End-of-life decisions and demented patients. What to do if the patient's current and past wishes are in conflict with each other?

European Journal of Health Law

Volumn 19, Issue 2, 2012, Pages 177-186

  Lemmens, Christophe ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF ANTWERP   (Belgium)

Author keywords

advance care planning; advance directive; behaviour of incompetent patient; conflict in medical decision making; demented patients; end of life decisions

Indexed keywords

ARTICLE; CUSTODY; DECISION MAKING; DEMENTIA; HUMAN; LEGAL ASPECT; LIVING WILL; MENTAL CAPACITY;

ADVANCE DIRECTIVES; DECISION MAKING; DEMENTIA; HUMANS; MENTAL COMPETENCY; PROXY;

EID: 84858397089     PISSN: 09290273     EISSN: 15718093     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1163/157180912X629117     Document Type: Article

References (62)

1. http://www.who.int.
2. C.P. Ferri, M. Prince, C. Brayne et al., "Global prevalence of dementia: a Delphi consensus study", Lancet 366 (2005) 2112-2117. (Pubitemid 41797645)
3. L. Deliens, F. Mortier, J. Bilsen et al., "End-of-life decisions in medical practice in Flanders, Belgium: a nationwide survey", Lancet 356 (2000) 1807
4. A. Van Der Heide, L. Deliens, K. Faisst et al., "End-oflife decision-making in six European countries: descriptive study", Lancet 362 (2003) 347
5. J. Bilsen, J. Cohen, K. Chambaere et al., "Medical end-of-life practices under the euthanasia law in Belgium", N. Engl. J. Med. 361 (2009) 1120.
6. http://www.gezondheidsraad.nl/en
7. http://www.alzheimer-europe.org
8. http://www.alz.org; http://www.alzheimer.ca and http://www.dementiaguide. com.
9. S. Fazel, T. Hope and R. Jacoby, "Dementia, intelligence, and the competence to complete advance directives", Lancet 354 (1999) 48. (Pubitemid 29304309)
10. D.C. Marson, B. McInturff, L. Hawkins et al., "Consistency of physician judgments of capacity to consent in mild Alzheimer's disease", J. Am. Geriatr. Soc. 45 (1997) 453.
11. L. Deliens, C. De Gendt, I. D'Haene et al., Advance Care Planning, (Brussels: King Baudouin Foundation, 2009) 15 (in Dutch, summary available in English, http://www.kbs-frb.be)
12. L.K. Fellows, "Competency and consent in dementia", J. Am. Geriatr. Soc. 46 (1998) 923
13. L.P. Francis, "Decision-making at the end-of-life: patients with Alzheimer's or other dementias", Ga. L. Rev. 35 (2001) 541-549.
14. S.Y.H. Kim, E.D. Caine, G.W. Currier et al., "Assessing the competence of persons with Alzheimer's disease in providing informed consent for participation in research", Am. J. Psychiatry 158 (2001) 712-717 (Pubitemid 32429837)
15. J. Warner, R. McCarney, M. Griffin et al., "Participation in dementia research: rates and correlates of capacity to give informed consent", J. Med. Ethics 34 (2008) 167-170
16. J. Moye, M.J. Karel, A.R. Azar et al., "Capacity to consent to treatment: empirical comparison of three instruments in older adults with and without dementia", Gerontologist 44 (2004) 166-175 (Pubitemid 38541820)
17. J. Warner and E. Nomani, "Giving consent in dementia research", Lancet 372 (2008) 183-184.
18. http://www.psych.org
19. M.B. Kapp, "Legal standards for the medical diagnosis and treatment of dementia", J. Legal Med. 23 (2002) 359-402.
20. S.S. Richards and H.C. Hendrie, "Diagnosis, management, and treatment of Alzheimer disease. A guide for the internist", Arch. Intern. Med. 159 (1999) 792
21. M.A. Drickamer and M.S. Lachs, "Should patients with Alzheimer's disease be told their diagnosis?", N.Eng. J. Med. 326 (1992) 948.
22. Commissie Aanvaardbaarheid Levensbeëindigend Handelen (CAL) Medisch Handelen rond het Levenseinde bij Wilsonbekwame Patiënten, (Houten: Bohn Stafleu Van Loghum, 1997) 111-116.
23. M.L. Rurup, B.D. Onwuteaka-Philipsen, H.R.W. Pasman et al., "Attitudes of physicians, nurses and relatives towards end-of-life decisions concerning nursing home patients with dementia", Patient Education and Counseling 61 (2006) 372-380. (Pubitemid 43767440)
24. D.K. Gjerdingen, J.A. Neff, M. Waing and K. Chaloner, "Older persons' opinions about life-sustaining procedures in the face of dementia", Arch. Fam. Med. 8 (1999) 421-425.
25. J.C. Ahronheim, S. Morrison, S.A. Baskin et al., "Treatment of the dying in the acute care hospital. Advanced dementia and metastatic cancer", Arch. Intern. Med. 156 (1996) 2094-2100. (Pubitemid 26346968)
26. M.R. Tonelli, "Pulling the plug on living wills. A critical analysis of advance directives", Chest 110 (1996) 816-822 (Pubitemid 27009310)
27. T.S. Drought, B.A. Koenig and T.A. Raffin, "Advance directives. Changing our expectations", Chest 110 (1996) 589-591 (Pubitemid 27009274)
28. A.J. Block, "Living wills are overrated", Chest 104 (1993) 1645-1646. (Pubitemid 23360079)
29. S.H. Miles, R. Koepp and E.P. Weber, "Advance end-of-life treatment planning. A research review", Arch. Intern. Med. 156 (1996) 1062-1068 (Pubitemid 26158061)
30. M.R. Gillick, "A broader role for advance medical planning", Ann. Intern. Med. 123 (1995) 621-624
31. Royal College of Physicians, Advance Care Planning. Concise guidance to good practice. A Series of Evidence-Based Guidelines for Clinical Management, (London: 2009) 4.
32. R. Dworkin, Life's Dominion. An Argument about Abortion, Euthanasia, and Individual Freedom, (New York: Vintage Books, 1994) 226.
33. A. Meisel and K.L. Cerminara, The Right to Die. The Law of End-of-Life Decisionmaking, (Austin: Aspen Publishers, 2004) 7-20 f.f.
34. R. Andorno, N. Biller-Andorno and S. Brauer, "Advance health care directives: towards a coordinated European policy?", EJHL 16 (2009) 213
35. C.M.P.M. Hertogh, "The role of advance euthanasia directives as an aid to communication and shared decision-making in dementia", J.Med.Ethics 35 (2009) 100
36. S. Fazel, T. Hope and R. Jacoby, "Effect of cognitive impairment and premorbid intelligence on treatment preferences for life-sustaining medical therapy", Am. J. Psychiatry 157 (2000) 1009-1011 (Pubitemid 30412356)
37. E.L. Diamond, J.A. Jernigan, R.A. Moseley et al., "Decision-making ability and advance directive preferences in nursing home patients and proxies", Gerontologist 29 (1989) 625.
38. N.L. Cantor, "Prospective autonomy: on the limits of shaping one's postcompetence medical fate", J. Contemp. Health L. &Pol'y 8 (1992) 13-48
39. S. Michalowski, "Advance refusals of life-sustaining treatment: the relativity of an absolute right", Mod. L. Rev. 68 (2005) 974-977.
40. D. Parfit, Reasons and Persons, (Oxford: Clarendon, 1984) 199 f.f.
41. R. Dresser, "Life, death, and incompetent patients: conceptual infirmities and hidden values in the law", Ariz. L. Rev. 28 (1986) 379-381
42. R. Dresser, "Dworkin on dementia: elegant theory, questionable policy", Hastings Center Report 25 (1995) 32-38.
43. A. Fang, "The living will of dementia patients: an exercise of autonomy and maximisation of utility?", UCL Juris. Rev. 4 (1997) 156.
44. D.W. Brock, "Justice and the severely demented elderly", Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 13 (1988) 73-99
45. J.D. Arras, "The severely demented, minimally functional patient: an ethical analysis", J. Am.Geriatr. Soc. 36 (1988) 940-941.
46. A. Buchanan, "Advance directives and the personal identity problem", Philosophy and Public Affairs 17 (1988) 280 f.f
47. H. Kuhse, "Some reflections on the problem of advance directives, personhood, and personal identity", Kennedy Institute of Ethics Journal 9 (1999) 347-364
48. L.L. Emanuel, "What makes a directive valid?", Hastings Center Report 24 (1994) S27
49. A.R. Maclean, "Advance directives, future selves and decision-making", Med.L.Rev. 14 (2006) 295 f.f.
50. R.S. Dresser and J.A. Robertson, "Quality of life and non-treatment decisions for incompetent patients: a critique of the orthodox approach", Law, Medicine &Health Care 17 (1989) 234-244
51. R. Dresser, "Missing persons: legal perceptions of incompetent patients", Rutgers L. Rev. 46 (1994) 609-719
52. R. Dresser, "Relitigating life and death", Ohio St. L. J. 51 (1990) 425-437.
53. N.K. Rhoden, "The limits of legal objectivity", N.C.L.Rev. 68 (1990) 845-865
54. S.H. Kadish, "Letting patients die: Legal and moral reflections", Cal.L.Rev. 80 (1992) 871-878
55. S.G. Post, "Alzheimer disease and the 'then' self ", Kennedy Institute of Ethics Journal 5 (1995) 313-314
56. M. Donnelly, "Best interests, patient participation and the Mental Capacity Act 2005", Med. L. Rev. 17 (2009) 25-29
57. J. Samanta, "Lasting powers of attorney for healthcare under the Mental Capacity Act 2005: enhanced prospective self-determination for future incapacity or a simulacrum?", Med. L. Rev. 17 (2009) 385.
58. http://www.ethikrat.org
59. H.J.J. Leenen, J.K.M. Gevers and J. Legemaate, Handboek Gezondheidsrecht, Deel I, Rechten van Mensen in de Gezondheidszorg, (Houten: Bohn Stafleu van Loghum, 2007) 209-210
60. A. Jaworska, "Respecting the margins of agency: Alzheimer's patients and the capacity to value", Phil. &Pub. Aff. 28 (1999) 105-138.
61. R.S. Olick, Taking advance directives seriously. Prospective autonomy and decisions near the end-of-life, (Washington: Georgetown University Press, 2001) 192-194
62. R.L.P. Berghmans, "Ethical hazards of the substituted judgement test in decision-making concerning the endof-life of dementia patients", Int. J. Geriat. Psychiatry 12 (1997) 283-287. (Pubitemid 27148446)