Chinese herbal medicines for treatment of hand, foot and mouth disease: A systematic review of randomized clinical trials

European Journal of Integrative Medicine

Volumn 4, Issue 1, 2012, Pages

  Cao, Huijuan ^a   Liu, Zhaolan ^a   Steinmann, Peter ^a   Mu, Yujie ^a   Luo, Hui ^a   Liu, Jianping ^a  

^a BEIJING UNIVERSITY OF CHINESE MEDICINE   (China)

Author keywords

Chinese herbal medicine; Foot; Hand; Meta analysis; Mouth disease; Systematic review

Indexed keywords

ANTIVIRUS AGENT; CHAIHUANG; CHINESE DRUG; CHIQIAO QINGRE; CHUANHUNING; DAZI DECOCTION; GANLUXIAODU DAN; GANLUXIAODUDAN; GEGENQINLIAN TANG; HERBACEOUS AGENT; JIDAIYU DECOCTION; JIEDUXIAOZHEN; KANGFUXIN; KANGGAN; LIANBIZHI; LONICERA EXTRACT; PUDILAN; QINGKAILING; QINGRENING; QINGREXIEHUO DECOCTION; REDUNING; RIBAVIRIN; SHUANGHUANGLIAN; TANREQING; UNCLASSIFIED DRUG; UNINDEXED DRUG; XIYANPING; XUEBIJING; YANHUNING; YINQIAOHUOYIN TANG; YINQIAOSAN;

ABSENCE OF SIDE EFFECTS; ANDROGRAPHIS; ANTIPYRETIC ACTIVITY; CHINA; CHINESE HERB; DIARRHEA; DRUG EFFECT; HAND FOOT AND MOUTH DISEASE; HERBAL MEDICINE; HUMAN; INTESTINE MOTILITY; LEUKOCYTE COUNT; LONICERA; META ANALYSIS; NAUSEA; PRIORITY JOURNAL; RANDOMIZED CONTROLLED TRIAL (TOPIC); RASH; SHORT SURVEY; SIDE EFFECT; SYSTEMATIC REVIEW; THROMBOCYTE COUNT; TREATMENT OUTCOME; ULCER HEALING; VIRAL CLEARANCE;

EID: 84857634330     PISSN: 18763820     EISSN: 18763839     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.eujim.2011.11.004     Document Type: Short Survey

References (100)

1. Frydenberg A., Starr M. Hand: foot and mouth disease. Australian Family Physician 2003, 32(8):594-595.
2. Emond R.T.D., Welsby P.D., Rowland H.A.K. Colour atlas of infectious disease 2003, Elsevier Science Limited, pp. 194-195.
3. Kushner D., Caldwell B.D. Hand, foot and mouth disease. Journal of the American Podiatric Medical Association 1996, 86(6):257-259.
4. Robinson C.R. Report of an outbreak of febrile illness with pharyngeal lesions and exanthema, Toronto, summer 1957 - Isolation of Group A Coxsackievirus. Canadian Medical Association Journal 1958, 79:615-621.
5. Goh K.T., Doraisingham S., Tan J.L., Lim G.N., Chew S.E. An outbreak of hand, foot, and mouth disease in Singapore. Bulletin of the World Health Organization 1982, 60(6):965-969.
6. Chang L.Y., Lin T.Y., Hsu K.H., Huang Y.C., Lin K.L., Hsueh C., et al. Clinical features and risk factors of pulmonary oedema after enterovirus-71-related hand, foot, and mouth disease. The Lancet 1999, 354:1682-1686.
7. Yao X.J., Hao C., Xu H., Chen C., Zhang H.L., Deng Y.M. Investigation of the risk factors of hand, foot and mouth disease in Changzhou. Acta Universitatis Medicinalis Nanjing (Natural Science) 2010, 30(9):1275-1278.
8. Li S.T. Analysis of HFMD epidemiology and risk factors in Hebei district of Tianjin from 2008 to 2009. Port Health Control 2010, 15(4):26-28.
9. Cao M.H., Liu H., Wan J.F., Zhu L.Y. A case-control study of severe case of hand, foot and mouth disease (EV71) in Fuyang City, Anhui Province. Anhui Journal of Preventive Medicine 2010, 16(1):19-20.
10. Ministry of Health of The People's Republic of China. Report of epidemic situation of infectious disease in China from January of 2010 to January of 2011. http://www.moh.gov.cn/publicfiles/business/htmlfiles/mohjbyfkzj/s3578/201102/50646.htm.
11. Lighton L. Hand, foot and mouth disease. British Journal of Infection Control 2001, 2(2):28.
12. Yang H.S., Yang W., Li N., Tian Y.M., Zhang J.Y., Li X.H. Analysis of characteristics of the cause of hand, foot and mouth disease based on traditional Chinese medicine theory [in Chinese]. Global Traditional Chinese Medicine 2010, 3(6):413-415.
13. Li B.Q. Development of the medical treatment for hand, foot and mouth disease. PJCCPVD 2011, 19(6):1064-1065.
14. Jiang X.J., Zhang Y. Clinical observation of Qingkailing for hand, foot and mouth disease [in Chinese]. Journal of Clinical and Experimental Medicine 2006, 5(10):1610.
15. Chen Y.H. Clinical observation of therapeutic effect of Shuanghuanglian Injection on treatment of infantile hand, foot and mouth disease [in Chinese]. Chinese Journal of Integrated Traditional and Western Medicine in Intensive Critical Care 2006, 13(1):47.
16. Gong Z.A. Observation of Yinqiao Daochi San on treatment for 76 children with hand, foot and mouth disease. Clinical Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine 2007, 19(5):463.
17. Cochrane handbook for systematic reviews of interventions version 5.0.2 [updated September 2009] 2009, The Cochrane Collaboration, [Available from www.cochrane-handbook.org]. J.P.T. Higgins, S. Green (Eds.).
18. Cai H.W. Effect analysis on Chuanhuning for hand, foot and mouth disease. Journal of Pediatric Pharmacy 2001, 7(1):38.
19. Cai J.Y., Zhao Z. Effect observation on Xiyanping in treating children with hand foot and mouth disease. Medical Journal of Communications 2010, 4:440-441.
20. Chen Z.M. Effect analysis on Xiyanping adjuvant therapy of hand foot and mouth disease. Modern Medicine & Health 2010, 3:431-432.
21. Cheng H.Q., Huang C.H., Yao Z.C. Study of Yinqiao San modified in children with hand, foot, and mouth disease. Modern Journal of Integrated Traditional Chinese and Western Medicine 2009, 18(14):1585-1586.
22. Cheng H.J. Effect of acyclovir combined with Honeysuckle for hand, foot and mouth disease. Jilin Medical Journal 2010, 15:2223-2224.
23. Cheng Y.M., Ren X.H., Wen J.Z., Kui Y. Dazi decoction for 60 patients with hand, foot and mouth disease. JETCM 2010, 19(4):675.
24. Deng C.L., Wu Effect observation on Yanhuning injection for hand foot and mouth disease. Practical Clinical Medicine 2010, 2:87-88.
25. Deng S.Z., Huang J., Cl Z. A controlled study of Interferon combined with Andragrapholide for treatment in children with hand, foot and mouth disease. Public Medical Forum Magazine 2010, 13:390-392.
26. Ding S. Tanreqing injection treated 52 cases with hand foot and mouth disease. Zhejiang Journal of Integrated Traditional Chinese and Western Medicine 2011, 3:183-184.
27. Ding H.L., Li X.R. Treatment of 40 cases of infantile hand, foot, and mouth disease by modified Jidaiyu decoction. Shanghai Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine 2004, 38(6):37-38.
28. Fan M.Y. Clinical observation on Tanreqing injection in treating children with hand foot and mouth disease. Chinese Journal of Clinical Rational Drug Use 2010, 6:38.
29. Feng F.Y., Cen Y. Effect comparison on Yanhuning and ganciclovir in outpatient treatment of mild hand foot and mouth disease. Chinese Journal of Coal Industry Medicine 2010, 10:1454-1455.
30. Guo W.Z., Wu S.L., Wang S., Pan Q.H., Zhang J.F., Mao B.R. Observation on effectiveness of ribavirin combined with combined with Ganlu Xiaodu dan for treatment of infantile hand, foot and mouth disease. Medicine Innovation Research 2008, 5(12):73-74.
31. Guo X.Y., Xu Y.P., Fang J.Q. Clinical observation on Qingkailing granule as assisted treatment for 80 cases of hand, foot, and mouth disease. Journal of Emergency Traditional Chinese Medicine 2009, 18(9):1449-1450.
32. Hao S.L. Clinical observation on Qingkailing injection 48 cases of hand foot and mouth disease. Modern Journal of Integrated Traditional Chinese and Western Medicine 2011, 2:261.
33. He Y.P. Observation of efficacy on hand, foot, and mouth disease treated with integrated Chinese and Western medicine. World Journal of Integrated Traditional Chinese and Western Medicine 2009, 4(2):103-104.
34. Hu Y.L., He C.X., Xu L.Z. Clinical observation on Yanhuning Injection for infantile hand, foot, and mouth disease. Inner Mongolia Medicine Journal 2009, 41(9):1110-1111.
35. Huang R.W., Li L.Y., Yang R.Y., Du Z.Q. Clinical study on effect of Reduning injection for foot, hand, and mouth disease. China Modern Medicine 2009, 16(22):49-50.
36. Huang R.W., Li L.Y., Yang R.Y., Du Z.Q. Study on effect of Tanreqing injection for hand, foot, and mouth disease. Journal of Emergency Traditional Chinese Medicine 2009, 18(12):1983-1984.
37. Huang S.P. Clinical analysis on Yanhuning injection combined with ribavirin in treating children with hand foot and mouth disease. Internal Medicine of China 2010, 6:605-606.
38. Huang X.H., Zheng M. Treatment of hand, foot, and mouth disease by Qingre Xiehuo tang: a clinical observation of 50 cases. New Traditional Chinese Medicine 2004, 36(7):27-28.
39. Huang Z.G., Ling J. Observation on effect of Shuanghuanglian for hand, foot, and mouth disease. China Practical Medicine ZSSA 2009, 4(28):128-129.
40. Jiang X., Hu A., He W. Observation on Tanreqing injection in treating 193 infants with hand foot and mouth disease. Zhejiang Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine 2010, 1:74.
41. Li L.J. Integrated traditional Chinese and Western medicine in treating non-severe type of hand, foot and mouth disease. Guide of China Medicine 2011, 6:296-297.
42. Li P. Clinical effect analysis on Lianbizhi in adjuvant therapy of children hand foot and mouth disease. Anhui Medical Journal 2010, 6:663-664.
43. Li Q.X. Summary of Yinqiao Huoyin tang in treating 68 children with hand, foot, and mouth disease. Hunan Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine 2006, 22(3). 31, 37.
44. Li S.L., Nie Z., Peng Z. Tanreqing combined with ribavirin in treating 200 cases with hand foot and mouth disease. Journal of Emergency in Traditional Chinese Medicine 2010, 4:675-676.
45. Liang X.L. Clinical study on acyclovir combined herbal retention enema therapy of hand, foot and mouth disease. Medical Innovation of China 2010, 7:34.
46. Lin Y.Q. Evaluation of clinical therapeutic effect of Xiyanping on oral ulcerations of hand, foot, and mouth disease in children. Modern Hospital 2008, 8(6):51-52.
47. Liu M. Clinical observation on Gegen Qinlian tang modified for infantile hand, foot, and mouth disease. Journal of Guangxi Traditional Chinese Medical University 2006, 9(1):27-28.
48. Liu W.D. Observation on efficacy of Bonner plus Chimonanthus leaf particles treatment of HFMD. Chinese Journal of Misdiagnosis 2008, 8(28):6838-6839.
49. Lu N. Observation on effect of Reduning injection for treatment of 27 children with hand, foot, and mouth disease. Journal of Emergency Traditional Chinese Medicine 2009, 18(10):1615-1616.
50. Luo X.S., Wei H. Clinical analysis on yanhuning injection combined with ribavirin in treating children with hand, foot and mouth disease. Chinese Community Doctors 2010, 17:128.
51. Ma J.H., Xu L.L. Clinical study of Tanreqing injection combined with ribavirin for infantile hand, foot, and mouth disease. Journal of Clinical and Experimental Medicine 2010, 9(02):143-144.
52. Ma Y.P., Guo Y., Kang L., Zhao L., Peng J., Luo G.Y., et al. Hand, foot and mouth disease in traditional Chinese medicine clinical analysis of 100 cases. Global Traditional Chinese Medicine 2010, 6:408-409.
53. Mao B.R., Xin J., Chen S.X., Wang L., Tian H., Li W.J. Observation on the curative effects of Xiyanping united with interferon to therapy the hand, foot, and mouth disease. West China Medical Journal 2009, 24(06):1524-1525.
54. Mei P. Effect of Pudilan antiphlogistic oral liquid in treating hand foot and mouth disease. Modern Journal of Integrated Traditional Chinese and Western Medicine 2010, 11:1345.
55. Miao D.X., Sun Y., Tan N.N. Therapeutic effects of Pudilan Xiaoyan oral liquid on children with hand, foot, and mouth disease. Journal of Pediatric Pharmacy 2009, 15(05):32-34.
56. Pan R., Chen M., Pan J., Wang X.G., Liu H.J. Therapeutic effects of dehydroandrographolide succinate combined with ribavirin on children with hand, foot and mouth disease. Anhui Medical Journal 2010, 12:1406-1407.
57. Peng H.B. Clinical study on Tanreqing for hand, foot and mouth disease. Modern Medicine & Health 2009, 25(16):2451-2452.
58. Shi Y.P., Li D., Li X., Dou Y.F. ChaiHuang granule combined with Kangfuxin liquid in treating 65 cases with hand, foot and mouth disease. Shaanxi Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine 2011, 3:283-285.
59. Sun Q.K. Effect observation on integrated traditional Chinese and western medicine for 38 children with hand foot and mouth disease. Yunnan Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine and Materia Medical 2011, 1:17-18.
60. Sun Y.F., Sj J. Clinical analysis on Tanreqing injection in treating hand foot and mouth disease. Clinical Medicine 2010, (07):92-93.
61. Tian Z.L., Song S.P. Clinical observation on the treatment of hand, foot, and mouth disease in children with decoction of detoxicating and slaking rasher combined with acyclovir. Guide of China Medicine 2008, 6(24):185-187.
62. Wang L., Liu J. Clinical observation of Xiaoer Chiqiao Qingre granule for 75 cases with hand foot and mouth disease. Modern Journal of Integrated Traditional Chinese and Western Medicine 2010, (32):4160.
63. Wang P. Observation on combination therapy of ribavirin and Kanggan Granules in treating hand, foot and mouth disease of children. Medical Information 2010, (12):3736.
64. Wang X.G., Zhang C., Bai W., Zuo L.Y., Yan Z.G. Clincal study on Lianhuaqingwen granule in treating hand foot and mouth disease. Journal of Medical Forum 2010, (22):183-184.
65. Wang Y.P., Li Z.J., Wang F.C., Zhang J.M., Liu L., Chen H.B. Study on traditional Chinese medicine for infantile hand, foot, and mouth disease according to symptoms pattern. China Pediatric Integrated Traditional and Western Medicine 2009, 1(4):366-367.
66. Wei X.L., Meng T., Mo W.M. Effect observation on Tanreqing combined with ribavirin in treating hand foot and mouth disease complicated with pneumonia. Journal of Youjiang Medical University for Nationalities 2010, 05:742-743.
67. Wu Y.H., Shao G.Q., Zhang J.F. Observation on effect of ribavirin tablet combined with Pudilan Xiaoyan oral liquid for treatment of children with hand, foot, and mouth disease. Guide of China Medicine 2009, 7(4):85-86.
68. Xi R.H., Li H., Luo Y., Xi Y.N. Effect on differentiation of symptoms and conventional treatment for hand, foot and mouth disease. Clinical Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine 2010, (07):587-589.
69. Xin S.X., Wang X.M., Jia L. Clinical research of Reduning injection for hand, foot, and mouth disease. Chinese Journal of Primary Medicine and Pharmacy 2009, 16(7):1281-1282.
70. Xin Y.N., Qu Y., Wang Y. Clinical observation on Huangzhi flower oral liquid in treating children hand foot and mouth disease. Journal of Baotou Medical College 2010, (06):80-81.
71. Xing H.Z., Tian Z.L., Duan Z.M. Liangxue Jiedu tang in treating 47 children with hand, foot, and mouth disease. Journal of Shangdong Traditional Chinese Medicine 2009, 28(08):540-541.
72. Xu H., Han G., Li H., Rao R.X., Huang G.Q. Clinical observation on Jinzhen oral liquid for 96 children with hand foot and mouth disease. Hebei Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine 2011, (02):259-260.
73. Xu R., Deng Y.Y., Lu X., Guan D.X., Tan Y., Li Y.X. 1st HFMD herbal medicine for 278 cases with hand foot and mouth disease. Chinese Journal of Integrated Traditional and Western Medicine 2010, 06:662-663.
74. Xu Z.F., Huang F. Observation on effect of Yanhuning for infantile hand, foot, and mouth disease. Journal of Emergency Traditional Chinese Medicine 2009, 18(7):1077-1078.
75. Yang P.Y., Hao J., Yang Z. Clinical observation of Lian Zi Tang for rectal instillation therapy on 110 cases with hand foot and mouth disease. Chinese Journal of Clinical Research 2010, (10):923-924.
76. Yang Z.J., Zhao Y.C., Liao Y.X., Wu Y.X., Xiong Y.L., Zhong X.J., et al. Clinical effect of Yanhuning in the treatment of infantile hand, foot, and mouth disease. Journal of Tropical Medicine 2009, 9(10):1171-1172.
77. Yao B.Y., Zh X. Observation on Chuanhuning injection on 33 cases with hand, foot and mouth disease. Zhejiang Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine 2011, (03):190.
78. Yuan B.B., Zhang J., Zhao L. Clinical observation on Tanreqing combined with Ribavirin for hand foot and mouth disease. Clinical Medicine 2010, (11):108-109.
79. Zeng Q.S. Clinical effect comparison of two methods in the treatment of children with hand foot and mouth disease. Practical Preventive Medicine 2010, (12):2479-2480.
80. Zhan G.Y., Dong S.H., Liu Y., Chen M.J., Han Z.D., Lin Y. Observation of efficacy and safety of Reduning injection in treating hand foot and mouth disease. Guide of China Medicine 2010, (26):117-118.
81. Zhang H. Clinical observation on Xiyanping in treating children with hand foot and mouth disease. Journal of Pediatric Pharmacy 2010, (03):61-62.
82. Zhang J.W., Zhang Y.C. Study on effect of Xiyanping combined with ribavirin for hand, foot, and mouth disease. Medical and Pharmaceutical World 2009, 11(05):119-120.
83. Zhang N., Yuang D. Jinlan mixture for 68 children with hand, foot, and mouth disease. Fujian Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine 2003, 34(1):30-31.
84. Zhang Q.P., Chu H.R., Cheng H.L., Li T.F., Tang J., Yang J. Analysis of therapeutic effect on hand, foot, and mouth disease treated with pricking moxibustion combined with medicine. World Journal of Acupuncture-Moxibustion SJJA 2009, 19(03):14-19.
85. Zhang W. Observation on effect of traditional Chinese and western medicine for infantile hand, foot, and mouth disease. China Medical Herald 2008, 5(7):81-82.
86. Zhang W.H. Effect of ribavirin aerosol combined with Pudilan Anti-inflammatory decoction for infantile hand, foot, and mouth disease. China Tropical Medicine 2009, 9(05):856-857.
87. Zhang X. Clinical analysis on comprehensive treatment for children with hand foot and mouth disease. Chinese Journal of Practical Nervous Diseases 2011, (04):26-28.
88. Zhang Y. Xiehuangsan in treating 60 children with hand, foot, and mouth disease. Journal of New Chinese Medicine 2007, 39(9):75-76.
89. Zhao J.W., Sun B.X. Observation on effect of Reduning for hand, foot, and mouth disease. Chinese Journal of Medicinal Guide 2009, 11(6):1002-1003.
90. Zheng H., Li Yh Clinical observation heat clearing enema in treating fever of hand foot and mouth disease. Journal of Changchun University of Traditional Chinese Medicine 2010, 26(2):250-251.
91. Zhi Z.Q., Qin W. Observation of the effect of Yanhuning injection (Potassium sodium Pehydroandroandrographolide succinate injection) on children with hand, foot, and mouth disease. China Modern Doctor 2008, 46(13):94-95.
92. Zhong Z.W., Yan X.R., Zhou Z.M. Observation on the results of treatment of infantile hand, foot, and mouth disease with addition of Yanhuning. China Tropical Medicine 2007, 7(11):2048.
93. Zhu X.L., Yang J.S., Li H.Z. Study on effect of Yanhuning injection for treatment of children with hand, foot, and mouth disease. Practical Clinical Medicine 2009, 10(3). 85, 87.
94. Ding H. Observation of Tanreqing injection on the treatment of 36 cases of children hand foot and mouth disease. Practical Pharmacy and Clinical Remedies 2008, 11(2):87-88.
95. Li B. Observation on effect of integrated traditional Chinese and Western medicine in treating 13 cases of infantile hand, foot, and mouth disease. China Modern Doctor 2008, 46(24):139.
96. Tang Y.B. Observation on effect of Tanreqing injection combined with ribavirin for hand, foot, and mouth disease. Chinese Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine 2009, 21(5):426.
97. Wu Y.H. Clinical observation of integrated traditional Chinese and Western medicine for hand: foot and mouth disease. Modern Clinical Nursing 2009, 8(3):38-39.
98. Zhang L.X. Clinical observation on the treatment of 32 cases of children hand foot and mouth disease with modified Yinqiaosan. Guiding Journal of TCM 2007, 13(9). pp. 43, 48.
99. Li C.X., Zhao W. Treatment of 100 cases of hand: foot and mouth disease by integrative Chinese and Western medicine. Shanghai Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine 2009, 43(9):35-36.
100. CONSORT Statement 2001-Checklist: Items to include when reporting a randomized trial. http://www.consort-statement.org/.