Why we disagree about assisted migration1: Ethical implications of a key debate regarding the future of Canada's forests

Forestry Chronicle

Volumn 87, Issue 6, 2011, Pages 755-765

  Aubin, I ^a   Garbe, C M ^b   Colombo, S ^c   Drever, C R ^d   McKenney, D W ^a   Messier, C ^b   Pedlar, J ^a   Saner, M A ^e   Venier, L ^a   Wellstead, A M ^f   Winder, R ^g   Witten, E ^d   Ste Marie, C ^g  

^a GREAT LAKES FORESTRY CENTRE   (Canada)

^b UNIVERSITÉ DU QUÉBEC À MONTRÉAL   (Canada)

^c ONTARIO FOREST RESEARCH INSTITUTE   (Canada)

^d THE NATURE CONSERVANCY   (United States)

^e UNIVERSITY OF OTTAWA   (Canada)

^f MICHIGAN TECHNOLOGICAL UNIVERSITY   (United States)

^g LAURENTIAN FORESTRY CENTRE   (Canada)

Author keywords

Assisted colonization; Climate change; Environmental ethics; Forest management; Species conservation

Indexed keywords

CONSERVATION; ECOLOGY; FORESTRY; PHILOSOPHICAL ASPECTS; RISK ASSESSMENT; UNCERTAINTY ANALYSIS;

ASSISTED COLONIZATION; CONSERVATION BIOLOGY; ECOLOGICAL CONSEQUENCES; ECOLOGICAL RISKS; ENVIRONMENTAL ETHICS; ETHICAL IMPLICATIONS; ETHICAL QUESTION; SPECIES CONSERVATIONS;

CLIMATE CHANGE;

CLIMATE CHANGE; COLONIZATION; CONSERVATION MANAGEMENT; ECOLOGICAL APPROACH; ENVIRONMENTAL VALUES; ETHICS; FOREST MANAGEMENT; MOVEMENT; POPULATION MIGRATION; RISK ASSESSMENT; SPECIES CONSERVATION;

CANADA; CLIMATES; CONSERVATION; ECOLOGY; ENVIRONMENTS; FOREST MANAGEMENT; SPECIES IDENTIFICATION;

CANADA;

EID: 84855414444     PISSN: 00157546     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.5558/tfc2011-092     Document Type: Article

References (83)

1. Aitken, S.N., S. Yeaman, J.A. Holliday, T. Wang and S. Curtis- McLane. 2008.Adaptation, migration or extirpation: climate change outcomes for tree populations. Evolutional Applications 1: 95-111.
2. Boorse, D. 2004. Teaching environmental ethics: Non-indigenous invasive species as a study of human relationships to nature. Worldviews: Environment, Culture, Religion 8: 323-335.
3. Bourdeau, P. 2004. The man-nature relationship and environmental ethics. Journal of Environmental Radioactivity 72: 9-15. (Pubitemid 38010292)
4. Candau, J.-N., V. Abt and L. Keatley. 2002. Bioclimatic analysis of declining aspen stands in northeastern Ontario. Ontario Ministry of Natural Resources, Ontario. 16 p.
5. Carroll, M.J., B.J. Anderson, T.M. Brereton, S.J. Knight, O. Kudrna and C.D. Thomas. 2009. Climate change and translocations: The potential to re-establish two regionally-extinct butterfly species in Britain. Biological Conservation 142: 2114-2121.
6. Ciancio, O. and S. Nocentini. 1997. The forest and man: the evolution of forestry thought from modern humanism to the culture of complexity. Systemic silviculture and management on natural bases. In O. Ciancio (ed.). The forest and man. p. 21-114. Accademia Italiana di Scienze Forestali, Firenze, Italy. 180 p.
7. Claudi, R., P. Nantel and Muckle-Jeffs, E. 2002. Envahisseurs exotiques des eaux, milieux humides et forêts du Canada. Service canadien des forêts, Ressources naturelles Canada. 320 p.
8. Colombo, S., B. Boysen, K. Brosemer, A. Foley and A. Obenchain. 2008. Managing tree seed in an uncertain climate: conference summary. Ontario Forest Research Institute, Applied Research and Development Branch, Ministry of Natural Resources, Ontario. 8 p.
9. Davidson, I. and C. Simkanin. 2008. Skeptical of assisted colonization. Science 322: 1048-1049.
10. Devall, B. and G. Sessions. 1985. Deep Ecology: Living as if Nature Mattered. Peregrine Smith Books, Layton, UT. 267 p.
11. Donlan, J. et al. 2005. Re-wilding North America. Nature 436: 913-914. (Pubitemid 41191657)
12. Dukes, J.S. et al. 2009. Responses of insect pests, pathogens, and invasive plant species to climate change in the forests of northeastern North America: What can we predict? Canadian Journal of Forest Research 39: 231-248.
13. Farcy, C. and F. Devillez. 2005. New orientations of forest management planning from an historical perspective of the relations between man and nature. Forest Policy and Economics 7: 85-95. (Pubitemid 39584235)
14. Fazey, I. and J. Fischer. 2009. Assisted colonization is a techno-fix. Trends in Ecology and Evolution 24: 475.
15. Flannigan, M.D., M.A. Krawchuk, W.J. De Groot, B.M. Wotton and L.M. Gowman. 2009. Implications of changing climate for global wildland fire. International Journal of Wildland Fire 18: 483-507.
16. Gauthier, S., M-A, Vaillancourt, A. Leduc, L. de Grandpré, D. Kneeshaw, H. Morin, P. Drapeau and Y. Bergeron. 2008. Aménagement écosystémique en forêt boréale. Presses de l'Université du Québec, QC. 600 p.
17. Gray, D.R. 2008. The relationship between climate and outbreak characteristics of the spruce budworm in eastern Canada. Climatic Change 87: 361-383. (Pubitemid 351423103)
18. Haber, E. 2002. Propagation et impact des plantes exotiques dans les paysages du Canada. In R. Claudi, P. Nantel and E. Muckle-Jeffs (eds.). Envahisseurs exotiques des eaux, milieux humides et forêts du Canada. p. 43-58. Service canadien des forêts, Ressources naturelles Canada, Ottawa. 320 p.
19. Harrington, R., I. Woiwod and T. Sparks. 1999. Climate change and trophic interactions. Trends in Ecology and Evolution 14: 146-150. (Pubitemid 29135464)
20. Hawkins, E. and R. Sutton. 2009. The potential to narrow uncertainty in regional climate predictions. Bulletin of the American Meteorological Society 90: 1095-1107.
21. He, F. and S.P. Hubbell. 2011. Species-area relationships always overestimate extinction rates from habitat loss. Nature 473: 368-371.
22. Hof, C., I. Levinsky, M.B. Araùjo and C. Rahbek. 2011. Rethinking species' ability to cope with rapid climate change. Global Change Biology 17: 2987-2990.
23. Hogg, E.H., J.P Brandt and M. Michaellian. 2008. Impacts of a regional drought on the productivity, dieback, and biomass of western Canadian aspen forests. Canadian Journal of Forest Research 38: 1373-1384. (Pubitemid 351947146)
24. Hughes, L. 2000. Biological consequences of global warming: Is the signal already apparent? Trends in Ecology and Evolution 15: 56-61. (Pubitemid 30349803)
25. Hulme, M. 2009. Why we disagree about climate change. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK. 432 p.
26. [IPCC] Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. 2007. Climate change 2007: the physical science basis. Contribution of working group I to the fourth assessment report of the intergovernmental panel on climate change. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK. 996 p.
27. Johnston, M., S. Webber, G.O. Neill, T. Williamson and K. Hirsch. 2009. Climate change impacts and adaptation strategies for the forest sector in Canada. In 2nd Climate Change Technology Conference. Hamilton, ON. 13 p.
28. Jump, A.S. and J. Peñuelas. 2005. Running to stand still: adaptation and the response of plants to rapid climate change. Ecology Letters 8: 1010-1020. (Pubitemid 41247276)
29. Klenk, N.L., G.Q. Bull and J.I. MacLellan. 2009. The "emulation of natural disturbance" (END) management approach in Canadian forestry: A critical evaluation. The Forestry Chronicle 85: 440-445.
30. Kramer, A.T. and K. Havens. 2009. Plant conservation genetics in a changing world. Trends in Plant Science 14: 599-607.
31. Kuhlberg, M. 2009.One hundred rings and counting: Forestry education and forestry in Toronto and Canada, 1907-2007. University of Toronto Press, Toronto. 334 p.
32. Larson, B.M.H. 2007. Who's invading what? Systems thinking about invasive species. Canadian Journal of Plant Science 87: 993-999. (Pubitemid 351775753)
33. Lemprière, T.C., P.Y. Bernier, A.L. Carroll, M.D. Flannigan, R.P. Gilsenan, D.W. McKenney, E.H. Hogg, J.H. Pedlar and D. Blain. 2008. The Importance of forest sector adaptation to climate change. Natural Resources Canada, Canadian Forest Service, Northern Forestry Centre, Edmonton, AB. 78 p.
34. Lenton, T.M., H. Held, E. Kriegler, J.W. Hall, W. Lucht, S. Rahmstorf and H.J. Schellnhuber. 2008. Tipping elements in the Earth's climate system. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 105: 1786-1793. (Pubitemid 351439417)
35. Leopold, A. 1949. A Sand County Almanac, and Sketches Here and There. Oxford University Press, Oxford. 240 p.
36. Levine, J.M., M. Vilà, C.M. D'Antonio, J.S. Dukes, K. Grigulis and S. Lavorel. 2003.Mechanisms underlying the impacts of exotic plant invasions. Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 270: 775-781. (Pubitemid 36459709)
37. Long, S.P. 1991.Modification of the response of photosynthetic productivity to rising temperature by atmospheric CO2 concentrations: Has its importance been underestimated? Plant, Cell & Environment 14: 729-739.
38. McLachlan, J.S., J.J. Hellmann and M.W. Schwartz. 2007.A framework for debate of assisted migration in an era of climate change. Conservation Biology 21: 297-302. (Pubitemid 46474754)
39. McLane, S.C. and S.N. Aitken. 2011. Whitebark pine (Pinus albicaulis) assisted migration potential: Testing establishment north of the species range. Ecological Applications doi:10.1890/11-0329.1.
40. Minteer, B.A. and J.P. Collins. 2010.Move it or lose it? the ecological ethics of relocating species under climate change. Ecological Applications 20: 1801-1804.
41. Morin, X., M.J. Lechowicz, C. Augspurger, J. O'Keefe, D. Viner and I. Chuine. 2009. Leaf phenology in 22 North America tree species during the 21st century. Global Change Biology 15: 961-975.
42. Mueller, J.M. and J.J. Hellmann. 2008. An assessment of invasion risk from assisted migration. Conservation Biology 22: 562-567. (Pubitemid 351813452)
43. Nealis, V. and B. Peter. 2008. Risk assessment of the threat of mountain pine beetle to Canada's boreal and eastern pine forests. Natural Resources Canada, Canadian Forest Service, Victoria, BC. Information Report BC-X-417. 38 p.
44. Norris, S. 2006. Evolutionary Tinkering. Conservation in Practice 7: 28-34.
45. O'Neill, G.A. et al. 2008. Assisted migration to address climate change in British Columbia: recommendations for interim seed transfer standards. Technical Report 048. Ministry of Forests and Range. Forest Science Program, BC. 30 p.
46. Oksanen, M. 1998. Nature as Property. Environmental Ethics and the Institution of Ownership. University of Turku, Finland.
47. Parmesan, C. 2006. Ecological and Evolutionary Responses to Recent Climate Change. Annual Review of Ecology, Evolution, and Systematics 37: 637-669. (Pubitemid 44907632)
48. Parmesan, C. and G. Yohe. 2003. A globally coherent fingerprint of climate change impacts across natural systems. Nature 421: 37-42. (Pubitemid 36077078)
49. Pedlar, J.H., D.W. McKenney, J. Beaulieu, S.J. Colombo, J.S. McLachlan and G.A. O'Neill. 2011. The implementation of assisted migration in Canadian forests. The Forestry Chronicle 87(6): 766-777.
50. Puettmann, K.J. 2011. Silvicultural Challenges and Options in the Context of Global Change: "Simple" Fixes and Opportunities for New Management Approaches. Journal of Forestry 109: 321-331.
51. Puettmann, K.J., K.D. Coates and C. Messier. 2009. A critique of silviculture. Managing for complexity. Island Press, Washington, DC. 189 p.
52. Ricciardi, A. and D. Simberloff. 2009a. Assisted colonization is not a viable conservation strategy. Trends in Ecology and Evolution 24: 248-253.
53. Ricciardi, A. and D. Simberloff. 2009b.Assisted colonization: good intentions and dubious risk assessment. Trends in Ecology and Evolution 24: 476-477.
54. Richardson, D.M. et al. 2009.Multidimensional evaluation of managed relocation. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 106: 9721-9724.
55. Sandler, R. 2009. The value of species and the ethical foundations of assisted colonization. Conservation Biology 24: 424-431.
56. Sarewitz, D. 2004.How science makes environmental controversies worse. Environmental Science & Policy 7: 385-403. (Pubitemid 39149551)
57. Sarewitz, D. 2011. Does climate change knowledge really matter? WIREs Climate Change 2 : 475-481.
58. Savolainen, O., T. Pyhäjärv and T. Knürr. 2007. Gene flow and local adaptation in trees. Annual Review of Ecology, Evolution, and Systematics. 38: 595-619.
59. Sax, D.F., K.F. Smith and A.R. Thompson. 2009. Managed relocation: a nuanced evaluation is needed. Trends in Ecology and Evolution 24: 472-473.
60. Schlaepfer, M.A., W.D. Helenbrook, K.B. Searing and K.T. Shoemaker. 2009. Assisted colonization: evaluating contrasting management actions (and values) in the face of uncertainty. Trends in Ecology and Evolution 24: 471-472.
61. Schwartz, M.W., J.J. Hellmann and J.S. McLachlan. 2009. The precautionary principle in managed relocation is misguided advice. Trends in Ecology and Evolution 24: 474.
62. Seddon, P.J. 2010. From Reintroduction to Assisted Colonization: Moving along the Conservation Translocation Spectrum. Restoration Ecology 18: 796-802.
63. Slimak, M.W. and T. Dietz. 2006. Personal values, beliefs, and ecological risk perception. Risk Analysis 26: 1689-1705. (Pubitemid 44952484)
64. Soulé, M.E., J.A. Estes, B. Miller and D.L. Honnold. 2005. Strongly interacting species: Conservation policy, management, and ethics. BioScience 55: 168-176. (Pubitemid 40218462)
65. Ste-Marie, C., E.A. Nelson, A. Dabros and M.E. Bonneau. 2011. Assisted migration: Introduction to a multifaceted concept. The Forestry Chronicle 87(6): 724-730.
66. Stone, R. 2010. Home, Home Outside the Range. Science 329: 1592-1594.
67. Thomas, C.D. et al. 2004. Extinction risk from climate change. Nature 427: 145-148. (Pubitemid 38094953)
68. Thompson, K. and M.A. Davis. 2011. Why research on traits of invasive plants tells us very little. Trends in Ecology and Evolution 26: 155-156.
69. Van Der Veken, S., M. Hermy, M. Vellend, A. Knapen and K. Verheyen. 2008.Garden plants get a head start on climate change. Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment 6: 212-216. (Pubitemid 351688519)
70. Visser, M.E. and C. Both. 2005. Shifts in phenology due to global climate change: The need for a yardstick. Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 272: 2561-2569. (Pubitemid 41796558)
71. Vitt, P., K. Havens and O. Hoegh-Guldberg. 2009. Assisted migration: part of an integrated conservation strategy. Trends in Ecology and Evolution 24(9): 473-474.
72. Vitt, P., K. Havens, A.T. Kramer, D. Sollenberger and E. Yates. 2010. Assisted migration of plants: Changes in latitudes, changes in attitudes. Biological Conservation 143: 18-27.
73. Volney, W.J.A. and R.A. Fleming. 2000. Climate change and impacts of boreal forest insects. Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment 82: 283-294.
74. Walther, G.R., E. Post, P. Convey, A. Menzel, C. Parmesan, T.J.C. Beebee, J.M. Fromentin, O. Hoegh-Guldberg and F. Bairlein. 2002. Ecological responses to recent climate change. Nature 416: 389-395. (Pubitemid 34272866)
75. Walther, G.R. et al. 2009. Alien species in a warmer world: risks and opportunities. Trends in Ecology and Evolution 24: 686-693.
76. White, L. and J. Townsend. 1967. The Historical Roots of Our Ecologic Crisis. Science 155: 1203-1207.
77. Williams, J.W. and S.T. Jackson. 2007. Novel climates, no-analog communities, and ecological surprises. Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment 5: 475-482. (Pubitemid 350071683)
78. Williamson, M.H. and A. Fitter. 1996. The characters of successful invaders. Biological Conservation 78: 163-170.
79. Willis, G.S., J.K. Hill, C.D. Thomas, D.B. Roy, R. Fox, D.S. Blakely, and B. Huntley. 2009. Assisted colonization in a changing climate: a test-study using two U.K. butterflies. Conservation Letters 2: 45-51.
80. Winder, R., E.A. Nelson and T. Beardmore. 2011. Ecological implications for assisted migration in Canadian forests. The Forestry Chronicle 87(6): 731-744.
81. Woodall, C.W., D.J. Nowak, G.C. Liknes and J.A. Westfall. 2010. Assessing the potential for urban trees to facilitate forest tree migration in the eastern United States. Forest Ecology and Management 259: 1447-1454.
82. Woods, A., K.D. Coates and A. Hamman. 2005. Is an unprecedented dothistroma needle blight epidemic related to climate change? Bioscience 55: 761-769. (Pubitemid 41242447)
83. Wotton, B.M. and B.J. Stocks. 2006. Fire management in Canada: vulnerability and risk trends. In K. Hirsch and P. Fuglem (eds.). Canadian wildland fire strategy: background syntheses, analyses, and perspectives. pp. 49-55. Canadian Council of Forest Ministers, Natural Resources Canada, Canadian Forest Service, Ottawa.