Legal briefing: Futile or non-beneficial treatment

Journal of Clinical Ethics

Volumn 22, Issue 3, 2011, Pages 277-296

  Pope, Thaddeus Mason ^a  

^a WIDENER UNIVERSITY   (United States)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

ARTICLE; CANADA; ETHICS; HUMAN; INFORMED CONSENT; LEGAL ASPECT; LIVING WILL; MENTAL CAPACITY; PROFESSIONAL STANDARD; TREATMENT OUTCOME; TREATMENT WITHDRAWAL; UNITED STATES; UNNECESSARY PROCEDURE;

ADVANCE DIRECTIVES; CANADA; ETHICS COMMITTEES, CLINICAL; HUMANS; INFORMED CONSENT; MEDICAL FUTILITY; MENTAL COMPETENCY; ONTARIO; TEXAS; THIRD-PARTY CONSENT; UNITED STATES; UNNECESSARY PROCEDURES; WITHHOLDING TREATMENT;

EID: 84855537695     PISSN: 10467890     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: None     Document Type: Article

References (145)

1. J. Hardwig, "Families and Futility: Forestalling Demands for Futile Treatment", The Journal of Clinical Ethics 16, no. 4(Winter 2005):335-44.
2. T. M. Pope, "Legal Briefing: Medical Futility and Assisted Suicide", The Journal of Clinical Ethics 20, no. 3(Fall 2009):274-86.
3. T. M. Pope, "Legal Update", The Journal of Clinical Ethics 21, no. 1(Spring 2010):83-5.
4. T. M. Pope and E. A. Waldman, "Mediation at the End-of-Life: Getting Beyond the Limits of the Talking Cure", Ohio State Journal on Dispute Resolution 23, no. 1(2007):143-94;
5. T. M. Pope, "Medical Futility", in Guidance for Healthcare Ethics Committees, ed. M. D. Hester and T. Schonfeld (Gambridge, U. K.: Cambridge University Press, forthcoming, 2012).
6. L. Ballinger, "Did Hospital Turn Off Mother's Life Support Machine to Save Cash?" Daily Mail, 2 February 2010 (reporting case of Lai-Mai Pang-Cheung).
7. D. L. Shelton, "Mom: 'They Are My Babies' Conjoined Twins Locked in Battle for Life", Chicago Tribune, 8 June 2010.
8. "A Medical Miracle: Conjoined Twins Kameron and Kaydon Celebrate their First Birthday", Daily Mail, 4 April 2011.
9. E. A. Roy, "Parents Refused to Let Daughter Die", Stuff, 3 July 2011.
10. N. Adlam, "Stroke Victim's Miracle Survival", NT News, 11 May 2011.
11. "De har Ratt att Avbryta Meningslos Behandling", Expressen, 5 February 2010.
12. V. Allen and A. Levy, "Doctors Told Me it was against the Rules to Save My Premature Baby", Daily Mail, 9 September 2009.
13. T. Cohen, "They Left My Baby to Die in My Arms", Daily Mail, 20 April 2011.
14. "My Baby Lived for 46 minutes, but Doctors Didn't Help Him", Southend Standard, 17 March 2011.
15. C. Lindell, "Sensitive Topic of Futile Medical Care Faces Long Road in Legislature", Austin-American Statesman, 8 May 2011;
16. E. Ramshaw, "Texas End-of-Life Bills Appear Dead", Texas Tribune, 23 May 2011;
17. J. Tone, "How Long Should Texas Docs Treat Untreatable Patients? The Debate That Won't Go Away", Dallas Observer, 8 July 2011.
18. T. Ackerman, "Teen's Move Sidesteps Futile-Care Controversy", Houston Chronicle, 1 July 2011;
19. L. Frillici, "Family Fights to Keep Teen Alive as Hospital Decides to End Life Support", KHOU 11 News, 30 June 2011;
20. T. Ackerman, "Brain Cancer Patient Going Home after Texas Children's Hospital Had Invoked Futile Care Law", Houston Chronicle, 23 August 2011.
21. Hartford Hospital Ethics Committee, "A Summit-Medical Futility: Medicine, Law and Ethics", 21 October 2010, http://www.harthosp.org/ Portals/1/Images/6/Ethics-Summit-Program.pdf, accessed 3 September 2011.
22. T. M. Pope, "Medical Futility and Maryland Law", Mid-Atlantic Ethics Committee Newsletter, Winter 2011, 1-3.
23. California Medical Association, 2009 House of Delegates, "Resolution 506-09: End-of-Life Care and Futile Treatment", http://sdcms.org/files/ 2009HODCommERes.pdf, accessed 3 September 2011.
24. Betancourt v. Trinitas Hospital, No. A-003849-08T2 (N. J. Sup. Ct. A. D. 7 August 2009) (Brief of New Jersey Hospital Association, Catholic Healthcare Partnership of New Jersey, and Medical Society of New Jersey), http://thaddeuspope.com/images/Betancourt-NJHA-CHP-MSNJ-amicus-small-.pdf, accessed 3 September 2011.
25. New York State Bar Association Health Law Section, Summary Report on Healthcare Costs: Legal Issues, Barriers and Solutions (September 2009).
26. Washington State Medical Association, 2010 House of Delegates, "Resolution A-2: WSMA Opinion on Medical Futility in End-of-Life Care", http://www.wsma.org/files/Downloads/AboutUs/pdf/Official-Actions- 2010.pdf, accessed 12 August 2011.
27. http://www.ccboard.on. ca/scripts/english/index.asp, accessed 12 August 2011.
28. The Yukon has a similar tribunal called the Capability and Consent Board, http:www.yukoncapabilityandconsent board.ca, accessed 12 August 2011.
29. M. Handelman and B. Parke, "The Beneficial Role of a Judicial Process When 'Everything' Is Too Much", Healthcare Quarterly 11, no. 4(Winter 2008):46, 48.
30. in re B. T., 2011 CanLII 20996 (ON C. C. B.).
31. P. Criscione, "Pastor Centre of Pro-Life Battle", Brampton Guardian, 26 August 2010.
32. in re J. M., 2011 CanLII 7955 (ON C. C. B.).
33. R. D'Aliesso, "Ontario Infant at Centre of Ethics Debate Has Surgery in U. S.", Globe and Mail, 21 March 2011;
34. B. Bernhard, "Cardinal Glennon Chief Answers Plea for Help", St. Louis Post-Dispatch, 27 April 2011.
35. in re B. S., 2011 CanLII 23615 (ON C. C. B.).
36. T. M. Pope, "Surrogate Selection: An Increasingly Viable, but Limited, Solution to Intractable Futility Disputes", St. Louis University Journal of Health Law and Policy 3, no. 2(2010):183-252.
37. in re S. S., 2011 CanLII 5000 (ON C. C. B.).
38. in re DW, 2011 CanLII 18217 (ON C. C. B.).
39. Li v. Sunnybrook Health Sciences Centre (22 October 2010) (Conway, J.).
40. Rasouli v. Sunnybrook Health Sciences Centre, 2011 ONSC 1500.
41. Rasouli v. Sunnybrook Health Sciences Centre, 2011 ONCA 482.
42. G. Stolz, "Final Hours Lost in Battle over Wife's Right to Life at Gold Coast Hospital", Courier-Mail, 6 April 2011. Radio interviews with the patient's husband and with the adult guardian are available at http://blogs.abc.net.au/files/adult-ethics-mornings-l.mp3 and http://blogs.abc.net.au/files/ziv-on-mornings-2.mp3, accessed 12 August 2011.
43. Report of the WRHA Working Group on Withholding and Withdrawing Life-Sustaining Treatment (22 March 2011), http://www.wrha.mb.ca/healthinfo/ reports/files/EndOflAfe-Report.pdf, accessed 12 August 2011;
44. "Withholding/Withdrawing Life-Sustaining Treatment: WRHA Board Working Group Report", December 2010, http://www.wrha.mb.ca/healthinfo/ reports/files/EndOfLife-BoardReport.pdf, accessed 12 August 2011.
45. WRHA, "Access to End-of-Life Supports and Resources to Increase for Patients, Families and Professionals", 25 March 2011, http://www.wrha.mb. ca/media/releases/2011/110325.php, accessed 12 August 2011.
46. D. L. Shelton, "Hospital Says Elderly Woman Ready for Discharge; Daughter Says No", Chicago Tribune, 8 November 2010.
47. Cardoza v. U. S. C. University Hospital, No. B195092, 2008 WL 3413312 (Cal. App. 13 August 2008) (reversing demurrers granted to careproviders because: [1] they were bound to comply with the patient's directive, [2] the patient's agent "was not authorized to depart" from the directive, and [3] compliance with an agent's decision that is at odds with the patient's directive does not qualify as "in good faith").
48. J. Sturges, "Public Guardian Often Can Help the Helpless", Naperville Sun, 26 July 2010.
49. in re Emergency Guardianship of Albert N. Barnes, No. 27-GC-PR-111-16 (Hennepin Cty. Dist. Ct., Probate Div., Minn., 11 February 2011) (Order).
50. Kisnerv. West Virginia University Hospitals, No. 10-C-190 (Monongalia Cty. Circuit Court, W. Va., 25 March 2010) (Verified Complaint).
51. B. Brubaker, "Woman in Coma out of Ruby: Bennett Still Needs Tracheal, Dialysis Treatment Facility", Dominion Post, 14 April 2010.
52. In one case, the infant patient's father admitted that his motivation for seeking to prevent the hospital from removing life support was to avoid charges of murder/homicide by continuing to artificially ventilate the infant's body for "a year and a day." Hernandez v. Abel., No. 08-2013 (4th Cir. 7 July 2010) (Brief of Appellee).
53. S. H. Foskett Jr., "A Family Decision-Judge Says Ventilator Removal Not Up to Court", Worcester Telegram, 25 June 2009;
54. B. B. Kush, "7-year-Old Removed from Life-Support, Pronounced Dead", Worcester Telegram, 27 June 2009.
55. P. Trexler, "Father Accused of Beating Girl Resists Removing Life Support", Akron Beacon-Journal, 9 April 2010.
56. "Judge Rules in Favor of Removing Life Support from Baby Jada", Akron Beacon-Journal, 16 July 2010.
57. State v. Below, 2011 WI APP 64 (2011).
58. A. Meisel and K. L. Cerminara, The Right to Die: the Law of End-of-Life Decisionmaking (New York: Aspen, 2010) § 3.24[C].
59. Betancourt v. Trinitas Hospital, No. UNN-C-12-09 (Union Cty. Sup. Ct., N. J.) (Trial Transcript), http://thaddeuspope.com/images/Transcript-order-to- show-cause-hearings-1.22.09,-2.17.09-2.23.09.pdf, accessed 12 August 2011.
60. S. I. v. R. S., 877 N. Y. S.2d 860 (2009).
61. D. Sontag, "Immigrant's Health Crisis Leaves Her Family on Sideline", New York Times, 3 March 2011.
62. D. Sontag, "Virginia: Judge Orders Nutrition for Immigrant in Nursing Home", New York Times, 11 March 2011.
63. J. Zick, "Man's Life in Court's Hands", Corning Leader, 22 June 2009;
64. R. Finger, "Wife Accused of Abuse Wants Guardianship of Husband", Star Gazette, 18 September 2009, 6A;
65. S. Cook and T. Fioraliso, "Gary Harvey's Daughter Speaks Out", WENY News, 16 December 2009.
66. "Court Allows Suit against Chemung", Star Gazette, 8 July 2011.
67. S. Smink, "Fighting for Her Husband's Custody", WETM News, 18 March 2011.
68. D. E. Hoffmann and J. Schwartz, "Who Decides Whether a Patient Lives or Dies?" Trial (October 2006): 30-7.
69. J. M. Luce, "A History of Resolving Conflicts over End-of-Life Treatment in Intensive Care Units in the United States", Critical Care Medicine 38, no. 8(2010):1623-9;
70. C. Huff, "Agreeing on Ending: Hospitalists Struggle with End-of-Life Disputes", ACP Hospitalist, November 2010.
71. Wheelock v. Doers, No. E2009-01968-COA-R3-CV, 2010 WL 3564422 (Tenn. Ct. App. 14 September 2010).
72. Wheelock v. Doers, Technical Record 5-6 (hearing on summary judgment before the Knox County Circuit Court, Tenn., 24 July 2009).
73. Wheelock v. Doers, Technical Record 242.
74. Wheelock v. Doers, Technical Record 241.
75. DeKalb Medical Center v. Hawkins, No. A07A1405, 2007 Ga. App. LEXIS 1269 (29 November 2007).
76. K. H. Tucker, "Malpractice Verdict Favors Doctors", Daily Report, 1 September 2010. The case is now on appeal. Oral argument was heard in May 2011.
77. Marin v. Cleveland Clinic, No. 1:09CV2090, 2010 WL 359699 (N. D. Ohio 29 January 2010) (citing Ohio Rev. Code' 1337.16).
78. Francois v. University of Miami, No. 07-03515-CA-31 (11th Judicial Circuit Court, Fla. 19 May 2008) (Amended Complaint);
79. C. M. Miller, "Lawsuit asks: Was Woman Breathing when Plug Was Pulled?" Miami Herald, 1 March 2010.
80. Pena v. Meeker, No. 10-15326, 2011 WL 2160831 (9th Cir. 27 May 2011).
81. Wawrzyniak v. Livingstone, No. CV-10-409585 (Ontario Superior Court of Justice 30 August 2010) (Statement of Claim);
82. R. Cribb, "Lawsuit Could Set Precedent about End-of-Life Decisions", Toronto Star, 4 September 2010.
83. Palmer v. Tennessee Children's Hospital, No. 176535-2 (Knox Cty. Chancery Court, Tenn., 23 November 2009) (Complaint).
84. May v. Alberta Health Services, 2010 ABQB 213 (30 March 2010).
85. In re RB (a Child), [2009] EWHC 3269 (Fam).
86. Sweiss v. Alberta Health Services, 2009 ABQB 691.
87. Slaveski and Ors. v. Austin Health [2010] VSC 493 (22 October 2010).
88. AVS v. A NHS Foundation Trust, [2011] EWCA Civ 7.
89. Application of Justice Health; re a Patient [2011] NSWSC 432.
90. T. M. Pope, "Responding to Requests for Non-Beneficial Treatment", MD-Advisor: A Journal for the New Jersey Medical Community (forthcoming 2012).
91. Jacobs v. CORE, No. l:09-CV-00048 (WD. Pa. filed 4 March 2009);
92. Ussery v. Children's Healthcare of Atlanta, Inc., 656 S. E.2d 882 (Ga. Ct. App. 2008).
93. J. Stein, "Group Sues UW Hospital over Policy on Withholding Treatment from Disabled Patients", Wisconsin State Journal, 14 May 2009.
94. Disability Rights Wisconsin v. University of Wisconsin Hospital and Clinics, No 09-CV-2340 (Dane County Circuit Court, Wisc, 14 May 2009) (Complaint).
95. Yarick v. Pacificare of California, No. F057032 (Cal. App. 1 December 2009).
96. A. Kelly, "Doctors Pressured Irish Man to Refuse Ventilator and Face Death", Irish Central, 16 April 2011.
97. T. Lincoln, "Never Take No for an Answer", http://how-we-die. org/How We Die/story?sid=4, accessed 12 August 2011.
98. M. Waites, "Anger after Doctors Put 'Do Not Resuscitate' Note on Records", Yorkshire Post, 1 June 2010.
99. E. Andrews, "We'll Do Cancer Scan on Monday⋯ If She's Still Alive': Agony of Family of Dying Grandmother Who Devoted Her Life to NHS", Daily Mail, 20 August 2010.
100. General Medical Council, Treatment and Care towards the End of Life: Good Practice in Decision Making (20 May 2010), § 16 (i).
101. "Leigh Day Serve Judicial Review and Human Rights Challenge to Use of Do Not Resuscitate Orders", 30 August 2011, http://www.leighday. co.uk/News/2011/August-2011/Leigh-Day-serve-judicial-review-and-human-rights-c, accessed 3 September 2011;
102. S. Greenhill and J. Geoghegan, "Husband's Battle to Re-draw 'Do Not Resuscitate' Rules after Wife Dies in Hospital Blunder", Daily Mail, 31 August 2011.
103. J. Rankin, "Hospital Accused of Acting Like God", Manawatu Standard, 29 October 2010;
104. J. Rankin, "Doctors 'Must Consult' about Resuscitation Orders", Manawatu Standard, 30 October 2010.
105. D. Jonasson, "Doctors Violate Life-Support Rules", Stockholm News, 28 June 2011;
106. A. Bäsén, "Så Bestämmer Läkarna om ditt liv är Värt att Räddas", Expressen, 27 June 2011.
107. "SOSFS 2011:7 Socialstyrelsens Foreskrifter och Allmänna råd om Livsuppehållande Behandling", http://www. socialstyrelsen. se/sosfs/2011-7, accessed 12 August 2011.
108. "Hospitals Can Cease Treatment if They Think It Is Futile", New Paper, 1 August 2011.
109. N. C. Chin, "More Patients, Families Engage Doctors in Treatment Discussions", Today, 12 July 2011.
110. J. Vincent, "Judge Grants Request for Restraining Order", Martinsburg Journal, 1 September 2009.
111. J. Vincent, "Family Opts to End Care", Martinsburg Journal, 5 September 2009.
112. J. Davis, "Brain-Dead Teen Taken off Life Support and Dies", Herald Tribune, 29 March 2011;
113. J. Davis, "Family Considers Taking Brain-Dead Son off Life Support", Herald Tribune, 28 March 2011.
114. Joint Theater Trauma System, "Clinical Practice Guideline: Management of Patients with Catastrophic, Non-Survivable Head Injury", 1 March 2010, http://www.usaisr.amedd.army.mil/cpgs/Catastrophic-Care-16-Feb-10. pdf, accessed 12 August 2011;
115. G. Zoroya, "Military Offers Closure in Brain Deaths", USA Today, 22 March 2010.
116. Parliamentary and Health Service Ombudsman, "Care and Compassion? Report of the Health Service Ombudsman on Ten Investigations into NHS Care of Older People", February 2011, http://www.ombudsman.org.uk/care-and- compassion/home, accessed 12 August 2011.
117. Moses v. Providence Hospital, 561 F.3d 573 (6th Cir. 2009)
118. cert, denied, 130 S. Ct. 3499 (2010).
119. U. S. Department of Health and Human Services, Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, "Medicare Program; Emergency Medical Treatment and Labor Act: Applicability to Hospital and Critical Access Hospital Inpatients and Hospitals with Specialized Capabilities", 75 Fed. Reg. 80, 762 (23 December 2010).
120. Inquest into the Death of June Woo, No. COR 2713/02 (Queensland Coroner's Court, 1 June 2009).
121. T. Plohetski, "Former Austin Nurse on Trial in 3 Deaths", Austin-American Statesman, 18 November 2009.
122. State v. Naramore, 965 P.2d 211 (Kan. App. 1998).
123. M. Nammour, "Doctors Stand Trial for Killing Patient", Khaleej Times, 18 July 2011.
124. T. M. Pope, "Legal Briefing: Conscience Clauses and Conscientious Refusal", The Journal of Clinical Ethics 21, no. 2(Summer 2010):163-80;
125. T. M. Pope, "Conscientious Objection", Lahey Clinic Medical Ethics Journal 18, no. 1(Winter 2011):6-7.
126. B. J. Balch, "Some 'Conscience' Laws Authorize Involuntary Euthanasia", National Right to Life News (April/May 2011): 9.
127. T. M. Pope, "Legal Briefing: Compliance with Advance Directives", The Journal of Clinical Ethics 23, no. 4 (Winter 2012), forthcoming.
128. Ley de Derechos y Garantías de la Dignidad de la Persona ante el Proceso de la Muerte, http://noticias.juridicas.com/base-datos/CCAA/an-l2-2010. html, accessed 12 August 2011.
129. Article 32 provides, "Offences under this Act shall be subject to administrative sanctions provided for in Article 36 of Law 14/1986 of April 25, General Health." That law specifies a fine from 2, 500, 001 to 100, 000, 000 pesetas. I converted that amount into Euros at http://coinmiIl.com.
130. R. Rincón, "Salud Multará Hasta con un Millón el Ensañamiento Terapéutico", El Pais, 3 September 2008.
131. E. de Benito, "La Ley de Muerte Digna Consagra el Derecho a Morir en una Habitaci6n Individual, El Pais, 13 May 2011.
132. G. Mollaret, "Un hopital condamne" pour acharnement thérapeutique", Le Figaro, 10 November 2009.
133. I. Plu et al., "Condamnation d'un Hopital pour Obstination Deraisonable sur un Noveau-ne: Reflexion Medico-Legal et Ethique", La Revue de Médecine Légale 2, no. 2(2011):83-8.
134. T. M. Pope, "Legal Briefing: Informed Consent", The Journal of Clinical Ethics 21, no. 1(Spring 2010):72-82;
135. Vt. Stat. Ann. § 1871.
136. Hargett v. VITAS Healthcare Corp., No. RG30547255 (Alameda Cty. Sup. Ct., Cal., 6 July 2011) (First Amended Complaint).
137. CD. Kollas, "Emerging Liability Issues and the Policy-Practice Gap in Endof-Life Care", poster at American College of Legal Medicine conference, 2003.
138. in re Kamrava, No. 06-2009-197098 (Medical Board of California, 1 June 2011) (Decision after Nonadoption), Factual Finding ¶ 40.
139. in re Kamrava, Factual Finding ¶ 41.
140. in re Kamrava, Factual Finding ¶ 17.
141. in re Kamrava, Factual Finding ¶ ¶45.
142. in re Kamrava, Legal Conclusion ¶ ¶13-15.
143. in re Kamrava, Legal Conclusion ¶ 63A.
144. American Bar Association, Commission on Law and Aging, "Resolution 106B", 22 July 2011, http://www.abanow.org/wordpress/wp-content/files Jlutter/1311422254-31-1-1-9-resolution-summary.doc-2011-0?'-23, accessed 12 August 2011;
145. http://www.american bar.org/groups/leadershipl 2011-annual-house-mtg- docs.html, accessed 12 August 2011.