Does supply chain integration mediate the relationships between product/process strategy and service performance? An empirical study

International Journal of Production Economics

Volumn 137, Issue 2, 2012, Pages 250-262

  Droge, Cornelia ^a   Vickery, Shawnee K ^a   Jacobs, Mark A ^b  

^a MICHIGAN STATE UNIVERSITY   (United States)

^b UNIVERSITY OF DAYTON   (United States)

Author keywords

Logistics performance; Process modularity; Product modularity; Supply chain integration

Indexed keywords

ADAPTIVE STRUCTURATION THEORY; CANONICAL CORRELATION ANALYSIS; CHAIN MANAGEMENT; DELIVERY PERFORMANCE; EMPIRICAL STUDIES; MODULAR PROCESS; MODULAR PRODUCTS; PROCESS MODULARITY; PRODUCT MODULARITY; RESEARCH MODELS; SERVICE PERFORMANCE; SUPPLIER INTEGRATION; SUPPLY CHAIN INTEGRATION;

SUPPLY CHAIN MANAGEMENT;

INTEGRATION;

EID: 84859101559     PISSN: 09255273     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.ijpe.2012.02.005     Document Type: Article

References (152)

1. P.G. Aaltonen, E.P. Markowski, and T.A. Kirchner Ingredients of financial services customer satisfaction: the case of credit card services Journal of the Academy of Business and Economics 10 3 2010 149 156
2. C. Avgerou, C. Ciborra, and F. Land The Social Study of Information and Communication Technology: innovation, Actors and Contexts 2004 Oxford University Press Oxford; New York
3. K.R. Baker, M.J. Magazine, and H.L.W. Nuttle The effect of commonality on safety stock in a simple inventory model Management Science 32 8 1986 982 988
4. C.Y. Baldwin, and K.B. Clark Managing in an age of modularity Harvard Business Review 75 5 1997 84 94
5. C.Y. Baldwin, and K.B. Clark Design Rules 2000 The MIT Press Cambridge, Mass
6. R.M. Baron, and D.A. Kenny The moderator-mediator variable distinction in social psychological research: conceptual, strategic, and statistical considerations Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 51 1986 1173 1182
7. S. Brown, and J. Bessant The manufacturing strategy-capabilities links in mass customisation and agile manufacturing - an exploratory study International Journal of Operations and Production Management 23 7 2003 707 730 (Pubitemid 37104664)
8. D.T. Campbell, and D.W. Fiske Convergent and discriminant validation by the multitrait-multimethod matrix Psychological Bulletin 56 1959 81 105
9. M. Carey Modularity times three Sea Power 40 4 1997 81 84
10. A.S. Carr, and J.N. Pearson Strategically managed buyersupplier relationships and performance outcomes Journal of Operations Management 17 1999 497 519
11. T.S. Chang, and A.C. Ward Design-in-modularity with conceptual robustness Research in Engineering Design 7 1995 67 85
12. H.H. Chang An empirical study of evaluating supply chain management integration using the balanced scorecard in Taiwan Service Industries Journal 29 2009 185 202
13. A.B. Cherns The principles of sociotechnical design Human Relations 29 8 1976 783 792
14. A. Cherns Principles of sociotechnical design revisited Human Relations 40 3 1987 153 161
15. H. Chesbrough, and D.J. Teece When is virtual virtuous? Organizing for innovation Harvard Business review 74 1 1996 65 74
16. K.-S. Chin, V.M.R. Tummala, J.P.F. Leung, and X. Tang A study on supply chain management practices: the Hong Kong manufacturing perspective International Journal of Physical Distribution and Logistics Management 34 6 2004 505 524
17. S. Cholette Mitigating demand uncertainty across a winery's sales channels through postponement International Journal of Production Research 47 2009 3587 3609
18. G.A. Churchill Jr. A paradigm for developing better measures of marketing constructs Journal of Marketing Research 16 1979 64 73
19. G. Cleveland, R.G. Schroeder, and J.C. Anderson A theory of production competence Decision Sciences 20 4 1989 655 668
20. D.J. Closs, M.A. Jacobs, M. Swink, and G.S. Webb Toward a theory of competencies for the management of product complexity: Six case studies Journal of Operations Management 26 2008 590 610
21. J. Cohen, P. Cohen, S.G. West, and L. Aiken Applied Multiple Regression/Correlation Analysis for the Behavioral Sciences 3rd ed. 2003 Lawrence Erlbaum Associates Mahwah, NJ
22. S. Collett, and R.J. Spicer Improving productivity through cellular manufacturing Production and Inventory Management Journal 36 1995 71
23. D.A. Collier The measurement and operating benefits of component part commonality Decision Sciences 12 1 1981 85 96
24. D.A. Collier Aggregate safety stock levels and component part commonality Management Science 28 11 1982 1296 1303
25. M. Conway How do committees invent? Datamation 14 4 1968 28 31
26. C.M. Crawford, and M.D. Rosenau Jr. Significant issues for the future of product innovation The Journal of Product Innovation Management 11 3 1994 253 259
27. P. Danese, and P. Romano Improving inter-functional coordination to face high product variety and frequent modifications International Journal of Operations and Production Management 24 9/10 2004 863 885 (Pubitemid 39182237)
28. P. Desai, S. Kekre, S. Radhakrishnan, and K. Srinivasan Product differentiation and commonality in design: Balancing revenue and cost drivers Management Science 47 1 2001 37 51 (Pubitemid 34191961)
29. G. DeSanctis, and M.S. Poole Capturing the complexity in advanced technology use: adaptive structuration theory Organization Science 5 1994 121 147
30. R. Drazin, and A.H. Van De Ven Alternative forms of fit in contingency theory Administrative Science Quarterly 30 4 1985 514 539
31. C. Droge, J. Jayaram, and S.K. Vickery The effects of internal versus external integration practices on time-based performance and overall firm performance Journal of Operations Management 22 2004 557 573
32. J.H. Dyer, and W.G. Ouchi Japanese-style partnerships: giving companies a competitive edge Sloan Management Review 35 1 1993 51 63
33. L. Erlicher, and L. Massone Human factors in manufacturing: new patterns of cooperation for company governance and the management of change Human Factors and Ergonomics in Manufacturing 15 2005 403 419 (Pubitemid 41684693)
34. N. Fabbe-Costes, and M. Jahre Supply chain integration improves performance: the emperors new suit? International Journal of Physical Distribution and Logistics Management 37 10 2007 835 855
35. N. Fabbe-Costes, and M. Jahre Supply chain integration and performance: a review of the evidence International Journal of Logistics Management 19 2 2008 130 154
36. E. Feitzinger, and H.L. Lee Mass customization at Hewlett-Packard: the power of postponement Harvard Business Review 75 1 1997 116 121
37. I. Fernandez, and T. Kekäle The influence of modularity and industry clockspeed on reverse logistics strategy: implications for the purchasing function Journal of Purchasing and Supply Management 11 4 2005 193 205 (Pubitemid 43308765)
38. C.H. Fine, R. Vardan, R. Pethick, and J. El-Hout Rapid-response capability in value-chain design MIT Sloan Management Review 43 2002 69 75
39. C.H. Fine, B. Golany, and H. Naseraldin Modeling tradeoffs in three-dimensional concurrent engineering: a goal programming approach Journal of Operations Management 23 2005 389 403 (Pubitemid 40357126)
40. G. Fliedner, and R.J. Vokurka Agility: competitive weapon of the 1990s and beyond? Production and Inventory Management Journal 38 3 1997 19 24 (Pubitemid 127459282)
41. B.B. Flynn, B. Huo, and X. Zhao The impact of supply chain integration on performance: a contingency and configuration approach Journal of Operations Management 28 2010 58 71
42. M.T. Frohlich, and R. Westbrook Arcs of integration: an international study of supply chain strategies Journal of Operations Management 19 2001 185 200 (Pubitemid 32130380)
43. P. Galvin, and A. Morkel The effect of product modularity on industry structure: the case of the world bicycle industry Industry and Innovation 8 2001 31 47 (Pubitemid 32296478)
44. R. Garud, and A. Kumaraswamy Technological and organizational designs for realizing economies of substitution Strategic Management Journal 16 1995 93 110
45. R.J. Gentry, and H. Elms Firm partial modularity and performance in the electronic manufacturing services industry Industry and Innovation 16 6 2009 575 592
46. Y. Gerchak, M.J. Magazine, and A.B. Gamble Component commonality with service level requirements Management Science 34 6 1988 753 760 (Pubitemid 18623122)
47. J.K. Gershenson, G.J. Prasad, and Y. Zhang Product modularity: definitions and benefits Journal of Engineering Design 14 3 2003 295 313 (Pubitemid 37147587)
48. C. Gimenez, and E. Ventura Logistics-production, logistics-marketing and external integration: their impact on performance International Journal of Operations and Production Management 25 2005 20 38 (Pubitemid 40251291)
49. K. Goffin Design for supportability: essential component of new product development Research Technology Management 43 2 2000 40 47
50. M.F. Gorman, and J.I. Brannon Seasonality and the production-smoothing model International Journal of Production Economics 65 2 2000 173 178 (Pubitemid 30588251)
51. A.L. Guiffrida A probability based model for evaluating delivery performance Journal of the Academy of Business and Economics 9 2009 95 104
52. A. Gunasekarana, and E.W.T. Ngai Build-to-order supply chain management: a literature review and framework for development Journal of Operations Management 23 2005 423 451 (Pubitemid 40761046)
53. J.F. Hair, W.C. Black, B.J. Babin, and R.E. Anderson Multivariate Data Analysis 7th ed. 2009 Prentice-Hall Upper Saddle River
54. S. Hart, and C. Banbury How strategy-making processes can make a difference Strategic Management Journal 15 4 1994 251 269
55. R.H. Hayes, and S.C. Wheelwright Restoring our competitive edge: competing through manufacturing 1984 Wiley New York pp. 197228
56. R. Henderson, and K. Clark Architectural innovation: the reconfiguration of existing product technologies and the failure of firms Administrative Science Quarterly 35 1 1990 9 30
57. M. Holweg, and F.K. Pil Flexibility first Industrial Engineer 37 2005 46
58. M.R. Hoogeweegen, W.J.M. Teunissen, P.H.M. Vervest, and R.W. Wagenaar Modular network design: Using information and communication technology to allocate production tasks in a virtual organization Decision Sciences 30 1999 1073 1103
59. R. Hoole Drive complexity out of your supply chain Harvard Business School Newsletter 2006 3 5
60. S. Ismail, E. Maling, and B. Christiane Quality in supply chains: an empirical analysis Supply Chain Management 11 6 2006 491 502
61. A. Israels Canonical analysis. A review with applications in ecology Psychometrica 51 1986 495 497
62. K.N.S. Iyer, R. Germain, and G.L. Frankwick Supply chain B2B e-commerce and time-based delivery performance International Journal of Physical Distribution and Logistics Management 34 2004 645 661
63. M. Jacobs, and M. Swink Product portfolio architectural complexity and operational performance: incorporating the roles of learning and fixed assets Journal of Operations Management 29 2011 677 691
64. M.A. Jacobs, S. Vickery, and C. Droge The effects of product modularity on competitive performance: do integration strategies mediate the relationship? International Journal of Operations and Production Management 27 2007 1046 1068
65. M.A. Jacobs, C. Droge, S. Vickery, and R. Calantone The effects of product and process modularity on agility and firm growth performance Journal of Product Innovation Management 28 2011 123 137
66. D.M. Jaehne, M. Li, R. Riedel, and E. Mueller Configuring and operating global production networks. International Journal of Production Research 47 8 2009 2013 2030
67. J. Jayaram, and K.-C. Tan Supply chain integration with third-party logistics providers International Journal of Production Economics 125 2010 262 271
68. J. Kallio, T. Saarinen, M. Tinnila, and A.P.J. Vepsalainen Measuring delivery process performance International Journal of Logistics Management 11 2000 75 88 (Pubitemid 33206146)
69. L. Kanovska Customer services: a part of market orientation Economics and Management 15 1 2010 562 565
70. J.D. Kasarda, and D.A. Rondinelli Innovative infrastructure for agile manufacturers Sloan Management Review 39 2 1998 73 82
71. T.M. Katunzi Obstacles to process integration along the supply chain: manufacturing firm's perspective International Journal of Business and Management 6 2011 105 113
72. K. Kim, and D. Chhajed Commonality in product design: cost saving, valuation change and cannibalization European Journal of Operational Research 125 3 2000 602 621
73. S.W. Kim The effect of supply chain integration on the alignment between corporate competitive capability and supply chain operational capability International Journal of Operations and Production Management 26 10 2006 1084 1107 (Pubitemid 44222023)
74. S.W. Kim An investigation on the direct and indirect effect of supply chain integration on firm performance International Journal of Production Economics 119 2009 328 346
75. P. Kotler Principles of Marketing 3rd ed. 1986 Englewood Cliffs Prentice-Hall, N.J
76. X. Koufteros, M. Vonderembse, and J. Jayaram Internal and external integration for product development: the contingency effects of uncertainty, equivocality, and platform strategy Decision Sciences 36 2005 97 133 (Pubitemid 41602170)
77. X.A. Koufteros, G.E. Rawski, and R. Rupak Organizational integration for product development: the effects on glitches, on-time execution of engineering change orders, and market success Decision Sciences 41 2010 49 80
78. R. Landeros, and R.M. Monczka Cooperative buyer/seller relationships and a firm's competitive posture Journal of Purchasing and Materials Management 25 1989 9 18
79. P. Lawrence, and J. Lorsch Organization and environment; managing differentiation and integration Boston: division of Research, Graduate School of Business Administration 1967 Harvard University
80. H.L. Lee, and C.S. Tang Modelling the costs and benefits of delayed product differentiation Management Science 43 1997 40 53 (Pubitemid 127575304)
81. J.D. Lewis Business world: western companies improve upon the Japanese 'keiretsu' Wall Street Journal A21 1995
82. L. Li, and J.N. Warfield Perspectives on quality coordination and assurance in global supply chains International Journal of Production Research 49 1 2011 1 4
83. Y. Lin, Y. Wang, and C. Yu Investigating the drivers of the innovation in channel integration and supply chain performance: a strategy orientated perspective International Journal of Production Economics 127 2010 320 332
84. N. Lohse, S. Ratchev, and G. Valtchanov Towards web-enabled design of modular assembly systems Assembly Automation 24 3 2004 270 279
85. N. Lohse, H. Hirani, and S. Ratchev Equipment ontology for modular reconfigurable assembly systems International Journal of Flexible Manufacturing Systems 17 2005 301
86. S. Lorenzi, and A.D. Lello Product modularity theory and practice: the benefits and difficulties in implementation within a company International Journal of Automotive Technology and Management 1 2001 425 448
87. I.R. Mac Neil The New Social Contract: An Inquiry into Modern Contractual Relationships 1980 Yale Press New Haven
88. J.O. McClain, W.L. Maxwell, J.A. Muckstadt, L.J. Thomas, E.N. Weiss, and D.A. Collier Comment on Aggregate safety stock levels and component part commonality/Reply Management Science 30 6 1984 772 774
89. K. McConneghey Environmental Laboratory Annual Performance Benchmark Study 1999 Mc Conneghey and Co. Raleigh, NC p. 96
90. M.H. Meyer, and A.P. Lehnerd The Power of Product Platforms: Building Value and Cost Leadership 1997 Free Press New York
91. M.H. Meyer, P. Tertzakian, and J.M. Utterback Metrics for managing research and development in the context of the product family Management Science 43 1997 88 111 (Pubitemid 127575308)
92. J.H. Mikkola Capturing the degree of modularity embedded in product architectures The Journal of Product Innovation Management 23 2006 128
93. F. Montabon, R. Sroufe, and R. Narasimhan An examination of corporate reporting, environmental management practices and firm performance Journal of Operations Management 25 2007 998 1014 (Pubitemid 47285464)
94. R.N. Nagel, and P. Bhargava Agility: the ultimate requirement for world-class manufacturing performance National Productivity Review 13 3 1994 331 340
95. R. Narasimhan, and J.R. Carter Linking business unit and material sourcing strategies Journal of Business Logistics 19 2 1998 155 171
96. R. Narasimhan, and S.W. Kim Effect of supply chain integration on the relationship between diversification and performance: evidence from Japanese and Korean firms Journal of Operations Management 20 2002 303 323 (Pubitemid 34704331)
97. R. Narasimhan, M. Swink, and S.W. Kim Disentangling leanness and agility: an empirical investigation Journal of Operations Management 24 2006 440 457 (Pubitemid 44291868)
98. P.M. Noaker The search for agile manufacturing Manufacturing Engineering 113 1994 40 43
99. S. Novak, and S.D. Eppinger Sourcing by design: product complexity and the supply chain Management Science 47 2001 189 204 (Pubitemid 34191970)
100. J.D. Pagh, and M.C. Cooper Supply chain postponement and speculation strategies: how to choose the right strategy Journal of Business Logistics 19 2 1998 13 33
101. E.L. Paiva Manufacturing and marketing integration from a cumulative capabilities perspective International Journal of Production Economics 126 2010 379 386
102. K.J. Petersen, R.B. Handfield, and G.L. Ragatz A model of supplier integration into new product development Journal of Product Innovation Management 20 2003 284 299
103. K.J. Petersen, R.B. Handfield, and G.L. Ragatz Supplier integration into new product development: coordinating product, process and supply chain design Journal of Operations Management 23 2005 371 388 (Pubitemid 40357125)
104. B.J. Pine II, B. Victor, and A.C. Boynton Making mass customization work Harvard Business Review 71 5 1993 108 119
105. B.J. Pine Mass customization: the new frontier in business competition 1993 Harvard Business School Press Boston, Mass
106. P.M. Podsakoff, N.P. Podsakoff, S.B. MacKenzie, and J.-Y. Lee Common method biases in behavioral research: a critical review of the literature and recommended remedies Journal of Applied Psychology 886 2003 879 903 (Pubitemid 37239703)
107. T.C. Powell, and A. Dent-Micallef Information technology as competitive advantage: the role of human, business, and technology resources Strategic Management Journal 18 5 1997 375 405 (Pubitemid 127467823)
108. D. Prajogo, and J. Olhager Supply chain integration and performance: The effects of long-term relationships, information technology and sharing, and logistics integration International Journal of Production Economics 135 2012 514 522
109. J. Prince, and J.M. Kay Combining lean and agile characteristics: creation of virtual groups by enhanced production flow analysis International Journal of Production Economics 85 3 2003 305 318
110. Ragatz, G.L., Sandor, J., 2009. General session. In: 55th Annual Purchasing and Supply Chain Management Executive Seminar, Michigan State University.
111. Y.K. Ro, J.K. Liker, and S.K. Fixson Modularity as a strategy for supply chain coordination: the case of U.S. auto IEEE Transactions on Engineering Management 54 1 2007 172 189 (Pubitemid 46431436)
112. A.M. Rodrigues, T.P. Stank, and D.F. Lynch Linking strategy, structure, process, and performance in integrated logistics Journal of Business Logistics 25 2004 65 94 (Pubitemid 39436801)
113. F. Salvador, C. Forza, and M. Rungtusanatham Modularity, product variety, production volume, and component sourcing: theorizing beyond generic prescriptions Journal of Operations Management 20 5 2002 549
114. R. Sanchez, and J.T. Mahoney Modularity, flexibility, and knowledge management in product and organization design Strategic Management Journal 17 1996 63 79
115. R. Sanchez Strategic flexibility in product competition Strategic Management Journa 16 Special Issue 1995 135 160
116. M.A. Schilling, and H.K. Steensma The use of modular organizational forms: an industry-level analysis Academy of Management Journal 44 6 2001 1149 1168 (Pubitemid 33388263)
117. M.A. Schilling Toward a general modular systems theory and its application to interfirm product modularity The Academy of Management Review 25 2 2000 312 329
118. R.W. Schmenner, and M.L. Swink On theory in operations management Journal of Operations Management 17 1 1998 97 113 (Pubitemid 128419950)
119. R.J. Schonberger Japanese Manufacturing Techniques: Nine Hidden Lessons in Simplicity 1982 Free Press New York, NY
120. S.M. Shafer, and J.M. Charnes Cellular versus functional layouts under a variety of shop operating conditions Decision Sciences 24 1993 665 681
121. H. Sharifi, and Z. Zhang Agile manufacturing in practice: application of a methodology International Journal of Operations and Production Management 21 2001 772
122. H. Simon The architecture of complexity Proceedings of the American Philosophical Society 106 1962 467 482
123. W. Skinner The focused factory Harvard Business Review 52 3 1974 113 122
124. A.S. Sohal, P. Fitzpatrick, and D. Power A longitudinal study of a flexible manufacturing cell operation Integrated Manufacturing Systems 12 2001 236 245 (Pubitemid 32991484)
125. M. Spring, and L. Araujo Service, services and products: rethinking operations strategy International Journal of Operations and Production Management 29 5 2009 2 12
126. T.P. Stank, S.B. Keller, and D.J. Closs Performance benefits of supply chain logistical integration Transportation Journal 41 2001 32 46
127. D. Stewart, and W. Love A general canonical correlation index Psychological Bulletin 70 1968 160 163
128. A. Susarla, A. Barua, and A.B. Whinston Multitask agency, modular architecture, and task disaggregation in SaaS Journal of Management Information Systems 26 4 2009 87 117
129. P.M. Swamidass, and W.T. Newell Manufacturing strategy, environmental uncertainty and performance: a path analytic model Management Science 33 4 1987 509 525
130. J.M. Swaminathan, and S.R. Tayur Managing broader product lines through delayed differentiation using vanilla boxes Management Science 44 1998 S161 S172
131. M. Swink, R. Narasimhan, and C. Wang Managing beyond the factory walls: effects of four types of strategic integration on manufacturing plant performance Journal of Operations Management 25 2007 148 164 (Pubitemid 44880529)
132. M. Sytch, and R. Gulati Creating value together MIT Sloan Management Review 50 1 2008 12 13
133. F. Talib, Z. Rahman, and M.N. Qureshi Integrating total quality management and supply chain management: similarities and benefits Journal of Supply Chain Management 7 4 2010 26 44
134. Y.K. Tse, and K.H. Tan Managing product quality risk in a multi-tier global supply chain International Journal of Production Research 49 1 2011 139 158
135. K.T. Ulrich, and S.D. Eppinger Product Design and Development 1995 McGraw-Hill New York
136. Ulrich, K., Tung, K., 1991. Fundamentals of product modularity. In: Proceedings of the 1991 ASME design engineering technical conferences - conference on design/manufacture integration, Miami, FL, 7379
137. K. Ulrich The role of product architecture in the manufacturing firm Research Policy 24 1995 419 440
138. R.I. van Hoek, and H.A.M. Weken The impact of modular production on the dynamics of supply chains International Journal of Logistics Management 9 1998 35 50
139. R.I. van Hoek, H.R. Commandeur, and B. Vos Reconfiguring logistics systems through postponement strategies Journal of Business Logistics 19 1 1998 33 54 (Pubitemid 128072449)
140. N. Venkatraman, and V. Ramanujam Measurement of business economic performance: an examination of method convergence Journal of Management 13 1 1987 109 122
141. S.K. Vickery, C. Droge, and R. Markland Strategic production competence: convergent, discriminant, and predictive validity Production and Operations Management 3 4 1994 308 320
142. S.K. Vickery, J. Jayaram, C. Droge, and R. Calantone The effects of an integrative supply chain strategy on customer service and financial performance: an analysis of direct versus indirect relationships Journal of Operations Management 21 2003 523 540
143. L.R. Vijayasarathy Supply integration: an investigation of its multi-dimensionality and relational antecedents International Journal of Production Economics 124 2010 489 505
144. E. von Hippel Task partitioning: an innovation process variable Research Policy 19 5 1990 407 418
145. H. Voordijk, B. Meijboom, and J.D. Haan Modularity in supply chains: a multiple case study in the construction industry International Journal of Operations and Production Management 26 2006 600 618 (Pubitemid 43781529)
146. S.M. Wagner, and D.R. Krause Supplier development: communication approaches, activities and goals International Journal of Production Research 47 12 2009 3161 3177
147. G.A. Walz Design tactics for optimal modularity Proceedings of Autotestcon IEEE November 1980 281 284
148. X. Wang, D. Li, and C. OBrien Optimisation of traceability and operations planning: an integrated model for perishable food production International Journal of Production Research 47 11 2009 2865 2886
149. C. Ward What is agility? Industrial Engineering 26 1994 14
150. J.D. Wisner, K.-C. Tan, and K. Leong Principles of Supply Chain Management second ed. 2008 South-Western Mason, OH
151. N. Worren, K. Moore, and P. Cardona Modularity, strategic flexibility, and firm performance: a study of the home appliance industry Strategic Management Journal 23 2002 1123 1140 (Pubitemid 35459491)
152. T.P. Wright Factors effecting the cost of airplanes Journal of the Aeronautical Sciences 3 1936 122 128