The Buncefield explosion: Were the resulting overpressures really unforeseeable?

Process Safety Progress

Volumn 31, Issue 1, 2012, Pages 55-71

  Taveau, Jérôme ^a  

^a INSTITUT DE RADIOPROTECTION ET DE SÛRETÉ NUCLÉAIRE IRSN   (France)

Author keywords

Baker Strehlow Tang method; Bang box; Buncefield; Congestion assessment method; DDT; Explosion; GAME; Kinsella; MERGE; Multi energy method; Overpressures

Indexed keywords

ASSESSMENT METHODS; BAKER-STREHLOW-TANG METHOD; BANG-BOX; BUNCEFIELD; DDT; GAME; KINSELLA; MERGE; MULTI-ENERGY METHOD; OVER-PRESSURES;

EXPLOSION TESTING; EXPLOSIONS;

EXPLOSIVES;

EID: 84856704718     PISSN: 10668527     EISSN: 15475913     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1002/prs.10468     Document Type: Article

References (49)

1. Buncefield Major Incident Investigation Board, "The Buncefield Incident 11 December 2005, The final report of the Major Incident Investigation Board, Vol. 2." Crown copyright, 2008.
2. D.M. Johnson, The potential for vapour cloud explosions: Lessons from the Buncefield accident. J Loss Prevent Proc 23 (2010), 921-927.
3. K. Van Wingerden, Investigations of the Buncefield accident, GexCon Industry Seminar, Institut de Radioprotection et de Sûreté Nucléaire (IRSN), Fontenay aux Roses, France, November 2009.
4. S. Davis, P. Hinze, O. Hansen andK. van Wingerden, 2005 Buncefield vapour cloud explosion: Unraveling the mystery of the blast, Interflam' 2010, Vol. 2, 1365-1374, Interscience communications, London, UK.
5. K.G. Kinsella, A rapid assessment methodology for the prediction of vapour cloud explosion overpressure, Proceedings of the International Conference and Exhibition on Safety, Health and Loss Prevention in the Oil, Chemical and Process Industries, Singapore, 1993, 200-211.
6. A.T. Cates, Fuel gas explosion guidelines, Conference on Fire and Explosion Hazards, Moreton-in-Marsh, April 1991, 53-62.
7. A.J. Pierorazio, J.K. Thomas, Q.A. Baker andD.E. Ketchum, An update to the Baker-Strehlow-Tang vapor cloud explosion prediction methodology flame speed table. Process Saf Prog 24 (2005), 59-65.
8. J.B.M.M. Eggen, GAME: Development of guidance for the application of the multi-energy method, TNO report PML 1995-C44, 1995.
9. Buncefield Major Incident Investigation Board, Explosion Mechanism Advisory Group report, 2007, Crown copyright, 2007.
10. Buncefield Major Incident Investigation Board, Initial Report to the Health and Safety Commission and the Environment Agency of the Investigation into the Explosions and Fires at the Buncefield Oil Storage and Transfer Depot, Hemel Hempstead, on 11 December 2005, Health and Safety Executive, Crown copyright, 2006.
11. B. Burgan, Buncefield explosion mechanism, Phase 1, Steel Construction Institute for the Health and Safety Executive, Research Report 718, 2009.
12. Fire And Blast Information Group (FABIG), The Buncefield explosion mechanism, Technical Meeting n°58, 1st presentation, Overpressure and directional indicators, Tam, V., British Petroleum, London, June 2009.
13. Buncefield Major Incident Investigation Board, The Buncefield Incident 11 December 2005, The Final Report of the Major Incident Investigation Board, Vol. 1, Crown copyright, 2008.
14. S. Mannan, The Buncefield explosion and fire - Lessons learned. Process Saf Prog 30 (2011), 138-142.
15. French Ministry of the Environment, Circulaire DPPR/SEI2/AL-07-0257 du 23/07/07 relative à l'évaluation des risques et des distances d'effets autour des dépôts de liquides inflammables et des dépôts de gaz inflammables liquéfiés, 2007.
16. J.S. Puttock, Fuel gas explosion guidelines: The congestion assessment method. Inst Chem Eng Symp Ser 139 (1995), 267-284.
17. J.S. Puttock, Improvements in guidelines for prediction of vapour-cloud explosions, International Conference and Workshop on Modeling the Consequences of Accidental Releases of Hazardous Materials, San Francisco, September-October 1999, 541-569.
18. Q.A. Baker, M.J. Tang, E.A. Scheier andG.J. Silva, Vapor cloud explosion analysis. Process Saf Prog 15 (1996), 106-109.
19. Q.A. Baker, C.M. Doolittle, G.A. Fitzgerald andM.J. Tang, Recent developments in the Baker-Strehlow VCE analysis methodology. Process Saf Prog 17 (1998), 297-301.
20. M.J. Tang andQ.A. Baker, A new set of blast curves from vapor cloud explosion. Process Saf Prog 18 (1999), 235-240.
21. M.J. Tang andQ.A. Baker, Comparison of blast curves from vapor cloud explosions. J Loss Prevent Proc 13 (2000), 433-438.
22. J.K. Thomas, A.J. Pierorazio, M. Goodrich, M. Kolbe, Q.A. Baker andD.E. Ketchum, Deflagration to detonation transition in unconfined vapor cloud explosions, Center for Chemical Process Safety (CCPS), Proceedings of the 18th Annual International Conference & Workshop, Scottsdale, 2003.
23. A.J. Pierorazio, J.K. Thomas, Q.A. Baker andD.E. Ketchum, An update to the Baker-Strehlow-Tang vapor cloud explosion prediction methodology flame speed table, 38th Loss Prevention Symposium, AIChE Spring National Meeting, 2004.
24. G.I. Taylor, The air wave surrounding an expanding sphere, Proc Roy Soc London. Series A 186 (1946), 273-292.
25. A.C. Van den Berg, The multi-energy method. A framework for vapour cloud explosion blast prediction. J Hazard Mater 12 (1985), 1-10.
26. A.C. Van den Berg andA. Lannoy, Methods for vapour cloud explosion blast modelling. J Hazard Mater 34 (1993), 151-171.
27. Committee for the Prevention of Disasters, Methods for the Calculation of Physical Effects of the Escape of Dangerous Materials, CPR14E, 3rd ed., Holland, (1997).
28. W.P.M. Mercx andA.C. Van den Berg, The explosion blast prediction model in the revised CPR 14E (yellow book). Process Saf Prog 16 (1997), 152-159.
29. W.P.M. Mercx, Large-scale experimental investigation into vapour cloud explosions, comparison with the small scale DISCOE-trials, 7th International Symposium on Loss Prevention and Safety Promotion in the Process Industries, Vol. 4, Taormina, Italy, 1-20, 1992.
30. C.A. Leal andG.F. Santiago, Do tree belts increase risk of explosion for LPG spheres?. J Loss Prevent Proc 17 (2004), 217-224.
31. C.J.M. Van Wingerden, Experimental investigation into the strength of blast waves generated by vapour cloud explosions in congested areas, 6th International Symposium on Loss Prevention and Safety Promotion in the Process Industries, Oslo, Norway, 1989.
32. R.J. Harris andM.J. Wickens, Understanding vapour cloud explosions: an experimental study, 55th Autumn Meeting of the Institution of Gas Engineers, Kensington, UK, 1989.
33. D. Bjerketvedt, J.R. Bakke andK. Van Wingerden, Gas explosion handbook. J Hazard Mater 52 (1997), 1-150.
34. J.E.S. Venart, Buncefield: Cause and consequences, ESREL 2010 Conference, Greece, 5-9 September 2010.
35. A.J. Harisson andJ.A. Eyre, The effect of obstacle arrays on the combustion of large premixed gas/air clouds. Combust Sci Technol 52 (1987), 121-137.
36. A.J. Harisson andJ.A. Eyre, Vapor cloud explosions: the effect of obstacles and jet ignition on the combustion of gas clouds, 5th International Symposium on Loss Prevention and Safety Promotion in the Process Industries, Cannes, 1986.
37. I.O. Moen, D. Bjerketvedt, A. Jenssen andP.A. Thibault, Transition to detonation in a large fuel-air cloud. Combust Flame 61 (1985), 285-291.
38. I.O. Moen, D. Bjerketvedt, T. Engebretsen, A. Jenssen, B.H. Hjertager andJ.R. Bakke, Transition to detonation in a flame jet. Combust Flame 75 (1989), 297-308.
39. D.J. McKay, S.B. Murray, I.O. Moen andP.A. Thibault, Flame-jet ignition of large fuel-air clouds, 22nd International Symposium on Combustion, 1339-1353, 1988.
40. G.M. Makhviladze andS.E. Yakush, Large scale unconfined fires and explosions. Proc Combust Inst, Volume 29, Issue 1, pp. 195-210, 2002.
41. D.S. Burgess andM.G. Zabetakis, Detonation of a flammable cloud following a propane pipeline break, US Bureau of Mines, Report ofinvestigation 7752, US Department of the Interior, 1973.
42. D.C. Bull, Gas detonation hazards, Proceedings of conference: The Control & Prevention of Gas Explosions, 1983.
43. Analyse, Recherche, et Information sur les Accidents (ARIA), Explosion suivie d'un incendie dans un dépôt d'hydrocarbures le 7 Octobre 1991 - Saint-Herblain (44) - France, Ministère chargé de l'environnement - DPPR/SEI/BARPI, fiche n°2914, 2006.
44. J.F. Lechaudel, Y. Mouilleau andG. Russeil, Saint-Herblain, le 7 Octobre 1991 - Déroulement de l'accident, analyse des effets, Journée professionnelle INERIS - Retour d'expérience, les accidents dans les dépôts d'hydrocarbures, Lyon, Janvier 1996.
45. J.F. Lechaudel andY. Mouilleau, Assesment of an accidental vapour cloud explosion - A case study: Saint Herblain, October 7th 1991, France, 8th International Symposium on Loss Prevention and Safety Promotion in the Process Industries, Anvers, 1995.
46. G. Atkinson, S.E. Gant, D. Painter, L. Shirvill andA. Ungut, Liquid dispersal and vapour production during overfilling incidents, Proceedings of IChemE Hazards XX Symposium & Workshop, Manchester, UK, 15-17 April 2008.
47. S. Coldrick, G.T. Atkinson andS.E. Gant, Large scale evaporating liquid cascades - An experimental and computational study, Proceedings of IChemE Hazards XXII Symposium & Workshop, Liverpool, UK, 11-14 April 2011.
48. Fire And Blast Information Group (FABIG), Innovations for the prevention, detection, control and mitigation of fires and explosions, Technical Meeting n°62, 2nd presentation, Large flammable vapour clouds - how they form... and what the risks are, Atkinson, G., Health and Safety Laboratory, London, June 2010.
49. M. Van Wingerden andB. Wilkins, Experimental investigation of the effect of flexible obstructions on flame propagation in vapour cloud explosions, GexCon report no. GexCon-08-F44110-RA-1, rev 01, 2008.