004) The problem of postoperative pain: issues for future research. International Journal of Nursing Practice 10, 257-263.
8. Braithwaite J., Runciman W.B. & Merry A.F. (2009) Towards safer, better healthcare: harnessing the natural properties of complex sociotechnical systems. Quality & Safety in Health Care 18, 37-41.
9. Bridges J., Flatley M. & Meyer J. (2010) Older people's and relatives' experiences in acute care settings: systematic review and synthesis of qualitative studies. International Journal of Nursing Studies 47, 89-107.
10. Brown D. (2004) A literature review exploring how healthcare professionals contribute to the assessment and control of postoperative pain in older people. Journal of Clinical Nursing 13, 74-90.
11. Brown D. & McCormack B. (2006) Determining factors that have an impact upon effective evidence-based pain management with older people, following colorectal surgery: an ethnographic study. Journal of Clinical Nursing 15, 1287-1298.
12. Bucknall T., Manias E. & Botti M. (2001) Acute pain management: implications of scientific evidence for nursing practice in the postoperative context. International Journal of Nursing Practice 7, 226-273.
13. Burns N. & Grove S.K. (2005) The Practice of Nursing Research. Conduct, Critique and Utilization. Elsevier, Missouri, USA.
14. Calvalien T.A. (2002) Pain management in the elderly. Journal of the American Osteopathic Association 102, 481-485.
15. Casey D. & Murphy K. (2009) Issues in using methodological triangulation in research. Nurse Researcher 16, 40-55.
16. Chang E., Hancock K., Hickman L., Glasson J. & Davidson P. (2007) Outcomes of acutely ill older hospitalized patients following implementation of tailored models of care: a repeated measures (pre- and post-intervention) design. International Journal of Nursing Studies 44, 1079-1092.
17. Chelsa C.A. (2008) Translational research: essential contributions from interpretive nursing science. Research in Nursing & Health 31, 381-390.
18. Clabo L.M.L. (2008) An ethnography of pain assessment and the role of social context on two postoperative units. Journal of Advanced Nursing 61, 531-539.
19. Coker E., Papaioannou A., Turpie I., Dolovich L., Kaasalainen S., Taniguchi A. & Burns S. (2008) Pain management practices: older adults on acute medical units. Gerontological Nursing Association Perspectives 32, 5-12.
20. Collett B., O'Mahony S., Schofield P., Closs S.J. & Potter J. (2007) The assessment of pain in older people. National guidelines. In Concise Guidance to Good Practice Series, Vol. 8 (Royal College of Physicians, British Geriatrics Society and British Pain Society eds). pp. Lavenham Group, Suffolk, Great Britain, pp. 17.
21. Cote L. & Turgeon J. (2005) Appraising qualitative research articles in medicine and medical education. Medical Teacher 27, 71-75.
22. Croskerry P. (2003a) Cognitive forcing strategies in clinical decision making. Annals of Emergency Medicine 41, 110-120.
23. Croskerry P. (2003b) The importance of cognitive errors in diagnosis and strategies to minimize them. Academic Medicine 78, 775-781.
24. Crowe L., Chang A., Fraser J.A., Gaskill D., Nash R. & Wallace K. (2008) Systematic review of the effectiveness of nursing interventions in reducing or relieving post-operative pain. International Journal of Evidence Based Healthcare 6, 396-430.
25. Dartnell J., Hemming M., Collier J. & Ollenschlaeger G. (2008) Putting evidence into context: some advice for guideline writers. Evidence Based Nursing 11, 6-8.
26. Dihle A., Bjalseth G. & Helseth S. (2006) The gap between saying and doing in postoperative pain management. Journal of Clinical Nursing 15, 469-479.
27. Ducharme J. (2005) Guidelines and polices: can they improve emergency department pain management? Journal of Law, Medicine & Ethics 33, 783-790.
28. Eva K.W. & Norman G.R. (2005) Heuristics and biases-a biased perspective on clinical reasoning. Medical Education 39, 870-872.
29. Fervers B., Burgers J.S., Haugh M.C., Latreille J., Mlika-Cabanne N., Paquet L., Coulombe M., Poirier M. & Burnand B. (2006) Adaptation of clinical guidelines: literature review and proposition for a framework and procedure. International Journal for Quality in Health Care 18, 167-176.
30. Gagliardi A.R., Brouwers M.C., Palda V.A., Lemieux-Charles L. & Grimshaw J.M. (2009) An exploration of how guideline developer capacity and guideline implementation influence implementation and adoption: study protocol. Implementation Science 4, 6.
31. Hadjistavropoulos T.P., Herr K.P., Turk D.C.P., Fine P.G.M.D., Dworkin R.H.P., Helme R.M.P., Jackson K.P., Parmelee P.A.P., Rudy T.E.P., Lynn Beattie B.M., Chibnall J.T.P., Craig K.D.P., Ferrell B.P., Ferrell B.M.D., Fillingim R.B.P., Gagliese L.P., Gallagher R.M.D., Gibson S.J.P., Harrison E.L.P., Katz B.M., Keefe F.J.P., Lieber S.J.M.S., Lussier D.M.D., Schmader K.E.M.D., Tait R.C.P., Weiner D.K.M.D. & Williams J.M.A. (2007) An interdisciplinary expert consensus statement on assessment of pain in older persons. Clinical Journal of Pain 23 (Suppl), S1-S43.
32. Harari D., Hopper A., Dhesi J., Babic-Illman G., Lockwood L. & Martin F. (2007a) Proactive care of older people undergoing surgery ('POPS'): designing, embedding, evaluating and funding a comprehensive geriatric assessment service for older elective surgical patients. Age and Ageing 36, 190-197.
33. Harari D., Martin F.C., Buttery A., O'Neil S. & Hopper A. (2007b) The older persons' assessment and liaison team 'OPAL': evaluation of comprehensive geriatric assessment in acute medical inpatients. Age and Ageing 36, 670-676.
34. Harper P., Ersser S. & Gobbi M. (2007) How military nurses rationalize their postoperative pain assessment decisions. Journal of Advanced Nursing 59, 601-611.
35. Hawker S., Payne S., Kerr C., Hardey M. & Powell J. (2002) Appraising the evidence: reviewing disparate data systematically. Qualitative Health Research 12, 1284-1299.
36. Henderson R. & Rheault W. (2004) Appraising and incorporating qualitative research in evidence-based practice. Journal of Physical Therapy Education 18, 35-40.
37. Herr K., Bjoro K., Steffensmeier J. & Rakel B. (2006) Acute Pain Management in Older Adults. In The University of Iowa College of Nursing GNIR Research Translation and Dissemination Core (RTDC): Evidence-based Practice Guideline (Titler M. ed.). The University of Iowa Gerontological Nursing Interventions Research Centre & RTDC, Iowa USA, pp. 116.
38. Hewitt-Taylor J. (2003) Developing and using clinical guidelines. Nursing Standard 18, 41-46.
39. Hoffman K.A., Aitken L.M. & Duffield C. (2009) A comparison of novice and expert nurses' cue collection during clinical decision-making: verbal protocol analysis. International Journal of Nursing Studies 46, 1335-1344.
40. Idvall E., Bergqvist A., Silverhjelm J. & Unosson M. (2008) Perspectives of Swedish patients on postoperative pain management. Nursing and Health Sciences 10, 131-136.
41. Joanna Briggs Institute (2008) Chapter 6. Critical Appraisal of Qualitative Research. Online, available at: (accessed 23 October 2009).
42. Juthberg C. & Sundin K. (2010) Registered nurses' and nurse assistants' lived experience of troubled conscience in their work in elderly care-a phenomenological hermeneutic study. International Journal of Nursing Studies 47, 20-29.
43. Kilstoff K. (2006) The Nursing Management of Acutely Ill Older Adults in Hospital. University of Western Sydney, Doctor of Philosophy (PhD), School of Nursing, Sydney.
44. Kim H.S., Schwartz-Barcott D., Tracy S.M., Forthin J.D. & Sjostrom B. (2005) Strategies of pain assessment used by nurses on surgical units. Pain Management Nursing 6, 3-9.
45. Klopper H., Andersson H., Minkkinen M., Ohlsson C. & Sjostrom B. (2006) Strategies in assessing post operative pain-a South African study. Intensive and Critical Care Nursing 22, 12-21.
46. Manias E., Botti M. & Bucknall T. (2002) Observation of pain assessment and management-the complexities of clinical practice. Journal of Clinical Nursing 11, 724-733.
47. Maroney C.L., Litke A., Fischberg D., Moore C. & Morrison M.D. (2004) Acceptability of severe pain among hospitalised adults. Journal of Palliative Medicine 7, 443-450.
48. Molony S.L., Kobayashi M., Holleran E.A. & Mezey M. (2005) Assessing pain as a fifth vital sign in long-term care facilities: recommendations from the field. Journal of Gerontological Nursing 31, 16-24.
49. Nordgren L., Asp M. & Fagerberg I. (2008) The use of qualitative evidence in clinical care. Evidence Based Nursing 11, 4-5.
50. Noyes J., Popay J., Pearson A., Hannes K. & Booth A. (2008) Chapter 20. Qualitative research and Cochrane reviews. In Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Interventions Version 5.0.1 (Higgins J.P.T. & Green S. eds). The Cochrane Collaboration, West Sussex, pp. 571-587.
51. Osborne S. & Webster J. (2005) Chapter 12. Development and use of evidence-based guidelines. In Evidence for Nursing Practice (Courtney M. ed.). Elsevier, Marrickville, Sydney, pp. 183-197.
52. Palviainen P., Hietala M., Routasalo P., Suominen T. & Hupli M. (2003) Do nurses exercise power in basic care situations? Nursing Ethics 10, 269-280.
53. Parran L. & Pederson C. (2002) Effects of an opioid taper algorithm in hematopoietic progenitor cell transplant recipients. Heart and Lung 31, 303-317.
54. Peek C., Higgins I., Milson-Hawke S., McMillan M. & Harper D. (2007) Towards innovation: the development of a person-centred model of care for older people in acute care. Contemporary Nurse: A Journal for the Australian Nursing Profession 26, 164-176.
55. Phelan C., Hodson F. & Douglas J. (2009) Pain assessment and management of the older person in the acute care setting. In Clinical Practice Guideline for Acute Care (Higgins I., Hayes C., Burstal R. et al. eds). Hunter Integrated Pain Service and the Division of Medicine, John Hunter Hospital, Newcastle, NSW, pp. 1-75.
56. Powell C. (2003) The Delphi technique: myths and realities. Journal of Advanced Nursing 41, 376-382.
57. Puntillo K.A., Miaskowski C., Kehrle K., Stannard D., Gleeson S. & Nye P. (1997) Relationship between behavioural and physiological indicators of pain, critical care patients' self-reports of pain, and opioid administration. Critical Care Medicine 25, 1159-1166.
58. Puntillo K.A., Miaskowski C. & Gleeson S. (2002) Use of a pain assessment and intervention notation (P.A.I.N.) tool in critical care nursing practice: nurses' evaluations. Heart and Lung 31, 303-315.
59. Puntillo K.A., Pasero C., Li D., Mularski R.A., Grap M.J., Erstad B.L., Varkey B., Gilbert H.C., Medina J. & Sessier C.N. (2009) Evaluation of pain in ICU patients. Chest 135, 1069-1074.
60. Rees J., King L. & Schmitz K. (2009) Nurses' perceptions of ethical issues in the care of older people. Nursing Ethics 16, 436-454.
61. Roddy E., Zhang W., Doherty M., Arden N.K., Barlow J., Birrell F., Carr A. & Chakravarty K. (2006) Evidence-based clinical guidelines: a new system to better determine true strength of recommendation. Journal of Evaluation in Clinical Practice 12, 347-352.
62. Sandelowski M. (1986) The problem of rigor in qualitative research. Advanced Nursing Science 8, 27-37.
63. Sandelowski M. (2004) Using qualitative research. Qualitative Health Research 14, 1366.
64. Schluter J., Winch S., Holzhauser K. & Henderson A. (2008) Nurses' moral sensitivity and hospital ethical climate: a literature review. Nursing Ethics 15, 304-321.
65. Scott S.D., Plotnikoff R.C., Karunamuni N., Bize R. & Rodgers W. (2008) Factors influencing the adoption of an innovation: an examination of the uptake of the Canadian Heart Health Kit (HHK). Implementation Science 3, 1-8.
66. Shapiro S. & Donaldson N.A. (2008) Evidence-based practice for advanced practice emergency nurses, part II: critically appraising the literature. Advanced Emergency Nursing Journal 30, 139-150.
67. Siddall P.J. & Cousins M.J. (2004) Persistent pain as a disease entity: implications for clinical management. Anesthesia and Analgesia 99, 510-520.
68. Söderhamn O. & Idvall E. (2003) Nurses' influence on quality of care in postoperative pain management: a phenomenological study. International Journal of Nursing Practice 9, 26-32.
69. Stige B., Malterud K. & Midtgarden T. (2009) Toward an agenda for evaluation of qualitative research. Qualitative Health Research 19, 1504-1516.
70. Sussman S., Valente T.W., Rohrbach L.A., Skara S. & Pentz M.A. (2006) Translation in the health professions: converting science into action. Evaluation and the Health Professions 29, 7-32.
71. Swarm R., Abernethy A.P., Anghelescu D.L., Benedetti C., Blinderman C.D., Boston B., Cleeland C., Coyle N., de Leon-Casasola O.A., Eilers J.G., Ferrell B., Janjan N.A., Karver S.B., Levy M.H., Lynch M., Moryl N., Murphy B.A., Nesbit S.A., Oakes L., Obbens E.A., Paice J.A., Rabow M.W., Syrjala K.L., Urba S. & Weinstein S.M. (2007) Adult cancer pain. Journal of the National Comprehensive Cancer Network 5, 726-751.
72. Tamches E., Buclin T., Hugli O., Decosterd I., Blanc C., Moushine E., Givel J.C. & Yersin B. (2007) Acute pain in adults admitted to the emergency room: development and implementation of abbreviated guidelines. Swiss Medical Weekly 137, 223-227.
73. Tan T.P.Y., Stokes T. & Shaw E. (2009) Use of qualitative research as evidence in the clinical guideline program of the National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellance. International Journal of Evidence Based Healthcare 7, 169-172.
74. Titler M.G., Herr K., Xie X.J., Brooks J.M., Schilling M.L. & Marsh J.L. (2009) Summative index: acute pain management in the older adults. Applied Nursing Research 20, 1-10.
75. Vaartio H., Leino-Kilpi H., Suominen T. & Puukka P. (2009) Nursing advocacy in procedural pain care. Nursing Ethics 16, 340-362.
76. Westabrook J.J., Coiera E., Dunsmuir W.T.M., Brown B.M., Kelk N., Paoloni R. & Tran C. (2010) The impact of interruptions on clinical task completion. Archives of Internal Medicine 170, 683-690.
77. Whittemore R., Chase S.K. & Mandle C.L. (2001) Validity in qualitative research. Qualitative Health Research 11, 522-538.
78. Wilson B. & McSherry W. (2006) A study of nurses' inferences of patients' physical pain. Journal of Clinical Nursing 15, 459-468.
79. Winters B.A. (2009) Older adults with traumatic rib fractures: an evidence-based approach to their care. Journal of Trauma Nursing 16, 93-98.
80. Wolf Z.R. (2007) Chapter 10. Ethnography: the method. In Nursing Research: A Qualitative Perspective (Munhall P.L. ed.). Jones and Bartlett, Miami, USA, pp. 293-330.
81. World Health Organisation (2009) The world is ageing fast - have we noticed? Online, available at: (accessed 03 September 2009).
82. Wright S.W., Trott A., Lindsell C.J., Smith C. & Gibler W.B. (2008) Creating a system to facilitate translation of evidence into standardized clinical practice: a preliminary report. Annals of Emergency Medicine 51, 80-86. e8.
83. Yorke J., Wallis M. & McLean B. (2004) Patients' perceptions of pain management after cardiac surgery in an Australian critical care unit. Heart and Lung 33, 33-42.